संवाद # 184: Reality of Kashi Vishwanath Corridor, Gyanvapi, Varanasi as Shiv Nagri, Jaggi Vasudev

Prof. Rana P.B. Singh, born on December 15, 1950, is an eminent scholar in the fields of cultural landscapes, heritage studies, and pilgrimage research. He holds an M.A. and Ph.D. from Banaras Hindu University (B.H.U.) and has received numerous accolades including the Fellowships in Japan, Italy, and Korea, and prestigious awards like 'Ganga Ratna' and ‘Koshal Ratna’ in India. Prof. Singh served as the Head of the Department of Geography at B.H.U. from 2013 to 2015, and as President of the Asian Cultural Landscape Association from 2018 to 2023. He is currently the President for Asia of the "Reconnecting With Your Culture" initiative, affiliated with UNESCO, and has held this role from 2021 to 2024.
His contributions extend to significant roles in international committees such as ICOMOS-IFLA and ICOMOS-India, where he coordinates the National Science Committee on Cultural Landscapes. Since April 2022, he has been a Visiting Professor at the Centre of South Asian Studies, Gifu Women’s University, Japan. Over four decades, Prof. Singh has conducted extensive research in India, Japan, Sweden, Italy, South Korea, and China, delivering 79 special lectures across 25 countries. He has authored 43 books and 342 papers, with notable works including "Banaras, Making of India’s Heritage City" (2009) and "Hindu Tradition of Pilgrimage: Sacred Space and System" (2013). Currently, he is co-editing three forthcoming anthologies for Springer Nature.
Prof. Singh also plays a pivotal role in the International Scientific Committee of EdA Esempi di Architettura, where he has co-edited thematic volumes focusing on historic cities, cultural heritage, and architectural symbolism. His distinguished career and extensive body of work highlight his dedication to the preservation and study of cultural landscapes and heritage globally.
0:00 Madhyameshwar & Gravity
3:30 Extent of Kashi
5:47 Kashi in aesthetic sense
7:05 Shiv, Parvati & Ganga
8:56 Kashi in modern sense
11:26 How Kashi became Shiv Nagri
17:24 Kashi is also Vishnu’s Nagri
19:37 Why Kashi became a city of sinners
23:35 How Kashi became a national religious centre
27:40 Today’s jyotirling same as Mahabharat era
34:31 Jyotirling & a Christian student’s story
37:38 Modi, Kashi Corridor & what’s right-wrong
42:45 Two Problems with Kashi Vishwanath corridor
47:15 Learn from Tirupati
51:00 Learn from Vivekanand Centre of Chicago
53:12 Mistakes in Ayodhya & Kashi
58:32 Modernity & Kashi Corridor
1:00:09 Dharmacracy
1:02:25 Learn from Indore
1:02:54 Learn from Jaggi Vasudev
1:05:32 Modernity is a must but…
1:11:01 Satyanarayan Ki Katha ki katha
1:16:28 Prof PB Rana’s brilliance
1:20:10 Prof PB Rana’s works & expertise

Пікірлер: 306

  • @mnsexim
    @mnsexim28 күн бұрын

    ऐसे ज्ञानियों को अपने channel पर लाने के लिए बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद !

  • @rebelme6564
    @rebelme65642 күн бұрын

    मैं पहले भी 2 बार काशी विसनाथ मंदिर गया हूं। लेकिन हर बार तकलीफ हुई। लेकिन इस बार एक दिन पहले मैंने रात में मन ही मन विसनाथ जी से कहा, "देखो विसनाथ कल सुबह आ रहा हूँ, अगर दिक्कत हुई तो फिर ठीक नही होगा". सुबह पहुंचा तो विसनाथ जी की सब व्यवस्थाए सक्रिय थी। दर्शन कर बहुत आनन्द आया। अपने घर लौट आया हूँ। लेकिन फिर आऊंगा इस संकल्प के साथ। विसनाथ कॉरिडॉर का निर्माण और व्यवस्था अद्भुत है। काशी में और भी अनेक पुराने अदभुत मंदिर है, उनका भी दर्शन किया। .... कुछ लोग की आदत होती है निंदा कर के अपना महत्व बढ़ाना। ऐसे लोगो का इंटरव्यू नही लेना चाहिए। काशी के बारे में प्रमाणिक रूप से सुनना हो तो मीनाक्षी जैन को सुनिए।

  • @adityaukey
    @adityaukey28 күн бұрын

    Maine ek din frustration me aake shivling banaya aur banake prayer kiya ki mera job laga do bhagwan usi samay mera interview letter aa gaya ...OM NAMAH SHIVAY !

  • @iXpress
    @iXpress29 күн бұрын

    Internet is helping Hindu Revival Otherwise such gem & knowledge would never come to us.

