Movie:- Red Cliff 1+2

There's a similar battle formation called chakrayuham in Indian history it was said to be used in battle of Mahabharata.

@ArchitaBandral

2 ай бұрын

Right

@trishafilm

2 ай бұрын

Explain please. The names were so confusing here I couldn't understand anything 😢

@user-mu1zh7zd4o

2 ай бұрын

@@trishafilm the Chinese are using a jigsaw like circle battle formation. In India we have battle formation that’s shaped like a target basically it has troops formed in circles that get bigger and bigger and the soldiers kept moving to the right to confuse the enemy. It was considered a hard formation to defeat due to the troops always moving it was hard to break the circle and move in. The Indian battle formation is called Chakrayuham.

@trishafilm

2 ай бұрын

@@user-mu1zh7zd4o I'm indian but couldn't understand anything from the video. Thanks for explaining.

I love the 3 kingdoms I learned all of it from dynasty warriors that game is fire is so good

Redcliff is actually a pretty good movie. I'd suggest it to watch.

@barrywhite8747

4 ай бұрын

Its better if you get the international version, its slip into two parts. I also have the U.S. version that's dubbed but I don't watch it now that I know was cut out.

I love prehistoric ronaldinho 😂😂

I love this movie. Saw it in the original Chinese, the only way to watch it. The English version is a jumpcut of the two films smashed together. Also, "the warrior" you mention with the polearm weapon is Guan Yu, the third of the 'brothers' with Zhang Fei and Liu Bei.

Ever heard of the chakravhyu ?

Known as the chakravyuh , ancient indian and chineese warfare has written records of this pre dating 5000 BC

Two iconic battles in Dynasty Warriors

Narration of this classic movie had many errors or blatant mistranslations, and even over-zealous exaggerations added in. Some significant scenes were also totally omitted. But since it is meant for a western or non-chinese speaking audience, I guess there is still some entertainment value left this in highly edited and compressed version. 😂

This is nothing but chakravyuh mentioned in Mahabharat, epic battle in indian mythology

@obethlama6415

2 ай бұрын

this is one of the most brutal and iconic history of china based on real life event the three kingdom where tons of war lords fights over only 3 of them of emerge in victory, truly a great history and you talk about mahabharat and shit. you indians cant stop caliming everthing is yours now can you ?

@Snoozefor10minutes

2 ай бұрын

@@obethlama6415 chill dude, no one claiming anything here. By the way Mahabharata is much older than your Chinese civilization. This scene is very similar to Mahabharat tv series of 1988 and 2013 Here take a look at this scene, done in India in 1988 kzread.info/dash/bejne/YqtrtZhygJy5obA.htmlsi=5Tuc8XBAkUKbHm0X Don't tell me we copied it after reading some Chinese books now

@obethlama6415

2 ай бұрын

@@Snoozefor10minutes aint no one gonn give 2 shits about your fantasy book lil guy

A prime minister named Chow Chow😂😂😂

If you keep executing your generals because of your pride or their little mistakes, you will lose the war.

Red cliff

TD 5 soldiers be like

Romance of the Three Kingdoms, classic novel (using partial historical military characters), written by Luo Guan Zhong.

There are so many of these Korean, Chinese, or Japanese historic fiction films, loosely based on real events. So many seem awesome - like Red Cliff. We need more like this in the West. Larger than life figures (like William Wallace, Caesar or Augustus, Washington, Sherman, Grant, or Alexander, etc. and epic battles, and only a loose grasp of the historical record. The heroes are borderline demigods (like Achilles or Hector) and capable of feats that are laughably wild. Then again, I’m also the type of person that bitches about the inaccuracies. Not about Braveheart, tho. NEVER about braveheart. I KNOW scot’s didn’t wear Kilts then. I KNOW They didn’t wear pagan warpaint either. I don’t care. It’s magnificent. Perhaps a compromise is best: like Gladiator. With a few real people and a few fictional. And events that COULD have happened (they didn’t). Like with the film Alexander, they tried to remain true to a well known historical record bc the Greeks loved to write shit down. And when the Greeks reach their zenith, you know they wrote everything down. We didn’t get a culture as studious and meticilous with their record keeping as the Greeks for like another 1300 yrs, when Alfred the Great decided to write everything down. But his hegemony over part of a single island was not even secure, so it didn’t all remain. I think great records were kept in the Middle east but were lost when Constantinople fell along with the rest of the Byzantines.

Im not sure if this is AI generated, or just AI voiced but if it's a real dood writing the recap he or she should just do it themselves. It's well written and people like hoomans.

@giriprasath.d9273

4 ай бұрын

It was korean movie

@burtan2000

4 ай бұрын

@@giriprasath.d9273He’s talking about the recap, not the film. We don’t have AI films… yet. We will

@burtan2000

4 ай бұрын

I don’t mind the AI voices. I’ve grown accustomed to them.

