Thank you Jonathon for all that you do. Keep saying it like it is! Slava Ukraine🇺🇦

Thank you, Jonathan. Slava Ukraini 🇺🇦

I was deeply sorry to hear of Shoigu leaving his level of gross incompetence, will seriously be missed!😅 Slava-UA 💙🇺🇦🩵🚀

@j.dunlop8295

26 күн бұрын

Non military dictators seriously fear a military coup! Putin had more FSB intelligence men, than military men! He put Soigu ex-army commander, had absolutely no military experience! Except being Putin's loyal functionary!😅 Shoigu's new book, "How to lose a war, for idiots!?"

@stephenhill545

25 күн бұрын

His wheel-barrel couldn't carry any more.

@bobjohnbowles

25 күн бұрын

We can look forward to even greater incompetence and grift from his successor.

Jonathan yes really how Ukraine has had to cope against a "Superpower" with one arm tied behind it's back is amazing and can only be ascribed to the fact that people fighting for their own country will fight like demons to protect their families and citizens. Ukraine has to beg for assistance and then gets arms at fits and starts and has little time to train to use these highly complex modern pieces of equipment. As one American ex Abrams tank crewman recently said about the Russian capture of an older model Abrams is that the Abrams is a very complex tank and is meant for offence operations and not defensive purposes and extensive training is required , a luxury the Ukranians could not afford. The same goes for the F16 fighter which requires specific skills to master. Thanks for your great work.

Thank you Jonathan for the high quality work you do! I'm trying to listen to every episode

@SiliconCurtain

26 күн бұрын

👍👍👍

@APW-ry2ok

25 күн бұрын

@@SiliconCurtainHi Jonathan ,where is your MUGA hat ? As endorsed by MTG.

@olivemd

24 күн бұрын

I had trouble finding time to listen to them, but now that garden weather is here, I listen while I garden. I really learn a lot too.

The Muscovites have zero chance even to approach Xarkovъ, not to speak of capturing. The defensive operation is headed by general Drapaty, one of the best Ukrainian commanders. He became famous back in 2014 when being just a captain he successfully led the breaking from encirclement at Izvarine and saved his brigade from inevitable death or captivity.

If the Tzar needs a new General, Steven Seagal, is available.

@SiliconCurtain

26 күн бұрын

😂

Russia allocated only 50.000 meatmen to this new front, which means they'll last about two months. :D

@j.dunlop8295

26 күн бұрын

Non military dictators seriously fear a military coup! Putin had more FSB intelligence men, than military men! He put Soigu ex-army commander, had absolutely no military experience! Except being Putin's loyal functionary!😅 Shoigu's new book, "How to lose a war, for idiots!?"

@PandemoniumMeltDown

25 күн бұрын

Weeks

@anthonyhulse1248

25 күн бұрын

Or less.

@PandemoniumMeltDown

25 күн бұрын

@@anthonyhulse1248 32000

@philippage60

25 күн бұрын

Nom nom nom 😊 Ukraine loves meat.🇺🇦

I'm not making light of war, but. This "attack ", and previous high casualty offensives put in mind the Crusifiction scene in , Life of Brian, by Monty Python. The suicide squad attacking. The Russian... sorta army is a horrific comedy.

@j.dunlop8295

26 күн бұрын

Definitely, Ukraine civilian soldiers, GPS every likely spot, in retreat villages for connon attention later in the "given up" village's! Slava-UA 💙🇺🇦🩵🚀💥💥🧸 bear fodder!😮 Non military dictators seriously fear a military coup! Putin had more FSB intelligence men, than military men! He put Soigu ex-army commander, had absolutely no military experience! Except being Putin's loyal functionary!😅 Shoigu's new book, "How to lose a war, for idiots!?"

Such a detailed, in depth analysis and review is absolutely compulsory viewing/listening. What makes it work is Jonathan doesn't just report events. He breaks them open and looks inside. World class commentary.

