Was going through the Neoclassical lecture, still can't believe this is for no cost at all. Much respect and a sincere thank you!

@mnmmnm8321

2 жыл бұрын

@@markosdesta348 She also said that there is only love and work. She had heaps of good quotes but they reckon one of her boyfriends helped her come up with a lot of her witticisms. Also speculation she was a spy but who for and who really knows?

@anesu846

2 жыл бұрын

@@markosdesta348 I think that was more family than wifi

@georgepsomas6257

2 жыл бұрын

Wish he'd discuss ayn rand.

@reasonerenlightened2456

Жыл бұрын

Demolition of Smith: THE FREE MARKET INEVITABLY LEADS TO EXTREME CONCENTRATION OF WEALTH BECAUSE IT ALWAYS BECOMES TRAGEDY OF THE COMMONS PROBLEM DUE TO THE RELENTNESS PURSUIT OF PROFIT IN A FREE ACCESS ENVIRONMENT. (The free market ALWAYS concentrates Wealth, because it is a battlefield and also because competition is unsustainable).

@Laocoon283

Жыл бұрын

@@markosdesta348 like pssy

It's unbelievable to lecture at length without having notes on papers whatsoever.

@paulmarr7873

2 жыл бұрын

can you imagine the totality of hours spent reading?

@Al-himathy

2 жыл бұрын

@@paulmarr7873 exactly

@BigVillyStyle

2 жыл бұрын

And on such a vast range of subjects!

@josephtrinkle3255

2 жыл бұрын

Absolutely insane I agree. Great mind

@AlexIsUber

2 жыл бұрын

Didn't take a break for a second... he's extraordinary

I cherish and am grateful for every lecture Dr.Sugrue has given as a 70 year old student! Thank you so much 🙏🙏🙏

@braidenbianco

Жыл бұрын

Wow congrats to you for never ceasing to be a student at 70 years of age. Very very admirable and inspirational I wish the best to you

@0_1_2

4 ай бұрын

Wow, you were alive when Adam Smith was writing the book! What was he like?

This is arguably the best KZread channel I've found in long time. Thanks for the quality material for we all non-philosopher philosophers

from a 22 year old, thank you michael

We 21st century humans with easy access to KZread are immensely lucky to have access to university level education in a couple of clicks or taps. Thank you for these uploads that provide knowledge for the greater good

These are tremendous lectures and go beyond what I’ve previously listened to. A true intellectual

Professor Michael Sugrue’s lecturing skills are outstanding and his breadth of knowledge is massive. How does he present one lecture after another, transversing the Western Canon of literature and humanities and economics without referring to a single note?

@BCC288

2 жыл бұрын

was just thinking about this. really impressive

@TheZigzagman

2 жыл бұрын

When you sing a song you like and know well, do you have to use a cheat sheet?

@BCC288

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheZigzagman terrible analogy

@TheZigzagman

2 жыл бұрын

@@BCC288 Is it? What would you have chosen to illustrate the almost reflexive recall of a rigid structure with set points of emphasis combined with mostly spontaneous connective tissue?

@BCC288

2 жыл бұрын

just quit while you’re behind. the pseudo intellectual rhetoric isn’t working

Great to see these vintage Teaching Company lectures make it to KZread, since they are no longer available from either The Great Courses Plus or Wonderium. I learned a lot back in the day from listening to Professors Staloff and Sugrue.

Dude is a genius. Stoked beyond imagination to listen.

I've been looking for this video for 7 years. I've finally found it :)

Having read some of the comments it appears I am rather late in pointing out that Adam Smith was not English but Scottish. Nonetheless, it does not diminish the lecture, which was yet again an intellectual edification. Thank you, Professor Sugrue, for sharing these wonderful lectures with us for free on the KZread.

@andyayala9119

10 ай бұрын

So was Kant

@kenhutley971

9 ай бұрын

@@andyayala9119 "So was Kant". ???

Such a great stuff. And for free! Wow, thank you so much, Dr. Sugrue.

