Who is your fave? Who would you put together in one group? In part two of this video I will check the rest of the voice and will arrange VCHA blind - without knowing how JYP decided. :) If you would like to check out my course: Basics of K-pop singing, make sure to subscribe here: www.katriinka.com/newcourse

@nee306

9 ай бұрын

the perfect lineup for me wouldve been: Gina, Kaylee, Camila, Lexus, KG, Savanna and Melissa (who sadly wasnt even able to appear in the bootcamp episodes) i got nothing against kendall at all, i js think she mostly got picked cause of visual. Which is common in survival shows. And im still in shock that Gina didnt make it, no doubt she wouldve finished this group perfectly

@blvemaze

9 ай бұрын

@@nee306 The character evaluation in A2K was crucial to be able to debut and be part of the final lineup, if Kendall didn’t receive so many votes she would’ve probably be eliminated together with Cristina and Gina. But that’s one thing you have to reflect on : Kendall has received the most stickers together with Lexus by trainers! They know how much potential Kendall has and how much she improved. The only problem i think is that she’s a lil unstable but her tone and voice colour are so nice.

@blvemaze

9 ай бұрын

My favs are probably Camila and Savanna!

@relaxcalmly1742

9 ай бұрын

Vocal-wise, in order, it’s Camila, Melissa, Kaylee, Kaylee, KG, Kendall. These are the girls who are the better singers. The others are stronger as dancers but got better through the end after some training. Just talking about vocals here since you’re a vocal coach.

@john15photo

9 ай бұрын

They have progressed greatly down the line. This is at a very early stage. Some weak at vocals became strong and some weak at dancing became strong there. This is not a totally accurate indication of their trajectory. And trajectory is a very big thing in this series.

I recommend you check out KG’s version of Leanne Rimes’ Blue later on in the show. It is absolutely BEAUTIFUL. I don’t like country usually but it’s almost a crime she didn’t go down the country genre.

@keeptaiwanfree

9 ай бұрын

just thinking of her cover of Blue gives me the chills, she absolutely owned that performance and honestly it makes me sad too that she won’t be singing country music like that. it feels almost like a waste for her voice to be used in short lines in k-pop songs haha :’) but at least she slays the high notes

@nabi5864

9 ай бұрын

Im Korean, and the older kids plus young adults are not into Kpop here … we instead gravitate towards K-Indie music… if KG learned some Korean and sang country in Korean , she’d be a big hit here

@ddhika7332

9 ай бұрын

Lol.. I thought that performance are the worst performance of KG, but maybe its hugely because I never like a "real" country music, I only like pop music that get some influence from country, like Taylor Swift, Shania Twain, Jewel etc..

@silklavender

9 ай бұрын

@@ddhika7332so basically you have common basic mainstream taste in music

@strwshir

9 ай бұрын

upp

My bet Savanna has the best potential. Because although her voice is not yet develop, its full in nature and resonating in nature and she could hit higher if trained properly.

@akaikeshi1906

9 ай бұрын

I love her timber, it's so unique

@Xhin229

9 ай бұрын

I've listened to their official pre debut release and Savanna definitely is the who had the most improvement out of all of them. She has proven that potential indeed.

@navaehwilliams-rw4zx

9 ай бұрын

​@@Xhin229I think KG honestly. Let's not all forget she could not dance at all. It's not she was ever a bad dancer she was just never a dancer and never taught to dance

@Nopebrbra

9 ай бұрын

​@@navaehwilliams-rw4zxnope not kg

@Frozzter

9 ай бұрын

Her tone is so good

JYP knows that he's dealing with teens, who are still kids, in essence, so he has to be careful to mix praise with critique. As he said before, he is not looking for perfection. He is looking for talents who are willing to be trained, those who are can grasp the lessons fast and yet, still maintain good character/personality. I think this is why JYP talents stand out also because of their great personalities, aside from their talent.

@maiherojj

9 ай бұрын

So true. I agree with you.

@tenzintulotsang1953

9 ай бұрын

yeah everyone talks about kendall being a rly bad singer and tbh right now she does make more mistakes then ppl who didn't debut BUT she does have the potential as well as a voice that's still very raw (no bad habits that you have to unlearn)

@jennie_shiningsolo

9 ай бұрын

@@tenzintulotsang1953I think he chose her because she's visual material

@marinap5372

9 ай бұрын

​@@jennie_shiningsolohow can you say this when she did the 24 hour cover so well ??

