Wow, that's weird! I normally expect high quality blades from Darkwood. Well, flaws in the steel happen... I'm sure they'll replace it for free. Always nice to see you experiment with so many different weapons by the way.

@martinhg98

Жыл бұрын

helo skall i love your videos

@beowulfshaeffer8444

Жыл бұрын

No, Skal! It's the inherently magical lightsaber qualities of the katana! 😜 I suppose a sturdier blade is needed for this. Maybe that line of Kveton blunt sabers that Matt Easton is always promoting?

@weaponism

Жыл бұрын

We always enjoy watching your videos!! We hope to shoot a video with you someday. it would be such an honor!👍👍

@Baby-Blue-102

Жыл бұрын

@skallagrim What do you think of their Miyamoto Musashi Dual blade sparring videos and the general technique, if i may ask? I personally think its some of their most entertaining videos and some of the most thought provoking personally, but I'd like to know what other's think. : )

@sageofsixpathskakashi3742

Жыл бұрын

Daddy Skullgrim knows about Weponism 😮

Bro, he struck the katana with the saber and I just died on the spot laughing.

As an Olympic fencer, and with how frequently blades break in the sport, this hurts me to my bone

@SirConto

Жыл бұрын

Wow, never knew that happens. How often does that happen? And how much does it cost to replace it?

@pizzawoomy4010

Жыл бұрын

@@SirConto it depends on the quality of the blade. FIE approved blades generally last around 6 months to a year, and costs around 140 USD. Cheap ones, depending on how much you parry, can last a low of one month, but it only costs around 30 USD. You can only use FIE approved blades for international competitions tho.

@dorukgolcu9191

Жыл бұрын

@@SirConto unfortunately one of the costlier aspects of the sport

@johnapostolopoulos4

Жыл бұрын

As a former saber as well (not olympic) I would also like to add that we do not use full swings like that on a sword that parries. The olympic sabers are made for contact mostly and do not account for heavy parries. A saber that is more akin to a polish saber will probably be better for a real sword fight.

@matthewpham9525

6 ай бұрын

It's 1000000% times worse with HEMA. This Darkwood Dueling saber blade is $165, even more than a bunch of FIE Blades

I was confused by the video length before clicking but this was funny 🤣

I think if you want to test Katana against the sabre you should use cavalery sabre (like Polish sabre) not dueling one.

@celtibero599

Жыл бұрын

As an Spanish fencer of rapier and saber I have to dissagree. The dueling saber is a very good obtiene to do this, specially because the katana is also a dueling sword. The Polish saber, as you said, is for cavalery, for war, is not designed for dueling, dispait you can duel with it.

@Kirill_Ivanov.

Жыл бұрын

​@@celtibero599I'm sorry, but what about HEMA? There is a whole discipline - "Hatton's military saber".

@sapmartatlas

Жыл бұрын

​@@celtibero599 el sable de Simón De Frías es mucho más cercano a uno de caballería que los sables de duelo de gimnasio de fines del siglo XIX con una hoja mucho más delgada y menos curvatura (al estilo de Hutton). Además al menos uno de los Mereló (no me acuerdo cual) se queja del actual sable español, porque debería ser más ancha la hoja.

@jestfullgremblim8002

Жыл бұрын

Polish Sabre rocks! 🤟😻

@radoslawboklak

Ай бұрын

@@celtibero599 No man, actually polish saber, was designed to fight on foot, using polish cross cutting art. kzread.info/dash/bejne/oYN2o5R_gbXXlrg.html

I might suggest a Kvetun Easton Mk. 3 Saber. It's a military style saber with a much beefier blade, a lot better for doing mixed weapons stuff. I used one in the Open Steel event at IceBreaker 2022 and it stood up well to shields and longswords.

@sacredxgeometry

4 ай бұрын

if you mean as in Kvetun Armoury, I also second this.