Putin has put an economist in Shoigus job to go through the books and report to Putin.

@SiliconCurtain

26 күн бұрын

The entire system is corrupt, so it won’t help at this stage.

@geoffgill5334

26 күн бұрын

​@@SiliconCurtain😂😂😂 👍

@geoffgill5334

26 күн бұрын

Military are not going to like their golden goose going away

@stephenhill545

25 күн бұрын

Another young talent comes through. There are so many there.

@artmcteagle

25 күн бұрын

How to you think Putin got his billions? He is probably the richest man in the world and Bill Browder estimates that the russian elites have stolen over $1 trillion dollars from the russian public. Belousov can probably squeeze a bit more from the military-industrial complex, but it's all about power dynamics in the vertical heirarchy of power and removing any potential future threats to Putin's power.

Informative

Top quality analysis

Thank you, Jonathan, for another excellent episode of Silicon Bites. Very much appreciated. 🇺🇦 Перемоги і миру всім українцям! 🇺🇦

♥️🇺🇦

That was just excellent, thank you.

US, EU and others, all are really weak and slow. We''re lucky to have Ukraine, not the reverse.

@stephenhill545

25 күн бұрын

Not weak, just don't care enough, which is sad, because the majority of European citizens do.

@4mb127

25 күн бұрын

@@stephenhill545 Inability to act rationally, ingeniously, swiftly and effectively, because unfamiliarity or denial of the new state of the world--it is weakness.

🇬🇪🇺🇦🇬🇪🇺🇦🙏💪

I like your interviews and your excellent partners but I also like to hear your point of view and your analysis. Thank you.

Slava Ukraini, from Denmark.

@SiliconCurtain

26 күн бұрын

👍👍👍

@j.dunlop8295

26 күн бұрын

Non military dictators seriously fear a military coup! Putin had more FSB intelligence men, than military men! He put Soigu ex-army commander, had absolutely no military experience! Except being Putin's loyal functionary!😅 Shoigu's new book, "How to lose a war, for idiots!?"

@BogdanTestsSoftware

25 күн бұрын

Thank you Denmark for supporting Ukraine and its heroes!

@squireson

25 күн бұрын

Denmark has been remarkable in it's support and insight. I would very much like to know the difference in public debate in Denmark vs public debate in the U.S.

@mwtrolle

25 күн бұрын

@@squireson there isn’t any MAGA!

You’re an eloquent wordsmith and unbowed warrior JF… … love it.

Ty Jonathan for your work,support for Ukraine👍🙏we in Sweden belive in and support Ukraine!🇺🇦❤️🇸🇪👍

45:14 ".... which can't happen soon enough." On behalf of Chechens: Hear! Hear!

Russia's last throw of the dice.

Well said Jonathan. Ukrainian victory is paramount. The US can pump more oil.

Hi Johnathan, Konstantin gives a very insightful analysis of Shoigu's demotion and the reasons for Belousov's promotion in his latest video, it's not what most western analysts suppose. Great overview as usual!

@dananorth895

25 күн бұрын

KGB/FSB in charge of operations?

Dobryy vecher Jonathan 😺 Spasibo za vash analiz. Working with Ukrainians and watching news I am learning Russian and Ukrainian!😊

Thx Jonathon Great work!

love how you just discuss stuff and no 'effervescent' stuff makes it into your comments. A big fan, wish more knew and listened to your work. thanks a lot.

Thank you sir 🇺🇦

I'm surprised putin hasn't yet placed Mike Flynn in the role.

@artmcteagle

25 күн бұрын

Jeez, don't give them ideas! He's a traitor but still a relatively competent general.

