I bought the CD box set Tone. Giles Martin and his team have done an great job with Revolver. Your review is also an excellent guide through their new remix. Cheers

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much Eddie .I agree excellent job by Giles and Sam. Glad you enjoyed the video

I've been binging on these reviews of my favorite Beatle album lately. nice vid. I must be the only one who likes this mix of She Said She Said lol 😀 i had to sub, of course i did 😝

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

11 ай бұрын

Thanks very much for subscribing, welcome to the channel and I hope you enjoy the content here. Im ok with the She Said , She Said remix, going on memory, I think I said I was liking it but it took a bit of getting used to

The mono in this box set is an incredible mix. Fidelity A plus. This stereo mix is very nice too

Great review, really good analysis of the changes to the mixes. Your excitement and enthusiasm really comes across, and I really love your move to technicolour! I had no idea revolver came so close to the World Cup win - what a great week that must have been to have lived through! Thanks for this great video.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much - glad you enjoyed the video. Ye sIm not sure there has been a better 6 days in English history !

Love your review the best one yet

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks you so much John - I really appreciate this comment

Hi Tone, i always love to watch your reviews, thanks for sharing and greetings from Italy 🇮🇹

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Prego Rob ! Thanks very much, I really appreciate this comment . greetings returned from London my friend.

I follow many beatle youtubers...Tony's review is hands down the best without a shadow of doubt. Tony you are a true fan its great seeing you get so passionate about my fav beatles album! Your video was a joy to watch, and your insightful reviews of each song was detailed, a great comparison to the 2009 mix. I hope anyone watching this video shares with their friends...Tony absolutely deserves more followers and coverage great Reviews and videos!!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Hi Marcus, thank you so much for this amazing review of my review- really appreciate these very kind words. Glad you enjoyed it. I never try to be first out of the blocks with these reviews - especially when its such an important album. I like to live with it for at least 10 plays before casting an opinion, to me this is more important than the rush for views approach. The channel has been growing recently but its still pretty young (15 months) and Im delighted with the number of subscribers I have here and I enjoy interacting with other fans in the comments, but feel free to to spread the word and share with anyone you think will be interested - that would be amazing. Thank you again so much.

Thoroughly enjoyed this review .Going out to get the remix based on this. Thanks, great stuff!,,

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much Jim, glad you enjoyed the video. Enjoy the Revolver remix.

I agree totally here there ,and everywhere is so beautiful it made me cry the original didn't.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

That's the power of pop music - lovely stuff. The remix is stunning

Fabulous review Tone, really enjoyed that. I love She Said, She Said on this remix. This will be my go-to as well. Thanks for a brilliant review.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much James - I really appreciate this comment and glad you enjoyed the review. Im seeing quite a bit of support for the She Said remix now

Very good review. Making me excited to Revolve some more with the new mix. I really do enjoy it. Need to crank it up some more. I know you said not to listen in the car, but that is where I can crank it up the most. Thinking my drive home tonight I’ll do some Revolving. Can’t wait for your thoughts on the sessions!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Dustin, glad you enjoyed the review. crank it up and keep on revolving my friend

@BeatleDustino

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel I took the long way home and Revolved while Driving My Car. Really cranked it too. The clarity keeps blowing me away. This time especially the bass. Loud, proud and completely undistorted! Even at the volume I had it at. I’m either getting used to She Said, She Said, or the difference isn’t as notable as it was on the headphones.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@BeatleDustino You've revolved so much lately you much be very dizzy. Yeah I think when something sounds different like She Said, it takes a bit of time before the difference stops jarring - repeated plays is always the answer. Glad youre enjoying the remix though

Excellent review.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much. Glad you liked it.

Hi Tone. Well I said in a previous message that your review on this set would be worth waiting for and oh how correct I was! Objective and fair as we’ve come to expect from you and can’t wait for your next one on the sessions etc. Mine arrived a few days ago, and like you, I’ve been playing it to death! Have a great weekend.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much Peter, I really appreciate this comment. glad you enjoyed the review and that your stuff has arrived . hope you are enjoying it and having a great weekend mate.

