"When Australia went into World War 2, they had, apparently, a grand total of three submachineguns.-" Oh three models in their arsenal? That's not bad. "One was an MP18 in a museum, one was a Thompson submachinegun that a captain brought back, and one was an MP38 confiscated by customs." Oh.... you meant literally three SMGs....

@somberyu

4 жыл бұрын

My thoughts exactly.

@thedirector1378

4 жыл бұрын

Same lol

@matthewtscott1

4 жыл бұрын

It's true, while we had some heavy machine guns leftover from the 2nd world war, no development had continued in Australia on improving our military assets up until the threat of Japanese invasion. In fact we didn't even take the threat seriously until the Japanese where on our doorstep in Papua New guinea.

@gastonbell108

4 жыл бұрын

"30 Years of Electricity"

@Frombie_01

4 жыл бұрын

@@matthewtscott1 "In fact we didn't even take the threat seriously until the Japanese where on our doorstep in Papua New guinea. " The threat was taken very seriously, just not by some. Churchill declared that Australia could fall and the English would get it back after the German were defeated. John Curtin argued that Australia's defense was paramount. Churchill thought it was ungrateful, impudent and highlighted innate “Australasian anxieties”. Roosevelt thought that Curtin's argument “tasted of panic and disloyalty”(this is after Pearl Harbour). Even after the fall of Hong Kong, The Philippines and Singapore, Churchill still refused to release the Australian 6th and 7th Divisions from the Middle East. Thankfully, Curtin persisted against Churchil's and Roosevelt's strategy to "defeat Hitler first" and brought Australian troops home to defend Australia and the Pacific. Mathew, maybe you should study Australian history and politics a little more, before indulging your ignorance and rubishing Australia and your fellow Australians.

When he said they had three SMGs, I first thought they had three types in service.

@Dreska_

4 жыл бұрын

well, technically we did!

@liddz434

4 жыл бұрын

Lol, yeah, me too! Didn’t realise he meant literally!🤣😭😱

@curiousrelic

4 жыл бұрын

Same here

@Dreska_

4 жыл бұрын

@@Galf506 public service!

@arachnonixon

4 жыл бұрын

reminds me of Flight of the Concords, when Murphy remarks that "well, we've got the one gun, but the army's using that".

"The Austen stock is much more complicated to produce." Yes but the sten stock is made entirely of sharp edges and sadness.

@AM-hf9kk

4 жыл бұрын

I thought the "die casting expertise... or rather experience" would result in more than ONE PIECE being cast. How hard would it be to cast a simple one-piece stock?

@alganhar1

4 жыл бұрын

@@AM-hf9kk Very, in fact I would got as far as to say trying to cast one piece stock would be an exercise in stupidity, especially in the 40's. Casting is great for large pieces like armour plate, say the transmission cover, front glacis plate and turret pieces of the M4 Sherman, but for small, complex pieces with lots of tubes and bends like a stock? You are throwing good money after bad. The only way you are going to get good reliable complex castings like a stock is probably the lost wax casting method, and that is a method of production more suitable to artists or jewellers (my casting experience comes from the latter), not mass manufacture of 'cheap' SMG's. This is before you consider that after casting you then have to 'finish' the cast, so remove sprue etc, and then you have to machine in various parts of that stock. The ones that spring to mind are the catch system to attach stock to the receiver (has moving parts, they need to be manufactured and fit seperately), and machining out the wells for the screwdriver and cleaning rod as you are NOT going to try casting a hollow tube! Believe me, it would be much easier and a LOT cheaper simply stamping or pressing the various parts and welding them together. Casting had its place in the weapons of the 1940's, but SMG stocks was not that place!

@AM-hf9kk

4 жыл бұрын

@@alganhar1 I agree that this catastrophe would be a bitch to cast. But the cheap simple version wouldn't have any of the odd features. It could be a single part with two flats and a hole to pivot on a bolt in a simple bracket, allowing it fold fold beside the action instead of around the mag and grip. Outside of the pivot area the sprue wouldn't matter at all and there would be no finishing work. It might run slightly heavier and uglier, but who cares? It's designed to be a quick, cheap, disposable weapon in desperate times.

@alganhar1

4 жыл бұрын

@@AM-hf9kk Maybe, but you are still better off just stamping or pressing tubular steel, it is faster, cheaper, and uses less material than casting. The only way you are going to get an effective cast is to move to a flat casting rather than a cylinder design, sort of like an I beam type arrangement. Even so, for this type of thing stamping/pressing is simply more efficient. Casting takes time, you have to regulate the pour, you have to ensure there is no bubble formation (which will seriously weaken if not outright ruin the cast), and you have to wait for it to cool. Then of course you have to clean it up. With pressed/stamped pieces you can make those pieces far, far faster, and simply weld them together. Clean up is as simple as sanding or grinding down the sharp edges and you are good to go. As I said, casting did and does have its place, but there are reasons it is generally not a method used in the mass production of metal items, especially small ones. Stamping and pressing are simply cheaper, faster and usually use less material.

