Old retired cop here with a lot (a lot!) of bullets downrange with both revolvers and semi autos, and my go-to gun for concealed carry when I feel the need is the S&W 442 with Speer Gold Dot +P, just like in this video. Statistically 5-shots is more than enough for 99-percent of anticipated civilian encounters, so I don't feel that I'm outgunned or under-gunned.

@keving52002

4 жыл бұрын

1000% agreed.

@wayneedward7391

4 жыл бұрын

@Amber oh no my laser stopped someone help

@JacksonWalter735

4 жыл бұрын

What made you get the 442 over the 642? I've seen both at gun stores, but the 642 tends to be more popular and a little more expensive even though they're the same revolver with different finishes.

@FredericoChilibreath

4 жыл бұрын

@@JacksonWalter735 The 442 was there at the LAPD gun store when I walked in and the 642 was not. Maybe if I had the choice I would have paid a little more for the 642, but after everything is said and done I would be happy with either version. As a Police Firearms Instructor I would no recommend either gun for the "average" shooter and especially people who don't like (or can't handle) recoil, the 442/642 is small and light and there is negative payback when shooting +P ammo. This said I still like the pistol for it's smallish size and especially that it can handle +P loads, but it is definitely NOT a casual plinker on the range.

@JacksonWalter735

4 жыл бұрын

@@FredericoChilibreath I appreciate the your thorough comment and advice. Currently deciding between the S&W 642, 442, and Ruger LCR for my father-in-law. He can't consistently rack the slide on his Glock 43 anymore (even when using the sights) after his stroke. I can't even begin to imagine what would happen if his gun jammed and he needed to clear it. Your comment helped me tremendously.

i love how sootch just blows a hole through his shirt with no hesitation!!!

@dlam2864

4 жыл бұрын

it's clearly an old shirt

@Bobdixon_Moonvarga_Dancer_III

4 жыл бұрын

D Lam still a good shirt, he could have made it a giveaway item.

@scorchtv8269

3 жыл бұрын

Dam this is an old comment

@ruuzulu8814

3 жыл бұрын

Lmao I thought the same “goddamn he actually did it” 😂😂

@johnfernandez3166

2 жыл бұрын

🤣🤣🤣

One of my favorite, most informative channels. Helped me choose what is right for me, so I thank you.

The average time for a self defense gunfight is 3 seconds. So whether you carry 5 rounds or 10 doesn't really matter. The one who gets the first shot on target is the one who wins the gunfight in the vast majority of cases.

i have a colt special detective 38 , never looked back

@wayneedward7391

4 жыл бұрын

Have u tried shooting hott ammo through it I mean is it rated for self defense rounds ?

Good video Sootch. My EDC is a revolver, love it. It's interesting how many similarities there are between shooting and Karate, muscle memory, aligning the bones for impact, creating calm, etc. A lot of people just don't realize that it's an art that must be learned. Keep up the good work Bro.

I have been carrying these revolvers since 1973 as both an off duty gun and now (retired) as a licensed citizen. LOVE THEM. I have tried all the others, I own several polymer 9mms, etc. I always go back to the J frame concealed hammer revolver. I have used the Model 40, Model 640 and now, the Model 642. With practice (use wadcutter loads for practice, and even dry firing) you can "stage" the S&W trigger to rotate the cylinder and cock the (internal) hammer, then the final squeeze fires the gun. Muscle memory. As you say, S&W has been making these since 1880 with the "Lemon Squeezer". I have a 1930s era S&W .38 "Safety Hammerless", more as a collectors item than anything, but I love the top break design, though it lacks strength for the modern ammo everyone wants. It is fine for the old .38 S&W cartridge (not .38 Special) For carry in the Model 40, 640 or 642, I use Buffalo Bore 158gr. +P soft lead SWC-HP. It is NOT pleasant to shoot, but generates right at 1000 fps in the 1-7/8" barrel (chronographed, 984 avg.), 300+ foot pounds of energy and perfect expansion every time. My usual carry holster is a DeSantis mini-scabbard OWB holster. I will also just drop it in a pocket sometimes.

Thanks for a well thought out and nicely crafted video.

