I actually did grow up knowing something about the US invasion of Russia. My grandfather was one of the US army engineers who served with the Polar Bears. He told stories about the Americans assigned to unload the British supplies. The soldiers would pass the supplies from man to man until it was stored in a warehouse. When they got to the whisky rations for the British troops, they formed another line and every 4th bottle went to a basement where it was hoarded by the US troops. He would also talk about being kept there for a year after the war ended. He said that, if the had been kept there another year, we kids would have had a Russian grandmother. At which point, Grandma would smack him on the arm.

@threatassessment606

Жыл бұрын

And give him a cigarette and a shot of vodka

@Nobody-Nowhere-USA

Жыл бұрын

I love your grandfather even though I have never met him! My kind of people!

@Leo137156

Жыл бұрын

Great story, thanks for sharing it. I served in Germany where my eldest daughter was born, but to my American wife. But Lord knows, had I been single, I would have married some pretty German chick and my eldest would have been half German, on top of German-born. Stuff happens lol

@zahidkhan5733

Жыл бұрын

American ingenuity...

@michaeldelisieux

Жыл бұрын

Is he talking about the first or the second Russia 's American invasion?

American, British, Canadian, Australian & Japanese troops all fought in the Russian Civil war - on the Anti Communist side :)

@ZeroResurrected

2 жыл бұрын

French and Czechoslovak too

@markfinlay422

2 жыл бұрын

And all were defeated.

@ZeroResurrected

2 жыл бұрын

@@markfinlay422 And then won the Cold War

@jjdelft3216

2 жыл бұрын

@@markfinlay422 I wouldnt say they were militarily defeated, it was mostly due to western powers getting tired of war so they didnt want to go all the way

@TheGrinningViking

2 жыл бұрын

It's a good thing the citizens of Russia won, instead of the foreign invaders.

Russian Civil War is a favorite period of study for me. It's amazing to me how few Americans know that U.S. troops invaded Russia in 1918-19, yet it's common knowledge to every Russian I've ever met.

@July0705

Жыл бұрын

We learn that at school , and one of reasons that Bolsheviks has won - was involvement of USA troops to support „white army“ so regular civilians saw that like invasion and betrayal from its own officers , that is why they had to choose „less evil “ and fight along with „red army“

@thomaslacornette1282

Жыл бұрын

This period always looked very complicated to me, i was just vaguely knowing white Russians had some support from the west but i didn't realize there was actual expeditionnary troops and all those legions constitued of former prisoners. What a mess! :) I always asked myself how the Bolcheviks managed to wage such a bloody war with troops that wanted end of the war in 1917. lol Cossacks style war raids is maybe more "fun" than trenches war. :)

@frankmueller2781

Жыл бұрын

@@thomaslacornette1282 Yeah, historically the RCW was a total $h!t show, with only bad guys of varying degree. (At least once Alexayev was slain)

@lucatoni4509

Жыл бұрын

equal of US Civil War

@frankmueller2781

Жыл бұрын

@@lucatoni4509 the irony is that while the Russian Civil was a REAL civil war, it wasn't much of a revolution so much as a couple, yet the American Civil War wasn't so a civil war (Except in Kansas & Missouri) as a failed revolution.

My wife's family actually had a family member who was in the Polar Bear expedition and was killed, and still buried there. Thanks so much for the work on this video. (:

Not only Vladivostok and Arkhangelsk. In the city museum of the city of Medvezhegorsk (on the northern shore of Lake Onega) there is a photo of a wooden train station with an American flag above it. American soldiers raised their flag over the station building and took pictures under it. The station was built in 1916 and in 1919 it was practically new. By the way, the building itself has been preserved unchanged, which is very rare.

You should also do one on the Japanese intervention in Siberia in the Russian Civil War. The Japanese sent more soldiers to intervene in Siberia than the rest of the Allies combined, was an interesting follow up to the Russo-Japanese War and an important but not well known contributor to World War II in the Pacific.

@AICW

Жыл бұрын

I heard about the Siberian mission just last year from the anime Mars Red. The main character of the series is an IJA colonel who lost an arm in the Siberian intervention.

@jody6851

Жыл бұрын

How many people know Japan was a member of the Allied Powers during WWI? For that reason, as part of the Treaty of Versailles forced upon Germany by the victorious Allies, Japan was handed control of German holdings in the Pacific including the Marianas (Saipan and Tinian among others), the Marshall Islands, Pulau, parts of the Solomon Islands, and Western Samoa. In other words a giant chunk of what would become the Japanese Empire's Pacific island holdings which the US had to seize one bloody island at a time during WWII. Even more history few people know: Woodrow Wilson pushed for an end to the Colonial Era and the formation of the League of Nations which he is famous for. Chinese intellectuals looked to him as their hero and champion to help rid China of the European and Japanese colonialists who had exploited China and ruled sections of Chinese territory as economic concessions. However, Wilson was so determined to get Japan into the League of Nations, he agreed to allow Japan to keep its Shantung Peninsula Chinese holdings as an incentive to join the League. So many Chinese intellectuals felt so betrayed by Wilson that they decided to look to the new Soviet Marxist model instead of one based on the United States for inspiration. Mao Tze Tung came out of this sense of betrayal. They invited Russian Communists to come to present their case and suggestions secretly, and the Chinese Communist Party was born. So it can be said that Woodrow Wilson indirectly is responsible for the creation of the Chinese Communist Party.

@AICW

Жыл бұрын

@@jody6851 Wilson is one of the worst U.S. presidents of all time. The federal income tax (by way of the Underwood Act), the Federal Reserve, and the 17th Amendment allowing for direct election of U.S. Senators happened under his administration as well.

@Steve-O_27

11 ай бұрын

Along with his resistance to the women's suffrage movement for equal rights for women. He sure did step in everything while claiming to be an isolationist, and everything he touched including himself went to 🪑. And let's not forget the rise of crony captain under his watch that we still suffer from today and the pushing of oil over better and cleaner fuel sources along with tree paper over hemp because that's what his friends wanted. All thanks to the Rockefellers and their ilk and Wilson helping them all along the way!

