Duo reactions to TREASURE I Love You, Stray Kids Back Door, Seoul Phil's arrangement of Jonghyun End of the Day, Fromis_9 Feel Good, Taemin Never Gonna Dance Again Album, Stray Kids IN生 Album and Day6 (Even of Day) The Book of Us: Gluon album have been filmed and Umu & our assistant editors are working hard to get them out soon! More info about our Classical + Jazz Musicians React series ⬇️ ➡️ CMR Reaction Release Schedule + list of our Patreon-exclusive videos: docs.google.com/document/d/1uvf-u1EJVB-hmB3IU0P6M-obdMNu11fo_aUIf6dur70/edit?usp=sharing ➡️ Songs that are currently being voted on or waiting to be voted on by our musician voting panel (or votes are tied akjnfsakjdfn): kzread.info/head/PLFw_XZtkCVMMt3F3O3jvbeYlUyGo8v2nX ➡️ Will not react to list for the Classical Musicians React series & why songs may not be reacted to: docs.google.com/document/d/1b5aQLWbYgUCm30Pj5-AalSjwMaq8gm5jOyrcbAlMu6c/edit?usp=sharing

@TheHekateris

3 жыл бұрын

Oh, I cannot wait until you hear Never Gonna Dance Again Act 1 - woo!!! A masterpiece.

@kundans9265

3 жыл бұрын

Yes, looking forward to JongHyun's music reaction, Thank you

@artanis82

3 жыл бұрын

Omg you're reacting to the orchestral version of Jonghyun's song, I'm thrilled ❤️❤️❤️❤️

@saiarvindarun7856

3 жыл бұрын

Taemin has such a superb dancing gift. I really wish him the best. Now this might be off topic, but could you please react to dreamcatcher live cover of bigbang bang bang bang, it's really good.

@helenaorr

3 жыл бұрын

how do you vote on which songs

Taemin harmonizing with himself is just pure gold to my ears

@danielfarshipov1815

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah i live for it!

@sabidinhalaly

3 жыл бұрын

I came here just for this 😍

@Dreadhuh

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah me too

"It doesn't sound like a kpop song" But it DOES sound like a Taemin song and that's incredible, Taemin is ART

@lynnyljes

3 жыл бұрын

and this isn't even us fans hyping it up. It's literally a masterpiece.

@Bunker193

3 жыл бұрын

True

@EnderWigginKML

3 жыл бұрын

Tae-Pop man

@giovannamaria8946

3 жыл бұрын

@@EnderWigginKML !!!

@shineetaemint6548

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah we called his music T-pop(Taemin pop) because his music is not like typical kpop song

I love how Kevin said Taemin seems so dominant but sings from a submissive side. That perfectly summarized the whole suspect x innocent concept that Taemin wants to communicate across. In conclusion, I'm one proud Shawol!

@lori4021

3 жыл бұрын

Yes, me too. I mean the visual aesthetic of the MV, the choreography, his voice really complemented the lyrics and sound of the song. All elements combined to create the cinematic atmosphere Taemin wanted.

@dheu

3 жыл бұрын

I loved that too because it really crystallized the thought in my mind that every aspect of this song is reflecting the theme. His vocals especially before the third chorus really ARE submissive and so soft, revealing his innocent side and the struggle between rejecting and embracing his suspect side. There is the “destroy me more”/“run away from me” moment and the duality of what he says also showing that conflict, and then the dominance in his voice really comes out during the last chorus, overpowering the softer backing vocals of the usual chorus melody. 😫 This song is literally a masterpiece, I could talk about it and the MV for hours. I’ve been watching it constantly since day 1 of its release and even though they are right that the song itself is “simple” there is something about it I find incredibly complex and interesting. I could listen to it for hours without ever getting bored! ❤️

@zeddy2284

3 жыл бұрын

perfectly summed up in a sentence

"he is dominant singing from a submissive side" BLESS THIS. no one articulated this thouth better

@arimatos2983

3 жыл бұрын

I was blown away when he said that. Like, taking into account what the song is telling, it makes sense!! I'm just too blown away by how intentional it all is in all levels, Taemin is a genius!!

@Luminous.A.Glory_VitaNostra

3 жыл бұрын

Agreed!! Showed he was deeply focused and paying attention to the words and a MV so well!!!!