Thanks a lot for this great review Tone. I've heard the remix four or five times and I really like it. The clarity of the recording has much improved. Like someone put a thick curtain away. really great. I also like the picture disc, I saw in your yesterday's video. What a nice item. I don't mind about yellow submarine, but I never thought of replacing it with rain. But you are right. What a strong album this had been. But still my favourite songs remain And your Bird can sing and Got to get you into my life... both are really enhanced with the remix and for the later one it's great to hear ringo's fantastic drumming more better. I am looking forward for the review of the session tracks. BTW I am still waiting on my copy from Mediamarkt. It is not only amazon

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Armin. glad you liked the review and also glad that you are happy with the remix. I like your curtain analogy too. yes Ringo's drumming was exceptional around this period . thanks for a great comment and I hope your copy turns up soon.

Great review👍

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thank you

Thank you for such a thorough review. I love the remix too. Giles Martin has got a great pair of ears, and so have you!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much Paul, I appreciate your kind words. Glad you enjoyed the review and are enjoying the remix.

@paulchristoforou4824

Жыл бұрын

I forgot to enter the Yellow Submarine debate. Does it belong on Revolver? Does When I'm 64 belong on Pepper and does Revolution 9 belong anywhere?

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@paulchristoforou4824 Im less offended by When Im 64 and maxwells Silver Hammer for that matter and as for Rev 9 - although I doing want to listen to it too often, somehow the White album would seem as weird without it as it does with it. 🙂 but I do take your point.

Hi Tone & a brilliant honest review basically telling it as it is on this in my opinion wonderful box set.... To my ears mostly everything sounds beyond stunning & my only disappointment on the new 2022 remix is what happened to one of my album favourites She Said She Said as it sounds horrid especially the guitar track which actually cuts out from time to time & I'm surprised Giles Martin let it through sounding like this!! My absolute highlight on the remix is Got To Get You Into My Life which sounds awesome but to be fair just about every track does but in saying everything above what can be said about the outtakes of Yellow Submarine with John singing actually edged on by Paul McCartney.... As a Beatles fan for over 50 years this is one of the greatest surprises ever for me! Love it.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Stephen for a brilliant comment. I knew that She Said She Said would divide fans. I hadn't noticed the guitar cutting out but will go back and have a listen. thanks for pointing that out. GTGYIML os absolutely stunning on this mic I agree as is pretty much everything. Glad youre enjoying the set and yes Yellow Sub demos are a revelation. more about those in my next video. Glad youre enjoying the set and thanks again for this comment.

@girlswanted7

Жыл бұрын

If you listen carefully to She Said She Said it also cuts out on the original stereo mix, but it’s less noticeable. But, it definitely is there each time as I’ve compared the two versions. I believe it’s more noticeable now because Giles centered the guitar, etc.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@girlswanted7 Yes someone else pointed this out too. I didnt notice it before , but I know what you mean

Great analysis, Tone. The new mix is becoming my go-to as well. She Said She Said is the flaw in the Persian rug, I suppose. I really like the clarity of the track and how the sound is spread out, but I do miss those big cymbal crashes. All in all, Giles did a great job with this remix.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Matthew , I will begetting to your review very soon, I have it on Watch Later. I knew She Said would divide people's opinions , it does take a bit of getting used to for sure but Im ok with the quietening down of the crashes. Giles and Sam have done a great job here - probably the best one so far for me. glad you're liking it too and looking forward to hearing your full review . thanks as always for commenting

I can't agree more Tone it is jaw dropping

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Isn't it just ! Glad youre enjoying it. make you think what could be achieved with the other albums yet to get the treatment. Exciting times for us all.

