There are some very talented young luthiers today. Very nice to see Tamara and only her 10th guitar. Amazing!

I think the Tamara Stahl is very fine and her guitar is also nice . The Mario Gropp seems so precise I guess is the word , the intonation is spot on . Glad you had a great vacation , you deserved it .

Very interesting. I really enjoy it. Thanks

Nice to see you Tamara, thats really great guitar. Toraja, Indonesia

Great to have you back! Wow, the Stephan Connor is amazing, fantastic! The rest are also very nice!

I live by Manzanita. It's lovely out here.

I really enjoy the natural and more intimate sound of Stefan Nitchke and Mario Gropp, may not be suitable for concert guitarist but they are perfect for personal enjoyment. Connor and Perry are great as usual. ❤

Perry Concert 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍!!!

What a nice person Tamara is, and her guitar is singing, just beautiful. Connor guitar couldn’t do the same, it was a nice comparison.

Lovely guitar by Tamara Stahl it sounds like it will develop it's sound to be a very beautiful sweet but bright concert guitar. I really like it myself.

The Jellinghaus made in China Torres FE17 sounded like a really fun guitar, beautiful Bass too. I liked Perry's guitar, and also Stahl's guitar. That Stahl: she's a sweetie. I talked to her on the phone years ago when she still worked for Siccas and she was exceptionally polite and helpful. This is the second or third guitar I hear from her, they all sound very nice. Connor is loud and beautiful? Loud, totally. Beautiful, not so much. Camps? Ehh not at all my thing. It's probably nobodies thing. Jellinghaus or Altamira are both better for similar money. Gropp, very nice intonation. Nitschke gets it. He knows how a beautiful guitar should sound. Nitschke easily takes first. Perry, Jellinghaus and Tam Stahl share a close second with their lovely guitars. Siccas steals the whole KZread show with yet another excellent weekly guitar session.

That vibrato he does at 12:48 is amazing!! Never heard it done like that before the guitar literally sounds fretless !

I am using the Knobloch strings (several types) and love them all ;-) ... worth the price a they keep longer the nice tone!

Hi Tamara I am sliim and have Brazilian back and sides love u❤

私は話している事はなんとなーくしか勿論分かりません。それよりも、ほとんど話している意味は分からないです。でも、私は音楽の音色を聞いてます!! 良い音だと思います!!✨

Everything is great, thanks for the service, BUT, can the host learn new pieces??? Schubert is tired since last year already :) Tamara is such a fine lady!

I need mere information about the strings that Siccasguitars uses. I am eager to try it. How to purchase?

Have to agree with your comments about Knobloch strings. My Picado guitar came with Knobloch carbon CX 500 strings and sounded wonderful. Since then, I've experimented with various brands and types, and none of them come close to the sound it produces with Knobloch Carbons.

@SiccasGuitars

9 ай бұрын

That‘s what I mean!

Does anyone have the specific tensions per string of the knoblochs? I'd like to try them but only if the bass strings doesn't have a higher tension than the savarez Crystal Corum basses.

@niceguitar6144

9 ай бұрын

You should also strongly consider the precise thickness of each string, and whether the bass strings are wound clockwise, or counterclockwise, it affects the sound and playability greatly hahahahaha

Tamara Stahl and Mario Gropp give the best sound for me. Btw, you should give infos about the bracing and the structure of the guitar : traditionnal, double top, lattice (carbon or not) ..... . You do it for some guitars, but not always. It's a very important info, yet. In your videos as on your site, where this info isn't even displayed.

The first three guitars illustrate the sound I really like when played in the vicinity of the 12th fret. For me, this is a quality I would want and expect in a very high build. The only problem I have is that it is very hard to define in terms that I could explain to someone else and expect them to agree with clear understanding and concurrence. Tamera Stahl's build was super nice! Her creative skills and ideas should carry her a long way. I am looking forward to seeing and hearing what she produces next. The Gropp looked like it had a split saddle. Could you cover the advantage of that extra effort the next time an instrument shows up similarly set-up?

@SiccasGuitars

9 ай бұрын

We will get a touch on that if we are showcasing a smililar guitar.

To answer what is undoubtedly the top question on everyone's mind: mahogany (English) = Mahagoni (German). Interesting that the vowels move around like that.

I liked the last guitar best due to its beautiful, clear, and long sustaining treble stings. It has the kind of open sound I prefer, as it produces a lively, dynamic, and lyrical sound. I don't particularly care for the "old guitar" look. Most of the other guitars had treble strings that sounded very smooth, but to the point that they sounded lifeless, and more like a Harp than a Guitar. All the guitars are obviously good, and in different hands each will respond differently and be more suitable to that players style.

What was the name of brand of the strings you spoke of in the start of the video?

@SiccasGuitars

9 ай бұрын

Knobloch Strings!

high tension strings?

Do you know some good ecuatorian guitars luthier?

Name of the piece he plays at 23:17?

@slpatterns

9 ай бұрын

Schubert's Standchen

Wieso unterhaltet Ihr Euch nicht einfach mal auf deutsch wenn sich doch beide Gesprächspartner auf English etwas schwer tun? Es gibt ja auch Untertitel 🙂

You shouldve walked the streets of San Francisco and Oakland then tell us about how beautiful Cali is 😂

@niceguitar6144

9 ай бұрын

Good job brother, you tell them, and I agree totally

@Manetjo

9 ай бұрын

Well brother I hate to tell ya but Manzanita is a costal city in Oregon… you see the pacific coast runs along several states. But I am sure you can learn that on youtube

@niceguitar6144

9 ай бұрын

@@Manetjo hey, there's also Manzanita in CA, San Diego county. Jouyan didn't say which state he was visiting but it could've been CA and not OR. Maybe you should do your own consulting with youtube

@Manetjo

9 ай бұрын

Well actually I did do my research and you are correct there is manzanita in California, technically it’s an un-incorporated area .. and though he didn’t say what state he was in he did say it was coastal, and manzanita, California is not a coastal town .. Manzanita , Oregon is a coastal town.. anyway my original point still stands.

@niceguitar6144

9 ай бұрын

@@Manetjo touche

Can you please let me know why you never ever give us listeners a prize tag in your presentations? These guitars do of course all sound incredibly impressive but without the most relevant information the instruments are all of no interest for me since I have to consider them non affordable.

@Navportxl

4 ай бұрын

The luthiers price is always rising ,not only with inflation ( cost of obtaining CITES wood included) but also with their abilities to produce a better guitar and the recognition from the guitar community. May not be in the best interest of a luthier that is in the process of a price hike. Also Julian is doing the luthier a favour by directing the viewers to their guitar web site

@detlefh.7090

4 ай бұрын

@@Navportxl Thanks for your reply. Of course prizes are always going up for what ever you are trying to achieve but giving a range is not too much to ask for isn't it?

The Tamara’s does not sound so nice through the video… certainly better in real since it sounds very reedy for me.

The tone color variation of Stahl‘s guitar is not that good. But the luthier herself is nice.

@niceguitar6144

9 ай бұрын

The tone variation? The professorial type of guitarists that are familiar with every string measurement, or the smallest guitar nuance are just insufferable. Her guitar is fine.

@markcritchley9663

9 ай бұрын

@@niceguitar6144 It sounded good and so did the Camps for that matter

@niceguitar6144

9 ай бұрын

@@markcritchley9663 what sounded good, the Connor? I'm glad you like it. What else, the Camps? It sounded good to you? Fine, whatever floats your boat.

@bka24141

9 ай бұрын

@@niceguitar6144tone color variation, i mean