I think you should’ve given Sugar an honorable mention for her perfect game in survivor Gabon. No votes against her OR for her. Perfect.

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

LOL

@Teinve

2 жыл бұрын

THE PERFECT GAME

@jofujino

Жыл бұрын

They did vote for her to go into exile multiple times though. That said, exile was hardly a punishment since it essentially gave her immunity and fruit to eat as the rest of her tribe starved.

@yeahokaybud264

Жыл бұрын

@@jofujino ez win

@_peepee_

Жыл бұрын

if i was there i wouldve voted for her, she was awesome

Earl played the statistically best game coming 0.1% away from being 100% perfect. He got 100% of the Jury votes, voted 100% correctly and only got 1 stay vote.

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

J.T. only voted incorrectly once and that was when he threw a vote on Erinn knowing full and well Coach was going.

@bigbuffguy9589

2 жыл бұрын

@@OnceUponAnIsland I agree. I don't count "incorrect" votes that were part of a successful vote split or had an even better strategic purpose than just voting with the majority. JT's vote for Erinn to secure Coach's jury vote is perhaps the best example of this. Voting "correctly" in that case would actually be a negative for JT, as it could potentially put Coach's jury vote in jeopardy. There really is very little that I can criticize about JT's game.

@abhainnxv1554

2 жыл бұрын

Well, technically Earl voted incorrectly one time, and that was on the Mookie vote. But that was because of a vote split, so it doesn't really count as "incorrect" in essence.

@christiangal2124

2 жыл бұрын

There was one vote casted against him in his season

@gonealoof2106

Жыл бұрын

I love how the very premise of your entire comment is wrong. Earl voted against Alex in a split vote, and Mookie ended up going home. By this count he is statistically tied with JT, who voted incorrectly twice.

I never realized how hilarious it is when Jeff is reading off "Mike.. does not count." over and over and literally every single person is pissed and then there's Mike sitting in the middle with a huge toothy smile on his face 😂

@teamsteed1

Жыл бұрын

He is kinda cute.

Would've been Hilarious if you mentioned Sugar's game from Gabon as a joke. "Up next we have Sugar from Survivor Gabon. A game that was so perfect, that I think it went a little bit TOO perfect." Literally 0 votes casted against her throughout the season, only to then have 0 votes casted for her to win Survivor. I think the only player that didn't have their name written down on that piece of parchment the entire season without Med Evacs or Quitting the game.

@israelizzyyarrashamiaak766

Жыл бұрын

😂😂😂😂😂 true.

I know “technically” Earl didn’t get a perfect win, but I still personally think his game is deserving of a perfect or pseudo-perfect title because that one stray vote takes nothing away from his gameplay, and also makes no sense in the context of the season.

@bigbuffguy9589

2 жыл бұрын

Earl played a top-five game in my opinion. It was kind of like a pitcher who gave up a bloop single in the second inning and then was perfect the rest of the way. Not technically a perfect game but still incredibly impressive.

@WolfeXCIX

2 жыл бұрын

@@bigbuffguy9589 honestly great comparison lol

@yee6870

Жыл бұрын

​@@bigbuffguy9589 reminds me of spankie jackzon of drag race down under was in the bottom in the first episode then proceeded to be on the top for the remainder of the competition and won the crown

JT played the Absolute Perfect Game, on top of his achievement he got the Fan Favorite Award for his season. Cochran lost the award in his season to Malcolm

Natalie on SJDS is also super close. She never had a vote cast against her, and got every jury vote except 3. 2 of them were for family members and the other one was from Reed who cast his just so that Missy wouldn't get second place.

I feel like Tony’s win in Winner’s of War should’ve been mentioned. I know Natalie had 4 votes for her in the end(which doesn’t make the cut off in your list), but this was also a jury of 16. I mean, Tony never had his name written down to be voted out and won 12 final tribal jury votes, that was very impressive.

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

If I included every winner with 3 and 4 votes off from being perfect then the list would have ballooned from 9 winners to 19. That's literally half of the 38 winners we currently have.