Great review Tony, I agree with most of your comments 👍 When you mentioned your nostalgia for your childhood memories of Yellow Submarine, I was 11 years old when it was released and now regard that recording as a work of art rather than a children's novelty, as opposed to Wings recording of Mary Had A Little Lamb, I wish Paul had never made that record!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Adrian glad you liked the review. I was 5 when Yellow Sub came out and I can vaguely remember the song from that time although I wouldn't have known it was by the Beatles. Im not saying that it shouldn't exist, I just feel its a bit out of place on revolver where the other songs are so mature. I think as a stand alone single it would be perfect - juts my opinion of course. As for MHALL, pretty embarrassing but I like to think it exists as a kind of statement after the banning of Give Ireland back to the Irish , its a kind of of 'ok here's something completely sterile that you cant ban. This is the only way it can be justified. 😂

Hi Tony looks at you so artsy in the begging. It sure is amazing of a set. But it was fun to have your great opinion of it all. And as you went through it, I was saying yes mmm you are right!!!! I do like I am only sleeping and how it does sound on it (nice). For no one is just wild O yes:)!!! It is a lot of fun to compare the new one with some of the other pressings. Just a top notch set well done one on this one Tony!! .... Ps have you see the coool video on KZread for I am only sleeping ?. Cheers!!!!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Hi Brad, glad you liked the video. haha the black n White thing was a little bit of fun. Ive got yours on Watch later so I will get to it soon. really loved the video for Im Only Sleeping. This is a great remix - probably the best so far and Im glad youre liking it so I'll look forward to watching your review my friend .

@beatlebrad5339

Жыл бұрын

The B/W was cool. You know there are promo videos for all of them... You know Thay need to put out a DVD of it out:) Cheers mate!!!!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@beatlebrad5339 Thank you and no I didnt know that. Official promos?

@beatlebrad5339

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel :)!!!!

One thing I really like where on and your bird can sing I like where their voices really blend together on the word me on the Giles Martin remix

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

yes the vocals are great on that song in particular

Really good review and I have to agree with most of what you say. For me, every instrument and part now has their chance to shine. Things are no longer buried and there's just a general sense of spaciousness to the recording.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Totally agree Michael . glad you liked the review and are enjoying the album . thanks for commenting

Thanks, Tone, for heads up and very cool with the drum info as always! I really appreciate the drum insight and I eagerly await the outtakes review because that's what I really am interested in, the bootleg boy me. great idea with Rain in place of Yellow Sub! I wish they had done that. it was thrilling to hear the organ notes on she said she said as the cymbal smashes reduced. never heard it in clarity like that. I always thought that was buried sustained guitar feedback in mono mix, what a revelation. Ringo's drums on all of this era's songs are remarkable. I find it odd that during these touring years 1965/66 Ringo always complained that touring "was wrecking my playing. we couldn't hear each other" ...breaking news just in....VAR is re-checking the Hurst goal! oh wow my friend World Cup is right around the corner.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much Russ for a great comment. Glad you liked the review and the little drummer's eye view. Yes Ringo's drumming at this point is quite astonishing - really good playing on Rubber Soul and Revolver. The clarity and the re-positions of instruments and voices has made this album something really new that sparkles. I guess it was difficult for Ringo during the touring years , Ive been in that situation a few times when you cant hear what's going on properly (but for different reasons obviously) and its tricky. That was a tense 56 years waiting for VAR to finally give the nod but thank goodness we got the decision. I was saying to y mate the other day, that I dont feel the same excitement for this World Cup as I usually do at this close to the tournament . I think its because England have played crap for about a year coupled with the fact that its in the winter. im sure this will change once the tournament gets started.

@RussBeatle63

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel I love it all and not complaining (unusual) about anything with this package. They got it right and should be applauded. As I said this summer 2022 when I found this wonderful channel "World Cup should be going on right now, in season will be very strange"...I think that is the excitement factor that you are talking about. We are focused on club results, not country. I know it will change with 3 matches a day for a few weeks. VAR finally came in handy, about time! now if VAR can do something about that hand of God in 1986!... have a good one Tone and thanks for video!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@RussBeatle63 Hi Russ, Also really enjoying this - really great work. Yes I remember you saying and its true. Just not feeling at the moment. I think we are naming our preliminary squad this week so maybe that will raise the bar excitement wise. Just this weekend and next for league figures then it stops until Boxing Day and yes a lot of football to be playing in between. Are you in the mood for it yet?

