What did you think of the TV adaptation of the Novel? let me know your thoughts in the comments below!

@veronicaneacsu7483

26 күн бұрын

@@averagejoe8358 the real one was much worse..... a killer

@lynnedavies5884

18 күн бұрын

I want to watch the show very much however can i ask does it show anything cruel.

@marionweidenmuller7216

10 күн бұрын

Es ist leider nur in Englisch gesprochen hätte es mir gerne angeschaut

@mysticalwolfakela4131

7 күн бұрын

​@lynnedavies5884 Unfortunately it does. 😢

@lynnedavies5884

7 күн бұрын

@@mysticalwolfakela4131 Thank you.

I cried most of the time and I am pleased to see Romani people were included in the movie. I hope it will help these days to reeducate the public what has happened in Auschwitz

@Posie-hg1ze

23 күн бұрын

It’s an outstanding series. So emotive, heartbreaking yet beautiful.

I read this and the 2 books that followed in the series also by Heather Morris. The second book is "Cilka" which told the story of a woman Lale and Gita had known in Auschwitz and what happened to her after leaving Auschwitz. She had been forced to be a prostitute for the Nazis but the Soviets punished her for this by sending her to Siberia and what happened to her there. The third book was called "3 Sisters" and told about 3 sisters from Czechoslovakia who were sent to Auschwitz and how they cared for each other there to ensure that each survived. I hope they make films of these 2 stories as well as "The Tattooist of Auschwitz." I hope I can see this movie soon.

@audspod1

17 күн бұрын

Thank you. I didn't realise there were 2 other books. I will certainly read them. Lest we forget!

I’m watching it now. It’s heartbreaking It’s horrific and G-d forbid we shall never know what these people suffered… We shall Never Forget!

Jonah Hauer-King played the young Lale.who is Jewish, done a fantastic job. I’m so sick of hearing this negativity based on one opinion. The melbourne holocaust museum invited heather to discuss her book when it was released alone with holocaust survivors, they clearly didn’t have an issue with the book. I wouldn’t call this a romance, this lale story he meet Gita in the camps so obviously she is going to be the main focus of his story. What right does anyone have to question lale story, it’s his own personal story, maybe he didn’t remember factual information 100% correct.. if someone reads or listen to one persons perspective on the holocaust and actually believes they have full knowledge and understanding of what happened that’s on them of being stupid. Anyway there is something seriously wrong if this is the first information they have learned about the holocaust.

I have watched many documentaries on aushwitz books even been there 3 times now and this series was really good i enjoyed it ..programmes like this are important ..history should never be lost in time

@user-pj2lu2mw7h

Ай бұрын

Watch the grey zone movie

I have read the book 📖 and I have seen the 1st series of it and its so heartbreaking 💔 😢 I was so emotional in some of it all can't wait for the 2nd one the following week 💔 😢

The movie deserves 5 stars. Everything from script to acting fabulous. Harvey Keitel superb.

@NiamhDaly-xr9gb

13 күн бұрын

Brilliant

It’s an excellent documentary film. It must be terrible to have to live the rest of your life with these horrific memories.

@audspod1

17 күн бұрын

Incredible! Beyond belief. How can humans do this to other humans??!

Wow just wow brilliant acting wrenching story very good worth watching

The show showed that even though you had to find ways to survive in the camps, love will always find a way to survive. I think it was a good show to let people know what the prisoners had to indore to stay alive.

@NiamhDaly-xr9gb

13 күн бұрын

Brilliant

I thought it was well acted true to life to think this really happened and it could happen again gives you shivers it brought a lot of things we should be great full for

Brilliant

I think it"s a great show

I didn't realize it was Harvey Keitel until the last episode.

fantastic series just wow

Good show.

Some of the information that was missing was because it was not available . It was shame though? May those who did not make it out of there. May they rest in peace.😢😢😢😢

Incredible. ❤

@BrainPilot

25 күн бұрын

It was a good show wasn't it!

