Sunak’s mandatory National Service is a ‘terrible idea’ | Ed Vaizey
“An off the shelf policy about National Service, completely out of the blue with no context, strikes me I’m afraid as a gimmick.”
The Tories’ plan to bring back mandatory National Service will turn young voters away from the Conservatives, says Times Radio presenter Lord Vaizey.
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.co.uk/subscribe/...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...
Пікірлер: 1 100
I'm 64 my kids and grandkids arent going to fight for a bunch of neo-fascist Eton educated Tory w⚓'s!
@GrooberNedJardine
22 күн бұрын
Exactly !!! i told my sons don't ever go and fight for a country that hates you . Never .
@CursedWheelieBin
22 күн бұрын
@@GrooberNedJardineWhy would the entire country hate your sons? 😂 Are they really that bad?
@boota1979
21 күн бұрын
@@GrooberNedJardine Tell me when did the EE ever have our best interest at heart?
@chriswilde7246
21 күн бұрын
@@GrooberNedJardineAgreed....and it probably wouldn't be for our nation, It would probably end up being for the european theatre........yet again!
@bensims7501
21 күн бұрын
Tell them to not work either. Everything should be free. Someone else should fight for us
Young people face unaffordable housing, student debts, privatised monopolies and high taxes... and now they want to conscript them too? Wow.
@user-hs1zh1se4c
22 күн бұрын
Yeah and they probably won't be paid for it either. They'll be using 18 year olds as unpaid labour that's a tory service cut
@casadellangelo
22 күн бұрын
It's disgusting how the younger generations are being treated.
@a133m210
22 күн бұрын
@@user-hs1zh1se4c unpaid labour or literal cannon fodder?! And if you say no to being sent to the front line your bank account and passport are blocked. The desperate ones will be grabbing the dinghies the syrians leave on the beach and fleeing. Probably there'll be a huge boom in sick notes for ££ like in Ukraine and anyone with rich parents will be on some sort of disability benefit asap
@millrace32
22 күн бұрын
the tories know that they're dead in the water - literally. there is no way for them to win the election. the national service idea is merely a fiction to support the further fiction that the party of strivers & good ideas is being thwarted by the party of moochers, post-election
@magnuscarlsson9969
22 күн бұрын
When it comes to this, i want to see a plan for how it works before i judge. Since i went trough national service and I'm very happy i did however it wasn't exactly the military bits which made me feel content, it was the other stuff aka. the education i received in healthcare(field medic), the assistance i got with my drivers license, the ability to earn and save some money, not to mention the structure suited me at the time etc. This was how the Swedish program was setup, basically it was more of an education then doing military drills all day long. You could of course move into more professional military training if you wanted to, but the vast majority chose the basic military training and civic duties. Also the people who had a goal of heading into higher education or wasn't at all suited for the program got exempted, i even had the choice after my evaluation but still made the choice to sign up. However I am also proud of my country and i would without any doubt chose to remain here or be sent to the front lines if we ever went to war. The problem i see with mandatory military service often boils down to how motivated a person is... People who have no motivation to fight for their country ain't exactly suited for that purpose, in a sense they would probably end up being more of a liability then an asset. Even a person with no formal training but indeed do have the motivation is probably more valuable. Me and a coworker both received our "in case of war" assignments a few months ago, she have no training but she's a nurse so we will be stationed at the same hospital only difference is that she have a choice and is considered a civilian, I don't have those privileges.
Put the Tories on the front line
@geoffbirchall7552
21 күн бұрын
All government, because they are all the same! We live in a dictatorship, democracy is dead!
@jackdubz4247
21 күн бұрын
Send them to Rwanda.
@pholdway5801
20 күн бұрын
Sunak in front Not all on the right are in favour . I don't like it either . Stuff conscription . My IQ is sky high but my bravery is ZERO
@markbleak7228
20 күн бұрын
Grant Shapps on the front line
@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968
18 күн бұрын
Go live in Russia, before Russia comes to live with you.😂
The people who like this think it’s a great idea for other people’s children.
@lsmith6378
21 күн бұрын
Agree
@jackdubz4247
21 күн бұрын
Yep. No one who goes to private school is ever going to be doing this so-called national service nonsense. They will all get special exemptions. Or be given really cushy "jobs" to do.
@rachelmatthews3070
21 күн бұрын
@@jackdubz4247 Exactly, I noticed how only those going into the military would get paid (though their policy seems to be constantly being contradicted by MPs) So in other words, working class kids will be pressured into going into the military because of financial pressure while the middle class kids will be able to have the more 'genteel' jobs because they'll be able to afford to not get paid.