@RussBeatle63

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel Hey Tone - not really in the mood yet. I wish I was. If it was early June, I would going bonkers and reading about all teams/squads. I would be asking you opinions on this and that, but I am more inclined to ask opinions about the Hammers vs Palace tomorrow er um today. huge game you could leap them. good luck i will be watching

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@RussBeatle63 well its a gem we should win at home but by all accounts we are rubbish up to this point and will be lucky to get a draw (its 1-1 with 10 to play)

This is an amazing upgrade of a fantastic album.But and its a discerning but.Paperback writer. Yes it's cleaner yet I miss the original sound and that humming bass sound at each interlude section. Tomorrow never knows mono mix RM11 and I'm only sleeping mono mix RM1 is the beas knees 4 me. When you think you've heard everything This is the hi lite of Beatles Ness. As for the book,we'll am still digesting it all. It knocks me out.Simply Brilliant.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yes Davi, brilliant throughout. Glad you're enjoying the set so much. Roll on the next one. Thanks for this great comment.

Fine review, Tone! I've mostly been staying away from reviews because this remix had such a profound effect on me, but I definitely wanted to hear what you thought. Interesting that you mentioned how this album took the world from black and white to color. That's exactly how I felt after hearing this for the first time. In fact, I was thinking that a colorized version of the cover in the book might have been an appropriate choice. I've mentioned my longstanding critiques have been the stereo mix and the quality of most of John's compositions. After one listen, those 2 issues have been completely eradicated. After a dozen listens (at least), I now consider this a top 5 album on my list. I'll spare you a track by track analysis, but John's tracks have all gone up for me, especially She Said, She Said. The snare on And Your Bird is a highlight for me. Tomorrow Never Knows leaves me speachless every time. It's the overall breathing room throughout the track and the floating tape loops that I find so special. I now feel like Pau's songs are appropriately produced. For No One is particularly stirring. At least, I can listen to Yellow Submarine and find it a little more interesting than before, partially because I now know the backstory of the compostition. George's songs are certainly more vibrant. Just filling that gaping hole in the stereo mix of Taxman made this a success. I've listen to this remix in almost every way: Home stereo, headphones, in the car. I've heard the cd and the hi-res. The vinyl listening will hopefully happen this weekend. I've been comparing the remixes to all other versions of the tracks that have been remixed from this album and just let the entire catalog shuffle to see how they would sound when they would pop up in comparison to everything else. No matter how I listen, these tracks just sparkle!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much Pete for this comment. Glad that you are in the thumbs up for She Said camp. Many reviewers went early on their reviews of this and most got it wrong - the rush for views and all that ! The remix is stunning throughout for me and interesting to hear your highlights are similar to mine and this has changed your mind about some of the songs ,as well as the album in general. I heard the hi-res files yesterday and was stunned all over again - just superb . Enjoy your vinyls this Weekend my friend and thanks for a brilliant comment.

@BeatlePete910

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel I was so positively affected by the remix, I wanted to keep it for myself for as long as possible. For that reason, I stayed from all YT reviews. It makes perfect sense that I would like the remix of She Said... while most don't. It's probably what everyone liked about the original that didn't sit well with me all these years. It makes me sad to think people would sacrifice their cred in the rush to be first. I have a whole day to delve into the vinyl before I have to make the trip to Mum's again. Being this is the Missus favorite Beatles album, she wants to sit with me an listen to the whole thing in its entirety. The high res is definitely spectacular! Looking forward to your review on the session tracks.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@BeatlePete910 Hi Pete, I also stayed away from reviews until I had mine made as I didnt want to be influenced. Since mine went out Ive watched nothing but reviews ! Yes in the you tube world, those who get their news, unboxing and reviews out first will get the most views so its always a bit of a bundle . I don't think it matters so much with news because people will watch the same news story from different channels just in case one of them says something different. With reviews , I just don't think you can review a major release after playing it once or twice - I prefer to not be early with these and listen thoroughly and consider all options before going public with it - there doesn't seem any point in not doing that . I guess by now you've had a chance to go through the vinyls so I hope that was a positive experience for you

Wonderful analysis. And my understanding of you "despite" accent is improving. :)

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much. Glad you enjoyed the review. Sorry youre struggling with the accent.