I believe the saber was Darkwood's Italian Dueling saber. It's a fine weapon as far as it goes, but it's a light-bladed saber designed for dueling against a similar-style weapon. it's not meant for any kind of heavy combat against even other style sabers like the polish military saber. They have a heavier, more military grade blade available that would be far more appropriate. Castille has several saber models available as well, which I personally have used very often against longswords for years, and they stand up very well.

My defense was so strong😂

"Glorious Nippon Steel Folded Over 1000 Times!"

@VestedUTuber

11 ай бұрын

Can cut through any European sword - as long as the European sword is a renaissance era fencing sword and not anything heavier. XD

British or Polish military sabre should be able to fare better, I think. That type of sword, if I remember right, is more so for duels rather than battlefields, a more fitting sword would be one of the battlefield sabres, especially cavalry sabres, those things can be tough.

@18ps3anos

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, but a cavalry sabre wouldn't be safe for sparring unless the user has loads of control. Certainly, any military sabre would be better than a duelist sabre, but I think either the weapon took a beating previous to this or it had a construction defect. The sabre broke on its own cut against a static parry.

I've had 3 darkswords and every one of them has broken. I'm not surprised

@bsmnt23

Жыл бұрын

Darkwood, or Darksword; they're two different companies. This one was Darkwood.

That was beautiful… You guys need to talk to some HEMA people for a Sabre- that looks more like an Olympic sport style fencing, saber- which will have a great advantage in speed because it’s so late compared to a real one.

@zooml4959

Жыл бұрын

It's not a sport saber, it's an Italian dueling saber, later period but still contemporary to some sturdier sabers.

Honestly, a saber of the Kościuszkówka type or similar would work far better for such a duel. Or, if you want a a bit straighter blade profile Batorówka-type saber could be a nice fit for 'vs katana' duel.

Wow at 0:07 he blocks and makes an attack !!! So cool !! 진짜 멋있다 ~~!! ㅇㅅㅇ

Anime katanas in real life be like.

I bet someone's going to use this as "proof" that katanas are the ultimate sword.

@danjohnston9037

Жыл бұрын

Yep. Magical Blade That Cuts Steel 🙄

@rodjjt7742

Жыл бұрын

​@@danjohnston9037 and bullets

@dorukgolcu9191

Жыл бұрын

Pretty much the comment right above yours, in fact 😂

@thfkmnIII

Жыл бұрын

Seethe

@Cretaal

Жыл бұрын

Like HEMA fangirls would be any different if he landed a thrust. Just stop.

I've seen multiple dark wood sabers break, we actually banned them at our club.

Ayyyoo, I was expecting a lengthy duel 😄 But dang, I hope the manufacturer replace that sword for free.

Kvetun Armory makes high quality sabers with a variety of styles to choose from.

lmao I just can't stop giggling :D that poor saber just decided to give up ...

Man, that sucks. I really wanted to see this interesting kind of duell. Guess they will give you back the money or send you a good one, becuse it is very clear, that this blade is rubbish, no matter how hrd the katana blade is.

Good demonstration.

The legend of the Katana grows

Back at it again with the classy saber. Such a shame for what happened to it though...

and they say it only happens in movies

Griffith and Guts battle be like

Aww, going to have to re-visit this one, ha.

That saber look rather thin almost Olympic saber thin. I would recommend something like an Easton sabre 3 by Kvetun armory.

Nice

have u tried tulwar?

awesome

Absolute win

Lightsword vs kenjutsu please

I think you should to use military sabre in next time)

1 strike Kamis of katana says No this time ussar!

Please try again. PLEASE :D

Saberguy seeing ichigo and tanjiro: He's literally me!

Wow....

There are sabers designed to take heavy blows. Springy steel. Katanas usually are stiff. There are heavy sabers. Fencing models are weak.

Someone needs to show this to Shad 😆

The katana depth (edge to back dimension) is much greater than the saber, making it much stiffer. Stiffness is proportional to the square of the depth of the blade.

아니 눈물이..ㅠㅠ 제 세이버 빌려드릴까요

Katana Rules!!

I think cold steel company make good saber replicas. Cavalry saber. Brits light cavalry saber, Napoleon saber, US heavy cavalry saber.