@rosetyong

3 жыл бұрын

Thought?

it’s a real shame this comeback isn’t getting the hype it deserves. obviously the song is good, but the choreo too...he really outdid himself, and that’s saying a lot for taemin!

@ariasinistra

3 жыл бұрын

the choreography hit me like a train the hand wave downwards thingy he does is so satisfying to watch

@octopu5ie

3 жыл бұрын

But it is! Taemin's Criminal won a double crown for digital performance and his album topped many #1 lists worldwide! :)

@natalierodriguez6897

3 жыл бұрын

When I saw the video I was amazed, but when I read the lyrics, damn😧my heart. I love Taemin's styles in his videos. 😊

@qualityblood5651

3 жыл бұрын

sm didnt promote him well... im upset with sm..

@GrEaTvIdGirL

3 жыл бұрын

Not to mention he's been working on it since literally before this year started (it was supposed to come out around March but it got delayed many times). His SuperM mate's are doing more promotion than SM actually, and fans in Korea rented a bus to promote the song too

Taemin is a legend. No one is doing it like him. Criminal is his turning point, he put his soul in this comeback. Watch the video with the subtitles on, you won't regret it. The song is about Stockholm syndrome and he's the victim

@naps9754

3 жыл бұрын

Yep. Stockholm syndrome with himself as the victim as well as the suspect... This entire album is a masterpiece! Incredible art.

@renroser6618

3 жыл бұрын

Plus he put his soul into this comeback while promoting for superm. What a king.

@Artemisian11

3 жыл бұрын

@@naps9754 Yup, victim and perpetrator, got to love the duality!

I can't believe that this is the Taemin that we used to adore before. Criminal made me realized that he really really has grown up as a top tier artist in the industry. His name, Taemin has already becoming a genre. He is always setting the bar so high for these Kpop stuff like music, dance, production, and even the back up dancers. Black Rose is awesome and I like it, too. Actually all of his songs in this Never Gonna Dance Again album, they are gold.

@GrEaTvIdGirL

3 жыл бұрын

I was just talking about this with my brother, and he's more of a casual listener than a fan but he said "Taemin doesn't sound like kpop, he sounds like Taemin. Even if it wasn't him singing I would think this song sounds completely like him" and I think that's so on point. Nobody's doing it like Taemin, he has a genre of his own

@reharm_reality

3 жыл бұрын

He has literally said that before, that he is not K-pop but "Taemin pop".

@loveliiikuromi3557

Ай бұрын

right?? i know this comment is from years ago but can’t believe this is the taemin who was a coconut that ate crayons and had never seen broccoli

lee taemin is art, there’s no one like him.

@ariasinistra

3 жыл бұрын

nctzens supporting Taemin is what I like to see ;))))

"the mixing is PERFECT" cannot agree more

He actually came out on his Vlogs and specifically said he wants to make TPop now. Taemin Pop.

@uhhuh4665

3 жыл бұрын

He has a lot of self confidence lmao He also said I love me too when amber from f(x) said I love you to someone lol

Kevin : "That was so Good!!!" Kevin : "this is one of the best k-pop song i've heard in a very very long time" just WOW!! WOW!! and WOW!! that's The King TAEMIN!!!

@Luminous.A.Glory_VitaNostra

3 жыл бұрын

Yessssssss!!!!!! I’m just sooo happy he’s being recognized, he’s incredible!!!!

@nana-fb4yu

3 жыл бұрын

our baby cheese is THE king 👑😌

@ElaB-zt7hr

3 жыл бұрын

Amen

Kevin points out mixing is perfect. Taemin was also satisfied with the mixing of cirminal. Taemin would be so happy to know this.

Kevin: "it's so edgy", "I love everything" COME TO THIS FANDOM, KEVIN hahaha Taemin is on a leage of his own, no one will ever come close

I never thought I would ever like a Taemin single more than Move but here we are.

