To those who don’t know, the reason they cut their hands was because the crys knife cannot be unsheathed unless it draws blood

@TheTaxburden

Жыл бұрын

Thank you! I was looking for this comment.

@johncontreras2327

Жыл бұрын

@@TheTaxburden it’s actually based on a real knife once used on a culture the French once colonized. They say that the knife has a bloodlust and cannot be sheathed unless it taste blood.

@keysersoze5920

3 ай бұрын

Just like a samurai with his katana.

@senseishu937

3 ай бұрын

@@johncontreras2327 the bedouin or the algerians?

@johncontreras2327

3 ай бұрын

@@senseishu937 I’m not sure sorry

"I judged hastily." Bro tried to kill her like 5 secs after meeting them go figure

@bondrewdthenovel3598

Жыл бұрын

Is because he initially thought that she is just a normal woman. When he realized that she is a Bene Gesserit skilled in the Weirding Way he changed his mind.

@Badartist888

Жыл бұрын

Love how she sniffs him as he says that then lets him go. She can smell that he is telling the truth from her training.

@bondrewdthenovel3598

Жыл бұрын

@@Badartist888 Considering that Fremen don't take showers often (is a waste of water) I guess Jessica burned her nostrils on that sniff.

@svetchannel2998

Жыл бұрын

A vile, low and vile people of bandits who gladly kill children and women lost in the desert

@tb4495

2 ай бұрын

@@bondrewdthenovel3598Ha!

"What can you offer?" Aren't they from a whole-ass planet full of water?

@FPAlpha

Жыл бұрын

With no ability to get it from there to them 😉

@IdoDekel-do7hh

Жыл бұрын

They don't even need that, they can go get some asteroids that have ice on them and drop to the fron orbit. There must be millions of gallons of asteroid ice in that solar system.

@TayGizzle

Жыл бұрын

@@FPAlpha don't the Fremen smuggle spice offworld to a bunch of planets? (Hence no satellites over Arrakis). You're telling me they can't go back home with ships full of water on those return flights? They got the spacing guild in a chokehold because of their addiction to spice.

@FPAlpha

Жыл бұрын

@@TayGizzle No they don't as it is not yet known that the Fremen have the potential to wipe out Spice production forever, Paul makes this public at the end when they win the war and he uses this nuclear option to get everyone including the Guild ( which in reality is more powerful than the Emperor) under control. They could go back with the smuggler's, Jessica mentions this in the movie but Paul decides to stay and fight the war. I was talking about your assumption that they could pay with water from Caladan, which is theoretically possible but they don't have control over Caladan anymore as they had to give it up to take over on Arrakis. In any way why would the Fremen accept such a flimsy offer when they have 2 people full of water right in front of them? Fremen are very practical and direct - better have the spoils now than to trust the word of an outsider.

@quintoblanco8746

Жыл бұрын

@@TayGizzle The Harkonnens control most of the spice mining. Remember the big spice harvesters? They exist both in the book and in the movie. The Freman don't have those. As for Caladan, the Atreides no longer control it after the death of Leto. Paul could stake his claim as the legal heir, he is a Duke so technically Caladan belongs to him. But without military power he would be killed. And without political or military power, the Guild would not help him. SPOILERS... of course after the Harkonens are defeated, Paul controls all spice mining and indeed uses that to force the Guild to do his bidding and off-world water is transported to Arrakis. As for this particular scene, the Freman want water now, some of their troop are likely dying of thirst. There not interested in a vague promise of some water in the future.

Stilgar: What wealth can you offer beyond the water in your flesh... Jessica: 10 gallons of Crystal Springs water delivered to your door once a week.

@pseudonymousbeing987

Жыл бұрын

Stilgar: "should we get married?"

@grantmccoy6739

Жыл бұрын

I think he meant, "right now".

@NightRunner417

Жыл бұрын

ROFL Stil: "You make a generous offer but your water is needed now." Jessica: "Well, what about free delivery with Prime? You get to choose your Amazon Delivery Day and it's pretty fast." Stil: "This we have heard of but we do not consider it to be cost effective given the membership fees." Jamis: "They waste our time! Amazon Prime has not been reliable for many months!" Paul: "Ok, we see your point, but what about Fedex overnight for a small fee?" Jamis: "Stilgar! Come back to reason! It is known that in this pandemic no fast delivery services are reliable!" Stilgar: *sigh* (Fremen all nod sadly)

@TheGianKl

Жыл бұрын

if she continue that road he will answer like in the movie no country for old man

