Please make a sequel to this story you could go so far and make a perfect supernatural mini series out of this

@nursestoyland

9 ай бұрын

yea

@Toaster-iq4wy

9 ай бұрын

agreed

The real plot twist is the guy just had a song stuck in his head from back home.

So Bert is either possessed by the yellow engine, or he's become part of whatever cult it is

@loganbloom6191

9 ай бұрын

Or he is the yellow engine reborn

@stevenmosco20

9 ай бұрын

Or he could just be screwing with the others to creep them out

@gavrail9568

9 ай бұрын

Well remember how he said those close enough to tell you are never heard from again what if it’s a curse and once you tell someone about it you get infected

@elifreemantle80

9 ай бұрын

@@stevenmosco20I would screw with them too if I were him.

@abrahamproductions2951

9 ай бұрын

that overhaul he had, might have done the trick

That was very unexpected here. Interesting use on Victor's first livery model here to portrayed this mysterious yellow engine here. I guess we all needed a break from Proteus being used as a supernatural entity here. Also use a different yellow engine other then Duncan or Proteus or even Rheneas himself in a yellow livery. This kinda reminds me of Albert's Ghost sort of, but I guess I have that in my mind here. The ending was very unexpected. A very twisted and interesting Story here. Can't wait for the other stories you have in mind for us.

Ending is very interesting. I hope we get a follow up. I love the inclusion of Victor; I think most of us are tired of Supernatural Proteus

@Canadiansteamer43

7 ай бұрын

Yeah, it has gotten SO STALE!!!!!

@XV-5_WithTophat

6 ай бұрын

Victor but in his yellow livery

@kemperrogers5101

3 ай бұрын

We’re you really surprised about the ending?

That is a plot twist right there.

From what I can deduce, Victor’s counterpart was speaking in incantation. The mine serves as a sort of gateway between the land of the living and the land of the dead. Perhaps this engine is a lost spirit of the underworld, stuck in limbo traveling between the two worlds and can only be put to rest unless he takes the form of another engine. As far as which religion or language, I’m torn between Mayan and Aztec.

@PhoenixMoth

7 ай бұрын

😮

I think it is the ending that makes this story more creepy than the back story itself! To know that an engine that we all know and love can potentially disappear and/or maybe connected to the mysterious yellow engine that isn't Proteus. This story is more mystery than anything else and I think this is a real winner! There is a lot of new creative ideas here, the biggest one obviously being the use of Victor's pre-Sodor livery and the idea that Stanley was not the Mid-Sodor's original Number 2 but the MSR outsourcing to South America. 10/10.

Guys, remember Bert is technically already dead? The Guard from Hell took him... so maybe this Bert we now see is nothing more than the shape-shifting yellow engine taking on his appearance...

@fanf_trains

9 ай бұрын

He got rebuilt

@brendanhanley2741

9 ай бұрын

Different canons

@gavinfischer4928

4 ай бұрын

I never thought about it, you might be onto something

What you have to understand is Bert is the oldest put of all of them, being built in the 1880s, whilst i don't believe he is the yellow engine, he definitely knows a lot more that what he says.

I like to think that this is one of Victor’s brothers and not Victor himself, heck this engine could be his twin.

"Who is Victor? Well what if we took it one final step and said that Victor is Bert from the Arlesdale Railway?" - Not Matpat

@ShadrakJohn

8 ай бұрын

Victor is the repair engine at the steam works.

@Canadiansteamer43

7 ай бұрын

Matpat NEEDS to make a theory

The mystery whisper from a demon that sends or more likely puts engines in hypnosis then makes them disappear in the night

I like how the ending is left open to interpretation. Maybe Bert is Victor? I mean, would it be that far fetched to say a ghostly/demonic engine could use some black magic to Shapeshift? Maybe Bert is simply possessed ? Maybe Victor caught Bert at some point and swapped places with him? Maybe Bert is carrying on the legacy of this yellow engine? (Although, seeing as we literally saw Victor, I find that option unlikely. I think he’s definitely still out there.) Or maybe I’m completely off the mark? I love it when spooky stories don’t give you all the information, but give you just enough that you can piece together your own explanation

@thetiredscot7821

9 ай бұрын

If you don't mind me asking what do mean by swapped places? Do you mean he swapped bodies?

