Robin Hood reviewed by Mark Kermode
Фильм және анимация
Mark Kermode reviews Robin Hood. A Crusader returns to England to find the country plagued by corruption and cruelty. Determined to reclaim the Crown for its rightful owner, he leads a revolt against the Sheriff of Nottingham’s regime.
Please tell us what you think of the film -- or Mark’s review of the film. We love to include your views on the show every Friday.
If you like this, why not subscribe to our podcast for more reviews, interviews and general wittering of the highest order: www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00l...
Twitter: @Wittertainment
www.bbc.co.uk/5live
Fridays at 2pm on BBC 5 live.
Пікірлер: 203
Hollywood should make a film about a production company money laundering by making bad Robin Hood and King Arthur films.
@bebaguette766
5 жыл бұрын
@GiRayne Nice.
@livinginvancouverbc2247
5 жыл бұрын
They could call it "Spring Time for Hitler".
@titmusspaultpaul5
5 жыл бұрын
Lol.... it would end up being a 4 hour movie..... or longer.
@bebaguette766
5 жыл бұрын
@@livinginvancouverbc2247 Damn, didn't notice the similarities.
@TheArtkaw
5 жыл бұрын
The Coen Brothers should direct.
Whoever decided to greenlight a $100 million Robin Hood film (and then put it out in the US the same time as Creed 2 and Ralph Breaks the Internet) needs to be fired. Hollywood needs to stop trying to make big budget Robin Hood/Peter Pan/King Arthur films happen, they're not going to happen any more!
@joeodonnell921
5 жыл бұрын
Yup 3 musketeers usually makes an appearance aswel
@tigermunky
5 жыл бұрын
They never worked in the first place. I mean, fair play for trying again, but there's surely a point when a studio needs to just give up trying to give life to a rock.
@kpbelshaw
5 жыл бұрын
I think they can be done right, for some reason Hollywood just keeps doing them wildly wrong!!
@cheekyboy5000
5 жыл бұрын
or spend more than 50 cents on the script and directing.
@KJ_1810
5 жыл бұрын
Summed it up perfectly.
Costumes as designed by Kanye West and Gucci
Men in tights is the best Robin Hood film ever. No one's gonna beat that.
@fullygraciousedits8238
5 жыл бұрын
When you film franchise gets parodied well, it's probably time to stop making sequels, young Frankenstein, men in tights, Spaceballs, airplane.....
@sadlobster1
5 жыл бұрын
What about The Adventures of Robin Hood with Errol Flynn or Disney's Robin Hood
@thejoin4687
5 жыл бұрын
CBBC's Maid Marian is where it's at.
Mark ... Robin Hood Prince of Thieves is a damn classic. For no other reason than the fact that it gave us Alan Rickman threatening to cut Kevin Costner's heart out with a spoon.
@pamelairving4818
2 жыл бұрын
And to cancel Christmas..🤞
Errol Flynn, dead for almost 60 years, effortlessly retains first place as Robin Hood.
Is there a reason Robin Hood films are constantly being pumped out despite, from what I can see, zero interest in the character or lore?
@charliepanayiotou4305
5 жыл бұрын
The character is public domain. Doesn't explain why they spend so much on the films though...
@richarddixon1450
5 жыл бұрын
Because we've heard of him/it.
@charliepanayiotou4305
5 жыл бұрын
@@richarddixon1450 Doesn't stop the films from bombing though
@richarddixon1450
5 жыл бұрын
@@charliepanayiotou4305 oh I know. Think we all wish Hollywood would put time and effort into new original ideas and creators
@vincevirtua
5 жыл бұрын
@@richarddixon1450 they do, people don't go see them
I can't wait to visit Nottingham again after watching this. I can't remember the mountains which surround the city, although there still a few steep streets in the town...
Another Robin Hood movie nobody asked for.
@joynerkt
5 жыл бұрын
mappyhappychappy 😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
What public domain characters could actually headline a franchise? I mean I wouldn't mind a Dostoyevsky cinematic universe (The Depressors), but that wouldn't make bank.
@TulilaSalome
5 жыл бұрын
Shakespeare is too obvious. Canterbury tales? Not PG-13 enough? Jane Austen has already been sort of done... but not enough! Der Niebelungen is underutilized, like someone made a 16 hour musical number of it that has sort of a cult following, but surely less caterwauling and more explosions would make it A-OK.
@gunark
5 жыл бұрын
Clearly it’s time for a Bible Universe to appear. There’s tons of crazy ones in there.