@salguodrolyat2594

10 ай бұрын

She should have told him about all the water on caladan. More water than all fremen could use in a lifetime.😁

I feel like this scene was cut short. In the book it emphasizes how huge a deal it was she bested Stilgar as he was the leader and thus the best of them. He accepted her because he wanted her to teach her fighting techniques and there was a good amount of negotiation. The also crammed in the fight with Janis his death and funeral. How Stilgar gave the name Usul to Paul after he admitted he never killed a man and paul beating Jamis without a scratch on him and crying for him was also a big deal as it fit him into the legend. Also how paul got the name Maub dib

@ericgoodwin6285

Жыл бұрын

This the trouble with movie adaptations. There have to be choices which people may not like. The film really should be viewed before reading the book as a sort of primer.

@TheDrexxus

Жыл бұрын

@@ericgoodwin6285 I'm glad books are starting to be adapted into high budget series rather than movies. Trying to cram all that content into a 2 hour run time, or even the rare 3 hour run time, just leaves out too much. But in a 10 hour season like game of thrones? It is far superior. If there were a series made at this quality, it would've been so much better. We would need so much less forced exposition and rushed scenes to get the story from A to B.

@nvelsen1975

Жыл бұрын

@@ericgoodwin6285 Maybe that's the best praise to Villeneuve, the director: Previous adaptations pretty much required reading the books to find them decent. This film you can see without reading a single page and still get it.

@skoomamuch356

Жыл бұрын

lol Part 2 isn't out yet

@NinoNiemanThe1st

Жыл бұрын

Yes, I agree @Pat Fam. Although getting all the complexity of the book into a movie in a Hollywood series is pretty hard!

“Our conversation ran short”’sounds like a line from Mission Impossible! lol

I think this was one of the best scenes. You get to see how capable Paul and Jessica can move in unaccustomed terrain. Also Chani's skills.

@jdgoesham5381

Жыл бұрын

What skills? As a womb for Paul? Haha.

@magneto44

Жыл бұрын

@@jdgoesham5381 huh?

@timothywilkins1831

Жыл бұрын

@@jdgoesham5381 she plays a huge part after her death in Ghanima's other memory

@DeadManSinging1

Жыл бұрын

@@magneto44 What he means is that Chani doesn't do anything.

@LandersWorkshop

Жыл бұрын

You don't see Chani's skills in this scene.

I imagined Bene Gesserit as ninja-assassin-nuns in my head canon.

@koko40800

10 ай бұрын

That's kinda what they are yes...ninja assassin nun sorceresses

@fdajax5107

4 ай бұрын

Not too far off the mark, my main gripe of the movie was that Jessica was not portrayed correctly she's more calculated, cunning and stoic.

@bos9824

2 ай бұрын

@@fdajax5107 And the second movie?

@alariaharken9573

2 ай бұрын

If you want to read more about ninja assassin nuns read the book of the ancestors trilogy by mark lawarence

@docjayva7973

15 күн бұрын

what other superwoman fantasy are they going to create , yes women are all powerful not .

Jessica called tails on the coin flip but she knew what she was flipping for.

@ericsong5155

3 ай бұрын

LMAO the reference

Loved seeing both Paul and Jessica engaging in combat with the Fremen. Brief scene but showcases both of their combat skill

Great scene. The arrogance of the Fremen, and especially Jamis and Chani in their dialogue as the duel looms, is astounding. Jessica and Paul jacked up their whole operation in like 5 seconds.

@spencerschubert5001

3 ай бұрын

I have always found it comical how Jamis gets so ridiculously cocky and condescending in the next scene and then flattened no problem by Paul

@koko40800

3 ай бұрын

@@spencerschubert5001 Well to be fair there's no way Jamis could have known this boy had BG fighting training, and weapons training from some of the best fighters in the Imperium...his bad luck, he called out the wrong kid lol

@lekhakaananta5864

2 ай бұрын

@@koko40800 seems like something that is possible to anticipate if you know the boy is the son of a duke of one of the most powerful factions in the universe. Not every duke's son is gonna be trained as a super soldier, but it way more likely than your average boy. So it's still ignorance/arrogance.

@Pdmc-vu5gj

Ай бұрын

​@@lekhakaananta5864 It's implied that some of the fremen are extremely ignorant

@JohnDoe-sw1rs

Ай бұрын

Someone said if Paul didn’t disarm Jamis and embarrass him he wouldn’t have invoked amtal

This scene is too bright. Needs to be darker.

@marioxxx154

Жыл бұрын

Dude....

@hajoos.8360

Жыл бұрын

There is no free luncheon for everyone.....