@francesconicoletti2547

4 жыл бұрын

alganhar1 you’re assuming there was a high throughput stamping press available in wartime Australia to make SMGs. Australia didn’t have a car industry until after the war. We were eating up industrial resources by doing things like trying to turn out our own fighters from modifying Trainer designs. Just sticking a wooden stock on the thing would probably have matched our available technology better.

Germany: "Guten tag!" Australia: "You blokes are ages away! No worries!" Japan: "Konnichiwa!" Australia: "CRIKEY!"

@user-bg3tn4xv3i

4 жыл бұрын

That actually made me lol

@JonJon-wi2dh

4 жыл бұрын

Nice

@rhys3350

4 жыл бұрын

As an Aussie, that was really funny.

@kestrel4077

3 жыл бұрын

Can't help but hear "crikey" in Steve Irwins voice.

@joshmaher1403

3 жыл бұрын

Shit that’s funny

Thinking they can improve the Sten? Austentatious.

@jameslines6200

4 жыл бұрын

👏👏👏 Comments winner right here lads! Pure class. Bad Tanker, I doff my hat to you sir.

@johnnytrigger5512

4 жыл бұрын

Brillient 1🤣🤣🤣🤨

@hanisk2

3 жыл бұрын

Genius.

@somerandomdudeable

2 жыл бұрын

Ohhhhh, Austen is short for "Australian Sten"

How many smgs do we have? Three sir! Three what? hundred? thousand? No sir , only three one in a museum one in private ownership and another was confiscated by the authorities at the port. Some guys must have had pretty strong headaches for a while.

@KuraIthys

4 жыл бұрын

Well, I mean, what do you really expect for a country that doesn't have an extensive history of private gun ownership, AND up to WW2 has literally never actually had to defend itself from well... Anything? I mean, pretty much every battle Australians have ever been in has been on foreign soil, and more often than not for the sake of defending an ally, not ourselves...

@gergokerekes4550

4 жыл бұрын

@@KuraIthys Yeah smg and rifle bullets do not do much aganist spiders or snakes so i understand that you needed none of them. joking aside you got a pretty gun up in a rather quick time with the owen.

@gergokerekes4550

4 жыл бұрын

@@0neDoomedSpaceMarine yeah i saw that "tank" that they had made as a stop gap mesure it looks fun like the ones i drew when i was a kid. But if you have jack shit and the enemy is at the porch you toss the shit in his face , it might work or slow him down.

@gergokerekes4550

4 жыл бұрын

@Billy sorry i was thinking about the bob semple but i now look it up and it was new zealand design

@thesturm8686

4 жыл бұрын

@Billy i mean, you probably could penetrate japanese tanks with machineguns and their asian wide conscripts aint gonna do much either

Gonna need a follow-up on the story of that rouge MP38.

@fetishartist137

4 жыл бұрын

Dark Docs would have to cover that. Maybe Ian and Dark 5 could collaborate

@ahorsewithnoname643

4 жыл бұрын

Have you seen that MP38? I know the Aussies painted the Owen in camouflage colours but who would paint a MP38 rouge?

@John-un3lj

4 жыл бұрын

@@ahorsewithnoname643 Not as in colour. Rouge as in shady, off-the-grid, spy-hush-hush-business.

@John-un3lj

4 жыл бұрын

Just realized I spelled it wrong. Mah baedz.

@ahorsewithnoname643

4 жыл бұрын

@@John-un3lj Did you go a bit rogue ?🙂🤗

Why is it that every Australian gun was designed on a napkin, as a dare, and then when asked whether "the new submachine gun design was ready", they told their boss "nah yeah she'll be right"..

@andreahighsides7756

4 жыл бұрын

Liamv4696 whats funny is their best submachine gun from this era was designed by a teenager, the Owen smg. edit: Oops, he was a young man not a boy, 22 iirc.

@allangibson8494

4 жыл бұрын

@@andreahighsides7756 On a napkin at home....

@michaeldanks5975

4 жыл бұрын

Don't you mean beer coaster?

@michaelscott8567

4 жыл бұрын

@@andreahighsides7756 It wasn't just "their" best. It was the best smg of the war.

@andreahighsides7756

4 жыл бұрын

michael scott Yes good point! Still used in Vietnam like the grease gun

You'd think it would be impossible to make the Sten Mk 1 any worse. Instead, they took away the one good thing about the Sten, the fact that it was cheap. Quite impressive.

@zxbzxbzxb1

4 жыл бұрын

I guess it seemed like a good idea after 24 cans of Fosters...

@zxbzxbzxb1

4 жыл бұрын

@UC0cCf-YP5pY870l0XKBn2sQ sold to us gormless poms to get mashed on whilst teetotal Ozzie-land produces a race of cricketing super humans like Steve Smith to keep our ashes for the rest of eternity 😆

@ajvanmarle

4 жыл бұрын

@@0neDoomedSpaceMarine Agreed, which is what makes it so sad. If they'd just limited themselves to welding on a couple of simple pistol grips, they would have made a major improvement for minimum costs.

@SeizureSpecialist

4 жыл бұрын

ZB6 uk Aussies don’t drink fosters.