@areanaangel8964

9 ай бұрын

He has a growth oriented, learn as you go mindset. YG has the opposite approach and won't debut until everything is perfect. He releases music sparingly because he's focused on the final product.

It's a shame Melissa left. Her vocals are amazing and her expressions are the perfect touch. I hope she becomes a singer here in America and make it big on her own.

@jessicadesmarais9256

9 ай бұрын

Yea she was probably my favorite singer of all the girls shown auditioning. Sad thing is every time I read comments there was a lot of negativity towards her, or at least not wanting her to debut, maybe because of her dancing? I thought her and KG had the most unique voices of the bunch.

@shweeroomdrrr9264

9 ай бұрын

@@jessicadesmarais9256melissa was def made to shine solo, i actually was relieved she dropped from the show because she doesn't suit kpop at all, and i mean this positively

@dearrachel83

9 ай бұрын

@@jessicadesmarais9256I never read comments since I watched all the episodes from my TV so it’s not easy to check, but that’s sad to hear. She seemed to have waaaayyy more life experience that she could put into her performance at such a young age. I do agree that she would shine as a soloist and I really hope she makes it and reaches her dream. ❤

@dearrachel83

9 ай бұрын

@@shweeroomdrrr9264I am wondering if she got other offers (wouldn’t be surprised) and that’s why she chose not to go.

@adinasworld

9 ай бұрын

@@shweeroomdrrr9264 this isnt kpop

Melissa left the show on her own and is now working as a soloist, she's fantastic

@sayurioffenborn4960

9 ай бұрын

why are you spoilering this? She have said she try to not spoiler herself. And now all the comments spoilering it for her. Hope she have someone which filters it.

8:41 probably it’s because jyp is trying to create a global kpop/pop group, and if she uses her “country” voice she’s going to stand out too much when they’re all signing together, when in a group they’re supposed to “blend” their voices. But for sure her voice is very unique and hopefully they’ll release unit or solo tracks where she can use it!

@Katriinka

9 ай бұрын

I see. I honestly do not thing twang is only connected to country so I do not mind it, but I see it can clash in group sound. I am looking forward to see how they blended the voice in the end. I will do my own arrangement haha

@DRUtastic

9 ай бұрын

@@KatriinkaI think it also has to do to with culture. In KG’s audition she was great but she had the typical Indie girl with a guitar voice. JYP said he wanted her to lose that. My guess he was thinking it wouldn’t go over well in Korea. Not that it isn’t great, she was awesome, but they have a standard to what voices should sound like. I’m hoping as the group gains more popularity all of the members can let there originality shine more.

@SYDDOS

9 ай бұрын

Blend voices? Have you heard Harvey's voice in the XG girl group?

This was soooo FUN. Having your awesome comments along with the show was really really nice. Thanks a lot!

@ginapark9902

9 ай бұрын

She has no clue this is a k-pop audition. She is in the dark why country song twang is not welcome in this audition.

@aur1_

9 ай бұрын

@ginapark9902 Even tho she doesn't know, it's absolutely OK for her to say that she likes it and that she wouldn't make the girl change it. (It's a personal opinion after all) Besides, All singing techniques are used to convey certain styles and feelings, if JYP doesn't want them it's OK to ask for his groups to not use it. And so, it's OK for us to 'wish' that wouldn't be the case. ✌🏻

KGs version of blue is her best performance, I love how unique her vocals are more than how good they are, she still gives me chills! Her Verizon of blue is literally one of my favorite like….audio files ever made LMAO

@emily_eliza

9 ай бұрын

i always go back to listen to that performance! her rendition of blue just sends shivers down my spine

@HolicChan

9 ай бұрын

@@emily_elizasaaameeee the control she has over her voice is wild

Although Yuna was by far one of the weakest vocals , she had that Kpop tone … but at her age being the oldest at 17 it would take a year or two… unfortunately she only had couple months

@parisortiz8731

9 ай бұрын

Yea I feel like if she was given more time she could have done better

@valerialuna3598

9 ай бұрын

Yeah, I hope that after coming back to the US she keeps practicing and taking lessons

@DKPaladin03

9 ай бұрын

​@@parisortiz8731she got 2 months to prepare for her perfomance but still fail

@multipotter1828

9 ай бұрын

Unpopular opinion but not everyone in a kpop group has to be a vocalist? I thought her rap in The Feels was amazing

@clackracks2349

8 ай бұрын

@@multipotter1828it was alright

the contestants were given a list of songs that the company has the copyright to broadcast. that's why they're all singing these difficult songs and why many of them chose the same ones.

