The reason why teddy’s songs are hits is only because he works with strong and charismatic artists who can carry the songs imo

@scarlett9750

2 жыл бұрын

Trueeee

@seulmiseforever9603

2 жыл бұрын

Gonna agree with this one

@Androids23

2 жыл бұрын

Blackpink carried him lmaooo

@suckmetaehyung69

2 жыл бұрын

It's not about the artist it's about the popularity instead

@rosie5816

2 жыл бұрын

@@suckmetaehyung69 purrr. It’s all about popularity. Not hating hot most of the songs just plain suck and even the artist can’t make it sound good. Rember I’ve cream- yeah let’s not talk about that. But there hyped bc of how popular the group is. Someone like bts could come out with a song that talks about chicken nuggets and it would still place number 1 on billboards bc h Of how popular they are 😭😭

Blackpink at this point is more of a brand then a artist/music group

@XX-nf7gw

2 жыл бұрын

@@randomkid4783 its about black pink and not Bts. Pls don’t mention other groups

@yosandrytejedadelrosario8944

2 жыл бұрын

@@randomkid4783 imo bts is both

@raynasomers6266

2 жыл бұрын

@@randomkid4783 I don’t think it’s for the best. It’s for marketing and making money, but the music stays quite stagnant because of this

@raynasomers6266

2 жыл бұрын

@@randomkid4783 they aren’t bad songs, but when a huge part of discographies are made up of the same formula there is a problem. In my opinion at least. Hylt on its own isn’t a bad song, the only problem with it is that blackpink has released a lot of songs with the same structure before it. I also get that the songs are for the company’s mostly to make money, but as a fan I don’t think it’s weird to dislike it when there is such a formula. In my opinion it would be for the best if there is more experimentation, but if you want to look from the company’s point of view I get that it’s for them the best.

@hollyrose2418

2 жыл бұрын

You can say that about any kpop group to be honest

Another factor why people eats up his formula is because YGE itself puts their artists into a long hiatus to starve the fans.

@TomarBoroDada

2 жыл бұрын

Yg even promotes solo stan behaviour by doing shady things like not releasing teasers for certain members , leaving their solo pics out of campaigns , and not letting them talk during interviews , and not releasing statements for accusations to keep the fandom active

@nheilvocal3801

2 жыл бұрын

@@TomarBoroDada true though :(( im even dissapointed with BlackPink's album photobooks cause there's rarely group photos

@cookieeees

2 жыл бұрын

Not to mention, the pinks don't interact with their fans as much as other groups that famous, like BTS or twice. Idk if it's a management thing tho.

@cookieeees

2 жыл бұрын

And they also rarely let them go on reality tv shows. For a group that big you'd expect them to be everywhere, but that's not the case. It's probably why they're not as popular in South Korea, aside from the younger gen. Since they don't do many reality tv shows, that older people watch as well, people of other generations don't know them as much.

@whippedlikethetwoguysfromm7778

2 жыл бұрын

Starving ppl would grab for the bare minimum.. True

It's the freakin streaming culture and short attention spans. The reason Teddy's songs are so successful is because: - His songs are only around 3 minutes which makes it easier to stream (in terms of view counts) - Choruses themselves are written in a way that they are as catchy as possible. Instead of having long, complicated lyrics, it's just a few words chants that stick in your head immediately, and a repetitive melody. - Short verses and long choruses so the catchy part would play for the longest time in the song. - Two regular choruses and one "party chorus" or "dance break" or call it whatever you like, so it's not as repetitive as it would be with a third chorus. - And this party chorus is put at the very end because it's the most interesting part of the song and it makes people stick till the end. I personally prefer songs around 4 minute, those have the most room for structural experimentation, and feel less condensed and overly dynamic (as in they progress more smoothly) but Teddy's formula undeniably works. I don't think it's the formula in itself that is getting boring, but the genre and the soundscape. Teddy just can't get away from a very specific type of EDM.

@evelinramosmiranda619

2 жыл бұрын

his songs sound rushed sometimes

@bhpbp

2 жыл бұрын

👏👏you said it

@pg3856

2 жыл бұрын

Wdc bp outsold your faves

@roansiruno4637

2 жыл бұрын

@@pg3856 very childish of you to react like that when og comment wasn't even an insult to your fave. grow up

@jin_hit_entertainment3442

2 жыл бұрын

fr I was listening to dumb dumb and it felt like seconds and the outro already came

The thing is Teddy's works used to be soo good, Taeyang's Eyes Nose and Lips, Darling, iKON Apology, and of course Blackpink As If It's Your Last, Playing With Fire. He used to be very good, but after 2018 idk what happened lmao, it feels like he trapped in a box or found a formula and stick with it thus his works quality is deteriorating since.

@Bom13

2 жыл бұрын

Blackpink's success was so huge since the beginning, and Blinks are so loyal and desperate for new songs, that it made him realize he didn't need to put much effort in the girls songs.

@kelseyleeves8514

2 жыл бұрын

@@Bom13 which is really sad because I would love to see something different :(

@benholmes8870

2 жыл бұрын

I don’t know, I think he sometimes deviates from the formula and experiments producing longs like playing with fire, AIIYL and ice cream. But boombayah, ddd and the songs he produced before blackpinks debut for other artists seem more boring to me everyday. The more he puts out the same soundscape and structures, the less I appreciate blackpink’s discography as a whole. Everytime a new bp or somi song comes out, I find it catchy, but also boring. He’s never really been an experimental genius, his formula itself and it’s ability to be catchy is extremely clever, but teddy park is only considered such a big name because of the successful groups and soloists he is tied to…

@rmsdimples8533

2 жыл бұрын

He litterally just copy and pasted the same formula to Gashina, Solo, and Dumb Dumb. Which are total bops but after 10-20 listens I'd probably never play it again.

@ElenyM

2 жыл бұрын

Good point

Teddy Park's artistic peak was with 2NE1. Teddy Park's commercial peak was with Blvckpink.

@reddd5115

2 жыл бұрын

Facts

@HAJIMAY

2 жыл бұрын

True! “I love you” was so ahead of its time

@ana_26___

2 жыл бұрын

F A C T S

@NikkoTanGoogle

2 жыл бұрын

Can't Nobody - Iconic, Fresh, a bop for years

@Joseph-nm5xu

2 жыл бұрын

FACTS!

one thing to point out with somis dumb dumb is that this song looks like it was intended to be marketed and get viral on tiktok, hence why the chorus and choreography is simple and get stuck in your head easily

@sophiajackson8843

2 жыл бұрын

i totally agree with that. besides the prechorus and the chorus (beat drop), i believe the song is pretty stale.

@crisdl2509

2 жыл бұрын

Yes the chorus looks like the songs in tiktok

@2000seoulsonyosound

2 жыл бұрын

that's another thing that needs to go, tiktok challenges

@Bom13

2 жыл бұрын

@@2000seoulsonyosound YES !!!

