The Worst Survivor Reunion Moments of All Time
What happens when Survivor goes live and Jeff Probst is completely unfiltered? One word... Chaos.
Patreon, sign up for free - / onceuponanislandchannel
Facebook - / onceuponanislandchannel
Instagram - / once_upon_an_island_ch...
Email - ouaichannel@gmail.com
00:00 - 1
02:52 - 2
04:10 - 3
05:59 - 4
08:57 - 5
11:05 - 6
12:08 - 7
14:43 - 8
Пікірлер: 236
That Eric and Jamie thing aged really badly...
@raymanmann8132
2 ай бұрын
How come?
@snobey
2 ай бұрын
@@raymanmann8132 Eric recently got in some trouble because of domestic violence
@tmm4195
2 ай бұрын
I was so sad and shocked to hear about that. I would never have expected that from Erik
@freckleface8402
2 ай бұрын
@@tmm4195wait what happened
@OnceUponAnIsland
2 ай бұрын
Wow, I had no idea when I made this.
i forgot how bad Brandon had it with Russell being the only family member to show up, dude was only 19.
@varisrevolver4061
2 ай бұрын
South Pacific as a whole was brutal towards Brandon, Coach used him and his religion in a malicious way, for payback against not what Brandon did, what Russell did to him in HvV, aside from the wanting to get rid of someone because she's hot and he's scared he'll be unfaithful, all I can do, is feel sorry for him
@Roz390
Ай бұрын
I felt so so bad for him. I still feel bad. After his dad showed up I was like, oh no. This kid was the only good person to come out of that family.
@user-mt5lj8ot3h
Ай бұрын
@@Roz390 He didn't seem that great.
@michaelbreaux-tj6mx
28 күн бұрын
@@varisrevolver4061 the brandon snapping part was staged. Brandon was fired and he asked if he could have an outburst moment to get voted off, and that's why he dumped the rice. Was just for the camera's then they decided it was too much so they just got rid of him at the challenge.
The season 45 reunion really showcased why we need the old reunion back. Like the Bruce and Katurah rivalry felt like such a big thing during the season, but it was never talked about during the reunion because no one saw the show or knew how they would be portrayed. Bruce wasn't aware of how much Katurah hated him and Katurah didn't know how bad and Bruce focused her edit would be. Definitely missed out on what could've been a fun reunion moment with Katurah being salty and trying to defend herself against the edit and Bruce just vibing lol
@so_obsessed_
2 ай бұрын
EXACTLY! I miss how they would talk about big events or storylines in the season or show funny clip shows!
@cassiusfelix2805
2 ай бұрын
Yup
@alexpoage1078
2 ай бұрын
Yes! Covid can't be the reason anymore, bring the live reunion back! It's a shame that the last live reunion we had was season 39 which had a black cloud over it due to the unfortunate events that took place throughout the season
@so_obsessed_
2 ай бұрын
@@alexpoage1078 yeah, it seems like all survivor cares about now is money. stay in fiji, shorter game, repeat challenges, immediate "reunion" all to save money without caring that it decreases the quality of the show.
@entertainer_ev2747
Ай бұрын
@@so_obsessed_ agreed. This show has been on life support for a long time
yo that jeff kiss was straight up messed up. kissing the dude without his consent, and him being married making it all the more uncomfortable.
@miajean1514
2 ай бұрын
If the genders were switched I think the contestant would have gotten a lot more backlash
@eatchiIdren
2 ай бұрын
Fr
@Littlebirdie886
Ай бұрын
He was assaulted , and he was so in shock he laughed it off.