@nimzgaz7049
21 күн бұрын
Its a great idea. Actually a very bold idea. 🎉
@GGGZEEE
21 күн бұрын
That’s probably true of leadership - which is how most privileged think: how to take care of their now at the expense of all others. That’s not community, that’s classist/market capitalist. Not something to be proud of.
Sunak will slink off to California when he loses. His kids will never be conscripted.
@user-ej7yn3nz9w
21 күн бұрын
Exactly 💯
@Andygb78
18 күн бұрын
I could see him taking up a position on the board at Hindustan Unilever after losing the election.
These Tories who went to Eton, Oxford, Stanford etc...among the dumbest people I've ever seen.
@Rivr23
21 күн бұрын
They still managed to con millions of Brits into voting for them so what does that say about the general population
@lesdundas4869
21 күн бұрын
this is the people who would benifit most from this year in service , would give them some disipline how to look after yourself and makes you part of how to work in a group , makes you grow up it certainly made a better man of me
@Rivr23
21 күн бұрын
@@lesdundas4869you're meant to learn things like that from parents and school though...if they don't have it by now it's too late
@HelenBellen123
21 күн бұрын
Translation_ anyone you don't agree with is "dumb" 🤨
@RugbyPass81
21 күн бұрын
@@HelenBellen123National service is a dumb idea. I served for 22 years and national service is about the worst idea imaginable. I later refused to soldier after my second tour of Afghanistan, after gradually admitting it, like Iraq and world war two,.Vietnam and others , were wars the very rich, lazy, greedy business interests want to happen for their own gain. Not one was for the defence of a nation. Now, as a father myself, if an armed forces recruitment advisor tried to talk to my children, he would find himself picking his teeth up off of the floor in short order. I regret every single second of my service. I was conned.
Whoever convinced Sunak National Service was a vote winner must want Labour to win!
@Norfolkbiker50
22 күн бұрын
You're actually closer to the truth than you think, a lot of their "advisers" work for members of several parties
@TheReelDealFilmReviews
22 күн бұрын
For sure, I completely agree.
@gio-oz8gf
22 күн бұрын
@@Norfolkbiker50 Which advisers are you talking about and how do you have this information? I'm starting from a position of not believing you know anything.
@Koi-addict33
22 күн бұрын
His wef bosses
@Norfolkbiker50
21 күн бұрын
@@gio-oz8gf the first one that springs to mind is Iain Anderson, there are obviously others because these people are freelance and can work for whoever they like, much like a solicitor, I don't care whether you think I know anything or not but if you don't think I do then do some research yourself instead of expecting me to do it for you because whatever I say you'll dispute anyway.
Due to austerity policies, my children sometimes had to eat one cooked meal daily. These idiots suggest mandatory national services for our children to become canon fodder in trenches in the Baltics. Maybe the government should stop funding wars and spend taxpayers' money on education, NHS, and other public services in desperate states.
@jonnycollison
22 күн бұрын
Well said
@user-oo6ef4ho4r
20 күн бұрын
Well said
@johnmartin9424
20 күн бұрын
Totally Agree. if they hadn't hollowed out the Armed forces... Emptied the ranks, Sold off the Barracks, withdrawn our troops from Germany... Sold our tanks for scrap: we wouldn't need it.
@thematic3893
18 күн бұрын
Rishi wants your children in those filthy trenches to fight the bear! 🇷🇺🐻🇷🇺
@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968
18 күн бұрын
WW3 won't just remain in the Baltics. You should study the enormity of the problem. Under Putin's New World Order your Kids won't eat and you'll have no NHS to worry about.
I bet his kids wont have to do it
@alexwright3301
22 күн бұрын
Of course they won't he'll be off to America before they're old enough to do it.
@fetbetty
22 күн бұрын
@@alexwright3301 disgusting people, the ruling classes, the wealthy, and entitled. We a all so disposable, inconsequential to them.
@pasta8470
21 күн бұрын
@@alexwright3301 Pretty much what Bill Clinton did to avoid serving in vietnam
@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968
18 күн бұрын
Putin's kids don't have to do it. They live in a mansion in Switzerland. What point are you trying to make here?
On school fees… “middle class voters!?” Does he understand the actual cost of current private school fees? It’s not middle class people, it’s the wealthy.
@lonyo5377
21 күн бұрын
Non boarding is probably only a bit more costly than full time nursery. The middle class stretching to send kids to private school are the ones who will no longer be able to. The wealthy won't be impacted
@gm9460
21 күн бұрын
Yeah - there are not going to be a noticeable number of middle class people for this is a single issue election. It is cobblers. I have no idea where he is getting this from. The people for who this is seriously a single issue were never voting Labour anyway
The army didn't want National Service after the war. It was a pointless burden on them. Employers would not want to lose staff and the people themselves would be joining the army now if they wanted to do it. Who does want this? Old right wing colonels and codgers maybe?