@cloud_hee2742

2 жыл бұрын

omg yesss, the amount of tiktoks that somi has done with other artists

to be honest, the only thing that makes his formula stand out is the artists who carries it. otherwise, it would just float into the ocean of many many similarly produced songs. the songs he produces for BLACKPINK are like, 90% identical sounding to each other regardless if its a title or b-side. same goes for Somi. his music formula is lazy, (almost) always the same and unexciting anymore.

@erii7816

2 жыл бұрын

that makes a lot of sense, i still love blackpink, they’re so talented and sweet, but i really can’t listen to most of their music anymore for that reason 💔

@anujgopalsharma8911

2 жыл бұрын

I absolutely agree that either he need to change his formula or we need another producer but I disagree that all no song sound the same because their beside are real jems they sound so refreshing and also Somi and go formula can be compared but only to a certain extent as one is a soloist and other angel and also out of the 4 Somi song all sound polar opposites

@tanjieeyang8312

2 жыл бұрын

Agree. The only reason i still listen to the songs that he produced is because blackpink literally carried and well performance.

@yunjeans

2 жыл бұрын

The only thing that makes me listen to the songs is the instrumental, the instrumental proves he's a music genius but the formula proves he's lazy. So at this point, I have no idea whether he's both or neither

@ivyreid7

2 жыл бұрын

Isabel reed thank you! They seemed to have still missed the point. Out all somi’s songs only one of them is different.

i want him to produce a song like come back home by 2ne1. that song is insanely good like what happened after that😭

@iheartmomosoo

2 жыл бұрын

YESSS WE NEED ANOTHER COME BACK HOME 😭😭‼️‼️

@scarlett9750

2 жыл бұрын

@Did someone say DRACO MALFOY uh?

@seulmiseforever9603

2 жыл бұрын

@Did someone say DRACO MALFOY How does this even related to the topic itself-

@mookchie

2 жыл бұрын

@seulmiséforever What did they say?

@iheartmomosoo

2 жыл бұрын

@@mookchie they said "you never know is better" or something lmfao

i swear to god if he does this to lisas solo I'm gonna be so mad. she deserves a good and complex dance track. roses on the ground was a huge letdown for me and the beatdrop was awful imo. she deserved better

@matt_villanueva

2 жыл бұрын

I’ve said the same thing about on the ground too but lemme tell you, I got so much backlash for it

@klee4358

2 жыл бұрын

@@matt_villanueva that sucks, i wish people would respect that there are aspects about otg that just weren't likable to some ppl smh

@charlufquinto8725

2 жыл бұрын

Lisa is a dancer and a rapper so you should expect something like this

@V.xshhhh

2 жыл бұрын

Gone was better the lyrics the beats were really good imo but otg the beat drop the chorus was awful and I didn't like the high note at end it was kinda meh gone deserved to be the title track

@klee4358

2 жыл бұрын

@@V.xshhhh oh totally agree I LOVED gone it should’ve been title

I think that’s why I love ‘Lovesick Girls’ it has a proper Chorus, pre chorus, bridge and verses. IMO one of Blackpink’s best songs.

@Nanahaosaki

2 жыл бұрын

And I really like how they had David Guetta on it

@davidmchugh2959

2 жыл бұрын

@@Nanahaosaki oh wow I never knew he had a writing credit… that prob explains why I love it!

@Nanahaosaki

2 жыл бұрын

@@davidmchugh2959 I think it was producing I’m not sure about lyrics I forgot

@davidmchugh2959

2 жыл бұрын

@@Nanahaosaki he’s credited on Spotify so could be either… it definitely sounds like his work

@Nanahaosaki

2 жыл бұрын

@@davidmchugh2959 yeah I agree

I agree with this. As long as it's benefiting YG, they'd most likely to stick with it. The songs are charting, getting recognized worldwide, getting awards and music show wins. It just shows that the GP and fans themselves are appreciating these releases and as long as consumers are doing it, they will never try something new.

@sheyaneleane7932

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly. If they know that blinks will eat the same thing again and again. Why would they want to change it. At this point Blackpink is now a group for show and not for music. They know the fandom will elevate the group whatever the songs are good or bad.

@scarlett9750

2 жыл бұрын

@@sheyaneleane7932 ikr.

@loveholic1511

2 жыл бұрын

If it's not broke don't fix it

@markcutie9959

2 жыл бұрын

This is what I thought so.. if ain't broken don't fix it as long the fans will take it serve it. That's how business works.

@blueb9023

2 жыл бұрын

@@sheyaneleane7932 period

I read that YG only allows their male trainees to take producing and composing classes. We also know Jennie's been writing songs for a while and they've been good according to Jennie's teachers, so it's surprising her first songwriting credit was 4 years into their career. I also definitely think Blackpink would benefit from working with a variety of producers and songwriters on their title tracks and b-sides rather than just Teddy.

@lucienvana4655

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly like imagine the amount of songs blackpink would have if YG let the girls partake in the production of their music.

@tasmiaazad7117

2 жыл бұрын

@@lucienvana4655 Knowing YG I highly doubt it'll happen 😭. But we can always hope that somehow they come out with songs where Bp had more creative control in the future!

@kashitakhalate9116

2 жыл бұрын

Maybe you are right or maybe i am wrong but as much i do remember YG do allow his artist to write and produce if they are good.... maybe BP is not good enough in that...but i did like rose story telling style of writing songs so i can say she have or can develop that ability........rest of. The member its doesn't seems like that....not hating i like Jennie but here solo rap in concert of the album was very very generic

@Bom13

2 жыл бұрын

Rosé co-wrote her solo songs. She was listed last in the credits, and it was still the same boring formula with no real chorus. Maybe Blackpink are just satisfied with being models and Instagram influencers now. Like the songs got so boring and repetitive that the singers themselves are bored with the singing activity altogether. Only 2 years left before the contract expires anyway

@jmd0605

2 жыл бұрын

@@kashitakhalate9116 I mean sure but lest we forget, this is only a treatment the FEMALE artists get. To insinuate that ALL the female artists "aren't that good" in the eyes of no one else but the executives of YG is a roundabout admittance of sexism and misogyny.

Teddy is probably experiencing burnout, he's been working non stop ever since. I don't think he even had a decent vacation. I think he doesn't even have time to have a relationship. I feel like he needs a really long break, like be in a different environment, regroup or something like that.

@rockaria11

2 жыл бұрын

Yep. He's basically lived in that studio for decades now lol he prefers to stay alone in the shadows 24/7 (my impression as someone who's been a big fan for over a decade).

@crudojoshuaricofort8795

2 жыл бұрын

He can just retire honestly, he is just staying for the money. If he leaves yge they would need to change everything up in their company.