@RMCbreezy

4 ай бұрын

​@@AICWand pray tell why is it a travesty that the people themselves elect senators?

Love the coverage of this. As someone who served in the 31st infantry regiment as a polar bear (modern day) its not common knowledge the time spent in Russia. The unit was first created there, sent to China, the Philippines and eventually Korea before ever being stationed in the US. The unit motto was Pro Patria ( for the father land in latin). The 1st 2nd and 3rd battalions to my knowledge were all retired after being completely overrun during various battles (Bataan and Tet offensive etc) Due to the lost story and the missing units the 4th battalion unofficial motto is "Polar bears are real". Thanks Simon really enjoyed this.

@PizzaGrunt

Жыл бұрын

Pro Patria and Climb to Glory brother.

@MrMeanstreek

Жыл бұрын

Thank your for your service wish i was brave like you man :/

@zahidkhan5733

Жыл бұрын

Interesting info! thanks

@briangall8442

Жыл бұрын

Russian's smoked more Nazis than the USA and Canada combined! Thats a lot of chemical, clean up!

@briangall8442

Жыл бұрын

Ask Schwartzdeau! He has your injection! And your casket vote!

Cool to finally hear a story about this. My Great Grandpa came from Greece and to get his citizenship he joined the army. He had some relatives in Michigan. So that’s where he had residence at. So when it was time to ship out the war ended. But because he was “from Michigan” he was one of the men sent to Russia. He was from the Mediterranean lol. So he did not have a good time in the insane cold. He saw combat like was talked about in the video. He also said one of the worst things that was done is both sides would pump boiling water at each other. Freezing the enemies in their trenches. Same happened to the Americans as well. It was hell. But he made it back and lived a long great life. My grandpa was the youngest of 8. So I never got to meet my great grandpa. But my grandpa told me a lot of his stories.

@dejanjovanovic2298

Жыл бұрын

Hah... It is not just cold what makes Russian winter, so special. there are even colder regions in the world. But what Canada can do in Russia, for instance. Canadians can't live without comfort, as well as americans. but imagine poverty during sharp winters. Imagine slushy and mudy roads, and all other issues that Russians had to deal with for centuries... that's what creates Russian "General Frost"

@chaindrive_blvd

Жыл бұрын

so i guess your great grampa changed his last name what was it before the change? I am just curious as I am second generation Greek Canadian as my dad was an immigrant

@joshuapeterson2232

Жыл бұрын

@@chaindrive_blvd his last name is Lirones. He is my maternal great grand father. My grandpa would tell me stories about him. There are a bunch of Lirones from around Mount Pleasant, Michigan. That’s where he settled when he came over. A bunch of them immigrated at different times. So there are many different spellings of the same name. My mothers maiden name is Lirones. But I’ve seen it spelled Lyronis, Lyrones, Lironis, etc

@anpu777sotomayor7

Жыл бұрын

And it could be apply in Ukraine right now!!!

@Qingeaton

Жыл бұрын

@@dejanjovanovic2298 We can live without comfort, we just choose not to.

Americans have all but forgotten about this (even back during Reagan's time it was barely remembered). But the Russians never forgot it.

@alexref955

Жыл бұрын

@Farmer Stole My Tank 2022 - Yeah, right

Can you talk about the Russian empire's contribution to the American civil war. It is another footnote in history but it's one nobody ever talks about

@woofkaf7724

Жыл бұрын

О таком "позоре" Запада говорить не принято.

@AntiFurry927

4 ай бұрын

@@woofkaf7724🤣🗽😘

Can you add more geographical diagrams to help illustrate the logistics of the battles? In general I think it would help this channel. Love your work.

@zahidkhan5733

Жыл бұрын

we will keep it in consideration, thank you

@DauthEldrvaria

Жыл бұрын

@@zahidkhan5733 don’t impersonate people

@zahidkhan5733

Жыл бұрын

@@DauthEldrvaria I'm the owner of this and 23 other channels thank you, I make my living off your and others eyeballs

@DauthEldrvaria

Жыл бұрын

@@zahidkhan5733 Fuck… Touché 🙏🏿🙏🏿 More power to you!

@timosauter975

Жыл бұрын

@@zahidkhan5733 I thought the same as Steven, would really help with such content. Overall I love these videos, very interesting stuff and well done.

one interesting story you might want to cover, is the so called "Murmansk legion". It was a British navy unit, fighting in the area against the invading Finnish whites, consisting of ex-red guard soldiers from Finland, who had just lost their civil war against the Finnish whites. They, and the escaped Finnish red guards in Karelia on the Soviet side of the border, are one of the reason why the last battles between the Finnish red and white guards were waged in the 1920s, despite the civil war ending in 1918

@Taistelukalkkuna

2 жыл бұрын

Wasn´t it British Army unit?

@cutekrizu8214

2 жыл бұрын

@@Taistelukalkkuna It was, but I am not 100% sure if it was officially that, or unit armed by the British. After the conflict, majority of them were transported to Britain where they continued to live, some for the rest of their lives, others moving to the united states or seeking a permission to return to Finland. Still, weather it was or not, I think an ex red guard unit, fighting against the Finnish whites under a British flag is an interesting prompt for a good story

@cjthebeesknees

2 жыл бұрын

@@cutekrizu8214 yes it is, very interesting indeed. Makes one wonder what was the British’s motivation or aims? I have a suspect in mind but this comment will likely be censored anyways. Thanks for the info my friend.

@ralepej

Жыл бұрын

It was pretty complicated (whole civil war was). British, Finnish Reds and Russian reds were against White Finns but same time British and White Russians were allied against Reds. And next year (1919) British Navy had base on Finnish soil against Red Russians.

@zahidkhan5733

Жыл бұрын

This video probably has the best comments section, learned as much as video.