@jnagarya519

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel It's okay to speak with an accent, but not to hear with one.

She said, She said was a big surprise for me, great to hear the clarity but it surprised me to hear what sounded like rogue guitar notes. On previous mixes I never noticed them. maybe they shouldn't be quite so prominent in the mix though. Always been a fav song of mine, just getting used to hearing new bits..but so far I think I'd have left them in the edit room.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

She Said is a strange one and took me a while to get used to it. One of my favourites on the album too and this mix hasn't diminished that for me, like it has for others. Thanks for your comment

Fabulous run through of the remixed Revolver, Tone! I haven't bought it yet, hoping to land a bargain during Black Friday/Black Week. Your idea of exchanging Yellow Submarine for Rain on the album is a brilliant one! I don't really mind Yellow Submarine on its own, but it is the odd one out on the album. Rain is a better fit! I fully agree on listening to the album on a proper hifi system rather than in a car or something. Good headphones is a good alternative way for a serious and devoted listening session in my opininon. I loved your magic "let there be colour" trick early in the video - well done, mate! I love all your videos allthough I don't always comment on them. I also believe your worries of doing too long videos is a sensible take. But reviewing a full album requires time. At least I didn't fall out during the half hour. (Though I did look up Twitter on my other screen while listening to you...) Yes, I always watch YT on my computer. Almost never on my mobile phone. 😄Looking forward to your next videos. take care!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks you so much for this really great comment and feedback - I really appreciate your input. I did see that a lot of KZreadrs went really early on their reviews of this remix as this helps them get more views by being first out of the blocks and in doing this I noticed that they sacrificed detail for speed. Revolver is such an important album, I really wanted to take it all in for a few days before giving an opinion (I am still as I write working on my review of the sessions albums). Funnily enough, I also only watch YT on my computer. Glad you made it to the end of the video but you just cant do a proper review in 10 minutes . Also glad that you enjoy the content on this channel and have taken the time to give me some feedback - I really appreciate that. I hope you manage to pick up a bargain on Black Friday because this is a really get set. Thanks again

@eikerkongenrex6249

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel My little update: Yes, joy! Today I bought the CD box set for NOK 1049.- That's the equivalent of £89. Not bad, eh? They sold out in 60 minutes - the company only had a limited quantity at this favourable price. (The 80 x 7" vinyl box from Paul which was announced today is far too pricey and I will pass on that.)

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@eikerkongenrex6249 That's a really great price for the Cd Revolver set. Glad you've got, enjoy it my friend. totally get it about the singles set -very expensive in one hit especially straight after revolver. thanks for the update.

Great!. Finally a non-precipatated and focussed review on the main purpose on this 2022 remix, (vocals centered etc). Please keep on with Rain and PPBW-

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks very much I appreciate your comment. Will definitely be giving the EP the same treatment in the next video although the sessions will of course be reviewed on a different basis. Thanks again

@TonioFigueras83

Жыл бұрын

You' re welcome! The "she said, she said" debate: I have listened to the mono/stereo mixes for decades. And for me the most stunning moment of the 2022 remix is when I heard for the fist time a second guitar (left channel). It had been there all these years, blended with the first guitar!. What an exciting surprise courtesy of Mr Giles Martin et al.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@TonioFigueras83 Yes exactly, I love how these remixes tease out stuff that has always been there so that we hear them. Something that's old but with a new spin, which is what these remixes are for me. The work that has gone on here is a revelation.