Always good info. After years of semi auto and modern technology I find I like revolvers, pump shotgun and lever actions rifles. For the most part they will take care of all my problems.

Love how sincere this bastard is

I always end up going back to my snub nose revolvers for edc. They seem to conceal better on my person than an auto loader, even of similar size too. Either way, you also don't have to worry about a backup magazine since magazines are another point of failure. You also won't have failures due to a high off-hand grip, or a loose strong-hand grip, like an auto. The internet commandos will always say "this is why you train", but training is not going to prepare you for that real-life self defense situation. Almost no one will have the "perfect grip" in a reactionary self defense situation.

@rubensnyman1728

2 жыл бұрын

What in God's name are you on about

@pgman5416

2 жыл бұрын

@@rubensnyman1728 reality and experience . New shooter? I’m guessing

@pgman5416

2 жыл бұрын

@@rubensnyman1728 lol ok on a serious note: If you shoot an auto loading hand gun frequently, and train for speed and reactive self defense, you’ll notice quirks with grip, the slide, and magazines and failures that you’ll never deal with when using a revolver. The issue with the magazine is that some failures happen within a magazine, or some failures to feed or extract may not clear by simply racking the slide. This is a serious fact that isn’t covered often on KZread. When this happens, the only way to clear the malfunction is by dropping the magazine and clearing through the well. It’s advisable to have a spare magazine on your person since it will be more manageable than picking up the original magazine or holding it and replacing it. Other issues with grip affect the slide and may introduce other malfunctions when you’re reactionary that may not affect you when you’re shooting at the range. You have to consider that in self defense you’re often not standing at low ready or some tacticool stance to begin with. You can almost never hold a revolver incorrectly so much that it fails so long as you pull the trigger. Injury is a different factor obviously, but I’ve gotten close to the forcing cone many times with a .38 when doing reactionary drills and never suffered injury. Reactionary shooting is always disadvantageous compared to the assailant so these extra variables that don’t often become an issue when you’re at the range may become issues in real life. If you train right, you’ll notice them happening and you’ll figure out ways to mitigate based on your gear. For me, using a snub nosed revolver addresses all the above issues with less work.

@McCaroni_Sup

2 жыл бұрын

@@pgman5416 Very well put. I wasn't exactly around to see the era where everyone used wheel guns over auto loaders, but after doing my own research I have come to see the value in them, especially for concealed carry. One of the issues that has been drawing me towards a revolver and away from a semi auto is the issue of limp-wristing, which may be likely to occur in certain scenarios such as if your arm is injured or you have to shoot in an awkward position. Philosophically, when you carry a gun you prepare for the worst. To people who prefer auto loaders, preparing for the worst means an increased magazine capacity. For revolver users on the other hand, it means being able to rely on the notion that their gun will go bang on their mark and continue to do so regardless of any imperfections in their grip. Overall, I believe that both semi auto fans and revolver enjoyers are driven by a similar philosophy, it is merely that their approach to it that differs.

I just went and got it. Smiling, because I learned to shoot with it. Awesome firarm. Thanks for the video.

Love all your videos, you are the everyman of simplicity. Keep it simple stu---. Demo's are always top notch. Thanks John

This is a very informative video. Well explained for someone new to shooting. Thank you

I;ve been carrying a 642 which is the stainless version of the 442. The stock rubber grip that comes with it is very small and in my medium hands made shooting not fun at the range. I replaced the grip with a Pachmayr Presentation Compaq and the difference was day & night. No more thumb bite from the cylinder release. No more bruising between the thumb & forefinger. I went from shooting 10 rounds to now 100. Combined with the new grip and a Bianchi Lightnin' 55 holster and I have a great EDC combo!

I carry a snub nose model 60 and practice with it often and do most of my shots in double action and weak handed! I usually like doing trigger work to some of my firearms but in this one I only polished the rebounding slide and where it runs inside of the frame, by doing that it doesn't lessen the trigger weight but it does make it smoother and easier to pull!

As much as I love my Taurus 709 (for summer) and my Khar CW45 (for winter) I'll forever adore my 3" S&W .38Spl. ALWAYS in my pocket no matter the season.

Very informational video Sootch! Love the thru the shirt shots. Good stuff, and something I hadn't particularly thought of before.