Experienced katana fighter with an actual weapon, equally experienced saber fighter with actual weapon, one on one, saber wins.

JAPANESE STEEL IS THE GREATEST IN THE WORL-

Bad heat treatment, look at the grain structure where the break in the blade occurred, it is likely very uneven.

most likely the heat treatment problem

That's clearly a manufacturing defect of some sort. They will probably replace the sword if you send it back to the sellers and tell them what happened..

Dude, more from the wrist. Its a Saber not a club...don't swing it like a club!!

Meh, I'm still waiting for a sport sabre vs. yourself. You have greatest saber fighters in the Korea. Use them😅!

I'm curious what historical specimen that sabre was based on. It looks very thin compared to English, French, and Polish sabres that I'm used to.

@penttikoivuniemi2146

Жыл бұрын

It's an Italian-style dueling sabre.

@mrgoober6320

Жыл бұрын

Thank you, that seems to be correct. Not the style of sabre I'd have chosen to match against a katana - which is essentially a short-ish, thick steel bar.

@penttikoivuniemi2146

Жыл бұрын

@@mrgoober6320 Agreed, not an especially good style to take the kind of abuse fencing with a katana is likely to cause, but it for sure shouldn't have broken as easily as it did. Must have been a manufacturing flaw of some kind.

That was SO disappointing, I really wanted to see this.

1:12 well in a real battlefield the sabre would have not been a sports sabre. :-) but still - you'd expect the damn thing to actually last more than a few hits, lol

🙂

Brother is he trained in saber or he is just trained in kendo

This is most likely due to a bad temper more than blade geometry. That sucks though.

Hahahahahah that was awesome!

Western blades are not match for glorious Nippon steel!!! 😂😂😂

lol very nice, sabre came from china maybe? Real Sabres are really flexible & not brittle in the slightest ;)

Superior katana technology prevailed! :D Anyway I hope warranty will help :)

Why do you say "Ah"? Cause he already had a feeling that this word might become relevant soon.

i recently posted a video featuring a much higher quality saber vs a katana. neither broke.

NIPPON!!!!!

Dark Armory has quality control issues. Not the best one to go with. Purpleheart armory has more trusted manufacturers.

@fencingleprechaun

Жыл бұрын

Funny story, got a VB from PHA, had zero flex so Wasn't safe for sparring at all, I returned it and got a darkwood witch was a big upgrade, five years of weekly sparring and tournaments and it's still better than any VB I ever held. Tho PHA is a reseller so they carry other swords now as well. Swords that are still made by hand can have defects, judge a company by how cool they are about fixing an issue.

저서양검술 이 내가 익힌건데요. 중국검술 과 함께.

제목ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

Love how the names of the sword changes depending on the country. Saber ,Sable ,Sabre, broadsword are all used here to describe the Chinese Doa ? The Jian demoted to merely the straight Sword ! There doesn't seem to be any agreement or even knowledge of H.E.M.A broadswords or a true Eastern Europe Saber ! Im in shock because i came to learn the Rapier but most have no idea of it ? What country 🇪🇸 yes Spain and cannot find fencing or even reasonable equipment . As for this video 🤔 what a shocker !! Katana wins again 💪 As much as i adore Tàijíquán and the Jian 🗡️ my experience with the Katana or multiple katanas x2/x4 will always hold the Katana design as the most useful.

Ho no x)

xd...

This was clearly a poorly-fabricated saber. A good steel should not have broken that way. Maybe they forgot to temper the blade. Maybe the blade had a flaw or crack from the original tempering process. I wouldn't buy another one from that manufacturer.

What is "saber"? And this is not sabre anyway :)

Made in China or sum?

How can a kenjitsu man use saber . Just make good content 🎉 expert vs expert. Katana vs saber

That's to bad

Use guns, gunpowders, and bullets. Works better.

lol very nice, sabre came from china maybe? Real Sabres are really flexible & not brittle in the slightest

@Dancorg

Жыл бұрын

nop, darkwood armory is from USA