@fatfreddyscoat7564

Жыл бұрын

This makes the battle scene in Game of Thrones look bright.

@hajoos.8360

Жыл бұрын

@@fatfreddyscoat7564 A beach fighting during the sun is shining is in Robin Hood or El Cid. In Winter it is not so funny.... beaches are uncomfortable for killing enemies.....

@ashcarrier6606

Жыл бұрын

Sarcasm noted and logged.

Stilgar takes position on Jessica, Jessica squares up without hesitation or fear after looking to her son as if to confirm a plan of action. Stilgar misses all of that and then asks why didn't you tell me? He cut the conversation off and yet she still managed to tell him he was about to get clapped 😅

@bos9824

2 ай бұрын

Lmao true

@23Revan84

Ай бұрын

Worse, worse is that Jessica never used the voice. 😂 Imagine Jessica using the voice on him and on the others. 😂 Jessica is a beast and barely fought and used her training. Stilgar was clapped before they even met. 😂

I love the use of Chakobsa. I also think the choreography and filmmaking is very good here, contrary to what I've heard others say. Everything is very clear and you can see exactly what each movement is. They look believable. Jessica really seems to outmanoeuvre Stilgar and Paul looks extremely agile.

@neub4321

Жыл бұрын

Unclear to me, like the others you've heard. Maybe better on the big screen...

@ericarmstrong3435

Жыл бұрын

Paul was extremely fast. No doubt a result of training from his mother and many of the best warriors in the Dune universe.

@bradleyjacinto7732

Жыл бұрын

@@neub4321 i saw this in Imax and this whole sequence was perfectly crisp and clear . Device brightness is probably the issue, definitely combined with the god awful compression this video suffers from.

@ronanwaring3408

Жыл бұрын

@@bradleyjacinto7732 Yea even compared to others of the same scene

@seandlax9

Жыл бұрын

@@ericarmstrong3435 Paul and Jessica have complete muscle control due to the Bene Gessarit teachings. They're both faster AND stronger than normal humans derspite their small frames. There's a reason the Reverend Mother tells Paul that no one would make it past Jessica as long as she guards the door at the beginning of the movie.

Lady Jessica is more than she appears to be.

@accessdenied5998

Ай бұрын

She trained in Weirding way and Bene Gesserit Acolyte ofc she more than that

01:36 Proper answer "Have you been to Calidan? It is a planet covered in water." (eye roll)

@960456

Жыл бұрын

I mean what good is that to the Fremen, who have no way off of Dune?

@Petey0707

Жыл бұрын

Yes but it is incredibly expensive to move water

I love how in the book, Lady Jessica tries to manipulate the Fremen by basically throwing buzzwords at them to pretend like she knows their culture and religion, even resorting to use her Bene Gesserit training, although she knows very little about Arrakis and the Fremen. It really shows a different side of the Atreides. They're clever, and use people the way rulers do, and aren't as heroic and "good" as they are in the film. Really great scene nonetheless, I loved the movie as a whole, really captured the dreamy, almost religious, vibe I got when I first red Dune.

@BeezOne84

Жыл бұрын

> It really shows a different side of the Atreides. It really does not. She's a duke's concubine and Bene Gesserit, not Atreides. Anyway, Paul has his time to show different side of Atreides in the future.

@pedroeldiablo811

Жыл бұрын

​@@BeezOne84 paul is good ! and Timothée is so cute ! ❤️🧡 😊 He will avenge his father and become a good ruler ! the fremen will be free ! what else could happen ?? 😇

@matthewhelton1725

Жыл бұрын

This was the whole purpose of "Missionaria Protectiva"; To provide the blueprint of legend for people to follow... since the Bene Gesserit influenced those legends for thousands of generations across the known universe, a Bene Gessarit Sister could, possibly, using the utmost discretion, survive (and prosper) in an unfamiliar culture.

@jakeg3733

Жыл бұрын

The woman that plays Jessica didn't get enough credit, she was freaking amazing and added a lot of nuance to this roll. You're right, if you pay attention you can see her not only being the concerned mother but trying to decode Fremen culture on the fly. She knows that "a path has been layed", as in these people were manipulated by her sisterhood for generations but she's trying to figure out exactly how they had done it

@woodwyrm

4 күн бұрын

well afaik the Atreides are portrayed as very Machiavellian in the books, even more than the Harkonnen.

