Murdoch actually has a lighter axle load than Thomas, because his axle-loading is spread out. So he could go chill at Ffarqhuar

That was wonderful! The twist of Murdoch going up the branch line caught me so off guard that I had to rewind the video - Mavis' Toby/Murdoch crossover theme made that sequence! Really nice watch!

It’s great to see the script being brought to life at last! The recording session was great fun, but it’s all come together so well with the music and visuals too - great job!

I'm definitely going to watch this later

I can definitely tell you trying to sound aesthetically like the Ringo Starr era this is amazing this brings back childhood this is more thomas-the-tank-engine acetic than anything I've seen come out for children nowadays this is fantastic

I Love the story. I just think it's odd to see a 9F on a branchline but eh it's all on good fun I suppose

Nicely done old chap.

This was awesome glad I watched it, love of faces you gave James

To anyone confused about how Murdoch was able to work on the branch line, I have an potential theory. There are a number of big engines built for Main Line work, but are just light enough to work on some Secondary routes and Branch Lines. From what I remember, the British Railways 9F's were one such engine. He might have plenty of driving wheels, but the weight on his wheels is actually some tons lighter than an engine like Gordon or Henry. So, in theory, Murdoch could work on a branch line if needed. Though his power and speed would be much better suited for the mainline. By contrast, an engine of James' size and weight would be perfect for a branch line. But of course, James being James, he wouldn't much appreciate doing that too often!

This is the best episode ever

Loved this Episode very well done and great use of Murdoch to.

James is always in a foul mood!

is'nt Murdoch too heavy to run on Thomas"s branch line?

Brilliant episode ! Featuring my favourite character Murdoch as well, it was wonderful ! I can’t wait to see more

absolutely love episodes like this, do keep up the good work.

Wonderful Episode! For one second I thought that at 4:42 that I got a bluescreen xD

Wow, that was really good.

Would Murdoch be allowed on Thomas’ branch line.

Great story. But wouldn't Murdoch be too heavy for the branch Line? He is a 9F after all. It's already been estaished that Henry and Gordon are too heavy for the branch, surely the same circumstance would apply to Murdoch? (Yes I am that guy)

Murdoch is the best engine ever

5:04 Who’s whistle is that? May u plz send me a link?

I saw Benny and a female breakvan i'm glad you've kept them in the show will they get new introduction episodes?

@ThomasTheModelAdventures

5 жыл бұрын

At some point I hope to give them a proper introduction, but that'll be a little way off yet - some other ideas are better developed at the moment and will be made first.

Isn't it dangerous for big tender engines to travel on branchlines because of their weight?

Or 4

How is murdoc ment to go on the branch line hes to heavy and big

Is that Fat Controller figure custom? Or is it modified from some sort of merchandise range?

@ThomasTheModelAdventures

4 жыл бұрын

I believe it is from the Nakayoshi range in Japan. It came with a job lot of toys I won a few years ago.

@SlickVideoProductions

4 жыл бұрын

Thomas The Model Adventures I see.

Season 4

Nope season 7

Glad to see you got that editing done! Lovely treat to watch tonight--lots of great sets, and the story was very nice, and amusing as well! As always, great stuff, can't wait for your future projects!

Very interesting story and usage of characters. I loved the music, my favourite being the Toby and Murdoch mix and I look forward to the next episode. BTW what kind of Fat Controller model did you use?

@ThomasTheModelAdventures

5 жыл бұрын

TankEngine97 That is from the Nakayoshi range I believe.

That... Was amazing

Great episode, Mr. Railway Inspector of youtube dot com! And now to wait another 12 months for episode 3... lol jk Love how you characterized and utilized Murdoch in this. Generous and brave of him to sacrifice his time to help out on Thomas' branch line... and disobey the Route Availability system in doing so- But I digress! Lighting seems to have improved a little, and I see you HAVE went through with cutting up the scenic backgrounds! Very good. Mavis' music is on point as usual, too. Character theme combos seem to be a recurring thing with them! 4:39 Intersting choices for character cameos too. Any chance we might see Splodge in a major supporting role sometime in the future? Great work once again! As always, I look forward to seeing what else you have in store...!

@ThomasTheModelAdventures

5 жыл бұрын

Sandy Eggo No plans at present for Splodge but who knows what the future may bring. Episode 3 is already in the works. Still more improvements to make but Rome wasn’t built in a day. Thanks for watching. :-)

That was amazing a nice combination of engines ps I love how u mixed Murdoch’s theme and Toby’s theme together

An excellent use of one of favorite characters.

This is amazing had the feel of a railway series book . Very well done

This AND a new Carson video on the same day!? I'm so excited...

lovely story!

This is wonderful Owen! Well done! :D

Incredible work, well done!

The production quality on this one is incredible. Well done. I appreciated the meticulous audio editing and the ambitious camera shots. I will say the starts and stops with Murdoch in particular could have been smoother, and the narration could have been just a tiny bit louder. All in all, however, I’m very excited to see another channel with such high-quality production design. Looking forward to what you do next.

Honestly surprised the rails didn't give out under Murdoch's weight! He ain't exactly light on his feet y'know....erm....well, wheels in this case. XD

This was beautifully made

It’s a bit like the beginning of James and the tat wagons./Dirty Objects.

Well Done

Beautiful as always! Can’t wait to show you my model series in future! (Once my layout is built!)

Hang on, wouldn't the track and bridges on the branch line be too weak for Murdoch? I mean Gordon got away with it once but it kind of makes it worse considering Murdoch is heavier than Gordon.

@castlesandjazzers1534

5 жыл бұрын

Even then, Gordon hardly ventured beyond Toryreck. Just can't suspend disbelief for this one I'm afraid lol

@ThomasTheModelAdventures

5 жыл бұрын

Of course, Gordon’s weight is centred on just three driving axles, whereas Murdoch’s weight is over five and a longer wheelbase, so less weight would be focused within the same area. My awareness on “route availability” in the railway world isn’t great, but if you look at some heritage lines these days, a lot have engines much larger than would have actually run on them in the day. Or the alternative argument is that this isn’t necessarily set at the same time, and bridge works are bound to have taken place over the years and subsequently they have all been strengthens.

@castlesandjazzers1534

5 жыл бұрын

@@ThomasTheModelAdventures Forgive my ignorance then; that is tricky to argue with! Lemme just live the vid a thumb-up real quick.

@steam-powered-cyborg

5 жыл бұрын

@@ThomasTheModelAdventures Alright, fair point. Perhaps clearing that thing up in the story would've made it better, unless you couldn't fit it in with the classic series timeframe and all. That would be understandable.

How did he not fall off the track?!

Isn't Murdoch too heavy for the branchlines ?