@mr_terminator5864

4 жыл бұрын

Do you mean the mk1* or mk2/3? At least the mk1 had a flash hider and grip

The mk 2 austen looks like a 1990's tippman paintball gun

@bensevrywere

4 жыл бұрын

98 custom*

@esrvdb88

4 жыл бұрын

@@bensevrywere The earlier ones were just marked "Tippmann 98" the 98 customs came a bit later with some revisions, kinda a 98A1

@edwalmsley1401

4 жыл бұрын

@@esrvdb88 that what I have,98 custom,been gathering dust for almost 20 years 😂😂

@JunkyardBashSteve

4 жыл бұрын

God forbid someone rigs a large optic on to it, then it'd just look like the paintball hopper xD

@ExplosiveWeaponForum

4 жыл бұрын

look at a tippmann SMG 60 i have one shooting on my channel it looks like a sten with a cast recevier

Blue gloves, for when you have a gun video at 10 and a colonoscopy at noon.

@oneproudbrowncoat

4 жыл бұрын

Two by two...

@Pijawek

4 жыл бұрын

Hands of blue

@jonathangriffiths2499

4 жыл бұрын

No chance of combined the two together with the current barrel fitted ?

@alltat

4 жыл бұрын

They're common in biochemistry, so maybe he'll be looking at biological weapons next?

@diamondflaw

4 жыл бұрын

Just..... try to... relax.

Yep and only one bullet shared across all 3 machine guns. It was the wrong caliber for all of them but we made do.

@proonguice8386

4 жыл бұрын

I’ve heard throwing the actual machine gun might disable someone long enough to run away but only if you make a precision hit on their funny-bone or eye.

Took me a minute to realize that it stood for Australian Sten and wasn't just named after some dude named Austin.

@vaclav_fejt

4 жыл бұрын

Jane Austen - Pride and Extreme Prejudice.

"The Sten gun is able to be produced quickly, simply and cheaply... but don't worry, we can fix all those problems!"

That putting "Austen" in quotes is still something they do today, the Steyr AUG is designated the F88 "Austeyr"

@staryoshi06

4 жыл бұрын

pretty sure we use the F90 now though

Ian self corrects from “Mel-born” to “Mel-burn”... good on ya mate

@aussiebloke609

4 жыл бұрын

I prefer to describe the pronunciation as "Mel-b'n"...but yeah, that was a good effort from GJ. :-)

@70zenboy

4 жыл бұрын

Was waiting for melbs. 😂

@darwinchevalier

4 жыл бұрын

@@70zenboy good effort and good info on the Austen..

@TonkarzOfSolSystem

4 жыл бұрын

It's pronounced "Mel-bourne". The r is hidden in the Australia accent which puts r's everywhere.

@SaulKopfenjager

4 жыл бұрын

@@TonkarzOfSolSystem It's the "O" that is hidden, which the Aussie accent puts everywhere mate-i-o

"The Germans aren't going to invade Australia" *laughs in HOI4*

@clongshanks5206

4 жыл бұрын

I just got done island-hopping as commie Anzacs lol I forgot how crappy their population was

@SirDankleberry

3 жыл бұрын

*Laughs in Scrap Iron Flotila*

@347Jimmy

3 ай бұрын

Even more laughable is the idea of Germany invading Australia in WWI But the propaganda posters all said it was going to happen

I can imagine the Australian military watching this video and just thinking to themselves "Shit. We forgot one."

“the diggers dismay” sounds like the name for a TF2 weapon.

@itsconnorstime

4 жыл бұрын

This could be a skin for the Snipers smg.

@KingEddo8

4 жыл бұрын

Snipers new sub confirmed.

@thatguybrody4819

4 жыл бұрын

sounds like a new spade for soldier.

The only thing you'd need to add onto a Sten gun to improve it, was a proper grip and a front handguard. That's it.

@nutsandgum

4 жыл бұрын

It wasnt particularly reliable due to its magazine and feeding system as well.

@calvingreene90

4 жыл бұрын

@@nutsandgum Stop using the magazine as a handgrip and the reliability is greatly improved.

@calvingreene90

4 жыл бұрын

The sten gun needed better steel as well.

@JS-ob4oh

4 жыл бұрын

@@calvingreene90 Bullshit. The magazine is based on the same German design that was also used by the MP-40 and caused the same problems. Only a desperate nation would adopt it and only an idiot would call it reliable.

@joshuahadams

Жыл бұрын

Carve out a nice piece of wood to seat it in and get some stain and lacquer for it.

I was almost 4 minutes in before I figured out "Austen" wasn't someone's name. I'm an idiot.

@Arbiter099

4 жыл бұрын

Not too much of a stretch to think it stood for AU Sten or Australian Sten

@larrygilbert7273

4 жыл бұрын

@@Arbiter099 I know, right?! That's why I felt like a dope! Guess I'm not stretch enough.

@fred4089

4 жыл бұрын

Awful sten.

@GruntyGame

4 жыл бұрын

Now you know for if you see someone talking about an Austeyr.

@sillydude17

4 жыл бұрын

Took me the whole video. Kept thinking 'Austin' sounds much more like an american name, palm met my face quickly after.