My Glock 26 is my main CCW, my second choice is the Smith & Wesson 442. It is a great second choice I usually carry it while hiking.

Nice review man! An S&W snubbie is still one of the best carry guns out there.

I have a S & W 642 and purchased it in 2006, it is easy to conceal in the warmer weather. The author of this video did a very good job on the firing, carrying and performance of a small revolver. I love my Browning HP and 1911, but in the hot and humid weather of Dixie they can be rather difficult to carry. The hammerless is the best for versatility for defensive carry.

I missed this video when it came out. But I've been carrying ruger 38 lcr. For over 3 yrs. Still think its a good choice. Hornady critical def +p. Luv your vids. I support you. Keep up the great work.

You absolutely rite sootch... I have a Charter Arms Pitbull 40S&W and a Taurus #605 ...357 mag and I feel totally safe with them as EDC. I'm 67 and retired Military. have fired a lot of different platforms of weapons. feel totally safe with a revolvers.

@michigunsanta8680

3 жыл бұрын

I’ve got the Pitbull 40cal but for some reason it never worked for me for conceal carry. I might pick up the S&W442 I think it’s smaller and lighter. The Charter arms was relegated to a “truck gun”.😁

Great video! I like to carry my LCR in 38 spcl and XS front sight more than my Smith - but love my mod 36. Seeing someone with a LCR in 357 does make me question their judgment, though.

Snubby in the pocket holster is so much more comfortable to carry. Like switching from briefs to boxers.

I have found the LCRx snubbie in 327 Federal Magnum an optimal choice. My wife carries 32 H&R Magnum and I carry 327 Hydra-Shok.

Great vid Sooch00. I love the fact that you actually fired through the shirt. keep up the good work!

I reload .38 for cowboy action shooting and use those for snubbie practice. About 700 fps. Very pleasant to shoot. This dramatically reduces my cost and makes practice less tiring. My favorite holster is the Vedder pocket locker.

Very interesting videos Always learning..I've been collecting semi autos and just started with revolvers..Thanks for the great content..

I have a ton of pistols and carry all the time. Usually a glock 19 or Shield. But I must say that the 442 is the easiest gun I've ever carried. Even better than my LCP or CW380. It's always what I grab when in wearing gym shorts and heading up to the store real quick. And far more accurate than most give them credit.

S&W 642, my always gun.

These are not fun guns to shoot, I have carried them for over 30 years, my 638 is super accurate. If you can afford it pick up a 22lr version and practice with that. Use low recoil loads for bulk practice, and run a few cylinder loads of defensive ammo to know where your hitting. HPR is good ammo. Thanks for a good video. One other thing you can get grips to fit any hand for most revolvers.

S&W 437 with a hogue grip and one speed strip for this guy 🇺🇸👍

Great video. Even though several years old, the content is relevant and well delivered. Long time subscriber.

@captainamericaamerica8090

4 жыл бұрын

Why would you even not have the Smarts' to see😥😥👀👀that this guy here couldn't CARE LESS! HE'S BEEN GONE FOR OVER NINE YEARS.

@BitcoinWillFixEverything

4 жыл бұрын

@@captainamericaamerica8090 well, I ,too, make content on another KZread channel. I still read my messages from my earliest videos. And he's not long gone, he's still putting out content to this day. I find it interesting that you develop such a strong opinion on meaningless matters.

@captainamericaamerica8090

4 жыл бұрын

@@BitcoinWillFixEverything it's more insane that you post on matters that you consider invalid.😂😂

I’m someone who prays I never have to fire in self defense, ever. And were I to find myself in a desperate situation I would only fire my weapon as a last resort. As in, I will probably die or be severely injured unless I act with deadly force. My firearm would, hopefully, serve mainly as a deterrent. I would rather not have to take a life with all the moral and legal implications. However, I value my own life enough to be prepared if the unthinkable happens. I think a 5-6 shot revolver is sufficient. SHTF? Well, that’s more hi-cap territory.

Note on the grip... while one-handed it is better to have the bore aligned with your forearm for structural support, when shooting two-handed, it only applies when using the limited weaver-style hold. A well-tuned isosceles hold will ensure the recoil is consistent, and the front sight tracking repeatable for the fastest possible follow-up shots.