8:27 Space & Time Transportation Canals, Roads Production Increase Government Interference BAD, Limits Markets Monopolies, Protective Tariffs 11:10 Natural Equilibrium “The Invisible Hand.” 25:57 Mass Production, Mass Consumption, Declining Marginal Utility 28:07 Henry Ford 29:54 Government: Stay Out Of Economics More of everything More happiness 31:56 Social Cohesion, Common Set of Sentiments 32:57 Feeling of sympathy 33:03 _Homo Economicus_ 34:04 The Behavior of Markets 36:14 Economics, and Math. Predictive Power.

@Cyrus52

Жыл бұрын

Well done!

@MohorMom

Жыл бұрын

THANK YOU!

@toddavis8603

25 күн бұрын

A natural equilibrium btw supply and demand= INVISIBLE HAND.Henry Disston and Sons my favorite Industrialist.Sawmaker founded 1840◆

I have attended a couple of universities and earned a couple of degrees, but you are definitely the best Prof I never had the luck to know in person but have learned a lot from your teaching. Thanks for uploading these lectures.

Professor Sugrue was great, he could break down theories into easy to understand explanations.

Thank You!

I love these lectures. Thanks for preserving such intellectual tradition and making them handy for us. I'm sold as a subscriber!

One of the best.

Please keep these coming, and then up on your channel!

Pure gold❤️❤️❤️

Thank you

It’s mind boggling how he can deliver a lecture of such complexity and depth **without** any notes, and ad lib … truly outstanding and extraordinary.

Dr is just wow, I am a big fan of him

Professor, I have attended much of your lectures. No notes, no side cards, no PPT. This is mastery. ❤❤❤ Watching from The 🇵🇭

Honestly, your presentation ability is an art form. I think this is as close as it gets as plugging my brain into Wikipedia and clicking download... its phenomenal. Thank you 🙏🙏

Timeless still, Dr. Thanks for sharing.

Just... Thank You... Thank You, Dr Sugrue.

Always a learned experience to listen to the Dr

Amaziiiinnnngggggg!!! I'm currently reading Adam Smith's WON and this talk is a cherry on the icing

Such an incredible talented Professor.

What a treasure trove I've found..love and regards from india

many thanks

Nice lecture as always!

I'm listening to his lectures before going to sleep and while working out, this is one of the best YT channels I've found in 2023.

Well-timed, Sir,

Didn't blink once during this presentation. I watched the whole thinking while taking notes. Impressive class by Mr. Sugrue!

I have never seen in any one of this gentleman's lectures, notes in front of him. Amazing and unbelievable.

This is just so much free knowledge so eloquently packed, we're so lucky to have modern technology and this great guy putting his soul into his lectures. 10/10.

Lovely!

A brilliant lecture...All done without notes....

Looking forward to this one. Thank you Dr Sugrue for sharing your amazing lectures with us all :)

I rarely have so many ah ha moments as listening to these lectures. Thanks again

RIP, you great man

Commendable.

The irony is that the most efficient modern factories do not view workers as unskilled. The Toyota Production System for example

After listening to the lectures on Plato's Republic, I really see you as a Socrates figure sharing out humanities collective wisdom. Thank you 🙏🙏

Brilliant. I am using this for my presentation on Adam Smith. Have to shorten the info to 10 minutes :D

i really like the engaging style and knowledge of the good Dr. There is some major 1990s era 'End of History' optimism built into it the thought. I'd be fascinated as to what his discourse would be if delivering on some of those subjects today.

Tell your dad he's an Intellectual Pillar of Perfection. Such a great communicator. I've owned his Great Courses for 22 years. Interesting to finally put a face to that voice.

These lectures are all that and more. :0)

I would love to see a serious discussion with Dr Sugrue and Dr Niall Ferguson on what ever topic they choose

Il Professore has a knack for gleaning the essence of a complex work and, with a great economy of words, clarifying it. Bra--vo! I feel I got an enhanced Cliff's Notes version of a masterpiece.

National treasure.. Academia should insure Dr. Sugrue’s intellect for a $billion ! Health and Happiness to you!!

Just to let you know that you've helped my mind a great deal. Thanks for the education.

This dude is unbelievable

I’ve been going through all of your lectures recently and you’re works are brilliant and enlightening. Wait… is this your actual channel doc?