There was a lot of MP18’s floating around the place, the 1st AIF stole everything not bolted down 👌

Evolution of the STEN SMG based gun in simplicity: Plumbers Competition

@allangibson2408

3 жыл бұрын

The Sten was called the plumbers nightmare. The Austen was built by plumbers suppliers.

When Churchill called for the formation of the commandos in 1940 there was only 40 Thompson subguns in all of Britain.

How to improve on the Sten for real this time. Just put on the handgrips from the Austen on a Sten. Good enouf and the troops will thank you. None of the other stuff was really needed.

@pelao824

4 жыл бұрын

I *think* one mark of the canadian sten had it (at least the foregrip) (Edit) only postwar, but stens with pistol and fore grips were fielded by the british in 1944 (Mk.V)

@StacheMan26

4 жыл бұрын

Don't even bother lengthening the receiver, just weld the handgrip to the stock in place of the anotamically impossible to grasp rib thingy

@clongshanks5206

4 жыл бұрын

pelao824 didn’t the Mk V have problems?

The fact that Gun Jesus can pronounce Melbourne correctly is a testament to his power. I honestly can't think of a single time an American youtuber has stopped and corrected in that way. Respect

@SaulKopfenjager

4 жыл бұрын

But Ian did still first mis-pronounce it for the "American" audiences there, but it was at least a super fast correction to proper pronunciation of my home city name; MEL-BURN!

@IncredibleMD

3 жыл бұрын

@@SaulKopfenjager You pronounce your home city's name wrong.

@donjones4719

3 жыл бұрын

@@SaulKopfenjager Yes, I think Ian did deliberately mispronounce the name so people could find it on a map.

@markfryer9880

3 жыл бұрын

@@IncredibleMD How Dare you say such a thing about a fellow Melbournian!

@markfryer9880

3 жыл бұрын

Given the number of Yanks that came to Melbourne during WWII, you would think that more Americans could pronounce it correctly.

"Die-cast construction. It's a lost art."

@Panzerkampfpony

4 жыл бұрын

Beast Wars?

@itatane

4 жыл бұрын

Loved that show, there were so many inside jokes and quotable moments. Yessss.

@astondriver

4 жыл бұрын

A gazillion match box cars use die casting. It was the forerunner of injection moulded plastics.

As someone that has an Austen Mk 1 I have to agree with everything you said about it with the exception of two points. 1. The length of pull is actually ok...unless you are a hobbit. 2. It is a much better weapon than the Sten. Over engineered...yes. Not as suited to mass production as the authorities had hoped (which goes hand in hand with over engineered)...yes. Totally and unequivocally outclassed in every way by the Owen...yes. But still better than the Sten.

@lazzie7495

Жыл бұрын

I mean, the sten wasn't supposed to be a good gun. It was supposed to be a gun that you could shove into every grubby hand as quickly as possible. Subtracting from the latter element means your just making a worse 1918.

"But he had not that supreme gift of the artist, the knowledge of when to stop." (Sherlock Holmes, "The Adventure of the Norwood Builder") Jonas Oldacre had something in common with a lot of firearms designers.

My dad always said that when they took away his Thompson and gave him a Sten he was less than impressed (especially since he had to wrap the punched metal ‘handgrip thing’ with insulating tape to avoid being cut by it)!

I'd still pronounce it "Aus-Sten".

There is a interesting story in Laurence Hartnett's memoirs. Laurence Hartnett was the Director of Australian Ordnance Production. He visited General Marshall, Chief of Staff of the US Military in Washington during WW2. Laurence Hartnett carried his briefcase into the General's office and took out a Austen SMG to demonstrate Australia's capabilities in manufacturing. Laurence Hartnett remarked that none of the military guarding General Marshall bothered to check his briefcase.

As an Australian, I appreciate the correction of Melbourne :). Love your videos Ian, your attention to detail and history of the featured weapon is amazing.

@AR15andGOD

Жыл бұрын

Well considering it's spelled bourne and not burn and given Americans don't usually interact with australians, it's perfectly understandable that this would happen. Not to mention the obvious dis ingenuity going on here, where you refuse to acknowledge the fact that the "proper" pronuncuation stems from your accent of shortening the "our" syllable in "bourne".

6:38 The relevance of tools for maintainability - remember an Australian weapon was probably going to be used in more remote areas, (jungle, bush or the outback) rather than an urban fighting Sten.

@klausbrinck2137

3 жыл бұрын

There wasn´t such thing as an "urban fighting Sten"! Remember, Berlin was taken by the Soviets, not by the Brits...

@rynehall9990

2 жыл бұрын

Agreed..the entire maintenance kit should have been hidden inside the weapon

So basically, they only had three smgs, and all of them were effectively stolen. How Australian

@corysanderson6177

3 жыл бұрын

nani?

@Goannadria

3 жыл бұрын

Considering the Australian units in North Africa were nicknamed the "Thirty Thousand Thieves", and would just about routinely break into and ransack their allies' supply depots... yep, very Australian.

@PhoenixOfArcadia

3 жыл бұрын

@@Goannadria Or the fact that the only surviving German A7V tank is in Australia because some of their soldiers saw it sitting abandoned in No Man's Land and they decided "hey, you see that abandoned tank out there? We wanna steal it."