This is not an accurate title - the US was part of the Allied intervention in the Russian Civil War - but it was at best a half hearted intervention. The US only contributed around 11,000 troops - which was less than 5 other nations

@BluemoonSpaceRock

Жыл бұрын

Let me guess, you’re saying this because you don’t like the fact that you can be called a hypocrite for condemning Russian aggression when America is the only one that has attacked Russian troops while being a foreign military in their land when Russia has never been in American land attacking American troops. That’s what this is about. Why else play semantics about it being called a invasion vs. a “intervention” or “expedition” Yet…when it’s Russia that backs separatists in Ukraine since 2014 and sends GRU/FSB units to help command, arm, and train rebel separatists it’s considered a Russian occupation & Russian invasions + occupation of Eastern Ukraine But when US troop “advisers” who engaged in combat & CIA Special Activities Division Paramilitary Officers were participating in backing and fighting with Contra Death Squad Rebels in Nicaragua and El Salvador and overthrow the Leftist Sandinista Government it’s not considered a US invasion of Nicaragua and El Salvador nor “American backed separatists or “Rebel held American foreign occupied territory” *Makes fun of Russia for calling it a military operation instead of invasion* *Simultaneously says things like “it’s not a US invasion, it’s a expedition “intervention”* Look, Anytime Foreign troops are in your land shooting people in your country while being across the globe from their nation, they’re invaders. That is the internal affairs of another nation. When the Communist Afghan Government requested the Soviet Union come in to help them repel the Mujahideen Islamic militants that began attacking Government forces and trying to overthrow the Afghan Government, the United States still referred to it as a soviet invasion despite the fact that the UN Charter internationally recognized Afghan Government requested the Soviet Union send their military in to help them repeal Mujahideen fighters As matter of fact, after the American backed Islamic Mujahideen militants (including Osama Bin Laden) successfully overthrew the Soviet Allied Afghan Government (After the USSR withdrawal) The United States and the rest of the world in the UN Charter never even recognized the subsequent Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan (Aka Taliban Government) Regime that took power in Kabul replacing the Soviet Allied Afghan Government. So America literally still recognized the coalition accord Government with the same Soviet Allied Afghan President that America had backed Islamic extremist to overthrow yet they stilled called it a Soviet Invasion So if you’re gonna call the Soviets entering Afghanistan a invasion then you can’t be a hypocrite and say Americans didn’t invade Russia during World War 1. As matter of fact, the Bolshevik and Reds were already the new Government officially in power in Saint Petersburg and Moscow & had signed a peace agreement to end participation in WW1 and remain neutral for the rest of the war The United States and British forces are the ones that invaded Russian territory to deny land for German forces and for their allied forces to be able to use it to launch offensives from while simultaneously backing the now overthrown and toppled absolute monarchy czarist forces and their loyalist that had already been deposed and overthrown and put out of power by the Russians who rose up to put them out Now if Russia would have “intervened” when Yanukovych was forcefully overthrown by a violent uprising and overthrow (Yes the Maidan by the end of it had turned from a peaceful protest to a violent and bloody clash between organized anti government street militants and insurrectionists throwing fire bombs at capital policemen, shooting capital security forces, and taking over government buildings) and if Yanukovych requested foreign “intervention” from Russia to come in and restore order after a new government commenced in Kyiv would that not be considered a invasion? Oh wait, that already happened and Americans called it a invasion after Yanukovych requested Russian troops to increase their levels in Crimea even before the annexation of Crimea! Don’t be a hypocrite then. That is the *INTERNAL AFFAIRS* of another nation. It is not another nations place to send their military in to the internal conflicts and internal affairs of another sovereign nation to influence a favorable outcome to who ends up in power subject to their national interests and interjecting their military to make it happen. If Russia was invited in by the rebels in the American civil war and Russian troops were killing The American soldiers who fought for the union side would you not consider that a foreign invasion despite the fact they were welcomed by other Americans who had no right to invite a foreign nation into the internal affairs of their nation? Of course you would, that is a invasion, don’t joke about Russia calling it a “military operation” if you’re gonna call it a “humanitarian intervention” or “expedition” while sending your military in to attack another nation in Russians in their land during WW1 You are equally using semantic word play just like Russia when they call their invasion a “military operation” Invasions aren’t contingent upon having 100,000 troops involved nor is it contingent upon thousands of tanks rolling across another nations borders blitzkrieg style. ANY event where foreign troops are sent in and attack another foreign nation is a invasion, period. It doesn’t matter if it’s only some American fighter jets and US military choppers carrying units of American special forces and supporting them with air strikes & recon for raids and drone warfare JTAGS that do extrajudicial killings. The US can’t decide to use drone military attacks or cruise missile strikes in the internal affairs of another nations militant factions just because our own Government designated them terrorists The Russian Government recognizes Right Sector and Azov as foreign terrorists organizations and Dmitry Yarosh publicly advocated in support of the jihadist terrorists attacks on subway trains in Russia So if Russia sent In cruise missiles and drones to blow up Dmitry Yarosh and Right Sector bases are you telling me America wouldn’t condemn them as a foreign invasion attack against another sovereign nation? Of course they would. Well same thing when America does extrajudicial killings against who we designate as foreign terrorists. For example the Yemeni Houthi Rebels that took power in the capital of Yemen are designated foreign terrorists, how is it America’s place to aid and support in the bombing and military forces attacking Yemeni’s in their own country fighting the internal affairs and internal conflicts of their own nation just because they are butt buddies with Saudi Arabia and Israel who want them dead because of their friendly relations with Iran? Iran is a enemy because they aren’t subservient to US national interests, Iran’s democratically elected leader was overthrown by the United States in a military coup and was replaced by the American installed U.S. puppet shah who was a brutal absolute monarch totalitarian that ruled over the Iranians and sold out their commodities and oil to American and British corporations at cheap and privatized prices, enriching himself at the expense of suffering Iranian people Ever since the Iranian Revolution of 1979 rose up and overthrow the US installed puppet shah, Iran has been a huge enemy of the US ever since, all because they have huge natural gas and oil reserves and they dared overthrow our puppet and nationalize the oil that went on to be BP oil. We later backed Iraq’s invasion and became best friends with Saddam, giving him weapons, targeting Intel, and Donald Rumsfeld even gave Saddam biological and chemical weapons to use against the Iranians as payback for them ousting our puppet, our goal was to have Saddam and Iraq’s military collapse the Iranian government so we could re-install a American puppet and privatize the oil and commodities again for America Iranians led by Khoemeni fought tooth and nail against Iraq though and prevented it from happening That’s why it’s so hypocritical that USA acts like we cared for Iraq invading sovereign nations during the gulf war, we have just gotten done being best friends with Iraq and overwhelmingly supporting their invasion of Iran like Saddam’s cheerleaders and providing them with everything they need to win line satellite Intel, weapons, and even CIA training The Gulf war had nothing to do with invasions, it had to do with Saddam having too much access to the earths oil supply and being a potential threat to Israel and Saudi Arabia which are US client states that America relies on for our national interests and use of petrodollars keeping the US dollar as the global reserve currency If the gulf war was truly about supporting international law and being anti invading nations, the USA wouldn’t have invaded Panama less than a year before Iraq invaded Kuwait We supported Iraq invading another nation just 2 years before the gulf war and we invaded another sovereign nation just the year prior to the gulf war