@jaxcey4288

3 жыл бұрын

Me tooooo

@Lena-zn4re

3 жыл бұрын

His comebacks keep getting better and better.😍

@kimqie6294

3 жыл бұрын

True haha after ‘criminal’, I finally put ‘move’ down😂😂😂

@manaacass

3 жыл бұрын

Every single i was like that whahahaha

It doesn't sounds like a kpop song because it's T-pop, taemin pop

I believe the 80s influence was intentional, if you look at his Instagram teasers plus the choreo, there's a lot of references to Micheal Jackson. Also funny how I might consider this to be his best comeback in terms of song, mv, styling, and choreo. and it just so happens that Taemin had the most creative control in regards to all of those things this comeback. I really wish SM would invest more in promoting the album, it's easily the best album to come out this year. P.S. I missed Kevin

@arimatos2983

3 жыл бұрын

YES to everything you said.. It proves that he's turning in the kind of artist that he always wanted, no matter if it's still not "popular".. I love the Press It album and closely followed by Want, but he outdid himself with Act 1 and I CAN'T WAIT for Act 2! ❤️

When I first heard the song, I immediately felt the way Kevin felt. Criminal absolutely 100% transcends. As someone who doesn't grasp music and musical concepts as well as you guys, I immediately knew what Umu was talking about when she was referring to how Taemin's music is very atmospheric, and uses this aspect of itself to elevate into a genre all of his own. I didn't think NCT 127's Superhuman could be surpassed for me as the greatest KPop song of all time, but Criminal is slowly but surely creeping incredibly close.

@madeleinearcher999

3 жыл бұрын

Matt Vesliño me me me. Superhuman for me is still the greatest Kpop song to me, but Taemin isn’t even Kpop anymore. And this. This is PEAK taemin Tpop.

Taemin is just an amazing artist. He doesn't even have one bad song. On top of it all, his musicianship is just out of this world. His sound is so unique the moment you hear his song you can immediately say it's Taemin's.

I really wanted you all to react to this because honestly yes, it hasn’t been getting much promotion and Taemin himself has been quite troubled about it, so I was hoping you all could help him get even the slightest bit more recognition for his work. He’s been working extra hard on this too, being involved in multiple aspects of creative decision making, as he’s talked about in his recent behinds and commentary. And he really really cares about the dark story in this song, and the WHOLE package, getting portrayed in the way he wants it to be. So thank you Kevin and Umu for acknowledging all the things about this that he worked so hard to get across. It kinda feels like the whole industry knows how good this is and is rooting for Taemin - we just need more of the general public to acknowledge it too!

@Luminous.A.Glory_VitaNostra

3 жыл бұрын

judy 쥬리 lovely, lovely comment, and I completely agree. He is getting SUCH amazing feedback from everyone who hears and sees his work, and that’s so heartwarming. I’ve just been feeling so sad for him that SM isn’t promoting this like the masterpiece that it is, but it makes me feel better to hear him bd recognized for his incredible art.

"He seems so dominant but sings from submissive side" Well said. 1000% Agree.

finally the authentic review from musically educated people without being distracted by his hair or eye patch. yeah taemin always puts music first, the rest just follows up to fit the concept. he has very sophicated taste in music and wide variety of influences in his work. thx for the thoughtful in depth review. much appreciated. p.s. it'd be interesting to hear your thoughts on his other song "stone heart". here's the link of his off-sick concert version. kzread.info/dash/bejne/qJx3q9x-Z73Ffag.html

@arimatos2983

3 жыл бұрын

Oh YES!! one of my faves from him!!!!

@caterinabandiera7529

3 жыл бұрын

I also think Stoneheart is an amazing song. I wish it was more popular. It just grabs me and I can’t get away from it.

@mariapaulas199

3 жыл бұрын

Stone heart is so amazing and the LYRICS 😭 is poetry and music all put together so good.

@conradannie9771

3 жыл бұрын

*STONE HEART IS THE MOST PRECIOUS THINGS EVER* literally Taemin always pours his heart and soul into all the album, every single song is just ugh *art*, not only him but other kpop artist too, they have beautiful tracks in an album but people mostly will just know the main song which has MV. *tbh I was so distracted by his hair and eyepatch at the first time watching it because he is gorgeous sjksjkjs* BUT the song itself is speechlessly well done omg

“it doesn’t sound like a kpop song” exactly! taemin is the genre👏 this is taeminpop👏 no one does it like him fr

I want taemin to watch this, this is the kind of support he needs

@Luminous.A.Glory_VitaNostra

3 жыл бұрын

Grandpa Rick agreed!! I hope someone sends it to him. He’s been so sad. We see you, Taemin!!! And you shine so brightly!!