@Katriinka

9 ай бұрын

I was thinking about this! Yes, I get it now. It would be amazing if they would give them more options. Like obviously adele rights were...accessible haha.

@mills55

6 ай бұрын

@@KatriinkaChristina went on a podcast and revealed they didn’t choose their songs at all or the outfits for the most part.

please continue evaluating all the episodes! I loved hearing a vocal coach's perspective. They perform together later, I'd love to hear if their voices blended well.

@RIQS-f8u

9 ай бұрын

that's gonna be embarrassing for their fans, seeing the talent is just average

Please do more A2K videos! I want to learn an experts opinion about their vocal journey. If they improved and if not, what do they have to do. Also, a dream academy videos would be nice too! Thank you so much! I enjoyed today's video as well 💗

Wow, Melissa is amazing! I can't see her working as a group singer. She needs to be solo. She would shine brighter as a solo artist.

Honestly kg has so much potential. Shes definitely one of my most favorite contestants. Shes eye-catching and unique and i love her vocals.

Thanks the detailed evaluation on Kendall. Personally, I didn't Kendall was all that good for this and her other performances but your explanation helped my understand JY Park's evaluation .

@melismaze

9 ай бұрын

Lexi was the one contestant who had the most improvement in her vocals! It's great seeing her debut.

@SyazwaniShukri

9 ай бұрын

I was truly surprised Kaylee got more criticism than Kendall. i love Kendall but she wasn't then best here for sure

Now that was great young lady. Please do more on this group. Thank you so much

Melissa has a good voice, it is just sad that she quit the show before they went to Korea.

@hallooos7585

9 ай бұрын

Fr Camilla, Melissa, and Kg was the Jiwoo, Channell, and Jongeun version of A2K 😭

@sayurioffenborn4960

9 ай бұрын

why are you spoilering this?

@soosoolar

8 ай бұрын

@@sayurioffenborn4960cause its over, the group is decided

@sayurioffenborn4960

8 ай бұрын

@@soosoolar maybe people watching this which not knowing the group or thr resoult.

@soosoolar

8 ай бұрын

@@sayurioffenborn4960 why would you do that instead of watching the actual show lmfao

I 100% NEED part 2. Your analysis and commentary on the vocal performances is really insightful to people(me) who don't know anything about vocal performance

Id love to watch you and hear your opinions on other episodes and performances too! My girl KG has such an amazing performance a little later on! Great video ^^

A nice analysis, it helps me to connect more details that I missed to see. Btw it's very nice to see your video. Your voice rocked!

This was super interesting! Id love to see the other contestants as well! Especially Gina and Camila!

I relate so much with Kendall, because I clearly see that we have the same difficulties when singing. But seeing her improvement, it creates a little of hope to me

@vandodbrandli9448

9 ай бұрын

I relate to her so much with the allergies. I have the same problems when allergy season hits

Very interesting! I’d like to see part 2 with the other contestants

7:04 I burst out laughing at mischa's reaction too when I watched this ep 😭😭 she's so cute

@rahrety

9 ай бұрын

I hate jyp too for wanting her get rid of that voice style he's playing safe too much he needs to step out of the box that's why fifty fifty got it international.

For Kpop, vocal technique no need to be very good, but good enough. Of course how minimal skill is subjective. Kpop group need to dance and sometimes dancing while singing. It is different skill. Usually "the voice kids" contestants have better vocal technique than debuted kpop group. Like you said, don't give songs that a kid do not understand. In these contest, Gina failed because she can only express a happy song. Everyone have different age to be mature mentally.

They were given a list of songs to choose from.. none of them are easy. Its to see their capabilities and potential early on. The girls who made the group from this show deserved it! This was a tough one!