@jajaja8

2 ай бұрын

​​@@giriprasath.d9273No. This is a China-Hong Kong movie collaboration. It has a Mandarin version and a Cantonese version. 100% Not Korean. Directed by John Woo, from China.

the ai pronouncing "bow" as "bao" xD

Sooo.. dynasty warriors? 😂

This was a cartoon show I used to watch in early 90s

chow chow? who dat?

sooooo who ever watches oversimplified yes you know this

I watch this solely because of the superboy kaneshiro 😁

whats this movie?

@SathishKumar-bc5bh

4 ай бұрын

Redcliff chinese movie

@Ahmad-rr1gi

4 ай бұрын

Ya mum

@_Zen0

4 ай бұрын

@@Ahmad-rr1gi you dont have 1? xd

@kaho6891-

4 ай бұрын

@@Ahmad-rr1gi oink oink hu Akbar 🐖🐖🐖

@AnNoPaing

3 ай бұрын

@@SathishKumar-bc5bh Hong Kong bro,not Chinese

I thought in dynasty warriors cao cao was the good guy

@LiewVoonHooi

3 ай бұрын

It's complicated. Chinese describe him as 治世之能臣,乱世之奸雄

@AnNoPaing

3 ай бұрын

Most Three Kingdoms fans from inter cao cao is a hero but not in China. Liu Bei is a hero to them

@nomorehentai1331

3 ай бұрын

@@AnNoPaing It is because how entertainment industry portray him especially in China. if we look without bias, there is no hero or villain in this history.

@fredlin6303

2 ай бұрын

@@nomorehentai1331 Winners are the heroes - because they write the history.

@nomorehentai1331

2 ай бұрын

@@fredlin6303 yes might be in some case but if we look three kingdom history throughly, there is really no hero or villains in this history. All warlords are trying to conquer or unite the lands. It is not like US vs Nazi Germany. I mean we can't put or differentiate who is good or bad in three kingdom. I just want to blame the entertainment media. Cao Cao was smart, his passion and purpose are as great as Liu Bei.

Cao cao not chow chow

@jajaja8

2 ай бұрын

A lot (almost all) of the chinese characters were pronounced wrongly or simply not recognizable to chinese speakers. But its still fine, since it was consistently mispronounced the same manner for the entire video clip. 😅❤

This is a real combat tactic.. but in reality it was so complicated… it did not work as shown in movie.. my opinion mostly.. so !!!

@burtan2000

4 ай бұрын

IIRC there is a similar technique shown in Waterloo. Whether or not they actually employed it to defeat Napoleon, i cannot say. i wasn’t there

@IkRooney

4 ай бұрын

@@burtan2000 Those are square formations.

@injusticeanywherethreatens4810

3 ай бұрын

...

@user-mu1zh7zd4o

3 ай бұрын

There's a similar battle formation called chakrayuham in Indian history it was said to be used in battle of Mahabharata.

cao cao*

Chow Chow or Cao Cao, Im confused..

@muhamadikhsan9152

3 ай бұрын

its sao sao

@themi4155

3 ай бұрын

@@muhamadikhsan9152 dao dao or bao bao

@Raiayasaki

3 ай бұрын

@@muhamadikhsan9152 It's actually pronounced "t-sao t-sao".

@jajaja8

2 ай бұрын

Its 2 different chinese characters, pronounced differently in chinese. CÁO CĀO. 曹操

@jajaja8

2 ай бұрын

The fictional supposedly genius war strategist-advisor, miscalled completely as CHUGA throughout this video is actually called ZHU GE LIANG. A 3-syllable chinese name totally different from a train-sounding 2-syllable anglicised nickname (Chuga) which the imaginative narrator gave him. ❤

6:42 Kebab? It look more like a satey.

Way too many characters to keep track of. And yea, does anyone really win in war?

Low key like the Trojan War🔥

Red Clif 1. Need to block video content like this. Hidden the movie title.

had to thumbs down because I had to look through comments to find movie title.

chakraveew

Your pronunciation of the names is really bad lol

@jajaja8

2 ай бұрын

Yup. 90% wrong for every single character. In fact, not 1 character was pronounced correctly ..... except for prehistoric RONALDINHO. ❤

tbh everyone look the same

@FilipLuch

4 ай бұрын

and have the same name

@johnm9126

3 ай бұрын

Racist unbelievably racist. That’s like saying all white people look the same and their names are the same smith Jones Johnson Williams. I mean come on

@jsolo2x585

3 ай бұрын

That gotta be racist

@Co-nm8nt

3 ай бұрын

For you yes but for your mom i bet she know them by names and knows their trunk size as well

@UnknownX-Edits

3 ай бұрын

Oh, I get it 💀💀💀

the baby with the back pack is a true story

For all the army and soldiers go to war for a chick. Wow.😑

Chow Chow looks Ethiopian 😆

Nonsense film...laughable premise at best

this movie is full of sh*t

电影： 赤壁

#caocao