Stephen Hawking was arguably one of the greatest physicists of our generation. What are some of your favorite moments from Neil's interview with Stephen?

@uss_04

6 жыл бұрын

National Geographic this was a report of an earlier interview? When was it?

@adamcochran1309

6 жыл бұрын

I liked when Stephen Hawking Explained his reasoning for the big bang, and It reminded me of Magnetic poles, and how Much he (Stephen Hawking) must think about the "big" big bang and all the "what if's" streaming from him daily. For example, Is There things the opposite of a black hole? has one been created(Probably not By humans)? I feel that if Before the big bang, there was Absolutely nothing, Than Nothingness is

@AlwaysWrenchin

6 жыл бұрын

My favorite part is when Neil refers to hawking as being a in the same chair as Issac Newton, and Hawking smile just priceless. you made that mans day. from 8:04-8:10. thank you both for a great interview.

@gwenconner2923

6 жыл бұрын

National Geographic when Neil asked Steven what would he ask Newton! His answer was priceless! R.I.P 😇

@jasongriffin8177

6 жыл бұрын

I would have to say that the look on Neil Degrasse Tyson's face when Stephen Hawking was talking about time travel. Neil's eye looked like they were rolling into the back of his head because Neil's Mind had to reboot. Priceless.

The fact that this LEGENDARY duo has an interview that has significantly fewer views than anything the Kardashians put out really illustrates Earth's issues.

@dmitriychernoshey4139

2 жыл бұрын

Yep, and it proves that even in a hundred years humanity will still be a type zero civilization

@chrissinclair4442

2 жыл бұрын

@@dmitriychernoshey4139 Unsealed documents stated Stephen Hawking abused children on the child abuse islands of Jeffrey Epstein. It came out in unsealed documents with pretrial judgments of the on-going Ghislaine Maxwell prosecution. And yes, Epstein had several islands. Also could be Epstein was running same operations out of his brothers mansion in NY, that he was out of his.

@computerfreak247

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah I was surprised by the view count, thought it would have more.

@salesp6351

2 жыл бұрын

That’s just what’s available and advertised on tv. Blame the ones who control the media

@kevinvotaw2916

2 жыл бұрын

I'm sorry but this low hanging logical fallacy is just... so dumb. For starters, you realize how elitist this perspective is, right? It's gatekeeping on the virtual highways. You are affixing yourself as the arbiter of what is important, worthwhile, and take it upon yourself to declare that a great population of our earthly brethren are "stupid" or "sheep" or "missing what's important" or any other nonsensical conclusion drawn sneering at our society while seated so snidely atop your ridiculous high horse. I really hope you outgrow this perspective, and channel your energy and focus onto our similarities, not out differences. I hope you can put to rest this malignant idea that there is some Kardashian-loving piece of the population that is in any way different than you. Empathy. Good luck, and we're all counting on you.

"People won't have time for you if you are always angry or complaining" - Stephen Hawking. This is my favorite quote from him. Thank you for your great contributions to humanity.

@JustLikeHeaven77

6 жыл бұрын

Jose Jimenez You just described me and yes, I am alone.

@iorr98

6 жыл бұрын

revolutions always starts with anger and complaints, we'd still be living under feudalism if it was not for that. There's a time and place for all emotions.

@originalghoul3738

2 жыл бұрын

Can you imagine if Stephen Hawking lived today in 2020-2021, wonder if people would take his quote and ignore these non-sense SJWs?

@seikoshinohara3084

2 жыл бұрын

@@originalghoul3738 I'd imagine that Dr hawking would have (and has) supported social justice.

@chrissinclair4442

2 жыл бұрын

Unsealed documents stated Stephen Hawking abused children on the child abuse islands of Jeffrey Epstein. It came out in unsealed documents with pretrial judgments of the on-going Ghislaine Maxwell prosecution. And yes, Epstein had several islands. Also could be Epstein was running same operations out of his brothers mansion in NY, that he was out of his.

Seriously got choked up to see him so happy in the 0 gravity plane.

@chrissinclair4442

2 жыл бұрын

Unsealed documents stated Stephen Hawking abused children on the child abuse islands of Jeffrey Epstein. It came out in unsealed documents with pretrial judgments of the on-going Ghislaine Maxwell prosecution. And yes, Epstein had several islands. Also could be Epstein was running same operations out of his brothers mansion in NY, that he was out of his.