@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967

9 ай бұрын

Which is something the CGI series should have often.

@loganbloom6191

9 ай бұрын

@@thetiredscot7821 souls stitched body

@JohntheLNERP2

9 ай бұрын

What if this is connected to The Guard From Hell? What if El Diablo or the yellow engine offered Bert a second chance at life in exchange for his soul?

@anf_8310_ab

9 ай бұрын

​@@JohntheLNERP2it could be. Because maybe Bert we know now isn't the same Bert from 'Guard From Hell' video

the vanishing express, the yellow engine & the whispers in the woods, they all must be connected to an even more sinister plot, just think about it give me the chills, when are you going to make a finale to explain that conventional plot.

@VPC12370

5 ай бұрын

Along with the sinister ending.

Holy scrap Victor's brother is a demon engine!

@laurahossack9953

9 ай бұрын

We don’t know for sure

@Thomasfan2002-pt7ht

9 ай бұрын

You think his name could be Vector?

@sabertooth3studioshq838

9 ай бұрын

@@Thomasfan2002-pt7ht I doubt that.

@BlooMonkiMan

8 ай бұрын

that's not a brother. That is Victor himself

Dude, awesome job on this! It was very well-written, and I’m intrigued to see what happens next. I appreciate you choosing me to be Bert, it was fun!

@NorthWestern1919

9 ай бұрын

You did great with both this and Guard From Hell! I've observed that poor Bert seemingly can't catch a break on this channel, hehe!

People on here saying Bert could be possessed by the Yellow Engine, reminds me of Dane/1020 from TheBlueSnowplow's horror series.

Damn! I’m gonna be at work when this premieres

I think i speak for all of us that we shoud have a second part of this story , is very original , an engine speaking on a languege that nobeone undestand is kinda creepy . Well done man 👍👋😃

Finally more scary stories about my favourite childhood show these always make me feel nostalgic

This is Intresting Victor met Duke

Keep it up Rheneas Productions Boy The Fact That Use Victor For This Story And That Bert Puff Away While Saying The Chant Like The Yellow Engine From His Story Did 9:35

What the hell- that ending was.. i was not expecting that- that was really good!

Interesting to have a ending like this

Well I’m surprised that the yellow engine was similar to Victor but it does speak a different language and it sounds eerie, but I don’t think Bert would haunt anyone, because after all, he was told the stories such as Albert’s ghost, so he’s just a normal engine especially in his rebuild

@kemperrogers5101

8 ай бұрын

I agree with what you said about The Yellow Engine.

That ending got me so good! I loved this Rhen, can’t wait to see what’s in store for the next installment!

Man that was unexpected! I Love It! Please make a sequel!

Very good! Quite spooky actually. Honestly thought it was Victor but was pleasantly surprised to find it was an original character. Nice! And very ambiguous ending too. Great stuff mate! Another TTTE horror classic

That was a freaky story but good! That plot twist of Bert was awesome I was like no way! Somehow this story reminds me of a ghost story my mom told me about what my grandpa encountered when he was a little boy.

@edwardryan2476

2 ай бұрын

Can you tell the story please, I’m interested to hear it.

@dougsfilmtv9810

2 ай бұрын

@@edwardryan2476 When my grandpa was a young boy him and his family see this strange looking man and they decided to follow him. They follow him to a cemetery and the man is standing on the grave and all of sudden he drops, I don't mean drop dead, I mean descended into the grave.

@edwardryan2476

2 ай бұрын

@@dougsfilmtv9810 is there any prior story as to who this man was ?

