The fact that the one girl was saying "For the boys it's not so dangerous, they just get killed." If her definition of "not so dangerous" is literally dying, something is wrong, in Burma as well as Nauru. ~:~

Even Nauru turned into hell... The world is in a really bad shape.

Thanks for the video. :D

I have been in Nauru and it's not how it looks from this video...

@jdevries5606

4 жыл бұрын

Zephuros Notos You are not from Nauru.

@WillGodaskyouifHecansavemetoo

4 жыл бұрын

what IS it like? How did you leave? this video sounds like people aren't allowed to leave.

@josephseymour5386

4 жыл бұрын

R. Allyn you can leave by going to the airport and going on a plane.

@therealmeaning8356

3 жыл бұрын

@@WillGodaskyouifHecansavemetoo watch the video before commenting -.-

@Hambonehoven

2 жыл бұрын

Because you didn’t go to detention camps.

3:58 why TF is there a swastika?

Wow, seems like that second Australia will be created in the future

I love the way the kids day there is nothing to do all day and then show them digging of the dirt. LOL so fake. The fact is they have activity officers entertaining them and adults too. Sewing class complete with sewing machines, art, and music classes. A library, school, internet, English language lessons and a shop with lots of treats, phones cards and cigarettes. The gates are open through the day and they have access to buses to go into town. Adults get given $50 a week to spend, teens $40 and children $25. Very generous pocket money I would say. When was the last time Iran was a war torn country? Over half Asylum seekers are Iranian. Many young men who just don't want to go into compulsory military in Iran. Sob story and using children to pull at your heart strings. Shameful media at it's best.

Those women on Nauru of child bearing age got pregnant as soon as they could, came to Australia to give birth. All of those families are all out in the community now, they were not sent back. All children from Christmas Island were also given visas to come and live in Australia. Those now on Naruru arrived after the cut off date and it would have been kinder to have towed their boats back to Indonesia. They are still free to go home with money in their pockets. Sri Lankans always were given safe haven in India but preferred Australia. Country shopping. Real Asylum seekers are happy to find anywhere safe.

are those people who live behind the metal fences are in australia or nauru?

@donjon1518

4 жыл бұрын

Nauru Island!

Absolutely disturbing and disgusting. You shouldn't have added the dramatic music, though. It feels manipulative and fake. Just let the children speak. That's more than enough.

@Anna133199

7 жыл бұрын

Uuh.. That's a random question. Hehe. How is that a reaction to my comment?

@Indonesiansurftravel

7 жыл бұрын

"manipulative and fake" you nailed it, yep the music sits perfectly.

These kids have been filmed in 2016 with chubby faces, Microwaves, TV's, toys and even kittens. Their only complaint was being bored due to parents taking sleeping pills and forcing them to play quietly. Being brain washed by rioting adults that ruin $60m worth of property to get their own way is the problem. I say send the kids my way deem the parent unfit and negligent for putting them on the boat and lock them up for child endangerment. Thank god they are kept from doing that type of damage to a place like Tasmania.

So why didnt they go to saudi arbia or uae?

@Anna133199

7 жыл бұрын

As if people are free there. Didn't you hear the girl? She wants good education and FREEDOM.

@Anna133199

7 жыл бұрын

+Danker Memesberg lol I'm a traitor? Right! People like you are so disgusting. I don't know how you can live with yourself. You should read the article about the files. If you'd do that you'd see that children make up about 18% of the asylum seekers, but 51,3% of the reports of incidents that now have been leaked and can be found on the website involve children. They mutilate themselves out of desperation, they are sexually/physically abused by guards, etc. People who worked there in the past have described it as a 'concentration camp'. These camps are a disgrace. If you're okay with that there's something wrong with you. I'm not the traitor here. I actually like western civilization. You know what is also a part of western civilization? Human rights! Besides, how do you know being a Christian in Iran isn't the reason the Iranian girl fled?

@youjustgotowendbyme

7 жыл бұрын

+Anna133199 so you think it is the Solution to let everybody into Australia? No it isnt. The Solution is to get rid of the Problems in there home Country. You cant ran away from your Problems

@Anna133199

7 жыл бұрын

Of course the solution is to get rid of the problems in your home country, but this is Earth, not some fairy-tale planet. Sometimes not running away from your problems means death or torture. Australia is one of the countries that voted in favor of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Article 3: Everyone has the right to life, liberty and security of person. Article 5: No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. Article 14: (1) Everyone has the right to seek and to enjoy in other countries asylum from persecution. (2) This right may not be invoked in the case of prosecutions genuinely arising from non-political crimes or from acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations. If fucking rich first world country Australia isn't willing to uphold basic human rights, why would any other country?