@alenjimenez831

2 жыл бұрын

@@OnceUponAnIsland But those jury’s didn’t have 16 people. If you look at it percent wise, Tony came closer to a perfect game than Ethan in Africa

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

Tony missed it by 4 votes. I guess we could keep moving the goal posts. So counter point, Tony was never getting those 4 votes. Ethan was shy by 2 and could have gotten them.

@judahjodrey958

2 жыл бұрын

@@OnceUponAnIsland I understand your point, but I just feel like Tony was a special case and could’ve at least been an honorable mention. Obviously this is your channel and I’m not trying to tell you what to do, just wanted to share my thoughts :)

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

No problem. It's all opinions. I concede that Tony's WAW game was more impressive and a lot more fun to watch. This list was compiled strictly by the generally agreed upon definition.

The Jeremy win is *EASILY* the most impressive in my opinion. *The first ever NO VOTE tribal council* _(WHICH WE LATER FIND OUT ENSURED HIS PERFECT SEASON thus making the night extra special)_ *was the highlight of any regular season voting… outdoing the fire making challenges and rock drawing in my opinion.*

@noahswartwout-jk8fy

3 ай бұрын

Idk his gameplay is overshadowed by his constant my wife is pregnant and that's why I deserve to win over anyone else baloney.

@hed0nismbot

3 ай бұрын

@@noahswartwout-jk8fyI agree, during FTC this was my last straw to the point I thought to myself that I’d vote for Spencer if I were on that jury. I mean how is the baby’s gender relevant to the game? That was disgusting manipulation. Not to mention, both Spencer and Tasha probably wanted to have children later, why is it more important that the baby is coming now as opposed to sometime in the future? Ugh

@HectorRios-ue4im

3 ай бұрын

@@hed0nismbotlol This is survivor Play all your cards

I think Danni needs more credit here. To be on the bottom from the merge to the end and be only two votes shy of a perfect game is incredible!

I'm glad you pointed Sandra's near perfect game, one vote and she would have been the first in Season 7. Many fans like to bash her because they're salty about HvV but Sandra worked hard for her wins, even if she's not as flashy as other fan favorites. Also note how Sandra agreed or directly orchestrated JT's vote outs at HvV and Game Changers, the first person to play a perfect game.

@kamohelo6418

2 жыл бұрын

She shouldn't have won HvV. It's not a discredit on her game. She's still one of the best survivors of all time. Her game on Pearl islands had equal weight socially that it did strategically. When Rupert was voted out she showed how adept she is at shifting the target and even leveraging information. HvV should have been Parvati quite simply. On the basis of immunity wins, strategic prowess and tbh I find it hard to believe her social game was weak. It's Parvati. The Russell factor is what distorted everything unfairly. Sandra is ultimately an unsatisfying victor

@yzaraine

2 жыл бұрын

She won it though so she did have the best game still. You don't get to have the best game if in the end the jury doesn't want you

@gamingwithjay3

2 жыл бұрын

@@kamohelo6418 I'd have to disagree. She played simply amazingly during Heroes vs Villains and I was rooting for her the entire time because she was playing so well. I think she did bad in tribal council which causes people to think that her actual game wasn't pitch perfect. She managed to weazel her way to the end while being in the minority alliance through pure social game.

@kamohelo6418

2 жыл бұрын

@@gamingwithjay3 listen. I have massive respect for Sandra but we need stop dressing up her HvV win. The Hero tribe was massively flawed as a collective, they were high on their own supply. Sandra provided very little strategic value, did not win challenges and ladies agency for the post-merge portion of the game. She coasted by on the basis of being a 'non-threat' in Russell's eyes. Her performance in HvV is far opposed to her Pearl Islands game where she was very much in the driving seat and had her own agency whilst showing her ingenious style that we all love. I won't take her win away from her because frankly I can't but it's not very high up to me on the totem pole because I think the jury actually were so flawed in the way they judged. Parv should've been the winner if we are quite honest since Russell was a kamikaze. They both played better games than Sandra. I wish Jerri actually went to the end and won because at least she would've have been a much more satisfying winner. Sandra still is one of my favourite players and characters but let's be real