Really loving these lectures. Thank you for sharing. My only regret is I can’t visit him during office hours to discuss my follow up questions.

I didn't even know lecturers of this caliber existed

Given how much companies have found ways to squeeze out wealth, I'd say smith was spot on about the ability for companies to collude. Michael missed how much asset inflation could be used to manipulate the economics

Awesome lectures, Ford raise the salary to 5$ a day not per hour, obviously it was a huge increase but he had huge employe rotation so it wasnt generosity, but the spirit of mass consumption is there.

I'd love to hear Dr. Sugrue's ideas about how AI might change society today.

Philosophy and economics should be on the core curriculum at every grade level

@conservativelibertarian

Жыл бұрын

then the Marxists would take over

@georgefisher9304

Жыл бұрын

Mmm, that would require the self-discipline and seriousness that i am not sure most young people are either capable or willing to exercise.

nice

Wow, thank you Professor. I doubt I'd ever have read this book, but now I might. Seems to me Smith's division of labor paved the way for Babbage and Lovelace's primitive computers of the 1820s, and for computerized automation all the way up to cloud computing.

@excitedaboutlearning1639

2 жыл бұрын

I'm not familiar with Babbage and Lovelace's contributions to modern computational theory, but I have something to say. It's a personal remark. When I understood the concepts of variable, function, input, algorithm & output, I could see the mechanics of the world in new light. Previously on, I had found physics equations impossibly hard to grasp, but then I finally understood the relations that things have with each other and how to model those relations mathematically. I think variable is an extremely powerful concept when you've grasped it's abstract meaning as opposed to only being able figure out unknowns in equations. For a long time, I could solve for x and y, but I didn't understand what x and y were.

Adam Smith's twin books are really exercises in psychology - with a bit of economics thrown in.. "Group selfishness maximises total community wealth.."

The economist Anwar Shaikh has a very good economic theory that addresses the issues surrounding monopolies and collusion between capitalists. He argues that the competition between businesses has nothing to do with rational monopolies looking to exercise their control and collude with other businesses to keep wages low. Instead, his theory of Real Competition argues that companies compete as if they are at war. They will do whatever they have to do to push their competitors out of the market. If that means lowering their wages in order to price their competitor out of the market, then they will do that. If it means investing in newer technology that will make their workforce more productive, they will do that. His theories actually correspond very well with real world economic trends.

@wordsnexttoeachother

2 жыл бұрын

yep

Although I understand and partly sympathize with your disclaimer about the ”free markets are natural” argument, I think there’s another side to this that you overlook. Often it is the case that this point is mentioned in an economic context as a reaction to claims about the opression that the free market supposedly causes. For instance; the minimum wage is artificially inflating lower wages above their market value and minimum wage laws are for that reason ”unnatural” by some economic standards

15:35 “economic discipline” translates to conformity

As the machine age roared to life, it didn't just replace muscle with metal; it redefined muscle altogether, blurring the lines between 'men's work' and 'women's work.' The factory floor became an unexpected battleground for gender equality!

A great lecture marred by a lack of understanding that Adam Smith was in fact Scottish not English.

Henry Ford paid $5 a day, not $5 an hour. Also, Adam Smith was not English, he was Scottish. Otherwise, brilliant lecture that puts Wealth of Nations and economics generally into excellent context.

@TheZigzagman

2 жыл бұрын

That's almost a thousand dollars a week adjusted for inflation. Not too shabby.

@ideologybot4592

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheZigzagman it's a great wage. Wasn't paid to everyone, and the working conditions were hardcore, but it was the start of middle class factory wages, which is why it makes sense to put it in this lecture. It only matters because I don't want people getting the idea that Ford was paying $5 an hour in 1925. That would be insane.

@conservativelibertarian

Жыл бұрын

​​@@TheZigzagman $1 in 1929 is equivalent in purchasing power to about $17.33 today, an increase of $16.33 over 93 years. The dollar had an average inflation rate of 3.11% per year between 1929 and today, producing a cumulative price increase of 1,632.81%. 17.33$x 5 x 7 days a week = 606.55$ a week adjusted for inflation. 31,540.60$ a year. That's a subsistence level wage.