@saddpaanda

2 жыл бұрын

@@chrissinclair4442 huh?

@joltjolt5060

2 жыл бұрын

@@chrissinclair4442 how the heck he was in a dang WHEELCHAIR.

@chloehennessey6813

2 жыл бұрын

@@joltjolt5060 that doesn’t matter. Had a guy lift my skirt in a wheelchair on public transportation.

@Mahlak_Mriuani_Anatman

Жыл бұрын

@@chloehennessey6813 👀

The smile when he compared him with Issac Newton...my heart is melting🥺💞

@mysticfidah1563

Жыл бұрын

You gotta ♥️😁

It’s sad to see such an intelligent, determined, and funny man go. The scientific community, no, the world has lost a wonderful asset. You will be dearly missed Dr. Hawking.

@NatGeo

6 жыл бұрын

May he rest in peace. Stephen Hawking will be always be remembered for his groundbreaking contribution to physics and our understanding of the universe.

@0okamino

6 жыл бұрын

Stephen Hawking was barely a teenager when Albert Einstein died (though it's an interesting coincidence that Hawking died on Einstein's birthday). Perhaps there's another young mind with just as brilliant potential out there right now. I certainly hope there is. Maybe they'll help us go even farther with our knowledge.

@extropian314

6 жыл бұрын

It will sure be cool if he chose to do the cryopreservation, and we see his bright light again down the road :)

@bazookajoe6133

6 жыл бұрын

+extropian314 that's just creepy

@xxxgames4458

4 жыл бұрын

Fraud illumanti puppets. We are all clueless wanting answers and these fraud satanic decievers are doing exactly that, deception. Funny Neil degrasse tyson or hawking or einstein magically has the right answer , any other theory is instantly denied and ridiculed unless, it goes with the scheme/system. Star talk haha, ok, no one has been to outer space, even better when people like hawking's have theorys on black holes aka theory not universal truth but not 1 time has even been into outer space. Genius pure genius.

Neil is such a good anchor. So respectful when interviewing Stephen. Love him!

@JoseMarquez-lt6yx

3 жыл бұрын

Is this the nice way of saying he held back the laughter was it just me or was he trying not to laugh

@josephbenson4444

2 жыл бұрын

@@JoseMarquez-lt6yx taking into consideration how much Neil loves science, he was probably just elated knowing he was talking to Stephen Hawking. I know i would be and i havent dedicated my life to science.

@mrbyzid618

6 ай бұрын

If it's fun, then surely it's not science.

“What we know is a drop, what we don’t know is an ocean.” - Isaac Newton

@stellarwind1946

2 жыл бұрын

Well that was before Einstein.

@HackionSTx

2 жыл бұрын

@@stellarwind1946 now what we know is an electron. What we don't know is the entire universe.

@stellarwind1946

2 жыл бұрын

@@HackionSTx that will always be the case until there’s a theory of everything

@user-zx7fj9ct2d

3 ай бұрын

@@stellarwind1946 That's never gonna happen.

I am heartbroken I never got to meet Stephen, but his work and legacy has left no one untouched. People come and go, but it is their ideas that are immortal, which will, in turn, inspire others to grow into new geniuses, and the cycle continues. Thank you, Stephen Hawking, for being such an inspiration by not letting forces out of your control stop you from doing what you love. You will live on in your work and in the lives you have touched.

@NatGeo

6 жыл бұрын

Thank you for sharing those kind words, Kimmy! While we too mourn the loss of Stephen, we ultimately are looking forward to how his work will inspire the next generation of bright, young minds.

@imlost9036

6 жыл бұрын

amazing comment 💙

@chrissinclair4442

2 жыл бұрын

Unsealed documents stated Stephen Hawking abused children on the child abuse islands of Jeffrey Epstein. It came out in unsealed documents with pretrial judgments of the on-going Ghislaine Maxwell prosecution. And yes, Epstein had several islands. Also could be Epstein was running same operations out of his brothers mansion in NY, that he was out of his.

Thank you NatGeo for making this available for all to watch.

People like Mr. Tyson and Mr. Hawking are gifts to our civilization. It's like mr. Hawkings body has been sacrificed for his mind. I can't imagine what it's like sitting there with Hawking. I could tell that Mr Tyson was nervous a little. Mr Tyson , I appreciate what you do. And sharing this information with everyone.

