Living in a predominantly Mormon town and as a practicing Jew (Conservative ), I met an Orthodox gentleman and I was so happy to see him. I greeted him and he asked me “How many Jews in this town?” And I couldn’t help but say “There used to be a minyan around.”

@shulamislefkowitz7816

3 жыл бұрын

Shit you don't know how much you can do

@matero4life2019

3 жыл бұрын

Hey I live in Utah as well we probably know eachother lol you probably mean rabbi Benny from the chabad in Salt Lake City . I grew up here it’s very challenging being a Jew here. Bennys a mensch I really like him. Love chabad of Utah 🇺🇸❤️

When I wrote this I was in high school in Memphis, TN. I could have never envisioned such a warm, universal response. I have Lenny Solomon to thank for making it such a hit. I am also grateful to the Maccabeats for teaming up with Lenny and taking Minyan Man to the next level. Great job, guys! Victor Shine

@Favorites227

7 жыл бұрын

Really! Cool!! This is such a beautiful and spiritual anthem to me. I am Christian. But, I've listened to the song so much..I think maybe we all have Jew somewhere in our blood. Really, really great job!!

@francinegray9383

7 жыл бұрын

Thank you P Me.

@amazingabby25

7 жыл бұрын

fiddlinvic I have very warm memories of singing this song every Shabbat at Camp Yavneh, thanks for writing it.

@impalamama7302

6 жыл бұрын

Shalom from the "Big M" town! I love this song! I was born and raised in Memphis. I come from a long line of Sephardic Jews, who came to this country to Charleston, SC during Colonial Times, who lived and intermarried and were assimilated. But I have knew my roots,and have embraced them for decades. Thank you for realizing and putting into song that the Jewish influence in America isn't always from the Ashkenazim, and even in the depths of the South there is a presence and heritage of the Tzadkim. The Secretary of State of the Confederacy was a Jew...Judah Benjamin. Might not fit in with today''s PC enviroment ...but there it is! Shalom and La'shanah Tov!

@francinegray9383

6 жыл бұрын

Excellent! So right, as the Sephardis and Romaniotes too long have melded into Ashkenazi culture. BTW, I think there were other major Jewish figures in the South too. Shanah Tovah!

I watch this at least once a month. I literally crave this song. Thank you.

This is so profound and delicate; brings tears to my eyes. Shalom from a Mizrachi Jew!

For some reason this song brings a tear to my eye, and a simple sense of pride in The Tribe.

@impalamama7302

6 жыл бұрын

Amen, Francine, Amen.....I love the way the harmonies reflect those common to the harmonies of Southern gospel church music..... no Klezmer here...

@francinegray9383

6 жыл бұрын

Interesting point.

@impalamama7302

5 жыл бұрын

@@francinegray9383 The American South is MORE Pro-Israel than anyplace on earth. It is because the South was well-salted by the Sephardic Jews that were well assimilated prior to the War Between The States.In colonial times, and after the War for American Independence, It also blended well with the Scottish HIghland/ Ulster Scots and Cherokee customs that built up the LARGE parts of the South that did NOT rely on slave labor. It's very interesting just how much Southern tradition is closely aligned with Sephardic Jewish tradition.....there is very much shared...Israel has no closer friend but we don't care....we are used to being called names! We STAND with Israel!

@francinegray9383

5 жыл бұрын

@@impalamama7302 Thanks for that info! Very interesting. We need better education in the U. S. about these types of assimilations.

@F_Tim1961

3 жыл бұрын

I made post on this less than 4 hrs ago and it appears to have been deleted. Chabad AUCK was involved in the discussion. TE. Fidler in NZ .. Weird ?? @Francine Gray .... BTW The Apprenticeship of Duddy Kravits is free to air on KZread at the moment. I guess the copyright period is over. well worth a look . It is a real scream this film... cynical but quite subtle too. a very young Rick Dreyfus puts up a bravura performance.. th ebest scene is when He tries to do some Gesheft with Farber in the junk yard. Farber realises it is an idea opportunity to stitch up Segal after he (F) strikes a price for the bar mitzvah film with Duddy.. just priceless. :-) Tim Fidler New ZLD

I’m from Birmingham where part of this was filmed. I went to a high school that had a large Jewish presence and I learned to love and respect the Jews and I stand for Israel! Our spiritual home on this Earth.

