If Viggo and Ian don't come back for this I will cry.

@httrtaylor21

Ай бұрын

Me too... they need to come back!

@115spt2

Ай бұрын

@@httrtaylor21 I agree but Ian is literally in his mid 80's, and Viggo has aged quite a bit, but with Deaging they could both pass.

@patricksnavely5850

Ай бұрын

I won't watch it without them.

@PolBlanesCebrian

Ай бұрын

@@patricksnavely5850 Don't lie to yourself like that; you'll just watch it angrily and then say you didn't like it xD

@PolBlanesCebrian

Ай бұрын

​@@patricksnavely5850 okay man wtf are you on about? I just said you would watch it anyway and maybe not like it. I never said you would make a video or anything... I will be hurt if they don't get the cast back together but I'll watch it anyway if they don't because it's still PJ, Boyens and Serkis. It will bring me back to something close to the trilogy for sure. If they deage them well it will be the best, if they recast them well it will be okay, if they deage them badly it will be worse than a good recast, and if they recast them badly I might stop watching the movie without finishing it... But I'll still give it a try no matter what and I would expect someone commenting on this video to do the same unless they're just fans of Viggo hahaha

Anyone who wasn’t involved in the production of the 3 original films shouldn’t touch this , Peter and the crew deserves ultimate control and the ultimate rights to create this for us . God bless

Please don’t choose Timothee Chalemet to be Aragorn. I would be so sad.

@therealcaptainredbeard

29 күн бұрын

This deserves the top comment 😂

@nadaproblem3023

21 күн бұрын

Why? He was fcking awesome in Dune 2.

@CagedSUPERMAN

19 күн бұрын

Absolutely not no femboys

@realteabaggins

18 күн бұрын

@@nadaproblem3023 ew

@pipleehk

18 күн бұрын

No way he’s too young

The War in the North would be an incredible film! Such story potential there.

@Fuar11

29 күн бұрын

I've wanted this for so long

@mysticalmistress666-wc4ki

27 күн бұрын

There's a game of it, which was fun. I wonder if we'd get to see that protagonist trio return and then have a boss fight against Agandaur that occur simultaneously with the Assault on the Black Gate, chronologically. Having a dragon ally would be nice, since that's sort of what we did in the game.

@michaelburandt9134

4 күн бұрын

@mysticalmistress666-wc4ki That's what I'm sayin', I loved that game!! It actually kind of made me mad that you couldn't fight Urgost 🤣

As long as Amazon has nothing to do with it. I have been more than just a fan, I have spent a lifetime reading Tolkien. That abomination is not worth wiping a trolls arse with.

@orangemochacino6420

29 күн бұрын

Why would Amazon have anything to do with it? It’s Warner Bros.

@josh29221

29 күн бұрын

you need to relax.

@narth9414

29 күн бұрын

@@orangemochacino6420 He's making a statement that amazon has trashed the lotr ip.

@narth9414

29 күн бұрын

@@josh29221 You're telling a guy to relax about something he spent his lifetime reading.

@scottclark1839

28 күн бұрын

I couldn't agree more. It is a travesty and a stain on Tolkiens's work of genius. The arrogant "creators" of that filth deserve to lose hundreds of millions more than they already have.

Our prayers of Peter Jackson's return has been asnwered 🙏

@pmg83

Ай бұрын

Really ? I hope you do remember that ridiculous crap The Hobbit Triology.

@southernlady5085

Ай бұрын

Yes, hope returns!!!!! ❤ I hope I live long enough to see this. Looking forward to it!

@pmg83

Ай бұрын

@@user-jt1js5mr3f Actually I completely understand as a matter of fact. The Hobbit is a very nice simple children's story that movies stretched into adult versions for profits. I would not have complained if Peter Jackson had made 6 movies based on 6 LOTR Books.

@sameehkins5957

Ай бұрын

​@user-jt1js5mr3f The Hobbit suffered because it was extended into 3 movies (which was Jackson's decision NOT the studios decision). Jackson's reason for extended it from 2 movies to 3 movies is because "there was too much footage" of stuff that he invented (love triangle, Legolas). Also, Jackson included things that weren't even part of the Hobbit story, like Azog. Sauron in LOTR barely shows his face and he is more iconic and has more presence than Azog. Azog is a forgetful villain that most people don't even care about. Keep in mind, all of this was Jackson's doing.

@pmg83

Ай бұрын

@user-jt1js5mr3f Deleted comment addressed to me to which I had replied. It might have been an Amazon AI bot :)

I would die for a movie with Viggo and Ian returning as their characters.....

