Great video guys! Haha…I laughed at your comment regarding cobblers resoling Doc Martens “…they probably can resole them. They just don’t want to.” Yep…1000%! 😁 They’re just a pain.

@matttherrien9608

2 жыл бұрын

Somebody better damn well resole my Horween Docs! lol.

@AuslanIz

2 жыл бұрын

Rose Anvil and Trenton & Heath Sub here! 👍🏻👍🏻

@Psycho-Ssnake

2 жыл бұрын

Now I want to see a Trenton & Heath video resoling docs. Just for the fun of watching you guys have to do it for a video.

@matttherrien9608

2 жыл бұрын

I think the masses have spoken. Please make a video on Dr Martens!

@julianshepherd2038

2 жыл бұрын

If you want an old school DM then look at Solovair

I agree that Bean boots don’t look very good, but they’re not made for fashion- they are made for hunting in New England, a task they excel at. The fact they are still made in America and relatively inexpensive as boots go makes them a big win in my book.

@user-kb7ij6ye8u

Жыл бұрын

They're horrible hunting boots...

@bolandjd

Жыл бұрын

@@user-kb7ij6ye8u Oh, well that settles it. The world famous hunter Gel Mibson has spoken.

@thedinkmaster4545

Жыл бұрын

@@bolandjd always negative people trying to ruin peoples days

@capnspicy5565

Жыл бұрын

@@bolandjd Agreed, But... Now that I'm grown up I kinda like the look. However the super chunky rubber snowmobile boots with the felt liners, Them things were and still are ugly and uncomfortable.

The LL Bean boots are great work boots if you are a landscaper/gardener, muck out livestock stalls, or do anything where your feet are wet or muddy a lot. They don’t rot out like leather boots, or take forever to dry. For city rain and fashion, yes, there are better options.

@amishjim

2 жыл бұрын

They're not comfortable on hard surfaces at all. They are a field boot.

@seancoyote

Жыл бұрын

Way too high of a fashion expectation for a boot that shines for being able to stand in poop for 12 hours.

@MrHeathendragon

Жыл бұрын

Yeah exactly. They are more of a duck boot as well. They are meant for people that need their feet to be partially or completely submerged for a long time without getting jungle rot

@jbeezostl

Жыл бұрын

I like the upper and the rubber. I hate the ramen noodle looking outsole.

@davidparker9676

Жыл бұрын

@@seancoyote I don't get the impression that either of these millennials have actually worked a day in their lives. These metrosexuals are just using work boots as a fashion accessory to attempt to look more masculine.

That thumbnail tho

@ee4396

2 жыл бұрын

love your channel!

I was a Bean boot hater until I moved up to New Hampshire and had to deal with real winter and then "mud season." I'm a big fan of fashion meeting function and Bean boots are the perfect example of that. Spend enough time in NH, VT and ME and you'll be wearing the uniform in no time. Those boots make me feel invincible come winter. Bean boots in Manhattan on a rainy day? I can see the argument.

@AHungryHunky

Жыл бұрын

Yup, Western PA here. I don't own beans but Ive owned a couple pairs of boots with a similar style. No one is going to compliment your boot with that rubber lower half, but your dry warm feet will compliment you all day and your favorite pair of leather boots will compliment your ugly boots for taking the abuse from the salt. There's just a certain point, late December through January, where fashion just no longer applies. Although looking out my window now, might be fashion goes away mid November this year.

@MAGAMAN

Жыл бұрын

Those LL Bean boots are hideous. It's like a cross between a girl's boot and a rummer boot. There are a lot of other boots that are waterproof and weatherproof that look like real boots and not something you would see in a drag queen story hour.

@NLSkooch

7 ай бұрын

Yeah, that dude lives in NYC. I have lived in NH for 30 years and wear my Bean Boots every day in the winter. You also need to learn how to wear them without tieing them. They look much better that way.

@mrschuyler

6 ай бұрын

Bean boots are kind of like keopectate: Tastes horrible, but it works.

@SassyTheSasquatch96

17 күн бұрын

@@MAGAMAN I could bench your whole body weight.

As a guy from Western New York, you are dead wrong about the Bean boots. With the amount of salt they dump up here, I don’t wear Goodyear welts from November to April.

@jeremyhershberger3012

2 жыл бұрын

There's definitely a place for bean boots. Keeping the salt off is a great example of their use but they do lack the comfort of a leather boot. If your budget allows I recommend a silicone infused leather boot.

@timbuck2406

2 жыл бұрын

I think the main issue with this video is it’s just opinions and people may take this as more then that. If you don’t like bean boots you’re not wrong about anything and vise versa.. stridewise always fails to provide any reasoning why he doesn’t like something other then he just doesn’t like it because for whatever reason it didn’t work out for him.

@sd26001

2 жыл бұрын

Right on Bro. I live in the upstate NY Capital Region and fished with my Bean boots from fall to winter, until the lakes froze, and they worked like champions. The hell with NYC hipster BS.

@exexpat11

2 жыл бұрын

LaCrosse Rubber Muckers. Ankle high and can be found in steel toe. The Bean and the LaCrosse are work boots and not fashion boots.

@aradoran

2 жыл бұрын

Is the salt that bad on GYW boots? Why not just have a couple of dedicated commando sole winter boots?

Bought a pair of Doc Martens 1460 Greasy’s 4 years ago. Conditioned them once before wearing. I’ve worn them through harsh Canadian winters (and hot summers), and I constantly get people thinking they’re new. No problems whatsoever. When they get dirty I literally just wipe them off with my hand. Best $200 CAD I ever spent.

@mfchris8026

Жыл бұрын

They made in England?

@cvfunnsixspeed9213

Жыл бұрын

@@mfchris8026 Same here; mine are not made in England. Wish they were, but no.......great luck with them. I used their leather conditioner not long after purchase. I understand the 1/2 size issue since I wear a 10.5 US size. But the 10 in England/Europe size fit me perfect. Perhaps I was lucky.