@GoldenGyroBalls
5 жыл бұрын
Don't give them ideas.
@MrRjhyt
5 жыл бұрын
Given the time of year. Usually A Christmas Carol, Oliver Twist, or other Dickensian tales.
@emile1365
5 жыл бұрын
@@gunark Wasn't that started with Darran Aronofskys rendition of Superboat, I mean Noah!?
It’s kind of crazy that after all these years, only three films I can think of-The Adventures of Robin Hood (Michael Curtiz), Robin Hold (Disney), and Men in Tights (Mel Brooks)- have remained the most faithful to the spirit of the original stories. And two of them are arguably spoofs!
He's playing the same character that he did, in Rogue One
@charliepanayiotou4305
5 жыл бұрын
And Ready Player One!
@mragunathan1627
5 жыл бұрын
and from the looks of it, the same costume too XD
@terencechesney9098
5 жыл бұрын
@@mragunathan1627 That caught my attention too!
@Declan_Lyons
5 жыл бұрын
And the Dark Knight Rises.
I’m pretty sure the director was actually shouting at Ben Mendelssohn “No Ben, do it EXACTLY LIKE YOU DID IT IN ROGUE ONE”. I hope he’s one of these actors that doesn’t turn roles down instead of picking a bit of a stinker like this, he’s genuinely menacing (Animal Kingdom) when he’s not being asked to camp it up.
@calvinlaw7790
5 жыл бұрын
Ian McGurren He’s absolutely terrifying in Animal Kingdom. Honestly, he’s one of the best actors working today based on his more low profile stuff (Mississippi Burning, Beautiful Kate, Starred Up), it’s a shame Hollywood just gives him mostly Generic Hissy Fit Villain roles to play.
@sweetchristmas101
5 жыл бұрын
Sort of like Christoph Waltz once he was "discovered" Tarantino.
FYI: "A duster is a light, loose-fitting long coat. The original dusters were full-length, light-colored canvas or linen coats worn by horsemen to protect their clothing from trail dust. These dusters were typically slit up the back to hip level for ease of wear on horseback." Thank you Wikipedia
Putting aside Crowes accent I enjoy that version was the most realistic. They were gonna make two more I would have liked to have seen how they did it.
@ExtremeBogom
5 жыл бұрын
I liked the Ridley Scott version too. It's probably the best Robin Hood film of recent years. Is it silly? Yes, but all films in this canon tend to be. Acting wise it has a good cast, the cinematography and set pieces are well-done too. I remember people dismissed it at the time as being "Gladiator-lite" and that people thought Russell was just too old for it, but it honestly works well enough for what it is.
Here's a bit of interesting information for you. On Wendy Carlos' website, she talks about the Eltro, an early analog device that allowed you to do what is commonly done digitally nowadays: independently control the pitch or speed of a sound. The Eltro was used to to the voice slowdown of Hal singing "Daisy". It's not as simple as "slowing the tape down" which is what I'd thought they'd done. Furthermore, Kubrick told Carlos that Douglas Rain's voice had been slightly slowed down for the entire performance. That might be the key to why the cadence of his speech just feels very slightly unnatural, which is such an important part of what makes it so unnerving. Not in any way to detract from Rain's performance, because the way he speaks and pitches his voice is entirely his work, but an interesting little detail in the making of the film which I hadn't seen elsewhere.
@chrisofnottingham
5 жыл бұрын
This would be a great comment to put under the Voice Recognition / Douglas Rain video
@ajostuder
5 жыл бұрын
chris4072511 done that! bloody app jumped videos on me.
Need Jason Isaacs with a handlebar mustache stat.
So happy to see the return of King Arthur Daley, ee's alright. Ok so ee's done a bit of thievin, it's not a crime is it?
Just give me Richard Green from the English TV series 1950s I enjoyed as as a boy.
@nifralo2752
3 жыл бұрын
With Patrick Troughton?
I had suspicions about that King Arthur movie the moment looked at the poster and noticed his " ZARA " sheepskin jacket from the popular high street retailer. I thought this is is gonna be c**p. Unless they declare it a "spoof".
I was appalled by Crowes accent in The Mummy. His My Hyde sounded like Ray Winstone with a case of Jaundice.
I was hoping that Mark wouldn’t disappoint me...... he didn’t disappoint me.