@timonsolus
22 күн бұрын
Only 30,000 out of 3,000,000 would join the armed services. And most of them would be fighting from behind a desk and a laptop screen. The remainder would be doing community service. Again, only a small minority would be with the police, fire service and NHS - the vast majority would be picking up litter and sweeping the streets. Some in rural areas might get sent to do fruit picking and other farm tasks. Doesn't sound quite so bad now, does it?
@mr_incognito9305
22 күн бұрын
@@timonsolus forced labour in menial jobs? Sounds great...
@maryj5593
22 күн бұрын
Some of the prison population could be doing tasks within the community. We need a work force that possess social skills, so many people don't know the basics of being civil and it's not always the younger generation
@gio-oz8gf
22 күн бұрын
@@timonsolus It sounds bloody ridiculous and it's never going to happen. We live in the UK, not communist China. It's a throwaway line designed to appeal to their elderly voters. They sound increasingly clueless and desperate.
@20quid
22 күн бұрын
Most military officers do not want to become glorified babysitters to a revolving door of kids who don't want to be there. It's not the army's job to whip your child into shape and make up for the shortcomings in your own parenting. They've got a very important and dangerous job to do and we should stop bothering them with pointless nonsense.
I will never ever ever allow my boys to fight for this corrupt government
@AnotherPointOfView944
21 күн бұрын
National Service is not conscription. Can you not read?
@kristinabelievesinfairies
21 күн бұрын
@@AnotherPointOfView944 mandatory national service IS conscription!!
@stewartbunting3568
21 күн бұрын
It just proves to show how desperate the Tories have become, it's not even a vote sweetener, it's a turn off for the books.
@Andygb78
18 күн бұрын
@@kristinabelievesinfairies It's mandatory voluntary service.
@kristinabelievesinfairies
18 күн бұрын
@@Andygb78 that's an oxymoron
I doubt the army or navy would want this. A group of young people who don't want to be there.
@Jim90117
22 күн бұрын
I serve currently and you've hit the nail on the head.
@Taffnp
22 күн бұрын
Which is why the military option is voluntary
@Makeyourselfbig
22 күн бұрын
@@Taffnp If you don't do the military then you have to do the other. That is not how volunteering works. But it is how coercion works.
@richardjames3022
21 күн бұрын
For once a sensible comment from young Tom
@tomsheppard378
21 күн бұрын
It's just for headlines, the govt could use jobcentres to encourage volunteering amongst young people.
My wife told me this this morning, I thought she was either joking or clicked on some daily mail Clickbait story. Just when you think Sunak couldn’t get any dafter.
people want their weekly shop not to double again, not have kids forced to join the army
@rachelmatthews3070
21 күн бұрын
Bravissimo 👏 👏👏
@AnotherPointOfView944
21 күн бұрын
Its not the armed forces
Ill thought-out final act of Conservative Party self-destruction.
Restore national pride, vote a Tory out
@browngaymethodistjesuschri1361
21 күн бұрын
Starmer being able to talk to world leaders on our behalf would make our nation proud?💀
Excellent!!! That's the way to lose an election. You carry on, Rish. Byeeeee
As if a labour victory wasn't already likely, they've just been handed the "vote us or your kids will be forced to join the army" card
National Service, the number 1 priority on voters minds!
@Tom_murray89
22 күн бұрын
Nope getting the Tories out of power is more of a priority for voters
@briannewton3535
21 күн бұрын
I hadn't even realised this was so important to me until this idea came to light. Who knew?
@browngaymethodistjesuschri1361
21 күн бұрын
@@Tom_murray89keeping the squeaky guy with the massive noggin out of power is voters priority
@robinholland1136
21 күн бұрын
@roncozens Ah, but it keeps the rabid Tory press in headlines . . .
@timdunn2344
20 күн бұрын
Strong vibes similar to Corbyn's last-minute nationalize-all-internet-firms gaff before his election...
If young people want a military career, they are perfectly entitled to, and capable of, joining voluntarily. Forcing them is just BONKERS. They took away their right to move freely and participate in educational programmes in Europe without giving them a say, and now this. Utterly clueless
@ProfoundFamiliarity
21 күн бұрын
To be fair, the public did vote for Brexit but I agree forcing 18 year olds to join up is daft.
@gjaxx
21 күн бұрын
@@ProfoundFamiliarity Those affected by this had no say... Neither did any of those who DIDN'T vote for Brexit (a majority of the eligible electorate, whatever spin you put on 'they didn't vote to stay so it was a vote to leave'). Leave won by the slimmest of margins, and declared the 'Will of the People'. A huge percentage of the nation were allowed no further say. Excluded from every aspect of the disaster that followed... So no. Let's NOT be 'fair'
@ProfoundFamiliarity
21 күн бұрын
@@gjaxx that's true although how else would we want the democracy to work?