@mattblah7737

Жыл бұрын

Loll you guys are so cucked. I cant imagine ever mentioning that ny denomination is USD

@breahjade

Жыл бұрын

Right I got a patent leather pair 4 years ago, at the store in NYC where they are from Brittan and fell in love with them, I wore them 4-5 times a week for years and they still look and Feel brand new, I still wear them at least once a week or a second pair of them with flower embroidery on the side, I bought at the mall and say that are made in some other country, they have worn the same way, I will say the flowers do look dirty and some of the stitches are lose in the decoration design but again they still look amazing.

@DJFAmenHeavy

11 ай бұрын

Dr Mrtens are fantastic. Haters gonna hate though 😂

Fun fact, similar to the boots, Harley Davidson uses their previously good name to sell sub par bikes too! So the boots do match the primary product!

@admechskitarii6967

10 ай бұрын

To be fair, the issue isn't so much the bikes being bad as them being antiquated. They're built like tanks, but way overpriced for what they offer

@chinatownboy7482

9 ай бұрын

@@admechskitarii6967 Nothing like paying top dollar for a bike with 50 year old technology. My Harley still has a carburetor.

@elobiretv

7 ай бұрын

and I bet unlike he said here Harley people will buy these. Everyone knows Harley riders only buy the bike so they can cosplay as they're favourite Sons of Anarchy character

I love the LL Bean boots. They are confortable, at least on humid terrain, they are great on snow as well, can be bought with insulation or not, the construction is really solid, and you can wash them both in 10 seconds without having to take care of them at all. I think they are too iconic to be ugly. Those have a purpose, and that purpose isn't to bring your labradoodle for a walk when it's raining in the upper east side.

@NLSkooch

7 ай бұрын

This dude probably has a French bulldog.

I wore Doc Martens for most of my Police career but all of a sudden, when they became Trendy, they went narrow fitting and I couldn't wear them anymore. The inner sole also started wearing through quickly. I spoke to the staff in the shoe shop where I used to buy them and they told me there had been a definite redesign and many people had found the same problem. Needless to say I never bought them again.

@nobbynoris

Жыл бұрын

It's true. You just can't kick the heads of striking miners in in Ugg boots.

@rogerwilson6367

Жыл бұрын

@@nobbynoris True. I just couldn't get a good run up.

@Murtagh653

Жыл бұрын

i think the worst part is that they lie about it. when you ask them if there has been a material change (newer leather is thinner than old leather) they say there has been no change, and that it is the same material, but that is clearly not the case.

@rogerwilson6367

Жыл бұрын

@@Murtagh653 Agreed

@a6m41

7 ай бұрын

@@rogerwilson6367 Get solovairs and your sorted their matte finish looks better too imo

Docs were once a brilliant boot back in the eighties. I still have my 12 high black pair I bought in 1981. I have had the soles replaced but the uppers still look great thanks to regular cleaning and polishing. They are head and shoulders above my new Docs.

The LL Bean Maine hunting shoe is a great boot for what it is. Thick socks and proper care and they last. I’ve had mine for over 25 years with resoles 2x and they are wonderful wet and winter weather boots and upland hunting.

@CruelSun69

2 жыл бұрын

Agree

@CruelSun69

2 жыл бұрын

I think he made a good explanation stating he just hates the way they look. I think they don't look too bad and they are good boots.

@TommyNitro

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, I thought that one was a bad call. Forget the aesthetics, if they’re functional for what they were designed and well made (they are) then they are a good boot.

@CrimeVid

Жыл бұрын

Doc Martens,are crap, but you must realise that they are made for forklift drivers and warehousemen. They are made for working on concrete,not rough ground, the aircells are meant to cushion your feet on the hard,hard going on the loading dock !

@JJ-zr6fu

Жыл бұрын

@@CrimeVid No Doc Martens are made for fashion and they were originally made for gardening

I wore Doc Martens for about 30 years, but after the last pair; and after comparing them to my Redwings, I never will again. They are fashion tat, sold to people that don't know any better. I'll admit, I was one of them until I clued myself up. Doc Martens should be ashamed of themselves, especially since Solovair is quickly making a name for themselves selling similar boots, better made, and at a similar price point.

@edrader746

2 жыл бұрын

you were happy with them for 30 years means something

@xenophon1999

2 жыл бұрын

@@edrader746 I was, I loved them for years but the quality deteriorated over that time unfortunately, I have a pair of Solovairs now which capture the look and feel of those older Doc Martens as they are made by the company that used to make Doc Martens before they decided to cut costs.

@GertTown

Жыл бұрын

@@xenophon1999 they didn't cut costs, they moved most manufacturing to Asian hellscapes. They still make a few in england like 1460s but you pay alot more than Asian 1460s

@jabezhane

Жыл бұрын

Yeah you could by a 8 hole pair in a UK hardware store in the 80's for like £30 and they would last for years. But I won't pay £150 for a pair made in a sweatshop.

@malthuswasright

Жыл бұрын

@@GertTown They moved manufacturing to cut costs! Duhh!!!

I live in a cold climate and like my bean boots for ice fishing as long as I put ice cleats on over them for traction. My everyday work footwear is red wing. I can't recommend those boots enough. My current pair is going on 8 years with a few new soles.

Brilliant video and totally agree with your views on the brands and for the reasons you mentioned.Especially the first two brands mentioned and i can support that out of personal experience. Need more people like you guys who know thier stuff and can call out these companies and the dodgy stuff they sell at rip-off prices. Well done guys. Good work.

As an Englishman I should be defending the Doc Martens, but I agree 100% with everything you said. Maybe they were good once, but they have no structure, they’re bad quality, no style and they’re not even that cheap. I do hope England isn’t associated too much with Doc Martens. We have some amazing boot and shoe manufacturers here. I’m desperate to see Weston cut some Tricker’s or Loake 1880s in half. That would be interesting.

@robertsandgren9389

2 жыл бұрын

Loake 1880s look great!

@Lord_Mad_Dog

2 жыл бұрын

if you want better docs that are actually still associated with england, then solovair is the way to go. also i would like to see Weston cut some england shoes/boots like church's or crockett and jones

@sharpyt1

2 жыл бұрын

Would love to see that! The Loake 1880 range are built like tanks, and you can often pick them up pretty cheap. I'd also like to see the iconic Trickers Bourton chopped up!