@meniweizmann644

2 жыл бұрын

Amen to that brother!

@joescott123

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you, form all of us.

This song is so moving it brought me to tears. I have been a minyan man several times in my life in a small town and it is an intensively gratifying feeling--a real mitzvah.Once I was a minyan man in central Tel Aviv. I said how could this possible; how naive I was.

One of the best Maccabeats songs.

@JsbergVR

5 жыл бұрын

A Philip Actually this song is from Lenny Solomon (Shlock Rock Leader)

Every time I see my husband listening to this fine music I always ask him what the lyrics means and he tells me. Thanks to Lenny Solomon for making and creating this masterpiece of a lovely Jewish song that anybody can relate to.

@fiddlinvic

4 жыл бұрын

I give Lenny a lot of credit for making this song a worldwide hit, and for transforming it from the ballad I originally wrote. Here is the link to the original tape I sent him in 1986 with me playing guitar and violin, and singing. (I used two tape recorders): kzread.info/dash/bejne/aI15zrmYh8_TqLw.html

Love _everything_ about this! The words, the melody, the wonderful harmony of the Maccabeats, the filming. " ... and the back of the store still remembers the song."

@fiddlinvic

3 жыл бұрын

@satchmoshello I get chills when reading your kind words. Thank you!

God bless my Jewish brothers & sisters.

Crying!!! Shabbat Shalom, holy Jews. May we all come together under G-d soon

Religion in the South is amazing. Whoever you meet, they are most likely to be religious and practicing. There are mostly Protestants, but also Catholics, Jews, and a handful of Orthodox Christians. I am a young adult convert to Catholicism, and I must say, that every one of these congregations have their own sort of beauty. God bless, what a beautiful song!

@hannahs1683

2 жыл бұрын

Very few Orthodox lol

@erikbishop7

2 жыл бұрын

@@hannahs1683 Indeed, I know it.

@mariekatherine5238

Жыл бұрын

Old comment, but it’s true. I’m Traditional Catholic and have spent many summers in the south. However unlikely, I can think of only once that I didn’t find a Latin Mass for Sunday or Holy Day.

This brings much meaning to us in Southern Africa too… where one can find hundreds of beautiful synagogues throughout cities, villages and towns (dorps in Afrikaans) some have not seen a Jew, yet alone a minyan in many years. I too am leaving in a few months… I am making aliya… but even in Israel … a little part of my heart will remain in that beautiful stained glass shul (synagogue) where I had my bar mitzvah so many years ago. The shul opened in 1942… it can seat over a thousand; in a suburb that was once Jewish and today is known as Johannesburg’s China Town called Cyrildene. Cyrildene Shul

This brings me back to my childhood. I love the song and video, especially the old film. Precious memories. A favorite.

This song gives me goosebumps, it is so beautiful!

I love listening to this song. Brings me to tears at the end every time.

First time I listen to this song tears came in my eyes and there was pain in my Heart. It is Again an excellent touching song about jews, and yet the music is so great you cannot get it out of your head. The filming is so well done in colours Brown taking us back. God bless the jews ..... I stand for Israel.

One of my all time favorites. The Maccabeats add a really different dimension. I loved the original too. The clips taken from the original were filmed in the back of my friend's father's hardware store in Birmingham, Alabama. Memories...

I love this song. I am from a small city that struggled every week for a Minyan but thanks to our wonderful new Rabbi and his wife we are now reviving and starting to thrive!

What a great song and an awesome rendition guys. Thank you Maccabeats, you rock!