@kamohelo6418

2 жыл бұрын

@@gamingwithjay3 simply isn't true

cochran is one of my favorite winners, his transformation from the nerd to the alpha was great to see, wish he was on waw

@noahanimations1401

Жыл бұрын

Cochran is my fav as well he is great

@skyechang1309

Жыл бұрын

That was my favorite season to watch by far. Absolute legend, I love that man. To see his growth from his first season was awesome, and knowing he was such a huge fan made it even better

Crazy how Gabler was one vote off from joining this

@rosemulet

9 ай бұрын

Yeah he def should’ve been in the video imo

@OnceUponAnIsland

8 ай бұрын

@@rosemulet The video was made during Survivor 41, check the upload date.

@rosemulet

8 ай бұрын

@@OnceUponAnIsland Sorry!

IMO part of Sandra's strategy that never gets talked about is how she pits herself against villains like Jonny Fairplay and weak, unstable castaways like Lill, including taking them to the F3. This most likely gives her a much higher chance of having the jury vote for her.

@kamohelo6418

2 жыл бұрын

Still should've never won HvV. Jury did an absolute terrible job of fairly judging her game (or lack thereof). Parv should've won. But her Pearl Island game is top tier and is a staple of her "as long as it's not me" style with a lot of strategic weight also behind it. Queen stays Queen. Her GC game is also underrated

@rowanmoon

2 жыл бұрын

​@@kamohelo6418 She won twice with the same strategy. Sure, not as strategic as Parv or Russell, but an impressive feat nonetheless.

@kamohelo6418

2 жыл бұрын

@@rowanmoon 100%. Sandra is a legend. Mount Rushmore.

@stolencbscontent3233

2 жыл бұрын

It wasnt a strategy it was luck lmao

@chwaftka9775

Жыл бұрын

@@kamohelo6418 Parvati didn’t have as good jury management as Sandra did in that season but it wasn’t shown on the show. Plus her having at some point in time been showing her actively trying to get Russell out made her look like the underdog to Russell being the overdog in the jury’s eyes, and since they were against Russell and his terrible messiness, that gave more of a reason to vote for Sandra.

Personally, I think Brandon was setting Ethan up to lose a vote anyways by asking that question. Either that or Ethan could’ve just said that no one on that jury is undeserving, even if it is a cop-out.

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, I wonder what the right answer would have been for Brandon? Maybe Frank since he doesn't like him.

@GordyByGordy

2 жыл бұрын

@@OnceUponAnIsland Yeah though I think he could have "sold" it better... I think Ethan saying "You" is probably the best answer. Saying someone else just insults another person, and then risks Brandon not liking that answer.

@charlesross7673

2 жыл бұрын

@@GordyByGordy The answer would be "The juror that thinks Kim should win."

@midnalazuli793

Жыл бұрын

Ethan’s mistake was that he didn’t explain his answer. Brandon gave him the option to not explain himself, but obviously it doesn’t look good to bash a juror on their own question and not even own up to it. It was honesty without conviction.

"All about Survivor is what YOUR jury wants". You nailed this perfectly. And also this is the reason when I see arguments like "they would've won/lost with the modern jury" stupid and insulting to most of the players (argument common especially for Samoa). You should know and give what jury wants to hear, and not "know better than them how to vote".

Honestly I'm STILL amazed Sherry went to final three AND had the audacity to say "I don't need your vote". Girl. Yes you do. If you want to win this money, you NEED every vote you can get. SMH

Not a winner but Cirie in game changers technically also played a perfect game and was eliminated with no votes

@RandomIndyWrestling

2 жыл бұрын

Also Paschal I believe

@dashieprodx

2 жыл бұрын

Technically Colton in BvW played a perfect game under that definition.

@RandomIndyWrestling

2 жыл бұрын

@@dashieprodx blimey, under that criteria, so did Kourtney in One World.

@dashieprodx

2 жыл бұрын

@@RandomIndyWrestling Heck, under that criteria Jonathan and Wanda from Palau.