@gjaxx
21 күн бұрын
@@ProfoundFamiliarity Oh, I don't know... Maybe if they'd been brave enough to hold a 2nd ref to validate johnson's 'oven ready deal'?... But he already knew how that would go, so chose to present boogy man Corbyn as a distraction instead. A one issue referendum rather than a broad spectrum election. After all, that was what brexit was decided on... in or out... with absolutely no plan as to how 'out' would work
You can tell these presenters send their kids to private school and aren’t happy about the Labour proposals on taxing private education.
@gm9460
21 күн бұрын
They are completely out of touch
@jonnobloggs1139
21 күн бұрын
The female presenter attacks any Labour leaning interviewee like a rottweiler on heat and gives tories an easy time .She is Julia Hartley Brewer with a red wig
You have to ask if Sunak is deliberately trying to lose.
@philipnesbitt3334
20 күн бұрын
As he is failing at everything then you could be right because if he fails then he wins! What a ghastly thought.
The only people in favor of conscription are those who are too old to be affected.
@josephnulley6808
22 күн бұрын
I am over 70 and believe this plan is outrageous and should never be implemented
@mr_incognito9305
22 күн бұрын
@@josephnulley6808 you are proof not everyone in your age group thinks like this but you have to admit, it appeals to a good number of older voters unfortunately
@browngaymethodistjesuschri1361
21 күн бұрын
*favour
@user-kz4ke8mg4r
21 күн бұрын
Older people have young relatives they love and don't want to sacrifice for this corrupt government.
@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968
18 күн бұрын
You're obviously young and naive. Nobody is too old not to be effected.
Labour offers the young the vote. Tories, hard labor. It's like they're trying to throw the election. And i bet it will be forgotten within the week.
As a member of the armed forces this is a terrible idea. Its hard enough to keep people that wanted to join. Also will this apply to their children? Where would they get the funding 😅 this smells like a grab for mid/far right votes.
@Makeyourselfbig
22 күн бұрын
It is. Sunak is trying to get some of the Tories that have gone over to Reform back in the fold.
@timonsolus
22 күн бұрын
Only 30,000 out of 3,000,000 would join the armed services. And most of them would be fighting from behind a desk and a laptop screen. The remainder would be doing community service. Again, only a small minority would be with the police, fire service and NHS - the vast majority would be picking up litter and sweeping the streets. Some in rural areas might get sent to do fruit picking and other farm tasks. Doesn't sound quite so bad now, does it?
@ben_______123abc
22 күн бұрын
@@timonsolus where would the funding for this come from? what return would the nation get on its investment over how long? the logistical infrastructure needs to be built up to support this. Training a pressed person is worth far less than a willing person. Professionals are volunteer, you need to know the person next to you believes in why they are there not because they have no other choice.
@ProfoundFamiliarity
21 күн бұрын
Thank you for your service and for this honest comment
@timonsolus
21 күн бұрын
@@ben_______123abc : The Tories have said that the National Service scheme would be funded by raiding the levelling up budget (they don’t care about levelling up disadvantaged areas anymore, because the people in those areas now mostly support Labour). I imagine that going forward they would fund the scheme by putting fines on young people who don’t comply, or maybe even by allowing rich young people to pay a large fee and buy themselves an exemption from service.
Give young people education and jobs not "national service"
@MR_THINQ
21 күн бұрын
They will get that in the military. My brother was in the navy, by the time he left he had a degree in engineering!.
@Carys211
21 күн бұрын
Me and all my siblings except my sister were failed tragically by our schools.
@user-oo6ef4ho4r
20 күн бұрын
Thank you
@Myndir
14 күн бұрын
@@MR_THINQ The army has enough to do without becoming a massive vocational college, thanks.
Sunak's money means "an uncertain world" offers HIM and his family an infinity of possibilities. Patronising, pontificating public schoolboy.
My question is why? Why now? What does the government know that’s going to happen that we aren’t being told?…
@rosella1919
17 күн бұрын
Because they want the vote of the oldies, and know that most of them will be in favour of it. I’m old, but there’s no way I would vote for anyone who proposed this. I was married to a Vietnam Veteran. Enough said!
😂😂😂like anyone would fight for a government that hates you and has run your country into the ground and stolen ALL the money. Do one, get recruits from oxford and cambridge 😂😂😂
@boota1979
21 күн бұрын
@Rj-xl8ei Armed Forces swear allegiance to the King and his successors, not who happens to be in number 10.