I'd love to hear Simon talk for 20 minutes about the history and tactics of the Whiskey War... a decades long conflict, still devoid of resolution.

@TonyDootjes

2 жыл бұрын

They just resolved that issue a few weeks ago, Canada and Denmark are now land neighbours.

@andersjjensen

2 жыл бұрын

Unless he describes each stone on the island individually there is simply not material to cover 20 minutes.

@Redwhiteandtired

Жыл бұрын

It has been decided just this year with Denmark getting roughly 65% of the island and Canada getting about 35%. As someone else stated they now officially share a land border.

@Pattern51lover

Жыл бұрын

I space out after hearing his voice for about 30 seconds… I’m always disappointed when I click on a video I think I’ll like and then his face pops up “Hi! I’m Simon Whistler!” (Just kill me know.. 🙄)

@andersjjensen

Жыл бұрын

@@Pattern51lover Then there's an easy solution for you: The "don't recommend channel" function. Simon is the only host on all of Simontube, so if you've seen him once on a channel, you know its Simontube.

The timeline in the intro is a bit wrong. The British landed in Murmansk already in March 1918, as opposed to July when the Americans joined the effort. The first battles were actually not even fought against the soviets, but Finnish paramilitary units in Pechenga. I wish you'd covered the British part of the Intervention, that would have included some cool things like the Kronstadt-raid and the aforementioned skirmishes with White Finns.

@warographics643

2 жыл бұрын

Sorry about that, and thank you for the correction :)

@Kap_Kay

2 жыл бұрын

@@warographics643 sounds like another cool video to aid you in your takeover of youtube...

@Oxtocoatl13

2 жыл бұрын

@@Kap_Kay I would be thrilled if they covered the Kronstadt raid.

@MrPrussianjester

2 жыл бұрын

@@warographics643 will there be a re-release of the video with corrections or a separate video?

@VeggieRice

Жыл бұрын

thanks for pointing this out respectfully. I wish Simon had peers to vet his research or scripts before posting vids. i've encountered more than one incongruence, which put me ill at ease vis a vis the rest of his seemingly well-produced content

Still learning more on your channels! Thanks for the info!

This is one of the reasons why I distrust the traditional education I recieved. Failure to inform me about this invasion made me question the motivations of - not the teachers - but those who dictate the curriculum.

@deaddocreallydeaddoc5244

4 ай бұрын

All "traditional" education is meant to be an overview. First through twelve grade education, especially history is merely an introduction. The hope of the educators was (before the Leftists took over) that this foundational education would create curiosity. I learned about this so-called "invasion" from a documentary series on WW1 decades ago. I also read about in my books on WW1. If you study history beyond HS, you learn such stuff. Delving into details like this sideshow would mean that the most critical history would have to be replaced by it. This has been done in fact, by Leftists such as Howard Zinn to demoralize youth and indoctrinate them, rather than educate them into a cynical view of Western history. The Allies were worried about communism and Bosheivism in particular and for good reason, as its history well illustrates. They were concerned with the stability of Russia. They soon learned that they could not make a difference. I think calling this adventure an "invasion" is sensationalizing an otherwise interesting, but inconsequential piece of history.

Yet another reason why Woodrow Wilson is one of the worst presidents ever.

@everburn

Жыл бұрын

Agreed

@castanedaalfredo9217

Жыл бұрын

Yuuuuup

@robertschrum5496

Жыл бұрын

Wilson was Boss Tweed's man.

@ryancoupland8425

Жыл бұрын

one out of a million reasons

@jacksontrevor191

Жыл бұрын

​@@everburn how is he different

Thank you for posting this. I had no idea about this action. I'm now going to look further into it. I love learning something new in history!

One interesting fact about this battle is that the American expeditionary troops were armed with American made mosin-nagant rifles. These were originally purchased by the Czar's government to supplement their own domestic production which could not keep up with war demand but were not able to be delivered. The American made mosins were made by Westinghouse and Remington. They were very unpopular with American soldiers who much preferred Springfield rifles. The thought process was that common ammunition with both red and white Russians would simplify logistics.

After seeing this video I hope you guys also cover the forgotten war between the Phiippines and US. For me its a forgotten history that is full of nationalism, betrayal, conquest and many more.

@Oxtocoatl13

2 жыл бұрын

Yep. Every time someone says America never had colonies I point them to the Philippines. That was a horrifically brutal war and occupation.

@klcs77

2 жыл бұрын

that story has much more truth to it than this one does. this is a narrative lacking important facts. What the US did there was shameful, yet remember the US unlike any other country is public about its shame, and there is a lot of shame.