We need more scientists like Neil. He makes science fun.

@ElderGod4

Жыл бұрын

Science has always been fun he doesn’t need to make it fun . People are just low iq

@harls3337

Жыл бұрын

@@ElderGod4 what??? Having fun has nothing to do with a low IQ

@ElderGod4

Жыл бұрын

@@harls3337 if you can't uunderstand you cand find it fun

@rishdhoni319

Жыл бұрын

@@ElderGod4 This is true when you don't understand it, you can't find it fun and Neil is not touching the actual core of what they are talking about because people would get bored

@christophersebastiao7501

Жыл бұрын

@@ElderGod4 👈🏼 higher than normal IQ detected.

Never thought I would see Neil look confused. RIP Stephen Hawking

When Dr. Hawking actually stated a 10000% justifiable question to Newton, it gave me chills. Because Newton would figured it out.

@O.WhyMe.0

4 ай бұрын

Yess

Never in my wildest dreams I thought I would see my 3 favorite mad scientist together, S. Hawkings, N. DeGrasse and M. Kaku discussing a topic.... Wow, mind blowing info. I really thank you for sharing this N.G.

May you lay in peace Stephen.

@mrinvader

6 жыл бұрын

matter may neither be created nor destroyed... so We Will See Him Again.. He has merely transformed.

@ArcaneTurbulence

6 жыл бұрын

Actually.. It's energy that can't be created nor destroyed... Matter is made up of energy, but it can be destroyed and turned back into energy. I guess it's all in how you interpret the word "destroy". ;)

@jacobdrollinger4802

6 жыл бұрын

Q_Scope_Long Horn oh, he's at peace all right. Since, in his opinion, there is no God, and no afterlife!

@vinnyr3676

6 жыл бұрын

He is in space right now ahhhh

@3John-Bishop

5 жыл бұрын

Im glad he died, he is free of the chair now, his former prison.

I have never been so confused yet be able to understand something in my life.

When neil said Stephen hawking was on the level of Isaac Newton, Stephen hawking smiled.

@chrissinclair4442

2 жыл бұрын

Unsealed documents stated Stephen Hawking abused children on the child abuse islands of Jeffrey Epstein. It came out in unsealed documents with pretrial judgments of the on-going Ghislaine Maxwell prosecution. And yes, Epstein had several islands. Also could be Epstein was running same operations out of his brothers mansion in NY, that he was out of his.

Wow . Watching til the end was worth it. Seeing Michio Kaku, Bill Nye, and hearing that powerful message at the end was moving. Thank you Neil for this amazing episode.

@andrewgarcia4330

Жыл бұрын

I tried turning off because I had things to do, but couldn't. This was so great. I'm glad I watched it all.

Rest his soul

@JuneInjoy

3 жыл бұрын

He doesn’t believe in souls

@ZackeryCool

3 жыл бұрын

@@JuneInjoy rest his chair 🙏🏻

@JuneInjoy

3 жыл бұрын

@@ZackeryCool 😂

@kingsway731

3 жыл бұрын

Rest his identity data🤷‍♂️

@cheapdope

3 жыл бұрын

He was photographed on epstien Island. Just sayin.

my ex wife was full of negative energy, that time traveling she wolf!

@PearlDrummerFTW

6 жыл бұрын

Lmao

When Neil Degrasse says "I got 20% of where he's going", that's G.O.A.T. status. Thank you Hawking.

RIP Steven Hawking he put me on to astrophysics and the universe I’m in awe of this interview and how they try to make us civilians understand what they’re talking about completely

I almost cried from Professor Hawking's joke about the computer virus. Omg may he have the most peaceful rest. This is aching

3 of my favorite physicists in one episode. I love it.

Thankyou for not loading this full of commercials.

Godspeed Mr. Hawking, enjoy your trip through the universe sir.

@dinoceman9663

Жыл бұрын

Do not Go gentle into your good night

@josefsmolorz8311

11 ай бұрын

🛰️🎓🛰️

@simplyshady20

25 күн бұрын

Rage, rage against the dying of the light​@@dinoceman9663

Sad that we lost a brilliant mind but his work and findings will live on.

