anti fascist song sung by partisans and the partisans were mostly socialists and communists, it is not anti communist by a long shot

@TheAstroTheory

8 ай бұрын

Hello! In the video I never claimed that the song was anti-communist, quite the opposite. I'll copy & paste the answer to another comment: "The song is definitely anti-fascist. However, the video explains why its popularity is, in part, a byproduct of post-war anti-communism" May I ask where you got that idea from? Was it just the title or did you have the same impression after watching the content? It might be a problem on my part

@robotrage3882

8 ай бұрын

Just the Title, my bad @@TheAstroTheory

@skywalker541

6 ай бұрын

Uffa, che imbarazzo! Why would you comment before viewing? Che questa sia una lezione per te​@@robotrage3882

very underrated channel you deserve many more subs and you just earned one from me

@TheAstroTheory

8 ай бұрын

Thank you!

Hai spiegato molto bene e chiaro. Grazie mille. Viva la nostra vera L'ITALIA. Italia, che è nata nei nostri cuori e vivrà sempre anche se noi non lo siamo, l'Italia vivrà sempre e non ha bisogno di nessun partito o ideologia di disturbo per sopravvivere. Viva l'Italia 💙 🇮🇹 💙 Salve 💙🇮🇹💙

Very informative video, even knowing some or much about this video's theme it helps clarifying the more obscure points and framing the song in it's context. Great work, of course thumbs up for the songs used in the video and on a less serious note, I'm a simple man: I hear Modena City Ramblers-I'm liking the video!

@TheAstroTheory

8 ай бұрын

Grazie!

Fascinating

Thank you for the explanation. Great job!

Beautiful video! I couldn't imagine finding a great background story than this one. I searched for it and I found the this great one! Thank you again!

Phenomenal video, entertaining and informative. I'm not sure how to feel about the song now, on one hand I am closer politically to the Partisans than anything else and don't feel great about their ideology being erased from the story given that it was frequently communists in fascist countries who were the first to resist and frequently the first to die. On the other hand, it's a banger.

A very informative video thank you for helping me understand the meaning behind the song

Huh, I never knew a lot about this song. Thanks for the history lesson.

@TheAstroTheory

9 ай бұрын

Thank you for watching!

Victory for the people is rare as happiness, but ohh how we cherish it more the longer it takes to find it.😊

Great video man

Wonderful channel fratello!

This song dates back to the early 20th century, when many women had to work for pittance for rich landowners in their rice plantations! btw, the first US foreign meddling was in Italy in 48, they were thinking that France would become a commy state too in case Italy would become a commy state!

Now then, thank you for explaining. However, isn't there another verse about the "banderra de labor" or something that is often left out but part of the song as well? Which would also make it a communist / socialist piece.

Wouldnt it be anti fascist?

@TheAstroTheory

8 ай бұрын

The song is definitely anti-fascist. However, the video explains why its popularity is, in part, a byproduct of post-war anti-communism

Katyusha in Italiano?😮😮😮

It is absolutely insane to me to say Bella Ciao has a "Joyous mood"

That communist song is the Soviet Katyusha with the lyrics changed.

@sherbet3657

Ай бұрын

I immediately recognized the melody because I remember being taught this song by my great grandmother

What are the names of the other songs you played in the background of your video? I want to look up the one that plays while you're talking about the leniency on ex-facists.

@TheAstroTheory

8 ай бұрын

That one is Fischia il Vento by the Modena City Ramblers. The others are La Brigata Garibaldi and Bandiera Rossa.

Bella Ciao still mentions a red flag though.

Kinda weird the melody at 4:40 reminds me of a German military song but I cant quite remember which it is, its like at the tip of my tongue

@TheAstroTheory

8 ай бұрын

Hello! The original tune of Fischia il Vento was inspired by the Soviet song Katyusha. There are some version of Katyusha in German made by the DDR, it could be that

Bellissimo video ho imparato qualcosa anche io, soprattuto perche' il titolo mi ha sballato completamente (anti-communism?!?!?!) lol

When I first read Bella Chiao lyrics, I instantly felt like its a Katyusha rip off. Now I kno I felt correct, and why it sounds so cheap ans cheesy compared to Katyusha.

la casa de papel !

Video top bro, ma il Mattarellone nazionale si chiama Sergio, non Giorgio, quello era Napolitano😂

@TheAstroTheory

8 ай бұрын

Sapevo che non l'avrei passata liscia, prima o poi qualcuno doveva notarlo. Da Giorgia Meloni a Giorgio Mattarella è un attimo

@marcoroccoromiti423

8 ай бұрын

@@TheAstroTheory Eh ho immaginato, sono nomi con un suono simile. Comunque video davvero di livello, complimenti. Se vuoi un consiglio, lascia meno immagini di sfondo a tinta unita, in un video informativo secondo me non rendono. Continua così 💪🏻

Bellissimo video ho imparato qualcosa anche io

Very fascinating stuff, though always sad to hear about how the West interfered with the Italian leftist movements

Actually the best video on this song. To think that the vast majority of people just hear this song and think "hurt durr pro communism anti fascism" when in reality it seems to have been a very deliberate move by western powers to make sure Italians were rallied against fascismo but also made sure to stay anti-communist. Incredibly similar to what Americans do to their mainstream right wing bloc by rallying around anti-fascism but without any of the communist trappings that often come with that.

That clip where President Meloni is staring at the people singing the song... just in this period when Meloni is desperately trying to pass a reform to get extra political powers... or just see her government fall: absolutely precious. Another fascist down. 😎👍

The title of the video a bit misleading but overall a solid point, great video. It's still a great song, really catchy. Though I do think Bandiera Rossa rules, they should have picked it instead.

Im sorry i wanna sub but you have a funny number amount of subs and im torn

Well yes, "Fischia il Vento" is way better as partisan song.

wow unbiased

I stop playing bella ciao on the street after casa del papel get more popular

thank you war thunder

lmao media literality is dead ill be the first critical rating

@TheAstroTheory

8 ай бұрын

Hello! I don't quite know what you mean by that. Care to explain?

@unpopuler

8 ай бұрын

@@TheAstroTheory Use your head... where those guys fighting with hitler? Must be nice living life on auto pilot

@TheAstroTheory

8 ай бұрын

​@@unpopuler You seem a little confused. Partisans fought against Hitler for the liberation of Italy. Had you watched the video you'd know it analyses the reasons behind the song's success, deeming it in part caused by post-war anti-communism.

@unpopuler

8 ай бұрын

@@TheAstroTheory you need a better title sorry

Forza lega che schifo quest canzone

This song was originally sung by the MONDINE ,rice pickers of northern italy against the greedy land owners in the 1800's !

@TheAstroTheory

8 ай бұрын

It probably wasn't tough, as explained in the video. Dato che il nome mi pare nostrano ti invito a consultare la pagina Wikipedia italiana di Bella Ciao

@robotrage3882

8 ай бұрын

Wiki says it's an anti fascist song sung by partisans and the partisans were mostly socialists and communists what are you on about? @@TheAstroTheory

I'm an anti communist but I like this song