@klcs77

2 жыл бұрын

@@Oxtocoatl13 the US did good and bad in the Philippines. I would point out that to this day the government of the Philippines does not have control of all of the islands it claims. Yes the US took many colonies from the Spain at the end of that war. As stated that history is very ugly for the US, but it is very ugly since the US left as well.

@mnemonija

Жыл бұрын

But mostly full of war crimes, so we don't really talk about it. It would illuminate however why the crowd goes into a frenzy whenever Duterte uses an expletive with USA.

@talisikid1618

Жыл бұрын

I’m beginning to see how jealous minor nations are. Too bad. The world would better off with that.

Another fascinating dive into history, Simon, but I really wish you would slow the speed of your delivery, Your rapid speech is at times incomprehensible .

I don't know how, but you 'got' me on this obscure tidbit of military history. 👏👏👏

I remember being an undergrad in a military history of the united states class and this venture into Russia was glossed over and surprised the hell out of me. Glad to see this video!!

@zahidkhan5733

Жыл бұрын

yupp, we never spent time on the interesting stuff.

@Chapaev-fu5un

Жыл бұрын

Я нисколько не удивлен

This is fascinating to learn about, having only recently found out from family that my great grandfather was a part of that Vladivostok expedition and survived a gunshot wound.

Thanks! Interesting and informative! i don't think I've ever heard of this before?

Thanks

Good video 👍

Not sure if more shocked to hear about this, or the fact that Simon has yet another channel.

@andyyang3029

2 жыл бұрын

Welcome 😎😎it's just a few months old

Thank you very much!

This was very interesting!

I really wish you would include more maps, and visible dates in these videos.

Crazy that this never gets talked abt… new battle unlocked

@simonkevnorris

2 жыл бұрын

Watch the Warren Beatty movie 'Reds' where there is mention of 12 foreign armies at one time. It's not a great movie but it is worth watching once. It's based on John Reed's experience there as a journalist. He also wrote the book 'Ten Days That Shook The World'.

I was aware of this because my grandfather’s friend participated in the expedition. I was a young child when heard about this for the first time. Thank you for the info.

I love your videos Simon

So awesome seeing the battalion I was with in the Army history. I was a polar bear from 2008 to 2011. I remember seeing newspaper clippings and other stuff on the battalion headquarters wall showing the units history.

@zahidkhan5733

Жыл бұрын

which side comrade?

Thanks for the great video. I have always wondered what Kolchack did before he hunted down werewolves and vampires.

excellent recovery of the lost story!

Nice cut

Simon is literally everywhere and its good.

0:50 - Chapter 1 - A rather confusion prologue 4:35 - Chapter 2 - Here come the bears 7:00 - Chapter 3 - The war drags on for the bears 8:40 - Chapter 4 - Mutiny ! (kind of) 11:20 - Chapter 5 - Eggs loaded with Dynamite 15:15 - Chapter 6 - More complications arise 18:10 - Chapter 7 - Warlords on a train 20:45 - Chapter 8 - An assessment

As an American, i find myself struggling to find a time when my country knew peace.

@Very_Nice_and_Polite_Person

Жыл бұрын

The U.S. has been at war for 92% of the entire country's existence, 228 out of 246 years since 1776. Truly insane to think about. Imagine if we spent all that time, resources, and money on our own country instead.

@L.J.Designs

Жыл бұрын

As a non American I struggle to find a modern war where America is not involved. And I tried not to be biased in any way. To be fair I struggle to see Europe, and USA (bonded by NATO) separate but hope things does not lead to a point that Europe and America will start to see each other as enemies similar as the US liberals and democrats do. Take care. Sincerely from a person having family in South Carolina.

@okakokakiev787

Жыл бұрын

America are Reptiloid

@mikeoneill655

Жыл бұрын

You struggle since it was only for about 30 years total out of the ca. 250 years of its existence that the USA has not been at war with someone somewhere around the world. And if of course it’s existence comes from the war of extermination of the indigenous population of the North American continent. The USA federal government is the global bully with arrogance and belligerence. And that’s from an Irishman with family, friends and colleagues in America.

@robinmangala3536

Жыл бұрын

Y’all are instigating almost every war

Very cool video, I think showing a map would've made it better though. Never knew this 🤘🇨🇦

I’d like to see a Warographics on the war on drugs in Mexico.

@robertoleary5470

2 жыл бұрын

Would love this

@pyromania1018

2 жыл бұрын

That sounds more like an "Into the Shadows" topic.

@jesusthugmusic

2 жыл бұрын

what war?? you mean the opiate epidemic they never slowed or the legal research chemicals they failed to keep out of peoples hands? thats how this fentanyl ordeal started. i know because i was the one blowing up the dea, fda and fbi about the selling of "legal" fentanyl under the name of research chemicals. i got like 3 sites shut down for ten more to pop up. they finally acted but it was too little too late.

@pulse3732

2 жыл бұрын

@@pyromania1018 Agree, would be a great video aswell

@thecrippledone3325

2 жыл бұрын

Nein

I think I saw an earlier documentary on this but your tutorial is more thorough. Yes this is not well known and the earlier documentary I saw You tube and the internet for public use didn’t exist at the time We need to remember why we get into conflicts no matter what the motivation is.

This should be a mini series.

PLEASE do a video in the whole civil war its so complex and wild I cant find any good videos on this

Glad you got rid of that harsh lighting, bud. Thanks for all you do!

My great, great grandfather fought in Archangel with the polar bear expedition, only learned about it via a genealogy test! Thanks for covering this!

I had previously heard about this when I watched Warren Beatty's movie Reds (when the movie was released back in 1981) that was based on John Read's experience there where it mentioned that there were 12 (?) foreign armies in Russia at one stage.