I love this type of content. I watched the whole show religiously. I would love to hear your take on it more ❤❤

I love this type of video! I enjoyed the show very much and it is very interesting to hear the opinions of someone with so much knowledge. It helps me understand more about it. I'd love to see you do another a2k reaction from their last few performances to see what you think about their progress. I'd also love to see you do this for some of the older shows like Gp999, Youth With You 2 and the Produce 101 series.

Couldn't agree more. I love KG's country twang.

@ginapark9902

9 ай бұрын

Then why KG came to kpop audition? She should have gone to a country singer audition.

@VivikaJooan-ri2lo

9 ай бұрын

​@@ginapark9902that was her decision...

@chuuahhh

9 ай бұрын

@@ginapark9902 listen to her solo songs and you will get it

@lin-gx1lp

9 ай бұрын

​@@ginapark9902it clearly worked for her if she debuted in the group

@isabel-be4vy

9 ай бұрын

@@ginapark9902because kg doesn’t want that career. she doesn’t have to have it even if she’s better at it, training can make her good for k pop

Love this video i wish you did the second vocal evaluation when they went to korea to see the progression of the kids.

Loved the video! I hope you can keep watching a2k and see some of the girls evolve!

I really enjoyed this video. I usually watch your reactions to already established artists, where a lot of the time is spent explaining why they sound so good, and what techniques they use, to enhance their sound and performance. So watching this, where you instead critique some more obvious flaws and explain what causes them, is an interesting change, which also doesn't stray too much away from what I think your audience likes from your channel, AKA your in depth vocal knowledge. I would love to see more like this ^_^

Would love to see an updated reaction/opinion after VCHA released their "Behind the Scenes" raw vocal recordings of "Only One." 😊

Melissa was so perfect So sad that she decided not to continue the show😭

Also pls continue with a second part! I loved watching a2k and I also love hearing what u have to say

Yes plsss!! You gotta finish listening to the rest though! Pls do part 2!! Thanks 😊

Looking forward to more!

Thanks for this video. Lookimg forward to the next one on the other members

I appreciate your detailed analysis. I agree; it would be interesting to see how much they evolve until they reach the final group. I also believe that Camelia is one of the top singers, right up there with KG and melissa

I need to see your reactions to the more final performances at the final stages! Just to see their growth and what you think about that! ❤

Thank you. This is really interessting to see. Especially because most people say JYP is too nice to Kendell (singer 2) and you defended her. It will help some people to see where the girls stand.

@relaxcalmly1742

9 ай бұрын

Yes she defended her but she also disagrees on the technical parts of Kendall’s voice which a lot of people are with. And some people are mean but there are some who are just honest but people who love kendall will still take it as hate if they disagree. This is just constructive criticism. Kendall is one of my biases too and i do not dislike her.

@keeptaiwanfree

9 ай бұрын

@@relaxcalmly1742Exactly, I’m pretty annoyed with people who are upset that we are giving kendall constructive criticism. just because we’re criticising someone doesn’t mean we’re hating them or even dislike them?? I had an issue with JYP always calling kendall’s vocals “PERFECT!” bc they were… far from perfect. By lying to her, he doesn’t even allow her to improve at a normal rate and that’s why she ended up sounding worse during her final performance too (but who cares, we all knew jyp would still pick her because he finds her charming or whatever.) I also just think the favouritism is unfair to other contestants, but I digress.

@aniki3856

9 ай бұрын

​@@relaxcalmly1742depends on who you see So far I've not seen that much constructive criticism and mostly only hate PPL saying her voice is bad (some giving opinios while some hating outright), her singing is worst out of them and stuff like that. They are not judging but just hating cuz their favs weren't praised. Like I said mostly hate and only some giving criticism saying that her vocals won't improve if jyp only praises her.

@aysha6044

9 ай бұрын

​@@relaxcalmly1742imagine if kendall was so good than Gina and jyp pick Gina imagine how she and her fans and the audience would be. Kendall apart from Yuna dnt think she has the best among the other members she is just there even the facial expression he is talking abt for gina Kendall has only one facial expression. He is clearly biased in all honesty and the problem is that he did not even tell her mistakes if he was told her the mistakes we would have improved we the audience are the only ones speaking the truth.