@switters8679

2 жыл бұрын

Seems we all need another look at the definition of technically….

Personally I think that if you nullified votes at tribal using an idol they still count as votes to your total. I believe that the perfect game is more about your social game than idols, but hey everyone has their ways and this is still a great video👍

@handsoaphandsoap

2 жыл бұрын

Agreed, imo a 'perfect game' means getting no votes cast against you, regardless of whether they counted or not.

@Keisha531

2 жыл бұрын

Knowing to use an idol the one time you were the target is maybe more impressive than slipping under the radar.

@robinmontgomery9160

2 жыл бұрын

@@Keisha531 You're not necessarily wrong but the definition of a perfect game isn't about impressiveness as much as it is about recognizing when someone never even came close to losing.

@midnalazuli793

Жыл бұрын

Jeremy’s “perfect” win is definitely debatable. It technically does meet the requirements to be considered a perfect win, but it lacks technicality.

@aidanpevida8429

2 ай бұрын

But the definition also allows players to play a perfect game by winning immunity. I think if JT lost immunity towards the end of the game he would have been voted out, for example. The way I see it: immunity is a part of the game and getting it in the form of the necklace OR the idol is another way, besides social game, to avoid votes and get the perfect game.

JT will always be the most perfect winner to me, not only because he was the first one to do it and blaze the trail, or because the only other purely perfect winner was a returning player, but because I think part of a perfect winner should also be how well liked you are by the jury. And JT clearly left everybody else in the dust in this category.

What about Natalie Anderson? She was very close to a perfect win, only reason she didn't get it was because of the blood v water twist, and how the finalists loved ones voted for them.

@desk661

2 жыл бұрын

and the only reason Jaclyn got two votes was because Reed didn't want Missy getting second. She 100% would have had a perfect game

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

She was close, but she missed it by 3 votes. Everyone in this video is 2 votes or less.

@desk661

2 жыл бұрын

@@floatinrocktubetalk3768 that's Natalie White this is Natalie Anderson from season 29

@desk661

2 жыл бұрын

@@OnceUponAnIsland fair enough but I think the context of those three votes is important.

Negated votes officially do count towards/against a perfect game according to the Survivor Wiki, and in my opinion, that is the correct method of determining whether a winner of Survivor played a perfect game or not. Playing an idol to negate votes is one thing; being so likeable that no one writes your name down is something else entirely.

@paulsancho88

Жыл бұрын

Actually no, Wiki states that some believe votes voided by an idol does not count but then states it's not actually accepted. If Jeff says it doesn't count, then why would it count.

@0mathgaming

Жыл бұрын

@@paulsancho88 the votes don’t count to eliminate someone, but they still count in terms of someone voted for you.

interesting point that we see kim’s win as one of, if not the most, dominant but it’s nowhere near statistically perfect by these standards

Sierra calling Stephen "weak" just pisses me off for obvious reasons

i’ve never ever been this early, love your channel and thank you for the great content!

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks for watching!

I think the fact that Jeremy was able to play his idol at the ✨perfect time✨ makes his win even more valid

I'm curious which winner had the "worst" game (received the most votes throughout the game while still making it to the end and winning) I have a feeling it'd be Richard Hatch 🤔

@handsoaphandsoap

2 жыл бұрын

Honestly, a great question. Could even workshop into a top 5 list tbh, jump on this Idoled Out.

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

Ben - 14 votes Chris U - 13 votes Aras - 11 votes Natalie W - 10 votes Wendell - 10 votes

@yugiwinninglex

2 жыл бұрын

@@OnceUponAnIsland Hahaha my first thought is Ben. Guess most of these are negated votes through idol or those weren't counted?

@mjtestaverde418

2 жыл бұрын

I was thinking Aras had more votes than Ben tho...🤔

@yugiwinninglex

2 жыл бұрын

@@mjtestaverde418 6 votes at f7, 4/5 votes at F6, 4 votes at F5, not to mention before f7 and premerge. Ans 3 more votes if not for FMC.