@browngaymethodistjesuschri1361
21 күн бұрын
@@boota1979explain the ministry of defence then dip💩
@SheilaBloom.
21 күн бұрын
@@boota1979 who would fight for big King Jug ears
@boota1979
21 күн бұрын
@@SheilaBloom. In WWII people and the country were very different and in my opinion way better. They way our country has been wrecked from within saddens me to the core. I wonder Sheila if one day the world will be at peace.
@SheilaBloom.
21 күн бұрын
@@boota1979 Personally, I think it’s the Job of politicians & diplomats to work for peace. War is a policy failure and I would we should send the failed policymakers to the front line first Last week we heard how the British state had deliberately murdered its people with cheap imported blood & lied about it for over 30 years sign up to protect these corrupt f*ckers on your bike.
Sunak and his children, and the rest of his MP villains will be exempt of course…….
Classic "dead cat" tactic- for the next few days the focus will be on this, not the tory record on the Economy; RAAC in schools and hospitals; sewerage in rivers and beaches; cost of living; high mortages and rents; issues with GP & dentist appointment; PPE scandals; NHS waiting lists etc etc
In view that many people feel deeply alienated from the British Society, is it a good idea to give them military training and access to weapons?
I remember well my late father (one of the last year cohort of conscripts). Telling me that the only thing national service taught him was how to skive. This does all rather smack of ill thought out chest thumping impotent fluff.
@simmybear31
22 күн бұрын
Exactly and don't forget the Krays were National Servicemen spending their time in the Glass House before a Dishonourable Discharge! It's totally ludicrous!
@Makeyourselfbig
22 күн бұрын
My late dad was the same. He did his NS back in the 50's. He said most of them were always being dragged back after going AWOL because they didn't want to be there. Just wasted two prime years of his life. The professional army didn't want to know about them.
Bear in mind they only came up with it yesterday
Young people have had misery, debt and lack of opportunity heaped on them by the tories… now this. Its just a gimmick to appeal to the over 75s.
@RemoanersRtossers
22 күн бұрын
I'm 45 and it appeals to me! 👍
@danielcraig4974
22 күн бұрын
@@RemoanersRtossersSend you first gammon
@RemoanersRtossers
22 күн бұрын
@@danielcraig4974 Your mother loves Gammon . 😉
@TheBT
22 күн бұрын
@@RemoanersRtossersEnlist, lead by example
@RemoanersRtossers
22 күн бұрын
@@peterholden3672 At least 10 years too old Son! Any more silly questions or is that your quota for the day?
The policy staggers me.
It shows how out of touch the Tories are and getting the Tories out of power is more of a priority for the voting public
🤣🤣🤣. Good luck with that!! Young people today national service??!! 🤣🤣🤣... I will be very surprised if the conservatives get more than 80 seats in the election
@boota1979
21 күн бұрын
@MrCostas32 80 seats, I was hoping 80 votes!
Sunak has jumped the shark! Is this the Theresa May manifesto moment?
@michaeladkins6
21 күн бұрын
richi is counting the days until he is in San Francisco.
I would rather go to prison than fight for the WEF
@gio-oz8gf
22 күн бұрын
Will you stop talking about the WEF, you sound like a fruitcake. What shape do you believe the Earth to be?
@boota1979
21 күн бұрын
@ballshippin3809 You wouldn't be fighting for the WEF.
@Rondoggy67
21 күн бұрын
Don’t worry, you won’t be called up. There isn’t a tin foil hat brigade in the British Army.
@boota1979
21 күн бұрын
@@Rondoggy67 Clueless....
@ballshippin3809
21 күн бұрын
@@Rondoggy67 Have you taken your 900th booster shot yet?..
If the Tories are so keen on national service why haven’t they done any in the last 14 years?
@briannewton3535
21 күн бұрын
Because they are now desperately clutching at straws.
@edmurth
21 күн бұрын
@@briannewton3535 my comment is ironic in that in the last 14 years the Tories have only served themselves and not the nation.
@briannewton3535
21 күн бұрын
@@edmurth Yup, I knew it was ironic, I chose my response to be less so, as the tories truly are clutching at straws now to gain relevance.
@stewartbunting3568
21 күн бұрын
Exactly, the Tories think it's a vote sweetener, which it isn't, it's a turn off for the books.
@MarkFoster321789
21 күн бұрын
It is called The WEF Plan…
National Services is for the Poor Lower Castes
Sunak doesn't relate to anybody but the 1%!!!! Useless!!!
It is a terrible idea. But elderly voters will lap it up.
@iwaddi1037
21 күн бұрын
I really really hope not. I'm sure elderly people are better than this.