@user-mt5lj8ot3h
Ай бұрын
I think about this all the time. the audacity of her
7:50 Jeff: This is raw footage… Dan: Throw me under the bus. Jeff: *Death Stare*
@user-mt5lj8ot3h
Ай бұрын
That stare gave me life
Jeff asking another man if they have a prejudice against women is sooo ironic
@tmm4195
2 ай бұрын
To be fair, at that point in the show, jeff seemed to change his ways and views a lot. Plus, Dan was so much worse with it lol
@user-mt5lj8ot3h
Ай бұрын
Maybe back in the day but he's obviously grown and we've watched it happen
Jaime and Erik do not end up being a happy ending at all... He is going on trial for domestic violence towards her, and possibly their child too.
@SteelersFanEv
2 ай бұрын
bro needs to post again
@horsepuncher95
2 ай бұрын
Eagerturtle 😍
I'm just here for David Murphy
@queenzoroark
2 ай бұрын
Shut the flippin front door
@machoman1016
2 ай бұрын
In his defense guys don't date girls who don't make the merge 😅
@eagerturtle4791
2 ай бұрын
Amber watching the whole thing is so iconic!
@esinger23
2 ай бұрын
Carolina: Shut it down 😂
the winners at war ZOOM reunion was the biggest disappointment ever
@OnceUponAnIsland
2 ай бұрын
They made up for it by extending the length of the finale.
@DR-xt5jq
2 ай бұрын
@@OnceUponAnIsland which is fine but it would have been a really really good reunion if COVID never happened
Rosie O’Donnell on the Marquesses reunion is in the “so bad it’s good” tier
Also, Jerri's a badass. No notes.
@_nate_young_6264
2 ай бұрын
I only know Jerri from HvV, and that clip of her getting booed off stage broke my heart honestly. Crazy how cruel audiences could be back in the early 2000s, I don’t think that would’ve happened today.
Despite some of the nasty things that Jeff and some of the contestants have said during these reunions, the audience will always be the worst part of the reunions for me. Rarely ever do they add anything of note, and in some cases they just serve to bully the contestants. I'm still pissed about how they treated Jerri during the All-Stars reunion. Unfortunately since they're a collective of unknown people, they can't really be called out on their behavior.
@eichy815
2 ай бұрын
I remember online commentators making light of it, back when it first happened, by glibly writing, "Hey, it's a New York audience!"
I can't even watch new era reunions - they're SO inauthentic and tbh, particularly cruel to losing finalists who are still stinking, filthy, and have had 30 mins tops to process the fact that they lost before they have to put on a happy face
Imagine if the new era got live reunions. Season 45 would've been awkward with Dee and Austin being split up and Katura hating Bruce.
@dictatureduaevuxgi8619
2 ай бұрын
Wendell in the crowd 👀
@crazyinsanepenguin
2 ай бұрын
@@dictatureduaevuxgi8619 Wendell in Dee 😜
@TheChamp33
19 күн бұрын
It would’ve been the messiest of the new era reunions for sure.
Poor Brandon man. Even coach was sitting there like damn that’s a too far.
I miss the live reunions. I love seeing what people think after they have seen what everyone else has done.
@stefanyordanov2885
2 ай бұрын
The "New Era" of Survivor has come with some unpopular changes since Survivor 41 so I can see why they would want to avoid live audiences for a while. The whole show is playing it extra safe on who they cast and what political opinions are allowed to be spoken out. Even though he show now has devolved a highly chaotic twisty gameplay, the whole "microcosm of society" concept of the show has never felt as controlled as it is nowadays.
@MultiJejje
2 ай бұрын
@@stefanyordanov2885i really enjoyed back when Survivor didn't have so many twists. Not every episode must have a twist, some episodes have even more than one. Too much luck involved. I honestly think the best player usually never wins anymore. Back when there was real skill... I know it's entertainment but too much is too much.