Honestly I think Jeremy’s win was the best one. The decision on whether or not he played his idol was the difference between him being sent home and him winning the game, and that’s a little bit more admirable than winning the popularity contest against your runner ups.

Tony went into his last FTC with no votes against him. There are four jury votes he doesn’t receive, all of which come with caveats. He probably gets Jeremy if Natalie’s not a finalist. Maybe Tyson too, though he had antagonized Tyson earlier, so maybe not. Ethan and Parvati were premerge boots with whom he’d never had a chance to interact, so it all gets murky. And here’s another question: If the final immunity winner puts you in the fire making challenge, does that still count as no votes? I mean, it would literally, but on the other hand, it means someone’s doing their best to eliminate you.

@yugiwinninglex

2 жыл бұрын

The only reason ppl pile on Tony with the votes is cause Natalie alr have some votes. Otherwise the votes will be more split if Natalie isn't a finalist.

I kind of see Earl Cole as a perfect game even though technically Rita voted against him. She only did that because she couldn’t vote for Sylvia or Anthony as she was in an alliance with them and knew there was no chance that Earl was going home. She liked Earl and didn’t want to see him voted out. Earl was on the right side of every vote, essentially had no one who wanted to vote him out, controlled the game, and got all the votes at the end. That’s an impressive game even if he didn’t actually get a perfect game on account of one vote that wasn’t intended to vote him out. The perfect game is a cool statistic, but it’s not the end all be all of the game. I think Jeremy played a solid game in Cambodia and those three votes at the F6 Tribal that he idoled out don’t take anything away from his game in my opinion (although if we want to be technical those idoled out votes don’t count 😜) Although it would be cool if Jeremy actually had the perfect game status, but I’ll take an asterisk. Still counts!

Great vid 😄

i loved watching jeremy that season, one of my faves winners of all time

Your my fav survivor you tuber keep it up

Strongly disagree about your assessment of Ethan. I'll give you Kim P's vote, heck I'll even concede Kelly's vote (I know that she voted for him to win but god dammit why didn't he just guess 4?????), but Brandon's question would have guaranteed he lost someone's vote. If he says Frank like Brandon wanted him to say he just loses Frank's vote.

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

He could have said the least worthy to sit up there was Big Tom. Big Tom ain't switching to Kim J. He hates her lol

@BrettMKW

2 жыл бұрын

@@OnceUponAnIsland He would be blatantly lying though and I don't think the jury would have respected that. I guess we'll never know for sure. I actually remember watching it when I was 7 and was so flabbergasted when Kim had to pick a number between 1 and 1000 and guessed 3, and then Ethan has a perfect opportunity to say 4 and says 888. I don't know which answer is worse. I will concede I find Ethan's jury speech to be one of the worst out of people who actually still won but I think Brandon's question put him in a no win situation.

@ohandthefracking

2 жыл бұрын

@@BrettMKW Ethan said 888 because him and Kim had a talk about their favorite movie and she mentioned three digit number between 600-800 in there...you can even see Ethan struggling cuz he tried to remember what shes talking about

@jenniferconstantine9041

2 жыл бұрын

I think part of managing the jury properly lessens the chances that you get a question like this to begin with. I like how Stephen Fishbach joked that every question was basically a different iteration of tell us why JT is so amazing.

New to the channel - would love to see a video on Cochran one day, he was my favorite

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

Every winner is guaranteed a video about their win.

I love these

great vid ty subbed

i love your channel

@buffalobuffalobuffalobuffalo

2 жыл бұрын

Same here!

While I DO understand the perception of calling Jeremy a "perfect winner" and saying Mike came close on account of using their Idols to negate votes, I do still consider negated votes (especially when them being negated is the only reason someone survived a Tribal) to count as votes against, on the basis of intent, as they were very much made to get said person voted out.

@rthompson9809

2 жыл бұрын

Nope.. officially they’re nonexistent and it’s only that way because of their gameplay and strategy. With that I’m mine I don’t know how you don’t include them.

