Scientists are getting uncomfortable with this theory: Dark forest

Тәжірибелік нұсқаулар және стиль

Join us as we dive into the controversial theory that has scientists feeling uneasy: the Dark Forest theory. Is the universe truly a dangerous place? Watch to find out more about this intriguing concept.
In a universe teeming with mysteries, "Bright Side Series" embarks on a cosmic journey to unravel one of the most unsettling theories that has both scientists and space enthusiasts on edge. 🌌👽 In our latest episode, "Scientists are getting uncomfortable with this theory: Dark Forest," we delve into the enigmatic realms of extraterrestrial life, ancient aliens, and the perplexing Fermi paradox. 🛸💫 Featuring insights from renowned physicists Michio Kaku and Brian Cox, alongside the cutting-edge observations from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), this video is a must-watch for anyone fascinated by the possibility of alien civilizations and the implications of artificial general intelligence (AGI) in our quest to understand the cosmos. 🌠🔭 Join us as we explore the latest space news, science news, and the intriguing concept of aliens AI, guided by the expertise of Neil deGrasse Tyson. Whether you're a fan of SpaceX, Elon Musk's visionary projects, or simply captivated by the mysteries of the universe, this space documentary promises to enlighten and entertain. 🚀🌍 Don't miss out on this journey through the dark forest theory, where the search for extraterrestrial life takes us beyond the stars. Subscribe to "Bright Side Series" for more episodes that shine a light on the bright side of space exploration and the endless possibilities that await. 🌟✨
Thanks for watching!
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Subscribe to the Bright Side Series channel:
/ @brightside_series
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Our Social Media:
Facebook: / bright.side.universe.o...
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
OTHER LANGUAGES:
Italian: / @illatopositivolaserie
Polish: / @jasnastronaseria
French: / @sympaseries
German: / @sonnenseiteserie
Spanish: / @genialserie
Indonesian: / @serialsisiterang
Portuguese: / @seriesdoincrivel
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Stock materials (photos, footages and other):
www.depositphotos.com
www.shutterstock.com
www.eastnews.ru
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Animation is created by Bright Side.

Пікірлер: 183

  • @idealchanful
    @idealchanfulАй бұрын

    Living in fear and paranoya is ok... But I use to live far away in wild woods, dark forest. I feel safer there than in a random city. Monsters seem to exist only in humanity

  • @zeke9123

    @zeke9123

    Ай бұрын

    Agreed. Especially given the status of our cities today.

  • @dazwol9104

    @dazwol9104

    Ай бұрын

    That's because as the apex species on earth the dark woods for a human IS the city's

  • @AKmumu

    @AKmumu

    Ай бұрын

    I would feel safe until I see or hear someone lurks around the house in the middle of nowhere, far away from any help

  • @Kn1ghtborne

    @Kn1ghtborne

    Ай бұрын

    Until we stumble upon our natural predator

  • @ivanschekoldin7315

    @ivanschekoldin7315

    Ай бұрын

    You should define a monster first. Humans are just the most sophisticated monsters we know but humans, unlike say, animals are wired to mean well. Most of us at least. Any predator on the other hand will happily munch you without a second thought.

  • @arty2k
    @arty2kАй бұрын

    AI voice is terrible.

  • @FarmHandz-cx4rn
    @FarmHandz-cx4rnАй бұрын

    They probably see what we do to ourselves and want absolutely no contact with us.

  • @TheGregwilliams70

    @TheGregwilliams70

    Ай бұрын

    😂

  • @rayholmes4402

    @rayholmes4402

    Ай бұрын

    .. or they are also to busy fighting and killing each other too! 😂

  • @subspace666

    @subspace666

    Ай бұрын

    assuming they consider us intelligent at all , its debatable lol, maybe they just don't care at all. kinda like we don't care about some ants killing some others.

  • @origintrackz5235

    @origintrackz5235

    17 күн бұрын

    ​@@rayholmes4402Exactly 😂

  • @kenfryer2090

    @kenfryer2090

    11 күн бұрын

    What do we do that animals don't? We just do what is natural for apes

  • @FinGeek4now
    @FinGeek4nowАй бұрын

    The main issue I have with the Drake equation and Fermi Paradox is the distances involved, not too mention we haven't been listening or watching for other civilizations all that long in a cosmic timeframe. It is more highly likely that the signals (including light) hasn't either reached us yet or has passed by long ago. Also likely is the fact that if a civilization is sending signals, we either cannot interpret them and/or we don't even know what we should be looking for.