@relaxcalmly1742

9 ай бұрын

@@aniki3856 I see those comments too. Those are mean comments. They are upset when there are unfairness. I’m not excusing their behaviors and do not condone it. However, when people say things like “Lexus sound better than Kendall on this part____… and JYP doesn’t even acknowledge it” or “she sounds weak and voice cracks on that part” they are comparing out of unfairness or out of constructive criticism if it is true. It’s when they say “she sucks” or “i hate her voice” or “her voice is ugly,” that’s disrespectful and rude. Those are straight up just criticism and doesn’t do anyone good. They’re a team, so we should just support them equally as one so they can be a strong team. Anyone can have their biases but don’t make enemies with fans of one team. I admire them all individually and they have their own uniqueness and strengths.

Your point about these teenagers not having the right songs to sing is so true, they really won't empathise with a mature "scorned woman." I think JYP gave them a list of songs that the contestants could choose from so alas this is what happened :/

It’s crazy how she gave the exact same comments jyp got so much hate for 😭

I love your analysis! Very interesting!

Love this kind of reaction 🩵🩵

Having watched the show already, this was still very interesting. I hope you decide to continue reacting to trainees/contestants in the future (especially Dream Academy, since that show has basically no commentary).

Wow, I’ve watched the whole series, and going back and seeing this, I almost feel like Kendall regressed throughout the competition? Her sounds stronger here

@StanChunghaOrGoHome

9 ай бұрын

She regressed because JYP didn’t encourage her to work more on her vocals. He kept telling her she was great in every round. JYP sabotaged her vocally I think through his favouritism.

@areanaangel8964

9 ай бұрын

Kendall's singing was better than I remember and Kaylee's was less strong. The only thing I remember were droves of people saying Kendall was soooo bad and couldn't sing at all and Kaylee deserved the stone. And a TON of "justice for Kaylee" comments. Listening to Kaylee's performance again, this is actually not how I remembered it. I think because of the sheer volume of comments in the beginning saying Kendall couldn't sing at all and this was an awful performance. I came back expecting it to be awful but it turned out to be not bad and to have some strengths and parts that were good!

@areanaangel8964

9 ай бұрын

She actually improved with Wannabe and was able to use her chest voice. She sounds fab hitting that note. I've replayed it so many times. Lol. She improved again with 24 hours with a slower dance. Once they started giving her dances with fast, hard choreography, that's when she sounded worse because she was the most unstable contestant. There were only two times when she sounded really bad but for some reason, people only remember those. Lol. The first was when she recorded that 1 line for the outro song. She was given that line to sing for the first time and it sounded really bad in comparison to KG, Camilla and Kaylee (main and lead vocalists). In the studio version, she sounds MUCH better. ALSO, when NO ONE knew it was Kendall singing that last line, the line sounded OK and no one had an issue. AFTER finding out it was Kendall, suddenly people were saying the last voice in the outro sounds not as good as other people's. Dude, we've all heard the outro every episode and no one ever said that the person who sings the last line is bad. No one critiqued the last singer's voice until they found out it was Kendall LOL. Her first performance with that last stage was bad because she was unstable due to hard choreography. In the LA performance here, she didn't dance. Watch her performances now after the pre-debut stages. She's actually the most stable she's ever been so she did improve.

@parisortiz8731

9 ай бұрын

Well also here she’s just standing and singing but in the other performances she’s dancing too.

Kendall is JYPs favorite thats why she praised her so much

Yes! Please do more of these.

Yes please about a2k please :) especially the final performances!

To choose Kpop artists 60% is about their dance/physical capabilities and the other 40% is half about their visuals/charisma and half about their singing/rapping. There are many members who debut without great singing skills because they are rappers or main dancers, the company gives them vocal lessons while they are already an established group

melissa's performance on the character evaluation episode was my fav, when she performed her own song

JYP set the songlist they had to choose from 😅 i don't know why he chose so difficult songs

2:55 KG 의 Country Music Style Or Sarah McLachlan Style 창법 (singing style) 은 쟝르에 한계를 가져올수 있으므로 JYP는 그것을 없애라고 하는것으로 보이네요~~

theres so many unprofessionals judging their ability😭 ty for this vid

That's a very accurate explanation. omg ~

Please please do it for JYP's other current show Nizi Project 2 also!