She Said She Said was a great surprise for me, I can hear instruments I’ve never heard clearly before, especially John’s Hammond organ, the vocals and drumming are amazing, plus the guitar sounds are an inspiration 🎉

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for giving your opinion on She Said. Im really interested to hear what other fans think of this remix, which I think is the most radical on the album. I really like it too, but it took a few plays to get it to sink in. Thanks for this comment Roy

I hadn't bought yet, but that remix sounds like its going to be awesome!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

It really Ken. Superb

After years of hearing She Said, British mixes or American, ill never get used to this mix of the crash cymbals. Makes no sense. They sound like their on the next block.(It's supposed to be a powerful track). Its not suppose to be UNPLUGGED! Outside of that, a great job was done on this box set. Really nice mixes! Keep em coming Giles! Good stuff!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

11 ай бұрын

Im ok with the part of the mix tbh Allen. To me as a drummer, it does make sense because the crash cymbals shouldn't be the loudest thing in the kit at any point - they are there to punctuate (usually a chord change) . the important thing for me here is that Ringo's kit generally is no longer lost in the mix and is strong and loud like it should be. I do agree however that the toning down of the cymbals has divided fans opinions . thanks for your comment

@allengattone4367

11 ай бұрын

Ah! We're getting there, bud! I do like the presence of the kit. So important. 4 track recordings with little or no bouncing, and it shows on Paperback Writer. (Most of the instruments are on one track.) Giles did a great job. I have a 24 track, sometimes I stare it and think what the Beatles could have done with this machine! 😃 😊. Martin, and Geoff would have had a field day. I was 17 the day it was released here in the States.( back in 66 ) I turned the lp over and saw only 2 John songs! Didn't rub me right at all. 😆 Where's Lennon? 😆 is this a joke? 😆 keep up the good work. Your review is pretty damn good! 😉 I enjoyed it.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

11 ай бұрын

@@allengattone4367 Yes the distribution of Lennon songs is a bit uneven - I guess these things are sequenced to flow the best way so I guess you cant always get an even spread. Im sure George and Geoff would have loved your 24 track desk at their disposal. Thanks Allen glad you enjoyed the video

Great review! With the new She Said She Said mix the changes are just too jarring for me, especially when listening with headphones. Giles and Sam took too many liberties here and I’m not sure why. I’m normally a big fan of their remix projects. But not on this track. I otherwise wouldn’t care that much but this is one of my favourite Beatles songs! The guitars in the left channel are thin and they oddly cut out in spots. It’s always been a perfect, dense, grungy guitar-heavy track but now the guitars are so ‘cleaned up’ and spread out; as a result the overall sonic impact is diminished for me. With this being such a brilliant song I don’t want it to take “some getting used to”. I really wanted to love it but I can’t. All of the individual instruments sound clear but as an integrated whole it’s a big fluster cluck. An intriguing sound experiment but not a good mix - to my ears. The cymbals bother me too but the guitars are my main beef. But many of the remixes really shine: I Want to Tell You, For No One, Dr. Robert, And Your Bird Can Sing, Love You Too, YS and I’m Only Sleeping, among others, for me.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

This is a really great comment, thanks for posting and glad you liked the review. With She Said, I think guitar spots that you hear on the left where almost certainly already there , but where he's split the two guitars left and right on the new mix you hear that spotting much clearer whereas on the 2009 both guitars are in the same channel so the other guitar masks the spotting. It definitely sounds different and that's really what I meant by 'getting used to' - when you've heard something the same way for decades you notice the changes so it takes a while for the difference to sink in - thats all I meant buy that. With the cymbals, on the original they become the loudest part of the lit and bleed over the lead guitar and vocals a bit. Im ok with the softening of the cymbals because the other side of that is you hear the riff and and the vocals that follow it much clearer - that's the payoff I guess. Everyone here's things differently and like I said in the video, I know this song would divide people's opinion. I just think he's tried something different and it works for some and for others, less so.

If the remix of "Revolver" is a triumph as you detail then it creates anticipation for a remix of "Rubber Soul". And "Beatles for Sale," during the recording of which they began using unusual instruments.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yes with this new tech, who knows what is possible, Exciting times for us all

@adrianmist6681

Жыл бұрын

I too am looking forward to a remix of Rubber Soul although I would like a more radical remix than we're probably going to get, imagine the drums and bass sounding like they do on Revolver, imagine the guitars on Day Tripper sounding like PaperbackWriter! But sadly that may be pushing it too far for some people and I'm not sure that it's even possible.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@adrianmist6681 I guess Giles is on to a hiding to nothing. he's never going to please everybody, especially the old school types who don't believe anyone should be tampering with the holy grail. Im very much pro the tampering - I want these things to sound the very best they can so that they have the audio quality that matches the quality of the songs themselves. A really good stereo mix should be the new holy grail . Thanks for your comment Adrian.