@moomin7461
21 күн бұрын
@@iwaddi1037Don't get your hopes up.
Once Mr Sunak spends some time in uniform then he can start forcing other people's children to do likewise.
The voice he’s using is really unnerving - worry people worry this is only the first step of his plan - the next step is Ukraine front line !
Why do the rest of use have up subsidise a small minority of rich people who choose to send there kids to private schools. They should pay their service tax (vat) like everyone else.
Labour 500 seats / Conservatives 70 seats/ Lib dems 50 seats... that's my prediction... We will see a new very small and very right wing fringe conservative party after this election... The conservatives are finished!!! and will not be back (if ever) for another 20 or 30 years
@briannewton3535
21 күн бұрын
I would love to see the tories sink to below 100 seats. 70 seats would be a win fer sure. There is a possibility that the Lib Dems could take a few more off the tories though at the cost of what Labour could get. Calling the election later could have put the tories in third place behind the Lib Dems, that would have been awesome, though calling it early should put them in opposition. I am kinda going with your prediction though lib dems getting a handful more and labour a few less. I put the tories getting 85 seats.
@user-ej7yn3nz9w
21 күн бұрын
I predict labour 450 cons 100 Still got the die hard old white haired withered oldies that haven't a clue, still vote conservative having no idea what they are actually voting for..... 😂😂 They will be up there with there Zimmer frames certain that they know best!
@Myndir
14 күн бұрын
@@briannewton3535 I hope the Lib Dems mop up the centre Tories and become the new opposition. People who want populist conservativism can vote Reform. There's no need for a Tory party in 2024.
Next week's big policy announcement ; free puppies for everyone!
@Andygb78
18 күн бұрын
British Bulldog puppies only, though, to foster a sense of service to the nation.
@Myndir
14 күн бұрын
@@Andygb78 And only for the over 70s. Cared for by voluntary mandatory service from teenagers.
Conservatives have bled this country dry
@Viper91157
21 күн бұрын
MPs have been cheating benefits as long as I can remember I am 73 years old
Crazy Sunak doing what he does best, fiddling round the edges instead of getting on with the day job
Every senior army officer I have ever spoken to about this says that they have no funding for training, equipping and housing a couple of hundred thousand people who don’t want to be there. Furthermore they have no use for half trained national serviceman in any envisaged combat scenarios. It’s hopeless.
@roydavidlivermore4664
21 күн бұрын
Well two thirds of the soldiers that fought in the Korean War were National service and almost 400 were killed in action.They were pleased enough with them then.
@owencarlstrand1945
21 күн бұрын
@@roydavidlivermore4664 Taught how to use a Bren, 303 rifle, mortar and grenades plus blancoing webbing and painting coal white (read the play “Chips with Everything” by Arnold Wesker. That’s not to belittle the contribution but in 1952 the size of the British Army was 871,000 so many National Servicemen were support troops. Plus there were no drones, manpads, artillery detection radar systems, missile systems or computerised comms systems all of which require months of training. Different times in 1952.
@roydavidlivermore4664
21 күн бұрын
@@owencarlstrand1945 Yes,and of course there is now a very small regular army who would be unable to cope with huge intakes of recruits.
@owencarlstrand1945
21 күн бұрын
@@roydavidlivermore4664 Absolutely correct.
The last time the youth of this country were conscripted, 400 of them died, fighting in Korea.
any parent would naturally be concerned what the motive is here...is it to give them a structured experience, or actually be calling on them to act in some sort of defence capacity and why couldn't he just have met his targets. rather than deflect from their own failings
Yeah national service is very out dated idea. You already have kids in education in 18, if it was ever implemented it would just cause uproar and division amongst youth and parents alike
Conscription is a terrible thing.
@AnotherPointOfView944
21 күн бұрын
This isn't conscription. Can you not read?
@SK-hv3zn
21 күн бұрын
@@AnotherPointOfView944 Yes, but that is the actual plan!
@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968
18 күн бұрын
War is a terrible thing.
Labour give 16 yrs old the vote Conservative give them boot camp
Do us all a Service and Vote The Tories out for ever.
Wasn't Sunak talking about setting up reeducation camps for people who he did not see as sufficiently patriotic at one point? He's a bit Stalinist isn't he.
A gimmick it stinks of the Tories are the modern Natc party
Have lived through 14 Prime Ministers and Sunak is be far the worst. Utterly clueless. 😂😂😂😂
Sunak is the worst Prime Minister ever. Because he has no principles, he blows hot and cold over and over again. Teach him a lesson and boot him out of politics for good.
Sunak doesn't want to be a wartime PM but he is happy to send young boys to war! Bold and brave! Inspiring at least!