@julianshepherd2038

2 жыл бұрын

@@Lord_Mad_Dog I wore DMs fro 1978 to somewhere in the 90s. I bought some Solovair and they at least as good as the old DMs. Probably better.

@Fireclaws10

2 жыл бұрын

Docs are for fashion, not for doing any decent walking in. They've got great colours, great shine and just look good. They aren't chasing that old market anymore, and I don't think there's any shame in that. Solovair look the same, for the same price, but without the brand recognition. Docs are for fashion, pure and simple.

Love the collabs you two do together.!

You are spot on regarding Doc Martens. The soles can delaminate, the leather is super cheap and looks like plastic. Now when it come to the LLBean duck boots… you are way off. Those are not meant to be fashionable. They are meant to be functional. The other boots you suggest as alternatives are water “resistant”. The Duck Boot is water “proof”. You can stand in a bog all day with dry feet. Then you can simply hose them off. That is the ultimate in a water proof hunting boot that doesn’t require fussing with waxes, creams or silicones. The fact that you see them in NYC on rainy days is a nod to just how perfectly functional they are. In addition, there are some who admire the aesthetics simply because of their near perfect function. I’ve walked all over the bogs of Ireland and Scotland in mine… perfect boot for those occasions. Plus Made in Maine.

I had the rare square toe Doc Marten's over 30 years ago, because ya know when you're a punk rocker, ya had to have Docs. They were pretty comfortable and lasted for a good while. I got a new pair (green with round toe 1460) a few months ago, and you guys are right. Bad fit, cheap leather, etc.

@omegamanGXE

Жыл бұрын

There’s a square toe style bex sole boot sold on Doc Martens website right now

@BobPapadopoulos

Жыл бұрын

Edit: *when you're a poseur you gotta have Docs

@johnvoorhees7881

Жыл бұрын

@@BobPapadopoulos lmao 🤣. I had many boots when I was "posing". But I sure looked good! And the best ones were not Docs

If the only problem with LL Bean is the look and you think Gooodyear welt is as capable in heavy snow and the mess that comes with it, maybe you should spend some time in New England in February.

The GYW evolution: sneakers> Dr. Martens> Thursday boots> Red Wing/Wolverine 1000 milers> PNW boots/Viberg/Alden> Heritage Japanese brands/Northampton makers like EG and Crocket and Jones> bespoke shoes.

@Stridewise

2 жыл бұрын

Pretty accurate

@jdelorenzod2725

Жыл бұрын

No Grant Stone? ;)

Two great channels cooperating! :D P.S: I think chukkas can be a decent "all-round" shoe when travelling. Good-looking enough for restaurants, sturdy enough if you walk "off-road" and more suitable for a city then a proper service-boot. I recommend the Timberland Belanger EK+ Chukkas!

@bobjohnson6321

2 жыл бұрын

chukas are the easiest boots to wear with shorts

@danshakuimo

2 жыл бұрын

@@bobjohnson6321 I think it makes sense given their history. I just imagine a bunch of British soldiers with their shorts and pith helm and chukka books chilling somewhere in egypt

@MayonnaiseOreo

2 жыл бұрын

@@bobjohnson6321 Chukkas look awful with shorts IMO. General consensus is that it's a no-go to wear both together but obviously everyone has their own style preferences.

The LL Bean Boots are made to wear in the mud and rain for a n easy clean up. Duck hunting also comes to mind, but to be honest I can’t remember the last time I thought about those boots and didn’t realize they were still being made. Great video!🇺🇸

I think that Nick's comment on the LL Bean boot being ugly is in line with my sense that he isn't a fan of Trad/Prep aesthetic---I recall he made a similar comment on Barbour in his wax jackets video. Both the LL Bean boot and Barbour Bedale & Beaufort are essential wardrobe pieces for the historically New England prep lifestyle/look that is tied more to school and 'country/leisure and that is a bit different than the heritage style. which is more tied to historically blue collar work aesthetic.

@janerkenbrack3373

2 жыл бұрын

Right. As I mentioned in my comment to the video, people in cities wearing Bean Boots seemed to be trying to suggest they have a home upstate or a cabin in Maine. They are worn for New England country credibility.

@chrisk5321

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah and they're leaky and let your feet get cold as f*ck, lol.

@travisadams4470

2 жыл бұрын

Nick is a feminine guy who cares more about fashion than practical footwear

@apocalypsepow

6 ай бұрын

Throw in some vineyard vines or a&f lol

Worn Doc Martens for 46 years, best work boots for hod carrying ever, a pair of them only ever lasted 3 months before the soles fell off, but they were comfortable and cheap, well until students started wearing them and the price then quadrupled, also as you say when they stopped making them in Northampton in the UK and moved production to Asia the quality plummeted.

I live in the tropics so the chukka boots are one of my favorites to wear because your feet don't get as hot, and with ease of removal and putting on, they are just incredibly functional. Doc Martins are great for a teenage first pair of boots, just so you can say you had a pair.

@Stridewise

Жыл бұрын

Great point with chukkas and heat

The LL Beans are for the snow and slush , and chukkas are great to wear cycling or doing the grocery shopping. Sometimes I’m not sold on guys that review boots that have too many and don’t wear them for their intended purpose !

@Dave-nz4iu

2 жыл бұрын

I just realized you're right how he wears his boots. He actually said "You don't need a waterproof boot" .... lol Goodyear welt is fantastic for a lot things, but using them for stomping around icy puddles, snow banks and salt piles all winter bc BB are "ugly?" He's got to be kidding me.

@alittlemorefour5512

2 жыл бұрын

I agree! Bean boots are great for farm yard chores in the winter.

@radiationshepherd

2 жыл бұрын

Rose anvil did a snow boot video where he tested a few I believe

I reached the same conclusions: 1) Doc Martins are junk-cheap and floppy; and 2) don’t buy any boots with a brand famous for something else. Clarks don’t fall into that category, I also agree with you on Clarks. Desert boots are so unstructured, they’re uncomfortable and the gum sole provide surprisingly little cushion. My biggest complaint about desert boots is the terrible slip.