@stefanyordanov2885
2 ай бұрын
@MultiJejje I believe the twists are not an isolated problem that just spawned out of the ether but more like a symptom of the problem I mentioned. The reason there are so many twists is that the production team doesn't trust the contestants to be entertaining enough on their own. Whether they are or aren't is not the point. The point is that production itself doesn't trust the contestants to be entertaining on their own because that's not the casting criteria anymore. The casting criteria is being diverse, having the correct safe CBS approved political talking points, being able to pull off a perfect 10/10 😱shocked soyface😱 on demand whenever Jeff announces yet another minblowing game twist for 79th time this season. Even Jeff said he no longer wants to cast villains anymore. So that's why we have all those twists. Twists = entertainment nowadays. Enjoy!
@alexpoage1078
2 ай бұрын
@@stefanyordanov2885 we're getting very close to having possible villains this season the way Q and Venus are playing
The worst reunion moment for me BY FAR is Kat talking about her breast implants in the blood vs water reunion. It’s the most second hand embarrassment I get from any moment in the shows entire history and I don’t say that lightly
It’s so wild how the 20’s and 30’s seasons brought so many messy moments. While in a way, I’m glad that there’s been accountability with these reality shows not exploiting people with inappropriate scenarios. Sadly, we’ve flipped the script super far now where these shows are too scared to explore conflict and exploring raw authentic emotions. Positive or negative.
@cassiusfelix2805
2 ай бұрын
Yup
@joemodest
2 ай бұрын
Social Media really made it harder too. You're not only getting articles or writeups but people can swarm you in many ways you don't want in your personal life
@dannibookeddan8914
2 ай бұрын
Messy and really cringe sometimes
That David and Carolina moment is forever cemented in my mind ever since that reunion aired. 😅😂
The entire Brenda and Dawn segment from Caramoan is super hard to watch especially knowing about all the harassment Dawn went through online
We REALLY need the old Reunions back AND PONDEROSA
During the finale of Cagayan when it switched to those kids that all started making fun of Kass
I’ll never get tired of the Sami is only 19 jokes
@Christian-ql7uq
2 ай бұрын
i was rewatching 43 the other day and thinking to myself if someone made a drinking game out of everytime sami says hes 19 in his confessionals, they would die of alcohol poisoning
@olivermensinger
2 ай бұрын
But did you know that Claire still hasn't played in a challenge?
@givemeliberty700
2 ай бұрын
That was dumb to me , and they kept acting like it was a big deal
@DividingLitchies
2 ай бұрын
Liz and her fat stacks of cash paid for Sami to be 19 forever
@peytonbond4886
2 ай бұрын
I will
The funny thing to me about trying to shame Chris for lying is that today it just reads like hype, because lying in Survivor is only bad if it makes people mad at you and loses you the game. Chris is a god-tier BS-er and it won him the game, so hearing about how good at it he is just makes me love him more
Carolina didn’t deserve the public humiliation she got😂
Great Video, Thanks so much 😄
The HHH reunion, it wasn’t a reunion, it was where Jeff glazed on Ben for all 15 minutes. Yes; 15 minutes.
@varisrevolver4061
Ай бұрын
That's as bad as him wasting 10 minutes of a 20 minutes reunion, shitting on Dan, and spent not even 6 minutes on Rodney and Will, (I say 20, because the remaining 12 was for the next season)
I wish they still did reunions after the season had aired. I know not everyone loved live finales, I don’t know if I miss them being live but there’s a lot of machinations that go on behind the scenes that contestants don’t get to see until it airs and I think it brings something interesting to the reunions. Time has passed, we get to see them cleaned up, if relationships lasted, how people felt about their portrayal and plays that happened they didn’t know about, etc. There’s something missing when they just toss them from defending their game to the jury, the vote, winner announcement and the “reunion” all in a time crunch with no breathing room.
@addi543
2 ай бұрын
Allegedly, part of the cast on IotI were unhappy with the edit (especially about Dan) and were planning a revolt/walkout, and some assumed that it played a role in why they don’t do live reunions anymore
@alexpoage1078
2 ай бұрын
@@addi543 it's a shame that's the last live reunion, there is a dark cloud over the whole thing
I forgot reunions got their own episodes. (NGL I miss those times)
Wesley, you have a great voice over on your videos. Thanks for being such a huge fan of survivor and putting these out.