The state should not force anyone to serve in the military, but should encourage them, for example, with good pay. I'm from Poland, but I'm sorry to hear that any western country wants to use such coercive measures
"Bring Back National Service" - the cry of every old man in a pub who thinks young people are terrible and need to be taught a lesson.
It's straight off the Daily Mail front page circa 1970/1980s, it might play well with the Tory membership but not the wider electorate.
@Myndir
14 күн бұрын
Straight out of Putin's policies.
Given National Service stopped in the 60s maybe everyone who missed out should be made to do it retrospectively? Let’s see how popular that is!
Are young immigrants going to be told to register as well or will they be left alone to do as they please like they are now
Guarantee you there will be a clause that will state, none of the MPs 18yo sons or daughters shall be included
Instead, why not introduce a one off boomer windfall tax on anyone the over the age of 65 with over 1mil in assets and use the money to scrap all existing student debt? Would go just a modicum toward equalising intergenerational inequality
Maybe RS could do some national service himself, once he is out of office and has more time on his hands. Young people who want to be in the reserves or do volunteer work can already do so - by choice.
Why call it Compulsory national service if they can refuse,talk sense people 🏴
@deviousdescent9010
22 күн бұрын
They can't refuse, it's compulsory!
@privatefeaces
22 күн бұрын
Of course you can refuse, you always have a choice. You may to to prison but it's still a choice.
@petesearle8632
22 күн бұрын
@@privatefeaces they can't put anyone in prison as there are no spaces!
@Koi-addict33
22 күн бұрын
@@deviousdescent9010they can't make it compulsory
@boota1979
21 күн бұрын
@@Koi-addict33 Can't you remember the 'pandemic' They can do what they want, we have no say!
Someone wanting to make national service a thing that hasn't served themselves previously should be front and centre in line to be conscripted*. Edited to change recruited to conscripted
Its an idiotic, ill thought out and unaffordable idea. It would cost over £2bn to implement, money we should be spent in doctors, but apparently we dont have. Ed is right its a total gimmick.
18 yr olds who have two kids and are married be like whaaaat? U want me to go do volunteering lol
At a different time this is a good idea. Military or civilian service, gives our youngsters something to do, gives them a purpose, life skills, discipline, a sense of belonging to a society and something they can be proud of. We can recruit pensioners with skills to pass on for a boost in their pension, mould the next generation to be productive instead of being paid to sit at home. At the moment nobody wants to fight for a war engineered by the elite, to fight for a country they no longer recognise, to die on a foreign field for someone else’s war. Our kids have no future, nothing to do but play video games or hang around on the streets being recruited into street gangs. No hope of getting on the property ladder, nothing for them to do, treated as a problem for society rather than a valued asset to society.
Its the beginning of things like social credit.
@AnotherPointOfView944
21 күн бұрын
Eh, you have no idea.
Whose young people do the Tories intend to conscript ? Their own first presumably?
Next up? Pet ASBOs
Who would fight for the UK. 😂😂I don’t even recognise my neighbours anymore or even speak their language. No let them fight for it
@user-xw7cs3cx8e
21 күн бұрын
Language didn’t matter during world war 2 era. Check the word war 2 casualties
@Mizzkan
21 күн бұрын
@@user-xw7cs3cx8e Yes good point. It’s not relevant here at all but thanks for sharing it. all the sane.
@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968
18 күн бұрын
@@Mizzkan Why is it not relevant here?
@Mizzkan
18 күн бұрын
@@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968 Is it not obvious from my comment.? Why would anybody fight for the UK when you have a society fractured into ethnic groups and who despise you. Like I said let them fight for it , I certainly won’t 👍
@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968
18 күн бұрын
@@Mizzkan You're fighting to live in a democratic country. If you hate democracy you could live in Russia, now very much a fascist country. You display certain racist tendencies so it might be a good move for you. Mobilization is colour blind.👍🏼
"Were is the war" desperate tories they are the ones that should be conscripted or put in jail.
They have a plan to sort out the country. They have had 14 plus years and have continued to make things worse, so forgive me if I'm less than convinced .
I'd choose sanctions and wouldn't do that either.
Someone is pulling the strings behind
Personally I don’t think anything especially national service should be mandatory for anyone, especially teenagers. Everyone should have the choice what they do with their lives. It’s not fit for everyone.
Someone needs to remind Sunak which century we're living in.
So Rishi, my kids could find themselves in a trench somewhere near Kiev while a bunch of chancers in dinghies are living it up in a 4-star hotel? I don't think so.
Sunak seems to be preparing for war with Russia
@Makeyourselfbig
22 күн бұрын
Well is the sort of thing Putin would use to convince the Russian people that the West is preparing for war with Russia.