  • @user-er2rc8cm2h
    @user-er2rc8cm2h28 күн бұрын

    As a Indian from South when ever I visited Mandirs of North it always irked me seeing this rapid commercialization of Mandirs in North especially main mandirs like Jyotirlingas I mean in South there're very strict rules for the day to day functions of Mandirs & it's premises absolutely no commercial business can be run in & around the premises that's related to deity & in the name of the God actly there's a certain level of discipline & order in the functions of Mandirs in South whereas in Northern part like anyone can sell prasad of the God & also anyone can go near Deity even touch it there's no sanity is maintained in such sacred sites as if the officials of that mandirs r running it as per their comfort & convenience.......

  • @Aman-kq7lx

    @Aman-kq7lx

    28 күн бұрын

    Then u hv never been to tamil nadu and kerala

  • @Aman-kq7lx

    @Aman-kq7lx

    28 күн бұрын

    Atleast north Indians r not heavy on m.e.a....and definitely not b.e.e...

  • @user-er2rc8cm2h

    @user-er2rc8cm2h

    28 күн бұрын

    @@Aman-kq7lx ??

  • @user-er2rc8cm2h

    @user-er2rc8cm2h

    28 күн бұрын

    @@Aman-kq7lx Yepp!!

  • @user-er2rc8cm2h

    @user-er2rc8cm2h

    28 күн бұрын

    @@Aman-kq7lx mea & bee??

  • @maheshsharma3959
    @maheshsharma39596 күн бұрын

    बाबा एक दिन में इतने बड़े ज्ञानी नहीं बन गए। कई वर्षों की तपस्या है। भारत गर्व करता है।

  • @shrimaan
    @shrimaan29 күн бұрын

    सुनना शुरू किया है। बंध सा गया हूं। आपका क्या ही हाल हुआ होगा।

  • @SumitSharma-vs3fq

    @SumitSharma-vs3fq

    28 күн бұрын

    Phr beech mein comment kahaan se karne lage

  • @ravikantmishra9135

    @ravikantmishra9135

    19 күн бұрын

    बचपन ललिताघाट पर व्यतीत किया है। नानाजी स्व. पण्डित लालबिहारी जी मिश्र (शास्त्रीजी/ वैद्यजी) के साथ आपकी बताई हर जगह, मंदिर में दर्शन करने का सौभाग्य प्राप्त हुआ। हमारे घर में ही गोस्वामी तुलसीदास जी के द्वारा स्थापित प्रथम हनुमानजी की प्रतिमा "आदिसंकटमोचन मंदिर" में स्थित थी। कॉरिडोर में ललिताघाट का प्रारंभिक मकान होने के कारण हमारा घर एवं यह मंदिर भी ध्वस्त हो गए थे। एक मित्र श्री संदीप देव जिन्होंने श्री मोदी पर पुस्तक लिखी एवं उनके बड़े प्रशंसक थे, को मैंने इस मंदिर के बारे में बताया। ईश्वर की प्रेरणा से अथवा उनके प्रयास से आदि संकटमोचन हनुमान जी की प्रतिमा एवं उन्हीं के साथ शिवलिंग, राम लक्ष्मण जानकी की प्रतिमाएं भी कॉरिडोर में निचली तरफ अलग अलग मंदिरों में स्थापित कर दी गईं हैं किंतु कोई भी विवरण नहीं दिया गया है और बिल्कुल अलग थलग ये मंदिर सर्वथा उपेक्षित हैं। केवल पुराने जानकार ही यहां दर्शन करने आते हैं। यह तथ्य सार्वजनिक होना चाहिए तथा इन अद्भुत मंदिरों का दर्शनलाभ सभी को सुलभ होना चाहिए। जानकारी के लिए बताना चाहता हूं कि गोस्वामी जी ने कुल ऐसे 11 मंदिर प्रतिष्ठित किए थे जिनमे दूसरा मंदिर मीरघाट के नये विश्वनाथजी के पीछे स्थित हैं। यह मेरी जानकारी में एक मात्र मंदिर है जहां अंजना माई भी स्थापित हैं। तुलसीदास जी का ग्यारहवां मंदिर अस्सीघाट - लंका वाले संकटमोचन मंदिर है। (दुर्भाग्यवश उपरोक्त श्री संदीप देव अब मोदीजी के भारत में संभवतः सबसे बड़े आलोचक हैं।)

  • @sanimahraj1124

    @sanimahraj1124

    18 күн бұрын

    Nahi poora sun ne ke bad kiye honge​@@SumitSharma-vs3fq

  • @ChandeepSinghBhulli

    @ChandeepSinghBhulli

    17 күн бұрын

    I don’t understand and unfollow this channel and make sure never seen this channel again

  • @ultraMG917

    @ultraMG917

    6 күн бұрын

    mulla hai​@@ChandeepSinghBhulli

  • @ankushpatyal9707
    @ankushpatyal970729 күн бұрын

    I don’t know why but I cried listening to it. Better knowledge of spirituality than any saint out there. Hope I’ll meet him someday. Gyaan ka sagar hai inke pass. 🙏