@neilhamill318

3 жыл бұрын

@@PhoenixOfArcadia Unlike the U.S. that returned home from Japan after WW2 with many borrowed samurai katanas

@schrodingersgat4344

Жыл бұрын

Two were sent there for "Buggery".

Oh my god the fading cut at 5:40 is perfect. The Sten turns into a ghost and disappears.

Ian, you're a legend mate! You will probably never read this a the video is a few year old but as an Australian lad I appreciate you bringing our weapons history manufacturing up and making vids about it. Keep up the great work!!

You almost butchered "Melbourne"… But you were quick to get it right! Hats off

@KingdomOfApple

4 жыл бұрын

I was mid-shudder when he corrected it. So very relieved...

@mufflersponge8969

3 жыл бұрын

He still didn’t get it right Mel-bin

One of the happiest moments in the past few years was when I got a reply from Ian. He posted a photo of the Austen trigger housing and I was the first comment that properly guessed that it was from this gun :)

The Brits had a saying back in the day... "The more you overthink the plumbing, the easier it is to stop up the drain." Hmmm... 🤔

@owen368

4 жыл бұрын

So thats were Chief Montgomery Scott got that from

Great Video, I'm an Australian and a military enthusiast and I e never even heard of this gun. Thank you Forgotten Weapons

This thing is so strange to me, they completely missed the entire point of the STEN guns existence in the first place.

@mr_terminator5864

4 жыл бұрын

Well, the Australians probably thought fewer but better smgs was better than worse but more smgs

@allangibson2408

3 жыл бұрын

The Australian Army likes guns that just work. The Sten didn’t.

Looks like something the British would take over their own Stens, at least before the Mk V came on Also, does the Owen also take mags from the MP 28 / Lanchester, Sten and The MP40? Or at least can accept their mag well to replace it?

@Zretgul_timerunner

4 жыл бұрын

"Yes" does it work equally good with said mags who the hell knows.

@andrewholdaway813

4 жыл бұрын

Not sure why you think we'd take it over the sten, since it's a worse performing gun. It actually looks like a sten might have before we threw all the fancy bits away to make it more quickly and cheaply

@Tiger351

4 жыл бұрын

As far as I'm aware the Owen had its own proprietary mags, there was a protrusion on the rear of the mag which acted as the ejector for the gun.

@TheDeadfast

4 жыл бұрын

@@andrewholdaway813 The Austen does have the distinct advantage of being able to be held though.

@andrewholdaway813

4 жыл бұрын

@@TheDeadfast Not a huge advantage if it doesn't work though

Another wonderful presentation, been a military historian for decades, mainly WW2 Commonwealth subjects and your programmes have revealed and explained so much to me. Thanks

Ian, what you have to understand about the Australian soldier is that he is an avid collector of souvenirs. The inclusion of a screwdriver into the design was a specific request from experienced frontline diggers. Where in the past the digger would steal anything that wasn't screwed down, he would now face no such limitation to his light-fingered activities. I hope this helps.

"How many SMG's do we have?" "Three." "Threeee...?" "Three." "Right but three *what*?" "Just three."

@ZGryphon

4 жыл бұрын

"... Bugga."

Thanks for covering this Aussie weapon Ian. As a former member of the Australian Army Reserve (89-91, 92-94) I had heard of the Owen Gun but I had no idea about the Austin. Incidentally, my first unit was a Regular Sigs Unit with Ares cell, and we had SLRs, F-1s, and 7.62 mm rebarreled Brens as our light support weapon.

They didn't think they were improving the gun, they thought they'd found a way to make it more complex to make more money.

1:18 I first thought "Three types of submachine guns? That's not too bad, maybe they can refine one of them like the Lanchester and Sten..." Then I realized he meant they had exactly THREE submachine guns in the entire country.

Weapon design failure : the whole point of the Sten was " do you want a gun that works now or take the chance on a better gun when it may be too late ?"

@allangibson2408

3 жыл бұрын

The Sten didn’t work in Australian trials. Hence the Austen that did.

I know an Australian soldier (LIonel Smith of he 2/14 battalion) who went to serve in the middle east prior to Japan entering the war, picked up a Thompson from a wounded British soldier and brought it back to fight the Japanese in New Guinea in 1942. Decades later he went to the opening of a memorial on the Kokoda track and mentioned how he had lost his haversack with shaving kit and extra magazines near a big rock where he had been firing somewhere nearby. A local lad asked for a few details, disappeared and came back with the pack and the somewhat rusty artefacts still in it. The Thompson was a heavy weapon to carry. Another member of the Battalion (can't recall his name now),covered his mates while they were withdrawing from an exposed position and held off the Japanese with a Bren gun under one arm and a Thompson under the other. One Japanse got close enough to grasp at his ammunition pouches. He was awarded the DCM. You don't get the VC for fighting withdrawals it seems. Another battalion member Bruce Kingsbury charged a group of Japanese who were about to overrun the headquarters and threaten the position at isurava and scattered them with a Bren gun as he was running at them, but was shot by a sniper when he paused for breath when he had seen them off. He was awarded a posthumous VC. There is footage from that campaign with other diggers using Thompsons in Damien Parer's Oscar winning documentary Kokoda Front Line.

