"From a certain point of view" is doing some serious heavy lifting.

I am sleeping to this like it's a bedtime story. Thank you Alex and Mollie for being the positive light in the Star Wars KZread community!

@_Korben-Dallas

23 күн бұрын

I did the SAME thing.

@RecoveryHacker

6 сағат бұрын

It's an awesome way to drift off...

I always assumed "e chu ta" translated to "eat sh*t" 😂

@StarSteve681

Ай бұрын

My head cannon is it’s the equivalent of saying the N word

@mysticmarble94

Ай бұрын

​@@StarSteve681 You have a cannon inside your head ? 😳

@user-bo5zx4ym1j

29 күн бұрын

Me to.

@The_Stranger1986

29 күн бұрын

​@@mysticmarble94Sounds painful 😂

@RobbyHouseIV

25 күн бұрын

@@StarSteve681 What caliber gun do you have in your head?

"Hey man what year is it?" "Oh it's... 12 before battle of yavin" "What's the battle of yavin..." "I... I don't KNOW..."

@edwardbloecher4563

Ай бұрын

No it's 1968 and this weed is amazing!!! 😂

@R3TR0221

Ай бұрын

That would probably be imperial year 7 in universe.

@DansBuddhaBodega

24 күн бұрын

​@@R3TR0221 I've never thought about it, but yeah, I think your right. Palps would DEFINITELY base the new calendar on the birth of the empire. However, It would take way more than 7 years to synchronize an entire galaxy. We didn't even invent the atomic clock until 1949. Telephones were invented in 1876. If we still required landlines, we still wouldn't be able to communicate with huge portions of 3rd world countries 148 years later.

@fractalmadness9253

6 күн бұрын

It’s a Christless society that’s why their most important milestones are their endless wars without end.

@R3TR0221

6 күн бұрын

@fractalmadness9253 Are you arguing for star wars to become christian propaganda?

I really like the idea of Luke tricking the guards into thinking that they’re being choked at Jabba’s Palace. It legitimately seems like something Jedi like Luke and Qui-Gon would do

now it's prequel time

@StarWarsExplained

Ай бұрын

In the middle of Attack of the Clones right now!

@tomlinson1710

Ай бұрын

@@StarWarsExplained 👀

@jnnx

25 күн бұрын

It’s NEVER prequel time, SON, and you should feel bad.

@Ulyssestnt

23 күн бұрын

@@jnnxSwallow your tongue,its always prequel time FATHER:)

@publichearing8536

9 күн бұрын

​@@jnnxit's always prequel time and you should be ashamed of yourself

Man, the "Han shot first" debate: The shots take place after the exchange "He may only take your ship." "Over my dead body." "That's the idea. I've been looking forward to this for a long time." This takes place while Greedo has Han at gunpoint. Han would be STUPID to wait for a second longer.

@JediSentinal

16 күн бұрын

Yeah, I always have just viewed it as they both shot. Greedo missed, han didn't. And that detail will never change! Makes it easier 😄

@djmarsupiaI

8 күн бұрын

@@JediSentinalthat’s not what happened in the movie

I know what I will be watching during the weekend with a nice glass of wine. Wow... thank you Alex and Molly for being the best Star Wars channel.

Obi Wan not knowing Anakin was alive is such a plot hole as you can see him hearing Anakin be called Vader in revenge of the sith

@Anonymous-xu2qk

2 күн бұрын

It's crazy what Disney has done to lore

Three dots to denote a possible continuation is called an 'ellipsis' and is a recognised punctuation mark. Four dots is wrong, and a good type-setter corrected the mistake.

The 'Theta' class dropship can carry 4 AT-ATs and 8 AS-STs in one trip. There are other dropships/ landing barges that can carry numerous combinations of vehicles and walkers.

24:07 Something most people forget... these are supposed to be modern telling of stories being told about people and events far far away, and a long long time ago, thus their languages and most idioms are being translated into something understandable to this audience. So an X-Wing, in our language, evokes a look, it may not be a literal translation, but something that evokes that shape to the people as it was then/there.

@JediSentinal

16 күн бұрын

Wish this was more well known.

Next up: Biggest PT and ST Questions ANSWERED

@shahzebhasan9995

Ай бұрын

Prequels, maybe. Sequels? Sadly, most of those questions won't be answered for quite a while...

@Makocat

Ай бұрын

​@@shahzebhasan9995Yep. "A good question, for another time" 💀💀💀

@SoraMotto

Ай бұрын

Biggest ST Question: "WHY???"