  • @RajSingh-wh3yy
    @RajSingh-wh3yy28 күн бұрын

    मैं अपने जीवन में पूर्ण रूपेण निराश और असहाय था, मेरे अपने करने से कुछ भी नहीं हो पा रहा था, मैं काशी, विस्वनाथ जी के दर्शन को आया, उनको छू कर प्रार्थना की, हे नाथ!आप ही कुछ करो,,,,, कुछ दिनों बाद बनारस में सरकारी नौकरी मिली,, वो भी विस्वनाथ जी के ही निकट पोस्टिंग मिली,,, काशी में घर बन गया,, अब मैं प्रसन्नता से सपरिवार यहीं रहता हूँ 🙏🙏🙏अब कुछ नहीं चाहिए,,,, जय विश्वनाथ 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @utkarshmishra6718

    @utkarshmishra6718

    6 күн бұрын

    Baba Ki Kripa Mata Ji Ka Ashirvad He

  • @adv.akashvikramsingh9517
    @adv.akashvikramsingh951728 күн бұрын

    Prof. Rana P. B. is my teacher. ❤

  • @suryashaw3906

    @suryashaw3906

    8 күн бұрын

    Really

  • @anandupadhyay4610
    @anandupadhyay46103 күн бұрын

    अद्भुत,विलक्षण, विद्वता और परम ग्यानार्जन की यही पराकाष्ठा भारतीय दर्शन की थाती है! धन्य हैं ऐसे मूर्धन्य अध्येता! नमन।

  • @manmohansharma4174
    @manmohansharma41747 күн бұрын

    प्रोफेसर राणा ज्ञान के अगाध भंडार हैं. इनको जितना सुनें हमेशा अदभुत जानकारी मिलती है वो भी धार्मिक, आध्यात्मिक,सांस्कृतिक और वैज्ञानिकता से परिपूर्ण होता है.

  • @bhagwanmishra7243
    @bhagwanmishra72436 күн бұрын

    पैदा हुआ बनारस में मैं शिक्षा पाया वहीं सभीं।गली गली घूमा देखा सब पढ़ा पुराण कथाएं भी।। किंतु न जाने गूढ़ बात काशी क्यों न्यारी प्यारी है। ब्रह्मा विष्णु सदाशिव शंकर आदि पुरुष की नगरी है।। धन्यवाद

  • @DG.956
    @DG.95629 күн бұрын

    Such a beautiful talk❤ I love it. Bring him back on VAAD.

  • @karanwaghwani8407
    @karanwaghwani840728 күн бұрын

    Never have i felt so connected and attached to any podcast but this. Started Listening, now I have deep and genuine interest in knowing more about Our religion and Banaras. Looking forward for more podcast with such Prof. Rana P.B. Singh sir 😊

  • @rajeevbhardwaj6890
    @rajeevbhardwaj689027 күн бұрын

    बहुत आनन्द आया , ज्ञान मिला और प्रोफेसर साहब का बनारसी अन्दाज़ दिल को गुदगुदा गया 😀🙏

  • @sidddddddddddddd
    @sidddddddddddddd26 күн бұрын

    What Modi did in Kashi, the same Tirupathi did in Jammu. They cut hundreds of trees to build a Tirupathi Temple in Jammu! Those hills surrounding Jammu were one of the only surviving forests 🌳 around Jammu! It’s all about money 💰 If tomorrow they construct a Vaishno Devi temple in Delhi, would it have any significance? Then why Tirupathi temple in Jammu?

  • @_its_Jay
    @_its_Jay27 күн бұрын

    अरिहंतभाई, आपसे अनुरोध है कि १२ ज्योतिर्लिंगों के उपर एक series बनाइए । केवल काशी विश्वनाथ पर focus करने से बेहतर होगा कि हर एक ज्योतिर्लिंग के विषय पर उस ज्योतिर्लिंग के विषय में विशेष जानकारी रखने वाले विशेषज्ञ को आमंत्रित किया जाए। उदाहरणार्थ KZread पर, घृष्णेश्वर ज्योतिर्लिंग, मल्लिकार्जुन ज्योतिर्लिंग, नागेश्वर ज्योतिर्लिंग के विषय में काशी विश्वनाथ, केदारनाथ या सोमनाथ की तुलना में बहुत कम जानकारी उपलब्ध है ।

  • @drarchnachandel6951
    @drarchnachandel695119 күн бұрын

    अब तक का सर्वोत्तम इंटरव्यू साधुवाद है राणा जी के और भी इंटरव्यू कीजिए

  • @alexcooper7595
    @alexcooper759528 күн бұрын

    Awesome samvaad bhai! Didn't know our Bharat has such hidden gems.

  • @jitendrarana3830
    @jitendrarana38306 күн бұрын

    अद्वितीय ग्यानवरधक जानकारियों के व्यासदेव आपको प्रणाम।साधुवाद ।

  • @stonedsufi
    @stonedsufi29 күн бұрын

    Excellent talk. Grateful to you for getting Rana ji on the show. Absolutely delightful and informative!

