सरस्वती नदी हिमालय से निकली थी उसके विलोप का कारण हिमालय ही था भूगर्भ मे परिवर्तन से ऐसा परिवर्तन हुआ होगा .

भारतीय संस्कृति ही सबको जोड़ती है

भारत, कुरु आदि के लिए सरस्वती पूजनीय थी । इक्षवाकू के लिए सरयू काशी के लिए गँगा । यही भारत की एकता थीं ।

Sangam Talks k yogdan ko Shat shat Naman!🙏🏻🙏🏻

सरस्वती नदी की शोधपरक प्रस्तुति हेतु साधुवाद।

Thanks sir very informative

सान्याल जी को सुनने का मौका मिला काफी दिन के बाद। हमेशा की तरह एक अति उत्तम व्याख्यान के साथ। धन्यवाद 🙏

सरस्वती आज भी बड़ी नदी के रुप में बह रही हैं।और आज भी उसका धार्मिक महत्त्व है।बस जगह ओर नाम बदल गया है।डाॅ॰ प्रद्युम्न द्विवेदी।

आपका बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद जय श्री राम.

जय हिंद जय भारत।

🕉🕉🕉🙏🙏🙏dhanywaad for very important information.🕉🙏

जबरदस्त ज्ञान🙏🙏

बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद

वामपंथ पे निर्भर नाही राहणा हैं, है कोन वो ?

Achchi jaankari Dee hai sir aapne

आप जैसे ज्ञ्यानी भारतीय को मेरा नमन

ध्रुव तारे की खोज राजकुमार धूत ने की थी जिसका समय लगभग 20000 वर्ष पूर्व बनाया जाता है

Thank you so much Sanjeev Ji!

अति उत्तम।

4:24 most important point!

It wonderful sir 👍

fantastic video by my favourite Sanjeev Sanyal ji , he is so interesting to listen to

I come to know many new things about Bharat, thank you Sir.

Well researched fact.

Fascinating should be a part of school, college studies

Great & easiest way to understand civilization of Bhart. your video.🙏🙏

🙏 जय श्रीराम !

Around 20000 BC was Last Glacial maximum and climate became very cold and there was very little Glacial water in the river, thereafter around 9000 BC there was was catastrophic event called Younger Drias and climate of the whole world became wormer. Therefore there was much more Glacial water in the river Saraswati and it flows with force and full water. How ever I differ with your opinion that Rigved was composed during 4500 BC or so. It is much more older than that.

@gopalkrishan3498

3 жыл бұрын

Ramayana period was 5000 BC and there is reference of Vedas in Ramayana text ,so time of Rigveda text is between 8-9 thousand years ago.

@avm1662

2 жыл бұрын

@@gopalkrishan3498 kzread.info/dash/bejne/epWVxqyKipTXqMo.html in gapodi ko naa sune saccha itihas isa video me dekhe

@bharat7917

Жыл бұрын

You have certainly not heard of Nilesh Oak or his books / talks.

@mikedesi5513

Жыл бұрын

Rigwed was composed by saraswats people who lived on saraswati river and ate river fish around 5000 //7000 years ago during early -harappan phase and had no relationship to Ramayana when the river flow was strongest this matches with archeological and historical evidence

Thanks

सत्यमेव जयते

Loved it!. What an informative session!. It is always a pleasure to read Sanjeev's books and listen to his talks. Could you please also give the reference of the Rigvedic commentary in Hindi that he used in the presentation? Thank you Sangam talks!

31.02 Rigved 4500 या 9000 BCE से पहले. 👌 Sarasvati के flow पर research के अनुसार । 9000 BCE से पहले पुरानी ऋग्वेद की पुस्तके होंगी । 9000 BCE के बाद नयी पुस्तके और पुरानी का उन मे संकलन 10 राजन - सुदास युद्ध के बाद । फिर महाभारत काल मे कृष्ण वेद व्यास द्वारा 4 वेद का संकलन / लेखन ।

If you visit Mount Abu in Rajasthan there is a place called Saraswati river ka udgam sthan .

कानचनाक्षी शायद कांतली नदी हो जिसके किनारे पर खेतड़ी माइन्स और गणेश्वर साईट

good to hear from sajneev ji after long time, that too in Hindi . rest he is always amazing & informative.

श्रीकांत तलागेरी जी ने भी भाषा का अध्ययन कर के यही कहा ऋग्वेद की पुरानी पुस्तक का लेना भारत, पुरु, कुरु के दृष्टिकोण से आर्यव्रत के अन्य क्षेत्रों के बारे मे है. बाद की पुस्तकों मे पूरे भारत वर्ष का ज़िक्र है

👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

Aap jaise logo ko is vishy pr tezi se kaam krna chahiye taki bharat k itihaas ki shi jaankari ho ske....

Jago hindu jago

The fluctuation of the status of Saraswati and it's scientifically established timeline,is a great and authentic determinent of Veda/Mahabharat/ Harappan chronology broadly. Cause facts don't lie.