@StuartLugsden

Ай бұрын

@@SoraMotto you know why

@GeekyMedia

Ай бұрын

“So HOW did Palpatine return!? 😱” 😂

You better believe I'm gonna watch this whole thing even though I watched all the individual ones.

18:31 I personally like the idea that for the dual on the death star, the two of them had known each other for so long faced each other, so many times and were aware of each other styles that it was more of a psychological battle. You will see experienced swordsman facing each other where the battle is over very quickly when somebody finds an opening or somebody else makes a mistake.

Sorry, but Palpatine himself has stated that Anakin would never be able to perform Sith lightning due to his debilitating injuries sustained on Mustafar, which included the loss of his only remaining organic arm. The ability to use force lightning is vastly different than improvising in a fistfight due to having only one arm.

This is such high quality content. Like what a great collection of answers to just have on hand for arguments 😂

Recently discovered your videos and am loving them. Thank you for your awesome work. Just spent the month of March rewatching every single Star Wars DVD I own while recovering from surgery, now I feel the need to rewatch the original trilogy yet again ...

0:57 … “hold your fire? What are we? Paying by the laser blast now?” “You don’t do the budget Terry, I do!” 1:29 had to time stamp this classic sample

Woot nice this is gonna be a good one to leave on in as ambient background. Also been noticing a lot of salty comments in the shorts uploads of these individual questions complaining about the point of it all when George never came up with it from 1977-1983. How come all of a sudden its a problem when this franchise has existed for almost 50 years?

Such a good video, as always, thanks Alex and Molly!!!

Bravo 👏🏼 I can only imagine the research you had to do to make this one great job

I always thought the protocol droid that C3PO sees in Cloud City before getting blasted was saying "INTRUDER!"

@JonO387

Ай бұрын

Lmao

I loved this video. Didn't skip a single piece. I rewatched several segments over. The comments have added great value to an immediately instant necessity for Star Wars fans, serious or casual. Thank you so much for all your hard work!

thanks for the ride, that was really nice. It's so simply easy to see that when the movies are great there are no bigger questions asked.

*Why did Han Solo have a Jedi Training Remote?* Me: "Oh who's says its his? Obi-wan probably had one for his own training and knew he needed it for Luke" Star Wars Writer: "WRONG! Here is my page long back Story about this minor Prop"

That was one of the best videos about star wars I ever watched. Such a great piece of content to listen to while driving or in the background ❤ That's a subscribe!

Boba Fett sees Han's hiding trick before.

This is the first time I've seen your channel and I just watched an hour+ video from cover to cover. Definitely subscribing right now.

These four brothers make me cry everytime I watch this masterful masterful masterful😢😅😊

Yoda "liked" helping younglings.... Can't wait for Star Wars: Operation Yew tree...

Thank you for joining us today, Firmus Piett. You are interviewing today for the open position that we have in the Security Department here on Axxila. After reviewing your resume, you were a former Admiral in the Imperial Navy? "Yes." What are your greatest strengths/weaknesses? "I'm a very experienced and able officer, as you can see on my resume. That would be my greatest strength. Weaknesses? Well, I hate working with bounty hunters. I just like to know where a person's loyalties lie before I work with them." How would your previous co-workers describe you? "I was Admiral Kendal Ozzel's personal confidant on many occasions as he was my superior before I served as Admiral on the Executor. He would describe me as loyal, dead pan and blunt at times, but with a dark sense of humor." Tell me something about yourself that isn’t on your resume. "Well, I have excellent survival skills, that's for sure. In one such incident in the past, I was serving as Fleet Admiral in the Imperial Navy when a fighter pilot actually, purposefully flew into the bridge of the Executor, causing the Executor to veer out of control and crash into Death Star II. To this day, I can't believe my luck, but I was able to fall off the dias, scramble off the bridge and get out in an escape pod. I thought I did pretty well all of those years serving Lord Vader and the Emperor directly." Tell me about a past difficult work situation. How did you overcome it? "Lord Vader had replaced Admiral Ozzel and Captain Viett, and I had only just began to serve under him, and there was this particular incident when we were in orbit over Bespin near one of their mining colonies. Lord Vader specifically directed me to deactivate the hyper-drive on a contraband YT freighter. My team did it - I verified the order myself - but in a key moment, the ship got away to hyper-drive as we were readying our tractor beam. I was frozen in shock, and to this day, I have no idea how that happened. But Lord Vader kept me as Admiral, and I overcame my daily fear at first by indulging in my lifetime love of Axxilian Negronis, but I'm happy to say that I'm 3 years sober." Describe a time when you had to work with someone whose personality or work style was very different from yours. "Lord Vader was a very curious fellow at times. One time I even saw him without his helmet, although it was from the rear, but he seemed to have a barely controlled rage about him, and you always had to remain on your toes and be as punctual as possible with him. I demanded a great deal of preparation from my team during that time to have the most flexibility for anything to happen, and to be ready for any order to be given. I basically did whatever he told me." Very well! We expect to fill the position soon and we'll be in touch. "Thank you."