Bring back the reunion show please it gives everyone a chance to see how they were perceived by the show and the audience.
Jeff was salty AF at Vanuatu to sole survivor Chris😅
Russel is the king of me, myself and I. I am the greatest, even God can’t match my greatness. Has anyone ever had him checked for mental illness.
love ur videos!
@onceuponanisland these are some other moments I think you should include in your next video(s) Survivor: China when Jeff hounded Courtney about her weight Survivor: Nicaragua when Jeff tried to redeem Shannon Survivor: Blood vs. Water when Jeff asked Kat about her and Hayden's relationship Survivor: Second Chance when Jeff made the comments he made about Joe Survivor: Game Changers when Varner promoted his book
@OnceUponAnIsland
2 ай бұрын
Gotta save something for a part 2
poor jerri didn't deserve it :(
I always found the game changers reunion hilarious! Brad being so stubborn towards Probst while they were playing their make believe game was such a Culpepper thing to do 😅 And obviously Jeff asking Courtney if she has an ed is wild but I’m sure you have that one on deck for the next video
Another good video
Carolina dodged a bullet IMO
@livingmasquerade1418
2 ай бұрын
hopefully she found someone else, cheating is so painful.
and Dan deserved every. single. word. 🥰
if David Murphy is here i’ll be outraged! that was a great moment. on the same level as Russell saying “America should have the percentage of the votes”
I can already see that goofball David proposing to a previous first boot.
@MenverMan
2 ай бұрын
Hopefully the ultimate 1st boot, Francesqua or was it Franella?
Sometimes I just have ask myself this: “What would Survivor be without Jeff himself?”
My 2 picks are Rosie O'Donnell hosting the Marquesas reunion or them showing Stephanie Dill's audition tape during the Thailand reunion with her being completely nude!
For me, I remember one time that the reunion was interrupted for Boston Rob talking about his book, and the SIA moment. that was terrible
Jeff should hire Adam Klein as a consultant for the show instead of ragging on his business because he helped Kaleb get cast and the show staff cast two quitters. Adam Klein actually has a lot of great ideas.
@tmm4195
2 ай бұрын
he really does but jeff would never
I really thought you were going to include Rosie O'Donnell asking Sean about his two little best friends (at the Marquesas reunion)
Jeff is the true Roast King 👑
Love these picks! The entirety of Caramoan for me is without a doubt the single worst reunion episode that it could ever get.
Everyone reunion moment from the new era
The Rudy and Richard part of the Caramoan reunion kills me every time.
Dan only claimed to be a superfan. He kept claiming that “flippers never win”. That alone shows that he’s only a casual fan.
I don’t miss the reunions, they very rarely involved anyone saying something interesting. I don’t like the immediate after parties much either, and I struggle to think of anything else that could cap off the finale. I guess I’m just doomed never to be happy. I do like that, before going on his rant about how he brought greatness to the game, Russell addressed Brandon directly and said he’d sit down and shut up if that’s what his nephew wanted. And I’m pretty sure Brandon was in on it, that the whole thing was cooked up between them to try to keep that rapidly fading Hantz star power going a little while longer.
i miss cringing. bring back the live reunions!!
Anytime Ozzie opened his mouth.
13:27 Jeff is talking about the authenticity of the show citing Jerri leaving the stage as proof. And the the clip literally shows Jerri’s sitting behind Rupert until the next shot where she has disappeared.
15:40 Ok, but this is actually one of my few favorite moments from the new era after shows! We never would’ve gotten to see Jamie’s (and everyone else’s) reaction to learning about the fake idol, and I really enjoy seeing people react to huge surprises.
