Neil Peart undoubtedly is the best drummer that ever graced this planet, hands down, period.

@RB-rf8rf

Жыл бұрын

I dunno, Gavin Harrison has to be part of the discussion.

@WishMount

Жыл бұрын

i love the professor, but Matt Garstka blew my fucking mind in the last 5 years

@nodrush80

Жыл бұрын

Agree.

@bobkitten8150

Жыл бұрын

Neil redefined the role of percussion in rock music. It's not just a beat in the background, it's an important part of the song.

@Tonyr0206

Жыл бұрын

Let me start of by saying that I'm a huge Neil Peart and Rush fan. Neil was a great Rock drummer, and probably the most influential drummer in the past 40 years, but there are much better drummers out there. I'm not being argumentative. I've been playing and studying the drums for over 40 years, so I've got a bit of knowledge on the subject. LOL Neil's contribution in the world of drumming can't be quantified, but to say he's the best that ever graced the planet is a stretch. Check out Vinnie Colaiuta, Dave Weckl, Joe Morello, Buddy Rich, Virgil Donati, Steve Smith, Thomas Lang, Jojo Mayer, Mike Mangini, Todd Sucherman, or Marco Minnemann. Buddy and Joe have paved the way for guys like Neil...and have elevated the art form to the point that 60 years later, people are still analyzing them and trying to figure out how they played the way they did. Guys like Vinnie and Dave, taken drumming to new heights far beyond what people thought was possible, even 10 years ago. Check all these guys out. You won't be disappointed.

The greatest rock instrumental ever written. ❤️❤️

@jimmywhetton1141

Жыл бұрын

And no Grammy

@cochese95

11 ай бұрын

Ok I’m a huge rush fan so trying not to be biased but can you honestly think of another instrumental that’s as good?

@lucaarcobello6341

10 ай бұрын

@@cochese95ktulu, orion

@gardensup52

8 ай бұрын

​@@lucaarcobello6341No

@gardensup52

2 ай бұрын

​@@lucaarcobello6341No

The unbelievable thing to me with this song is that they wrote this when they were 23-25 years old...crazy talent!!!

Alex Lifeson is one of the greatest guitarists of the rock era.

This performance was in Cleveland, in 2011, when Geddy and Alex were age 58 and Neil was age 59. As you could see, this was the opening song of their encore. Before this song was played, the band had already given its fans 2.5 hours' worth of their finest music. Wonder and be amazed!

@25newrush

Жыл бұрын

And Neil at 59 did an 8 1/2 minute drum solo on top of all that. He is incredible!!!

@edzeljereza8234

Жыл бұрын

....and the whole album Moving Pictures from beginning to end.

@oldnsleepysmitty5503

Жыл бұрын

Absolute professionals

@oldnsleepysmitty5503

Жыл бұрын

I dont know if any other band could make that musical weirdness float during Lifesons second "sassy" solo..but they surely did...masters

@jackteppo9633

Ай бұрын

I was here😊

On the album you will hear Alex Lifeson shredding on acoustic guitar at the beginning of this song. The polka circus music was a fun change up. This song was based on a series of nightmares that Alex Lifeson had and it was written in 1978. Brilliant!

At times during this epic tune - you swear there is three solos going on at the same time. The way these guys could jam together was impeccable. There will never be another Rush. RIP professor!

How can a trio have so many WOW moments. Best ever. Enough said.

Plus the most underrated bass and rock guitarist ever! Simple!

Best drummer hands down. Best band hands down. Best friends hands down. Best individual musicians hands down!!! G.O.A.T!

There will never be another Rush... And that gives me comfort. A fan since 2112 came out in 1976... Rest in Power, Professor.

RUSH is hands down the greatest band of all time

And the best bassist and guitarist! Simple!

Fun fact .. the front row at their concerts are reserved for very special people .. professional Air Drummers .. LOL

Many like to cite YYZ as a benchmark for Rush excellence. As fun as that song is, we all know it is this beast that is a true benchmark.

@dmusiclife5727

Жыл бұрын

YYZ live in Rio was out introduction into Rush and it’s still our all time favorite. But this one just seemed to be on a whole different level technically.

What you have here is a once in a lifetime band that Will never be matched. They were masters of there instruments and there music and songs are so deep. You will never equal them. RIP Neil Peart, and may Alex and Geddy live forever

Nobody can beat them live! They are the best ever!