This song is really right on - the way our people have drifted apart and away. It makes you stop and think about where we have come from and where we are going - and it needs to be back to our roots.

Thank you to the Maccabeats and Lenny Solomon for teaming up and bringing back such fond memories of the old KI (Congregation Kenneset Israel) minyan in Birmingham, AL. As far as I know, just about everyone of the men in the video are no longer alive or have moved away (Rabbi Tradburks to Israel and Richard Cohen northward). And yes, the hardware store was under Jewish ownership. I was teaching during the filming of the original video. Wished I could have been part of this moving musical video.

@Gingit

2 жыл бұрын

My grandparents were members of Kenseth Israel in Birmingham, Alabama where the filming of the minyan took place. My very tall Uncle Izzy Eubanks can be seen as one of the Minyan goers. Such a surprise❣

@Gingit

2 жыл бұрын

"Keneseth Israel"

@simafeinzeig2959

2 жыл бұрын

This hardware store w the minyan actually existed???? Wow !!

My research used to take me to locations far more remote than Mobile, AL and with many fewer Jews. Sometimes it would just be 3 or 4 of us getting together in places like the back of a clothing store, and sometimes I was the minyan man. I love this song and it brings back so many memories. Yasher koach, Mr. Shine, please know you have brought great joy into the world.

@fiddlinvic

3 жыл бұрын

@David Golden that is so kind of you to say! I am grateful.

It is physically impossible for me to be sad while listening to this song. :p

@fiddlinvic

4 жыл бұрын

This note makes me very happy :)

I wrote this song when I was in high school, and Lenny published it in 1986. I really enjoy reading the comments describing how this song is meaningful for so many people of all backgrounds. Thank you, everyone

@joshuakatz8367

7 жыл бұрын

fiddlinvic you're lying I wrote this song when I was in the womb

@fiddlinvic

7 жыл бұрын

How'd you fit a minyan in the same womb?

@PuzzlesC4M

6 жыл бұрын

I thought for sure this was another Maccabeats parody. The 1st time I heard it I knew the tune and some of the words, but I’m not Jewish! How did I know this song? I figure it had to be from the few summers I went to camp at the JCC. I’m a Christian, but learning about the Tanakh and history of the Jewish people makes my heart ache for all they have been through and go through to this day. I’m so glad I found this and the writer. May G-d bless you!

@PuzzlesC4M

6 жыл бұрын

fiddlinvic Meant to tag you in the comment

@dorothyyoung8231

5 жыл бұрын

One of my professors in college was not observant but had been raised in an Orthodox family. When the local men needed a Minyan Man they’d call him and he’d always go on shabbos to make up the minyan.

so lovley... a recurrent event in small town Canada too... my old shul in North Bay also used to be a hardware store about 100 years ago; last year and a half a few elders passed away and for the first time in memory they can't make a minyan ... time to make aliyah

@amandablount3121

8 жыл бұрын

That is super sad.

@impalamama7302

6 жыл бұрын

May HaShem raise up some young men to replace them!

@philw5699

5 жыл бұрын

I would guess that the young men moved away to more exciting places.

@wjameswright

5 жыл бұрын

Didnt know there was a shul in North Bay or I would have been there when i lived there

@christopherhartley845

5 жыл бұрын

With the intolerable prices in a lot of big cities these days I am sure that you will see a lot of millenials & younger moving back to smaller cities & towns.

I love, love the Jewish community so much. They've been through so much and yet are so strong. Greetings from Puerto Rico. Hey to complete I found out I am 1% Jewish in My DNA I was so happy to find that out.

@frogallin1621

4 жыл бұрын

Rebecca Gutierrez How is your DNA religious?

@ellierichards3796

4 жыл бұрын

Frogallin 1 depending on what dna tests you use, portions of your heritage can be simplified to “european jew” :)

@mrfarina1474

4 жыл бұрын

Judaism is an ethno religion

@leonamay8776

4 жыл бұрын

@@frogallin1621 it's not. But Judaism is also an ethnicity. Well, you can convert... So, if you're descended from converts the test may not find "Jewish DNA" 🤷🏻‍♀️

@frogallin1621

4 жыл бұрын

Leona DuLac So what exactly is ‘Jewish DNA’?