@dougsfilmtv9810

2 ай бұрын

@@edwardryan2476 No, that is a mystery but I have visited that cemetery where that story took place.

@edwardryan2476

2 ай бұрын

@@dougsfilmtv9810 Did your grandfather tell you what this man looked like ?

The MSR manager could've just thrown the pictures and documents into a fireplace, he didn't have to burn down an entire shed.

They call me the jock of all trades

This story sounds very interesting especially at the end where Bert just mysteriously wandered off. I did wonder if Bert could possibly be himself the yellow engine?

Bert fell victim to the curse that engine cast… it seems like that engine was infected by some kind of dark sorcery

definitely my new favorite video of yours! amazing work!

This feels like a true Rheneas Productions story, an ending with open interpretation with slight hints about what happened. Love this one, great job Rhen!

Good trainz model of Victor's 1st yellow paint job

I thought before I saw the video, it was going to be the same story from Blue Mountain Mystery but more darker ending for Victor.

@FerdinandProductions2021

6 ай бұрын

Same

how can victor haunt the miniature rails when he doesn’t fit they’re gauge.

@landonmarlin6116

9 ай бұрын

Ghosts aren't limited to the rules of the mortal relm. They have supernatural abilities that allow them to do things living people/engines can't do.

@nathanditton5011

9 ай бұрын

Demon powers

@KingchooRS

9 ай бұрын

Tell that to Albert too

@maniacmetallix

9 ай бұрын

You saw him rolling, and now you are hating.

@Somerandompokemon

9 ай бұрын

Its called a ghost. You even said it yourself. *Haunt*

BERTS been possesed 😢

Coming back from BLUE MOUNTAIN MYSTERY❤

This has made me go to a church and seek the lord’s comfort

This was amazing!! Genuinely spooky. So awesome.

This is a Spooky Story at that, Nice Job.👍

This actually really creeped me out, especially the ending with the plot twist. I couldn’t stop thinking about but I was able to sleep so that’s good 😂

I think I must have missed some preceding stories here - don't know Victor and Proteus, so the comments are lost on me. I thought the graphics are pretty good, love Frank's facial animations in particular, and the quite 'adult' backchat between them on the shed.

victor - I don’t know why Kevin but I feel like kicking Bert’s tender tomorrow

Quite the unexpected ending. Is Bert part of some cult we don't know of, that the Victor was part of. Also I don't like Victor being represented like this. Nevermind though. Also I hate Bert being rebuilt.

@kemperrogers5101

5 ай бұрын

Were you even surprised about the ending?

@TobyOliverHenryFan

5 ай бұрын

@@kemperrogers5101 Well, I don't remember. I watched it 4 months ago.

I love seeing Victor representation

This was amazing! I love that the ending was left up to interpretation too Poor Bert cant catch a break, first Guard From Hell now this

@NorthWestern1919

9 ай бұрын

Alas, poor Bert. His track record on this channel hasn't been too good, hehe. Not gonna lie, first time I saw Guard From Hell, I clicked on it expecting your average spooky Thomas story, so I was shocked when Bert DIED. I also clicked on it thinking it was a standalone story and only found out later that Sodor's Supernatural is a chronological series. Maybe someday poor Bert can finally earn a W in one of Rheneas' videos.

@amitysluzara2022

9 ай бұрын

@NorthWestern1919 track record ha! I find that funnier than I should simply because engines run on tracks lol I was absolutely shocked by just how dark Guard From Hell got. I knew it was part of a series and had seen all the episodes before too but, this really shocked me as I wasn't expecting that. 3rd times the charm Bert should get a W next time

@NorthWestern1919

9 ай бұрын

@@amitysluzara2022 "Track record" was an unintentional pun, hehe! Looking back, the fact that Toby was stated to have gone missing in Horror at Ulfstead should have been an indication to us that this series wasn't afraid to kill off beloved characters. Sure, Toby isn't confirmed dead, but it's reasonable to assume he is. And judging by the teasers, Rheneas will be the next engine to be killed. As much as I like Sudrian Stories From Hell, I do look forward to when Sodor's Supernatural resumes.