I hope they don't ruin the characters.

@comebackguy8892

28 күн бұрын

Why would they?

@boggeddown778

28 күн бұрын

Why wouldn't they?

@nadaproblem3023

21 күн бұрын

​@@boggeddown778 because they are the o.g. creators. Serkis voiced the books, which are absolutely incredible. He had a different, distinct voice for EACH character.

@rovhalt6650

20 күн бұрын

@@nadaproblem3023 That was then, this is now. When culture change, some people change with it unfortunately. I hope they have all been left uncorrupted by the wokeness. But I don't have high hopes.

I love Viggo's voice

@yakkattack

29 күн бұрын

For Frodo

@pipleehk

28 күн бұрын

Very gentle, like a benevolent father or mentor

"It is a good time to be a LOTR fan right now..." "The Rings Of Power".

@sweetjesus697

17 күн бұрын

yup!

@iscaria3337

16 күн бұрын

Surely he is trolling?

please please don't let this be some pk disney inspired interpretation where sauron is a non-binary asian thats identifies as a european who is unhappily secretly in love with a dark handsome man who in his turn claims to be a lesbian fish

@srikaustubhmandaleeka

20 күн бұрын

😂 true they fucked up too many movies so far in the name of diversity

@alexworm1707

16 күн бұрын

It will be shit

With how nearly perfect de-aging technology is; look at Dial and that was three years ago (as long as they take their time, hire the right artists) Viggo needs to return, he’s as fit and healthy as he was 20 years ago. Furthermore the Hunt for Gullum occurred between when Gandalf left with Frodo in charge and his return like a decade later.

If they don't bring back my precious Viggo, I'm going full Gollum mode.

@nadaproblem3023

21 күн бұрын

He's too old, unfortunately

@CagedSUPERMAN

19 күн бұрын

@@nadaproblem3023no he’s not

@lindildeev5721

17 күн бұрын

@@nadaproblem3023 Aragorn is supposed to be in his early 80's so you can't say he's too old for the part. And he still looks good for his age.

They should definitely try to get Viggo and Ian along with other legacy characters like Hugo Weaving, Cate Blanchett, Orlando Bloom and Lee Pace. Maybe even Elijah Wood. There's room for snippets of all those characters in this film with Viggo in make-up or slightly de-aged for his role as Aragorn hunting for Gollum. This bodes well for us fans. We love Peter Jackson's LOTR trilogy and we love Viggo, our brother, our captain, our king!

The one director to rule them all! Finally a movie we can actually look forward too

Thanks for always providing great content! Appreciate you 😊

@MiddleEarthUpdates

Ай бұрын

Thanks for the kind words :)

This video was so helpful to me!!!! Thanks SO MUCH!!! ❤❤❤

I love word "By fans for fans", these words are a reply to "Rings of power" for ruining middle Earth

It has been so long since Tolkien content has been created. Amazon doesn't count. I hope they use less CGI and more practical effects and take their time making the film/s.

@UncannyGameNerdz

28 күн бұрын

i was laughing, because it's true

Thank you for this analogy and explanation, I enjoyed this one and hope that it goes as you say. I have read some mixed / bad reviews and speculations that I did not quite understand, I didn't know that Andy Serkis was directing, this information makes me happy, Andy and Peter Jackson + crew working together then it will be worth the wait. Thank you for your hard work and I look forward to continued updates.

I can't imagine a recast. I couldn't...

Thanks for the update !

@MiddleEarthUpdates

Ай бұрын

Thank you for watching :)

I want to see Viggo as Aragorn again with a scenario he seems worthy to play.

Thanks very much for crediting Kerem Beyit's stunningly good artwork and not using AI rubbish.

This would seem like the most likely time frame for the movie to be set but personally I don't know if the actors would want to come back. It wouldn't be impossible as both Viggo and Ian loved their rolls and experiences working on lotr. Recasting would be a disaster and alienate a lot of people Imo. It would be like recasting Robert Downey Jr. as Iron man. HE IS IRON MAN. Just as much as Viggo Mortensen and Ian McKellen are Aragorn and Gandalf. If it is set during the 17 year Gandalf is gone then I believe they must go the de-aging route.

@comebackguy8892

28 күн бұрын

If they didn't want to come back, they wouldn't announce the movie.