आपने जो वेदमंत्रों का अर्थ संदर्व दिया है यह ग़लत है।

Logical and factual content

Sanjeev has established an epoch making truth and discovery by truely identifying SaptSindhu,. The assimilation process post dash Rajan yudh into the new encompassing Bhaarti philosophy, the original sulah kul ,as the basis of Vedic social fabric and the guiding mantra of Indian cultural Ethos since then, has been correctly stated finally by someone. Kudos SS great thinking Ground breaking. God Bless.

काफी दिनों बाद 👌

I hope sanyalji and Nilesh oakji get together to sync-up the great history of bharat to be finalised so to teach to our children's in school

It's very good to see sanjeev sir very time I have purchased his 2 books that are awesome🙏🙏🙏

Saraswati dwellers were called Saraswat who were fish eating aryans who migrated to bengal and west coast of India and still love fish

i can listen to this guy speak history all day long. guess when he will get to be in charge of our economy

@ramanvegda3232

3 жыл бұрын

Mera video dekle Bhai

Sarasvati itself never had a glacial origin, and came down from the lower Himalayas (the Shivaliks). Sutlej & Yamuna (that were once tributaries of Saraswati) had (and still have) a glacial origin. Even after Yamuna had completely diverted away from Saraswati & Sutlej had turned away from Saraswati (except for a channel or two in the lower reaches of Saraswati), the river Saraswati was still a perennial river due to intense monsoons in the 7000 - 4500 BCE period. Although it had stopped reaching the sea by about 10,000 years ago (ref. Paper by Nitesh Khonde in Nature magazine). After 4500 BCE, monsoons started declining which led to aridification of the area and Saraswati slowly started to go dry. This was a gradual process which culminated in the river going dry by ~1900 BCE (except for upper reaches seasonally and where a stream from Sutlej was meeting Saraswati). This confluence in the lower reaches of the river was where we find almost all the Later Harappan sites (1900-1300 BCE). This last confluence too dried up eventually and all that is left of the vedic Saraswati is a seasonal stream in the upper reaches which has water only during monsoons.

Very profound analysis has been presented.Such research works must be presented to the public.

💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝

Sanjeev Sanyal Ji ko mera koti koti pranam Yes you are right sir ji I proud of you sir ji aap bahut hi sundar aachha kariye kar rahe hai Aap ko mera koti koti naman hai 🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏🙏

Srijan Talks hi Sangam Talks hai. Subscribers kyu nahin badhte? Abhitak to minimum 10 Lakh ho Jana chahiye thaa. Kya KZread Admin. kuchh foul play kar Raha hai ?

श्रीमान जी ऋषि वशिष्ठ तो रामायण काल के हैं और गंगा नदी सरस्वती की धारा को मोड़ कर बनाई गई जो रामायण काल से पहले ही बन गई जिसे राजा सागर से लेकर भागीरथ तक बनाया गया

@dr.jawaharlsharma2644

2 жыл бұрын

No.Vasishth has been referred in Vedas.

यह नई theory है । सच है या नहीं आने वाला समय तय करेगा ।

Nice!

❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️👍

आप जितना मर्जी जोर लगा लो न ही वेद को समझ पाओगे और न ही आर्यों को विदेशी सिद्ध कर पाओगे।।

Sarsuti river as per local parlance in Haryana.

@4z4d

3 жыл бұрын

Even Sirsa town was called Sarasvati in mideval times even in Islamic accounts when they invaded and massacred sarasvati town. Ghaghar also till early british times named sarasvati in early British maps. Then colonial bias amd supreme race bias kicked in.

कमेंट में एक महानुभाव लगते तो बहुत बड़े इतिहासकार है लेकिन इन्हें शोध करने की जरूरत है आज कल व्हाट्सएप यूनिवर्सिटी से बहुत ही ज्यादा कॉपी पेस्ट चल रहा है

सरस्वती नदी गुजरात सिधधपुर से निकलती है ओर कच्छ के रण मै समा जाती है

🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

ऋग्वेद में आये हुए शब्दसमूह पदवाच्य को श्लोक नही मन्त्र अथवा ऋचा कहा जाता है ।

নদীতমা দেবীতমা সরস্বতী নদী।ঋকবেদ রামায়ণ মহাভারত এর ক্রনোলজির সঙ্গে এই পবিত্র নদীর ক্রমবিবর্তন কি অদ্ভুতভাবে যাচ্ছে---অবিশ্বাস্য।

वर्तमान काल मे इसकी विरल धारा बह रही है । उस स्थान को लोकेट किया जाए। आवश्यकता होने पर इंगित करने का प्रयास किया जाएगा ।

Modi k economic policy ka satyanash kisi ne agar kiya to bibek Debroy aur inka naam swarn aksharo me likha jaega, ye dono mahashay economy chod mythology me khoob adhyayan kiye

The theory of him much goes in the Aryan invasion theory way, which i don't believe.

@shivprasadjoshi5280

3 жыл бұрын

I don't believe in the Aryan invasion theory either. The Aryan invasion started between 1750-1870 and peaked till 2000, thereafter the studies of Indian gene started and after 2016 Sinauli horse chariot and bones found have proved the theory wrong. 250 years old and currently dead is a long life for a fake narrative along with the dravadian divide of India.....