What I find most amusing is how with each tour they changed something in the music and still opened up spaces for improvisation.

Just a thought, "Animate" live in Frankfurt and The Main Monkey Business, R40 tour live.

Every reaction video I see that's has Rush, the people always have big smiles listening to these geniuses of music

That was an update to the original 1978 version from the "Hemispheres" album. You should hear the studio version. Also, the live version from 1981 "Exit Stage Left" show -- the CD/audio version is all that is available -- is really amazing! Rush is incredible. This song blew everyone away, back in the day!

I was at this show in Cleveland and it was so awesome it’s almost too awesome to even describe it to someone who wasn’t there. I wish you two could have witnessed the magic of RUSH live. It’s unlike anything else you have ever experienced. Thanks for doing RUSH again. You guys truly “get it”!! This was filmed in 2011. FYI.

I love how they are out there having fun while blowing our minds with talent

Neil remember wrote all of their songs, and then played them out,flawless all hail to the professor!

Another great reaction!! STILL...arguably, one of the greatest pieces of music, by three of the greatest musicians of all-time. Rush has said that this is one of, if not, their most difficult songs to perform...and they did it live, with slight improvisations, FLAWLESSLY. Their music is a gift to all of us...those who have listened to them for years and those, just discovering their music for the first time. They were incredible...but their music is TIMELESS.

I first saw them in concert in 1980 and never missed a tour until the end. BEST BAND EVAR!

Love your channel guys! For some perspective on this song, you should check out the official Rush video for this song - it's a raw, live sound check performance of the song shortly after it was written in the late 70's. Being an early recording, there's much more tension in the song and it sounds harder/heavier - probably because it was new and they had to focus a bit more to pull it off... but they most certainly pulled it off!

IMHO this is hte greatest rock instrumental ever written and ever performed live. It really demonstrates their musical genius and prowess.

I was there in the upper middle section... looking directly at the stage 4/15/2011. My birthday... what a fantastic time 🙂👍

Miss the boys like one can miss oxygen.

Rush was a band like no other. As you said, the times pretty much dictate this will never be done again. Luckily, we have all their past concerts to show how amazing they were! When I saw this tour, I was as amazed as the first time I heard it on the album, and I have seen them over ten times throughout their career. They always blew me away live. They must have practiced non-stop to pull off some of their songs in concert.

If you loved that performance. Then you simply have to look up RUSH LIVE AT PINKPOP 79. That performance of LA VILLA will blow your mind. Please trust me on this... .. you'll thank me for it.

According to the Rush documentary, when they wrote this song as an instrumental on Hemispheres it had to be recorded in 3 parts. But they play this instrument all the time from R-30 onwards. The best live show of this instrumental is from the Pink Pop Festival in 1978 or 1979.

When you see the official video of this back in the 70’s at the end the last image is Neil Peart smiling and wiping off his face. My psychology professor in college loved RUSH. I used to tease him that Peart was smiling at him saying: THERE YA GO MEAN GENE! We called him that because in statistics class we learned about the MODE, MEDIAN, AND MEAN of a group of numbers. So the whole class chant was MEAN MEAN GENE DONT GO TO THE EXTREME! Yes he let us call him by his first name!

the reason why rush is the best band on the planet is because of NEIL- the way he writes music and portrays them to Geddy and Alex to sing or play is paramount - these three men Genius of music are musicans first.....and the rest follows......its all about music 1st and the stage show is 2nd this is a MASTERCLASS of music........I would honestly say if Beethoven or Bach was alive today they would be amazed.........Geddy Lee - Alex Lifeson and (RIP Neil Peart) THANK YOU NEIL

Greatest rock instrumental

When the musicians are enjoying themselves the music becomes emotion..................🥳

You played my fav version of this. Thank you!

Imagine seeing them Live. Unbelievable!

People watching performances by Mozart probably thought much the same as those watching this being performed for the first time. Live. This. Was LIVE. Absolute geniuses, all three.

That guitar solo is one of the most beautiful in all of rock, and sadly, most rock fans have never heard it.

@gardensup52

Жыл бұрын

Yeah, it's really sad that most people think Slash is a better guitar player😂

Loved the input from the nice lady! She was intense!