And the crazy thing is that Taemin worked on this while promoting with SuperM! It's like he's put his soul into this comeback, he actually said it himself that he was greatly involved in the making of it!

Idol of idols, God Taemin

I actually think the comeback is highly anticipated among the Taemin stan and the music industry because Taemin always brings his A game and produces innovative music. He never goes with mainstream Kpop music. He is a true SHINee. He is ahead of his time. That's why we refer hjs genre as T-Pop. He is highly regarded in his industry and very well respected by lots off juniors. His comeback even tho has not won an awards yet but he has set of lots of records already. #1 on iTunes chart in 32 countries. That is not easy to do. It sucks his company doesn't promote him in US and Europe. I think he will do very well here. But hope with his SuperM activity folks here will start look into him and his group

See how musicians and producers can't even add anything to the song, it's that perfect. Kulture even gave it a 10.1 points, and he never does that

The track is just so well produced, and the details make it really interesting, especially that final new melody line in the last chorus. Criminal, Black Rose, and Strangers are my favourites off the album. I'm so excited for your review and talk with Adrian!

It's not a kpop song, it's a tpop song lol. Taemin has his own genre at this point. Criminal is so modern and edgy and unique yet so very Taemin. It fits perfectly in his discography. The album is soooo good too, you'll love it. I love to see you guys appreciate him, he really doesn't get the recognition and appreciation he deserves. It seems like in kpop once you reach a certain time in the industry, newer fans won't pay attention to you and specially your company will stop supporting you. It's so unfair and just wrong.

I think this is the most classy and modern 80's inspired atmospheric track-I seriously agree, whoever did the mixing was on another level. The way his melody line gets dragged on and on, really suits the lyrics and concept of the song. Someone explain why this isn't blowing up.

@shineetaemint6548

3 жыл бұрын

What else it's his company fault for not promoting this comeback, this single and album must be more successful if SM put an effort to actually promotes him

@shineetaemint6548

3 жыл бұрын

@Harmon McCraw wow is it real?

@sindahat7451

3 жыл бұрын

@Harmon McCraw wow really?! Have a link to the interview?

Most of the times we are so immersed discussing and hyping on Taemin's dance that we forget to acknowledge how beautiful of a singer he is.

This song is SO good omg

@WitchlightNW

3 жыл бұрын

the whole album is really good - also is that a picture of suho obsession era as a dp?

@sa.kuzya_

3 жыл бұрын

@@WitchlightNW yes it's suho during obsession Eraaaa💗💗

he really is such a mature and developed artist with such a clear sound and image, i really love this whole album

“Destroy me more” I mean what a line!

Perfect mixing, perfect production. Well, you can expect nothing less when the artist, who's had a hand on the whole process, is a perfectionist! Taemin you are incredible and we, your Jjakgoongs, love you dearly. P.S. Thank you Reacttothek for this reaction/review of Taemin's Criminal. You guys are awesome.

When Umu and Kevin is impressed.. Now that's another level of musicality for Taemin and the composers/producers

난 한국사람이고 태민팬이지롱. 영어(자동) 자막으로 영상을 한번 보고, 한국어 자막이 올라오면 한 번 더 봐요. 그래서 하고 싶은 말은 reacttothek와 자막 담당자분들 감사합니다!

7:07 Kevin describing Taemin's sex noises has me W H E E Z I N G

@caterinabandiera7529

3 жыл бұрын

I never thought of that but as soon as Kevin mentioned it I was YES that is exactly right.

This is what i want... Finally u guys react to Taemin's Criminal I hope reacttothek make a react video to Taemin's Black Rose too..please..

@artistblue18

3 жыл бұрын

Nina Meddyanka They will probably talk in depth about Black Rose during the Album review especially since Adrian Mikinnon who co-composed Black Rose will be in the video.

It's funny you mention "The Weekend", I mentioned this about "Criminal" on another channel reaction. I stated that this song will be a slow burn instead of a white-hot flame, with many layers to this song and the album for that matter."Blinding light", that song has been out for about a year, and only now do you hear it everywhere,(by the way I love that song~). I consider Taemin to be an "Artists' Artist". I even mentioned on his company's site, that this album should be considered for a Grammy nod. I don't say that of many Albums, but Taemin has really made an exceptional piece of work. It's his turning point in his career and I am so glad I am here to witness it. I can only imagine what Act II is like and his next decade will sound like. I am just so happy for him. My ears are happy too~ 6V6

@Auntie67

3 жыл бұрын

OMG, Taemin nominated for Grammy is my dream! He so deserves it with this album!!! Hopefully one day...