@janerkenbrack3373

2 жыл бұрын

I don't own any Clarke's, but I understand the made in England versions are better. I have desert boots made in Italy that Allen Edmonds use to carry, and I like them well enough for some casual settings. One thing is the crepe is much better quality, and the shoe is even a little heavy and stiff. The one place they really do shine is on sand, not surprisingly. Crepe is marvelous walking on the desert.

@julianshepherd2038

2 жыл бұрын

Dms are rap but Solovair are v good

@bladesfortheadpocalypse2370

2 жыл бұрын

@@janerkenbrack3373 USA military desert boots are the boots that work in the desert. Clark's are good for indoors. Anything harder than sand will tear large chunks from the sole. All style, no substance. There's a lot more rock and gravel in the desert than sand. And it hasn't rained in two years!

@janerkenbrack3373

2 жыл бұрын

@@bladesfortheadpocalypse2370 Oh boy. First, I said I don't own any Clark's. Second, I said it was crepe that was great on sand. And third, do you not know that it was crepe-soled desert boots that an Actual Clark saw being used in the desert during WWII and sent the design back home to the family business? He saw that they worked really well in the desert. I've walked on all kinds of desert surfaces in the books I have, and not a chunk is missing. And for the record, I wouldn't be caught dead in a pair of army boots. I wouldn't want to look like some kind of pretender.

@bladesfortheadpocalypse2370

2 жыл бұрын

@@janerkenbrack3373 I live in the desert wilderness, in a tent. I'm no pretender. Clark's are Crap. You are a greenhorn. And I wouldn't be caught dead in any boots, because I'm a Survivor.

Harley boots... it is sometimes said that HD is a t-shirt company that occasionally sells motorcycles. What you said about bikers is wrong. Many of them absolutely want to sport their favorite bike brand on their gear. Unfortunately, they also believe that their beloved HD only puts out quality stuff. That desire only goes so far, however. I worked at an Indian Motorcycle dealer a few years ago, and we started selling a Redwing boot that was simply an Iron Ranger with an Indian logo embossed into one side of the heel. It cost exactly the same as a non-branded Iron Ranger directly from Redwing. Unfortunately, customers scoffed that they were too expensive. Sadly, they want those cheep branded boots.

@albertvillalobos1377

2 жыл бұрын

these guys always talk out of their butt and make way too many wrong assumptions, seems like they have pretty limited perspective

Great info. New to both of your pages. Canada has a standard for boots to be sold as “safety footwear”. CSA approved with a green triangle stitched the footwear at the ankle. Maybe you have covered this. Looks like I have a few vids to review. I have a 30 year old pair of Dayton lace up service boots. They were my go to for almost 20 years. Helluva boot. Cheers

I've been out of the loop as far as boots go and am very glad I caught this video to know what to watch out for and why.

It's been a while since I've watched one of your videos. Well done! Fun video.

@Stridewise

2 жыл бұрын

Welcome back! Glad you liked it Chris

I spent my entire teenage years and tht first could twenties in the 90's, so I've owned 4-5 pairs of Dr Martens. Every single pair I owned had to soles split along the sides.

Here in the UK Dr Martens soles can be replaced by a shoe repair company called Timpson. The replacement soles are usually made in England, which is embossed on the sole. People who own vintage (1970s, 1980s) made in England Dr Martens are more likely to have the soles replaced as vintage Dr Martens are sought after, owing to their cult status and arguably better quality.

@robw4057

2 жыл бұрын

Dr Martens were brought out in the 90s. They are shocking! There is a mini-doc somewhere on KZread. Solovair boots are actually closer to the original DM's as you'll find out in the doc. 👍

@brianfindlay4280

2 жыл бұрын

@@robw4057 The latest acquisition of the Dr Martens brand was by private equity company Permira in 2013. Dr Martens under Permira opened a court case against Solovair to prevent them using the Dr Martens 'trade dress' of yellow stitching and groove pattern on the sides of the soles. Permira Dr Martens won the case. Now Solovair cannot use the distinctive yellow stitching and groove pattern on their boots. However, Solovair are still appreciated for being made in England and will replace sole units of worn boots for their customers.

@MrPeach18

2 жыл бұрын

Dr martens have been out since the 70s

@barfly946

2 жыл бұрын

Says just who, exactly ?

@MrPeach18

2 жыл бұрын

@@barfly946 Me, in fact they've been out since the 60s. I suggest you do some research

I bough a pair of Doc’s on a limited release UK. made 14 years ago. I had to buy then in a size 8 although I wear a size 8.5. I wore them a few times but they were too cramping on my feet so in the closet they went for 13 years. It was just this year that I started looking into good boots and how to break boots in that I decided to give the Doc’s a go with some leather stretching techniques I learned from people like you guys on YT. I finally got them fitting comfortably at this point and switch them out with a pair of much superior Thursday Captains. The Doc’s are nice in that they have a squishy sole and are rather soft but the ankle support is just not there and I have no doubt they will become very floppy in time. Those were my first and last pair of Doc’s I will ever buy. I now use them as working around the house boots and use them to give my Captains a rest to air out. I hope one day to buy a pair of Redwing IR’s or a pair of Grant Stone Diesels once my Captains wear out. Thanks guy’s for all the Greta video’s and information!

I first came across both Rose Anvil and Stridewise channels when I was researching whether Doc Martens are any good. I took your advice and bought Solovairs instead...and that was my gateway boot.

@Stridewise

2 жыл бұрын

Yess I love to hear this

@benoproductions2711

2 жыл бұрын

Yes! That is exactly the same situation for me. I’ve had my Solovairs for well over a year now, and they’ve actually held up pretty well! I don’t like how they use a fiberboard insole and corrected grain leather, but I still think that they are pretty decent boots for the price.

@julianshepherd2038

2 жыл бұрын

@@benoproductions2711 took long to wear it but will last like it's 1978

@martinsmith1525

2 жыл бұрын

@@benoproductions2711 Solovair have full grain versions, like the greasy leather and gaucho leather, both great quality full grain leathers and last long if looked after. I have several solovair and gripfast boots and walk a lot in them and they have not let me down yet. 🙂👍

@martinsmith1525

2 жыл бұрын

@@Stridewise I would love for you to do a review on gripfast and solovair greasy leather and gaucho leather boots. Both made in the same factory in Wollaston Northampton England that make excellent quality footwear. Great channel by the way and thank you. 👍

I’ve been wearing Clarks Chukka boots since 1966. They are sturdy, long lasting, require no break in, and have been a chick magnet for me. I use them in casual and semi casual fashion. They are great outdoor boots, and more dependable than my Nike’s. Only second to my Vintage Converse! Stay well and safe!!!