I didn’t realize until I read the book that Jessica was “registering” Stilgar

@moondog5434

Жыл бұрын

What

@randomcurrypuff6237

Жыл бұрын

I’m just guessing here but the way she took a look at Stilgar… and even sniffed him is the Bene Gesserit way of “registering” someone which means she now sees through him, knows what kind of person he is and all that. Kinda like how Sherlock “deduct” people. Makes it easier to manipulate someone once you know stuff about them.

@SuperEholmes

Жыл бұрын

@@randomcurrypuff6237 I was curious about the sniffing she did on Stilgar.

@koko40800

10 ай бұрын

The BG also "register" a person by hearing them speak...once they hear enough of their voice tones, they know which 'Voice' tones will work on them....Jessica was able to use her superior martial arts skills to beat Stilgar tho, the BG prefer to use the Voice only as a last resort

@M.Elle-

3 ай бұрын

@@koko40800But she also won’t use The Voice on the Freman, let alone Stilgar.

I can't believe that Stilgar is also Anton Chigurh from No Country for Old Men! When I looked up the actor, I had to do a double-take!!

@thorbat

Жыл бұрын

It's amazing how he has an iconic voice but is still able to completely disappear into a role that you ignore it almost completely.

@arnoldfernbladst3875

Жыл бұрын

@@thorbat I compared the two and didn't think he sounded the same in both roles. He sounded American in NCFOM but Middle Eastern in Dune

@terben7339

Жыл бұрын

Javier Bardem sounds Spanish in every role he plays.

@ericgoodwin6285

Жыл бұрын

Damn. I knew he was familiar.

@AB-vp9mi

Жыл бұрын

@@terben7339 His eyes gave him away for me tbh. From N

I don't think any filmmaker could do the scene justice. You have to read the book and be inside their heads to know what's going here, and how formidable a trained Bene Gesserit is against someone who is arguably stronger than a Saudakar.

@DoubleClefFm

11 ай бұрын

The Dune universe is just too detailed for a movie. But i think this movie did a hell of a job. The atmosphere, the realism, the music, the storytelling......it is a great movie.

@milofah

4 ай бұрын

I think Children of Dune is the only one so far that has done the weirding way justice. Jessica goes from one position to another instantly when dodging the assassination attempt of Alia. That's what the weirding way is, focusing your entire will and control of your body into instantly moving from one position to another allowing next to 0 time for a response. Something not even a Sardauker can match. This looks more like she got the upper hand, not that they were not even remotely in the same class.

@bos9824

2 ай бұрын

@@milofah It looked cheesy cinematically though.

@TheDirtysouthfan

2 ай бұрын

It's a bit weird how Duncan Idaho claims that he's never been so close to death as to when he fought the Fremen, yet Paul and Jessica seem to overpower them relatively easily. It's also like how the Na-Baron is able to almost beat Paul and it's implied he's his equal or even better, but he's also never fought a fair fight before then. Even the one with the Atriedes who wasn't drugged was still in his favor because of those black being tasing him. The only reason they could possibly win is due to the powers of the Bene Gesserit, but they are so vague here.

@KylewithaK

2 ай бұрын

The fremen here were looked like slouchers in comparison to who they probably sent out to try and kill Duncan

at least they didnt sheath their blades unbloodied

@cadlac0594

Жыл бұрын

Now I understand why they did that

"Peace, woman. I judged hastily" Could be the famous last words 😂

2:51 that sniff felt strangely intimate

I liked the female voices in the soundtrack here. It's like the Bene Gesseritt are there assisting them against the Fremen.

@satioOeinas

Жыл бұрын

exactly!

I love me some Lady Jessica😂

Made me think of the Gurkha the way they wouldn't sheathe their blades without blood

@DanBeech-ht7sw

12 күн бұрын

The Ghurkas wash the blood off their blades in the tears of freshly-made eunuchs.

I do love how Stilgar is a man of faith, Janis was a mess tbh. Stilgar can let go of being killed and make a deal

I hope they expand more on these scenes in part 2. There are some important bits that they didn’t flesh out enough. I am glad the weirding way is back to a martial art though.

"We have powerful friends" It didn't work in Game of Thrones and it won't work here Lady Jessica!

@yeetwchybaban

3 ай бұрын

heh janos slynt??

This makes me want to read the book again.

@hateoverlove1

Жыл бұрын

I watched this and decided to buy all six books again lol

@MasterTSE

Жыл бұрын

I reread the book in preparation for this show. Well worth it.

That maula pistol looks sick

Incredible cinematography! (everything just a hair away from being the exact same color and tone lol)

Stilgar Ben Lifarily, may his tribe increase Awoke one night from a deep dream of peace And saw within the moonlight in his room Ichlyawich a riwoich yochiroah!