@youtubechannel7736

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah he really needs a break

@HetaClaude

2 жыл бұрын

they never letting that man out of the basement 😩😩😩

@legorahma

2 жыл бұрын

you say that like you know him personally lmfaooo

not particularly abt teddy but blinks have been complaining for years abt blackpink’s repetitive song structure and then they always eat up the kind of songs that they are complaining about ?? lovesick girls didn’t followed the same formula as most of their other songs but you can see a huge difference in the music video views. ofc 450 mio views is still a lot and lsg wasn’t flopping but it’s almost half the views of hylt which shows that they actually enjoy blackpinks girl crush songs. because of that i feel like their next comeback will pretty much follow the same formula since those type of songs always do well and blinks will eat up anything blackpink releases anyway. maybe if their songs that don’t follow the same concept would chart better teddy would actually try out smtg different but like idek🧍‍♀️

@bobthebuilder3041

2 жыл бұрын

we can't NOT eat up the songs.....it will affect Blackpink a lot AND thats alll we get for the rest of the year

@jaehyunsshoe9124

2 жыл бұрын

I mean the only reason why Blinks eat everything YG gives them is because of starvation. If they constantly released songs with the same formula, do you think it would have the same success that those songs have right now?

@taebubu_

2 жыл бұрын

@@bobthebuilder3041 but if you don’t like a song, you don’t like it and you shouldn’t force yourself just because they might not have another comeback lmfao

@taebubu_

2 жыл бұрын

@@lonekhiibus716 tbh i’m not exactly sure how it charted but the mv and performance views are just much less than hylt for example ! i saw many blinks saying that pretty savage should have been the title track which also pretty much follows the same formula so i just feel like most actually prefer their girl crush songs :)

@bobthebuilder3041

2 жыл бұрын

@@taebubu_ well..I still LIKE the songs, there are just so little of them...because thats all we get

In the most respectful way ever, in my opinion somi's songs (especially the newest release) sound like recycled blackpink songs and i get that may be the "teddy formula" but its getting old. like come on now let miss somi branch out a little bit you're giving her (and blackpink) the same thing just different variations

@ONLY1JAYJAY

2 жыл бұрын

No cuz for some reason I was thinking about blackpink when I was listening to dumb dumb

@suryalakshmi7958

2 жыл бұрын

@@ONLY1JAYJAY Same here. When the chorus started a was thinking about solo.

@specialisa4328

2 жыл бұрын

not blackpink particularly but very much giving me solo by jennie

@yunjeans

2 жыл бұрын

Like I genuinely thought Dumb Dumb was a rejected Jennie solo Edit: I can even hear Jennie's voice if I imagine hard enough I-

@lerinorthcott

2 жыл бұрын

to me they all (Jennie, Somi & just Blackpink's songs as a whole) sound like Gashina wannabes lol idk its boring

i do think that the fans play a huge role in this. just look at the number of people who wanted pretty savage to be the title track instead of lsg. pretty savage still gets more streams than lsg

@user-cl9ts4vy9g

2 жыл бұрын

New Fans or teenagers in school 2000s of course like this song but people 10 years kpop can see all similar teddy songs people who big fans 2ne1 or big band

@stanshvts1997

2 жыл бұрын

@@user-cl9ts4vy9g now what should teddy make music for ?? Kpopies who would never love his songs or new generations and western audiences who ate his songs

@gabriela-id8jb

2 жыл бұрын

Funny how everyone wanted to Blackpink change their concept but when they do it, they complain 😑 The hate people have towards Blackpink is truly amazing

His formula works so far even tho there's nothing new and is getting boring. But I don't think he'll change his formula, at least not now. Maybe he's just not a risk taker

@hsnrb9959

3 жыл бұрын

His formula isn't that amazing to begin with. The general public have very basic/bland taste in music anyway, which is why his formula works

@bobthebuilder3041

2 жыл бұрын

@@hsnrb9959 yeah, everyone else is the problem😔

@hsnrb9959

2 жыл бұрын

@@bobthebuilder3041 Sadly its true. Most of the general public have bland taste in music - that's why 'Old Town Road' broke so many records, even though it's a bad song

@bobthebuilder3041

2 жыл бұрын

@@hsnrb9959 Yes. Your opinion is right, and everyone else is wrong to think otherwise.😗

@thursdayscat

2 жыл бұрын

@@hsnrb9959 I agree. General listeners are mostly tuning in to every hype and dance music, and the girl crush concept is still in demand sooo

I personally don't think his producing style is necessarily bad, but I do think it is way too repetitive. I think that's why I tend to stan many SM groups because their comebacks are never repetitive and always bring something new to the table.

@Nanahaosaki

2 жыл бұрын

Yes I agree.

@PrinceDuCiel7

2 жыл бұрын

Really? I like the SM formula but it’s still there. Start checking how many of their artists songs have a talking section. Not rap. But just sorta, chanting together. I thought it was just Nct but Aespa and Super Junior came out with that formula. Heard it in a few Exo songs looking back. Haven’t checked Red Velvet, SNSD yet or soloists. But even Shinee had a bit of it, but I feel like they were strong enough in production to make it sound different and not just the exact same.

@user-cl9ts4vy9g

2 жыл бұрын

Twice similar songs jyp style Red velvet similar sm style Bp similar songs YG TEDDY STYLE

@paimonspie8913

2 жыл бұрын

Fr at least Sm works with multiple producers and songwriters to at least get their artists the best demos etc

@RUAmplified

2 жыл бұрын

SM have their own producer but they also out source them from other countries. Next Level by Aespa for example

Honestly I had the same question regarding Somi's music, but then I came to the conclusion that Somi herself wants that kind of sound for her music. She knows that it's that kind of music that skyrocketed Blackpink to success and she probably thinks that it will work for her too. I mean, it kinda does since her comebacks earned her music show wins. Also to add, Somi does have a say in what kind of music she releases. She's literally involved in the entire process, so if y'all are saying that her songs are mediocre then she obviously likes mediocre music, lol.

@aureumrose

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah people keep calling her songs boring and it’s kinda annoying bc just bc her songs aren’t your cup of tea doesn’t mean u need to attack the producers. I think her concepts fit her voice well, but I hope she’ll experiment more in the future

@GamingBrowni

2 жыл бұрын

@@aureumrose exactly. And I think she's trying to find her music identity so she's playing it safe & adjusting to being a solo artist & improving her skills. Her time will come I'm sure, she still has many years to show what she's capable of😊

@aureumrose

2 жыл бұрын

@@GamingBrowni Definitely agree with you

@randomkid4783

2 жыл бұрын

I really hate when people are like, WHERE'S THE ALBUM SOMI! When technically the Black Label is giving her freedom as an artist to let her do what she wants to do and when.

@singleminthugger

2 жыл бұрын

😂

In conclusion: YGE are just really damn good at doing the absolute minimum for money

@user-cl9ts4vy9g

2 жыл бұрын

YGX not best dancer go watch TV shows

DDDD, Kill This Love, and HYLT have always felt like the same song with a different title

the teddy formulae needs to GO already, like come on, i think he’s talented but he needs to stop using the same old repetitive formulae over and over again for all artists

@PureHoneyBoo

3 жыл бұрын

Not only the formula but he isn’t keeping up with the newest trends and is stucked in the early 2010s

@sjgwapa954

3 жыл бұрын

FACTS

@darkhalcyon101

2 жыл бұрын

u seem to be an expert on safeguarding what the majority should deeming as hot. ok.. so what is this groundbreaking sound that teddy should be doin instead. name a few sample songs to elucidate your point. ill wait.