  • @prakashchandra69
    @prakashchandra6928 күн бұрын

    बिहार के सोनपुर में हरिहर क्षेत्र मंदिर है, जहां गंडक और गंगा के मिलन स्थल पर हरि (विष्णु) और हर (शिव) का सम्मिलन हुआ था।

  • @Risingbharat01
    @Risingbharat0128 күн бұрын

    प्रणाम गुरुदेव अपने काशी के बारे में ऐसी बातें जानकर बहुत ही अच्छा लग रहा है और अंदर से उत्सुकता बढ़ रही है कि इसके बारे में और चर्चाएं की जाए आपकी एक बात जो कि बनारस शहर घूमते हुए हमें स्पिरिचुअलिटी का जो एहसास ना होता है इससे मैं सहमत हूं और जब हम मंदिर परिसर के पास पहुंचते हैं तब हमें प्रतीत होता है तो कुछ अलौकिक शक्तियां इस जगह विद्यमान है शेष बनारस में वह बात नहीं है

  • @anup141321
    @anup14132128 күн бұрын

    Such a beautiful conversation we need more

  • @sumedhasubhash
    @sumedhasubhash28 күн бұрын

    इतना आनंद देने के लिये धन्यवाद. आप को नमस्कार

  • @sarojkantamohapatra2431
    @sarojkantamohapatra24314 күн бұрын

    My thought process stopped, listened carefully at one go like a movie. Guruji is a real gem of our civilization and the modern Aryabhatta

  • @anantsharma8096
    @anantsharma809613 күн бұрын

    Bhai bohot anand aaya. Thanks! For a wonderful podcast 🙏. Namah Parvatipataye’ Har Har Mahadev!!

  • @anandupadhyay4610
    @anandupadhyay46103 күн бұрын

    ऐसे पुरोधा को शतशत नमन। काश इस सम्पूर्ण बातचीत को मौजूदा पी एम ओ के विशिष्ट अधिकारी भी देखें साथ ही करबद्ध अनुरोध है कि समय निकाल कर माननीय प्रधान मंत्री जी भी स्वयं समय निकाल कर खासकर काशी के नव निर्मित श्री विश्वनाथ जी परिसर में कतिपय अति महत्वपूर्ण व संवेदनशील सुधार को अंगीकार कर सुधार करा सकें।

  • @SONUSINGH-yb8xb
    @SONUSINGH-yb8xb28 күн бұрын

    बहुत सुंदर कुछ अहंकार के साथ अत्यंत महत्वपूर्ण जानकारियाँ। नमन

  • @user-zx8kn3st1t

    @user-zx8kn3st1t

    3 күн бұрын

    तुम उनके में अहंकार कहां देख लिए

  • @ptykpandey
    @ptykpandey23 сағат бұрын

    अद्भुत उद्बोधन...अथ श्री विश्वनाथ कथा....🌹🤗🌹

  • @dheerajsinghrajput5911
    @dheerajsinghrajput591126 күн бұрын

    Thankyou so much for this wonderful episode.

  • @vimleshkumartripathi8292
    @vimleshkumartripathi829229 күн бұрын

    Very Insightful Talk !!

  • @ManjitSingh-pg9qz
    @ManjitSingh-pg9qz28 күн бұрын

    Bring back excellent dr Rana b p Singh to speak in depth on importance of gyanvapi vishwanath vishweshwar please

  • @EnglishYogii
    @EnglishYogii5 күн бұрын

    मैं अपने शोध के सिलसिले में राणा जी से मिला पहली मुलाकात में 3 घंटा 45 मिनट की बैठकी हुई।

  • @madhubhaskar3796
    @madhubhaskar379628 күн бұрын

    Dhanyavad in mahanubhav ji ka , itne gyanvardhak podcast ke liye 🙏

  • @achandra8253
    @achandra825317 күн бұрын

    बहुत ज्ञानवर्धक जानकारी प्राप्त हुई। बहुत बहुत हार्दिक आभार। प्रणाम 🙏🚩🙏

  • @utsavkumarhalder4973
    @utsavkumarhalder497315 күн бұрын

    Iss vyakti ko jitna sunta hoon utna hi sunne ki man karta hai...aisa episode aur banana chahiye.. hat's off rana ji ..

  • @tempuser109
    @tempuser10929 күн бұрын

    Beautiful, a pleasure to the ear , great conversation

  • @amarnath2122
    @amarnath21228 күн бұрын

    सबसे पहले धर्म को राजनीति के चंगुल से मुक्त करवाना होगा तभी लोक कल्याण हो पाएगा । प्रोफेसर साहब जैसे विद्वानों के सलाह और वैज्ञानिक दृष्टिकोण से पौराणिक महत्वो को ध्यान में रखते हुए से तीर्थ स्थलों का निर्माण करवाया जाना चाहिए अंधा विकास नही होना चाहिए जो पार्टी

  • @tanmoyrgrg
    @tanmoyrgrg28 күн бұрын

    Excellent program.......because of this I could learn a lot...