Sounds like the Aussies did as good of a job on the Sten as Homer Simpson did on the Everyman car.

Which came first, the mp-38 or the telescoping toilet paper holder? The resemblance is uncanny!

@korbetthein3072

4 жыл бұрын

I'm serious though, it's actually starting to bug me!

I just want to see a shooting comparative between a STEN, a AUSTEN and a MP3008 somewhere in the future.

@mr_terminator5864

4 жыл бұрын

That would be at least 1000 years away

10,000 (10K) Austen MK.1's made. About 10 Mk.2's. According to some books, the UK did NOT send a full set of drawings for the Sten to Australia, or 9mm rounds for that matter, much of the information came from captured Italian/German gear from Nth Africa or 'liberated' British material - Original WW2 Aussie 9mm looks like Italian or German rounds for instance. The production engineering for the Austen was from automotive parts suppliers, encouraged by the Minister for Production(?) who had worked as an engineer for GM Australia. The Owen was made by Lysaughts who made industrial piping - different companies, different solutions. Lots of dodgy Political infighting involed in the production of both guns. Wonder if Ian can find one of the 08/15 Maxim conversions to .303 done in Australia as emergency substitutes for Vickers.

@gary1477

Жыл бұрын

Laurence Hartnett was the Director of Australian Ordnance Production in WW2. He was also the head of GM Australia. In his memoirs, he mentioned that Diecasters in Melbourne were anxious to manufacture and design weapons. They had never manufactured and designed weapons before. General Blamey head of land forces in the SW Pacific was completely opposed to the Owen SMG. Hartnett agreed to use Diecasters, as using Diecasters did not take away any capacity from Lysaghts (manufacturer of the Owen SMG) or SAF Lithgow (manufacturer of the SMLE and Vickers MG).

So glad that he corrected himself on the way to say Melbourne

So, basically, we took a Sten and made it better in every way. Gotcha. This Aussie thanks you for your service..

@repletereplete8002

4 жыл бұрын

Except they made it worse in nearly every way. The corks on a string flotation device was a good idea though if it was fumbled whilst drunk and dropped in a billabong;]

@DBCisco

4 жыл бұрын

Odd that he only talks about the extra tooling but not why this is "worse" than a Sten nor how it was "unreliable". Seems the Thompson is junk based on his "rules".

@jameshealy4594

4 жыл бұрын

From what I understand the Thompson is junk, especially by WW2. Heavy, expensive, not especially controllable, nightmare reloads etc. I know it's an icon but it seems that is at least partly based on cool points. *Edited to change "unreliable" to "expensive" as that's what I meant to write. As far as I know they were at least relatively reliable.

@DBCisco

4 жыл бұрын

@@jameshealy4594 How is it "junk" ? I can say the same thing about an M-16.

@TheCheat_1337

4 жыл бұрын

Because it was very heavy and expensive to manufacture. The M16 had problems early on but they fixed those, and on paper it's one of the best small arms - it's very accurate for a service rifle, it's light, you can carry a lot of ammo, and production techniques were advanced enough 20 years later (and especially now) that cost isn't nearly as much of an issue as it was back in the 20s - 40s for the Thompson. A modern stock standard M16 or AR15 is far cheaper than the Thompson.

Manufarcturers: we have an improved STEN! Australian army: it's the same gun, but more expensive Manufacturers: OH, wait, you think it was improved *for you* ? 0_o

I love that you corrected yourself when you said Melbourne.

3:14 Corrects himself and pronounces Melbourne properly! Well done! Its actually quite impressive.

@AR15andGOD

Жыл бұрын

Well considering it's spelled bourne and not burn and given Americans don't usually interact with australians, it's perfectly understandable that this would happen. Not to mention the obvious dis ingenuity going on here, where you refuse to acknowledge the fact that the "proper" pronuncuation stems from your accent of shortening the "our" syllable in "bourne".

@rosscof3660

Жыл бұрын

neckbeard

I'd argue that the advantages of the sten being quick and easy to produce aren't so advantageous to a place like Australia. They needed guns yeah, but they also weren't burning through guns due to combat. I'd say the austen was a product of a somewhat proven (and only) design they had to go off of with some improvements and that's all it had to be

Yet another great gun to base a blaster on, thank you again Ian!

Honestly love your work and it’s only gotten better recently. Keep up the good work Ian

3:13. ooh you almost got me there but you saved it at the last second. top stuff

Australia: well Germany cant invade us Japan: no they cant...

@allangibson2408

3 жыл бұрын

Australia: You can’t either...

Yeah pistol grips and fancy folding stocks are nice and all but they clearly missed the whole point of the Sten. Also I love that those manufacturers in Melbourne and Sydney were basically outdone by some kid in his shed.

There was a die cast loading tool for the Austen magazines. They are pretty nice.

Z and M force used these until the end of the war. 1st Parachute Battalion were also issued Austens. Nevermind that the 1st Parachute Battalion never deployed, but they were issued Austens.