@wederMaxim

Жыл бұрын

14

Awesome video. Some maps would’ve helped

I've never ever heard about any of this. Fascinating

It would be helpful to show maps. I’m pretty good with Geography but still can’t really picture clearly where these operations occurred. Near Finland is my guess

Didn't help that the State Department was pro-intervention and countering the Bolsheviks whereas the War Department was advocating for strictly adhering to guarding the railroad and Allied war materiel and only fighting in self-defense. Also, Wilson being sidelined by his stroke didn't help with clarifying objectives, which inevitably led to the Secretary of State and Secretary of War jockeying to dominate policy interpretation. It was just a huge SNAFU for the AEF soldiers. Recommend checking out MG William Graves's memoir. It's free online.

@klcs77

2 жыл бұрын

silliness while we remember this as a white vs red. there were no less than 4 sides and the bolsheviks were the 3rd gov't to take over after the czar

@cjthebeesknees

2 жыл бұрын

We should of never been involved, wonder why the Cold War and Stalin was the way they were towards the West. We intervened and that’s a slight.

@monaliza3334

Жыл бұрын

​@@klcs77 Americans and their proxy .. White or red Russians would still kick your @ss..

Great coverage, but it seemed rather odd that a channel called Warographics didn't have any graphics that showed what was going on. Mostly just pictures of people.

Yup, I am aware of the events but you speak so fast I got little out of it. Thanks for the video though, great topic.

You should do an episode on the American soldiers who fought in the Spanish civil war of 1936

Please cover Operation Tripoli, it was the first American armed intervention in the Middle East following independence and the first time American marines saw combat ever.

Have you done one on the British intervention in Russia in 1918 as well? U.S. troops also fought with the British operating out of Archangel. Some of the histories can be found online on Project Gutenberg. Yes, I was well aware of this piece of U.S. military history long before I saw this.

@stendall

Жыл бұрын

Dozens of nations invaded Russia in 1919. The reason it's forgotten is because these weren't invasions of conquest. They were military interventions. None of those nations were trying to wipe Russia off the map. People say Russia has been invaded like 50 times in its history, but there are maybe 3 times when those invasions/incursions were an existential threat, and those are the ones that get highlighted when teaching history.

@maximtyo2625

Жыл бұрын

@@stendall True technically these may not be called "invasions of conquest". But you wrong in saying "those nations were not trying to wipe Russia off the map". How much territory Russia lost due to "military interventions"? How much more Russia would have lost if Reds did not fight against intervents? Even Whites would have fought against intervents if they did not lose to Bolsheviks. Both sides in Civil war had one thing in common - preservation territory of Russian Empire. The only difference was who would rule - Reds or Whites.