  • @sachindrakumarsingh9470
    @sachindrakumarsingh947029 күн бұрын

    Excellent episode. Well done.

  • @adi482
    @adi48227 күн бұрын

    Best संवाद, so far 🤩

  • @georgezwills
    @georgezwills29 күн бұрын

    Arihant aapka athyadhik dhanyawad Kashike in chupe hue ratna ko hum sabke samne prastoot karne ke liye.. 🙏🏻

  • @purushottamagarwal90
    @purushottamagarwal9015 күн бұрын

    अद्भुत चर्चा हुई, अत्यंत ज्ञानवर्धक, अरिहंत जी आपसे निवेदन है कि आप इनके साथ आगे और episodes बनाएं, और हमारा ज्ञान बढ़ाएं । धन्यवाद।

  • @chandraveersingh1986
    @chandraveersingh198624 күн бұрын

    One of the best interview........ waiting for next episode..... thanks

  • @Nair_
    @Nair_26 күн бұрын

    Superb!!! I bow down to this professors knowledge, achievements and service to ParamaShiva.

  • @shivmishra2929
    @shivmishra292928 күн бұрын

    ज़बर्दस्त एपिसोड।

  • @nanukumar7651
    @nanukumar765114 күн бұрын

    Excellent narratives and information

  • @seemaagarwal3992
    @seemaagarwal399227 күн бұрын

    अहो भाग्य अद्भुत प्रस्तुति 🙏

  • @wisevictor9751
    @wisevictor975129 күн бұрын

    Pranam Acharya ji🙏

  • @hardyshayona8208
    @hardyshayona820810 күн бұрын

    One of the best Podcast of yours. धन्यवाद

  • @rajeevbhatnagar6495
    @rajeevbhatnagar649529 күн бұрын

    Kashi (Varanasi) is inhabited since at least 1800 BC. The holy complex has seen more than one destruction and reconstruction over thousands of years. Of late. In c. 1669 Auranzeb destroyed the main Kashi-Vishwanath temple and built the Gyanvapi Mosque over theplace. In 1780, Devi Ahilyabai Holkar built a temple few meters away from the original location (Original location is Gyanvapi Mosque). This happened during Maratha rule over northern India. In 2021, Shri Narendra Modi was instrumental in enlarging the temple premises and providing direct access via a staircase from the temple to Ganga River. Discussions & debate still going on recovery of original temple which is the Gyanvapi Mosque. Let us unite and work for making the ancient Kashi, and modern Varanasi, a city where we can feel calm, peace, and spirituality.

  • @vidit9970

    @vidit9970

    26 күн бұрын

    I think you didn't here the podcast properly, temples have been broken. There is no Ancient Kashi anymore. The spirituality of the Kashi is dying. The original yaatras mentioned in Skand Puraan are stopped because the original temples are no more. They have no plan to rebuild the temples. In fact they are planing to break more as, this was only the first phase of the Kashi corridor. They are promoting liquor party in the Ganga river, they have started ganga cruise for this. This temple breaking spree they call corridor building is not just isolated to Kashi. They have broken several in Ayodhya, Mhakaal jyotirling, Vrundaavan, Maa Vaishnodevi, many lesser known and local temples. They are still breaking more. Hidus will never unite in the name of temple breaking. If they do, they are not Hindus but Shivdrohis. Hindu unity exists only in social media comment sections.

  • @rajeevbhatnagar6495

    @rajeevbhatnagar6495

    25 күн бұрын

    @@vidit9970 You may be living in Kashi, but I have a different experience. I went to the Kashi Vishwanath Temple about 10 years back. I had to go in thru a narrow three feet wide path in between zoo-like steel bars. I felt like a zoo animal who was being watched by crowd of people from adjacent mosque thru the steel bars. {Experience in Prayagraj was still worse. We went for a bath in sangam. Water of our holy sangam was so dirty, so dirty, that it was repulsive even to put feet inside it. We took a bath somehow, but I vowed never to take a dip at any holy place.} In Mahabharata only two tirthas are mentioned in Varanasi. These are [i] Kapilhrada and [ii] Avimukta. Both are lost. In Mahabharata there is Yatra of Kurukshetra only, none in Varanasi. As regards Skanda Purana Yatras (like 5-kosi, or 84-Kosi), either effort can be made to make way for them, alternatively sequence can be changed or longer route taken. Anyone who implements a change can not keep everyone involved, or everyone happy. It is so easy to criticize anything and anyone. Change is inescapable. Since there are so many improvements in Varanasi - we visited six months back - let us embrace the change. It is now a place where young people will be happy & proud to go and pray.