Holy sh*t, honey... You're missing it, I think Bert's been possessed by the Yellow Engine.

never really cared about Halloween but all of a sudden last year I started loving horror stories, so glad people make ttte horror stories loved watched ttte as a kid

The yellow tank engine is of a class built in the united states not south america, but otherwise it's spooky.

@AlexTheTrain52

9 ай бұрын

I’m pretty sure it’s cuban

@Arkay315

9 ай бұрын

@@AlexTheTrain52 Nope, built in in the USA and then exported to Cuba.

Nice to see victor on mid sodar!

Nice adaptation, very eerie!

How am I not surprised about Bert singing the chant of the yellow engine or we could say victors first livery

bro the fact victor always has a strait face funny

4:26 It sounds like someone whispering over the speaker

Some South American steam locomotives and Philippine locomotives are known to be cursed so this yellow engine must be cursed.

Loved this Rhen! I keep thinking the yellow engine near after the beginning was an entity, funny how you added Frank’s driver was a smoker possibly shadowing he had mental health problems I guess..

Theese stories still are as amazing as last year I compared this to 10 o claw my favourite of 2022 and this was a huge improvement in terms of the writing and charecter choices also Victor was a amazing choice

Bert is the yellow engine ???

I Like Victor He Is A Cool Character In Thomas And Friends

After the Fog Phantom wraps up. Can you continue on this one?

My theory is that this engine is part of a multi dimensional cult and when he disappeared he left this universe and went to its own world.

Well, hopefully, we'll see more of this spooky mystery of these super natural at work and find what is really going on in order to solve it.

What if Victor was acting strangely because he was traumatized by his accident? Then he left to the Steamworks and was painted red

Either the engine came and unleashed a demon in the railway or a demon possessed him

This has left me scratching my head. I can't say for sure what the deal is with The Yellow Engine and what's he up to. All I know is that he's the splitting image or same model as Victor who FYI is from Cuba. But I may have a theory. My theory is that The Yellow Engine is actually from Haiti, which is right next to Cuba, and Haiti as well as other exotic countries are known for the occult tradition of....VOODOO. What I believe is that this engine was in fact experienced in the ways of voodoo arts and culture, and the mysterious chanting he was doing was an unclassified voodoo language, such as HVCL or Lucumi! As for if he's a friend or foe, I'm kinda torn. He could be just a deeply religious steam engine who often says prayers while he's doing his work to feel close to home and often goes out at night do a rite of passage or ritual, like confessing your sins or making the sign of the cross. BUT....as for why he disappeared, either he suffered a fatal accident while he was out or.....he may not even be a MORTAL BEING! So he went to mines at Marthwaite to either pray in peace or perhaps do some kind of ritual to travel someplace else! As for why Bert started chanting and went away, that's got weird written all over it! Surely Bert can't be the Yellow Engine....OR IS HE?? If THAT'S true, then the Engine must've changed his appearance to avoid suspicion and somehow learned English! But if he was a yellow engine when Frank saw him.....I dunno, some kind of voodoo spell?! O_o

Wow, what a twist ending!

Thank you so much!!!!

HYPED!!!!!!!

4:57 It sounds like background whispering

I come after the premier and no one has spoiled the ending and only mentioned bert and a plot twists. Im a scardy cat and i don't appreciate that.

IMMA CATCH THE PREMIERE?!

Would definitely like to see it more as bert being possessed

That yellow engine is just like victor

We need a part 2 to this

Great story.

I will NEVER look at BMM The same way again after watching this vid

Cool!

Nice way of using Victor for this story, especially when he's in his old livery. And that language he uses... Could he be a Parselmouth? And where on earth did Bert learn it from? What's going on?!?

The yellow engine is victor i think idk cause he was yellow but in this au i think he was scraped up and haunts the rails.