@BluemoonSpaceRock

Жыл бұрын

@@stendall Let me guess, you’re saying this because you don’t like the fact that you can be called a hypocrite for condemning Russian aggression when America is the only one that has attacked Russian troops while being a foreign military in their land when Russia has never been in American land attacking American troops. That’s what this is about. Why else play semantics about it being called a invasion vs. a “intervention” or “expedition” Yet…when it’s Russia that backs separatists in Ukraine since 2014 and sends GRU/FSB units to help command, arm, and train rebel separatists it’s considered a Russian occupation & Russian invasions + occupation of Eastern Ukraine But when US troop “advisers” who engaged in combat & CIA Special Activities Division Paramilitary Officers were participating in backing and fighting with Contra Death Squad Rebels in Nicaragua and El Salvador and overthrow the Leftist Sandinista Government it’s not considered a US invasion of Nicaragua and El Salvador nor “American backed separatists or “Rebel held American foreign occupied territory” *Makes fun of Russia for calling it a military operation instead of invasion* *Simultaneously says things like “it’s not a US invasion, it’s a expedition “intervention”* Look, Anytime Foreign troops are in your land shooting people in your country while being across the globe from their nation, they’re invaders. That is the internal affairs of another nation. When the Communist Afghan Government requested the Soviet Union come in to help them repel the Mujahideen Islamic militants that began attacking Government forces and trying to overthrow the Afghan Government, the United States still referred to it as a soviet invasion despite the fact that the UN Charter internationally recognized Afghan Government requested the Soviet Union send their military in to help them repeal Mujahideen fighters As matter of fact, after the American backed Islamic Mujahideen militants (including Osama Bin Laden) successfully overthrew the Soviet Allied Afghan Government (After the USSR withdrawal) The United States and the rest of the world in the UN Charter never even recognized the subsequent Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan (Aka Taliban Government) Regime that took power in Kabul replacing the Soviet Allied Afghan Government. So America literally still recognized the coalition accord Government with the same Soviet Allied Afghan President that America had backed Islamic extremist to overthrow yet they stilled called it a Soviet Invasion So if you’re gonna call the Soviets entering Afghanistan a invasion then you can’t be a hypocrite and say Americans didn’t invade Russia during World War 1. As matter of fact, the Bolshevik and Reds were already the new Government officially in power in Saint Petersburg and Moscow & had signed a peace agreement to end participation in WW1 and remain neutral for the rest of the war The United States and British forces are the ones that invaded Russian territory to deny land for German forces and for their allied forces to be able to use it to launch offensives from while simultaneously backing the now overthrown and toppled absolute monarchy czarist forces and their loyalist that had already been deposed and overthrown and put out of power by the Russians who rose up to put them out Now if Russia would have “intervened” when Yanukovych was forcefully overthrown by a violent uprising and overthrow (Yes the Maidan by the end of it had turned from a peaceful protest to a violent and bloody clash between organized anti government street militants and insurrectionists throwing fire bombs at capital policemen, shooting capital security forces, and taking over government buildings) and if Yanukovych requested foreign “intervention” from Russia to come in and restore order after a new government commenced in Kyiv would that not be considered a invasion? Oh wait, that already happened and Americans called it a invasion after Yanukovych requested Russian troops to increase their levels in Crimea even before the annexation of Crimea! Don’t be a hypocrite then. That is the *INTERNAL AFFAIRS* of another nation. It is not another nations place to send their military in to the internal conflicts and internal affairs of another sovereign nation to influence a favorable outcome to who ends up in power subject to their national interests and interjecting their military to make it happen. If Russia was invited in by the rebels in the American civil war and Russian troops were killing The American soldiers who fought for the union side would you not consider that a foreign invasion despite the fact they were welcomed by other Americans who had no right to invite a foreign nation into the internal affairs of their nation? Of course you would, that is a invasion, don’t joke about Russia calling it a “military operation” if you’re gonna call it a “humanitarian intervention” or “expedition” while sending your military in to attack another nation in Russians in their land during WW1 You are equally using semantic word play just like Russia when they call their invasion a “military operation” Invasions aren’t contingent upon having 100,000 troops involved nor is it contingent upon thousands of tanks rolling across another nations borders blitzkrieg style. ANY event where foreign troops are sent in and attack another foreign nation is a invasion, period. It doesn’t matter if it’s only some American fighter jets and US military choppers carrying units of American special forces and supporting them with air strikes & recon for raids and drone warfare JTAGS that do extrajudicial killings. The US can’t decide to use drone military attacks or cruise missile strikes in the internal affairs of another nations militant factions just because our own Government designated them terrorists The Russian Government recognizes Right Sector and Azov as foreign terrorists organizations and Dmitry Yarosh publicly advocated in support of the jihadist terrorists attacks on subway trains in Russia So if Russia sent In cruise missiles and drones to blow up Dmitry Yarosh and Right Sector bases are you telling me America wouldn’t condemn them as a foreign invasion attack against another sovereign nation? Of course they would. Well same thing when America does extrajudicial killings against who we designate as foreign terrorists. For example the Yemeni Houthi Rebels that took power in the capital of Yemen are designated foreign terrorists, how is it America’s place to aid and support in the bombing and military forces attacking Yemeni’s in their own country fighting the internal affairs and internal conflicts of their own nation just because they are butt buddies with Saudi Arabia and Israel who want them dead because of their friendly relations with Iran? Iran is a enemy because they aren’t subservient to US national interests, Iran’s democratically elected leader was overthrown by the United States in a military coup and was replaced by the American installed U.S. puppet shah who was a brutal absolute monarch totalitarian that ruled over the Iranians and sold out their commodities and oil to American and British corporations at cheap and privatized prices, enriching himself at the expense of suffering Iranian people Ever since the Iranian Revolution of 1979 rose up and overthrow the US installed puppet shah, Iran has been a huge enemy of the US ever since, all because they have huge natural gas and oil reserves and they dared overthrow our puppet and nationalize the oil that went on to be BP oil. We later backed Iraq’s invasion and became best friends with Saddam, giving him weapons, targeting Intel, and Donald Rumsfeld even gave Saddam biological and chemical weapons to use against the Iranians as payback for them ousting our puppet, our goal was to have Saddam and Iraq’s military collapse the Iranian government so we could re-install a American puppet and privatize the oil and commodities again for America Iranians led by Khoemeni fought tooth and nail against Iraq though and prevented it from happening That’s why it’s so hypocritical that USA acts like we cared for Iraq invading sovereign nations during the gulf war, we have just gotten done being best friends with Iraq and overwhelmingly supporting their invasion of Iran like Saddam’s cheerleaders and providing them with everything they need to win line satellite Intel, weapons, and even CIA training The Gulf war had nothing to do with invasions, it had to do with Saddam having too much access to the earths oil supply and being a potential threat to Israel and Saudi Arabia which are US client states that America relies on for our national interests and use of petrodollars keeping the US dollar as the global reserve currency If the gulf war was truly about supporting international law and being anti invading nations, the USA wouldn’t have invaded Panama less than a year before Iraq invaded Kuwait We supported Iraq invading another nation just 2 years before the gulf war and we invaded another sovereign nation just the year prior to the gulf war

I actually remember learning about the “Polar Bear Expedition” in high school. Not forgotten. We were backing the Minsheviks

Knew the Americans and Soviets were very close to fighting conventionally during the Cold War but didn't know they actually fought during WWI.

Mike Duncan did a "Revolutions" series on Russia and covers this timeline in excruciating detail if you're into that kind of thing.

I’d love to see a video on the US occupation of Haiti from 1915-34

I always knew this, I didn’t know this was “Forgotten”

I first read about this in a comic book when I was a pre- teenager. In the 1960s. It was a straightforward telling of the history, not a comic book version.

@elenagamora448

Жыл бұрын

It's sad that comic books are more informative than History text books

@beelz5932

2 ай бұрын

which comic?

@RicktheCrofter

2 ай бұрын

@@beelz5932 You’re asking me about a comic book I read over 50 years ago.

You know it's funny . This is the very first time I've ever heard this story. For some reason they skipped over this in American history class . They also don't tell us about the Japanese invasion of the Aleutian Islands . They usually don't mention we invaded Canada and lost in 1812 or whatever it was . They just cherry pick the best parts of history and try to Hollywood it up . It's no wonder so many of my fellow Americans consistently embarrass ourselves online 🤔

@cynthiasimpson931

2 жыл бұрын

I'd heard of the Japanese invasion and I'd heard how the U.S. invaded Canada during the 1812 war. This war I hadn't heard of.

@real.mir_

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly

@mnemonija

Жыл бұрын

yeah, its always wondering why would they not trust us, us the good guys, when we invaded them on the first day of their freedom from their emperor, trying to put the chains back on.

@darylgrimes2601

Жыл бұрын

@@mnemonija do you think the briish teach about their involvement? Do you think the finns teach about their involvement? It is the same everywhere in the world.

@darylgrimes2601

Жыл бұрын

do you think the briish teach about their involvement? Do you think the finns teach about their involvement? It is the same everywhere in the world.

Lol its this guy again! Bro is on that content grind

My great grandfather was part of the “Polar Bears” in Archangel. He was a machine gunner and apparently had some pretty wicked facial scars when he came back. Aside from commenting on the weather, which was colder than anything he’d experienced, he only said that he was “very lucky to be alive.”

At 14:47 Simon says"Vladivoscock".