  • @vidit9970

    @vidit9970

    25 күн бұрын

    @@rajeevbhatnagar6495 So all that you wrote, justifies the temple destructions? Filth needs to be cleaned, agreed, but there are other ways to achieve it. BREAKING TEMPLES is not one of those ways! People who think like you, are not hindus. Sadly there are lot of you out there. Yatras are based on mandalas mentioned in skand puran; You cannot just magically change the route as per YOUR convenience. Every temple, pond, tree in every yatra has been put there in a certain way so that the bhaktas can get benefit from it, it is designed as per the structure of the cosmos(not making this up, it is written). You mentioned the Avimukta Yatra, one of the main shiva temple, Avimukteshvara has been destroyed! The yatra themselves are broken because the temples do not exist. They didn't even keep the lingams of many templates. They broke them to smaller pieces and mix them with the rubble(Not making this up either, there is a whole video of this on Twitter as proof, they were doing this at night time). The temple of one of the main Vinayakaa is also destroyed. They have destroyed few ponds as well. They fell the Akshaya Vat(अक्षय वट), one of the holiest tree in India! They have destroyed the house of Mandana Mishra, destroyed the Vyasa Pitha itself, destroyed the house of Kedarnath Vyasa, with it countless manuscripts were also lost forever! This is not about making everyone happy. This is about preserving the remains of the oldest, holiest, God built city on this earth! Which we HAVE LOST due to the corridor. This is not change, this is destruction of a very sacred place. NO, it is not easy to criticize, rather it is easy to sweep the issue under the carpet, rather it is difficult to digest the truth. I will say this again. Those who perform, justify or support this type of destruction is NOT a hindu, but just a politically blind Indian.

  • @vidit9970

    @vidit9970

    25 күн бұрын

    @@rajeevbhatnagar6495 So all that you wrote, justifies the temple destructions? Filth needs to be cleaned, agreed, but there are other ways to achieve it. BREAKING TEMPLES is not one of those ways! People who think like you, are not hindus. Sadly there are lot of you out there. Yatras are based on mandalas mentioned in skand puran; You cannot just magically change the route as per YOUR convenience. Every temple, pond, tree in every yatra has been put there in a certain way so that the bhaktas can get benefit from it, it is designed as per the structure of the cosmos(not making this up, it is written). You mentioned the Avimukta Yatra, one of the main shiva temple, Avimukteshvara has been destroyed! The yatra themselves are broken because the temples do not exist. They didn't even keep the lingams of many templates. They broke them to smaller pieces and mix them with the rubble(Not making this up either, there is a whole video of this on Twitter as proof, they were doing this at night time). The temple of one of the main Vinayakaa is also destroyed. They have destroyed few ponds as well. They fell the Akshaya Vat(अक्षय वट), one of the holiest tree in India! They have destroyed the house of Mandana Mishra, destroyed the Vyasa Pitha itself, destroyed the house of Kedarnath Vyasa, with it countless manuscripts were also lost forever! This is not about making everyone happy. This is about preserving the remains of the oldest, holiest, God built city on this earth! Which we HAVE LOST due to the corridor. This is not change, this is destruction of a very sacred place. NO, it is not easy to criticize, rather it is easy to sweep the issue under the carpet, rather it is difficult to digest the truth. I will say this again. Those who perform, justify, support or "embrace" this type of destruction is NOT a hindu, but just a politically blind Indian.

  • @rbhar8050

    @rbhar8050

    8 күн бұрын

    ​@@rajeevbhatnagar6495 I agree with you. I went Kashi around 40 years back. After seeing so dirty place, dead bodies floating in ganga. It never occurred to me to visit Kashi again. But after seeing so much development I went there last year. There was not a single moment when I had not felt shiv . After sitting there in different ghats I as well as my children felt so spiritual upliftment. May be old generation feel disconnected but for young and future generations the development was necessary. Only two things I don't like are destruction of shivlings and cutting of trees.

  • @KAmith-tb5cj
    @KAmith-tb5cj27 күн бұрын

    अति सुन्दर संवाद रहा l ऐसे ही संवाद के वीडियो बनाते रहिए l ऐसे लग रहा था कि लगातार सुनते रहें l धन्यवाद 🙏

  • @ManojKumar-fc1dh
    @ManojKumar-fc1dh28 күн бұрын

    अद्भुत अद्भुत आदरणीय जय सनातन हर हर महादेव

  • @VishalKumar-ti1wl
    @VishalKumar-ti1wl28 күн бұрын

    Felt blessed ❤

  • @ameyakolhe4838
    @ameyakolhe483828 күн бұрын

    Fascinating ❤❤❤

  • @user-sr2od2dl6v
    @user-sr2od2dl6v28 күн бұрын

    Thanks Sir I am listening you after a long time.very beautiful talk.