@darylsdog9521

27 күн бұрын

@@comebackguy8892let’s hope your right

I do really hope they will make films, besides the hunt for gollum, about the war in the north. It will tell more about what happend in de rest of middle-earth during the story of the original trilogy, what we missed out off. I would love to see the old casting from both the trilogy and the hobbit films in a more combined storyline, only time will tell. If done right, it could be the next hit piece many crave for. although, i too realize, it might never be as great as the trilogy was before. 🙏

Billy Boyd looks amazingly young. Hope Merry and Pippin are included

@orangemochacino6420

29 күн бұрын

Why would they be included in a storyline they’re not a part of?

@ultraviolet540

29 күн бұрын

@@orangemochacino6420yea, it’s not gonna happen

@Trendle222

6 күн бұрын

they are WAY too young in the books when Gandalf and Aragorn are searching for Gollum, i think they are literally teenagers at most

Thank you! Such great news! And I'm glad they are filling in the sides....

Great video, thank you.

@MiddleEarthUpdates

Ай бұрын

Thank you :)

There's a lot they can do with this. It would be interesting to see the inside of Dol Gulder. I hope they do a blend of CGI like they did in LOTR so it seems more real. Too much CGI wouldn't make it feel real. I also think besides for the War in the North that you mentioned at the end of the video, They could do one on the Kingdom of Arnor in the North and how it fell.

@orangemochacino6420

29 күн бұрын

Exactly! Kingdom of Arnor and the rise of the Witch King.

@Eridorrr

27 күн бұрын

@@orangemochacino6420 this is what I want

I mean, this can only be on the level of fan fiction with the established characters, as there is no written material for it. Parts of the Hobbit movies already felt like this for me (like Gandalf meeting Thorin in that inn). It’s all based on nostalgia, longing for and trying to reiterate something great that once has been, and it can never be as good (even with PJ and Andy Serkis). It’s time to create new things.

This makes me so happy, I enjoyed the trilogy of lords of the rings (books and movies) when I was young, I hope to see this new features with my kids

I’ve been waiting for the Silmarillion soooo so long, I’m so excited 🫶🏼 just wish my dad was here to watch to watch these upcoming movie with me. We loved these books and the world Tolkien created.

@orangemochacino6420

29 күн бұрын

They’re not making the silmarillion tho?

In Fellowship of the Ring the novel, there were several years in between the time that Bilbo left the ring for Frodo, and the time that Gandalf returned to explain the history of the Ring. But in the film they made it seem like there was not much time at all that had passed. So I am wondering how they are going to reconcile all that.

Yes on what they are/were up to video

I am excited with Peter, Fran, Phillipa, and Andy returning to Middle Earth! They at least know how to honor Tolkien's work. Maybe some established faces will return... I stopped watching Rings of Power after episode 3. To say I was disappointed with the writing and fabrication/twisting/ignoring of lore is an understatement.

The optimal decision would be to release it as an animated movie featuring the original cast returning to voice their characters. This approach would allow for a faithful recreation of the world from the original Lord of the Rings trilogy. I am particularly fond of the art style seen in Princess Mononoke and other Studio Ghibli films, and I believe that such detailed animation would perfectly complement the tone of the new film.

@TokeThenJoke

24 күн бұрын

Or just move on from that 200 year span and cover some of THOUSANDS of years of juicy content that has been untouched.

@yokaboka

23 күн бұрын

@@TokeThenJoke i dont think they have the rights to the silmarillion stories.

All the actors look pretty much the same I hope they cast them all.I really like your videos pls do more theories about what the movies are going to feature.

@MiddleEarthUpdates

24 күн бұрын

Thank you! We have some planned videos about that. :)

Definitely nervous about this, considering the trend of LoTR adaptation quality over time, but I'd be happy to be wrong. High hopes, low expectations, we'll how this thing goes.

Absolutely buzzing, ngl.

I can't wait for all this! But I can't see anyone else playing any of the characters other than the original actors. Definitely can't see anyone else playing Gandalf besides Ian.

There isn't much source material and it is definitely just a money grab but if they must do this, I'm glad the original team is doing it

@Shcreamingreen

14 күн бұрын

I prefer them to work on scant source material rather than shitting on one that is far more extensive, like Amazon did

The movie was already masterfully made many years ago. How they deal with this, by apparently trying to shut it down many years later, is appalling.

@orangemochacino6420

29 күн бұрын

What u on about? Ur talking as if they are rebooting it

all I'll say is they better not ruin this franchise like they did to star wars.