@DanBeech-ht7sw

12 күн бұрын

Very good reference there.

Javier Bardem is good in everything.

I'm hoping the water measurement from Jamis' body and getting bestowed to Paul is in part 2 along with Paul selecting his sietch name of Usul.

@paulkellerman2603

2 ай бұрын

Of course it is.

-Stilgar! You know me, you came to my father's council! -Nah, that was in the book. In this movie, the council was the separate scene.

@peter9477

Жыл бұрын

There's another scene where Stilgar did indeed come to visit the Duke, who had his top people with him. I would assume that's what was being referred to. (Edit: the original comment was edited since my response, so this comment may now appear pointless. I hate when they do that....)

I think the lesson we should all learn from this scene is: NEVER UNDERESTIMATE YOUR OPPONENT DURING A FIGHT You never know what someone is truly capable of Lady Jessica besting Stilgar is a prime example

I hope that in Dune Part 2, we'll get to hear more chakobsa!

Totally aside the subject matter here but does anyone else's knees hurt watching the Fremen crouch then stand up without having to grab onto something for support? LOL I wish my knees were still that supple and that I didn't have fibromyalgia and degenerative arthritis. 😄

@Ghaztoir

Жыл бұрын

Yeesh!

@xanthippus3190

Ай бұрын

I am not sick but I am fat and I feel you friend lol

" Peace woman..Peace.. I judged ...too hastily..! I encourage you to read the books...so much nuance in that written word.....this movie does it justice.

So many questions can be answered, including Q's about this scene and the dialogue, if you just read the books. They're often not quick and easy answers, but Frank Herbert covered a lot of bases in his writing.

@blackmage665

Жыл бұрын

or pay closer attention to what is not being said. and even then this is heavily truncated because movies don't have much time to exposit information.

@DoubleClefFm

11 ай бұрын

@@blackmage665 I think the movie was just sooo well made, that it makes the viewer hungry for more. Thats where the books come into the game xD

in parts the film is crisp and clear, but a lot is blurred and dark so you dont see any thing ie the storm night attack should of been better lit

I am asking myself why she didnt use the voice on him.

Um, the scene wasn't this dark in the movie...

@pyrolight7568

Жыл бұрын

Likely to get by automatic flagging.

@flybeep1661

Жыл бұрын

I have the movie on blu ray, have a dual monitor setup and compared the same freeze frame. This YT vid is actually brighter than the bluray movie. You're full of shit.

Funny thing about this scene that this could be avoided if jessica said she was a bene geserrit immediately. Even astilgar was baffled about that.

Ilsa Faust doing Ilsa Faust things

Jessica’s Voice is cut out of this particular clip

"OOOOOOH, I fucked up. Sorry."

Video is so dark you almost can't see it.

Ahh yes the weirding ways

Why didnt Jessica just use the Voice here? Fremen are immune or something?

@heatherbukowski2102

Жыл бұрын

That's a lot of people to control with the voice at one time. It's been a while since I've read the book, but I think you have to be speaking directly to a person to use it?

@Anthrolithos

Жыл бұрын

Persons have to be "registered" by a Voice user to play on their unique and innate psychological profile. Thus, a Bene Gesserit adept must listen and make note of pitch, cadence, and timbre when the target is talking. The Voice is not mind control, but simply causes a momentary lapse in awareness and conscious action, and the more people are aware of it, the less it becomes effective. The Voice is not an infallible weapon, and using it against large crowds is not really possible until Paul awakens his oracular powers later, and uses his vision of time to register every single member of a congregation so that he can tailor a Voice projection and create the greatest effect. It was how he united the Fremen tribes of Arrakis together for the first time in several thousand years in the Jihad, he essentially whipped them into a fanatical frenzy of bloodlust and conquest.

@pyrolight7568

Жыл бұрын

Stigar made it a one on one with Jessica. Also the voice is not all that effective vs a large group.

@chocoalmondfudge

4 ай бұрын

Someone commented that it's used as a last resort

Cannot see picture.

I liked the miniseries version when she used the voice to scare them off. And the fast move effects were good too. I miss that. Theyre superior in speed compared to normal humans right?

@ptinatlanta6815

Жыл бұрын

I actuallly liked that they toned down their powers. Made it more real

@meodreadgaming4084

Жыл бұрын

Not so much superior as just infinitely in control of their bodies. Maximizing and avoiding the rash decisions humans make under stress.