Jonathan, what removed Milošević, were empty shelves, ques for bread and basic food, cold homes in winter, electricity and water supply shortages. And exorbitant inflation, nearly comparable with Germany in 1920es. As long as EU companies and banks laugh at our face and keep making profits with Vladolf Putler and his supporters, he will continue like this. Jonathan, my concern goes now beyond this war. Where and when will our companies stop committing such acts of treason? P.S. this concern is based on the direct experience with some EU companies, obviously run by psychopathic, seriously psychopathic, greedy management. Do they know the limits of their greed and are they capable of setting priorities in the case of broader conflict?

@SiliconCurtain

25 күн бұрын

I absolutely agree. I’ve always said Russians won’t revolt, as long as they have bread, cheese, sausage and vodka… we are doing nothing that would deny them these things…

@draganjagodic4056

25 күн бұрын

​@@SiliconCurtainThank You dear Jonathan 🌞

Dude, the people who listen to your podcast are already up on the news. We watched you because of commentary. I literally did not hear one new thing however, in general, I love your podcast, so it's just a bit of tough love

Thank you so much for everything you do! 💙💛

nice artwork!

Great coverage as always. Thank you 🇺🇦🇦🇺

Thank you Jonathon, always a well researched and balanced perspective. Слава Україні

that was ace

Why Russians attacked now and why Charkov ? Putin finally understood that the West will not let him defeat Ukraine - and he found out that Shoigu told him a lot of "stories". So he developed a new plan: He still wants whole Donbass - and now he tries a typical KGB method: he is trying blackmailing. His plan: take a part of Charkov region, and after that go in peace negotiations with the proposal to change this territory against the rest of Donbass etc.

@SiliconCurtain

26 күн бұрын

Interesting idea.

@dananorth895

25 күн бұрын

RU has long planned attack on kharkiv and Ukrain has known this and watched the buildup. This is an attempt by RU to draw UK forces from south and east to rebuild logistics lines and forces for summer offensive while digging in futher like ticks. It also helps to depleat RU supplies/lines before supplies come in full.

Thanks

@SiliconCurtain

25 күн бұрын

Thank you, that really helps!

In WWII they called that "Strategic Bombing".

Very good reporting 👏

Thanks, man. Respect.

Slava Ukraini! ❤❤❤

Thank you for all your efforts Jonathan! Is Shoigu being moved away from the defence department and army or towards the new role?

love what you've done to the images you showed, making them look like oil paintings.

The Kharkiv offensive is being led for Russia by General Lapin who has failed twice against Ukraine already. His orders haven’t really changed, secure the border of Belgorod Oblast. He just been given more troops to pursue this and given his track record he is starting this “defense” in Ukrainian territory, so when he is pushed back to the border he’ll have “succeeded”. Its not clear where Russia have taken these ground troops from, but its doubtful the VKS can fly two large operations at once. The offensive has to be taken seriously, but the tactical airpower directed at Kharkiv Oblast itself can’t be used in Donetsk as well. It seems unlikely that this serious aggression from Russia will make Western Europe less committed to opposing Russia. Its interesting that if the supply of F-16s to Ukraine doesn’t neutralise this threat, it seems NATO discussions have started to take more direct action in protecting Ukraine.

Brilliant - corruption - a normal system - not a " bug" !

Really good discussion of difficult subjects

Great channel, thank you very much ❤

👍🇺🇦🇬🇧

39:25 Let’s not forget that the Westminster parliament skipped an entire election cycle from 1940 - 1945 and that all Party support for Churchill’s War Ministry, as it was called, was how this was made legal. Once the Opposition Party’s support was withdrawn after VE day then UK elections were rapidly held.