@realwords4713

25 күн бұрын

@@BrainPilot absolutely! Certainly a must watch, and words can’t describe what a touching and complex story - soo well portrayed by everyone who had a part to play in this production 👏🏼 this will live with me forever no doubt and has even changed my personal outlook on life as a whole

@lynnedavies5884

18 күн бұрын

​@@BrainPilotCan i please ask does it show anything cruel as i find things like that difficult to watch.

@Step.Emanuele

13 күн бұрын

​​​​@@lynnedavies5884 there's some violent scenes but those aren't completely shown as some other topic-related films. The show is centered on Lali's memories and psyche, and it's focused on showing how some characters still haunt him untill old age. Overall it's not too gruesome or violent, obviously it's pretty dark and there are some pretty tough scenes, but it's not that cruel or too heavy to watch. I highly recommend it to you! I hope that what i wrote is understandable, my english isn't that great.

@lynnedavies5884

12 күн бұрын

@@Step.Emanuele Thank you so much for the information it is really helpful, also your English is great 👍.

I have read this powerful book but haven't yet seen the series. So glad it has been made into a series so hopefully this can never never happen again! Lest we forget 😟

A brilliant series, disturbing, shocking and beautiful, also great acting, music, a great 7th episode, a documentary.

My only few complaints are as follows. Why don't use the name of Kanada of the warehouse where Gita works . And it's odd she doesn't get food from there? There was always food hidden in the suitcases. Also, I feel they cut Cilka's role soo much. Nadya also if I recall older. And whoever read the book knows Lali knew ten languages, and I doubt anyone was speaking English. I wish there was a more authentic feel with subtitles. I actually thought there would be a multilanguage option.

all told in one breath, without punctuation

I have been there if you just stand still you can feel there still there

Those heartless monsters torturing those Jewish people my heart breaks for how they suffered.

Good but heartbreaking

@BrainPilot

Ай бұрын

Definitely!

There is also nothing about the Czeck family camp. When they were supposedly from Czechoslovakia !

No sound?

the book is a very good read and i was concerned that the series would do it justice. it did. to say about the young Lali having an english accent , well for me it did not distract from the performance what so ever. you stated on several occasions that they escaped from the camp, but they did not. they were both being marched to other camps when they made the run for it. not a big error, but if you are reviewing then its important thing to get facts correct. as for Lali's guard? he only did some nice things for them so that Lali would do things for him like the bottle of Schnapps. all in all the book and the series are very good.

Where can I watch this?

@BrainPilot

Ай бұрын

It's on Peacock/Sky

@veronicaneacsu7483

Ай бұрын

or sky showtime

@nancyayala2217

Ай бұрын

Peacock

@veronicaneacsu7483

Ай бұрын

@@nancyayala2217 in the rest of Europe will be on sky showtime on 7 of june

@HannnnR

26 күн бұрын

NowTV in the UK also

I saw the book in sainsburys the day

the author chose to come up with a fiction based on truw events... Heathet Morris was not really intending to write a historical account.. that wull require accurate accounts and evidence... Heather reasearched based on Lale stories... from his memories... she cannot basically make ahistorically accurate novel when here lrimary source is an old man wanting to tell his exoerience to reminisce his love for Gita...

@coreoYEAH

Ай бұрын

It's been a minute since I read it but I think Heather specifies that the book is not a historically accurate representation of Auschwitz, but a retelling of Lali’s recollection.

@ErinFindsHerWay

26 күн бұрын

At least she knows how to spell and form a sentence.

Jonah was Prince Eric

Where can I watch this anyone ? 🙏🏿

@BrainPilot

26 күн бұрын

It's on Sky or Peacock!

@ashleykraan7402

25 күн бұрын

Stacked on Amazon prime

love the book ilove Heatjer Morris... if i want accurate history i will jot read Heatjer Morris niv.. i will go to museums and check encyclopedia.. peopel should stop expecting the film as depiction of real life history... Read forat the history of the concwpt of film and the novel... And if you want facts read encyclopedias and primary sources... not movies ... this is evev promoted as dicymentary si we should nit expect... but the takeaway from this should be the value... human storytelling and how it revelas human resilience and ssearch for truth when we watch a fictional depiction of what happens in Auzswich

@ErinFindsHerWay

26 күн бұрын

If you want people to take you seriously, learn to spell, use correct punctuation, and how to form a coherent sentence. Your words look like gibberish. Nobody reads encyclopedias anymore, because those online are known to be inaccurate and the few print ones are out of date by 30-40 years. Also, my daughter works at a Jewish museum and is a history and Jewish studies major. Maybe let those with credentials speak.