  • @Mathan_6_95

    @Mathan_6_95

    Ай бұрын

    Not only that, the types of signals we *are* looking for don't travel that far through space.

  • @mariovillarreal8647

    @mariovillarreal8647

    Ай бұрын

    They do not measure distance traveled in time or miles. I think...

  • @FinGeek4now

    @FinGeek4now

    Ай бұрын

    @@mariovillarreal8647 distance travelled in time is a base function of anything dealing in the cosmos, miles though? More like AU. Even the 10 closest, which average at around 15 AU away, would take 15 years for any sign of life to reach us. If we disregard actually seeing their civilization and look at tech signatures, how much has ours changed in the past 15 years? For a broader sample range, we're looking at what, and average of at least 1,000 AU? If not higher? That's a looooong time, for us and them. They wouldn't see our tech signature or see the lights on our planet or anything for another 1,000 from now, likewise, 1,000 years ago, they didn't have tech (which is what we'd be seeing today). Now, those are just distances, not even mentioning cosmic timeframes. Perhaps Cent Prox B did have life? A million, tens of millions, of years ago. Further and older solar systems and galaxies, then the time span goes back billions of years.

  • @mariovillarreal8647

    @mariovillarreal8647

    Ай бұрын

    @@FinGeek4now portals thru time, interdimensionally also.

  • @quatamassshu33

    @quatamassshu33

    27 күн бұрын

    We're infants

  • @ast-og-losta
    @ast-og-lostaАй бұрын

    Man, they were here back in the 70's. I saw them at a Yoko Ono concert. They gave me the stink eye and left.

  • @anabelapedro1960

    @anabelapedro1960

    29 күн бұрын

    😊 nice

  • @origintrackz5235

    @origintrackz5235

    17 күн бұрын

    😂😂

  • @Vibhusaini27
    @Vibhusaini27Ай бұрын

    Stop using background music that so annoying

  • @damnft8218

    @damnft8218

    Ай бұрын

    You got ADHD or what?

  • @enguidmiggi

    @enguidmiggi

    Ай бұрын

    I disagree its perfect to fall asleep

  • @Ryan-eu3kp

    @Ryan-eu3kp

    Ай бұрын

    How about no.

  • @jefffalco587

    @jefffalco587

    Ай бұрын

    There talking 200 billion stars. You need music

  • @teknacious

    @teknacious

    Ай бұрын

    Disagree

  • @FreakyLynx
    @FreakyLynxАй бұрын

    The Drake Equation is an optimistic guess, the Fermi Paradox isn’t a paradox because we have nothing to base it on other than guessing. We haven’t even mapped our whole planet an we think we searched for signals enough to make any conclusions? We aren’t even a spacefaring civilization so we have no idea what’s involved other than in fiction.

  • @joshuawest3257

    @joshuawest3257

    Ай бұрын

    Which is what Lao Tzu, Frederick Nietzsche, and Sylvia Plath have in common!

  • @amelliamendel2227

    @amelliamendel2227

    Ай бұрын

    Not to mention out of all of the billions species that existed on Earth we have exactly one example of intelligence being selected for over camouflage, armor, ect. Natural selection doesn't care about algebra. There's no reason to believe that intelligence is inevitable. Also, it took The Earth 4.5 billion years to produce a quasi-space-faring species, with 2.5 billion years remaining if the human species fails to leave a solar system there will not be enough time for another species to make it off the planet...

  • @origintrackz5235

    @origintrackz5235

    17 күн бұрын

    We can only base our opinion off of what we know I guess...

  • @joshuawest3257
    @joshuawest3257Ай бұрын

    Isn't that just as well as the Fermi Paradox? I mean if two guys invented the same thing that it would be named after both of them.

  • @DaddyODadio
    @DaddyODadio23 күн бұрын

    What if the wow signal was a cosmic 'shush' and we actually doubled our efforts to tell everyone where we are.