Top information, to everyone.👍

Ukraine is not doing a blanket recruitment from prisons

@SiliconCurtain

26 күн бұрын

No, it’s not. Exactly what I said in the video.

and I think he was appointed since the war is really badly impacting the Russian economy. and the real reason why Shoigu was fired to keep shoigu on the leash and lessen his power. and Berlusov is a perfect yes man nobody who putin can control much more easilly than Shoigu

Some sources claim, that Shoigu is dismissed, and will later be taken out completely. The position he is appointed to now, is only there for him to save face. The thing is, that he is appointed to Patrushevs position. One of the most powerful people in russia. So how is it a just parking of an unpopular minister, to appoint him to the position of patrushev? And what does it mean, that a patrushev just gives up his position? This man is one of the most influential and powerful people in russia. He is a decision maker. You said that it isn’t clear, how Shoigus movement to being patrushevs successor, can be seen as a demotion. I really wonder how others interpret it as a demotion. Absolutely strange.

Why didn’t you mention that the UK also skipped an election during ww2?

Is Shoigu a good typist, though?

@stephenhill545

25 күн бұрын

He has a very big wheelbarrow.

o7

👍👍👍

Slava Ukraini. Free Ukraine of Russians, Free Russia of Pootin

The president of Georgia will veto the bill. Then…???

I don’t think we should give the FSB all the credit for planning. Some times people in power can see what worked for others to hold onto power and decide to emulate what worked for Putin. They don’t necessarily want to be inline with Putin, but they want the level of power he has.

Interesting that if it was not for US supplies to the USSR during WW2 the Soviets would have failed against the German onslaught, due to Stalin's purges that gutted the officer ranks before WW2 that placed communist dogma over military skill, this lead to Soviet forces being badly led at the onset of Operation Barbarossa. Russians seem to gloss over the fact that a huge mass of Ukrainian men that died in Soviet service.

How long will it be before the USA money and supplies reach the front lines?

Important to recognize that the German and USSR fight was between competing totalitarian regimes, with leaders who had great regard for the other on those terms. (The only man Stalin ever trusted was Hitler, Khcrushchev famously said). Putins professional life was as an instrument of the elite formations, his ideology is power accumulation.

@dananorth895

25 күн бұрын

For a different perspective read Victor Surorov works/analysis on ww2. See "Icebreaker: How Stalin Won WWII".

@paulblack8887

10 күн бұрын

@@dananorth895 His book The Chief Culprit is a good one too, thanks for the recommendation

Thanks Jonathan, a valuable update on the ominous developments around Kharkiv. Johnson and Trump have a lot to answer for.

Love your Channel. Watching it regularly. I s there any way you could improve the video interaction between your back ground and your face? I find the oscillations between your facial features, glasses, etc., disappearing and reappearing very distracting. Get your techies to take care of it, PALEEZE! Jochen

NATO must open it's own front.

@Dragonfly-sr5uw

26 күн бұрын

Cope, ruscists.

@j.dunlop8295

26 күн бұрын

Article 5 is pretty clear on this! Breaking treaty regulations, not happening! 🩵🇺🇦💙

@MrShuraj

26 күн бұрын

You think Russians are scared of NATO? Russia Dares!

@j.dunlop8295

26 күн бұрын

Definitely, Ukraine civilian soldiers, GPS every likely spot for connon attention later in the "given up" village's! Slava-UA 💙🇺🇦🩵🚀💥💥🧸 bear fodder!😮 Non military dictators seriously fear a military coup! Putin had more FSB intelligence men, than military men! He put Soigu ex-army commander, had absolutely no military experience! Except being Putin's loyal functionary!😅 Shoigu's new book, "How to lose a war, for idiots!?"

@petergeerts8895

26 күн бұрын

Go tell that to Macron. Got a briefing recently on what he is up against. End of story. , same goes for the Brits with an asshole D.Cameron.

Each according to their *station,* not a new story, all told. Compared to class systems of yesteryear, at least modern Kleptocracies had the feature that the station of a person could be correlated to performance. In theory...

Minister of defense is not in charge of strategy on the battlefield, and military strategy at all. Chief of the general staff position exists, he is appointed not by the minister, but by putin himself, and currently the position is occupied by gerasimov. MoD is largely an economic and logistics agency.