@drunkendog13

Жыл бұрын

@@rthompson9809 you’re wrong, they count, cope

@midnalazuli793

Жыл бұрын

Negated votes are still votes, they’re just votes that don’t count.

I really expected Stephen to put together a better final tribal performance. He should've leaned more into the idea that he didn't have the natural charm and skills that JT did, meaning he had to work harder to get to the position he's in than JT did - instead he brings it up but doesn't bring it full-circle making him look like he didn't really know what he was doing. Using JT's football logic, winning survivor would be based on your ability to build a fire or shelter, which we all know isn't the case. If Stephen had portrayed the relationship like JT was the quarterback of the team but Stephen was the coach (which it pretty much was), he would've at least picked up a vote or 2.

Thanks for the video.

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

You are welcome!

And now Gabler was just one jury vote away from a perfect game iirc

@OnceUponAnIsland

Жыл бұрын

I just posted a video about Gabler yesterday!

That was fun, unrelated to the vid but Sandra is the Queen and always will. More Sandra PI and HvV 'charcters' and we are living large as fans forever.

Whenever I think about who played the best *strategic* game, esp winners, I think about Todd. Maybe Tony. But I always forget about Earl like he played a great game. He probably played the most BALANCED game of anyone. He found a good balance between strategy and social game. Or, rather, he made his social game a large part, but not the only part, of his strategy. Even against Yau I think he would've won.

Honestly I always thought that Ethan told Brandon "you" bc one would think brandon would respect the honesty

OH I MISSED THESE VIDEOS

Thank you for making this video and also for adding the Bible verse at the end! God Bless

Because I think it's relevant here are all the other winners that either received no votes to Eliminate or Swept the Jury (so perfect in either their ftc or normal game): No Votes to Eliminate: Tina (Aus), 4-3 ftc Brian (Thailand), 4-3 ftc Nat A (SJS), 5-2-1 ftc Nick(DVG), 7-3 ftc Tony(Waw), 12-4-0 ftc Swept Jury: Adam(MVGX), 6 Votes against

Jeff’s PI finale shirt will live rent free in my memory forever

Absolutely loved jeremys game plus his family story throughout the season, definitely my favorite perfect winner

Appreciate the verse at the end

7:28 Even Katy's surprised someone voted for her! lol

Im a little surprised that Adam doesn't have his own segment here, he did get that Unanimous jury vote

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

He missed it by 6 votes! You need 2 or less to crack this list. 00:40

Spencer from Cagayan and Cambodia is my FAVORITE competitor and was the biggest opposition to Tony.

The people at JT’s tribal were pretty dumb. Their inability to see Stephen’s intelligence in getting both he and JT there, and the inability to blame JT for doing the same things Stephen did. Dumb. Stephen played a better game with his second chance than JT ever played without him.

@tmm4195

Жыл бұрын

I do think Stephan was the smarter player, especially looking back and watching J.T. play in future seasons lol. However, J.T. was socially stronger which typically carries more weight. J.T. also kind of demolished Stephan at the FTC.

If you like this video then check out The History of the Survivor Car Curse! - kzread.info/dash/bejne/p51quMOihqvUgps.html

@platypus3830

2 жыл бұрын

Did Sugar from Gabon not pull off something that should be on this list?

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

@@platypus3830 She didn't win.

@platypus3830

2 жыл бұрын

@@OnceUponAnIsland She didn't get any votes through Tribal Council, though.

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

@@platypus3830 Ok... but she lost 7 jury votes and didn't win.

@platypus3830

2 жыл бұрын

@@OnceUponAnIsland It's stil impressive that she could go so long without a vote. I bet you couldn't have done better. 😏

I know this has nothing to do with anything but I am very tickled by the cut off cheers at the vote ceremonies

I liked Mikes game, other than the auction blunder. But it went to show how crucial it is to eliminate challenge threats. He had bad challenge competition, so was able to steamroll through to the end. His early game alliances were strong enough as well to get him deep. Having allies that aren’t very good at challenges comes in handy, since you can get to the end with them and then simply win immunities, forcing others to have to go after each other, keeping your hands relatively clean. Garners you more jury votes I feel.