@youjustgotowendbyme

7 жыл бұрын

so tell me why do they want to go to australia. Isnt the first choice to go to a safe country? There are alot of country inbetween iran and Australia that are safe. Why does the first world does have this lifestyle because they fought for there RIGHTS.

Where are they now?

And the silly thing is...Nauru's representative talked in UN assembly about human right harassement in Papua where they got nowhere information. And this fact, please...you pointed out your index to other while your thumb pointed to yourself!!

Just out of curiosity, why Nauru? Australia is a fuckin huge country why can't they have detention centre with in the country just like others?

@richardtaylor4362

7 жыл бұрын

It is called a deterrent, the eu need one too

@Kuswasinnam

7 жыл бұрын

+Richard Taylor What an awful response. No empathy for others. You aren't welcome on 'Our Land', because we earned through murder and exploitation the right to say so. This is not a position that elevates you.

@Kuswasinnam

7 жыл бұрын

+Richard Taylor None of the people in this film were from Africa. Why the daft polemic? I'm talking about empathy. Do you see these children and think of them as unworthy of compassion? Are you aware that concentrations of wealth such as Australia's are only viable by exploiting other people around the world. Or do you believe that it was the Aussies bootstrap gumption that gave them prosperity? Ask an Indonesian about Australia's complicity with General Suharto. Ask them why it is profitable to maintain the suppression of workers rights, rights that we expect nothing less than to provide us with affordable clothes, sugar, timber, fish etc. You cannot just regurgitate scapegoat talking points that avoid our collective responsibility.

Yeah because people who are obviously so desperate to get to Australian wouldn't do or say anything to get here??? Even when many stayed in Australian detention centres we had riots and refugees setting buildings alight and sewing their lips together on hunger strikes etc. Sorry games over we all now know that 80% of refugees at Nauru live in the community and eve own business and those refugees at the centre are free to come and go 24/7 and live in modern self contained bungalows complete with Air conditioning, hot water and all the mod cons including big flat screen TV and even a Gym, three meals a day, and even receive an allowance, add to that free health care and legal advice etc. The reality is they live under better conditions than Nauru locals and hundreds of millions in this world and ten times better conditions than those in third world refugee camps who often live in tents without running water, clean drinking water, without toilets, struggle to get a feed and do not have access to health care or an income. BTW. True refugees from a war torn country would jump at the chance of a new life be it PNG or Cambodia, the fact they have turned down these options confirms they are country shopping...Do you really think those stuck in third world refugee camps would turn down the same opportunity of a new start?

@MelaniaRose

4 жыл бұрын

Indo Bule I agree ☝️ Refugees have self destructive behaviours in detention centres ! Few years the Australian navy had evidence of parents throwing their own children overboard on boats!

@scar4513

4 жыл бұрын

I lived in Nauru for 3 years as a refugee I was 14 yrs old when I lived there watching this video right now is kinda cringe most of those things are made up for the video it wasn't bad as ppl say i wanted safe place and I was safe in Nauru I was one of those first ppl people who signed for resettlement in U.S.A and I left Nauru in 2017 regardless of what ppl say abt Australian government I think Australia gave me a better future by giving me a chance to live in U.S.A and there is still lot of asylum seekers in Nauru and in Australia who had chosen to stay there instead of accepting the deal with U.S.A those people who doesn't want to work but live on Australians ppl tax and my grammar is pretty bad sorry lol

@royalpillows7716

4 жыл бұрын

Then why aren’t journalists and the public given access to that place?

Iran to Australia ending up in Nauru? How did that route happen? 4:41 The point is to not give people incentive and hope they will have a chance to live in Australia. It is to dissuade the flow of people, who would risk their lives and their children's lives to get to Australia. Otherwise you would end up with the situation in Europe, except across open ocean. This news piece doesn't include anything about whether this policy has slowed the traffic of people across that ocean to Australia nor how many children drowned previously in the attempt. The sentimental maudlin music is a clear attempt to make an emotional propaganda piece vs just be news

The asylum seekers ARE being given protection. That is all they are entitled to. It is not Australia's obligation to give a 'better life' to foreigners. They are not Australian citizens, yet we are supplying them with food and shelter. They are free to go to any place in the world that will take them, just not Austraiia. There are indigenous children born on Nauru and Manus. What is so special about Pakistanis and Iranians?