I think in the commentaries Peter Jackson said something about Gandalf being gone for 6-8 weeks

oh boy oh boy oh boy...i cant wait

Andy Serkis is just and amazing all around person. One ofy mnt rushmore actors

Can't wait to see this movie, love Lord Of The rings,

There was a fan based short movie called the "The Hunt For Gollum" released about 12 years ago. There was also a "Born of Hope". It should be better than Rings of Power

The Force is strong with the narrator of these videos

@MiddleEarthUpdates

Ай бұрын

;)

Peter Jackson I think would never recast because his visions for Middle Earth and his recognition of the cast and crew so far are reflections of himself as a storyteller and a decent human being

I thought it would be taking place between the Hobbit and FOTR? At the end Legalos was off to find Aragon. I figured that’s where it would pick up from.

Making a movie about the war in the North would be EPIC!! Make it so!

@MiddleEarthUpdates

28 күн бұрын

It would be amazing!

Hopefully they will bring all the old cast from trilogy LOTR

I don't know if this movie will do well in the movie theatres. We already know what happens to Gollum. It would most likely would do well as a TV mini-series or streaming series. The latter gives more time to flesh out the characters.

I've wanted more Aragorn stories for years. Wasn't Aragorn in the War of the Rohirrim's events? If so, then I'm definitely looking forward to that more than I was. Unfortunately, I doubt Viggo will reprise his role for that, since I've never heard of him voice acting for animations.

I still would rather have The Fall of Gondolin as a movie

I hope Lee Pace and Orlando Bloom comes back. !

To be honest, the only thing that I don't need at all again is another she-horned in Legolas-appearance but it can't be worse than in the Hobbit-Trilogy were they blew him up to be a main character again who defies all laws of physics...while new characters like Beorn barely got any screen-time or even got iconic kills stolen by Legolas...but I really hope that they get back Lee Pace as Thranduil aswell and have the Woodland Realm looking vaguely as it did in the second Hobbit-movie

An Idea: Movie of Lúthen and Beren?

@evenstar1608

Ай бұрын

Sadly, no copyrights for them. 😢😢

I bet there are good actors to be found. What made the original so believable was that the actors were committed, also physically. You cant fake having a 65 year old being athletic like Aragorn.

There are so many movies that can spin fron LOTR, the hobbit was nice, now Gullom, also Aragon, also Gandalf, Also Saroman... so many more...

Unpopular opinion: I don’t want to hear any more Jar Jar Gollum.

If all characters would come back and it were made like lord of the rings was made. It would fucking break the internet.

I think they should add a female version of Gollum for him to have as a love interest and give her a really compelling self-growth character arc.

I will watch this movie and collected this.

The fan film THE HUNT FOR GOLLUM (2009) is a great film. If you have not watched it I highly recommend it.

One simply does not make a Tolkien based movie without Peter Jackson

quality over quantity. please let it be good.

Andy is the GOAT

heyyyy this might actually turn out allright

Not sure if I am into a Gollum movie because we already have seen the end game on the big screen. However the animated Rohirrim show really excites me for I don't know much of the history of Helm Hammerrhand or the creation of Helm's deep. So many great stories in Middle Earth, hek I would even love to see Peter Jackson's interpretation of the Blue Wizards or the Rise of Angmar in the North. One last thing i would love to see is a better balance with practical and CGI effects. One reason I loved the LOTR original trilogy, it felt more realistic while the hobbit didn't have that same feel due to the heavy CGI just my opinion,

The scenes where Gandalf would be active they could easily just use a double and then digitally place Ian Mckellans face on the double like they did with Paul Walker in the Fast and Furious

@MiddleEarthUpdates

Ай бұрын

That's true, but having Ian McKellen deliver all the lines is absolutely necessary!

@Phoenixguy357

Ай бұрын

@@MiddleEarthUpdates agreed!

@multicreativeartist6579

Ай бұрын

Or Luke Skywalker in The Mandalorian

@multicreativeartist6579

Ай бұрын

@@MiddleEarthUpdates Doesn't Gandalf never age so he looks the same?

@njm361

Ай бұрын

They done that in lord of the rings too lol

Are you going to play tale of the shire

Hopefully they deage where needed. I feel like recasting would be a big misstep

if the original actors do not play the roles, it will ruin this for me. recasting should not be an option.

Betta be Howard Shore for soundtrack

@rhusradicans2122

21 күн бұрын

Yes! LOTR was the best soundtrack ever! And in my 'living will', I've requested that the LOTR Symphony be played at my funeral!

So long as it's not anything like the Gollum video game!