  • @meh3277
    @meh327722 күн бұрын

    7:50 for reference most of that range is useless since only minor galaxies exist beyond the 100k LY diameter of the milky way and Earth is often described as being in the Central-South region of the galaxy from our Core ward perspective.

  • @Abioticwinter
    @AbioticwinterАй бұрын

    This is old. There are endless sci-fi stories on this. Then robots/ai taking over.

  • @smokejaguar67
    @smokejaguar67Ай бұрын

    I think they were always aware of us.

  • @baronvg
    @baronvgАй бұрын

    Oh man, the AI voice is butchering some common words 😂

  • @a.e.rivera-weaver8175
    @a.e.rivera-weaver8175Ай бұрын

    Uhm, question here, at 36:50 you say, "at unimaginable speed" do you mean faster than the speed of light? According to physics, there is no more imaginable speed than that. Am I mistaken?

  • @enjoyedbugle9416
    @enjoyedbugle9416Ай бұрын

    hi id like to say i enjoyed yor video very much thank you for the information

  • @JoelRaymond-lw2fk
    @JoelRaymond-lw2fkАй бұрын

    How could we possibly know how big space is? And if it gets bigger then it would have to have somewhere to go, so it would already be bigger than what it is... Infinity has and always will be never ending

  • @socialmeaslesinpartnership1252

    @socialmeaslesinpartnership1252

    Ай бұрын

    Then it become so big that the speed of light can't cross it (already the case). You are clever!

  • @Medic99z

    @Medic99z

    Ай бұрын

    Well, we can see space expanding which means we can trace it backwards. What's outside of that could very well be nothing and asking "what's out there?" could be as pointless as asking "what's south of the south pole?" There is no "out there" Since there is no space there is no there to begin with

  • @Gamesackfan-bn6eg
    @Gamesackfan-bn6egАй бұрын

    He sounds like the G1 gransformers narator. So awesome.

  • @bighomieScoobs

    @bighomieScoobs

    25 күн бұрын

    Gransformer? What's the exactly lol??

  • @jaswindersinghsraa9435
    @jaswindersinghsraa9435Ай бұрын

    some existed in past , some exist now ,, with vast distances in between ,, its best to enjoy life on ones planet ,,, instead of wasting time to investigation of someone living maybe 100 light years away

  • @amelliamendel2227
    @amelliamendel2227Ай бұрын

    Yeah, we have 0 examples of any species that doesn't exploit all available resources.

  • @davidsingh9950
    @davidsingh995021 күн бұрын

    Like the video, but it doesn't even mention the "Dark Forest" theory like the title says it's about.

  • @bradpitts289
    @bradpitts289Ай бұрын

    If we could get a James Webb Telescope out as far or farther than Voyager 1 or 2 we could see further out start sending some to deep space

  • @FuccYew
    @FuccYewАй бұрын

    Saying that we haven’t contacted any of these civilizations is wrong.

  • @skiceman9611
    @skiceman9611Ай бұрын

    The Dark forest theory is not really plausible. The curiosity of species is a lot more powerful than fear. Humanity has been sending signals for decades, regardless of what we may find or who might hear us. It is highly probable that intelligent life on other planets would do the same.

  • @dananorth895

    @dananorth895

    Ай бұрын

    Oh sure just go imposing your ignorance, superstitions, delusions on others And the universe too! What could possibly go wrong? All it takes is ONE preditor species!

  • @joonsiu_
    @joonsiu_Ай бұрын

    Halfway thru the clip and there is ZERO mention of the Dark Forrest theory.

  • @KamikazeCash

    @KamikazeCash

    Ай бұрын

    Most of this video is AI-generated voice and script. Unfortunately this is the future of KZread.

  • @diamondbladexl2064

    @diamondbladexl2064

    Ай бұрын

    Didn’t listen to the first 2 minutes? 1:55

  • @Gamesackfan-bn6eg
    @Gamesackfan-bn6egАй бұрын

    What if, we are the first intelligent life. Like it took this long for life to happen.

  • @jamartin005

    @jamartin005

    Ай бұрын

    Slim chance lol

  • @SilverSin

    @SilverSin

    Ай бұрын

    That in itself is a terrifying thought.

  • @SilverSin

    @SilverSin

    Ай бұрын

    But at the same time, there are systems out there way older than ours.