I saw this, it was terrible. Spot on about the crusades scene the soldiers are moving through the city with bows like they're in a modern urban war with rifles. CQB in the crusades fought with bows apparently. Oh and that first scene of the crusades the Crusaders quite literally have to flank and take out a machine-gun-ballista that has the squad pinned down. Was so absurd.
@ayebraine
Жыл бұрын
I mean that was clearly the point. It's not like they're hiding it, they're SHOUTING it at you from the screen, that it's a take on a crusade that's basicaly action-movie Fallujah firefight.
Errol Flyn 1938😊
@neilhutchinson4545
5 жыл бұрын
Olivia De Havilland 😍
The Disney one is the best
It feels just like Batman Begins from the training scenes, the rooftop chase and the Restaurant scene. And then the battle scene from TDKR music and all.
Best of the Robin Hood movies is "Robin And Marion", with Sean Connery and Audrey Hepburn. One of the great details about that film is how the Sheriff (Robert Shaw) is not evil, he's actually quite a layered character, but he just happens to be Robin's rival because he is Nottingham's figure of authority, appointed by a previous king, making a living by performing his duties with no mustache-twirling melodrama.
For a second I thought Mark said "They Called in The Rock" like really lol.
Sorry to be that guy, but Kevin Costner arrived at the Seven Sisters in Sussex. :-)
@comanchio1976
4 жыл бұрын
oap23 Cuckmere Haven is a real place!! Well colour me astonished!
Strange affection for Robin Hood? Why is it strange? It’s an amazing story with a lot of relatable themes that are still present today.
When an animated fox is the best Robin Hood movie in the last 50 years.
Love the grimly fiendish reference
I heard it borrows HEAVILY from the plot of Batman Begins.
@MrRjhyt
5 жыл бұрын
It did end rather openly, and follow many super hero tropes, and action scenes. It also feels a little pantomime, with it's lack of subtlety.
@Luvie1980
5 жыл бұрын
And the style of kingsmen
@tanisdevelopment
5 жыл бұрын
You mean Jamie Foxx turns out to be Prince John?
@TheArtkaw
5 жыл бұрын
Uuuuuughhhhh
@MDBowron
5 жыл бұрын
@@MrRjhyt and Jamie Dorman's turn into the bad guy is basically Harvey to Two-Face from The Dark Knight, and the whole people rebelling against the sherriff is basically from The Dark Knight Rises.
This film is basically call of duty meets Batman with bow and arrows. There is also a bit that is basically a car chase but with chariots. It’s the sort of film that only works on a big sound system and a big screen. It’s not going to change your life but I found it great fun.
Still my favourite part of Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves, walking to Nottingham via Hadrian's Wall.
@worldofthought8352
5 жыл бұрын
I get the impression it was one of those moments the screenwriters knew was factually incorrect but wanted to throw in that so other audiences picked up on cultural references regardless on "accuracy"
@MarlboroughBlenheim1
4 жыл бұрын
Do you think Americans know this?
'Russel Crowe's accent was a geographical pitstop!' 😂😂😂😂
@Snipergoat1
5 жыл бұрын
No that was a reviewer pitstop. If they want realism, Robin and co. would be speaking middle English and no one would understand anything they said.
I am almost curious to watch it now just to see how it could be so amazingly weird
Ben Mendelsohn sounds like he's imitating Donald Sutherland in 'Revolution.'
In all seriousness the only good robin hood movie is the disney version.
It reminded me of a bad version of Batman Begins
I feel like this and King Ar'fur: Legend of the Sword would make a great 'so bad they're good' double bill.
@bocusfocus9714
4 жыл бұрын
I thought Legend if the Sword was really good tbh 🤷🏽♂️
I think I would forgive Tim Minchin, an Australian, for having a hint of an Australian accent.
@richardscales9560
5 жыл бұрын
his accent wasn't the least believable bit in the clip
Who In town made that coat Ben is wearing?
We need a Sheriff of Not Again.
What was the issue with Kingsman 1&2
@ryanillingworth5333
5 жыл бұрын
Most people were critical of the a-hole end scene. That'd be my guess. Not seen 2nd yet.
It is a complete shame, Because I personally love the story of Robin Hood. There is a reason some stories are clasics or legends. We haven’t thrown away stories for being old, so I am ok with having remasters of stories. So there are a number of Robin Hood movies out there, the shame is, why don’t you want to make the movie good? Seriously, I am sure many people like the story and myths of Roin Hood, but crappy movies? Crappy movies are going to tarnish stories. What I mean by that, it isn’t that it suddenly makes the story bad, but if you suddenly think of a crappy movie because of it, then you don’t care about it.