What crimes have these children done to deserve such unethical treatment? No records of criminality, yet they are being abused day after day. Not to mention the years of psychological trauma which they would have to face in their adult life. Release the innocent into the community now.

@chriswatson1698

5 жыл бұрын

It is their parents that are abusing them. The most inhumane people in the world are those who have children that they are not n a position to provide for.

@MelaniaRose

4 жыл бұрын

It’s was the parents fault their children are in detention because they broke international law! There is no trauma but the parents causing it themselves ! It’s well documented parents will harm their own children for sympathy! Australia provided the best facilities to accommodate the children ! The Australian navy reported at one time the refugees threw their own children overboard when they got caught out at sea !

If you are a true refugee you future home will be Nauru. What is the problem with that?

I beg to question what the meaning of "humanity" is. I agree, all nations needs to work and better themselves in providing basic living conditions for their people. But this is only possible if all nations are given a level playing field to achieve this dream. Exploitation of resources and people by the powerful which largely goes unpunished must be stopped. What the world is witnessing today is an ongoing war for resources. "Humanity" on the other hand does not exist. We are beasts who live off each other and those fortunate, exist by defending their loot with vile violence and brutality.

Flee from ur home and judge other people's home... You should stay where ur from

@IT-qb7dw

Жыл бұрын

No

@Skatted

6 ай бұрын

Says the guy with an RGB keyboard

@GHOST-os6uq

6 ай бұрын

I'm not trying to offense.. I'm just saying. you kid minded imbecile... Imagine a homeless person who came to your house, and ask for help, So you offered him shelter, food, but he complain about every effort you done for that person will you be happy? If your one of those Karen who knows nothing just keep ur mouth shut....

There are two options Option 1. Al Capone (people smugglers) decide who comes into Australia or Option 2. The Australian government decides who comes into this country and I pick number 2.

@hismajestyericcartmanthese5755

Жыл бұрын

IOpkpkopopolopopolopopokpkpkkpkpkpkpkpkpkkpkkpkpkkpkpkpkpkpkpkkpkpkpkkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkkpkkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkpkkpko

everybody can't just go to the country with freedom, free education etc, you have to build that up in your own country

@EP1CMONKEY

7 жыл бұрын

but abusing and raping those people is fine right.

@johnmathis1754

7 жыл бұрын

yep!

@johnmathis1754

7 жыл бұрын

+alpine breed Agreed!

@NoNo-uy8cb

6 жыл бұрын

Not so easy under tyrannical governments

@TheYayoii

5 жыл бұрын

How ignorant

Better, send him there

Lol at not understanding concept of deterrent

What has happened to humans, we no longer have love, compassion or empathy for our fellow human. Animals don't behalf like this. As a parent this breaks my heart.

@OmarAventador

7 жыл бұрын

+Danker Memesberg Nope, but this is absolute cruelty. Just send them back home.

@johnmathis1754

7 жыл бұрын

+Danker Memesberg I agree with you 100%.

@johnmathis1754

7 жыл бұрын

+Aki Nakamoto I agree.

@TVsez

7 жыл бұрын

You've proven my point you animals and your other comments on this thread are shameful. These people should not be locked up. No human is better than another

@waldena2851

7 жыл бұрын

I think that's all what we have been told. The reality is very different. The immigration is selective towards rich and educated people, leaving a poorer country as they take those "useful" people away

I feel bad for these people but Yea Australia has a lot of shit on it back Helping it fellow pacific islanders with climate change. plus they didn't come to the country legally. so if you know Australia it really strict when it come to people or animals that comes outside of there country, to protect it own people but yea if they could at least provide for these people even more and ask their country to contribute, that would be awsome

Go back home!

@sharnsrock5276

5 жыл бұрын

U dog

Dutton is a hero

IS NAURU PART OF MICRONESIA OR POLYNESIA IF MICRONESIA THEN THEY SHOULD PROBABLY HAVE A COMPACT FREE ASSOCIATIONS WITH THE UNITED STATES MEANING THEY CAN MIGRANT TO THE STATES FOR FREE.

@briantravelman

6 жыл бұрын

Nauru is an independent nation.

@analibonelanlo7316

5 жыл бұрын

Nauru isn't part of Micronesia you nutcase .. there are only 4 stars on the flag which point out to pohnpei , yaap, chuuk and kosrae ... trust me these people would've gotten a lot of help if they was in Micronesia cause by now they would've been either in Hawaii or America but they chose Nauru

@tenneseeangel1293

Жыл бұрын

Nauru isn't a part of Micronesia, it is a completely different country. And please for the of all things stop typing in all caps its very annoying.