@minimilchshaker8219

Жыл бұрын

In the book, she chose not to use the voice and I like that the move did not change that

@lexysraymont9627

Жыл бұрын

I didn't read the books but I'm glad she didn't use the voice. It allows her to show the entire range of her abilities, which are not only in her powers but also in her training. I read once the Bene Geserit were even better fighters than the Emperor's shock troops. And I feel like, not using the voice every time makes it an even more serious power, like something they would use only in dire necessity, and not a show off. Jessica wasn't afraid in this scene. I love the character, she is so complex, a melange of strength and weakness.

What’s the “wrist cutting” about at the end of the scene?

@JB-vx5jb

Жыл бұрын

I think it's in their culture never to sheath their blades until they've drawn blood.

@Kazanko28

6 ай бұрын

I believe that’s from the books. The knives they use are called cryst knives. If you unsheathe them they need blood otherwise they will break. The knives are made from the teeth of the giant worms.

@DanBeech-ht7sw

12 күн бұрын

Stilgar is devastated at losing.

blooper with pauls mask off n on while pointing a gun

She speaks Chakobsa, you look for a sign,

I wonder if stigar deliberately lose to her.

I like how the haunting soundtrack implies that the Weirding Way is being executed. Also, all of you people complaining about the lighting on a youtube video are LAME LMAO. You get what you pay for! Thanks for the upload!

1:20 the next sequel later... Lisan al Gaib!

Hans Zimmer is such a goat.

One of the reasons this series was so good was the brutal realism that unless you've witnessed it, may be tough to accept is how many think. The savage barbarity of a culture that celebrates murdering people for a need of their nutrients, which is little different than cannibalism, plus redefining honor to be more like a gang in the desert is not new. This scene wraps it up nicely by the celebration of murder and 'lead by martial prowess', all while claiming victimhood and willing to kill for any social slight and demanding no one dare judge their chosen path of barbarism. Our history is full of this and we see that emerging again. Frank Herbert did his homework.

@Anthrolithos

11 ай бұрын

Couple of issues: - Just "a" culture that celebrates murder to meet need? Do you know of any exceptions? - "Honour" is culturally defined, not universal, so an accusation of "re-definition" is a bit disingenuous. - "Leading by martial prowess" is bedrock statecraft. Not really sure how you expect the Fremen to be any different. - Not sure where you got "killing for any social slight" - Jamis is an exceptional hothead, and the book is clear that many Fremen are more even-headed. As for "claiming victimhood", the Fremen do no such thing, and they make no apologies for their existence and their struggle to be free - as for barbarism: in a universe where people are literal slaves, perhaps "bucking popular culture" is deserving of a more fitting term?

@hectorfernandez4098

10 ай бұрын

@@jaker9901 THE GREATER GOOD

Anyone know what language they're speaking? I'm not talking about in lore, I mean is this a real world language or did a linguist come up with it for the movie?

@bellatrix281

Жыл бұрын

Is lenguage chakobsa of the book original.

I love Stilgar

I hate to say this but the fights in the movie seem a bit underwhelming. The characters are supposed to be almost superhuman. Here, they just seem ordinary well trained men. There's no Prana-Bindu Weirding Way. Don't get me wrong, I love the foreshadowing, music and acting presence depicted in the movie. It's just that action sequences are not up to the same level.

wait wait this dude had had a gun on him this whole time!?

@LandersWorkshop

Жыл бұрын

Yeah but they aren't that effective against shields (although it would have wrecked the Fremen who don't typically use them) and he had a shit position until he took to the high ground. Also I think the Fremen carry them, at least in the first movie they did.

I think the dialect coach completely failed on this one. Bardem went for a very particular accent, but none of the other Fremen actors spoke in the same way: it ruins the sense of cultural cohesion that Fremen of the same Sietch are supposed to have. They focused on giving them their own language, but they didn't pay attention to when they were speaking English.

@trueandika

3 ай бұрын

We don’t care

@shaggygoatboy1125

3 ай бұрын

@@trueandika "We"?

@alvaroprieto2092

2 ай бұрын

They're all like different ethnicities lol, I don't think they were going for cohesion

😮

Liked the older versions so much more and weirding way battle techniques were cooler.

why didnt she or paul just use the voice? why they gotta be extra and use hand combat. I mean the author invented the concept of the voice so maybe use it more than twice in your story???

Lisan al gaib !

Why do they cut their wrists?

@abc123moomy

Жыл бұрын

I believe that’s from the books. The knives they use are called cryst knives. If you unsheathe them they need blood otherwise they will break. The knives are made from the teeth of the giant worms.

@Bajicoy

Жыл бұрын

@@abc123moomy that's wild, thanks!