@TheZigzagman

Жыл бұрын

@@conservativelibertarian Henry Ford's policy was put in place in 1914, friend. That's 148 a day adjusted for inflation. That's 1,036 in 7 days. Take off the roughly 10 federal holidays and throw in a week of non-working days and that's the equivalent of 50,000 a year. Which it most certainly wouldn't be in 1929 because the Ford company pioneered the 5 day, 40 hour work week in 1926. I think you googled the wrong thing.

@conservativelibertarian

Жыл бұрын

​​​​@@TheZigzagman In 1929, the average annual wage for auto workers was $1639. That's from the Ford hunger march wikipedia page. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Hunger_March#:~:text=In%201929%2C%20the%20average%20annual,were%20113%20suicides%20in%20Detroit. 1639$ x 17.33 inflation rate = 28,403$ annual salary adjusted for inflation.

I would be very interested to hear Dr. Sergue’s thoughts on Leo Strauss (particularly his political philosophy, and how said philosophy influenced U.S. Neoconservatism). Is anything like that extant?

@dr.michaelsugrue

2 жыл бұрын

Dad said Strauss was dead when he arrived at U of C but he studied with the usual suspects. He found out that Bloom's interpretative essay got book 5 of the Republic wrong and believes that East Coast Straussians (like right wing Hegelians) are more consistent with the master's thought but West Coast Straussians (like left wing Hegelians) misread the master in more fruitful and important and interesting ways.

@citycrusher9308

2 жыл бұрын

@@dr.michaelsugrue @20:00 onwards - W men didn't gain equality in the age of machinery(they already had that). They gained more rights than men. Please don't spread naive propaganda. It sullies the lecture. Thank you

@reasonerenlightened2456

Жыл бұрын

@@dr.michaelsugrue Demolition of Smith: THE FREE MARKET INEVITABLY LEADS TO EXTREME CONCENTRATION OF WEALTH BECAUSE IT ALWAYS BECOMES TRAGEDY OF THE COMMONS PROBLEM DUE TO THE RELENTNESS PURSUIT OF PROFIT IN A FREE ACCESS ENVIRONMENT. (The free market ALWAYS concentrates Wealth, because it is a battlefield and also because competition is unsustainable).

Another fantastic lecture, but a couple of points... The pre-industrial economy did _not_ consist of men in the fields, forests & quarries whilst the women and children were at home tending to the rose garden and embroidery. _All_ pre-industrial economies consisted of men, women & children out in the fields, forests & quarries together, trying to eke out what meagre living they might from the world around them. Relevant caveats for the ruling elites. What is claimed about the effects of factories on the position of women in the workplace is almsot 180 from reality. Women began to disappear from the workplace. Not due to the nature of factories but due to the moral sentiments of the legislators and their lobbyists... "it isn't seemly in this day & age, that a woman should work in such conditions". It was only with the increase of factories the Industrial Revolution brought about, that legislation to limit the working time (and earning capacity) of women and children was either thinkable - there's no reason for a Factory Act until you've invented a factory and factory conditions; or affordable - the wealth factories create was/is a necessary pre-condition to _any_ attempt at Welfarism.

There's still a lot to know of

Smith assumed it’s better for everyone to have 10 crappy pens than for most people to have one high quality pen.

25:57 I think the answer to that question is a resounding and obvious yes.

@user-hu3iy9gz5j

11 ай бұрын

That whole ”rebuttal” is based on circular logic. It is true that higher wages is good for the market, yes. It is also true that individual buisnesses will benefit from this in the long run. It’s the ”minimal levels” that flactuate, not the strive to keep them in place Wages have not been artificially inflated, but only followed the trend of general wealth increases in Society over time

Mega

Smith was Scottish, not English. Americans may not think the difference is significant, but the Scots surely do.

@cch312

2 жыл бұрын

What are some important differences? I don't know a lot about that and it sounds interesting. Would you mind sharing?

@cinnamon4605

2 жыл бұрын

@@cch312 there are unofficial enemy states.