  • @clemonsjovan

    @clemonsjovan

    Ай бұрын

    That isn’t possible, the age of the universe says planets like ours lived and died long before our sun was even born, universe is about 10-11 billion years older then our sun…..the Fermi paradox doesn’t just state because universe is so big there has to be life, it states because it’s so big and old, life should of had millions of years to advance to states far beyond ours….aka space faring races, so where are they?

  • @ChrisBrown-fx6ts

    @ChrisBrown-fx6ts

    Ай бұрын

    Not likely billions of other galaxies, it's just too far to get to.like a knit trying to fly around the world

  • @leonardmead1425
    @leonardmead1425Ай бұрын

    That's why amoua..... I can't remember the name lol... But that big long thing ( I call it the Floater) that tumbled by our planet not long ago. It is interesting that something like that appeared at this time, when we face so many impending problems

  • @bigmazem3

    @bigmazem3

    Ай бұрын

    Oumouamoa

  • @leonardmead1425

    @leonardmead1425

    Ай бұрын

    @@bigmazem3 the very chap

  • @davidsisk1768
    @davidsisk1768Ай бұрын

    My opinion we are the first of many it is still a young universe in the Cosmos can't wait to see what happens in the next 20 years let alone what happens nah lifetime of a universe

  • @robertthompson5858
    @robertthompson5858Ай бұрын

    Please get a human to read your script

  • @stevenbliss989
    @stevenbliss989Ай бұрын

    ***** UTTER CLICKBAIT!!!!! ***** First 3 milliseconds are about the title!

  • @lancelowery4027
    @lancelowery4027Ай бұрын

    We are alone. Life is probably everywhere just not intelligent. We ourselves are very lucky to exist at all. One meteor strike or slightly different oxygen levels or no moon and earth is probably void of life.

  • @c4lyoutube968
    @c4lyoutube96825 күн бұрын

    What about the drake leak equation???

  • @pacific7775
    @pacific7775Ай бұрын

    We have only been looking for around 100 yrs..and we are surprised we have not found life ? That's ridiculous in the grand scheme of things ...we shouldn't expect to find life for a long long time ...to think it's not mouth there seems very close minded and unrealistic

  • @Djjoeyd1167
    @Djjoeyd1167Ай бұрын

    The sky is hardly silent,not sure where you’ve been the last few years.. just saying

  • @brianrose21
    @brianrose21Ай бұрын

    IMO Dark Forest Theory is not all that compelling, if they can strike us after the short blip when we've been broadcasting then they're already here ✌️ this is a really great video though 👍

  • @criticality2056

    @criticality2056

    Ай бұрын

    Why bother though?

  • @ChristopherLecky
    @ChristopherLeckyАй бұрын

    There are forms of knowledge that doesn't have any potential unless its known by the majority as an awakening to truth within everyone is the stimuli necessary for a spontaneous self organising system to emerge,,,,, Sometimes keeping quiet is the worst thing that could occur,,,,,,,!

  • @johntalmid1563
    @johntalmid1563Ай бұрын

    Truth is we're not the first intelligent life, we're the most recently created and all eyes are on us for some reason 😅

  • @bigrick3267

    @bigrick3267

    Ай бұрын

    Maybe or for all you know we might be all there ever was or will be, we don't actually know

  • @criticality2056

    @criticality2056

    Ай бұрын

    Uh, what?

  • @KarloBrna
    @KarloBrnaАй бұрын

    Scientists are assuming that other live forms perceive photons in the same way as our human bodies do and this is the greatest mistake and a reason why we cannot find any evidence of their movement. What gravitational waves? Ripples? You're speaking in human physics. They probably perceive the universe through different laws and atoms and photons probably mean something different to them. Dark matter is the answer.

  • @ricf9592
    @ricf9592Ай бұрын

    The number and variety of variables which led to our own existence makes replication based on mere (Drake) numbers, a nonsense.

  • @ChristopherFalletta-rh9jf
    @ChristopherFalletta-rh9jfАй бұрын

    This guy must not realize how far the nearest solar system is

  • @frankmccann29
    @frankmccann2910 күн бұрын

    A starship much smaller, going faster than one tenth C isn't a starship by definition. A real starship much much smaller than a planet would certainly give much bigger signature. It's a matter of aiming the thing. When I hear dark matter I change the channel. I think we're through that already are we not?