@austinogle6654

Жыл бұрын

I agree, though I feel like that auction blunder would be more well received by the other players in this newer era. Hyper aggressive/risky moves are rewarded in todays game.

A Dawn comercial popped up literally when Phillip was about to say "Dawn" 😂

It was nowhere near "perfect" but Yule deserves some credit for the number of moves he made to somehow bear Ozzy

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

He is a great winner.

I didn't expected Danni would make to the Final in Survivor Guatemala🍊🍎

I thought Boston Rob would be on this list, But then I saw the he had a total of 6 vote against then Phillip got 1 vote at final tribe council

I'd consider Jeremy's win to be more of a "no-voter" like a no-hitter in baseball

Time to update this list ;-)

Which winner do you think played the best game?

@giovanniorellana2200

2 жыл бұрын

Out of the ones in this video, I would say Tom.

@sixredfish6115

2 жыл бұрын

Kim or B Rob played such dominate games which I think they played the best. Kim being 1. In the video JT was extremely impressive and everyone wanted him to win.

@Neon_Umbreon

2 жыл бұрын

Tony WaW easily

@bigbuffguy9589

2 жыл бұрын

@@danielmiller5 I think the Tocantins cast was significantly more difficult than the Caramoan cast. Cochran had pre-game alliances, and he benefited from a fans v. favorites format and two enormous goats. Don't get me wrong. It's still a very good game, as he didn't really make any mistakes. But JT's game was a lot more impressive to me. Also, Jeremy didn't play a perfect game. He got his name written down three times. Negated votes are still votes

@desirae827

2 жыл бұрын

Which winner has the "worst" game? (Most votes throughout the season/barely winning the finale)

Honestly, I consider someone that didn’t get any votes during the main season, then winning (no matter how many votes) a perfect season.

We can now add Jesse from the latest season to this list. If he had won fire making against Gabler, he would be on this list or maybe once grudge vote away. He played an incredible game!

@OnceUponAnIsland

Жыл бұрын

This list is reserved for those who won.

I liked how Katie looked confused at her vote

Earl is a classic and timeless winner

11:00 Survivor "Token Jeans" 🤣

💯 on Jeremy being a perfect winner

I’d give an honorable mention to Nick(David vs Goliath)

Haha I'm looking through Wikipedia and Brian Heidik almost made this list if he had gotten one more vote at final tribal council

I got a new idea of the next survivor history video how about talking about the unlonged tribes that are down in numbers when reaching the merge

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

Great idea! The patrons pick what videos I make :)

@cdawg4021

2 жыл бұрын

@@OnceUponAnIsland thank you for the comment 👍👍

They made me feel bad for Dawn but hey life is full of the range of all emotions.

I think without The Edge Tony could have had a perfect game in WaW. Jeremy would probably vote for him if he wasn't against Natalie, and everyone else who didn't went out pre merge, so never knew him. Unfortunately that is a huge what if, and it is also true that if Natalie isn't at final tribal, Sarah is, who probably gets Ben, Sohpie, and maybe Yul's vote(Because Sarah would donate 100k to ALS research) . So it is kinda not super close, but still he had no votes case against him, and got 12 final tribal votes, which is the most anyone has gotten, in an all winners season

@silverbowftw5225

Жыл бұрын

No because Sarah and Tony would’ve split votes

Sandra played a perfect game in season 7 in my books, Ti voting Lil just seemed random to me, Sandra was so close to being both the first two-time winner AND playing the first perfect game - those who don’t believe she deserves the title of Queen are deluding themselves

Sandra would have deserved it if not for the fact that her answer to Tijuana was absolutely terrible. I very much got the impression that Tijuana's vote was decided at final tribal council.

Gotta throw an honourable mention to tony in winners at war I mean he was so close to having the perfect game in one of the toughest seasons ever if not the toughest in terms of competition

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

He played an impressive game but he was off by 4 votes. 19 winners are within 4 votes aka half of all winners.