I should amend my last sentence....is PARTLY a lie..because ordinary Russian forces fought so very bravely.

At 39 : 52, how many readers have noticed a cleverally touched up facial features depicting brutal ugliness effect ?

I appreciate your presentations. However, although the video quality has improved from 360p to 720p (which is now perfectly ok for KZread) there are strange artefacts surrounding your head. Is that the Holy Ghost?

well in 2023 the Russians tried a offensive vs. Kharkov with around 100K men and hundreds of tanks, well it failed badly due to overstretched poor Russian logistics which was hit hard by the Ukrainians and the fact the Russians were attacking uphill, in open heavilly mined areas vs. strong Ukrainian positions. The 2023 Russian offensive vs. Kharkov failed badly with thousands of casualties and most of these guys were withdrawn and repositioned to the Donbass.

How are the Free Russian Legion and associates doing with recruitment?

Dora Chomiak , CEO of Razom for Ukraine received, on behalf of Razom, Order of Merit from President Zelenskyy. 2023 September

Losses? As new York Times stated no long ago Russia lost around 60 000 men. Ukraine, on the other hand, have already 600 000 casualties and twice as much wounded many of which permanently disabled. Russia is not playing games. They burn Ukrainian positions before the advances. If they meet some resistance, they withdraw and bombs start raining for days. After that Russians repeat the exercise. In Kharkiv regions Ukrainians simply abandoned the defence line. Whoever left, surrendered to avoid the war.

@stephenhill545

25 күн бұрын

Enjoy your tax increases and currency devaluation. Soon phones will be too expensive to buy for you.

@pablom-f8762

25 күн бұрын

If UA lost 600k men there would be no Ukraine anymore. Get a grip.

@DavidCarvalho-iz4ny

25 күн бұрын

100% spot on

What will you say when Ukraine capitulates and most regions join RF? Will you still mumble about Ukraine victory like nothing happened?

Ukraine victory? No men, no weapons, no ammunition, begging for everything? Can’t win a war by begging for bullets. What will Ukraine look like in 4 more years? Think hard about that….

@ulrichvonhermann2548

25 күн бұрын

You can say the same for soviets during ww2...

@westbenchmancave

25 күн бұрын

@@ulrichvonhermann2548 Sure buddy. Your “Coping skills” are lame, trying to rewrite history? Hahaha good luck, maybe your liberal democrat friends will believe you? Most won’t….

@DavidCarvalho-iz4ny

25 күн бұрын

@@ulrichvonhermann2548BS they had the men Ukraine doesn’t that’s pretty clear

RESPECT, SHADES OF FACHIESTA HISTORY IN FUGITIVE PUTIN NAMEING SHOE GOOS REPLACEMENT REMINDS ME OF APPOINTING ALBERT SPEER ARMAMENTS & WAR PRODUCTION MINISTER. PARTIALLY RESPONSIBLE FOR ECONOMIC STABILLITY 1942 TO 1MAY1945 A. H. APPOINTS A.SPEER Personal ARCHITECT 1933 to 1945. SOUTH PHILADELPHIA, OUT 🔱⭐

Jonathon---don m,ake these vidioes, just with you alone they are not attractiv--you are booring you need a famous guest--sorry

@terryhand

25 күн бұрын

Then don't watch them. Most of us find them extremely informative.

Only six more months.. ..... TRUMP2024 🇺🇲 ✊️😡

@18_rabbit

25 күн бұрын

i'm a centrist in the U.S. and if he wins, Ukr is done. DJT and his cronies have demonstrated repeatedly over the past 8 years that they do not support anything except a mindless 'great powers' concepts of nationalist major powers manipulating the countries in their spheres. This is a classic social-militaristic view that originated more than two millenia ago. These ppl are deeply stupid and i suggest u check your head and your strange biases. Look up a list of cognitive biases (aka thought defects, that ALL ppl are vulnerable to everyday! Wake the eff up!

👍👍👍