@insearchofthemoon

2 жыл бұрын

@@darkhalcyon101 barely understood what you said but I am the best by 2ne1

@darkhalcyon101

2 жыл бұрын

@@insearchofthemoon the commenter is saying that teddy should change his style... a style that has made teddy the best kpop producer accdg to billboard and has made millions fall in love with kpop... so im askin commenter to mention a specific style that teddy should adopt.

It seems pretty deliberate on the part of the company - because it even extends to styling and visuals. Somi, Rose and BP's MVs and styling is almost identical.

@PureHoneyBoo

2 жыл бұрын

They work with the same team

@scarlett9750

2 жыл бұрын

@@PureHoneyBoo ohhhh that’s why…

@scarlett9750

2 жыл бұрын

Agreeeee

@lontalley5915

2 жыл бұрын

@@PureHoneyBoo plenty of artists use the same team and their mvs still look different :/

@whippedlikethetwoguysfromm7778

2 жыл бұрын

@@PureHoneyBoo that really shouldn't matter at all.. Same team≠same output

He is growing old now... He's literally from bigbang, 2ne1 era... Cmon there are so many more awesome producers out there who deserve to be recognised. Blackpink kind of deserves a new producer

@user-cl9ts4vy9g

2 жыл бұрын

I understand now why Korean people keep saying OH is YG STYLE OR TEDDY STYLE

@kawaiiplastic5808

2 жыл бұрын

I think black pink is so overrated obviously it’s because of this man I remember Teddy park from early on like 2008

@kawaiiplastic5808

2 жыл бұрын

@❥𝓡𝓮𝓭 𝓥𝓮𝓵𝓿𝓮𝓽❦ Red velvet has great music automatic being one of my favorite songs ever

@Kenri_Basar

2 жыл бұрын

He is from 1TYM Era exactly. BigBang and 2NE1 is relatively new. He has been producing and active since then.

@sovarani5929

2 жыл бұрын

@@Kenri_Basar yes yes... I almost forgot he was an idol too

The main reason why I can't love Blackpink is exactly this, they haven't shown any significant amount of artistic or musical growth. Looking at the other top 5 GG's, even rookies are doing a much better job at evolving and developing a unique sound for themselves. It's honestly borderline insulting seeing how a group can thrive doing the same type of music for their entire career while the rest are showing amazing sound versatility and barely getting recognition for it

@levitatingstan6526

2 жыл бұрын

its not bp fault if ggs tank, most blinks dont even know songs by other kpop groups in general and bp audience is way too big so if its insulting to you just stream harder for the nugus ig

@camiloh2443

2 жыл бұрын

@@levitatingstan6526 I know they can't help but be successful, I don't need anyone to explain that to me. What I mean is that through their management BP as a brand has dominated without really having to put effort into their work. They can release their 10th drop chorus, Jennie starting, chant ending, Bollywood inspired song tomorrow and it'll top every chart and sell like crazy. My critique is mostly towards blinks and the general public that pay more attention to the pinks's Instagram posts than other girl groups that actually care about creating a good body of work

@ekuniverse1

2 жыл бұрын

Have you ever thought that Blackpink had a clear, unique sound since the beginning. They're already unique as they are, if they change their formula another group will take advantage of it. Think back to the first ever time you heard a Blackpink song, you were amazed right? Groups that are coming up like IVE and StayC use the exact same formula.

As an ex-blink, I just felt betrayed whenever BP put out a new song. I knew what I was getting, I knew Jennie would sing first, I knew there's no vocals in the chorus,I knew the third chorus would be a "party beat". I got bored and felt insulted basically. Tbh, I'm just waiting for BP's contracts to expire so the girls would move on and then I'll tune in to see what they're capable of.

@andreasvobodova8241

Жыл бұрын

Same here. I was a fan in 2020-2021, but I got sick of waiting 2 years for few boring songs. They should just disband already, I'm so sick of BP and their toxic fans.

Can't wait for the YGE pitchforks to come out

@user-pt2nk6bt9e

2 жыл бұрын

What does pitchforks mean?

@angelgowoon2479

2 жыл бұрын

it's a page that reviews songs & albums, but they are usually very strict

@HungVu-rq6th

2 жыл бұрын

I remeber that Kill This Love got 6.2 on pitchfork if i’m not wrong.

@user-cl9ts4vy9g

2 жыл бұрын

@@HungVu-rq6th what u think lalisa new song

@HungVu-rq6th

2 жыл бұрын

@@user-cl9ts4vy9g It's really good.

Teddy needs to collab with more artists. They should also let BP write more of their own music. Stay, You Never Know and Love Sick Girls sounds so different from the trademark Teddy sound.

@johnseennnnnn

2 жыл бұрын

bcuz LSG actually composed by David Guetta until Teddy took over the rest and make it sound like his

@user-cl9ts4vy9g

2 жыл бұрын

Love sick girls look hit songs 2012

@user-cl9ts4vy9g

2 жыл бұрын

@@johnseennnnnn song age old 2012

@PriyanshuKumar-ez6qi

2 жыл бұрын

Jennie did helped in composing of lsg

808 basses, arpeggios for the verses, guitars for the pre-chorus, hip-hop and trap drums, synth lead for the chorus (sometimes distorted vocal chops, and also often used as an intro), percussion, and a sine wave sub-bass, and then baam! You've got yourself a song using Teddy's formula.

@deyleigh6487

2 жыл бұрын

@@hopop2243 listen to pretty savage the melody playing in the chorus is a distorted vocal chop. You know the villain-sounding voice that's been distorted so much that it doesn't sound like a voice. Listen to d4, that's a flute-type synth lead. BP drums are always hip-hop or trap, 808 is the one giving the kick a lengthy low-end sound. Anyways, too much unnecessary info from the question you gave, but if you're interested in production, these are some of the basic terms you will use.

They need to just bring more producers into yg. I feel like that would solve all the problems: tiny discographies, long wait times between comebacks, and staleness and a lack of diversity I don’t know why yg relies pretty much on one man to produce all of blackpink and somis music when he’s clearly overworked and has a lack of inspiration for new ideas No wonder they only have like 25 songs in total

I want BP to have a new sound to fricking experiment with songs.

@lucienvana4655

2 жыл бұрын

!!!!

@seulmiseforever9603

2 жыл бұрын

Or at least make a summer bop like Forever Young or DKWTD as a title, that all I need

@pixiedust1999

2 жыл бұрын

@@Abc234Fans I'm not denying that lsgs was a new sound but that's just once, we want more songs Everglow is way younger than BP yet they're catching up to their number of songs and BP is a 5 year old group for God's sake. They deserve better, they deserve to write and produce and create things that they would enjoy to perform.