12 parsecs quote is related to how close he went by the Maw, cluster of black holes. He was fast enough to skip around and not get sucked in.

I personally loved his movies and antics on screen. God bless his soul

Sir Alec Guinness really done favours, the video "Obi Wan has PTSD" where his talk with Luke about his father and it cut together with prequel footage really shows how good he was as an actor

Thank you for answering these questions from canon, legends, and realistic standpoints.

It's the humility that gets to my heart strings with the majority Olof these war stories. That and the common sense that seems so natural. I am awe struck at every single one of these stories. Thanks

"As clumsy as he is stupid". Stupid for spying on vader/ the empire, clumsy for getting caught.

Of course the emperor knew she was pregnant. He was sending Anikin dreams of her dying in child birth

The most memorable part about going to see the Star Wars Special Editon was when the entire theater started booing when Greedo shot first. Changing that scene was completely unnecessary 👎👎👎

2:43 Now we need a series of three (or four) trilogies explaining why Uncle Owen “simply doesn’t care”. GIT ON IT DISNEY!

skywalker being a common name is really funny to me

For those who are interested, there is a fanfic re-creation of Vader vs Kenobi on the death star to be found here on youtube and it's pretty great!

The real reason they didn't shoot the escape pod is because YOU DON'T DO THE BUDGET TERRY, I DO!

Ok, the Force choke motivational speech was truly inspirational 😅 - Din

Kessel Run may have been more of an obstacle course than a race from A to B.

Very informative! Thanks :)

"E CHU TA" Translated to what that old lady said to the new sheriff in Blazing Saddles.

I wanna know why Padme acts like a completely different character when she's wearing the Queen outfit lmao. British accent, talks like a robot. It's strange 😂😂

Excellent video! Thank you, Alex and Mollie!

6:40 - In the novel he also looks at R2 While luke was talking to Han and says to him "It's been a long time, Old friend."

That extra dot on the crawl would've put them over budget ;)

0:00 this is where the fun begins

Let's compose ourselves and not complicate this compilation.

@30:51 Being a Warhammer fan, I straight up thought of the Warp. I had no idea that Chaos was a thing in Star Wars; albeit in not the same way.

Moral of the story... don't fakkk with peoples reputations. Great message Mate! Can't wait to see all the people he's screwed, vindicated!!! 😁👍

Oh boy, it's 'Biggest Questions ANSWERED' Prequal Trilogy edition time!

Lars is afraid that luke will end up as a sad old man drinking milk.

Thanks again, Alex! 🧾

Padme also used an English accent, after she revealed her true identity to the Gun Gun's leader. Like right before Maul's awesome entrance...she shouts.."Get to your ships" with a britches accent. Always found it weird she spoke like that AFTER everyone found out who the real Queen on Naboo was.

No you're wrong, the wire going up Alec Guinness's robe sleeve wasn't in hopes the blade lit during filming. The blade had movie screen on a tri-sided pole. That wire was connected to a motor that spin the pole. Obi-Wan would draw his saber, "Cut" support team would come in and add the pole. "Action" Lucas would resume filming. The pole would spin and catch the light and the post-production did their roto-scoping. The wire was confirmed by Mark Hamill in a video where a collector presented Mark with his hero prop from ROTJ.

Its funny that a book like Heir to the Jedi answered so many random questions

Great job!

I believe Kenobi said Yoda was the Jedi who taught him meaning taught him to become a Force ghost

GUYS!!! Take a chug of ur Blue Milk every time you hear "From a certain point of view.."! im so Din Ferik'd rn!!