Awesome song and video !! Shalom from Mexico City

I watch this video several times a week. The music and lyrics are so beautiful and it always brings tears to my eyes.

Another wonderful song by Lenny Solomon and of course the MACCABEATS. Every day I listen to it - it lift my soul so high. You jews are so talented in all arts, science, acriculture - yes you are certainly blessed by God. Blessed be you all. I stand for Israel.

One of the greatest Shlock Rock songs and this rendition with Maccabeats is perfect!

Terrific and so real. I've sat around in shul while the rabbi sent someone to go get the car mechanic because someone needed to get kaddish. And I've gotten the call too "ARE YOU available to help us form a minyan so we can say kaddish. I'm not even a traditionally observant Jew, but if someone grabbed me on the street and said they needed me for a minyan, I'd do like any mentsh would. So the other commenter's tear is totally understandable. Beautiful song and great performance.

Beautiful harmony and such tender words...the room remembers the songs. Well done!

I always sing thing. It was a staple on our high school retreats and the other day I was feeling emotional about the I/P conflict right now in the world and started to sing this and it brought me back to the sense of community we have and I started to cry in the middle of the mall.

@laurenhimbeault8434

3 жыл бұрын

my high school partnered with some of the maccabeats who would come on our retreats (before they were the maccabeats) and this is where they heard the song I'd guess. we love it so much

I'm not even Jewish and I love this song. Cool Jewish singers, how did they meet, form, gather. The video goes from 1989 to present day. Well done.

@carolinedevorahstephen7435

7 жыл бұрын

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Maccabeats

I wish this version could be put on iTunes. I absolutely love this song!

Great song and beautiful harmonies! 2

Thank you for the beautiful voices and my need to come back to our home one more time, please dear G-d!🙏

Какое СЧАСТЬЕ - видеть такие(!) глаза у людей, которые ПОЮТ!!!

This song is one of all time favorite songs. This arrangement with the Maccabeats is amazing and I keep coming back to listen to it over and over! Brings back such amazing NCSY memories with lots of good friends.

How did you guys have that film footage? My dad is the tall man standing right in front of the singer! He's been gone many years..... this was unbelievable!

@Shlockrock1

3 жыл бұрын

HI Judi, It is so nice to know that your dad is in the video. It was really a beautiful experience filming the original song back in 1989 and then again in 2015 with the Maccabeats!

@SOCORROSILVA-in7px

2 жыл бұрын

Judi, Is your dad located at approximately 2:04 being tall and having white hair?

@stephaniesaklad9224

2 жыл бұрын

My great grandfather was in that minyan too!!! We have vhs tapes with the original music video!

@missym5196

Жыл бұрын

Awww

@rebeccagurk1709

Жыл бұрын

Is that Frank Friedman at 2:16? And Rabbi RT?

dude.... i’ve been listening to shlock rock since second grade. this is so nostalgic for me. i love being so proudly jewish.

One of my favourite schlock rock songs teamed with the maccabeats 👌 fantastic

Great song, and great singing performance.

ANOTHER hit by the Maccabeats! Amazing!

@NageelaMom

5 жыл бұрын

No, by Shlock Rock.

@fiddlinvic

4 жыл бұрын

@@NageelaMom Actually I originally donated the song to Lenny Solomon's Jewish Public School Youth, but thanks for the note!

Makes me feel good

I'm sharing this all over!!! LOVE THIS SONG!!! brought tears to my eyes!

Incredible! Fresh sound to a classic. Great combo of talent.

excellent collaboration great jobs guys

My favourite facebook meme five years ago was "won't you stay with us for Shabbos, minion man" 😂

@EthanParmetItsDaBunny

5 жыл бұрын

How dare you

I cannot begin to comprehend the awesomeness of this.

love this song. Very emotional!