I think, for the song choices, they only had a handful of songs to choose from for this episode. Idk who chose the songs, (probably JYP because they seem like songs he likes), but I agree that they aren't really appropriate for this age group to sing.

Excellent commentary!

Very good analysis 😊❤

@Katriinka

9 ай бұрын

thank youuu! :)

Quiero tu análisis de dream academy. Quizás en el próximo reto puedas tener más información más profunda de las participantes. Actualmente hay dos videos donde están cantando. Espero que en el próximo evento todas puedan demostrar su habilidad en el canto. Muchas gracias

JYP has very specific tastes when it comes to singing. You see it in Sixteen (the show that put Twice together), in K-Pop Star (another idol audition show), and other shows he's a judge for. That's why he wants KG to take out the twang. He doesn't like it, and a number of other kpop companies don't like it either.

The new Ado's song "show" is crazy!cant wait for your reaction!

Please do a video of their evaluations later on in the show!

please continue for the next episode of tebtang a2k to the final episode, even they've already released the pre debut mv as well as and the name of the group from a2k is vcha

I hope you reacted to some group performances, they usually does better on groups

Melissa was my favorite voice from this show, i still miss her 😔

I love this video. Can you please also analyse the Dream Academy mission 1 vocal performances?

A2K is fun to watch especially towards the last 5 episodes honeslty

im so sad melissa never went to korea for whatever reason cause her vocal color is WOW

Please check out their pre debut track after you finish the series

my mother establish the voice for children and many things you said i have heard. she also pay a lot of attention to suprafrontal (not sure the term) resonators to establish a good "opera" voice.

yeah def do the second part

I need you to react to the second part of this vocal test

A lot of K-pop companies want to push their idols into singing a particularly style which is why he made those remarks on KG’s vocal twang.

@Katriinka

9 ай бұрын

sometimes it is such a pity. Like I understand the need to be able to build the sound of the group but I love the originality in voices.

@T_kats

9 ай бұрын

@@Katriinka Totally agree! And it’s even worse when they also force idols to singing out of their range in favor of highness :(

@elle_na619

9 ай бұрын

Yes, just like Rosè. I like it though it’s unique and I wish they let her sing with her twang a lil bit and not get rid of it completely

@InvisibleRen

9 ай бұрын

Yep. It’s super common for a K-pop group member to get a solo song and people go, “Wow, I didn’t know they could sing like that!” 😂

Omg i cant wait for this video so people can stop talking nonsense about who has best vocals...

Oh my, Melissa! She was really incredible and I'll always be thinking of her! She did so well in this competition

@atlanteantapir

9 ай бұрын

To be honest, she always gave me a more solo-ist vibe, and since dancing is not her most comfortable element, I think being a solo artist would suit her much more! Her singing blew me away

@melododie

9 ай бұрын

@@atlanteantapir omg I completely agree

Melissa was the perfect fit for this group but sadly, she decided to quit before going to korea. Its also good because we get see more of Camilla and KG as vocalists but the remaining 4 members, I'd say Kaylee has the biggest potential of becoming a good lead vocalist more than Lexus and Savanna. I'm sorry but Kendall definitely debuted because she's JYP's favorite and after hearing her voice in the Y.O.Universe and mushow performances, girlie is indeed backed up by JYP. I hope div3 will consider giving the girls to republic records and let them make their music instead of jyp.

@WokOverEasy

9 ай бұрын

She’s JYPs favourite because of her good looks and stage presence. You can work hard to improve in dance and singing. There’s little work you can do to look better or have natural expressions.

@SYDDOS

9 ай бұрын

Melissa was never a perfect match for this group or Kpop genre. Melissa's natural voice is that of a solo singer in a different music genre.

I hope we see Melissa again. Her vocals are outstanding. Her control is amazing, her performance is next level. KG seems to have the most vocal training base. I dont love that JYP likes to only hear a very specific vocal tone for kpop. Yg (who gives the worst vocal training it seems) doesnt so this, so Rose has a lot of twang left to her voice and they work it.