@alexpoage1078
2 ай бұрын
Right, that moment is actually not that bad considering there were so many fake idols that season and they were all epic fails! Sarah found the fake idol that Carolyn planted and she got voted out with it in her pocket and they never talked about it. Matty found the fake idol that Danny planted, but he didn't bring his bag and he did have a suspicion that it was fake and they never talked about it. The only one I guess that was worth mentioning was the one Jamie found that Matthew made since she gave it to Kane to hold on to and he left the game with it in his pocket
That forced proposal was akward to me
I'd almost forgotten that in the live reunions, some of the cast members are almost unrecognizable with their hair and makeup.
Wait kissing Jeff on the lips is INSANE HOW DID I NEVER KNOW THIS HAPPENED?
I refuse to watch David proposing to Carolina. I can’t physically watch without cringing
The blood v water reunion where cat talks about getting some “upgrades” so she’s more even with hayden is so awful I can’t even watch clips
I’m not sure if production is just being cheap or if there are budget cuts, or both, but it’s getting really obvious and the quality of the show is suffering for it. Obviously this is why they are not doing live reunions anymore.
I miss when Survivor became a trashy 90s daytime talk show at the end of every season 😢😢😢
9:17 "Bro" EDIT: Aye didn't expect my comment to featured at the end lol but thx
"So Erik, areyou still a virgin?"
The one that always stands out for me is in South Pacofic, Jeff makes a weird comment to Stacy and Christine that I've always found a bit awkward
That embarrassing moment from Blood vs Water reunion where Kat talks about her being top heavy now...OMG!
Definitely when he dissed Big Tom
Part 2 definitely needs to include Jeff asking Courtney if she's anorexic at the China reunion show
Jerri's comment reminds me of the Hunger Games
I have a feeling the China reunion is gonna come up a lot in this vid.
2:28 I CANNOT WATCH THIS LITERALLY EVERYTIME I HAVE TO SKIP PAST
1. The Rob/Russell bickering that led to one of the worst seasons. 2. The Denise from China scandal. 3. The entire reunion of Marquesas being hosted by Rosie O'Donnell. 4. Forcing the pre-jury boots to sit in the audience all because Brandon wasn't allowed to be at the reunion.
@alexpoage1078
2 ай бұрын
Yea, that made no sense, if someone isn't allowed to be at the reunion, why should all the other pre-merge boots plus Corrine be forced to sit in the audience? If they were trying to hide the fact that Brandon wasn't welcome, they didn't have to, the audience would have understood with one person missing why he wasn't there. Richard Hatch was still invited to the All-Stars reunion after what he did to Sue, but they re-arranged the seating so she wouldn't have to sit next to him since she quit right after he was voted out. At the David vs. Goliath reunion, Alec wasn't allowed to come because he broke his NDA and obviously Dan wasn't allowed to come to the Island of the Idols reunion, but they didn't force anyone to sit in the audience trying to cover it up because they didn't have to and they didn't have to at the Caramoan reunion either.
i know im about to cringe my way through this video. my second hand embarrassment cant take it.
When Jeff made a joke about Joe Anglims long hair, and Joe took it super personally and wouldn’t let it go while Jeff desperately tried to change the subject / go to commercial break. “Sooo you want me to conform to the standards of society….” I can’t remember the exact words, but just remember it being so cringe 😂
Why is Jeff having some issues with Adam’s business? He is becoming so unbearable.
you should just do a ranking of all of the reunion shows of survivor rank from worst to best once season 46 is over
@OnceUponAnIsland
2 ай бұрын
03:56
Wait what video is featuring Jeff insinuating Courtney has anorexia, if not this one? lol
Dude, did you know Erik from China was arrested super recently for domestic violence against Jamie?? It happened like a month ago or something. Truly saddening to see something like that happen. They'd been married for so long, and then this.
I literally won’t watch a new Era reunion. I’m glad to hear I’m not the only one
We don't get to see "Ethan Zorn"?