  • @jeffreythomas2711
    @jeffreythomas2711Ай бұрын

    Where are they coming up with these figures.?? They never say anything concerning (Electrons) witch is the structure of all substance. Electrons determine how atoms are formed. Bonding Protons and electrons and some times Neutrons together to create matter. All life forms are created in equal parts of matter that are similar to their planet body where they are spawned from. This also includes the frequency of their magnetic field with in their own quantum resonance vibration in the HRTZ range. Their bodies would be tuned to the same planet frequency and they would not survive long if they moved away from it. The same is true for us here on Earth.

  • @maartenneppelenbroek

    @maartenneppelenbroek

    Ай бұрын

    Where did you get this information? Seems lacking.

  • @criticality2056

    @criticality2056

    Ай бұрын

    How do electrons determine how atoms are formed? What about atoms without electrons?

  • @jayperie2337
    @jayperie2337Ай бұрын

    This video is all over the place and the music is annoying.

  • @Spliffie37
    @Spliffie3716 күн бұрын

    The answer of space size is beyond our comprehension thats the right answer

  • @aramaxes4802
    @aramaxes4802Ай бұрын

    The survival of the fittest theory do not apply on the universal scale. If life is so rare it is therefore precious. Intergalactic visitors would be aware of the immense value of life biodiversity.

  • @matthewhummel1572
    @matthewhummel157216 күн бұрын

    Please just read it yourself next time, and cut back on the music. As far as the age of the universe, the timeline is assuming we are in the center of it.

  • @TheLaReece
    @TheLaReeceАй бұрын

    Hold up.... Bio Dome was real???

  • @JimWoolston-cj9nu
    @JimWoolston-cj9nuАй бұрын

    I love the background music 💯

  • @poolman20001
    @poolman20001Ай бұрын

    At 44:00 you are talking about different things happening and the universe's Branch off and create new ones. This is not a real theory at all. It can never work like that it's not magic. Quantum mechanics simply is stating that, in a multi-bubble universe that expands into Infinity means that all the atoms in the universe will be aligned in randomness within each universe. But since there is an infinite number of universes, there must be other universes who's atoms alines exactly like ours. And of course universes that are almost exactly like ours. You know what I mean? it's like if you have a thousand marbles in a bucket and you're on an indoor basketball court. Then you take the bucket of marbles and you throw them on the floor. The way the marbles align themselves on the floor seems unique. So you could throw that bucket down a few million times and not have the same outcome. The marbles will always align themselves differently. However. If you have unlimited time and unlimited amount of times that you can dump this bucket of marbles under the floor. Eventually, those marbles come out exactly the same as some other times that you spilled them out. That's exactly what the multi universe means. That's all.

  • @deerazor8280
    @deerazor828010 күн бұрын

    LEGO 🛸

  • @Arcticstar69
    @Arcticstar69Ай бұрын

    Be quiet, kids. Do you know what integrity is?

  • @pablodaproducer8507
    @pablodaproducer8507Ай бұрын

    200 billion stars and only 100 billion planets.. u hearing yourself fam..

  • @TheCaptainAizen
    @TheCaptainAizen16 күн бұрын

    what's app? huh

  • @criticality2056
    @criticality2056Ай бұрын

    The logic of the conclusions are poor

  • @KristinWilliams-ub9nu
    @KristinWilliams-ub9nuАй бұрын

    To late!

  • @Lord_Shadowz
    @Lord_ShadowzАй бұрын

    The USA will show the forest why we don’t have universal healthcare!

  • @flix1179
    @flix1179Ай бұрын

    all tomorrow

  • @deebusoh9023
    @deebusoh9023Ай бұрын

    i love dark forest.

  • @halburd1
    @halburd1Ай бұрын

    the answer they seek is in the bible. but no no no don't ever consider that. "thinking they were wise they became fools"

  • @ChristopherB.-kc2xu
    @ChristopherB.-kc2xu9 күн бұрын

    😊 okay but why would it have to be so big LOL

  • @edpiv2233
    @edpiv2233Ай бұрын

    Very well produced.