@davemclaughlin8625

Жыл бұрын

If the knife is drawn blood must be shed.

@fishsing7713

Жыл бұрын

​@@abc123moomy The word is one word, Crysknife. And the blooding part is not because it'll break, rather it's a cultural teaching about importance of decision, if you gotta unsheathe the knife that mean you expect blood to feed the blade. kind of a nod to the Gurkha Kukri's myth. iirc the blade does break tho, if it leave the rightful owner's side without some treatment first.

@davidlittle7418

Жыл бұрын

@@fishsing7713 Yes Frank Herbert extrapolated a lot of myths & beliefs into the future in his books, I think I remember the Bene Gesserit were meant to be catholic nuns evolved into something other than they are today.

i swear my ex was bene geserit . i did all

well obviously they can offer water shipments from off world, such limited vision And if they don't want to depend on it then no reason to depend on supposedly easy preys from off world either, wouldn't want to grow spoiled.

@d-_-b8558

Жыл бұрын

The Fremen have been cheated, lied to, mistreated, and oppressed by the Harkonnens. They have no reason to believe the Atreides will be any different. Plus, the Duke is dead and these two are possibly the last survivors. What pull will they have? How will they even use what political power they once had? The Emperor wanted them dead.

@jacobsnapp

Жыл бұрын

Right now they can’t offer anything they have no ally’s no wealth and no power they’re two off worlders lost in the desert

@loganjelinek2226

Жыл бұрын

The Atreides have nothing in this scene. The Duke is dead. Paul and Jessica are presumed dead. Their ships are destroyed, their armies are slaughtered, and The Harkonnens control Arrakis again. The Emperor backs them. No interstellar travel can be done without the Spacing guild's consent, and the guild has absolutely no reason to piss off the Harkonnens or the Emperor by running water shipments to the planet for two Atreides who everyone else thinks to be dead. Someone would look into why water shipments from Calidan (Or any other world) are coming to Arrakis and would find out that Paul and Jessica were alive, which is obviously not a good thing for them. Furthermore, the Guild accepts enormous bribes of spice from the Fremen to perpetuate the lie that the southern half of Arrakis is uninhabitable and ravaged by magnetic storms that knock down satellites, because the Fremen are secretly collecting hundreds of millions of gallons of water to terraform the planet over the next few hundred years. Also, it's mentioned earlier in the movie that the Imperial census vastly underestimates the total Fremen population of the planet. If it's discovered that the Fremen are trying to terraform the planet, and that there are an enormous number of them living in secret, the Emperor and the Bene Geserit (who are 100% reliant on Spice as an economic and political tool) will have no choice but to descend on Arrakis and slaughter all of the Fremen, because if Arrakis is no longer a desert, the sandworms will die out, and that will mean no more spice. The Guild is also terminally reliant on the spice, which leads me to believe that even though they're taking these huge bribes of spice from the Fremen, even they don't know what their true intentions are. The Fremen have been surviving on Arrakis for thousands of years. They understand and implement very effective methods for gathering water every day. They don't need, and more than that, don't WANT offworlders bringing shipments of water to Arrakis because it will only draw attention to their intentions. The Fremen, and especially Stilgar, do not have "Limited" vision. It's stressed many times in the book that Stilgar is one of the most important figures to Fremen society and he most certainly knows when someone has nothing of value to offer him.

@satioOeinas

Жыл бұрын

this is wrong wrong and wrong. They had no allies and no money. no.

Lady jessica beats stilgar

why does she smell him?

@1down4upworkshop61

Жыл бұрын

I always assumed it was the relatively first time she has been near some one so immersed in the Spice and gave him a sniff .. Kind of like in the Lynch version when the Duke and Paul rescue the miners, and Paul makes mention of smelling raw spice ....

@Tinroofdeals

Жыл бұрын

He had farted....

@crack61616

Жыл бұрын

@@Tinroofdeals she wanted to smell a fremen fear fart,yeah.it is in the books.

@marioxxx154

Жыл бұрын

A benegeseret make a mental image from one person. His voice . Body mov and smell. Eyes . Bread

@LabTech41

Жыл бұрын

It might have something to do with the brief moment, as Paul and Jessica are trying to insinuate themselves into the Fremen, that Jessica tries to seduce or heavily imply that accepting her and Paul will afford Stilgar sexual access to Jessica. Stilgar would know she was married in all but law to the Duke, but he would also know that she's a widow now, and thus available to Stilgar. Basically, she's showing a primitive but effective form of affection to lure him in, and with his support their odds of survival increase dramatically. By the time Paul begins to make a name for himself within the tribe the lure is no longer necessary, but when you're in that vulnerable a position, why not use every option? It's dropped fairly quickly in the book, and it's not even brought up in the movie/miniseries that was previous to this.