@lucienvana4655

2 жыл бұрын

@@seulmiseforever9603 RIGHTTT

@merveillem001

2 жыл бұрын

I'm not even a blink but I kinda miss them 😅 I just casually listen to them, but when I hear other groups having comebacks, I'm like let me check on BP too but nothing from them😅

I think he needs to step it up before it's too late. You can't keep up such an act for forever. His formula will have to go out of trend soon, most especially due to how prevalent and obvious it is now. I also don't understand how a company can put all their eggs in one basket (Teddy) for so long. This was bound to happen.

@raynasomers6266

2 жыл бұрын

I think he will only change the style when blackpink disbands. If he constantly gives blackpink the same formula, they will still bring in the views, but when a new group does it, it might not work anymore because they haven’t made a name yet

@scarlett9750

2 жыл бұрын

Welp…the BLINKS STILL GON’ STREAM IT SO……I DONT THINK HE GONNA CHANGE ANYTIME SOON.

When Dumb Dumb came out, I didn't really know Somi, I didn't know her label was a subsidiary company of YG. When I heard the song I immediately thought "ugh, sounds like a song that Teddy would produce". I laughed when I found out that it was indeed a song produced by him.

@whippedlikethetwoguysfromm7778

2 жыл бұрын

Saaaame lmoaaa

@ananyaarajesh231

2 жыл бұрын

😂

@user-cl9ts4vy9g

2 жыл бұрын

What u think lalisa new song now

I love sunmi’s songs; I think what makes her songs a bit different from black pink’s or somi’s is her more retro vibe

@riffgroove

2 жыл бұрын

Sunmi also doesn't rely exclusively on Teddy.

@mariaj8998

2 жыл бұрын

Omg I was thinking the same. I discovered her not too long ago . And yes, her songs have a retro vibe to them BUT all of them still manage to sound different and more experimentive

@Flora-ix3os

2 жыл бұрын

@@mariaj8998 yeah I think gashina is one of the only ones Teddy has worked on

@johnseennnnnn

2 жыл бұрын

@@Flora-ix3os dont forget Heroine

im SO glad you talked about this, his formula has been tiring me since a while ago and it's sad that he is the reason why i don't listen to blackpink that much or any yg artist. i would love to listen other type of song from him since he is an amazing producer :(

@user-cl9ts4vy9g

2 жыл бұрын

What u think lalisa new song

I remember Pdogg said how he doesn't think songs under 3 minutes are really songs. And Teddy's songs are mostly 3 minutes. I agree wit the former. A song that short can't have much going for it except repetitive sounds. Personally, Teddy seems to be going for what's safer and not what's better which is just not something I like personally.

@EffortlessDuo

2 жыл бұрын

I remeber how pdogg said in bts mv reaction video with lee hyun of butter. Its sad that song is only 3 min or something i feel little bit dissapoint that our boys couldn't show what they have got because its so short. Like he wanted to show rap line rap more . Thats why i respect pdogg . He also think about artist not only about money

@user-qn1fz4nw3o

2 жыл бұрын

@@EffortlessDuo but in 3 minutes butter managed to show off all of the members and keep it interesting and even to have the dance breakdown segment,,,,the song is three minutes long but it doesn't feel like it because it manages to accomplish a lot in that time. Bts' in-house producers are such blessings, especially pddog and slow rabbit, the versatility is insane Also bts added the rapline verses which weren't originally part of the song and they brought that heat. And don't worry the guys were plenty happy with butter and how it all turned out 😊

@EffortlessDuo

2 жыл бұрын

@@user-qn1fz4nw3o yeah among three bts english song butter is my fav . I'm always satisfied with everything pdogg and bts does . I just said what pdogg said while reacting butter . Its his opinion not mine .

@user-cl9ts4vy9g

2 жыл бұрын

That's why bp come back so late To watch mv like I miss them so much and forget that song similar old song

@Snowboard4

7 ай бұрын

Eu concordo com o Pdogg. Música tem que ter mais de 3 minutos para ser chamada de música. Quando tem menos, dá a intenção que não está sendo aprofundada, que está faltando algo e que tudo está passando muito rápido, muitas informações. Essa cultura do streaming mata a música

Tbh I think the only reason why BLACKPINK's songs chart so much even though they're mostly the same is because Blinks get starved. BLACKPINK barely have any comebacks and we all know how the girls are on longgggg hiatus' every single time until the fans eat everything up without asking.

@user-cl9ts4vy9g

2 жыл бұрын

No why bp so famous because only girl crush in kpop 4 minute clc and g idle problem they has and people tired cute girl group That's why only has bp. I hope itzy make hit song

@mothergothelisagirlboss5735

2 жыл бұрын

@@user-cl9ts4vy9g itzy is imo not going to be popular like twice. I mean, they have good songs... but icy was a flop.

@user-cl9ts4vy9g

2 жыл бұрын

@@mothergothelisagirlboss5735 same thing people say to BTS look now next level we don't know what future be like soo anything happen 🤷‍♀️

@mothergothelisagirlboss5735

2 жыл бұрын

@@user-cl9ts4vy9g yeah, but i mean, they are good but overall their talents are mediocre. But still, aespa and itzy will lead 4th gen

@blackalwayspink

2 жыл бұрын

and what about it

I think both teddy's greatest gift and biggest flaw is he's a hitmaker, but that's it. He'll make individual songs for you that'll be huge hits but he cannot make an album to save his life. One critique I saw a lot on BP's "The Album" was that it didn't feel like an album, but just a collection of songs, and I definitely agree. He can make individual songs that stand on their own as if they were singles but he cannot make a cohesive body of work that makes sense and feels like one single entity, as opposed to a collection of individual things.

@MaeB

2 жыл бұрын

omgggg u explained it so well

I would argue that Rose's solo songs are much more Western and follow the pattern less, especially "Gone". A lot of Western producers worked on them, Rose herself grew up in New Zealand and Australia until she was 16 so English is her native language and her writing style is more probably Western. Both songs are in English and "Gone" is a folk/indie song with very little, if any K-pop influence aside from maybe the repeating of the word "gone" with that melody

when I first heard dumb dumb my first thought was "this literally sounds like blackpink" and one of my friends even agreed and I like dumb dumb but it's also very basic

I just really really hope he doesn't mess up Lisa's solo, we've been waiting for so long and she can pull of something so different than what teddy usually produces. I'm praying she gets to have a HUGH part in writing/composing the song like how jennie and jisso did for lsg, bc it made a new and interesting song. I completely agree with you

@user-cl9ts4vy9g

2 жыл бұрын

Lsg they just help change world song Korean what u talk about

@salimatoudiallo2831

2 жыл бұрын

Well this comment did not aged well, she did’t participate in any of her two songs😪

@onyrahajanirina8651

2 жыл бұрын

I'm here... Lalisa is so "Blackpink" song... i expected more...

@user-cl9ts4vy9g

2 жыл бұрын

@@onyrahajanirina8651 I expect more of her in my head dance hard hip hop and sexy like doja cat or cardi or normani 2021 But is 100% (YG OG STYLE) is like CL AND GD DEBUT 10 years ago swag things old fashion 2012 And singing like somi style if this song give to somi I swear she singing and rap same thing Only thing I like about her rap that's it and fashion

@grod338

2 жыл бұрын

well......