Thank you for your videos. Great job every time

Great and fun video. Thanks guys! I like hearing your casual take on this, hreat nob!!

I used to love Docs but after having a couple of pairs split along the sole I just can't do them anymore. Switched to Iron Rangers and am much more happy. I would have came out spending less money in the long run if I had just spent the money on the Red Wings in the first place. I did have to put Red Wing insoles in them. And chukkas look like peasant shoes from the middle ages to me.

@julianshepherd2038

2 жыл бұрын

Try Solovair

@CLOUDKID11

2 жыл бұрын

lol, "peasants from the middle ages" is the perfect description.

@bassheadlife492

2 жыл бұрын

My 10 year old docs are still in excellent condition

As someone from England who has owned several pairs of DMs over the years I say you are completely right. If ever there was victory of style over substance it is present day DMs. The "leather" cracks, I go through the soles in a remarkably short period of time and cannot get a proper fit. Safe to say don't but them any more, pity because they are cool :-(

@elenaziccarelli1295

Жыл бұрын

Try out solovairs

Bought a couple pair of Carhartts on clearance a few years back. The pu foam soles of my wellingtons are literally cracking and delaminating where it flexes behind the safety toe before I can even wear the tread off the heel. Glad I got 2 pair for less than MSRP of one.

LL Bean boots look cool af. Good to see you work with Rose Anvil!!

Surprised Caterpillar didn’t get an honorable mention.

When I was a kid I used to love Doc Martens 1460s because of their association with certain British subcultures (punk rock, skinhead, etc.). I tried on a pair I got probably a decade ago and I couldn't believe how uncomfortable they where. No wonder my feet used to ache so much. They used to be cheaply made and cheaply priced, now they are cheaply made and overpriced for what they are. The leather is hardly justifiable as leather and the soles wear out incredible quickly. I've worn out four pairs if 1460s in my life, my feet have paid for it, and I would not recommend them to anyone.

@grugg3108

2 жыл бұрын

It's not even that they were and are cheaply made. They were cheaply made, but they've gotten exponentially worse. Cheaper, thinner leather, no shank (and a bullshit excuse as to why), and if I'm not mistaken, they changed how they make the soles and they wear faster. The price rise was entirely on the back of the community they didn't cultivate. They ain't been good since the early 90s at least, but even then they were made to the standard of their price. Honestly it's one of the strongest betrayals I've seen a company give to the audience that came around them, snd then the audience just takes it. Edit: also I dig the pfp

I bought a pair of Chukkas on clearance from Thursday right before the Pandemic. I think I've worn them once? Aside from them just being a slight bit too large, I just don't really understand how to style them so I agree with you there.

Fair fair regarding the "Docs"... Dr Martin boots were my first pair of boots and I very much enjoyed them HOWEVER I moved to surplus military boots, then other makes and the Dr Martins don't stack up well when compaired to other boots.

I have black Clarks desert boots, and I think they look cool. But I had to add rigid insoles for more support.

@haydechman

2 жыл бұрын

I'd recomond people to check out the clarks bushacre boots. Exactly the same as the desert boots except with a harder sole. I got mine on sale for I think $60 as well.

@hejdingamleraev

2 жыл бұрын

@@haydechman There's a wedge sole version as well. Havn't tried them on but they look cool and you get around the no shank/support issue.

The LL Bean Boots fit into the category of ironically stylish where they're stylish because of utility, not unlike the path of Dr Martens (which started as orthopedic shoes), The Red Wing Iron Ranger and even Birkenstocks and Crocs.

I love my Red Wing work chukkas. Vans slip-ons used to be my go to shoes I wore daily but now the red wings took their place, except in the summer when if wearing shorts. I'm still not ready to fully embrace boots yet but I did pick up a pair of Timberland redwood falls moc toes and have been very happy with them so far for the sale price of only $105. I will upgrade to red wings or something of similar quality once the Timberlands wear out.

@stridewise Nick. I've got a small tip for your laces. The bow keeps turning out up and down. If you make the bow out to the tag end that you put over the top at first the bow will come out side to side. It's the difference in a square knot and a granny knot.

100% agree on the Dr Martins. I bought a pair a year ago, principally because I wanted a water resistant boot to wear round town in winter and, to be honest, I really liked the look. I was told they were really fiddly size-wise and didn't do half sizes (I'm usually 9.5 UK size), so I borrowed a pair of UK 9s from a friend, found them excruciatingly tight, and so ordered a size 10 instead. The 10s fit the general outline of my foot pretty well but are impossible to tie tight enough to stop my heel from lifting. The result is that they're excruciating to walk more than a mile in which, for a boot, is a nightmare. I ended up buying some fairly cheap Helly Hansen boots later and they not only fit better, but were more comfortable and seem to be putting up to wear and tear better. The thing is the Dr Martins are so cool looking I can't quite seem to bring myself to throw them out, and even still put up with the discomfort of wearing them occassionally purely for the aesthetics of my outfit lol

@cyclingtexas1670

Жыл бұрын

Can you wear thicker socks? Maybe two socks? This should help with the heel slip.

@tomcooney183

8 ай бұрын

Put a decent orthotic insole in them, it will solve the sizing problem and also the complete lack of any cushioning they have

I got my first pair of Dr Martens in 1992, having begged for them as a birthday present. I really want to defend them because there is no other boot that looks as good or is as comfortable... Unfortunately, I've never had a pair last more than six months. I've been wearing army surplus, Magum and Dickies instead for years now.

@Benzyl

Жыл бұрын

I found Dickies a few years back as well but I've never had the toecap sole survive much past six months before peeling off.

Great to see you blokes together.