"Oi mate, how many of them SMGs do we have at our disposal?" - "3." "...as in three hundred, or three thousand?" - "No. Just 3." That's either the most hilarious or most terrifying thing an army commander could probably hear.

Later developed into the "Stone Cold" Austen Mk. 3.16. Looking forward to that video.

@JonJon-wi2dh

4 жыл бұрын

Nice. Thanks for that

If you went into military disposal stores here in Australia in the 70s you could buy pieces of Austens for a few bucks. Mainly pistol grips.

The length of pull wasn't too long for us tall Aussies! ( I believe the main spring concept was to make them easier to clean and keep the mud out in the conditions in the jungles of New Guinea and the Pacific isles. My father said that the mud stuck to everything "like sh*t to a blanket"! )

Nice one Ian! Cheers from Australia 👍

Thank god we used the Owen gun more heavily

The Austen bolt is diecast brass - one of the reasons for the separate steel firing pin. The manufacturer didn't have a milling machine able to make the bolt out of steel.

Mate of mine served for quite sometime in various parts of the ADF, and introduced me to the term “Ausfuck” where various piece of equipment that are adopted by the ADF are “Australianised” and subsequently end up a worse product. I submit that Austen is the first example of Ausfuck occurring.

Imagine owning 1 of the 3 SMGs in your country..

@thesturm8686

4 жыл бұрын

Being the government make you own two of it

I’m 4 mins in and just realized it’s the Australian sten... Austen

@jacobhayes9992

4 жыл бұрын

Just wait until you hear about our standard service rifle. The Austeyr, Australian Steryr.

Thank you for doing some more work on Australian firearms Ian.

For those that missed it or are unaware at 4.30 between the H and the K is the broad arrow. This is shows both government approval and use. It was painted on eg trucks stamped on metal parts e.g. buckles or stenciled on cloth items e.g. ammo pouches.

The "you're lucky you even get a gun" design of the Sten married with German overcomplexity. Good on ya, Bruce!

So you’re saying that when a MP-38 and a Sten love each other very much... that is where Austen’s come from.

@douglaspurcell4192

2 жыл бұрын

From the grease trap behind the SMG abortion clinic.

I bought an Austen foregrip at Aussie Disposals when I was 11. I still have it.

I owned 5 Austen Mk1 and 11 Owens prior to 1996. The Owens were just light years ahead of the Austen, although the Austen was better than the Sten Mk2 & 3's that I had. Much is hyped about the die casting of the Austen but the only parts what were in fact diecast were the mag housing (not including the front grip frame which was a stamping), the mag collar and the mag loader. The receiver tube was lighter gauge than the Owen and therefore much more likely to damage. The mags were difficult to load by hand and needed the loader for the last 10 rounds at least. The Owen mags were easy with a lighter spring tension. The Austen could not be fired with one hand due to terrible balance, while the Owens with the centre of gravity at the rear grip could easily be fired with one hand in an emergency.

The second-system effect (also known as second-system syndrome) is the tendency of small, elegant, and successful systems, to be succeeded by over-engineered, bloated systems, due to inflated expectations and overconfidence.

@Ireallylikeeggs

4 жыл бұрын

Yo this is an interesting concept and I appreciate you bringing it up.

@allangibson2408

3 жыл бұрын

The Sten failed Australian Army trials. Replacement was required.

'Because the Sten was a piece of crap' don't mince your words, come right out and say it.

Kind of.... the Thompson was being issued (bought from the US) in some significant numbers before both the Owen and Austen were fielded. These rained in service but were slowly withdrawn as the Owen came online. Thompsons bearing Australian FTR (Factory Thorough Repair - an Arsenal Rebuild if you will) marking are well represented in military and official collections here. As the Owen was not the product of "the system" here it remained disliked by the Military Hierarchy and it is what the Austen was pushed through to service as a F-U but flopped....

Thank you , Ian .

3:12 Ian corrects the way he pronounced Melbourne. An American actually fixing the way they pronounce things, rather than just being ignorant towards other countries. This is why we love you Ian. You are rare. You are a good egg.

@goaway7346

2 жыл бұрын

He's OK.

@AdamantLightLP

Жыл бұрын

Who cares. Yall do the same thing about cities and places in the US. It doesn't matter as long as you understand the meaning.

@georgewhitworth9742

Жыл бұрын

Sheesh, give the other yanks a break. They don't live there, usually focused on something else, so who bloddy cares? Grow up.

3:07 and on. Nice correction on the pronunciation of "Melbourne" there. Melbournians would be proud.

@arthurneddysmith

4 жыл бұрын

Edit: No, it's not entirely perfect, but it's a shed load better than his first attempt. "Melb'n" is the best description I could give in case anyone is curious. Some would say "Melbun," but the "u" is hardly pronounced, if at all, so I think "Melb'n" is more accurate.

@1Wilful

4 жыл бұрын

Dude, it's Melburnian

One of my favorite guns are the sten. And seeing more variants or similar guns are awesome loved the video and i hope to one day own one of those old treasures of history.