@mnmmnm8321

2 жыл бұрын

Jevon, from Jevons Paradox, was also Scottish.

@spcphd

2 жыл бұрын

@@cch312 The Welsh, Irish, and Scots have had ethnic differences and territorial disputes with the (Anglo-Saxon) British for centuries. Check out the history of Scotland to learn about it. If you want to have some fun, watch the movie Braveheart.

Is there a lecture on Bernard de mandeville

24:50 PhD Sugrue stops himself from saying “they hang around eachother”. good catch

15:00 [As the level of skill in our workers declines] I'd argue the level of skill changes, from a broad to a more narrow and specialised set.

@user-hu3iy9gz5j

11 ай бұрын

Smith even mentions this in Wealth of Nations, that overall skill levels actually increase with the division of labour. At least for specialized and monotone jobs. He exemplifies by comparing rural farmers to urban industrial workers. The farmer will not be able to perfect all the varying skills involved in the duties of his labour, yet he must nevertheless perform these tasks by virtue of being a lone worker. Alongside this, the farmers are forced to switch between brief tasks, moving across large areas, switching gear, which slows the process significantly, while industrial workers could do this all simultainiously at different locations. So even if the farmer has a greater set of general skills he will be outcompeted at almost all of the individual tasks by his many infustrial counterparts

Can you please upload the machiavelli lecture? I enjoyed that one a lot. Thanks a lot for your time.

@ckchristos

3 жыл бұрын

me too . Machiavelli please. Loveee them so much.

There are alot of monopolies today. Is that the problem and if so what should be done about it?

Love Sugrue, probably my fav channel on KZread. But at 37:54 how can you just skim over China when it is the most populated country and a force to be reckoned with?

Damn, people were super optimistic about their elites back in the 90s.

1. Division of labor 2. Accumulation of capital 3. Economic history of the West

How can any economic structure be critiqued or assessed without addressing central banking? Adam Smith maybe talks indirectly when speaking about collusion, but I cannot see how international banking does not have its hand in both capitalism and communism.

@user-hu3iy9gz5j

11 ай бұрын

The snake is biting its tail

I'm always looking for new interesting lectures on Psychology/Philosophy, please let me know if you guys have any recommendations, would be highly appreciated

@cch312

2 жыл бұрын

All of Dr. Sugrue will do you good. He has a casual podcast with his daughter, just chat about philosophy. I also like Jordan Peterson's interpretation of a lot of existentialist ideas.

@bacchusinstituteofscience8650

2 жыл бұрын

Look up people that talk about Niklas Luhmann, Julian Jaynes and Robert K Merton for a good start.

Glory to Allah, The way Dr. Sugrue speaks like he is reading from a book, he doesn't stutter and keeps on talking. It's like he is just reading his own mind as he speaks. Excellent lectures by an excellent lecturer.. this looks like from the 70s or 80s. Does he lectures till now?

@jphanson

Жыл бұрын

Check out his recent videos, he still gives lectures on classic literature

Mercantilism 1. Natural causes - space and time, distance 2. Conventional causes 3. Government interference - laissez faire - invisible hand - natural equilibrium

Wealth for the few. Poverty for the wage slaves. Trevithick was the key to stean engines on rails. Technology drives all change.

Adam Smith was not English, he was Scottish. I always find it strange when people who have clearly read and studied someone's work in such great detail that they can make such a glaring error.

Now we just need to define "a rationale person."

When was this lecture given?

Are there transcripts of these lectures?

If you should happen to see this,I'm wondering what the Professor would have to say on the extension of this "dullness" created through the division of labor and Marcuse's insights in "One Dimensional Man" and also Durkheim's insights on the concept of Social Anomie and the pathology of atomization.. My take is that the professor has some interesting insights on Marxism and the growing social antagonisms we are seeing in the present day.. Thank you for these wonderful lectures..🙂

Excellent. I shall be seeking out all your output. [The expression is "the proof of the pudding is in the eating", not "the proof is in the pudding"]

A comment to feed the algorithm

I wonder what Smith would think of a service economy. When you cant extract your wealth from the planet it is hard to generate wealth by simply serving yourself.