Can’t we just agree that a bunch of these were just film-making choices? 😂

@Cybermat47

28 күн бұрын

We can, but that’s not as fun lol

@myriadmediamusings

18 күн бұрын

Aka the boring unimaginative no fun allowed answer

@maxtracker2904

18 күн бұрын

@@myriadmediamusings Well…but there is no way to explain, say, the guy not shooting the escape pod at start of a new hope. Unless you go back in and change the dialogue to “Hold your fire! The plans may be aboard and we want use them to trace rebel connections!”. I’m just saying that HAD to happen for the film to happen. I don’t like retcons. I don’t like, for example, stormtrooper poor aim becoming a canon thing. The reason they missed is because if they shot Han Solo the film can’t happen. But I think I did find this vid fun 😂👍

So what's the "From a Certain Point of View"-gymnastics answer for Luke and Ben having zero problem in telling two helpless droids the entire Empire is looking for to "wait outside" when they're refused service? A New Hope should have ended when they exit the cantina and the droids are gone forever.

@kentslocum

22 күн бұрын

There are a lot of movies that would be a lot shorter if the story was logical. 😂

There are many instances in the literary EU that reference hyperspace tracking/pursuit by taking note of a ship's trajectory and jumping right behind on the same vector. A technician listens for the hyperspace wake, like sonar on a submarine to be sure they are following, and hits the hyperdrive kill switch when he hears the target ship sounds like its dropping out of hyperspace. It takes lots of training and skill to be good at it. If you are not in pursuit and just monitoring a ship, you can also take note of the trajectory and accurately guess where they are headed based on the lane they have to be traveling on. A tactic to ambush them then would be the send ships in a chain of hyperspace exits so someone comes out near enough to the target to see them on the realspace tracking sensors. You can jump in any random direction to escape, but it must be a very short jump to ditch the pursuers... a la light speed skipping... before a calculated path must be chosen, cus as Han says you can jump into a star or black hole or something if you do not use proper calculations. The light speed skip is a tactic that is described in canon. You make a couple short random jumps to hide which way you are really going cus, like I said, there are only so many clear lanes and possible exit points because of objects and gravity wells and an ambusher could accurately guess where you are headed. But the odds of light speed skipping to 3 random places like in the movie would be highly unlikely. And your hyperdrive motivator would drop you out of hyperspace before you came near enough to be within a planet's atmosphere when you came out. And it wouldn't let you jump back out so near a gravity well. So the way its done in TROS is impossible. Most long hyperspace trips did require multiple stops and course changes to get across the galaxy without running into something. Though its not really the object you collide with, but the displacement in space-time its mass/gravity creates. In hyperspace you are not on this dimensional plane, so small objects like asteroids and other ships you pass right through. But the gravity shadow of massive objects can be collided with. The Holdor Manuever... its the space-time disruption that destroyed the star destroyer, not the matter of the ship jumping into it. It would be somewhat difficult to pull off because if you jump too early you pass right through and your wake disipates. Jump too late and you just crash into the target, and a ship that size, it wouldnt have been a killing blow, just a hole in the hull. It's gotta be timed just right. And there is a possibility Holdor survived. For reals. Though most likely, her ship broke up from thr disruption as well, and it and her corpse will be hurtling through hyperspace til it eventually gets pulled into a gravity well.

"Who shot first?" In the Lego Skywalker Saga video game one of the missions in Mos Eisley is interviewing eyewitnesses and reporting to Stormtroopers. It's 50/50.

That ball attack Vader uses, is homaged in his Soul Calibur 4 moveset.

Damn, Ret-Con A-Go-Go! (Great video, tho!)

In the original audiobooks, Luke is heard building his lightsaber. He is frustrated that he can't get it right, until he remembers what Yoda had said to him about letting the Force guide him, instead of trying to force it to work.

Blowin' my mind with those dots....

Nice video

1:24:19 nah nah nah Vader said that because Luke had the high ground

The medal one: I always figured that the big reason Leia honored them was because they rescued her on the Death Star. Wedge wasn’t there.

Nah, Han definitely shot first. It's the very first version made and released and it's how George wants it. No argument here, fact is fact. And it definitely does matter.

@The_Stranger1986

29 күн бұрын

I agree. The whole question about not wanting Han to be seen as a cold hearted killer was dumb. He's a survivor and that's all there is to it.

@CoachGruber

28 күн бұрын

Han ABSOLUTELY shot first. You can see the blast come out before Greedo’s and cause Greedo’s to miss as his body reacted to getting drilled. Matters 1000%, plus Han being a scoundrel fits the bill he’d shoot first while also protecting his life. He knew Greedo, so he’d know he wasn’t talking his way out. If he goes peacefully to Jaba, then he’s likely good for the beast and no carbonite.