As a Londoner in the UK I'm with you when it comes to Docs. They're rubbish I used to wear them day after day for years. But when they started to make them overseas the quality went down. They just brought out a new boot that they say is their toughest boot yet. I'm not sure about that? But one thing I have noticed in the past when I'm in the Doctor Martin's shop a few staff don't wear Docs. I've seen them wearing Solovair. Out of Docs or Solovair I would go for Solovair as they look like Docs but they're made a bit better and have a softer sole so feel better to walk around in. Plus they're still made here in England. I have a few pairs of Soliloair's and for work I go with Magnum boots. It would be interesting to see a tear down of any of the Magnum boots from the classic's to the Elite Shield or just any of their boots? I wear them for work as they are a tough boot. Still quite light. Leather or leather with other stuff depending on what you buy? Slight trainer feel. Don't need much wearing in you can wear all day from the first day especially the Viper's. And some even come in fire resistant sloes. Leather and laces. And they will last quite a while.

I gotta say, my first pair of 1460s, I loved them. But my most recent pair are from the new manufacturing and they ARE different, no matter what Doc Martens says. They are two years old now and STILL give me heel blisters, the leather is so stiff. The old ones I walked for miles in, and wore into the ground and they never hurt my feet, but these ones do. So I call BS on them claiming that they're the same quality as they used to be.

@ralex3697

Жыл бұрын

Maybe your foot is the problem

@no-barknoonan1335

6 ай бұрын

I do agree their quality has dropped, but where on your foot are you getting blisters? To be honest, better made boots with thicker leather, those are only going to give you more blisters. Yes Doc's are cheap and thin, that's what makes them more pleasant to wear out of the box. The break in period is short, that foam they have around the ball of the foot really helps with initial comfort, no high quality working man boots are going to provide you with that. Are you wearing long socks of normal thickness? I would recommend an insole perhaps? If these give you blisters, I don't see how better made boots won't give you blisters, they'll probably give you more. You need to condition your feet to wear boots, increase the quality of your socks, or consider that perhaps this may not be for you. Edit: if the blisters are around the heel, try tying the laces much more tight. You should have zero heel bob, the heel should be essentially static.

@NCrdwlf

5 ай бұрын

I had some 8 eyelet greasy 1460s that were great . They were bought in 83 . My new ones have crap leather .

I was not a boot wearer until this year. Never had a job where it made sense till this year. My first pair were Thursday Captains. Then I went and got Allen Edmonds Lombard. And just yesterday, I got my Grant Stone Diesel Cognac Ostrich.

@TSE_WOODY

2 жыл бұрын

The slippery slope of finding a world you didn’t realise could be as deep or as interesting as you thought, then just throwing all your money into it

@Stridewise

2 жыл бұрын

@@TSE_WOODY this guy gets it

@TSE_WOODY

2 жыл бұрын

@@Stridewise we’ve all been there with something. Boots, whiskey, coffee, beer, denim and the list goes on and on

@jimlittle5769

2 жыл бұрын

@@TSE_WOODY Are you saying I made some bad choices here?

@TSE_WOODY

2 жыл бұрын

@@jimlittle5769 oh no man, financially that entirely depends on your situation I couldn’t say but none of those are a bad choice. It’s more that I found it funny how quickly we all seem to go from knowing nothing to owning 5 pairs of quality boots and inspecting the grain pattern and welt. Keep on keeping on bro.

Great video. I own both the 1460 Greasy Leather Dr Marten boots that are lined and they’re both comfortable and they fit perfectly with my 10.5 shoe size. Also own Bean Boots and they do have their limitations they are awesome. I actually own an unlined pair and a shearling lined pair that I purchased at an end of season sale.

@ieatciggies

Жыл бұрын

how are the docs holding up?

@bflathead

Жыл бұрын

@@ieatciggies They’re holding up well.. they’re in my rotation of boots and I wear them a few times a month. I like the flat black finish and the overall look of them.

My favorite boot to this day are my Aus Redbacks. They are insanely comfy and durable. Slip on, black leather, steel toe, slip resistant rubber outsoles. Simply beautiful for the price point as well. 160$ USD - 200$ USD typically. Love the black widow Logo as well. Just lovely. I wear them only for work, as I am an Engineer. I wear SB dunks, Dunk OG, Jordan OG Highs through 13's outside work so comfort I'm used to......and the boots totally are worth it.

@maddyg3208

Жыл бұрын

Good to hear, I must get some too. Workwear here in Aust is of a high standard. A redback is a spider that iconically lives in "back dunnies" (outdoor toilets associated with old houses). Its bite is often deadly and most people are scared of them, which is probably also why I've never owned a pair of Redback boots!

I wore Doc Martin's in the 90s when it was trendy. they were terrible and clunky. but it was all about that yellow stitching if you wanted to be a cool kid at school lol

Fully agreed on Docs. I have *only* owned MIE Dr Martens. And I can fully attest that the quality has gone down, the most evident aspect the omission of the shank. Sure it was wood. But at least it was a shank. And the soles in the older Docs seemed longer lasting. And I swear had more padding and molded more closely to the contours of ones feet, offering greater support. Oh well. Been tempted to try a pair of Solovairs, but am afraid of wasting my money. Oh well. I still have my Beckmans. Great job, guys, mahalo! 🤙🥾

@michaelmclarney1994

2 жыл бұрын

I agree, I used to walk everywhere as a teen in my Doc's, late 1970's and never wore the sole out, very comfy. If I had a pair of the same era, now, I would get them resoled. I keep my eyes open just in case I find some!

@donmuang76

Жыл бұрын

Solovair shoes are great. I used to wear docs all the time. Switched out, never going back. Solovair has a shank and better leather and made in England.

@michaelmclarney1994

Жыл бұрын

@@donmuang76 thanks Earl, I think Solovair are worth a try and will give them a go. It would be nice to have a 'go to' pair of boots again for every day use.

I own the Carhartt Wedge boot, the Doc Martens 1460 cocoa snowplow boots, the Desert Clark boots, and a pair of canvas grey Palladium Pampa boots (wore by the french legion army). The only pair that I have issues (no support) are the Clark Desert boots, even my podiatrist told me to stop wearing them, I am ok with the rest. I also wear western boots. You should do a review on the best 10 western boots. Love your channel content, Peace out!