The problem with Teddy is that he’s proven that he can use the same formula to create very distinct sounds and songs despite the formula. Blackpink’s older discography proves that with how Boombayah, Whistle, and Playing With Fire all sound very distinct from eachother and have vastly different feels to them. Boombayah was a hyped up party anthem, Whistle was a lowkey song bursting with swagger, and Playing With Fire was a song that had a little more of an emotional and bittersweet feel. I just feel like since Ddu Du Ddu Du was released, Teddy has gotten really lazy and decided to slightly remix the same song for Kill This Love and How You Like That because all three of those releases have the exact same vibe and feel and are almost indistinguishable from each other. It’s also interesting to note that Teddy himself said in the Blackpink documentary that the reason that Blackpink doesn’t comeback as often and why there are so many unreleased songs is because they only release the absolute best ones out of the bunch. I just find that really hard to believe because the three songs I mentioned before as examples of how he used the same formula to create distinct sounds were all released in the same year, meanwhile D4, KTL and HYLT were all released a year apart from each other despite being extremely similar in sound.

He's lazy and a genius at the same time.🤣🤣. He cam up with a formula that works, but then again he overused that formula instead of finding more formulas and branch out.

@thursdayscat

2 жыл бұрын

This sums up everything lol

@scarlett9750

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly.

@cherryblossom7120

2 жыл бұрын

Shikamaru nara.

@kimberlycoraimaruizutrilla2250

2 жыл бұрын

Disculpa vago ?, quién te crees para que le digas vago el dijo estas horas y horas todos los dias en su estudio que te pasa

No Teddy, no Blackpink. I can't imagine the girls debuting to Ooh Ah or Happiness or even Dalla.. LOL People still look for Teddy's formula in every BP song. Look what happened to Stay and Love Sick Girls. They're good songs, but views & charts say otherwise.

@YumeiroPatissiereSP

2 жыл бұрын

Lsg was a hit in korea, and BP is a kpop group so that's what should matter the most, but i'm sure they are coming back with a girl crush concept next because lsg did not have the international impact hylt had, and tbh i'm totally fine with that lol

@katherinorellana2092

2 жыл бұрын

Those are my favorite blackpink songs 😭

@Michael-uh2zy

2 жыл бұрын

Lovesick Girls charted so freaking well lmao

@kyurious6037

2 жыл бұрын

@@Michael-uh2zy Yes, it charted. I didn't say it did not, but HYLT & LSG were released in the same year you could see the big difference when it comes to impact. So you see, that 'Teddy Formula' there does makes a difference.

@Michael-uh2zy

2 жыл бұрын

@@kyurious6037 A ridiculously tiny difference, because Lovesick Girls had much more impact than HYLT in Korea and other asian nations and it's still being reflected on the charts. HYLT was the comeback before a year and a half of hiatus, ofc it had much more international attention... Don't forget that IC (another song that doesn't enter the teddy formula) did much better than HYLT in America, China and other music markets.

Ive seen many this formula criticism video, but this one is so well explained. The thing you said about yg groups like blackpink releasing few music every year makes so much sense. They starve their audience and after a long time when they release, fans have no choice but to digest that music, it feels exclusive and exciting. This party themed and the beat that are making their songs such bops. Same formula over and over again, and it will definitely work every time without any failure.

I think it's a mix of both . Since yg style is famous for being cool and as they view laziness as a trop of coolness , Teddy uses this formula with a beat drop in the chorest and no vocal . Also , yg is somewhat considered a hiphop company so it's natural that they would hire hiphop producer, which in my opinion , I think they don't know how to make pop choresses . Because hiphop is a very verses heavy genre . So I think Teddy stated doing the no vocals in chores thing at first out of pure ignorance and when it worked out for him , he kept using the same formula . Also , I think Teddy is not very good at experimenting with sounds , because when he tried in lovesick , it sounded very outdated and he didn't bring nothing new to tie the 2010 style of music with the nowdays style of music .

@kashitakhalate9116

2 жыл бұрын

But LSG was produced by David Guetta as much i remember 🤔

@maryemhammedi9483

2 жыл бұрын

@@kashitakhalate9116 oh really !! Well that explains that tho . But I thought he had a hand in all of their songs like they get approved by him .

@eyerenesbitch

2 жыл бұрын

@@kashitakhalate9116 lol no. david guetta is way better than this. he was only one of the songwriters. the production was done by teddy.

@YumeiroPatissiereSP

2 жыл бұрын

@@eyerenesbitch what you talking about girl?? Acting like lsg is a bad song or something when it was a hit in korea, and you are a red velvet fan you should shout your mouth cause songs like rookie or umpah umpah are nothing but crap so you can't say shit about BP's music. Queendom is not that good either so please sit down, pff lsg stil charting even thou it was released in oct last year... And this bitch talks as if the song was the worst ever 🙄

@eyerenesbitch

2 жыл бұрын

@@YumeiroPatissiereSP first of all, i never said it was the worst thing ever so don’t put words in my mouth. second, calling umpah umpah and rookie shit just shows how little you know about music production. and because i’m a reveluv that gives me the right to talk crap about anyone’s songs ;) third, charting doesn’t make the song any better. and it also doesn’t get better each time you stream it. xoxo~

he definitely carried big bang and 2ne1 in the early days and made some unmatched bops. but he's currently playing it safe and reusing a formula he knows will work which is a bit of a shame bc he's an amazing producer

I hope that BaeMon does not fall victim to this formula, and if they do, they may be labeled as Black Pink Copies. I feel as though YGE depends way to much on Teddy for producing. They should at least bring in outside producers or allowing members to participate in composing a song.

someone needs to let him know you can keep the formula, and just expand on it to make richer and more dynamic. you could argue that songs like La Vie En Rose have the same structure, just shaken up a bit and given a unique sound so it retains replayability

guess i'm one of a few people who doesn't care, kpop is not that deep to me and i simply support and listen to the groups and songs that i personally enjoy :) i don't have a problem with teddy's producing, i love blackpink's sound the way it is, i love edm beats and empty choruses and the fact that i know what i'm going to get. so maybe i'm just basic lol. experimental sounds aren't for me, maybe that's why i usually don't enjoy sm groups' music for example.

@scarlett9750

2 жыл бұрын

It’s ok….but TOO MUCH is boring. Idk.

@Taylorc0de

2 жыл бұрын

Well that's weird

@hannah4107

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you, I completely agree. I enjoy most of Teddy’s songs and I also liked Dumb Dumb 🤷‍♀️ Some of the things vixxo said are definitely valid but I also feel like nowadays a lot of kpop stans feel edgy by hating on popular music. Disliking Teddy has become a bit of a trend among kpop stans.