Gibs me dat barbie

I feel sympathetic, but this is a necessary policy to have such a deterrent. In fact the eu should be adopting policies like this. Many on the left just have not quite grasped just how many people in the global south would flood the west in an instant given the chance with open borders. I want the United Nations to be taking the ideas of a few mega rich folks seriously, some have been trying to get backing to create refugee islands under un guidance, land would be purchased from nations like Philippines. I believe people who live in oppressive nations like the United deserve a second chance but you can not force another nation to accept you. I know this is probably a pipe real but I think we need to break some eggs to make an omelette.

I lived there for 3 years!

@abbad707

4 жыл бұрын

Sad,how were you treated,Mina?

Human rights violations! And the President of Australia just lets this happen! If I were in charge, he would be hanged.

@josephsteiner9091

7 жыл бұрын

Nathaniel Krigsman, you mean the Prime Minister of Australia, not President, Australia is a constitutional monarchy

Jail for Malcolm Turnbull

Hello from germany

Well, if I had been one of these "refugees", I would have stayed where I came from and made the effort to make my country better, or die trying.

@iEffingLovePenguins

7 жыл бұрын

Very easy to say when you've not been in their position.

@567raman

7 жыл бұрын

James mate what do you smoke? Lol

@Dan-xb7yy

7 жыл бұрын

They should convert to Buddhism and save their asses.

India has only a little to boast of it's own and they shelter thousands of myanmar, bangladeshy, nepaly even pakistani(India's born rivals) refugees. Some fuzz hapens. Still they are given place and peace to build their life. It's called human rights. Australia can do a lot lot better for the world. But yea.. Your country. Your rules. Your beliefs.

@MelaniaRose

3 жыл бұрын

Australia does more than enough. These people chose to break laws so it’s their own fault for ending up in detention. India and Australia are totally different. Refugees in Australia get new homes, jobs, citizenship rights and millions in organisations donations. Does India do that ?

_“Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, the wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door no-more...”_

Nobody told you to get to another country. Stay in your country if you dont want this to happen. If we will go to your country illegally we will experience the same thats why I will not attempt to go there

Why aren't they doing this in the uk

why are they complaining? they got away from the war, thats what they wanted.

Good on Australia! The rest of the World should take a stand along with then! Stay strong Australia for doing the right thing. You're so compassionate & kind :) Only an arrogant, distasteful and selfish human being would risk there own lives & children like this! SHAME ON YOU!

Because Nauru is rich, just like Gulf countries (Iraq n Syria). Greedy countries just want its resources by creating unstabil situation.

@royalpillows7716

4 жыл бұрын

Syria isn’t a gulf country...

Free the refugees but not to Australia. They shall be settled in Nauru or another country but Australia. PERIOD

My goodness. At this rate, Nauru's gonna be like Australia's Guantanomo Bay

@adrianmotley8855

4 жыл бұрын

syed firdaus that’s false

@MelaniaRose

4 жыл бұрын

Guantanamo is a prison. Nauru is a detention centre !

@NullaNulla

Жыл бұрын

OMG another uneducated sensationalist! Rule 1, DON'T BELIEVE THE MAINSTREAM (OR MOST) MEDIA!

Amnesty International is an organization which is irrelevant to today problems. Amnesty International was an organization that defended individual oppressed by government for their different views or simply criticizing their policies. Today Amnesty International systematically defends Muslim voices, defends Muslim expansion, defends Muslim orientation to terrorism. Amnesty International nowadays, never supports any Western nations for their foreign or internal policies,. Amnesty International again is systematically criticizing over and over and over. Amnesty International never contributed one dollar to people starving in Africa, Amnesty International never contributed one dollar towards million of displaced refugees. We must disband that organization fattening up in high-rise glass building in Geneva. . Amnesty International has become a useless tool that no monetary fund should be allocated by your private donation.

Australia needs to detain these people first to determine if their not terrorists. The children is another thing, protect them. For those who've caught themselves on fire, I have no pity.

@miahm1

5 жыл бұрын

are you human been my lord.who you are devil

Aussie foreign policy is dictated by Japan. The Japanese have dictated migration in the Pacific for thousands of years.

If i was trump,ill give 1 billion dollars to Nauru

@MelaniaRose

4 жыл бұрын

Hundoria save that billion dollars and help the. Poor in the US

Criminals gonna criminal

are those people who live behind the metal fences are in australia or nauru?

@MelaniaRose

4 жыл бұрын

farah safinah Nauru. They were free to roam on Nauru by the way...