"I know writers who use subtext...."
Wait a min! I was looking for a movie review on the one that Russell Crowe played in. I got maybe three minutes in this video and I'm confused as all out trying to remember when Marion tried to steal his horse and trying to remember the sheriff of Nottingham looking like he went to a fetish Nazi cosplay party. So I turned to Google trying to remember this costume design. That's when I learned there's a new Robin Hood movie that came out in 2018! Are you kidding me?! Well I saw the trailer for it just a few minutes ago and yeah, now I see what you're talkin about. I haven't actually watched the movie but at least I have a grasp of why you're saying the things you're saying. I'll probably eventually watch this Robin Hood movie just out of pure curiosity. I want to see the direction they've taken this version of the story. It looks a little too modern as far as the costume designs and yeah the explosions seem way too outrageous. But there was a moment in the trailer that made me laugh. So, if I can watch it as a comedy, (maybe it's meant to be a comedy), I just may enjoy it. I love Robin Hood stories and I love to see everyone's take on it when there's a new movie that comes out. I grew up of course on Disney's version with the fox playing Robin Hood and the lion as King Richard. I didn't grow up with Robin hood as a bedtime story or anyting. My dad is, was, Mexican and my mom is Caucasian with British, possibly Irish or Scottish descent. She did not have too many old world stories and neither did my dad really. My grandma who lived with us did but I don't remember really any of her stories. Anyhow, we're Americans and the stories I grew up on were like my dad's ghost stories from Mexico when he would go visit his uncle. Or stories from his hippie days. So I really don't know if most American kids grew up with Robin Hood stories outside of Cinema or a book in school because I never got traditional stories like that growing up. And no one at school ever talked about the bedtime stories their parents would read to them. Anyways I'm glad I came across your channel because now I got a new movie I've got to watch. I never would have known about sheriffs possible Nazi fetish kinks had I not been trying to find a movie review of the Robin Hood featuring Russell Crowe. Well I've babbled on enough. I'll go watch this video now that I know what the heck your discussing here.
Marks' description of Ben Mendelsohn had me laughing so hard, coke came out of my nose. (Coca Cola...)
Your review made me laugh. It looks like a dog's breakfast of a movie. And BTW, Tim Michen is Australian not British. Great review.
AK-45s, brilliant.
Best Robin Hood = John Cleese.
@Cartoonman154
5 жыл бұрын
Rik Mayall.
I thought this was an extended episode of Arrow.
Won"t ever beat Disney's adaptation.
Robin of Sherwood doesn't get enough credit. Nearly every version since has Marion in the forest and a Moor in the Merries, not to mention a bonkers Sheriff. It's a lot more fun than the last few dull versions
great. Thank you for the video. :D
Sounds like absolute toilet.
2:32 Should have been steam punk and dropped the girlfriends lover bit
Best Robin Hood = Rik Mayall.
Guess I'll stick to robin hood: men in tights.
It was pretty good to go see it with friends but it's not a film to see alone. A fun movie with a ton of action. P.S. I never said the action is that good.
What the hell was that clip? That's supposed to be Robin Hood?
There must be a gap in the market for a historically accurate version of Robin Hood.
@jrd33
3 жыл бұрын
Possibly, but not a $100 million gap.
@lw3646
7 ай бұрын
I doubt he existed, but they just need to make something half decent. The new French 3 Musketeers films were good.
Robin of Hoxton
LOL!!!! Good to know the film is pretty much as I expected! :D Wont be watching it!
I honestly don't think anyone alive that didn't work on the film in some way expected it to be anything other than ignored.
Robin Hood part 75
I'm going to make a movie about Titanic. Don't you tell me how it ends!
They tried to modernize Robin Hood and bring the medieval to modern times so that modern audiences would understand it because they, modern audiences, are alive now in curremt time and have not lived at that time, the Middle Age, in history.
The best robin hood movie is Robin Hood Men in tights
Adam (Wayne) Morris was the best and most authentic Robin.
Sam Elliott springs immediately to the fore
I rather see a movie about King John. His life was way more interesting.
@thejoin4687
5 жыл бұрын
He had his little ways.
it was pants
AK 45s ?
A new Robin Hood film? Why?
I love he hates to movie so affably. So much more cutting than an angry rant.
I think he liked it
It’s ridiculous but I was thoroughly entertained and it made me smile and laugh a lot. It was fun
@sadlobster1
5 жыл бұрын
Fun how?