Crazy to think that hawking was actually a very active person who had his body robbed but he still never let it stop him ever

The fact this is barely about to hit 2 million views at 4 years says everything you need to say about humanity.

@G3MiNiOfficial

Жыл бұрын

It’s at 1.2 Mil what do you mean about to hit 2 mil.

@alvaroq2024

Жыл бұрын

@@abl.5464 Are you serious? What do you have against Dr Tyson?

@mikepatterson8177

Жыл бұрын

@@alvaroq2024 he was careful not to say black clown.

@Hudson_Ellinger

Жыл бұрын

True .. when u see justin bieber videos are hitting over 2 billions and science related videos barely few millions sometimes even thousands u just add another reason of why this human race is hopeless

@Hudson_Ellinger

Жыл бұрын

True .. when u see justin bieber videos are hitting over 2 billions and science related videos barely few millions sometimes even thousands u just add another reason of why this human race is hopeless

This is my 5th time viewing this. I learned more with this viewing than any previous viewing. This was an absolute treat that kept on giving. This show and its contributors are treasures of humanity. Thank you for this.

@chrissinclair4442

2 жыл бұрын

Unsealed documents stated Stephen Hawking abused children on the child abuse islands of Jeffrey Epstein. It came out in unsealed documents with pretrial judgments of the on-going Ghislaine Maxwell prosecution. And yes, Epstein had several islands. Also could be Epstein was running same operations out of his brothers mansion in NY, that he was out of his.

Neil clearly showed that he was in the presence of greatness.

@chrissinclair4442

2 жыл бұрын

Unsealed documents stated Stephen Hawking abused children on the child abuse islands of Jeffrey Epstein. It came out in unsealed documents with pretrial judgments of the on-going Ghislaine Maxwell prosecution. And yes, Epstein had several islands. Also could be Epstein was running same operations out of his brothers mansion in NY, that he was out of his.

Great episode. I absolutely LOVE Janna Levin!

There’s something so exciting about hearing these awesome questions from people and getting “We don’t know yet!” There’s still so much to be discovered and learned!!

29:29 "Something bad can happen to the world..... virus...." and I am watching this video 4/21/2020 when COVID-19 is here.....

@purple_gladge

3 жыл бұрын

That/this virus cant stop us. Watching feb 24. 2021 we still here all 8 billion of us.

@elizabethgracewienert1645

3 жыл бұрын

Heyy! Nice to see you in 2021, maybe it's time for a rewatch. Praise Science! Boo virus

@Strange_Man1911

3 жыл бұрын

What a darn miracle that I found and read your comment in my mind as Neil was saying it.

@sam8404

3 жыл бұрын

@@purple_gladge yeah except for the millions of people who have died from Covid.

@chrissinclair4442

2 жыл бұрын

Unsealed documents stated Stephen Hawking abused children on the child abuse islands of Jeffrey Epstein. It came out in unsealed documents with pretrial judgments of the on-going Ghislaine Maxwell prosecution. And yes, Epstein had several islands. Also could be Epstein was running same operations out of his brothers mansion in NY, that he was out of his.

We’re all star dust anyway so return to the stars Dr. Hawking!

@anom3778

6 жыл бұрын

Who are u talking to? Hawking doesnt exist anymore. Move on. Mourning is tribal and unhelpful. We need to progress. Get ur science book.

@0okamino

6 жыл бұрын

anom - You should find a how-to-be-a-human book. You don't seem to have a grasp on it.

@HyaSan

6 жыл бұрын

anom Mourning after loss is essential for mental health. Take "ur" robotic, nihilistic pseudo-intellect and read a psychology book.

@grbgeslnger24

6 жыл бұрын

Amy B - well said Amy

@LogicalArtist

6 жыл бұрын

anom The science book did not explain consciousness and how in memories, thoughts etc. he still exists. Science didn't explain that, can you?

Amazing video! Neil’s answer of Vincent VanGogh was spot on. Would love to meet that artist myself. The human mind is a beautiful thing.

😀I met Mr. Hawkins in 🇺🇸Pasadena, CA. Back In about 2005 I think, it was awesome to be next to this fabulous genius ❤️😀 I took a picture with him👏🏼👏🏼💪🏼

@LexiNc8284

5 ай бұрын

Aww that’s awesome!