@Taylorc0de

2 жыл бұрын

@@hannah4107 no offense it's not about being "edgy". When many people are pointing it out there's got to be something wrong. Teddy has produced phenomenal songs but nowadays he is just a one trick pony. It's totally cool if you and many people like his production but you can't deny he is stuff now outdated🤷🏽‍♀️

@hannah4107

2 жыл бұрын

Hi @@Taylorc0de, I think you misunderstood the „edgy“ part. I said nowadays some people find it edgy to hate on popular music and I think that might contribute to the anti Teddy movement, not that it’s the sole factor. As I said, some of vixxo‘s points are definitely valid. Apart from that we seem to agree there’s a bit of a mob mentality going on. And I don’t agree his music is outdated. We probably just have different tastes in music and that‘s okay ^^

YIKES I CANT WAIT TO HEAR WHAT YOU HAVE TO SAY

@hyuckiahcarey

3 жыл бұрын

The Sunkyu profile picture and your username. My deobizen heart 🥺💚

@ItzTaeilTime

2 жыл бұрын

@@hyuckiahcarey WAIT OMG I SAW THIS SO LATE!!!!!! AAA YES DEOBIZENS UNITEEE

@madjayneify

2 жыл бұрын

Same here!! I just started it, and I think it’s still premiering atm

This is why I'm so disappointed at the new kpop culture. Fandoms are like cults that will support ANYTHING their faves will release and then complain why the songs are formulaic. These days is all about numbers smh.

I don’t stan Blackpink because I don’t like the music, but I stan the girls of Blackpink. They’re all ultra talented and I’d love to see them do projects away from the controlling arm of YG

They take “if it aint broke why bother fixing it “ too seriously. Lol

And its funny cause he just love 2ne1 songs, he even speak about how his fave songs that he even created are for 2ne1, right now he is just stuck i guess

Its hard to be creative and branch out when money, and success of artists are involved. Im not a fan of dumb dumb, but it works, and Somi seems to like it(I think). I understand that seeing different sides to Teddy's style would be nice, but in the scenario where its not well received, the only ones being put at risk would be the artists, and not actually teddy.

I'm glad that pple are finally criticising this. I started noticing the similarities way back in ktl.

At the end of the day , he is one of the most versatile producers out there .. with his work spanning from 1st gen to 4th gen..yes He is lazy with his current formula but they always bring in numbers and sales. As someone who has listened to all of his production and has stanned groups cuz of his touch etc , he is versatile and I can list so many songs in his catalogue that don’t sound alike at all. I also love how he incorporates personality of the artists he works with in his music. Also I need to mention that 2NE1 exists cause of him( he convinced yhs that 2NE1 is an amazing group) and everything Blackpink related was his idea. He monitors music shows , mv’s , dances and so much more. Something blinks/4th gen stans/ etc might not realise

@scarlett9750

2 жыл бұрын

He is smart but def not versatile lol.

@Ash-hk6lh

2 жыл бұрын

@@scarlett9750 he's very versatile. you've clearly only listened to his blackpink work. he produced apology by ikon, ice cream by bp and i am the best by 2ne1, among countless others. if that's not versatility idk what is. he can do so much, he just chooses not to.

@inyour_wetdreams

2 жыл бұрын

@@Ash-hk6lh if were talking about diversity, that title goes to JYP that mans is not getting respected enough smh

@Ash-hk6lh

2 жыл бұрын

@@inyour_wetdreams i'd say he's a better writer than a producer, but he's very good at both.

@mikimishisa

2 жыл бұрын

@@Ash-hk6lh honestly I wouldn't either if I'm expected to do the artists in another persons company plus my own. Bruh.

HE IS FREAKING LAZY WBK

Artists are supposed to experiment too. They are gonna keep going with the same formula for the rest of their careers. Take Gidle for example. They experiment and have done different concepts and music. Stray kids as well and bts. Working with different producers and writers too!

@yoxxie2169

2 жыл бұрын

But you know what straykids seem like they are follwing a cut and paste technique. With the rise of fans and popularity with gods menu we see a similar formula with: gods menu, back door, wolfgang, thunderous with the exception of mixtape oh. Even the new bside domino follows it through. Hopefully they express their said creative freedom coz i have been a huge fan of their works. Gidles discography is insanely creative tho.

@anisha5259

2 жыл бұрын

@@yoxxie2169 i kinda agree and disagree because except the title tracks I really like their bsides and they sound good but yes earlier works always wins in terms of being new to the industry and wanting to do something different

Ever since ddu du ddu du i stopped stanning Blackpink. The songs felt repetitive and the spark of blackpink kinda vanished. Compared to other groups they werent giving me enough

girl i love your analysis!! i feel the same way but u explained it all sooo well! & dont worry i think theres alot more people who feel this way about teddy's style of producing songs. i for one really love lovesick girls, you never know, hope not and the other b-side songs

Honestly he's a genius with a formula...n the ppl EAT IT UP whether u like it or not. He doesn't only write for BP. My favorite song he's written is Rose. It's just so beautiful!

but they all one common point : they all were highly popular his goal doesn't seem to do diversity and pure art but catchy songs that charts and makes money i think when you understand that, you feel better idk why

I actually enjoy blackpink and somi songs. I know the formula is very obvious but for me I know when blackpink is having a release I can trust that I’ll enjoy it because they’ve stuck to their signature sound. (Just my opinion)

yay vixxo found a way to combine both video essays and controversial topics in the same video!I agree with all of your points i dont see the reason to share my opinions lmao

BLACKPINK need a Producer who is open for new thinks and is still match they Style. Teddy is still in 2016

The only thing that carries Teddy's songs are the singers. And even they can't do it sometimes. As a producer it's fine to have a style but he's literally just doing the same song over and over. Especially with Blackpink it's sad because the members are very interested in working on the songs themselves but can't.

@kimberlycoraimaruizutrilla2250

2 жыл бұрын

Queeeee??? Pero si ya están acreditadas wtf.

Even though I can't make any predictions, it seems like he got burned out at some point and has lost his source of inspiration

finally somebody said it. i've been thinking this for the longest time and i knew it was because he produced all his songs the same. there was a stage where i really wanted to get into bp but i couldn't because all the songs had the same sound. this was a great video btw xx

maybe thats why yg artist don't release that often , because if we had back to back comebacks we wouldn't forget the formula and as a result we would stop tuning in. im convinced this is by design

It's not that I hate the formula. It's that they're so lazy about it. You can get creative with the formula. With a formula you should be able to pop out songs left and right. It's like. Linkin Parks first two albums. Sure, it's the same song, but it's a great song lol... and there's a bit of creativity in the formula.

I personally think his music is always technically really well produced, clean and has some great moments! The problem is that he tends to push his style onto every artist he works with rather than giving them room to develop on their own. With Blackpink especially I find that the songs from the album he DIDNT work in are some of the better ones (LSG and Pretty Savage excluded) like Love to Hate Me and You Never Know. I think he has great skills, but he’s stuck in a box of doing the same thing over and over.

tbh i doubt that it is all his fault, probably big part of these decisions are from the company, it makes sense financially to them to mantain what works :c

OH IM EXCITED FOR THIS

you literally took the words out of my mouth. I've been saying since 2018 that yg needs to hire some more producers for bp. I think it would be cool to see more female producers for the girl groups too.