저 남자분이 이렇게 극찬하는 거 처음봄 ...내가다 뿌듯... 감사합니다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

kinda geeked out when Kevin was talking about After Hours (The Weeknd’s album), which I also really like. Criminal definitely fits in that kind of production. this is my personal SOTY so I was really waiting for this video, I was assuming that Kevin would like it and clearly he likes it and then some haha. also agree with Umu really liking the 3rd chorus. looking forward to the album listen + interview with Adrian!!

I'm addicted to the song, help :( And the choreography too 🥺

kevin said criminal 11/10 so thats it from now on its t-pop

i actually cried hearing all their compliments,,, taemin deserves only the best because he is the best

thank you for reacting to Taemin again! It's kind hurts to hear you loving it so much and also saying it feels very "american" in a very good, unique way - yet because of legal issues that his company didn't bother to solve - Criminal can not be shown on any american show - making it impossible to promote him there. (that info comes from MTV who wanted to play Criminal and found out they couldn't) He really deserves so much more than he is getting from his agency right now - almost all promo comes from his friends and fans.

@Inspirit-gp4dp

2 жыл бұрын

what legal issues?

I was waiting for this so much!!! Tae worked soo much into each production part of CRIMINAL that the fact you were saying "it is perfect" makes me so proud and happy as you liked it. Also, your excitement with his signing makes me so excited as he was aiming for that: we know he's a great dancer but him hitting those high notes it's soooo dramatic and exciting and ...😭😭😭🔥🔥🔥🔥🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤

Best release of 2020! He slayed us all. This is Tpop!!

The things he could have achieved if his label actually promoted his comeback, makes me bawl.

I hope Taemin watch this reaction, he should know how people really apreciate his hard work on music, vocal, dance and everything. Let's stream Criminal !!!

A masterpiece!!

I'm sooooo glad you guys enjoyed Criminal as much as I did...It just felt PERFECT from the first listen, so very Taemin. It just grabbed me and held me in its atmosphere. I loved a lot of 2020 releases this but has gotta be on top.

Taemin Is art, that's it 🥰

The editing in this video was so cute 💕

Thanks for the reaction- interesting as always - and I love this song so much. I have to add tho, what Kevin says about it being more American/western - I'd argue that it's European (euro electrohouse). Obviously heavily influenced by 80's synth pop (generally American and British) but looking at that genre in a contemporary setting it's pretty specific to Europe, I think? For example "Diamond Veins" by French 79, "Blast Off" By GESAFFELSTEIN and "Odd Look" by Kavinsky (or practically any daft punk track) I think it's mixed pretty similarly to Diamond Veins but what makes Criminal outstanding tho (except for the fact that it's THE freaking ACE Lee Taemin) are how his smooth vocals stand out boldly in the track, the seamless mixing/mastering and that the song is mixed to be a pop track; super smooth and therefore more digestible. IMO a perfect track both instrumentally and obv vocally (shinee vocals/vocal mixing is always on point)! The adlibs sound absolutely impeccable and I could go on forever so imma stop here for now

@nausicaa17

3 жыл бұрын

I love this comment for introducing me to more artists producing music with a similar sound! I’ve always been into electronic music, so I really appreciate you sharing your insights!

@angelica-yw7ev

3 жыл бұрын

@@nausicaa17 ooh I'm so glad I could help ! I love the genre, and words can't describe how happy I was to see Taem do it so well !! 😭😭

this song is sooooooo good one of his best songs!!!!!

이번 Kevin의 반응에 놀랐네요 ㅋㅋㅋ 함께 멋진 곡 감상해주셔서 감사합니다. 비록 "컴백했는데 활동은 끝나버린" 크리미널이지만 앞으로 더 많은 사람들이 듣고 봐주는 곡이 될거라 믿어요. 11월에 더 멋지게 돌아올 태민의 ACT2 앨범도 기대 많이 해주세요!