@DoctorStrange01

9 ай бұрын

Isn't she already performing solo though ? lol. Melissa's case is really strange to me. She knew she's a soloist and went for a KPOP girl group audition, and a JYP audition at that and as we all know, this is not CUBE or HYBE, there's barely any artistic freedom there, especially for girl groups. Makes me wonder if going there was for the sole purpose of getting more recognition and her name out there through a popular show. Her answer during the interview kinda cemented this impression for me.

@donlee4105

9 ай бұрын

​​@@DoctorStrange01i loved all of contestants except for her. Like you said,recognition

@earthcitty

9 ай бұрын

@donlee4105 I was not a fan of Melissa or Yuna. Melissa obviously wanted to be a soloist. Yuna had a lot of issues, but she really was not up to the same level as the other girls.

Can you do further analysis on A2k i found this so insightful. Perhaps on other performances on the show

Your videos are amazing!!! I don't know if you know but Hybe did a reality show too that formed a girl group called I'll-It!! I would love to see you react their vocal skills, the reality show was RU Next

I do think you'd similarly enjoy reacting to the Dream Academy vocal groups for Mission 1 - they're comparatively short and you could knock both out in a single reaction. You might also consider doing a couple of the final performances from R U Next? for the contrast with the performances here. It's Hybe (as is Dream Academy) but a much more typical Kpop survival show. I do not think the resulting group I'll-it (yes, the name is terrible) has a particularly strong main vocalist compared to Vcha (also terrible) and whatever Dream Academy will produce though I like them well enough. (But what I REALLY REALLY want is your take on Ado's recent release "Show".)

I hope you go through the singing performances/group performances in the whole show. I would like to hear your comments on their progress.

Kpop artists are not just singer & performer. We see cuteness & pureness of them. So Kaylee & Kendall are not the 1st performer but they are good and makes people smile. They are adorable.

My fav voices are kaylee and camila I really enjoy listenning to them

Melissa she surprised me. It's a shame she hadn't finished the competition.

we need the second partt

you should have collaboration with jyp

Me gusta mucho Kendall por como interpreta las canciones, me pone muy triste que ella reciba tanto odio por su canto, me encantó que apreciaras sus habilidades! thank U!!

i hope you can react to their pre debut album. There are 3 songs i think. Btw, love your reaction and review.

@InvisibleRen

9 ай бұрын

That has heavy production applied to it though, what’s the point? Like, what do you want her to say? Her expertise is vocal coaching meaning singing techniques; everything done in the studio is stylistic and business choices and then afterward stylistic and business choices inform the producers’ mixing (autotune, vocal fx, etc). She can show her expertise better reacting to a live stage where the backtrack isn’t too loud. Then if she wanted, she could possibly compare the two, but that wouldn’t be fair unless the live performance was a sit-down acoustic version. But if there’s a sit-down version (which there probably won’t be), it’d probably be better to just react to that alone. 😅

@Katriinka , they already had many professional vocal coach.

Really want to know your take on their vocals. Yay! 12:08 😅

I am sure it is SAVANNA!!!! 😊❤️❤️

I think Melissa is the best singer in A2K contest, she’s perfect, her singing was so professionally done👍🏼 KG will be after her. Other than that, I don’t really think anyone could done better than the 2 but unfortunately Melissa give up half way🥺 hope she’ll debut too.

@sorbbae620

9 ай бұрын

we dont know that melissa "gave up" perse, she left for "personal reasons" it could have been a family emergency, or something of the sort, even if she did "give up" i would hope that she would know how talented she is, and use the exposure from it to further her career.

I miss Melissa... she was so good. I guess she was too good for a group. I hope she puts out some amazing R&B and brings back that generation of music.

You should do Alamat. The wish bus of Say you love me is amazing. The song Maharani and Walang Hanggan are great.

Hii! There is an incredible Korean artist called DAWN that just posted a new music video and he deserves way more attention, so if you could give it a shot it would be amazing. It’s really really good! The video itself and the music it’s all so creative and pretty. This year he came out with an EP and till now he already made 3 music videos for 3 of the songs. They’re all so creative, different from each other and very heartfelt as well!

Melissa had so much more potential than Camilla but she forfeited from the competition made me really sad !! She had more colors in her voice !!!

Plsss we need second part ahahah