@richardblayneamerican8149

Жыл бұрын

Can't wait for 'Rubber Soul', the first album of all-Beatles songs and my absolute favorite. Just to hear Lennon's voice through both speakers in stereo on the song, 'Girl'. So many incredible songs on that album! Did I say I can't wait?

@jnagarya519

Жыл бұрын

@@adrianmist6681 I live for a remix of "Beatles for Sale". And I imagine "A Hard Day's Night" and "Help!" were rather fast mixes. (George Martin wrote that "Help!" was the first actual stereo recording -- "The Beatles," flummoxed, asked, "Why TWO speakers!?"-- and that it was a mess.) And I wonder if they'll get around to the live BBC recordings . . .

Meine Meinung über yellow submarine, auch wenn er es nicht geschrieben hat, ist es immer Ringos Song. Lg von Ellen ❤ ✌I write you in some day(s)...you know this...stereo I have..lg from Germany 🎼🎶🎸🎹

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Stimmt Ellen.

@ellenbeckmann4293

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel hello,and today we're gonna have a good time...✌❤lg Ellen 🎼🎶nice week end..

I love this remix by Giles..he's done a fantastic job over the last 5 years with all these excellent box sets..I'm struggling to pick a favourite of all the 5 sets so far..this is definitely my go too listen now.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Yeah Go to for me too . I do think this is his best one so far - not the best box set, but the best remix. I thought he worked wonders with Let it Be as well. Thanks for your comment Colin

@Colinsdroneadventures1968

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel no problem..Let it be is outstanding..you will have to rank the box sets as an overall package Tone.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@Colinsdroneadventures1968 yes maybe one for the future Colin

@vicbertfartingclack4559

Жыл бұрын

For me the remixed White Album had the most impact. I love what Giles did there.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@vicbertfartingclack4559 In the main he got that one spot on. Im not sure about Helter Skelter though, that has lost something for me. I prefer the 2009 Abbey Road to Giles remix though

Hi Tone I love Yellow Submarine. I listened to the Eggpod podcast the other day which covers the sessions tracks. It gives a different interpretation of the song now we know John sang it originally. Given that John sings “No one cared” the interpretation is of a young boy who dreams of his absent Dad away at sea, who invents fantastic adventures for his Dad away at sea. It’s really changed how I think of this song, and the podcast is well worth a listen. Overall I love this mix, Giles best so far I think. On a separate issue I am rapidly getting George’s back catalogue on vinyl. I am awaiting LITMW which looks mint and is on the Capitol label interestingly, and also Extra Texture. What are your thoughts on Ex Tex? Best wishes Andrew

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Hi Andrew I agree deffo the best remix so far. Also agree that the yellow sub demos are mega interesting - more of that in the next video. Im afraid Extra texture is an album that I have never been able to find a way to love. there are a couple of good moments 'Tired of midnight Blue' is great as is "this Guitar' and 'You'. The others have never really grabbed me in any way. maybe its time to revisit it

@davirave9282

Жыл бұрын

Absolutely spot on. Yes Totally different realisation on Y.S know. This certainly sticks one up to the negative criticism back in the day. Shows the real genius that Lennon brought to the best band ever.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@davirave9282 A real genius for sure.Its a term that is bandied about too easily these days, but Lennon was a true genius without a doubt

Oh -- this is a fun video! My memory of the world changing from black-and-white to color was with the election - I was 12-years-old -- of JFK. Even though our TV was black-and-white.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

nicely put

The remix of She Said, She Said is the only fail for me. The drumming is buried in the center and you can't really appreciate it compared to the original mix. I think Yellow Submarine sounds better on the 2015 remix, but I skip that track anyway. I totally agree that "Rain" deserves a place on the album instead of YS.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Fair enough Allison, its interesting how we all hear things differently but I knew this song would divide people's opinion. It took me a while to get used it. For what its worth I prefer this mix of YS just because its got all the bits on it that were left of in error on all the other stereo mixes. Glad you agree with inclusion of Rain. How that song got thrown away as a b side is criminal . thanks for a great comment

I like the version without the cowbell best now, lol !