I usually never put songs on repeat but I listened to this like 10x in a row. His style is just so satisfying.

sees the title; hears the first few minutes; *screams in kevin* (in reference to the 1:40 in snsd reaction)

@WitchlightNW

3 жыл бұрын

very happy for a full album reaction (with ADRIAN! YAY) there's some REALLY interesting stuff happening in some songs (imo)

That "destroy me more" destroyed everyone..

I look forward to your listening to the whole album - it's a masterpiece!!! Taemin definitely goes beyond Kpop aesthetics, he has an incredibly sophisticated, western sound, which I loved from the very first moment I started listening to his music. Sensational artist, sensational album, there is no one on his level of artistry. He had a huge influence on the production of this album - both in sound and visual aspects and he said it's literally like his child! Thank you for your reaction and waiting for more Taemin!!!

As others have mentioned Taemin was very involved with this song. He stated he now wanted to make music his way and have greater control. The fact that you both and other musically savvy reactors are so hyped about this song is a wonderful confirmation of Taemin’s artistry. He also said that Criminal has a sound never heard in k-pop before and you both confirmed it. It is very disappointing that SM has not promoted this song and album and to know that Taemin is also disappointed makes this so upsetting. I really loved your reactions.

태민은 신이다 😌

@user-gi3cv3nu2b

3 жыл бұрын

탬멘

한국어 자막 올려주신 분 어디 계신가요 절 받으세요ㅠㅠㅠ

Stan Taemin everyone!

The Album is a MASTERPIECE! 😭❤️ If you can react to Black Rose if not all the Album. Taemin went all with this Album, there is everything. And totally agree with everything you guys said! The mixting is excellent, his notes are amazing, and the song keeps you in your toes all the time and goes and goes and goes and it builds up at the end till it destroys you 😂 thank you so much for your reaction! Loves the edit so funny 😂❤️

The king of kpop himself ~✨LEE TAEMIN✨~

The music video is the best SM MV I've watched in a WHILE

@roomofmirros

3 жыл бұрын

I'm just sad that they're not promoting this and hyping it as they should .... The world needs to listen to the song , watch the MV and hear the whole album , it's too good to be hyped by limited number of people :(

@shineetaemint6548

3 жыл бұрын

@@roomofmirros i know, that's why we are very upset(Taemin too) with the way SM handling his comeback this time. I'm mad and disappointed to SM but it didin't change anything

I still don't get why this comeback is so underrated, I've had this album on repeat since it came out and I don't get tired of it -3- Can't wait for the album reaction.

dude WHAT ADRIAN MCKINNON TOO?!?!?!! IM SO EXCITED

Criminal is a masterpiece !!! The album NEVER GONNA DANCE AGAIN is incredible !!

Yup Taemin is Amazing!!! He's Art, a Legend, a King, anything that great is HIM!! Btw can we talk about umu's childhood friend's introduction at 4:29 ?? That was so cuteee

Taemin is a masterpiece ....

Kevin praising the lyrics made me so happy. Taemin worked closely with lyricists Danke on Criminal. He asked that they take a more conceptual approach, blurring the lines between criminal and victim, tainted love and the one who did the tainting. The song portrays a toxic love, but it also portrays a protagonist who participated in his own downfall, by drinking from the poisoned chalice, again and again. If he was stabbed in the heart, he took part in the stabbing. In my opinion, the lines "I don’t hate how your words make my feet entangled and dance", and "My hands holding yours that stabbed me, are not clean either", best captures this ambiguity. Criminal is a masterpiece, and it is Taemin at the peak of his power - sophisticated, sensual, and dark (the choreography was partly inspired by dead bodies). So happy this was one of the tracks that made me a Taemint, and a Shawol. The other was Think Of You. Can't think of a better duo that represents Taem's duality.

I absolutely LOVE the vocal placement/timbre Taemin chose for the chorus, and I think it’s part of what makes the mixing and the balance so perfect. It’s softer, in his head voice, and is almost (breathy?). It allows the instrumental to come through, it re-frames your focus, and it allows the third chorus to be that much more impactful when he begins harmonizing with himself and using his stronger mixed voice. It also is very different from the typical chorus which is usually where a singer uses a fuller tone. Ugh this is easily my favourite kpop song of the year it’s literally perfect. Plus the choreo is so beautiful, artful, and shows us why he’s the best dancer in the industry. LOVE

I love this song I mean his ngda Act 1 album!! very proud of him! Thanks for loving it!!