  • @Jesusisblak
    @Jesusisblak11 күн бұрын

    😢

  • @Ellemaggie
    @EllemaggieАй бұрын

    beam me up scotty 😆

  • @U__PPa
    @U__PPaАй бұрын

    how easy is it to make one of these AI videos i wanna make money too

  • @robotaholic
    @robotaholic29 күн бұрын

    Nope ✋️ knott until u tawk bee ee ee ee ter

  • @adamstalilonis8787
    @adamstalilonis878719 күн бұрын

    AI reeding iz even worse!

  • @bradpitts289
    @bradpitts289Ай бұрын

    Maybe we are not the original version of ourselves but only a reflection or Memorex

  • @charless1145
    @charless114529 күн бұрын

    Why use AI voices?! Super obnoxious

  • @JAYDELROSARIQ
    @JAYDELROSARIQАй бұрын

    ÑÜILJV Y ÑLIJYQRrÜ ÑÜIRQX Y AZ BE YF MB HN WB IK

  • @ViceCoin
    @ViceCoin8 күн бұрын

    They left, after visiting Gaza.

  • @TraciPeteyforlife
    @TraciPeteyforlifeАй бұрын

    This was a moronic idea.

  • @Neobert5240
    @Neobert5240Ай бұрын

    95% true 5% false,,,plausible deniabilaty

  • @YC-mb1jl
    @YC-mb1jlАй бұрын

    Im getting tired of KZread pushing this Ai garbage

  • @2019inuyasha
    @2019inuyashaАй бұрын

    10 minutes ago first

  • @Grim-Crusader
    @Grim-CrusaderАй бұрын

    I can't watch for long, the AI generated voices insist on mispronouncing simple words...

  • @Jason-xf3ym

    @Jason-xf3ym

    2 күн бұрын

    I get it. But it should be spelled a-n-s-e-r.

  • @Allfaxnocaps
    @AllfaxnocapsАй бұрын

    The wierd ask sound effects they are adding make these videos so stew pid. If I spell it out I’ll get fined

  • @anthonyensley7200
    @anthonyensley7200Ай бұрын

    3rd

  • @JAYDELROSARIQ
    @JAYDELROSARIQАй бұрын

    FHlAMEVI RJQL IXKANYZ

  • @DemetriusAnchondo-hn5gd
    @DemetriusAnchondo-hn5gdАй бұрын

    🫥

  • @stevendavies8496
    @stevendavies8496Ай бұрын

    The man from turid ,,,,,it's from a book ,,,never been real,,,,,,,do some research,,if you can't get something so simple as this right,,,how can anyone believe anything else you say un subing

  • @Laradox...
    @Laradox...Ай бұрын

    First

  • @HNY_YT

    @HNY_YT

    Ай бұрын

    Don’t care

  • @Laradox...

    @Laradox...

    Ай бұрын

    @@HNY_YT same lol

  • @ericb2017

    @ericb2017

    Ай бұрын

    first to be loser l o l

  • @apocalypsator6
    @apocalypsator6Ай бұрын

    Cosmic whack-a-mole.

  • @ionzmarda2648
    @ionzmarda2648Ай бұрын

    JWST doesn't orbit the sun 😂😂

  • @magnetmountain33
    @magnetmountain3314 күн бұрын

    It’s flat give it a break

  • @HNIN1973
    @HNIN197313 күн бұрын

    This theory is old af, you're way late foo

  • @mondaview5565
    @mondaview5565Ай бұрын

    We don't want to meet these things you lot NASA STARTED ALL THIS

  • @andrewbako9494
    @andrewbako949420 күн бұрын

    If you're going to make a documentary about science at least know how to pronounce basic terminology correct...it's "lie-go" not "lee-go"

  • @jakebob6332
    @jakebob633212 күн бұрын

    You are way WAY off on the number of planets. 200 billion stars and only 100 billion planets. Given your numbers, half the stars have no planets and the other half have only one planet.

  • @donvancu
    @donvancuАй бұрын

    dont worry..they know us for so long...but we are not ready for the galaxy..monkeys with atomic sticks...

  • @zijadinsinani
    @zijadinsinaniАй бұрын

    besoj. te mos gabojn

Келесі