On the mid sodor the yellow engine was number two Bert is number two also so that means he’s most likely possessed

So you're telling me Duke worked nearly 40 years single handedly on the main till this yellow engine arrived and that yellow engine was on the railway for a whole 1 month before it vanished and Stanley was bought some time later (guessing 1922 here since he mentions he served in the war)?

I just thought of a big big plot hole in the story dukes line and Berts line are different gadges so the logic of a narrow gadge engine on small gadge track doesn’t work

Did you actually know that Victor from the famously well-known Thomas & Friends TV show's own official complete full CGI animation era certainly happens to be very shockingly surprisingly based on an official American-origin steam-driven railway O-4-O OST+PT tank engine built by Baldwin Locomotive Works in the officially well-known observational 191Os respectfully that officially built to work in Cuba as a standard gauge steam-driven railway O-4-OST+PT despite bein' completely converted to run on narrow-gauge tracks by the crew who made the show's own official complete full CGI animation era? It's completely true as according directly to the info 'bout Victor alongside his own official real-life locomotive basis in the video describing each of the characters ages alongside their own official real-life counterparts!

@DavidScholz-bu1ix

9 ай бұрын

It's true as I seriously read the info 'bout Victor alongside his own official real-life locomotive basis very shockingly surprisingly carefully!!!

@DavidScholz-bu1ix

9 ай бұрын

DON'T BELIEVE ME? CHECK IT OUT FOR YOURSELF!

@DavidScholz-bu1ix

9 ай бұрын

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH, REFERENCE TO THE FORMERLY KNOWN MID SODOR NARROW-GAUGE RAILWAY!

@DavidScholz-bu1ix

9 ай бұрын

❤

@DavidScholz-bu1ix

9 ай бұрын

SPOOOOOOOOOOOKY!

That ending

do you The Fog Phantom: Part III ? plsss

Victor is a narrow gauge engine from Cuba , South America and his old livery appears on the Blue Mountain Mystery. Also , he speaks Cuban , a South American which is his native language to Luke at Brendam Docks during he tells Thomas about his backstory. Victor to Luke : Hola a donde vas?? Vas a Sodor ??

@MSR2003Productions

9 ай бұрын

Cuban isn't a language, it's a nationality. He speaks Spanish.

@alekseyy__d

9 ай бұрын

@@MSR2003Productions ohh oohh , pardon me. Thank you.

@MSR2003Productions

9 ай бұрын

@@alekseyy__d it's okay, no worries 🙌🏻

@alekseyy__d

9 ай бұрын

@@MSR2003Productions 👍😁✅.

@kemperrogers5101

9 ай бұрын

That was just like the same language when he said hello to Luke and asked if he is also going to Sodor with and when he tried calling to crew for help after the chains that were holding his wheels broke after a big wave in Blue Mountain Mystery (2012).

What's the name of the credits music? Very dark and gritty, almost sounds like a haunted pipe organ

What did the yellow engine say in his echo voice???? And bert too

So if the migrant workers (possibly implied to be from Latin America) didn't even recognize the chants, what language is that?

When is part 2 coming out?

The yellow engine is Victor

What if this is connected to The Guard From Hell? What if El Diablo or the yellow engine offered Bert a second chance at life in exchange for his soul? Become that's my personal explanation for the ending

That Yellow Engine looks like Victor

@railwaysofcontrol2365

9 ай бұрын

Its Because it is Victor

@ThomasSirHandel

9 ай бұрын

@@railwaysofcontrol2365 Same class, different character

@kemperrogers5101

9 ай бұрын

He is just like the original yellow Victor with a Spanish language from Blue Mountain Mystery (2012) when he was on the boat with Luke to sodor.

Proteus engone Magic ❤

It's that, Victor !?

@ThomasSirHandel

9 ай бұрын

Most likely another member of his class

I wonder why they were muttering tiptoe through the tulips in that language.