You guys are way too dismissive talking about music. Just sounds like you’re hating on the people that like the music rather than the music itself.

Silent Way in C? You're killing me...

I'm with you guys. Your entire S tier deserves to be in the top 50. I would maybe include Velvet Underground and Nico and In Rainbows in there too. Others knocking on the door for me would be Remain in Light, Disintegration, Hounds of Love and Kind of Blue. The rest aren't in the conversation at all. Especially, to include all this music from the last 20 years in the top 50 is a bit of a joke. Top 500, maybe, but these are not the greatest albums of ALL TIME. There are so many important artists from the 60s 70s and 80s that are out of favour but it still doesn't diminish their greatness.

Mentioning the people who think 'Lift Yr. Skinny Fists' changed their lives... yeah that would be me. Straight up one of my favorite albums I've ever heard. Love your guys' channel even if we have differing opinions though. And I do agree that people wouldn't hate RYM so much if more people participated and challenged the common taste profile on there.

Fantano crying now

You guys are on fire

Damn that F tier is salty

Those King Crimson records are absolutely transcendent

I don't expect I'll be the only person to say this, but A LOVE SUPREME IS NOT BEBOP. NOT EVEN REMOTELY.

I used to be a regular on RYM 20 years ago and I can’t believe how much it changed. Top 50 is completely different then it used to be. Where is Marquee Moon? Exile on Main Street? No Dylan??? It’s a cool sight to search things, but I got nothing in common with people on those message boards these days

My face before clicking the video: 😃

These are a great idea - keep them coming. 👍

Great video! I am enjoying this series.

Portishead , Cocteau Twins & Slowdive are All Tier A , I humbly say.

cant wait to watch this on my dinner break!

Three of these in my top 10 ever: "Lift Your Skinny Fists...", "Hounds Of Love" and "In Rainbows" (this one is close to become my #1 any of these days)

Good video guys. I guess I'll have to make a RYM account. We got to bring back a proper top 50.

I am slightly older than you guys and have used RYM for 16 years (I have watched you lads for a year I think?), I actually wish there was more weirdness on the top list, it is an aggregate of ratings, so I would love to see more regional and off track stuff get recognized. Really interesting personal choices. Most of the users are teenagers from the US and Europe (and some South Americans) so if more Middle Eastern, South East Asian, African voters start rating, things could get really exciting. I do think it is weird that there is only one metal album on the charts; makes little sense considering how much people there talk metal all day (at least one thrash or death metal album would be welcome.) I love that a Juan Gabriel mariachi album is the #4 live album of all time, you don't see that most places.

this shoud be good. The RYM bubble skewing rankings.

Great video! There are a couple of points where I disagree with the conclusions, but I'd rather learn from you than leave with a frustrated face. LIKE