I feel as if the test wasn't as solid as it could be. You stated the door had no weather strips, therefore, that would be the bottleneck in the test. Regardless of how good the door sweep would be, at a certain point, the sound that would've been blocked by the weather strips overcame the soundproofing of the door sweep. Having a hollow door vs a solid core would do the same but, I'm not sure which one you said it was.

i love this video, EXACTLY what i have been needing to see

I have a door with a gap that goes from 1 1/16" on one side to 1 7/16" on the other, which is larger than the maximum gap these recommended sweeps will accommodate. I'm having trouble finding similar sweeps that will work for me. If anyone has any suggestions, I'd appreciate it. Thank you!

Thanku for this video! :) Im renting a room in a house and really needed to close the hige gap on the door

@soundproofguide

2 жыл бұрын

You’re welcome! Hope you find the product you’re looking for! Let me know how it turns out! 😊

not sure where i saw it, but some company makes one of those rigid rubber sweeps (the one you first showed) that can be retracted upward for when not need. it stays in place with magnets and i wish i knew who made it.

If the strips wear out, then will replacing the strips wear down the bottom of doors over time?

Thanks for doing this video I'm currently building a theatre room and I've been debating on getting a door sweep for the theatre room door

One I got that slides under the door is a tad bit more wide than the door, but it’s supposed to screw into the door. Is this it ok if the width is a tiny bit more than the door for this?

Will this mess up your central ac system since it blocks the flow of air?

I think the "Winner" door sweep you link to in the show notes is a different product on Amazon vs. Home Depot. I think the Home Depot one (Cinch 36 in. White Vinyl U-Shape Slide-On Under Door Seal) is the one you show in the video. The Amazon one (KS Hardware Double Bubble Door Sweep) requires screws and may have other differences.

Thank youuuuuuuu

Hey how it going loved the video and I am happy you finally made this video because my gaming room door has a HUGE GAP under it and the room is right next to a bathroom, kitchen and two other bedrooms

The slide on winner was actually in the mid-fifties so it cut noise a lot better than the other ones

Li like the video. Did you ever try a flat door sweep screwed into the inside and outside the door?

Jesus. The price of the winner is £75 now

Is there a version of #4 that uses adhesive instead of screws :/

This video was very helpful! I'm trying to sound proof my office. There is a double door and a single door. They are wood but I'm not sure if solid core or not. The room is carpeted and I plan on putting in a book shelf and some decorative wall paneling on another wall. How do you suggest I sound proof the double door?

@michelleprice3010

Жыл бұрын

Having the same issue with my office since its double doors. Did you find a solution?

Do you have similar comparison video or numbers on stc rating of hollow door vs solid door ?

Are these options compatible with a interior door threshold?

Your Right, thicker is better/ I suspect to do a door panel as well, to stop door strumming.

Question: ever tested the weighted slip on under the door sound & draft slip on?

great video

@soundproofguide

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you!! 😊

I just moved into a one bedroom. I live in a low income apartment complex. I need to sound proof my apartment to work online. Going to buy a doorsweep. What else can I do? Thanks

Have you considered testing sound insulation to a standard in your videos? eg, ISO 16283 or ISO 140

@joshhyyym

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah, this test didn't seem very repeatable since the music was not exactly the same in each test and the sound meter was not the same distance from the door (assume also that the laptop was not moved)

Is it worth getting a sweep for a 2” gap.

Will the 'winner' kind of door sweep work well enough with carpet too? My room is in desperate need of sound proofing from the outside I can't even have a conversation in my room in a shared house without people walking past hearing every word of it or my house mate in the room joined to mine :/ I'm hoping a door sweep at filling in all other gaps will help with the door but have no idea what to do with the wall as it is so thin all my music producer friends have said don't bother spending money on the walls it will be a waste of mony but I'm thinking maybe just one very large and thick wall hanging/ throw will help at least the voices be so clear? I bought a four panel split canvas and was hoping to fill it with a sound absorbing material but have also been advised walls are so thin it will be a waste of money as won't make much difference :/

@tbotec7516

2 жыл бұрын

I need the same thing kinda lmk what u did.

how did you cut it

What about the brush door sweeps? Can anyone comment on their experience with it and give some insight how it compares to a rubber door sweep?

@soundproofguide

2 жыл бұрын

I found the brush door sweep didn’t work as well for sound as the rubber ones.

@cru5t_

2 жыл бұрын

@@soundproofguide Thank you for the comment! Much appreciated :))

if the double bubble was the wiiner why the heck do you still recommend that industrial one lmao

Thank you for sharing this experiment. However, (in my opinion) it doesn't make any sense to test them out with the gaps around the door.

So if you were to install 2 industrial door sweeps on both sides, I’m guessing it could even surpass the expensive one!

@soundproofguide

3 жыл бұрын

Definitely!

Good information yet you leave no name of the products you tested and/or when I can purchase one?

@Creeper_-gl1lr

2 жыл бұрын

in the description

@ArielPeeri

2 жыл бұрын

@@Creeper_-gl1lr Don't mean to play hard, but, where do I find the "description"?

@StanTheIV

Жыл бұрын

@@ArielPeeri How old are you

7:51 BREAKDANCE

Which door sweep is the one with no screws necessary? My parents don’t want holes in the door!

@soundproofguide

3 жыл бұрын

It’s the “double bubble door sweep”. It’s the first one on the list in the description of this video. There’s a link for your choice of Amazon and Home Depot.

@ryanhonner9805

3 жыл бұрын

@@soundproofguide That’s what I was thinking too however when you go on Amazon it comes with install screws and doesn’t look like it has the little plastic things in between like the one in the video does. Are you sure that it is the correct link?

@ryanhonner9805

3 жыл бұрын

@@soundproofguide NEVERMIND! The Home Depot one looks like the right one!

@evanrmurphy

11 ай бұрын

Agreed the show notes is linking to different "Winner" products on Amazon vs. Home Depot. I think the Home Depot one (Cinch 36 in. White Vinyl U-Shape Slide-On Under Door Seal) is the one in the video. The Amazon one (KS Hardware Double Bubble Door Sweep) requires screws and may have other differences.

Test all the door but not the metal one that he always recommends lmao

Here 8 months late for the contest! :-D

Music is a terrible way to test it should be a constant noise that never changes

At the end of the video you lied about the results the winner was in the mid 50s. This whole video was off. You didn't even voice the results. Sometimes the meter was even hard to see on the video. Made me feel like you wasted my time.

Thank you this is useful. As a suggestion, can you please stop talking while you are testing for noise? When you are talking over the actual sound test, it distorts the test results and make no sense at all.

@soundproofguide

3 ай бұрын

Noted! 😊

Why did you keep (in edit) you being confused? Totally lost confidence in your knowledge of what you are doing.

this video seemed disorganized and scattered, I'd sugest watching some Project Farm videos to get a more compact and clear example.