Vinny Paul and mike portnoy both said in a rush doc that this was the drumming high bar for them growing up

The greatest instrumental ever by the greatest band ever. P.S. this was the first encore that night, the second was Working Man which you already reviewed. 😊

The intro is a tribute to "Rash" the oompah band that covers Rush songs with Tuba / Accordion.

You have the best bass player, guitar player, and the best drummer in a band... you get MAGIC! =)

Their live performances can still move me emotionally, even after seeing them scores of times…

Best instrumental....ever 😊

Check out any of their live songs from Rush in Rio. That was the biggest crowd they ever played for. In fact, check out the La Villa Strangiato on that video - it gives you a more accurate representation of the beginning of the song (no polka, though it is great, it's not natural.) And yes. This is the greatest rock instrumental of all time. Live or otherwise. Most people's favorite part of a Rush show as the drum solo, or Tom Sawyer. This song was always my favorite part. It's just a colossal piece of writing and musicianship.

Damn, Neil has the tempo jacked on this one. Should check out the studio release and compare. About the washing machines. These days you don't need the big amp stack on stage. You generally have one small speaker backstage in an iso cabinet mic'd up. Geddy had no problem getting rid of his stacks, but Alex still wanted the big wall of amps behind him. So while they were touring the road crew was thinking the stage looked a little lopsided. So during the tour, somehow, they sourced a bunch of old dryers and washing machines to stack up on Geddys side of the stage. And it just kinda stuck and became their thing.

I was at that show. Live in Cleveland. Time Machine tour.

Isn't it amazing what 3 people can do to make such awesome musical art

Such a great reaction to watch of my all time favorite band. I'll be following you here (not a stalker lol). good fun. If no one mentionedthtis, Alex had an actual dream, and hence this song.

I grew up on Rush, Van Halen, Pink Floyd, Etc. If you like instrumentals and rock and roll. Check out the all female Japanese progressive hard rock band called Band-Maid. Check out one of their instrumentals named "From Now On". Jimmy Page loves the drummer and the bass player is insane. The guitar work is also next level.

Those "washing machines" were supposed to be time machines as this performance was from their Time Machine Tour Live In Cleveland in 2011 but they did have washing machines, popcorn machines, chicken rottisserie machines, sausage making machines behind them in other tours. The story behind those various appliances behind them stems back to when Geddy Lee stopped using their own amps and speakers and just hooked up to the house sound system. Pretty soon he found it boring that there was an empty space behind him so he started putting in those appliances. In the meantime Alex ever the stubborn one stuck to using his own stack and speakers but pretty soon decided to join in on the fun and put his own machines but still used his amps and speakers either behind or to the side.

i love the the look neil gives geddy at 8:27..as they get back up to normal tempo...

Alex had a bad dream, wake up and create a masterpiece. Me had a bad dream wake up and watch TV.

Most of your Rush reactions are super energetic and enthusiastic, this one however I feel your brain literally couldn't comprehend the absolute musical annihilation thus turning you into a statue of disbelief and bewilderment.

I've been to 2 Rush concerts in my life, but I wish I could've been to more. My favorite version of this song is actually from the A Show of Hands live video. These 3 guys make music some bands with 10 guys wish they can make. The reason they're my all-time favorite rock band.

Seen them live MANY times and they brought it every time , musically and visually. Always a great show.

You nailed it. This performance and this group is timeless. It will never be duplicated. Those of us that were lucky enough to see it live witnessed living legends and magic in a bottle that will never again be duplicated. All you can do is thank them for the music and share it with others.

I saw them play during this tour and I bought a VIP ticket 3 hours after tickets went on sale, and the rest of the seats in the amphitheater were already almost all sold out (18,000 seats. And they extended it to 3 shows instead of just 2. I was there for show #2). I managed to have a seat directly in front of Alex 10 feet from the stage. They were AWESOME.

Buy Hemispheres. This was La Villa Strangeioto (An Exercise In Self-Indulgence) -- actual title of the track, in 1978. The reason these tracks sound so phenomenal is the great Terry Brown worked with Rush during their most seminal years. Just unforgettable. They recorded the album in the UK because of their love for YES they wanted to be over there to make a disc, right after their seminal and big F to the label, 2112, who threatened to pull their record deal. The fans fell in love with 2112, went Platinum and the label let them do whatever the hell they wanted from there on out.