I want Taemin to see this reaction so much TT he deserves to know he did so well with his comeback:’)

Umu this reaction is everything I was hoping for !!! Also, the little doodle edits are adorable !!!

@Sherry3959

3 жыл бұрын

ISRA'A jsjsjs I FOUND YOU HERE LMAOO XD uwuwuwuuwuwuwuwuwuwu

@Sherry3959

3 жыл бұрын

them appreciating this masterpiece is 🥺✨

@israadalvi4358

3 жыл бұрын

@@Sherry3959 Wait who are you thoooo ?? 😂😂😂

@Sherry3959

3 жыл бұрын

Isra'a Dalvi Nafisa ;_;

I'm so happy that they love the song as much as I do!! Definitely my favourite song of his! And the choreo and video is AMAZING as well.

She fell in love so quickly. Taemins power.

“Already speechless” SAME!!! UMU and Kevin you seriously represent my reaction😂

What Kevin said about it feeling like an American song makes me so mad that the licensing got stuffed so it can't be played in America

It's fascinating that musicians/people with musical background tend to pick up the same observations regarding this song likd the flawless mixing, the melodic lines, and the 80's-esque vibes (esp the synth). Goes to show how thoughtful these elements are in the song.

@arimatos2983

3 жыл бұрын

It basically means that Taemin's work and musicality is THAT good, knowing he was involved in EVERYTHING in this comeback... He needs to know that his pushing for quality was worth it and will always be, only time will tell he was right all along ❤️👍🏼

King Lee Taemin, yes!!

Taemin is really working hard with this comeback. He picked the song, he picked the director for the mv, he also gave a lot credit with the editing in mv and the album. He really proud of this album. But, yeah he's really doesn't care about what people wants, he just go with his way. Out of the box. Thank you for liking it and supporting him 💛

i was waiting for the reaction....

I WAS WAITING FOR THIS!! I'm so happy you're reacting to the full album too, it's really good!

Someone put this with Korean subtitles where Taemin can see it!! Go go go, Shawols!! Translate and share! This song and MV is Taemin's pride. Let's do what we can for GP to notice it because this song is above 'alternative genre K-pop' it's mature, it's a hit and a masterpiece and it's Taemin's own vision 100%, his mixing perfected as he wanted it, he's blossoming fully as a creative, independent artist with this! Get the MV everywhere we can think of, translate reactions like this where Taemin himself sees it, let's work together as a fandom, for him! Are you in?

@shineetaemint6548

3 жыл бұрын

718% i'm in

im still obsessed with this song😭iconic

Taemin's music has always been my favourite since I because a kpop fan. Move, thirsty, want, famous....they all have such a different vibe. And he gives such wonderful music.

Taemin’s Black Rose (the stage) please!! It’s so beautiful, elegant, and gothic aesthetic song.

I love Kevin, I love Umu, I love the fact that they loved this song :)

Thank you so much for this reaction! I'm totally agree with your review about 'fluidity' in this song, it could be repetitive and the structure is not that 'wild' but it still slaps so hard with its minimalism. I'm so upset tho with the way SM treated Taemin's comeback this time, they were bad but this time they didn't even bother to do a single thing to promote this masterpiece. I just hope his Act 2 album will receive the support it deserves because SM has been calling Taemin their ACE for 6 years now and didn't even do half of half from his hard work. Can't wait for the NGDA: Act 1 album review!

Not that i cried when Kevin said what he said..... ............ 😭

okay but the thing that caught my eye was (ITS CALLED BEARBEAR🥺) that little stuffed bear....

2024 and i still coming back for this reaction. 🥰

Super excited to see Adrian again for the album listen. Taemin is an artist, he's so so good at what he does. I could barely have a proper analysis for the song because it just blows me away everytime I listen so thank you for the fun tidbits and whatnot!

I just love how you reacts to Kevin's opinions 😂 I feel like his perspective and taste has changed so much I don't know what to expect from him in the recent videos 🤣🤣

IM SO HAPPY💖💖 I’ve been waiting for a reaction from you guys, specifically on the album. But in addition to that, we also get a bonus treat from the person who helped create Taemin’s masterpiece?? 😍