@cliffcampbell8827

25 күн бұрын

Han was the only one to shoot. Greedo didn't get the chance because Han shot Greedo, end of story. Not "Han shot first," its just "Han shot Greedo before Greedo started to squeeze the trigger."

@CoachGruber

25 күн бұрын

@@cliffcampbell8827 negative. Slow it down. There’s a blaster shot that hits the wall by Han’s head

@boyzinthewood1

25 күн бұрын

@cliffcampbell8827 Yeah, until they retconed it, and added Greedos blaster shot in. Then, and only then, the term "Han Shot First" was used. It was never used before it so pipe down

"The other" was an addition to help introduce Leia as a heroine figure... I have personally seen the original storyboards in which Luke didn't actually exist. In the very first rendition of the arc story Leia was meant to be the hero figure but when the scripts were sent to be analyzed for their chance of success; it was reported in the 70's that a super strong female character would not have been successfully marketed to the mass populace, so George was forced to create a male figure using an alteration of his last-name Lucas to "Luke" and Skywalker was the last name of the original owner of the ranch George purchased in Marin County.... so naturally in the sudden creation of a male character, Luke Skywalker became the obvious choice, thus increasing the success of the story arc during a time in society when male-based heroes were much more marketable. Afterwich George didn't see a point in eliminating her character since he had so much invested in her and simply changed the vector of her involvement, but then in the later stories she shows her high-end force capabilities which she used to stay alive in space.

I always wanted to know where Porkins was suppose to go. His ship, during the Death Star attack, starts to break up & Biggs tells him to "Eject"! Where in the cold vacuum of space was he suppose to go? Land on the surface of the D Star, find a maintenance hatch & knock asking if Darth can come out to play?

Now THAT's podcasting

44:30 I’m surprised you didn’t mention that Kylo Ren and Snoke visited the cave, with Kylo demolishing it after he saw visions of him and Luke clashing

Re Echo base being a base, I think it's also fairly clear that the Rebellion are still fairly new to the base and so haven't organized everything properly yet

30:25 one of the most bad ass lines in Star Wars

How nice of Vader to serve them dinner

Question: Are _Tales from Jabba's Palace_ and _Tales from Mos Eisley Cantina_ no longer considered canon? Great video! I just bought _Star Wars From A Certain POV_ . Looks like fun!

I saw the movie in the theater when it first came out and Han shot first. I also have the original dvd set and it shows it there too. Lucas admitted in an interview he changed it when the movie was released again in the 90s

Uncle owen maybe didn't recognize C3PO, but the robot would remember him and tell him who he was. especially knowing the farm.

Re: C-3PO knowing Leia - 3PO literally says, at about the 3 minute mark "there'll be no escape for the princess this time" while the ship is being boarded. Of course he knows who she is.

in the original cut of return of jedi , Anakin was his old self but not scared so technically George just wanted to change this retconning his own work. for those of us who remember the untainted cut of the original movies.

1:20:13 there are just two bearded commandos on the mission. That could work.

The truthful answer to every question here is: "It was retconned."

2.00 Because he was Gold

What a time to be alive

UNINTENDED IRONY DEPT. In the novelization of Return of the Jedi, when Obi Wan tells Luke, I sent you to live with my brother Owen on Tatooine. Takes place on get this,, PAGE 66 lol. In paperback format at least. Never perused the hardcover.

In the Star Wars role playing game one adventure involved going to a space junkyard and going onto a large surviving chunk of the Death Star and it included Vader's quarters which was where Obi-wan's lightsaber was being kept.

Once read many years ago that George Lucas claimed that Luke and Leia had 21 years old in "A new hope", not 19.

Why Owen didn't recognize the droids: In episode I, 3PO was in Shmi's house before she was married and didn't yet know The Lars family. In Ep 2, the droids remained on the ship so they never met Owen.

The Falcon used its backup class 12 hyper drive

Obiwan never owned Artoo. It was the property of the Queen (not personally but was just another maintenance droid on her ship until he saves the day). And not quite so seriously (and obviously a point of view), in the search for the death star plans, I think Vader just wanted "his" droids back because (1) Artoo is gifted to Anakin as a wedding present from Padme, and (2) he literally built Threepio.

Vader could use force lightening, he had the ability to use Red force lightning which is said to destroy the victims literal connection to the force, but due to his cybernetic body it was risky for him to use.