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

aww you can never have enough cowbell 😂

Tone your black and white into color nailed it. You didn't have to say a word after that. This remix sounds so good to me, we are definitely lucky Peter Jackson's group got involved, the end product was magnificent. The only downside I felt was that Tomorrow Never Knows wasn't different but like you said it was near perfect as it was. I don't do comparisons myself so I really enjoyed listening to yours. Looking forward to the next one. Take care!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Thanks Sharon. glad you enjoyed the review . I think a lot of people went early with their reviews without listening to it properly. It needs to be devoured and considered to do a proper review. I think the remix is stunning, such an improvement on what we had and youre right Peter Jackson's tech has brought this album back to life. best remix so far for me.

Doctor Robert y Yellow Submarine, parecen ser mejores canciones de lo que creíamos!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

si parece que es asi Jorge

The best stereo of 1966 Revolver is Geoff Emericks/George Martins mix of 1966 Revolver. The best Stereo CD Mix of Stereo Revolver is the 1987 Mix of Revolver. The best mono lp/cd mix of Revolver is the 2022 mix of Revolver. Giles did fabulous with what he had to work with and yet still please Beatles fans!

Adding Rain right before She Said would have been too samey. It’s perfect just like it is. Now that I have this remix I can’t imagine listening any other way.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Me neither, definitely my go-to version now

The 1987 will be lower volume and uncompressed. The 2009 compressed and cleaned up. The 2022 is even more compressed but remixed using cutting edge digital manipulation!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

1987 less compressed to some degree maybe but still suffers from the awful panning which the 2022 doesn't and that I guess , is the point

@KRAZEEIZATION

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel It’s hard to listen to 60s stereo recordings with headphones because of the imbalances of drums/bass left and vocals/guitars right. I did enjoy the 2022 because it sounds like it was recorded in the 70s!

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@KRAZEEIZATION Hopefully when Giles gets to the end of this project we won't need to listen to those early stereo mixes any more

"For No One" is definitely Dylan influence -- an emotional place illuminated by him.

So the first time one listen's one shouldn't bother to put one's socks on.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

😂😂😂

I didn't like this remix. This is different but not better or worse. I like the original. I played this once and have zero interest in playing it again. It's my favourite album . Paperback Writer was not good. Lost all its punch and the original vocal trick before each chorus isn't the original sound at all. I liked Pepper remixed but George Martin really was the guy for this stuff. Not saying his son is worse.Just a 2022 version but I have the original planted in my brain.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

Well I guess everyone hears things differently Steve but id never chose to have vocals and instruments panned to one side of the sound stage or the other in a stereo mix. I will be reviewing Paperback Writer and Rain remixes in my next video

@es330

Жыл бұрын

@@beatleytonesbeatleschannel I thought the hard pans were on the first 4 albums but then again I quite them too. The monos have a lot of punch.I really like the Dexter versions too. You cant kill a beatle recording no matter how hard you try. The songs are impervious.

@beatleytonesbeatleschannel

Жыл бұрын

@@es330 There are several songs that suffer from panning on the album. I detail those in the video and how they have been improved

@vicbertfartingclack4559

Жыл бұрын

You just described many of my issues with this remix perfectly. For me, besides She Said being a disappointment I find Tomorrow Never Knows to have lost its punch and impact. PPW is fine but not better than the “1” remix or 2009. The new Rain mix is very good however. Revolver is my favourite LP of all time so I’m picky.

@es330

Жыл бұрын

@@vicbertfartingclack4559 I agree the 1 remix was very good.And reveolver is the best album ever. I listened to this Revolver again and it's ok but the original will do me. Geoff Emerick said in his book years ago that there's not much you can do with the early remixes. And he is right. Btw that mono remix of Tomorow Never Knows that came out years ago is fantastic. So there are enough remixes and remasters to satisfy us all but I do like George Martins take on it all the most. It's in my memory. No mix can kill a Beatles song.