When I was a kid, my parents made me wear the L.L. Bean boots...and I hated them. Frankly, I just didn't realize how cool they are. They are the embodiment of New England practicality in that they are cheap and they work. That they have become part of fashionable (somewhat "high/low) "preppy' style is rather surprising but somehow they managed it. As for Chukkas, they are best worn with short shorts, a camouflage t-shirt, and while carrying an FN rifle (shout out to the Rhodies out there).

Glad I don't own any of those! Checking out those whites MPs for my next pair!

@Stridewise

2 жыл бұрын

a very good buy!

@keenobservations3050

2 жыл бұрын

You will love Whites

My least favorite boot ive ever bought was the Platinum boot by Refrigiwear. The run small and have a composite toe so they never had a loose enough fit for the insulation to actually work. The quality of the construction is sub par too. The bit of a toe cap tore and lost its stitching pretty easily and the lack of counter cover made the heel wear out prematurely. After i had worn them to work and found out theyre trash, it was too late to return them. The terrible goodyear welt filling made them terribly uncomfortable too. I have tried many refrigiwear products working in a refrigerated warehouse and theyre all bad and over priced.

@jokly1264

2 жыл бұрын

Have you found a good option? I'd recommend trying the Muck Boots Artic Sport.

Try being a Diesel mechanic. They only last 6-9 months. Hyd oil and all kinds of grease and fluids soften the leather. I have 2 pairs. I use a boot warmer every day on my boots. Mechanics roll on the ground. The toes will wear a hole and the sides. I wore Danner boots for years because work paid for them. They were just ok. I use Redwing and they are the most comfy with upgraded soles. I wore martins in my late teens and early 20s in the 90s. They all spilt on the sides and wore down fast. These were the made in England ones. Nice video!

I’ve yet to find a cobbler who can do it right. The truth is it’s actually cheaper to buy a new pair of Doc Martens than pay the labor to have them resoled.😑

The LL Bean boot is a fashionable boot and a stable in any preppies closet.

my own experience in my country (iceland) with ll bean boots are just great.a lot better as sorel boots and whatever. mostly is it very wet at us,wet snow for this they are perfect,and what is important for me i can drive car with them,with sorel i can not bcs you get always the break&power pedal together. ll bean is not so whide outside. but im very happy if i dont need to wear this kind of boots at all. br from iceland

Yepp, followed the starting with doc martens narrative, loved them for a while, and the moment I got Red Wings there is no way back. I even fixed the outsole that went off for some price but I really couldn’t wear them any more, cause the aged rubber without a shank was just killing me.

Bought a pair of Docs around 1994. Loved them. They are still holding up.

Docs literally ruined my feet. Took YEARS to recover from the literal foot rot they caused. I’ve worn Redwings for 25 years everyday on concrete, expanded metal and greasy refinery muck. Up until recently they’ve been amazingly tough and perfectly waterproof. Well like everything else made in the US of A, they’ve shifted to offshore manufacturing and it’s KILLED the quality. I’ve got a pair of Nick’s builder Pros on order with my fingers crossed.

@theunqualifiedgamer2344

2 жыл бұрын

heavywall im not sure if you need american boots but look up rufflanders by william lennon and co! handmade by one of 12 people in a little british factory theyve had the same machines over 110 years! awesome company to deal with!

@bushisahomo

2 жыл бұрын

you won't be disappointed with Nick's , the upgrade is going to be crazy. but what red wings did you own that were made offshore? I thought a lot of then were still US made

@TommyNitro

2 жыл бұрын

The heritage lines and some of their work lines are US made. But a lot of the work lines are not made here.

@Heavywall70

2 жыл бұрын

@@bushisahomo the model number is 2408, they are assembled here but now they’re saying made of imported materials so it could be anything really, the leather, thread or urethanes that make up the sole. I have a pair that is roughly four years old and they’re not holding up as well as the older “all American” pair. I have one pair that are very old and have been refurbished by redwing multiple times but as I age (and my feet age particularly) I need a heartier sole and upper.

@Heavywall70

Жыл бұрын

@Starcell I did, as I said, but now I don’t because I bought high quality boots that keep my feet clean and dry. Docs are not actually work boots any longer and haven’t been for quite some time. It’s a shame really, given their origin.

What’s weird is I’ve been wearing the same pair of doc martens as workboots for the past few years. And while I can’t speak for the quality of the materials, they’ve survived many elements while fitting my feet really well. Maybe there are better boots I could be wearing, but I know I’ll get at least another couple years out of my docs

@9HighFlyer9

2 жыл бұрын

One of the best pair of boots I wore while working at a cemetery/crematorium were Doc Marten steel toe. The company gave us a $100 stipend every 6months for boots. The only problem I had with them was sometimes I would leave the crematory with things melted into the sole.

@michaeldeguzman8675

Жыл бұрын

i just bought a pair of doc work boots in march and i love'm, but let's see after a couple years.

@chrispekel5709

Жыл бұрын

@@9HighFlyer9 hopefully not body parts

I'd love to see you guys review/tear down hiking boots. Etc Salomon, Merrell and so on

Honestly I love using Chucka boots at work in a warehouse. enough protection, comfort, and longevity in a situation where i do need a 'work' boot, but barely so.

I agree. The brands that do something other than boots slapping their logos on it. Please just partner with a great boot brand and say special edition

Agreed. I used to love doc martins. After getting more expensive boots, docs are not the best

I didn’t know stridewise, was subscribed to anvil, now subscribed to both. Nice work!

@Stridewise

2 жыл бұрын

Hooray! Glad you made it over, Wade!

My only experience with DM’s has been with the work boots. My dad, an HVAC tech, had Wellingtons, so wanting to be like him, I got Wellingtons. I *still* have those boots, and I love my Ironbridges. Maybe the work boots are of a better stock, though I still can’t wait to get some actual upper tier boots.

After wearing Bean boots for a few years, I've come to realize that the waterproofness is totally countered by my feet sweating like trout. They quickly became the smelliest shoes I own.

@dontworrybehappy8080

2 жыл бұрын

Not comfortable for fulltime wear at all.

@Ckons

Жыл бұрын

You’ll find that’s true for waterproof boots.