I think their latest song lovesick girls is pretty different from their previous songs. It felt like they were trying to diverge from the usual party style music.

I can't blame him, this formula is popular and they have profit sooo. I love bang bang bang, how you like that etc. They still have some elements which are addictive and sound great. I feel like people always complain, but there is so much work behind each song, they literally have to write lyrics, choose new clothing items, make it catchy, make the mv, make the choreography, just for your entertainment. If you don't want it, don't watch it and wait for better music for yourself instead of bashing blackpink and other hardworking artists. I personally think bp album was a great success.

@kimberlycoraimaruizutrilla2250

2 жыл бұрын

Cierto existe mucha gente quejona nada les parece bien nada.

Your videos are always really interesting! I like watching them, you dont seem stuck on an opinion and try to show different sides of a topic

to be honest i dont really care and kpop isnt that deep for me, the only thing that i do care about is whatever i like a song or not. personally i like every single song that blackpink released and im not even a blink

@dorianecaffa

2 жыл бұрын

Agree

@aniyahd1995

2 жыл бұрын

same

Actually u guys said Teddy formula is boring but alot of group try his formula and failed. It is about the formula that define his own style. Take some group As example, that have similar sound to bp, and they received hate and criticism because what teddy formula is creating for his artist. If anyone copy it, they will receive criticism.

@rosie_are_rose9151

2 жыл бұрын

Another example is bp dance before get criticism because they use the same formula dance however when other people did they don't receive criticism as bp. And now some other group use the same style dance as bp 😂😂😂😂. So the problem is they tend to have bad perspective on group or artist itself, it is not about formula

for the longest time i wondered why ikon was the only yg discography i thoroughly and genuinely enjoyed and it clicked when i realised that teddy doesn't have much of an influence on their music.

@shinobuily

2 жыл бұрын

😭😭

@Erisss1517

5 ай бұрын

That's right because Bobby, b.i and millenium were the producer of 90% of ikon songs

This is such an interesting video. It reminds me of my conversation with my friend before. We're both big 2NE1 fans and we're talking about the changes in Teddy's music before to now. We've also observed some of the points made in the video. At the end, we both feel that Teddy shouldn't be the main producer for YGE's upcoming GG. We had several reasons why. But music wise, we just felt that to be able to differentate the new GG from the other YG GGS, they need to have a fresh sound. I think doing the same formula with the new GG isn't going to be beneficial for the group and will only gain them backlash for being a copycat version of their seniors. Maybe this way too far in the future and it will likely be that Teddy will be the main producer of the new GG. Interesting to see what the future holds for the GGS in YGE.

ever since I learn about that Teddy Formula from watching Mera's video, can't seem to listen to YG artists' songs the same way again🤣 like, you can really tell which one was produced by Brave brothers and which one was already produced by Teddy🤣

I feel this gonna be a hot controversial issues and I'm in it!!!

@vessg221

2 жыл бұрын

Sameeee

finally a video who did in-depth research and every parts has been said with careful attention. kudos to that

ohh spicy... i'm looking forward to this...

I think it's extremly hard for one person or a team to make hit songs everytime while also being versatile and creative. I believe not many people can do that in this planet. Although bp's songs are generic and repetitive I still like their style and music which is enough for me

If you're ignoring all of his work with Bigbang and 2NE1, you really don't understand how Teddy fundamentally changed ALL expectations in k-pop music. There is a reason Lady Gaga Desperately wanted to work with him a decade ago. Bringing in EDM was not a thing before 2012 and "drops" were really not a thing before 2015. Also, he did Somi's new song "Dumb Dumb" and although it has a switch-up it suits her and I think is a very solid work of his. They have a sonic brand for Blackpink and yes, people will get upset if they deviate too much from what is expected of them; this is proven in every street interview done in Korea on this matter. Do actual research, please.

@LyzaLawal

2 жыл бұрын

SM Was doing EDM and drops with SUJU and SNSD so I dunno about that. But this is the point, ever since his the 2nd gen music the quality is poor now. He made two title tracks from the same label it’s very lazy, it’s not unique anymore. It’s becoming repetitive he didn’t do this with BB and 2ne1z

am i the only one that actually likes teddy’s formula like plz DONT change

@rockaria11

2 жыл бұрын

I agree.

He’s not a genuis, listeners just refuse to hear it.

He is a great producer... But the amount of songs he produced and delivers to the actual audience is too limited and makes those artists into his production a waist of time. So yeah he is very lazy and that damage the artists with delayed comeback and really few songs. He doesn't let artists participate with material and he doesn't look up for support making a group of producers that can composed when he is without ideas and give the artist more songs and more comeback. Also if someone here is to said that is because he continually evaluated his songs and discharge them... Well so much for his self confidence🤔

@bobthebuilder3041

2 жыл бұрын

....how did you post this comment 2 days ago??? the video just came out 82 minutes ago...

@ol.3917

2 жыл бұрын

@@bobthebuilder3041 Oh it's just like magic... Lol the comments section was open before the video was released

Teddy Park needs to expand his horizons. The EDM sound is tired, and if you have an ear for music you’d understand that most of the songs he produces sound similar and almost undeniably identical that it hurts.

Oh its a premiere I hate life. Anyway looking forward to this!!!

I love your pfp so much 💓

I'm patiently waiting 😀

I remember that before I got into Kpop I used to think Blackpink was a much older group than they actually are because of how their music sounds. I was really surprised to find out they only debuted in 2016 and not around 2012.

@SoSBxo

2 жыл бұрын

THIS! even their recent songs have aged terribly. i want to like them so much but there’s nothing interesting or fresh about their music sadlyw

@luisab3079

2 жыл бұрын

@@SoSBxo Yeah... I actually quite like Lovesick Girls, it's one of my favourites from them... But it does sound very 2014.

Thank you for your video, it hit on all the points it needed too, any real fan definitely knows and can see truth in everything the vid brought up no matter which side u personally prefer. I'd like to also add even after hearing and watching other peoples opinion I still have the same luv for blackpink and teddy. I see what yg is doing for blackpink the brand if it's been working the last 5 why change it I get it. As a fan man I wish they had the freedom other acts get and hope that one day we will get to see, I wanna see them get too write more and work with other producers which would bring different sounds good or bad. Thankful they get to do solo stuff I luv the premise that YG has done with them on that because otherwise u get the members of groups wanting to break up the group to do there own thing which by then is usually to late for that group to save or end up resentmenting or disliking each other ( example 5th Harmony and Girls Aloud) if they let camila do her thing there should be no reason why u have to leave or split . Kudos to the label for at least letting them do that and prasing each other as they do it. Thanks again for this video you have amazing insight that i was definitely needed to hear and watch as a fan cause my mind is have the same opions but is hard at times for fans like me to focus on cause my ADD or ADHD hinder me from getting the point across or going off on something off the subject. Ugh so thankfully there are fans like u out there