I think you should do a "Subtle Cringe Reunion Moments" video. Some examples... -- Jeff body-ogling Erin during the S5 reunion -- Jeff body-shaming Courtney during the S15 reunion -- Jeff asking Amanda if she's haunted in life by her mistakes at the S20 reunion -- Jeff letting Chase play guitar and sing at the S21 reunion despite the fact that he skipped over checking in with 6-7 people from the actual cast -- Jeff wasting time interviewing Terry Bradshaw about Jimmy Johnson's gameplay at the S21 reunion -- Jeff letting the random little girl in the audience dote over Ozzy at the S23 reunion -- Jeff wasting time interviewing Mayim Bialik about her opinion of Colton at the S24 reunion -- Jeff letting Boston Rob promote his book at the S26 reunion -- Jeff letting Rudy make the "gay joke" at Richard's expense during the S26 reunion -- Jeff not allowing the pre-jury boots to sit onstage at the S26 reunion...and then ignoring half the S26 cast members who actually WERE sitting onstage -- Jeff trying to coerce Dawn into apologizing to Brenda at the S26 reunion -- Jeff wasting more airtime by chatting with another random little girl who "reminds him of Andrea" at the S26 reunion -- Jeff allowing Sia to crash the S32 reunion so she could award Tai money for sparing the chicken -- Anytime Jeff lets a random little kid in the audience write down their winner prediction before he reveals the votes
@OnceUponAnIsland
2 ай бұрын
03:56
Jeff throwing Michele under the bus for Audry.
Wut! Sami was 19. Can't believe it!
Makes it even worse t hat eric JUST got arrested for beating jaime
Were the Dawson / Jeff roles reversed... Carnage.
the fact that jeff didn't immediately push dawson away when she kissed him... if i were his wife i'd be like we're done lol
Yam yam winning is the worst survivor moment in the shows history.
That kiss is crazy to me. And the virgin thing. Imagine sexes being changed on those and they were asking a young hot girl if she was still a virgin, or a man quite forcefully kissing a female host. But we don’t care about that kind of sexism right?
I mean dude's call each other's moms that all the time, and the shirt was funny af
@varisrevolver4061
2 ай бұрын
I think it might be because of it in general
@varisrevolver4061
Ай бұрын
After watching the whole season and reunion, Jeff had an agenda, he wasted 10 minutes of a 20 minutes reunion on everything to do with Dan, and when Dan even said he apologised, he didn't accept it, but if god sent Rodney said he said he's sorry, ah it's all good, onto Will it is. And that shirt...
People like Dan HATE when a mirror is held up. He ruined the season for me. Poor little loudmouthed victim.
Was Courtney shjtting on Denise in a confession and then apologizing for everything she said to Denise while Denise was one of the people who bored for her in a reunion? That made Courtney look like an azz. Even tho she owned responsibility.
Crazy pre mergers aren’t even invited to the reunion anymore
@alexpoage1078
2 ай бұрын
That's why they need to come back! We forget about half of the cast!
Him getting mad over Julie shows the power trip he’s willing to jump on when he’s simping. That’s so embarrassing for him. 🤡😅
Unrelated but they need to go back to the old Final Tribal Council format
If anyone missed it, once Erik responded to Jeff’s question, james leaned over to him and said “your mom is watching.” 😂😂
I feel bad for Daniel
Petition to bring back the full cast reunion 👇
I stopped watching survivor after 41? Am i missing something is it good or it's not worth the time? Especially the week in between episodes?
@sentientsardine9729
2 ай бұрын
41 and 42 merge together in my brain I constantly forget which details came from which game. 44 I really enjoyed, 43 and 45 are okay? Honestly 44 I feel is peak for prominent characters who are also good strategists. And some who are not.
@annesherman7014
2 ай бұрын
I haven't watched since they changed everything. Too many gimme on advantages and the shorter days. Too boring
@alexpoage1078
2 ай бұрын
It's gotten better since 41 you should get back into it!