@brownieboy69101

Жыл бұрын

Trout don't sweat.

What a great video. I don’t like to pile on, but Docs get my biggest raz. The last (Made in England)pair I bought was disgraceful. I have to defend LL Bean boots, I wear them all the time out in the woods, and when doing farm chores. They are cheap and last forever. Are they appropriate to wear in the City? I don’t think so. Highly entertaining content, keep it up!

@janerkenbrack3373

2 жыл бұрын

Much the same take I had on Bean Boots in my comment.

@chrispekel5709

Жыл бұрын

You can wear them in the city if you've got an upturned beanie, an earring or 3 (preferably one in your nose) and a thin moustache.

Doc Marten’s were popular with those who had to be on their feet walking around for long periods such as Police Officers, I was in the military and kept a pair of high leg Doc Marten’s for when I was doing foot patrols around our base, would never consider them for wearing on operations but they were perfect for pounding around the base.

Thank you for open my eyes 👀 Great vídeo , congratulations 👏

I'm 40 but at 17 I had doc Martin boots ,, I have fond memories I thought they were super comfortable and durable , my largest gripe was getting my foot into out of was always a task with lacing and unlaceing just alot of work lol

Y'all gonna make a favorite 5 boots?

I’ve never torn a pair apart, but my kids had Doc Marten’s in 1995 and they were pretty good. I bought a pair the next year. Fast forward to 2019 and their kids wanted a pair. They were pure garbage. The ‘leather uppers’ weren’t. The tongue and the pretend leather where the eyelets are are plastic. The stuff passing as leather is horrible

@AkuraTheAwesome

Жыл бұрын

They changed from making them in the UK through Solovair to making them abroad because it is cheaper. Buy Solovair, they're basically old school decent Doc Martens.

@pissant145

Жыл бұрын

They made some weird quality change in the early 00's. I hated the new crappy boots but with the original price tag. My 1994 boots stayed glued to my feet for seven years. Had to get a new pair in 2002, they were crappity crap crap.

Such an interesting breakdown of different boots. I was surprised overall about the Docs. Would you be willing to review the Thursday boot company? I’d love to see your analysis for the price point. Great information as per usual. 😻

@brian.phillips1985

2 жыл бұрын

He's reviewed Thursdays before, he thinks highly of them.

Almost every boot showed on both of each channels did not sell here in Brazil. Even that happens, it’s nice to know this content to avoid any further mistakes.

It is laughable that you compare an AE Chapman to the LL Bean boot for how waterproof they are. They have different uses. I would not wear a Chapman when out in slushy snow, but I would wear the LL Beans. You should just say you don't like the style.

I actually look LL Bean boots. That felt personal to put them in this list haha

I have wide feet and I love my Docs, I wear them for aesthetics over needing them to work though, Docs are in half sizes also but for some reason its not each size I know they do 9 1/2 & 6 1/2 versions of the 1460 :)

Great breakdown as always -- what henleys are you rocking?

I'd like to say that the main problem I have with doc martens is the fit. The horrible leather is fine, it's overpriced, whatever. Won't last, yeah. But the fact that absolutely no size of them actually fits my feet is unforgivable. No half sizes or wides means that I'm wearing a size that's half a size too big, and the tongue is still stiched low enough to absolutely murder the tops of my feet with my thinnest or thickest socks on. Unforgivable. Just terrible boots, even at the low price.

@mikecole4924

Жыл бұрын

You hit the nail on the head here. These are exactly my experiences also. My feet were too big for the 8s and too small for the 9s and the tongue connection to the toe never came right. Horrendous boots.

@pokachan3451

10 ай бұрын

and no arch support, and I get odd heel pain after several days of wearing DMs

I was 100% on board until your special mention of Chukkas. I don't care for CBDs, but I like the upper style of chukkas as a dressier boot. I have a pair of Sanders & Sanders Chukkas that are fantastic: Goodyear welted, studded rubber (Dainite) sole, great construction.

@actontreadway1168

2 жыл бұрын

Incorrect. All chukkas are bad.

...and Bean boots, despite their recent popularity, weren't designed to look good. They were designed as a hunting boot, primarily meant to keep your feet dry while doing that.

Chucka’s are perfect for a summer day and they can go semi formal down so completely casual plus their lightweight for those hot desert days like we get in the Oregon outback and a day at the beach. Their vintage Ive been wearing them for decades

I find the aesthetic panning of Bean boots amusing. I would much rather wear those than any of the Italian style shoes. They are too gaudy and pretentious. A classic Bean boot is clear about its functionality and doesn't try and hide behind a facade.

Great upload! I wore Doc Martens at school in the late 1970's UK. They were very comfortable from the off, no breaking in required and were hard wearing. I bought some again around 1986 and they cut the heels off me after 4 hours of wear; I still have the scars! I haven't bought Docs since but am tempted by Solovair boots. They are the company in Northampton that made the original Doc Martens but due to licensing, have had to rebrand. Have you any thoughts or knowledge on these please, as they are too expensive to take a chance buying them?

@metzthagoat9219

Жыл бұрын

rose anvil did a video on them, and i personally love my pair that ive worn almost daily for a year now.

@michaelmclarney1994

Жыл бұрын

@@metzthagoat9219 thanks for the recommendation, they sound like what Docs used to be like.

I actually like to wear certain chukkas with jeans. I don't like the shiny, dressy chukka boots, but a more casually styled pair is a lightweight, comfortable option to wear with jeans when you don't want to wear a full boot. If you don't cuff your pants halfway to your knees, you can't tell how tall the boots are anyway. They just wear like a nice pair of shoes 🤷‍♂️. What you'll never catch me in is sneakers, unless I'm exercising.

1000% agree with my 23 years’ experience of wearing Docs! People look at me like I’m nuts, but as someone who has been wearing them since I was 12; and, bought them in my 20s, especially for hard work in kitchens- they’re not safe, no one will resole them. I’d bought them specifically to have for dozens of years to be resoled - and within a couple of years weren’t even safe to wear to work. All of mine were made in The UK 🇬🇧 and it still didn’t make a difference.

@paralyzerfingereleven

Жыл бұрын

just get solovair or gripfast