Just shivers

I loved the looks of confusion on your faces during the circus clown show version at the beginning, while we all knew Rush was about to kick the door open with rock and roll awesomeness just a few seconds later!

Yes, yes it is 🤘

Love the reactions. Neil”s last name is pronounced P ear t. Just an FYI.

I used to listen to this every day before bed at night ages ago... Amazing.

This is an abbreviated version of the song. Drives me nuts listening to it.

Villa has always been my fave.. Catalogue is VAST but check out : Best I Can.. YYZ.. Cinderella Man.. Xanadu.. Trees.. Working Man.. Entres Nous.. and about 50 others.

RUSH......This is the way.

I listen to three genres of music: classical, jazz, and Rush.

You guys do know this is a song from 1979 on the album 'Hemispheres' its called La Vita Strangiato. Just in case you did'nt know 😮 😮 😮

Great reactions as usual. Rush is one of my all time favorites. Try reacting to Loren Allred--- Britan Got Talent. Over the top vocal

May I suggest listening to the version from Exit stage left.

They were dryers, filled with merch shirts, they tossed them into the audience at the show when I saw them at SPAC

You must realize....they are 3 virtuoso's, all in the same band.....unheard of. There will NEVER be another band that comes close....ever. As always, RIP to "The Professor"....greatest drummer to ever sit behind the kit.

hello to the Rush fans and the soon to be Rush fans. I really enjoy watching these reaction vids BUT I have too make this one little comment listen to the studio versions first please you need to know what the original song is then the live version. Rush does odd intros to be sure BUT live its the same and then you realize they dont jam live its the song reproduced live that is part of the rush legend now. I saw them 3 times live each was just as amazing as the first time. here in Canada they are like saints or next best thing. They are great ambassadors Canada. We all miss Rush (tear).

The washing machines and such started popping up when the technology changed making the giant wall of amps unnecessary. They thought the stage looked empty without them and wanted to fill in the space. Having the sense of humor they have they went with the washer/dryers. They even had roadies coming out during songs to change loads. They also did chicken roasters back there. Had the roadies coming out and basting the birds lol. Such a great band

Right song. Wrong version

Really wish you would have done the studio version first then the live version.

The greatest song ever.

They poked fun of themselves so much it was great. You should react to the Live in Rio version (full) where Alex goes off on some tangents being his usual goofy self that even Neil and Geddy gave him looks of "What?". great job. keep up the great work.

Yes. Yes it is.

Saw them in Frankfurt during the R30 tour. Best concert I ever had. And yes... the three had fun playing :)

The washing machines on the stage contain tshirts that they then throw out into the crowd at the end of the show. I was lucky enough to see them soon after their R30 tour. I don't think I blinked or closed my mouth the entire time.

Absolute mastery "

Make sure you check out the album version. The guitar intro smokes!! 🔥

Well Geddy,,,Alex may not be able to play Starship Trooper but he sure can play La Villa

Everybody plays air-guitar at rock shows... but at a RUSH concert, you get just as many fans playing air-DRUMS! lol

This is one of the true masterpieces from Rush.

Awesome, thanks for reacting!

Oh, my! Do The Camera Eye live. .. mind blowing! Thanks for the Rush!

more more more rush

You said timing. There timing is the best of all time to me.....

There are many recordings of La Villa in concert and it is some of the best playing that Rush does. It really is all three of them jamming together and just having fun. As you listen to every one of the recordings you notice that early recordings are more focused on the each of them playing their parts and creating and riffing themselves. As you listen to more recent ones they not only rip their own parts they begin to riff off what the other guys are playing. If you notice how Ged plays on Neil's fills... with the same rhythm as Neil... And visa versa Neil plays on Ged's solo parts matching his rhythm. Fricken amazing.

….AND THE PH.D IN GREATEST INSTRUMENTALIST OF ALL TIME GOES TO: RUSH: LA VILLA STRANGIATO!!!

I prefer both the studio and original video versions of this song. But this is still a good vetsion..

I love a lot of music from a lot of bands but jesus, yeah, Rush are on a whole different level of musicianship from 3 guys in concert. They literally have no equal.

Exit Stage Left La Villa Strangiatto is the best solo ever. He slowed downed a lot here.