@happybunny8704

12 күн бұрын

@@ErinFindsHerWayLet me explain what is being claimed here… The tattooist of Auswich is NOT true it’s a novel based on an old man’s memory as told to a novelist. The original post is correct if you read true accounts of what happened there from history you will find that Auswich was an extermination camp. Google if this is a true story and you will find that Heather Morris was nearly prosecuted by survivors and by the Auswich memorial foundation for claiming it was true when it clearly is not.. it’s fiction based on his memory and each episode has a disclaimer before it’s showing..

Great series very sad

Before you watch the show read the book

His name was Ludwig Eisenberg not sokolov he take the name after the war

Great story & sad

@BrainPilot

Ай бұрын

It really is!

Very good series. I did find myself annoyed with Heather's naivety though

It sold 30 Million copy's.

It's a novel and partly made up. I'd rather watch or read something that's truth.

I couldn’t finish the book because it simple was not true… the tv series was good but again filled with inaccuracies prefer the Pianist and Schindler’s list..

@coreoYEAH

Ай бұрын

The book was never claimed to be an accurate account of life in Auschwitz, it has always been a retelling of the memory of Lali.

@happybunny8704

Ай бұрын

@@coreoYEAH Then the retelling of his memory is inaccurate it’s been disputed

@coreoYEAH

Ай бұрын

@@happybunny8704 How do you dispute someone's memory? She’s recounting the memory of an 87-year-old man, not rewriting the history books.

@happybunny8704

Ай бұрын

@@coreoYEAH Historians have disputed it ..use google… there are a number of historical inaccuracies found in the telling of his memoirs …the book is fiction .. most people believe it’s true but it simply isn’t…

@raynorthedge5722

14 күн бұрын

How do you know it wasn’t true. Were you there

He was evill that whay he survived

spanish please!!!

I really wanted to like the book but it was riddled with inaccuracies. I'm talking about basic knowledge of the most infamous death camp. It was so upsetting that an author who apparently had conducted years of research, couldn't even put together basic facts. I have to agree wholeheartedly with the museum. The writing was also elementary and just so difficult to read. My one hope is that the series fixed those errors and had better writers.

@rebeccaearley4744

Ай бұрын

I think the fact she was writing from what Lale was telling her means they can not really be inaccuracies. It was more an old man as he was at the time miss remembering things or his brain putting things in different places. Heather spoke to Lale and did research on what he told her. Yes there are things that may not be 100%right but it's still his story

@coreoYEAH

Ай бұрын

She told Lali’s story as he told her. She’s always been honest about that.

@vickykulig5080

15 күн бұрын

This story is from Lale’s perspective, you can’t say someone’s own personal story is accurate. lale may not have saw a lot of the stuff that was going on in the camp, it’s raw and horrifying, but we as a community need to keep stories like Lale’s alive!

@happybunny8704

12 күн бұрын

You need to read survivors accounts of what really happened …this is a novel with a disclaimer before each episode shown that it is based on his memory

Don't watch it. Is shockingly bad.. The book was dreadful. Badly written .. The series is badly acted. It's just shite.

@nancyayala2217

Ай бұрын

Wow how can you say that

@johngreen-sk4yk

Ай бұрын

It makes me wonder what your actual motivation is for making that comment ? It's perfectly watchable . I'd encourage anyone to watch it and draw their own conclusions

@megadethmofo2001

Ай бұрын

What's your problem? I thought it was great.

@carla4282

Ай бұрын

Beautiful love story

@rebeccamccutchen6414

28 күн бұрын

I guess you don't know about the millions who died in the camps in world war 2 some people have no brains. Please get the facts before you speak.