2:54 - 3:20

why does jessica sniff stilgar tho?

@randomcurrypuff6237

Жыл бұрын

I believe she was “registering” him. Something the Bene Gesserit do. Not sure if you read the book (I did just after I watched the movie lol) but when you “register” someone you kind of see through them, what kind of person they are, and you know how to manipulate them.

@seekeroflest924

Жыл бұрын

to smell that 40 years of showering with sand

Wtf. The budget does not include lights?

@flybeep1661

Жыл бұрын

It's supposed to be night numbnuts.

@davelewis9439

Жыл бұрын

@@flybeep1661 whoa back big nell. Chill

@BeezOne84

Жыл бұрын

It looks like it was darkened. It was much brighter in IMAX.

@onesolopolo4194

4 ай бұрын

It’s to dodge copyright on KZread. The video was free, instead of complaining the correct course of action was to pay to watch the movie again or say “thanks for upload”

I'm a huge Javier Bardem fan but I have to say I'm not feeling him as Stilgar.....maybe the accent being heavy. I also had a negative response about Jason Momoa being cast as one of the all time great characters of the Dune novels and favorite of mine Duncan Idaho. Let me say this.....18 years ago I was not amused when BSG Starbuck was recast as a women.....I now eat my words/attitude for all to see. Katee Sackhoff was brilliant and Jason Momoa nailed it as Duncan.

Why did she do a Joe Biden at 2:49 ?

@ToreDL87

Жыл бұрын

Apparently its how the people she came from sized up others and learned to read them.

Can't see a thing 🤷‍♂️

@reidflemingworldstoughestm1394

Жыл бұрын

Basically the FBI agents follow the mercenaries into the the tunnel, and Kate takes a wrong turn where she finds Alejandro kidnapping the Mexican state police and he shoots the girl in her breast plate for being too sassy.

Filmed in the style of the last season of Game of Thrones…. Can’t see nothin

@jamesbrown5262

Жыл бұрын

adjust you brightness.

@mdd04000

Жыл бұрын

Open your eyes

@PaulLembo

Жыл бұрын

wasn't this way in theaters.

@BeezOne84

Жыл бұрын

It looks like it was darkened. It was much brighter in IMAX.

Speak English!

2:11 - 2:25

Completely black screen

shit shadow of what has already been done

this movie must be renamed CULTURAL APPROPRIATION FROM GAMES MOVIES AND CULTURES. its like that movie avatar who advertised its movie claiming original ideas and concepts

What a freaking hack job of a joke that new Dune movie is. Invented scenes, changed characters (the Baron is turned in a freaking Marvel villain), sooo much time spent on pretty pictures and sooooooo little content. The SciFi channel three part series is far superior, too damned bad was on a shoestring budget.

@kazoosc

Жыл бұрын

I find Stellan Skarsgard very believable as the mastermind behind the plot to snuff House Atreides after Part II comes out, I expect I will be ranking the adaptations .. Veilleneuve .. SciFi .. Lynch .. I want the atmosphere, the better effects

@johnpauljones9310

Жыл бұрын

@@kazoosc Lynch captured the grandeur of the empire, the "feel" of it. The SciFi miniseries told the story. This... is... The Ten Commandments and Twilight mashed together. Sure, it's epic, but the gender swapping and other unnecessary character changes were obviously to make it appeal to such a wider audience its bland -- flavorless, boring. Dune is not a hero story, but a warning.

@ericarmstrong3435

Жыл бұрын

I think a lot of stuff got cut in editing that should have been included. Hopefully part 2 shows us more about the weirding way and navigators guild and stuff. I remain hopeful. Also would love a directors cut with a couple hours of extra scenes to get the full scope of the story. The scene of Duncan Idaho doing an orbital HALO jump would have been awesome to see but they cut it from the opening of the movie.

@johnpauljones9310

Жыл бұрын

@@ericarmstrong3435 Having read the entire original series of books, I'm so fucking tired of Duncan Idaho I don't want to see another second of him.

@ericarmstrong3435

Жыл бұрын

@@johnpauljones9310 I just think it would have been a badass scene to see him do a suborbital halo jump on screen.

Lady Jessica is clever women

Why is this so bright? Can’t you darken it before you upload it?

Man they picked the worst actors for this. Shame

@brianm3160

Жыл бұрын

And?