This sounds like the ancestor of NATO only under a British command. Russia is a very difficult place to invade in any timeline as the French found out under Napoleon with their early easy victory.

Back about 1964 Petersen Publications 'Guns & Ammo' magazine ran a feature on this armed intervention involving a US veteran contributor who was actually there. He recounted that part of their mission involved laying track but the Unites States did not (as it's claimed in these comments) build the Trans Siberian Railway. This was completed years before and was a composite project funded by investors from several countries.

There is a monument to Michigan soldiers of the Polar Bears in Troy, Michigan, and there is a small military museum in Frankenmuth Michigan has a fairly good exhibit about the expedition in Northern Russia. Also, there is a chapter in Eugenie Fraser's A House By the Dvina that has some insight into the relations between Ms. Fraser's family and the US soldiers. There is also an article in the Historical Society of Michigan's Michigan History magazine in the early 2000s.

@PrimericanIdol

10 ай бұрын

There's a town named Fraser in Michigan. After this guy.

I used to have a 1891 Mosin-Nagant that was built by Winchester for the Tsar, unpaid for by the Bolsheviks and ultimately used to arm US troops sent to help the White Russians. My information is that the Doughboys that had trained on the Springfield and M1917 Enfield hated the Mosins. Possibly the origin of the description of the Mosin as the "garbage rod".

I served in the 2/27th 1987-1991 and we were expected to know a) that our unit participated in the AE forces in Siberia Russia b) our unit was called the Wolfhounds from this campaign and c) the mascot (Russian Wolfhound ofc)was named, at that time, Kolchak V

There is a great game about this time period called the last train home. Where you play as a group of the tchekoslovak legion moving along the grand siberian railway.

Thank you for the information. War did not end 1918, not taught in school

@jakerupp3840

Жыл бұрын

World war 1 did, Russian civil war did not, they overlap

Looks like instead of Tchaikovsky’s 1812 overture, there was Chaikovski’s 1918 overture to the Western allies

We have fought against Soviets, but not Russians.

@irustv7674

Жыл бұрын

lie, mass murderers of russians by Antanta - West invaders. No matter how you try to hide the crimes of your grandfathers and great-grandfathers against the Russians, you will not succeed and justice for their deeds will fall on the people of the West

@mtevilone

Жыл бұрын

@@irustv7674 You are a Putin propagandist. Russia would have been better off with anyone but a former KGB man. While he rakes in billions to line his pockets, the people in Russia start to do without. The genocide against Ukrainians, Georgians, and many others will guarantee him and his supporters eternity in Hell.

Unlike most, my high school history teacher covered this!!!!! I went to school in a different time though!

Odd that this video had not crossed my feed until now. Hmmmmm?

It’s easy to forget we did invade Russia in WW1.

How a warographics video on the battle of Madagascar in ww2, English civil wars of 1640s and battle of Trafalgar

Really good Lions Led by Donkeys podcast episode about this lol.

Just when you thought your knowledge of this was already extensive... 👌👍🏻

I'm ex US Army. Know quite a bit about the different conflicts the army has participated in. Never heard of this??? Thanks Simon.🙂✌️

@OP5redsolocup

2 жыл бұрын

Marine here- I’m sure the leadership in y’all’s version of TECOM probably has the same mindset: only teach the victories. If found myself teaching my Marines about the Second Battle of Fort Fisher (your guys won via land invasion, but our amphibious assault flopped) since nobody taught it.

@doobiejones9388

2 жыл бұрын

@@OP5redsolocup That totally makes sense. Sempre Fi. 😎

@ShawnJonesHellion

Жыл бұрын

Never know when they rewrote the past

My great uncle Walther was with the AEF that was sent to russia . I found videos of his unit along with other troops from England and France in archangel Russia.

@wat8437

Жыл бұрын

It'd be cool to watch them. Maybe digitize them if you can?

had no idea about this till I got to my unit.

A few years ago, Antique Road Show had a item there that from the AEF in Russia. It was an item that was made by an American soldier to remember there time in Russia

I had a great uncle Bob who was sent to Vladivostok to guard unused allied war supplies. I was told he was several years late in returning home from the war.

@blockededited8280

Жыл бұрын

Guard them? That's a 180° difference in how the current administration views our supplies.

@marklynch8781

Жыл бұрын

@@blockededited8280 Tend to agree, pointless in leaving billions of dollars in equipment behind. Plus all of my life I have had at least a mild interest in surplus materials, military, industrial, store etc..

Thank you Simon, appreciate hearing about Lenin and the Germans. More need to know.

@simonpierre8283

Жыл бұрын

Thanks

Dude how many channels have you got?

I didn't forget about it. The story was covered in an old American Heratige magazine I read years ago.

Too fast - way too fast. It was all interesting and I wanted to listen to every word. However, most of it was lost due to the speed.

@dsxa918

2 ай бұрын

Adapt the youtube speed to slow down, if that help

@dsxa918

2 ай бұрын

Adapt the youtube speed to slow down, if that help

@dsxa918

2 ай бұрын

Adapt the youtube speed to slow down, if that help

@dsxa918

2 ай бұрын

Adapt the youtube speed to slow down, if that help

My inner nerd and the former history student in me gets enthusiastic about this vid. Somewhat focused on the Russian civil war in my first writings.

why wont you include any maps? I still dont get what did the Murmansk expedition tried to secure, and it is hard to see where did that Czechoslovak legion tried to go to.

Sadly, even this wasn't taught to us students in 1990 (my Sophomore Year in High School) as I graduated in 1993.

A Mark II tank remained in my city after the intervention of the occupiers, now it stands as a monument

Grew up in Wisconsin. It does get to -40F during the winters occasionally. Living in a hotter climate now definitely isn't as nice as the cold. With the cold I can at least just put a heavier coat on and an extra pair of socks.

In Troy, Michigan (White Chapel Cemetary) there’s a Polar Bear monument with soldiers buried there from this event.

I’ve never heard of this