That ending talk by Neil, literally triggered a goosebumps. 🤯

RIP Steven.....to the stars and beyond

@chrissinclair4442

2 жыл бұрын

Unsealed documents stated Stephen Hawking abused children on the child abuse islands of Jeffrey Epstein. It came out in unsealed documents with pretrial judgments of the on-going Ghislaine Maxwell prosecution. And yes, Epstein had several islands. Also could be Epstein was running same operations out of his brothers mansion in NY, that he was out of his.

You can see how humble Neil is when he’s with Hawking.

Seeing Neil fanboying out during that interview was kinda cute even if he was being a little silly. Sometimes it's hard to contain your excitement when you're meeting one of your greatest heroes

I'm not able to express how grateful I am to be alive on the same time and space that precious minds and hearts portrayed by Stephen Hawking and Neil DeGrasse Tyson. ❤️

@OmarAbdulMalikDHEdMPASPACPAPro

Жыл бұрын

It is INDEED, a privilege!🙂❤️🌌🔭

@dianamoss159

10 ай бұрын

Me too!

@youtubesongsffdf

6 ай бұрын

There both idiots

Ok ok.. Neil , Hawking, Kaku and Bill the science guy in the same episode?? My day had an excellent start. Can't get better than this.

I can die happy now that I've seen these geniuses together on the same show. Thank you ❤️

Perfect episode. Bill, Stephen, Neil and Michio.

This is an outstanding Star Talk. Thank You!

Didn’t understand 90% of what Steven Hawking said. Even with an explanation. I love space and astrophysics but don’t understand it AT ALL!

@travelhungry1019

4 жыл бұрын

Same here!!!! My mind can’t wrap around it.

Hawking is greatness personified! 😭

Neil’s closing remarks are legendary

I love it when Neil's eyes light up at Michio's theories.

12:55 dude that smile. pure joy. rest in piece Dr. Hawking

Those pictures of Hawking floating in space were really special. A perfect episode.

Neil always looks like he just ate something so good when he’s digesting hawkings thought process into what he’s explaining.

Rest in peace Stephen Hawking. Neil De Grasse Tyson's parting words are excellent and impressive.

As usual great job Dr.Tyson👍👍👍

Seeing the photos of Hawking in the Zero G plane made me so happy and excited for him. I’m so glad he got to experience that before he passed.

I loved how Stephen Hawkins invited conversation with those of us who had interest to do so....and I did for almost 2 years....thank you so very very very.....very much Sir Stephen Hawkins...!!!!!

This was really nice and relaxing to just listen to, RIP Stephen Hawking!

Best episode ever Thank you Nat Geo! RIP Stephen Hawking!!

Neil Degrassi Tyson is such a cool dude, he explains things so clear and gives the average Joe a good understanding and grasp of the subject at hand.

I like to see Professor Hawking smile.

Thank you for sharing this. I am moved to tears and feelings I don't understand. Thank you for bringing science to the masses. Thank you for helping me understand.

My brain is on FIRE! such a great chance to listen to brilliant minds talk shop 🔥🔥🔥

I love the look on Janets face when Michio was speaking about the multiverse. Like “Are you really entertaining this?”

Great show and input for education

Thank you for your wonderful life and mind. Rest In Peace Stephen Hawking.

It's so intrguing watching great minds converse..

I love Neil. He has a lovely temperament and I would guess that he was a sweet, happy, curious child. I imagine he would be fun to be around...in addition to a total genius.

Great stuff and very entertaining and interesting

What a way to finish the talk Dr.Tyson. Great job! More videos like this please

Great speach at the end Neil I Definitely agree our greatest gift is our mind, Consciousness itself, having the ability to make our own decisions ,it's crazy to think that we take that for granted

This is the greatest technological human interfacing technique I have ever seen.

Neil is by far one of my favorite people alive

Stephen Hawking brain was secretly uploaded to the cloud.

@kameronrichardson2266

6 жыл бұрын

Will I wouldn't be surprised if he figured out how to do that before he died I just was like cya

@steveo3530

6 жыл бұрын

Will you might say it jokingly but that technology was already around before he passed and I'm sure a guy of his intellectual status for sure had his brain mapped on to a hardrive somewhere haha

@eyeofbast

5 жыл бұрын

Will this is what starts bs conspiracy theories. We live in the 21st century and have thousands of simple minded people thinking the earth is flat.