  • @pullaksud4171
    @pullaksud417128 күн бұрын

    I am very grateful for this immense knowledge 🙏

  • @tutorlogy7401
    @tutorlogy740126 күн бұрын

    Ati sunder narration 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🚩

  • @ashishmaharishi1372
    @ashishmaharishi137228 күн бұрын

    शुक्रिया सर। आपसे बहुत कुछ सीखने को मिलता है। असली बनारसी तो आप ही हैं।

  • @vijayeebhav9795
    @vijayeebhav979529 күн бұрын

    नि:संदेह आप विद्वान हैं, किन्तु अहंकारी हैं। अपशब्द का प्रयोग करना मूर्खतापूर्ण कार्य है। यदि हमारी बात से असहमत हों तो पूछिये, सत्यनारायण कथा के बारे में हम बताने का प्रयास करेंगे। यही अहंकार आप को डुबो रहा है।

  • @SoulSearchEternal

    @SoulSearchEternal

    28 күн бұрын

    बता दो भाई

  • @vijayeebhav9795

    @vijayeebhav9795

    28 күн бұрын

    अपना प्रश्न पूछिये, शत प्रतिशत प्रमाण के साथ उत्तर मिलेगा।

  • @user-dj5ub3hu8o

    @user-dj5ub3hu8o

    28 күн бұрын

    भाई, आप मूर्ख हैं!

  • @kulbirhooda8464

    @kulbirhooda8464

    28 күн бұрын

    ये काशी की भाषा है भराता श्री।

  • @vijayeebhav9795

    @vijayeebhav9795

    28 күн бұрын

    @@kulbirhooda8464 ये हुड्डा कबसे बनारसी समझने लगे भाई

  • @user-th8dq1ev2l
    @user-th8dq1ev2l26 күн бұрын

    Very happy to see such interesting video and professor talking about hindu religious texts and spirituality

  • @PremSingh-fy8uc
    @PremSingh-fy8uc29 күн бұрын

    अद्भुत अद्वितीय।हर हर महादेव

  • @user-rv7qk1kk3d
    @user-rv7qk1kk3d26 күн бұрын

    Bahut atcha 👌

  • @unibassmusic
    @unibassmusic29 күн бұрын

    Very informative

  • @yudhvirsingh4930
    @yudhvirsingh49302 күн бұрын

    Beautiful explaination

  • @vishalvi69
    @vishalvi6921 күн бұрын

    Truly humbled to hear so much about my city Varanasi, second part is must.

  • @psychologicalsayings1377
    @psychologicalsayings137728 күн бұрын

    Informative

  • @jaguhassan
    @jaguhassan28 күн бұрын

    Top class , just speechless

  • @Aryan_singh247
    @Aryan_singh24728 күн бұрын

    Awesome podcast 🔥

  • @phuloutmishu619
    @phuloutmishu61928 күн бұрын

    You are great man🙏🙏

  • @shivayshakti6575
    @shivayshakti657529 күн бұрын

    lovely episode

  • @DushyantSinghal
    @DushyantSinghal12 күн бұрын

    You have been doing a great job sir. You are inviting such a great personality who we are not familiar with. This was amazing session ❤

  • @RajSingh-wh3yy
    @RajSingh-wh3yy28 күн бұрын

    अति सुन्दर 🙏🙏

  • @phuloutmishu619
    @phuloutmishu61928 күн бұрын

    Very Thank

  • @suparnaunger723
    @suparnaunger72327 күн бұрын

    @Vaad, hope to see more of Professor's interviews... thankyou

  • @krishnajar
    @krishnajar14 күн бұрын

    My god, these kind of gems people exist. It’s amazing how much poetic aesthetics exist in our culture

  • @chandandey100
    @chandandey1006 күн бұрын

    Incredible 🙏

  • @kamalkamal-ie1sp
    @kamalkamal-ie1sp6 күн бұрын

    Great ❤❤❤

  • @aloksharma7550
    @aloksharma755028 күн бұрын

    Arihant ji ko sadhuwad waiting for next talk about Kashi and surrounding with great scholar Singh sahib🙏

  • @Roms2626
    @Roms262620 күн бұрын

    Amazing 👏 👏 bro..what a podcast...

  • @Raghu-ct7ul
    @Raghu-ct7ul13 күн бұрын

    आप भारतीय सब्जी अनुसंधान मे दस वर्ष पुर्व आये थे।आप ने काशी पर कुछ विचार प्रकट किये थे।तब से अनवरत आप के वाणी सुनने के लिए तरस रहा था।❤❤

  • @Gatha.Gangagram
    @Gatha.Gangagram12 күн бұрын

    बहुत सुन्दर चर्चा

  • @prakash7921
    @prakash79218 күн бұрын

    mesmerising

  • @rohitrajak5827
    @rohitrajak582710 күн бұрын

    Bohot bohot dhanyawad bhaiya , inse milwane ke liye.....please please inke sath or v conversation kijiye bohot sari , inke knowledge ki need hai ham jese youth ko . Abhi sab show off ka jamana hai please inke sath future mai v podcast kijiyega. Apke subscriber ka request hai please.and thank you bhaiya ............