Thank you for posting this! It brings back wonderful memories of listening to my kids at camp - singing full voice and with pride.

Saw this late one night on NYC public access. Tremendous song!

The Maccabeats harmonize so well.

I enjoy watching and listening to this lovely song every time that I want to. Please post only positive comments over here. ™ September 21, 2023 @ 10:45 am ™

Loved the song...brings me joy this Friday evening!

Great song!!! it touched my heart its beatiful voices and words made me feel the happiness of those men in that time thank you very much, i now appreciate having a minyan more than before

The most surprising thing about this video is how little Lenny Solomon seems to have changed since the original video. He must have been one of those guys who looked middle aged as a young man.

Absolutely beautiful!! KOL HAKAVOD!

As the president of our synagogue in Rapid City, South Dakota where we have about 25 family units in our synagogue this song, the music and especially the words resonate quite personally. As a 70 year old I worry about the fate of our island of Yiddishkeit in our little corner of the world. When one of our student rabbis join us for the academic year I always play this video for them - a reality test of what we confront out here in the suburbs of the diaspora - frontier Judaism to be sure - and yes, I shed a tear each time. Fiddlinvic et all are genius who they captured the hopes and fears of rural Judaism.

This song randomly popped in my head and I had to hear it again.

Wonderful song! Beautiful voices! The Lord is my song! ...mein Herz ist fröhlich, und ich will ihm danken mit meinem Lied.

Great song! Powerful!

I really love this song and find myself singing along while driving.

Wow another awesome hit this is great I'm gonna listen to it a million times !!!

Lovin' me some Maccabeats!!!

you all did such a good job on this song. I love the message and your voices are so powerful and beautiful! ~~mazol tov!!!

This song is universal, it's about connection and community, right? It helps being Jewish, to help understand the context -- and the message is universal. And so beautifully sung and arranged.

Such a touching song! Just is time for shabbos! Thank you, Maccabeats!

I love this song!!

Shlock Rock איזו נוסטלגיה!!! וואו!! 😍

Guys! This is wonderful--thank you!

Just perfect! Great idea!

My daughter LOVED this song as a little girl. Now we share these beautiful words with my grandchildren.

מקסים ביותר ,תודה 🙏

just perfect, very nice !

Love this it Is fantastic. Great I can meet you at Ycc this summer

This is my all time favorite tear jerker. It's an especially good shabbos for us today. Shabbat Shalom! ✌🏽

one word: just AMAZING

I am glad I could contribute with the subtitles in Spanish.

I love it sooo much

Great song and awesome harmonies as always! Keep up the great work and I'm looking forward to more videos!

A beautiful song and I am Christian.

It was so amazing and awesome

I think it's the best song ever

Fantastic, and the guys all have wonderful voices. I am going to share this video with my mischbacha

Wow! This is actually a beautiful song!

love it. love shlock Rock and the Maccabeats!

Great song ,really well sung ,this took a lot of work ,thanks

This is a WINNER!!!!!

I'm not an orthodox, actually, not religious at all, but you guys are great. Keep on your great work. Lots of love from Israel

Amazing!!!

There are more of us here in Mobile. We can find a Minyan, and 2 synagogues currently. I'm so thankful for our small community. I've lived in other places that this song reminds me of. Once I was the only Jew in Metter Georgia probably the whole county, for a few years. This song brings back those memories. Sometimes it's easy to forget how few of us there really are until you are the only one.

Love it!!!

I love the 90s nostalgia in the filmography!

moving song, great!

This song gets me in the feels every time I hear it.

A song like this can be writtem only outside of Israel when there are so many towns with Minyan or litle more.

@impalamama7302

6 жыл бұрын

And it was written about a region not associated with Jew....The South, and particularly Mobile, AL! The Southern Jews felt the Diaspora much harder, and still do than you would reflexively think!