Great video Don! I love the snubbies! Most reliable gun out there! Thanks Buddy!

Thanks for the great review Sootch! Anthony.

love the shot through the shirt always wondered about shooting from in a pocket or tangled up in your cover garment thanks sootch!!

I have both a Taurus 85 titanium and a S&W 442 lightweight. I bought the Taurus first and it is a good gun. I bought the S&W because it is truly a concealed hammer. The Taurus cannot be cocked but it does have a spur type exterior hammer. I carry an LCP more often as it conceals more easily, but I do like the fact that you cannot limpwrist the revolver nor will it go out of battery if pressed against a target.

Great review as always! Thanks for sharing!

We love our 637 & 638! -- Great video sir!

good video dude very good information thinking about buying Smith and Weston 442 your video shine some light on my decision I think I'm going to go with it

Sootch- I'm glad to see you're using the Short Barrel Gold Dots in your snubbie. Hollow point technology has come a long way, but even most modern hollow points are made to be used in service-size duty pistols, not the small pistols most people carry, though that is changing. .38 Special and .380 in particular have reputations for inconsistent expansion with JHPs in snubbies and pocket pistols due to the (already) low velocities combined with the short barrels of these guns. Rounds like the

Another great video, and it was very informative. Thanks !!

Good triigger control I also put my hand on the chest area to avoid covering my hand when you shot one handed. I put my hand behind my neck to avoid covering my hand compliments of Gunsite training

Another great video Sootch. I am looking at a Ruger SP101 as my CCW. I look forward to all your videos, keep up the good work.

It's all about whatever works for you. Revolvers lack a high capacity, but I'm sure after 30 years of carrying one you can put those rounds exactly where they need to go to stop a threat. Cheers!

Good video. The .38 snubbie is a great gun. You covered it well. I like revolvers.

I have the S&W 442 airweight, super concealable , and for shooting through the t/shirt.......subbed .

I have a 642, 60, Detective Special and a 3" barreled Ruger SP101. I like the small revolvers.

Thanks for this video like the part where you shot through your shirt.thanks for the info great job as always

I have the Smith & Wesson MP360 in .357 Magnum. I chose this because it can shoot 38special, 38special +P, and .357 mag. Any of the small J-frame revolvers are highly recommended by me, they are absolutely perfect for CCW, and a home defense weapon that all family members can operate easily - They are so good at what they do, that I give them a 10/10.

Excellent presentation, thankyou.

haha you must be the first guy on youtube that shot through his shirt good vid sootch keep em coming

Heyyyy that was my favorite shirt!!! LOL great vid sir!!

Made me think I still have my first gun. A S&W snub nose 2 1/2 barrel 357. It was fairly accurate. Loved that little thing. It was owned by a State Trooper before me. Nickel coated., I just went and go

Nice review on a great platform. I have the S&W 649 bodyguard, and it's great to shoot 38s with. 357s get tiring in a hurry.

2 Shots From Under The Shirt. That Was Gangsta sootch00

Dig this video a lot! PF9, P11, Glock 27, SA-XD45, Ruger P89, but my favorite to just take out to shoot, (and my truck gun) Rossi 351 38 special! I Love my revolver!!

Another great analysis and review.

GOOD INFO VID. I AM HAPPY THAT HPR CALIBERS ARE EXPANDING MORE, I AM A HUGE FAN OF THESE AMMUNITION.THANXZ DON.

Solid Video Sootch. Thanks for all your down-to-earth, common sense reviews. Now take that T-shirt with the hole in it and give it to a relative you can’t stand , for a birthday gift .... !

Excellent topic and demo. Reload for the win.

I never thought about the shooting from the pocket or under your shirt before... that is a good advantage of the revolver. Thanks

Good video and information. Thank you.

Like them 2 inch barrows u correct easy to conceal. Buying one soon.

I love snubs, even though I've never carried one. For some reason, they're the style of handgun I'm most accurate with by far. Tried a 7.5" revolver and couldn't shoot it as well as the same gun in 2.5". Ruger 454 that is. I miss my alaskan. Wish some company made a featherweight 5 shot 45 colt snubnose.