@briannewton3535
21 күн бұрын
I think he left it a bit late. When labour was in power we had 113,000 Defence personnel. the tories took us down to 75,000 I think just too little too late. 😅
More public money is spent on private school kids than on state school pupils in this country! You shouldn’t be allowed to be a business & have charitable status & all these other benefits that private schools have. If people want to pay for their kids’ ‘education’ then pay the full cost. I put education in quotes because they don’t pay for a special education, they pay for access that it brings in later life and looking at the state of the country, it is hardly an advert for the private school system
5:13 I am surprised that Tories are allowed to say that Labour has no plan. They are literally asking for a response “ Isn’t it hypocritical to claim that we don’t have a plan? We only didn’t have a chance to prove our plan yet. You had 14 years to make your plans reality, but look around. All the UK is in decay after your time in government. It tells me that either you have never had a plan, or you had a completely disastrous one. Which one is it?” I can tell for myself, that Labour lacking a plan is still better than Conservatives having many
vote labour the torys have lost it
@Andygb78
18 күн бұрын
Or in the words of Morrissey "Don't vote, it only encourages them".
This isn't the first time this has been mooted in recent years. I used to work for the dwp and the idea of compulsory national service for unemployed 18-24 year olds was batted around for a while under Gordon Brown's government. I know the reason it didn't happen and the reason it won't happen this time. Over 70% of Muslims in that age bracket are unemployed and it was made very clear to the government at the time that not one of them would ever agree to national service for the English armed forces so rather than be forced to explain why they were exempt the idea was scrapped, just as it will be this time!
@therealrobertbirchall
22 күн бұрын
English Armed forces? So they are only there to defend England? Why do the 'English military' have nuclear weapons in Scotland then?🏴🏴🏴
@ballshippin3809
22 күн бұрын
More British Muslims joined ISIS than they ever did for the British armed forces. Just shows you where their true loyalties really are. Yet they are just as British as you and me supposedly...
@Norfolkbiker50
22 күн бұрын
@@therealrobertbirchall hey, I'm just telling you what the report said at the time, and you're right, a disproportionate number of members of the BRITISH armed forces are Scottish, Welsh and Irish.
@Norfolkbiker50
22 күн бұрын
@@ballshippin3809 we both know there's no such thing as a "British Muslim".
@boota1979
21 күн бұрын
@Norfolkbiker50 Why were Muslims exempt? Muslims fought and died in their millions in WWII. What changed 2005/2010 to suddenly give them an exemption?
I have no sympathy whatsoever on the private school issue. Private schools are an elitist concept to begin with theirs no reason everyone shouldn’t get the same education. Private schools are just so rich people don’t have to send their kids to school with poor people.
I will not encourage my son to join the military. We would be better off getting rid of our current government instead. Make peace with Russia . Uk should not have helped orchestrate this conflict in Ukraine and scupper all peace deals which would have averted war, kept Ukraine neutral and intact. Now they want us to put our son’s lives up to bail out their misadventure.
@bendreczko9054
21 күн бұрын
problem with that idea is we know russia what all of ukraine, poland and other country under them, if they win Ukraine they will go after Poland next and poland is a nato country so we will be drag in, however if we halp Ukraine win, the war with nato will not happen.
@projectedone
21 күн бұрын
@@bendreczko9054 😂 nope. Where did you hear that? Sounds like you are just echoing the western media. Nowhere did Russia ever claim that they want to invade any other country. They even didn’t want to invade Ukraine.Widen your knowledge beyond the propaganda you would be amazed .
@bendreczko9054
21 күн бұрын
@@projectedone well it came out of Putin him self when he want to "have the Baltics back under russia rule" this includes poland, not that they can anymore if they are having such a bad time in ukraine which is no wear near armed as poland they got no chance, also these day the Baltic see is now really all nato so good luck getting a russia navy there.
@projectedone
21 күн бұрын
@@bendreczko9054 where did Putin ever say that? Never heard him speak those words.
@bendreczko9054
21 күн бұрын
@@projectedone Putin claimed on January 16 that Latvia and other Baltic states are “throwing [ethnic] Russian people” out of their countries and that this situation “directly affects Russia’s security.” He said the same thing before he try to invade Ukraine. Now you see why all nato countrys are spending more money on there armys
I'll vote for Labour party working class and thumbs up 👍
Maybe, instead of National Service for 18 year olds they should introduce national service for MPs. They all have to do several weeks volunteering in a school, GP, hospital, care home, social care and police within their first 12 months in office.
Private schools, rich kids going to university avoiding the draft. Less fortunate burdened with national service. You buy education in private school like buying other VAT products. Private schools are not charities.
National service for a genocide state, put me in jail first.
Here we go again let's traumatise another generation😢😢😢