@sadlobster1
5 жыл бұрын
@Bilbo's Nuts By that logic, you must have zero taste in art or creativity. REAL entertainment takes time, thought, dedication and most of all, respect for the material. Those who made this flop had no respect for Robin Hood's legacy. All they cared about was making something "hip," "cool," "trendy," "edgy" and "grim." Which is NOT what Robin Hood is about, not at all
@sadlobster1
5 жыл бұрын
@Bilbo's Nuts That depends on who you're asking and those people you speak of seem to be a rather tiny minority. Almost everybody else prefers stuff with art, story, good acting, respect for the material and actual thought put into it
There is only one great "Robin Hood" movie in my opinion, and that's the '38 Errol Flynn version!
This movie is not a classic telling of Robin Hood, but it states that from the outset. Then, it proceeds to deliver epic set pieces, highlighted by magnificent lighting, and some snappy editing: the first being the war scene on foreign shores, which was split into three different types of action that clearly demonstrated Rob's character, thus moving the story forward. The color choices in the scene were smart and supported the visual storytelling. Overall, the action scenes throughout showed us things we've never seen before, e.g. the chase through the mines with horse riders leaping across elevated wooden ramparts while horse-drawn wagons swerved through the alley ways beneath, surrounded by explosions and arrow fire. Yes, the characters didn't fill out beyond one dimensional, but what about Ben Mendelsohn's delicious delivery of his traumatic past? F. Murray Abrams was clearly having a romp as the villainous cardinal in a couple of brief scenes. Taron Egerton is charming and accessible and has good chemistry with Jamie Foxx. The script is a bit hit and miss, but the performances are steady throughout, although Marion as the only female role was more of a set prop. The music romps along, but was a bit too generic. A memorable score could have lifted the film beyond almost good. The costume designs were the most uneven, and exaggerated that the film overall is uneven. And probably, the most iconic costume item - the HOOD - was the most bland. What the film misses is landing the context and any emotional weight of the stakes. And this seems to happen partly because it has deviated from the spirit of Robin Hood. But that doesn't mean you can't munch on some pop corn and ooh-aah at the spectacle. It is an action movie - with plenty of action. It's not trying to be anything else, thus the surface skimming is acceptable, and there's much in the production value to appreciate. We can't be craving inventiveness and entertainment in movies and then trounce on people for having a go at that. Stephen King was once told he writes crap; his reply: "Yes, but it's good crap." There are undeniably good aspects to this film, and while it didn't land properly for me, the people I watched it with had a great time.
Could they just leave it, it was good with the Flynn version and the Disney version and the bcc series. Just let it rest 😂
No joe whiley butting in, heaven.
The movie steals liberally from Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy. One particular scene between Jamie Foxx and Ben Mendelsohn is almost lifted verbatim from 'Batman Begins'. Whoever did the musical score owes Hans Zimmer and James Newton Howard a pot of gold. Passable entertainment, but certainly much better than Guy Ritchie's unfocused mess of a 'King Arthur' movie
Wish he would have mentioned Marion’s ridiculous outfits that are constantly showing way too much chest area!
It’s not a movie but Robin of Sherwood is the best Robin Hood. End of story 🤚
not really a review. so was it a good film or not?
@nvalid6712
5 жыл бұрын
@@davidjames579 It was so bad but it wasn't even funny bad
Only great thing in this movie is Dubrovnik...
Prince of Thieves is the best Robin Hood film.
Greatcoat.
@Oceanmachine27
3 жыл бұрын
Or duster
Where is Errol Flynn when u need im
Robinhood in Gotham...
AK45....?
I'd rather watch Zapped on Dave
Ben Mendelsohn was good in that show where they said John a lot and it never stopped raining. This on the other hand looks like a glorified panto.
'ak-45' lol
Oh god, as I expected...It looks like King Arfur's cousin.. and it's a big fat NOPE from me. King arfur was one of the WORST films I've ever had the misfortune to watch.
The Tales of Robin Hood………ruined for another generation of movie goers.
Mark the main problem with the film is that there is no acting in the entire mind numbing turd of a film at all.
I just thought it was really odd, the costumes were very strange especially the women's outfits at the party/orgy, they were very modern, and would the men's hair really have been that well groomed and cropped. Also what accent did "maid" Marion have, was it American. I gave up watching part way through the second episode and do not think I will watch anymore. Sorry "Rob"