  • @darshanpandyadp075
    @darshanpandyadp0754 күн бұрын

    बहुत आनंद मिला। साक्षात सभी देव प्रत्यक्ष हो रहे है

  • @aakashdeep6848
    @aakashdeep684810 күн бұрын

    Aise dnyan ki anubhuti karne ka madhyam banne ke liye aapko Pranam. Guru Ji ko sun kar dimag ek nayi rup mein soch payega.🙏

  • @dr.ashishkumar1714
    @dr.ashishkumar171421 күн бұрын

    सर को सुनना हमेशा ही सम्मोहन एवं ज्ञानवर्धक होता है। काशी के विषय पर तो आपसे बढ़कर किसी का अधिकार नहीं है। मन होता है कि सुनते ही जाएं।

  • @nikhilunde9708
    @nikhilunde97083 күн бұрын

    पी बी सिंगजी को सुनके हम कृतकृत्य होगये

  • @cooladi6
    @cooladi610 күн бұрын

    I cried ....हे प्रभु

  • @dollythapa2
    @dollythapa2Күн бұрын

    Bahot he sundar roop mai wyakhya kiya apne

  • @ashishsharma-ox6fn
    @ashishsharma-ox6fn24 күн бұрын

    Information by such Divine person.❤ But Shame on the Government.

  • @shilpeegupta3357
    @shilpeegupta335719 күн бұрын

    सम्मोहित कर दिया गुरु जी 🙏🙏 धाराप्रवाह इतिहास 🙏🙏🙏

  • @vimalendukumartripathi3327
    @vimalendukumartripathi332713 күн бұрын

    अध्ययन की पराकाष्ठा, अद्भुत।

  • @nithinvijaykoushik15
    @nithinvijaykoushik152 күн бұрын

    Truly said about the “Pandits”. I was in the Vishwanath Mandira just last month and a Pandit “accompanied” us. I have a degree in Samskritam and when the “Pandit” was mixing Hindi sentences in actual Shlokas What’s more, my daughter has a very deep knowledge of Vyakarana and Chandas Shastras and she was shocked at what was chanted. This is not done. Nobody plays with our Aastha and get away with it. It is a criminal offence. If someone is doing Paurohitya, they need to be qualified. For example, archakas in the Tirupati temple have to be qualified in Vaikhanasa Agamas. Please press the Government to have qualified priests in our temples, they are earning from them.

  • @SecularKafir
    @SecularKafir14 күн бұрын

    मैं तो खैर आपका धर्म उसके ईश्वरो का त्याग कर चुका हूँ लेकिन मैं पहले दिन से जानता था कि चाहे काशी हो या अयोध्या जहाँ लोग आस्था और अध्यात्म की खोज में जाते है उन सबका व्यवसायीकरण हो चुका है मैं हर मंदिर जा चुका हूँ मुझे जब सनातन धर्म मे आस्था थी तब भी मुझे मंदिर में कोई शक्ति अनुभव नही होती थी अब तो ख़ैर सवाल ही नही।।पर फिर भी इन महोदय की बात पर गौर करना चाहिए कि मंदिर और धर्मस्थान कोई व्यवसाय नहीं है वो कोई पर्यटन स्थल नही है लोगो की आध्यात्मिक भावनाओ का सम्मान करना चाहिए और जो तमाशा राजनीति के नाम पर हिन्दू धर्मस्थलो पर हो रहा तथा जो हिन्दुओ को अपने देवी देवताओं की मूर्तियों का स्पर्श तक अब नसीब नही होता उसे ठीक करना चाहिए एक भक्त के लिए सबसे तकलीफ़ देह यही होता है कि वो अपने ईश्वर का स्पर्श न कर पाए।।

  • @ajaymishra9554

    @ajaymishra9554

    5 күн бұрын

    Good morning Jaisa aapka comments hai sanatan aur uspe aapke viswas ka ,uske liye hum kahna chahenge ki jis tarah Kasturi Mrig ke nabhi me rahta hai aur wo usko jagah jagh dhudhta hai , bhrm me rahta hai ki ye sugandh kaha se aa rahi aur idhar udhar dudta hai pr marne tak samjh nahi pata ,thik usi prakar aapka man hai sanatan dharm aapne xod diya ,aur apne according uski vyakhya ki ,jante hai qu ,quki aap apne man ,chitt ko samjha hi nahi paye. Jab bhi samjhna ka sochenge aapka man khud hi pavitra ho jayega , sara bhram toot jayega , Jis tarah tamam pradushan (pollution )din b din bad raha lekin hum swas le rahe gande jal ko hum suddh kar ke pee lete hai usi prakar hume bahar kaya practice me hai uspr dhyan na dekar hume khud ko us iswar ko samjhna chahiye. Aur saare dharmo me jitni vaigyanikta sanatan hai jitni purani ye hai ,duniya me koi nahi.

  • @physicsstudies2611
    @physicsstudies261110 күн бұрын

    Please ese aur Samvaad chahiye...🙏

  • @VishalKumar-ti1wl
    @VishalKumar-ti1wl28 күн бұрын

    Plz make more talks with Him❤

Келесі