Good stuff. Will grab some of those Gold Dots for mine as my EDC ammo. Thanks.

Wife: "You did WHAT to your shirt?"

Kinda wish I would have gotten a .357 snub, but I went with an old Charter Arms Undercover in .38, rated for +P. Its a lot damn lighter than a .357 snubby that I was looking at.

Do what you want, but I want my left hand forward keeping the threat at LEAST at arms length. AFTER I have established my 3 foot rule only then do I allow my left hand to come back to help stabilize my shooter hand....

@wcropp1 Gold Dot that are specifically made for a gun with a short barrel are a major asset for anyone carrying a small .38/.380. In the past, people have recommended carrying wadcutters in a revolver as they do more damage than round nose bullets, but they are not ideal for self defense. Hollow points are better, assuming they expand, and they're getting to the point of acceptable reliability (at least certain brands are) in these calibers. I would recommend +P rounds as well, if possible.

I have the same gun for self defense, a great little gun.

I just purchased a 43c 22lr S&W revolver. Damn I like this gun. You're saying what a 22lr! Yup, 8 shot capacity. You pop somebody with 3 or 4 rounds and I'll promise you they will start to leak! Great firearm S&W! 💥💥💥👍

fabulous video. I conceal carry the 642 and practice once a month. The recoil is hard on my old hand. I shoot at close range for accuracy. It does take a lot of practice.

I have a charter arms, bulldog, snub noise,6 shot, , older model, made in 1983 , with rubber grips, , easy to use, basically can hit fly with it, had used them, to defend and protect myself, in gunfights.

I have really been contemplating getting a Taurus PT 905 for a smaller Concealer. Its a 9mm revolver, which I like so I keep ammo likeness.

Another good video very informative I also carry a 642 edc. I HAVE glocks g26 /g23 I do carry them but more often the 642 for some reason its more comfortable to carry almost don't know it's there anyway thanks again . Keep them coming.

Thanks sootch00

I gotta say, I though I had made up my mind on not getting a revolver for actual carry, but after that shirt demonstration I think I'm going to rethink that. A gun that can't be stopped by a simple grab is a very attractive concept.

Nice shooting there Sootch and another great video bro'!!!!!

Good video. Thanks for posting it.

these things are going to be popular for a long time. my friend who is 18 plans to get one when he is old enough

very informative video..thank you for uploading.

I love S&W snubbys. I leaned to shoot with my dads 649 & 686. He started out on .38 special! I couldn’t wait for .357 magnum. No .22lrs for me growing up. Hahahaha.

I carry the S&W 340 and I have the Speer 38 +p 135 grain

I have a Ruger SP101 in 357 that I use in this role. In EDC I still seem to carry my Ruger LCP with crimson trace and a Glock 27 in Crossbreed IWB holster.

Good technique profiling vid sootch...thanks.....

Strait Forward to the point good info. Thanks for posting.

Like the belt hoslter & nice 38spl 5 rounder my a 6 rounder love it! 🔫👍

Sootch, living in MA we seem to have a lot of stupid rules when it comes to firearms. I love my little 442 so much, I even had my local gunsmith hone the hammer off my Ruger sp101 357 When it comes to legalities, double action is the way to go. keep up the vidios.

Excellent vid. the peek-a-boom scared me LoL

Excellent video Training!!!

You killed that shirt! D: How could you!?

love your vids bro kepp on making the great vids

I can not remember the last time I need to shoot a hole in my T shirt...LOL That is dedication, sacrificing a t-shirt for a video. Thanks thumbs up.

the 642 with a crimson laser makes a very good edc the only gun I carry more is a keltec 380 P3AT with a crimson

Sootch00, could you do a review on the Charter Arms undercover 38 special? That's another classic, with a lot of history. Thanks.

I was fortunate enough to find a excellent condition Smith 342 ti airlite centennial 11oz !! .38spec +p in excellent condition. I installed full size hogue monogrips.. which cover the back strap Cushing my hand against recoil and get all my fingers on the grip.. This is my pocket carry revolver I carry it in my right front jeans pocket in a DeSantis Superfly holster with velcro on flap to prevent printing.. I carry it loaded with Federal HST.38 +p 130 gr hollows .. these recoil very light even in my 11 oz centennial