@ljb5163

5 жыл бұрын

At least we know that no one can access it now lol

@xxxgames4458

4 жыл бұрын

I find it funny how people believe other people and recite their information as if genius level clicked in. Earth is earth because its earth and it's a ball in black space spinning 1000mph eastward and hurling 67,000mph because my tiny conciousness was told so and then I recite that like a slave because I'm a genius. I find it hilarious you think the iss is traveling at 3 miles a second yet video evidence clearly shows 0 motion or force, just like the cgi earth in the background that also have zero motion which scientists claim does various things like,spin,hurl,on axis. Oh so funny, flat earth? Psssss I dont need labels or groups bud, I know what you wish. Nasha to decieve in Hebrew Lookout for the underwater simulation drills and model effects/cgi with Hollywood trickery. I'm the crazy one. One rat chased the cheese, one rat made the cheese and one rat owned them all.

Stephen Hawking's smile when he dismissed Trump was priceless🤣

Wow! Tq NG for sharing this amazing talks from this amazing physicists.

Thank you Dr. Hawking, Thank You Dr. Tyson, and Thank You Dr. Kaku!!❤

@_asantesana_squashbanana_

4 ай бұрын

You missed one buddy.

@_asantesana_squashbanana_

4 ай бұрын

DR Janna Levin, the woman you somehow missed, is a highly respected astrophysicist. More so than Tyson and Kaku.

This episode answers so many questions I had and even questions that I don't think that I would have ever thought of. I believe in the Theory that energy can't be created or destroyed but only changes form and Stephen Hawking will still be with us along with all the other great energy in this universe.

MUCH MORE REAL & rewarding than any social gathering of people who are pretending something is real. That was incredible..especially the end.

The smile on Hawkins face when Neil compared him to Newton

Hawking, Einstein and Newton playing poker and arguing with each other on Data's holodeck program is my favorite moment.

I’m impressed that Neil asked the question “ so that means a black hole isn’t completely black?” Well in 2021 we finally got a clearer photo of one , and it does have color. It almost looks identical to what Neil said, it looks like it radiates some sort of temperature.

@sneed2600

Жыл бұрын

We got new ones recently, and this still holds true.

I had no idea that this conversation happened!!!! No words to express how I feel. Just smiling...

I really love neil voice!

@allaboutroofing2

5 ай бұрын

Like nails on a chalk board to me. Ever seen him on Joe Rogan?

@raghavjack

5 ай бұрын

@@allaboutroofing2 Sorry, you believe in god, opinion discard.

Knowledge provides self esteem. I like me for what i know. And i also enjoy the fellowship and discussion of the topics we need to keep the synaptic nerve endings firing. Thanks for the talk.

This was awesome. So much I didn't understand and now I need learn more. Love this. Imaginary time...mind blown.

can i just say how lucky i feel to have come across this video? i feel like my IQ increased a few levels which made me search for a friggin neil degresse video...im not kidding.

@AsifMehedi

5 жыл бұрын

I'm with you. We tend to forget how incredible and awe-inspiring this all is until someone like Neil reminds us.

@bena7153

5 жыл бұрын

Same

Awesome, thank you for making this happen .. . the inclusion of the comedian was brilliant play; we have to laugh at our ignorance!! I miss Stephen, as we all must!!

I can't help but smile watching this. Such an amazing interview

i was mind-blown throughout this video....truly fascinating stuff :)

When bill nye said go out and have a look there’s time my heart melted

Amazing. Almost got misty-eyed at the end. Great episode with some of my favorite people. The comedian did a good job too.

This hits different after the Island

@ispeakmucho

4 ай бұрын

Which island?

@edjudinew1237

4 ай бұрын

Epstein 💀

@kamzaangoyo.7588

3 ай бұрын

Oysters

Where can i see the full interview with Neil and Hawking without the other parts

This might be the best StarTalk ever. Did Michio just happen to be in the building? They didn't even have a long enough table to seat him! I'd likr to see a StarTalk with him and Neil -- nobody else. Cool beans. ;-D

Stephen hawking is a hero 🙏🏼❤️ bless his soul RIP

The amount of knowledge in these two men

I love the little smiles Stephen gives. A great mind gone too soon.

“It’s been a privilege spending time with you. Thanks for your thoughts and insights and being a source of inspiration to us all” Means so much more now that he’s gone.