Viggo is so much older now. I dont think this can possibly work.

I wish they would make a Been and Lithium movie.

they also can bring a movie about the downfall of Arnor and the rise of Angmar they got a lot of movies they can make but they need to keep very close to the lore

I think it might be difficult to bring back Christopher Lee, him being dead and all. Unless they resurrect him as Dracula.

They should turn shadows into live action movies/tv show👌👌

THE BOYS ARE BACK IN TOWN FELLAS!!!

They can do the same de-aging cgi disney did with Hayden christiansen when he came back for Ahsoka and Obi wan, with Viggo and Ian, im 100% both will join the gang, if Andy and Peter and all the writers are involved, no way they will miss it, we also might see Legolas and gimli, this movie will be the final nail in Rings of Power coffin

Is this Elliot from Battlefront Updates?

Big fan of Serkis as an actor but worried about him directing since it’s definitely not his strong suit.

@LisaMarieFord

29 күн бұрын

Did you know he helped a wee bit for LOTR and he was in charge of the 2nd unit filming for The Hobbit films; mostly the battle sequences?

@Chelios__

29 күн бұрын

@@LisaMarieFord I knew about the hobbit bit, not LOTR though. That’s interesting

@LisaMarieFord

29 күн бұрын

@@Chelios__ I think he wasn’t officially credited, but directing/running camera crew when they were in remote locations at times filling in for PJ. Not nearly as much as The Hobbit films, but a bit.

@Chelios__

29 күн бұрын

@@LisaMarieFord Cool. Thanks for sharing 👍🏻

Huh 🤔, so in the LOTR books it’s kinda like that scene in interstellar, where most of the crew go explore for just a few hours that planet with the monster tsunami waves, but in reality many, many years had passed by the time they returned to the ship….Interesting 🤨

I dont know what its going to be like, but I really don't care, its just exciting to have talented ppl writing and directing acting in LOTR.just stick to cannon and lore as much as possible and it will be a massive hit

Blue screen or real movie?

The badly stuffed the Hobbit….the lightning is out of the bottle and they can’t get it back in not expecting much 😢

@Brett1334

19 күн бұрын

The hobbit wasn’t Jackson’s film, he was brought on too late and tried to fix what he could with it but it was too late, he has stated this many times and said he wasn’t given the tools etc he needed and had to rely on cgi, hopefully with how that failed, Warner Bros have learnt from This.

Ian Mckellen actually wanted to play Gandalf in Rings of Power but they didnt want him so I think its not that unlikely that he comes back for this unless he got serious health problems in the meantime

@MiddleEarthUpdates

28 күн бұрын

First, I read, "Ian McKellen actually wanted to play Gollum in the Rings of Power…" and I was very confused. Then I reread it to see what you actually wrote. 😂 I didn’t know that! When did he say that? ☺️

@mariooooo.o3404

28 күн бұрын

@@MiddleEarthUpdates some Interview I cant find it unfortunately but I came across this kzread.info/dash/bejne/a2asy6ynhNHIh8o.htmlsi=4Omma5nzu0ManZsu and I would say I really doubt now he will play gandalf again sadly unless maybe he is only in a few scenes

Let's just hope Peter Jackson doesn't try to turn this film into a comedy like he did with the Hobbit movie.

If you don't let Peter Jackson do his job well we won't have other opportunities for him to work.

After the success of the game it’s kind of a no brainer

I also hope that it will have all of old cast or whole new one. This sounds good so far. I just hope they will lean on more practical effects than cgi. Cgi is so lifeless on itself. And I hope they go with Lotr movie way and not try to please all people like Amazon did with their garbage.

Legalos is thrandriels son. So will we see Orlando Bloom too u think? He was good in Hobbits and tuariel was so awesome. Hope to see more of her.

I would love the video describing what Gandalf , Aragorn , and Gollum were up to during the time of The Hunt For Gollum!

What a Serkis !

I dunno... normally I'd be excited if I were younger, but something about this seems not right. The Lord of the Rings was made with a passion to make films of Tolkien's work. It was done *because* Tolkien lovers wanted to make it. This, on the other hand, has an entirely different motivation: it's studio-ordered. As much as the people being brought onboard are all directly related to the trilogy's success, there was a different _motivation_ behind Lord of the Rings. Yeah everybody'll enjoy their time on this, but still. The difference between heartfelt projects that originated in love and projects that are ordered by studios (even IF the people brought on are passionate about the subject matter) is starkly different, and you can tell.