I will say that I really like that the front and rear grips are the same part. That's a legit manufacturing simplfication, although I admit it's somewhat offset by the fact that the original gun didn't have any grips at all. :)

Pretty sure according to Jack Sue’s memoir ‘Blood on Borneo’, these were still in use at least by our infamous Z Special Force through 1945. Some of the changes may make more theoretical sense when it was planned to see a lot of jungle usage?

@nutsandgum

4 жыл бұрын

My grandfather was in Z Special Force and carried an Owen during his service.

@PirataSports

4 жыл бұрын

nutsandgum It’s a shame the actions of those units remain relatively under-appreciated.

@aussiebloke609

4 жыл бұрын

Tropical jungle and rainforest means the cleaning rod and screwdriver makes more sense. Having a gun that's cheap to make doesn't help when you're on extended patrol in the rainy season and there's no way to get a replacement weapon to you when yours rusts solid.

Makes one wonder why the Aussies didn't just make their own MP38 clone instead of trying to improve a crap weapon?

@UXB1000

4 жыл бұрын

Probably there's not enough raw materials to work with.

@vrisbrianm4720

4 жыл бұрын

The MP38 is a relatively expensive sub gun, made from milled steel.

@marcusborderlands6177

4 жыл бұрын

@@jp18449 that isn't the point, yes they work, but they are far from ideal. The French resistance fought in spite of the shitty guns given to them, not because of.

@charlesadams1721

4 жыл бұрын

@@UXB1000no, that's not it at all. production of a relatively complicated piece of equpment is really quite difficult, That's why Ian mentioned that the whole technical package was sent for the Sten, the STEN? a gun that was said to be a "Plumber's Nightmare," to the Australians. As to the "wonderfulness" of the legendary Sten, I've known several dozen WWII veterans that were assigned the use of the Sten gun early in the US's involvement in the war, and none of them had anything complementary to say about it, other than it actually worked. not well, nor accurately, but it worked. As soon as "Grease Guns" were available, the discarded the Stens, and if ammunition was available, so did Brits. Interestingly, the few Aussies I ever spoke with liked their Owens, I think principally due to their confidence in the largely gravity feed.

@marcusborderlands6177

4 жыл бұрын

@@charlesadams1721 gravity feed? I thought they had the mag on top so that they could use the same mag design as everybody else, without worrying about the mags failing due to being faced up. So you reckon they made ground harness clips for em?

I think, perhaps, the idea behind the 'improvements' was rooted in the manufacturers perception of how to best adapt the STEN to the markedly different fighting environments ANZACs were facing in South-East Asia. Looking at the receiver of a STEN and seeing that exposed recoil spring can't possibly inspire confidence in a gun that's going to be used in wet and muddy conditions (such as those faced on the Kokoda track) and perhaps they thought that the enclosed telescoping recoil assembly of the MP-38 would prove more resilient to debris entering through the receiver cut. It's also possible that because there was a lower demand (Australia wasn't fielding as many troops as the UK) and there was less immediacy in their requirement (the distance from Japan to Australia, while not immense, is still markedly greater than that of Germany to the UK) the cost and time to produce were considered less important and they gauged the value of a folding stock and integral take-down and cleaning tools to be worth the offset. I'm not saying any of the changes or improvements were actually of any value, their popularity and short service life are a testimony to them not being so, but perhaps there is a legitimate and thought-out (if not well) reason behind their decisions. Using different magazines I've got no excuse for. I can't think of any reason why they wouldn't copy the STEN, save that perhaps they viewed the witness holes as another potential ingress point for debris and so decided to completely redesign the magazine to get rid of that feature.

@70zenboy

4 жыл бұрын

Tom Austin I was waiting to hear about how bad it was to shoot or poor the reliability was. If the biggest take away was we took a rubbish smg and made some improvements to it that made it more expensive and time consuming to manufacture then that’s a positive thing if time wasn’t too much of an issue. Not to mention that the manufacturing facilities were probably pumping out victa mowers or something not guns. Well done us I reckon.

@SnoopReddogg

4 жыл бұрын

You've probably got a point. I think history isnt fair on the Austen. I also believe the Owen torture test also used a sten, and Austen, a thompson and an MP38 for comparison. I might research how the Austen fared, I recall much than the Sten, so must've done something right?

@70zenboy

4 жыл бұрын

SnoopReddogg love the back shed vibe of the Owen and the diggers were very fond of em that’s enough of a recommendation for me.

There's genuine skill in cocking up something as basic as the plumbers delight

The "Austen", its "better"

I'm still in awe at an American pronouncing Melbourne correctly ;)

@radfatdaddy4169

4 жыл бұрын

Now say Milwaukee, or Racine.

@nomdemorte1302

4 жыл бұрын

@@radfatdaddy4169 Well, that's easy for us because we get American TV and movies here, so we hear the correct pronunciation often. Since you guys don't get so much Aussie TV, you tend to say it like 'Mel-bourne, as in Bourne Identity" which makes total sense, whereas we say it like "Mel-bourne, as in fire will burn you". In certain social circles here, we just call it "Burn City" :)

I enjoyed your presentation, thank you.

3:20 They figured "the sten is a piece of crap" I love how the first 3 and half minutes of this are just the Aussies roasting the Sten lol