@shubhampandey7534

3 жыл бұрын

@@shivprasadjoshi5280 That is what i am saying, i don't believe in Aryan invasion theory.

सरवस्ती नहीं, सरस्वती 🙏🏼

Sanjeeb jee pls read a book in bengali the book called Brahma Kamal by Kinnar Roy .it's also about all rivers of India including Saraswati .

HE IS RELATED TO SACHINDRA NATH SANYAL JI OF HINDUSTAN REPUBLICAN SOCIALIST ARMY 😊

Jal vayu parivartan aur satluj aur yamuna ka pashchim aur purva sarasvati se alag hone se paani kam hota gaya.

Please engage a Geologist in this regard. Make a document using a complete team not just by individuals.

@ashwaryp

3 жыл бұрын

You can watch Swadeshi Indology channel on KZread, they had involved research papers of Geologists while discussing about River Saraswati.

आपके तथ्य सही है लेकिन जब आप कांस्य युग बोलते हैं और ऋग्वेद भी तब समय काल की समानता नहीं दिखती, वशिष्ठ जी जो राम जी के समय के थे,उनका समय १३०००bc था,जब भरत जी कैकय से लौटे तो भी सरस्वती को पार किया , वाल्मीकि रामायण में है। ऋग्वेद का समयकाल १५०००bce से पहले का है,संकलन समय समय पर हुआ है।

Tabhi economy ka ye haal hai. Iska saara dhyaan yahi hai.. Saraswati kalpanik nadi hai grantho ki tarah, agar wo kahi hai to waha hai jahan haxarwati hai..

@RahulYadav-mq7zw

3 жыл бұрын

Tumhare jaise murkho ki zarurat nahi hai. Tajmahal ka agar saboot hai toh 10 sikh guru bhi honge. Toh tum tarkwadi Shahjahan ko history mante ho. Lekin guru govind singh ya tulsidas history nahi hai kya. Guru govind singh ko mythology nahi kaha ja sakta. Agar woh mythology nahi hai toh hamare granth bhi kalpna nahi ho sakte.

@nvspraneeth901

3 жыл бұрын

@@RahulYadav-mq7zw jitna bhi koshish kar lo brahmanwadi ko khush karne ka rahoge tum bhi shudr

@RahulYadav-mq7zw

3 жыл бұрын

@@nvspraneeth901 tumne grantho ko kalpna bataya. Maine jawab diya. Ram kalpnik hai. Guru govind singh kalpnik hai. Lekin Shah Jahan history hai. Yeh samasya atheist aur tarkwadio ki hai.

@nvspraneeth901

3 жыл бұрын

@@RahulYadav-mq7zw guru govind kalpanik ni hai

@wisevictor9751

Жыл бұрын

Halala Halala Spotted 😅

When you say RigVed was from Saraswati region and other areas had 'Granth' that are not available - we Need to be Careful - that some Western Scholar (as they publish quickly) does not Misrepresent it (they can say 'See we Said Aryan Invasion is True or something similar that northern destroyed southern culture - creating a split in our thinking)

Mahoday mahoday aapke Gyan Par Kisi Ko Sandesh Nahin Hai Lekin yadi aap apne bhasha

ऋग्वेद में कहा है कि सरस्वती के तीन उद्गम हैं, और यह सिंधु एवं सरयु के साथ 3 प्रमुख नदियों में है। तो 3 उद्गम और सरयू कहाँ हैं कृपया बताएं।

@dr.pradumndwivedi2171

2 жыл бұрын

सरस्वती का एक ही उद्गम है,और आज भी सरस्वती उसी उद्गम से बह रही है,पर धारा बदल गई है,जरा शोध-विश्लेषक और विद्वानों को सरकारी पैसा उड़ानें दो।डाॅ॰ प्रद्युम्न द्विवेदी।

@EkIshwar

2 жыл бұрын

@@dr.pradumndwivedi2171 The Rig Veda says that the Saraswati had a “threefold” source (6:61:12).

@dr.pradumndwivedi2171

2 жыл бұрын

@@EkIshwar एक सरस्वती और तीन और आज भी हैं।और निर्बाध रुप से बह रहे हैं सभी स्रोत।

@commonprophets

2 жыл бұрын

@@dr.pradumndwivedi2171 jahan hain 3 strot

@dr.pradumndwivedi2171

2 жыл бұрын

मेरी खोज पर डकैत डाका डाल कर अपना नाम कर लेते हैं।अनजान लोगों को डकैती डालने दो, क्योंकि?

Paper s. Taiyar rakho aur. Padho..,Before Presenting prepare well

Lagta hai ye sajjan time traveller hai 🤪

Study karo aur boli but

Sir please change ur shirt as it is selected by ur wife and doesnt look good on u

Fake

बकवास है युगाबाद विक्रम संवत कि बात करनी चाही ये जब पहलाद देव मन्दिर रो कियात्राके प्रमाण है सोमनाथ प्रभास क्षेत्र वर्णन आज का बीकानेर बाड़मेर सासोर कछ सेत्र है जय हिन्द

No. People of Rig Ved's time got pushed down times and again by later invaders. Now most of the clans of Ved's time are settled in eastern parts.