Tom, Mike, and Jeremy are some of my all-time favorite winners. I rooted for all of them though their entire games and was so happy that they won their seasons. I also liked JT, but I liked him less after he came back. So, that has always diminished my feelings toward him.

I feel like honestly Tony deserved a mention for Winners at War. He should have had a perfect game, and he also almost tied the record for individual immunity wins, and all of the votes he lost were at final tribal with the largest jury in history. The jurors who voted against him either didn't play much with him because they were out at edge in the pre-merge, with the person they voted for, or it was Jeremy, a great friend of Natalie's. He was at the largest disadvantage, being placed against all winners and having to deal with the edge of extinction without a vote ever cast against him until the four at final tribal.

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

The perfect game isn't determined by personal opinion, just the numbers. 19 winners were within 4 votes of perfection.

I love J.T ❤❤❤❤ very humble and nice guy❤❤❤❤

Coming back to this a year later, I didn’t think we’d see another near perfect game in the newer era of survivor. I’m fairly glad to say it can still surprise me that it happened considering Erika was only 3 votes off from a perfect game. Wonder if the winner of survivor 43 will have a near perfect game as well. We do have a few contenders after all.

@patrickburns6310

Жыл бұрын

I agree Erika killed her season. 100 percent on every vote...

I still think Jeff blew that up for Mike. I wonder if anyone else noticed before Jeff spoke up

I also believe a factor of perfection is to correctly be on the right side of each vote.

@OnceUponAnIsland

8 ай бұрын

If we are going by the definition set by the show in season 14, then it is not factored at all.

Is there anyone on season 41 who is on track to be perfect?

@henryjones411

2 жыл бұрын

I can only think of Danny, but that would require him, at this point, to basically take Shan and Liana to the end. Shan will blow her game up beyond repair if she gets to FTC mark my words, and Liana will be seen as a minion and won’t get much respect. In that scenario, and only that scenario, Danny can clean sweep a jury. Any other scenario and somebody else will also get votes.

@youkaliciousx299

2 жыл бұрын

SHAN

Statistically, who was the least perfect winner? The most votes cast against and least votes at final tribal? I’m sure it can be found, Chris Underwood is obvious but maybe Richard Hatch or Todd as they played messy games as well.

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

Ben Driebergen with 14

Fun Fact: The first "Perfect Game" was technically by Jonny in Survivor UK Season 2

@nachoalvarez7171

7 ай бұрын

But nothing happened that season, so eh

Cochran just pips JT because he had 2 other finalists to contend with. And he’s my all time favourite player :)

I can’t believe Mike freaking Gabler would be on this list now.

Jeremy is my favorite Survivor of all time

even if tom didn't statistically play a perfect game i still think he's the strongest ever survivor winner

Mikes position at the auction was already compromised. Everyone knew he was on the chopping block. The auction didn’t blow up his game- he was already fairly screwed by the time of the auction

Now, Erika Casupanan was also close to playing a nearly perfect game having only two votes cast against her all theough the season and just having one vote not for her in FTC winning 7 - 1

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

She was 3 votes off so 1 shy from making this video.

Ethan made the right decision answering Brandon for that question. Why piss another person on the jury off, especially since you're not even sure the one asking the question will vote for you if you pick someone else?

If you watched Australia survivor, David the golden god pretty much had the definition of a perfect game in his returning season

@OnceUponAnIsland

2 жыл бұрын

His numbers say that he was 6 votes off from a perfect game.

GIve me Cochran as King and Sandra as Queen of Survivor.

Jeremy is my favorite player ever

So in a final 3 if only one contestant receives all the votes how to they decide who got second and third place?

@OnceUponAnIsland

7 ай бұрын

They are tied for 2nd

What did Mike not do at 17:06? Also I think Jeremy was my favorite winner. I haven't seen many season but I have seen his

@blackroseinbloom

Жыл бұрын

They had agreed to buy the letter from home so those who wanted the advantage could all bet $480 on it and draw rocks for it. Mike initially didn’t buy the letter so he’d still have $500 and automatically have the highest bid for the advantage. It made him target number one from that point on.