🔥Download Rise of Kingdoms and enjoy the great Egypt civilization 📱 Mobile: uberstrategist.link/Wizards-and-Warriors-Mobile-ROK 💻 PC: uberstrategist.link/Wizards-and-Warriors-PC-ROK 🎁Use bonus code: 22ROKEGYPT to get incredible gifts!

@pyeitme508

2 жыл бұрын

Meh

@clarkstartrek

2 жыл бұрын

The HBO series was, basically, a retelling of the historical events of the English "War of the Roses"! Armies marching to and fro, and noble families jostling for power, in any way they could get it.

@alphagamer9505

2 жыл бұрын

You guys need to put in this channel those videos of Asoaif that are in Kings and Generals Channel

@brokenbridge6316

2 жыл бұрын

This is all well n nice. But when are you going to do more Sci-Fi video's?

@eriksgasins9086

2 жыл бұрын

nice video! Have you read the books? :)

"Three victories doesn't make you a conqueror" "It's better than three defeats" Robb stark was a real badass

@marcbartuschka6372

2 жыл бұрын

As military leader he was quite good, yes. As a lord and politican he was on the other hand really dumb, since he was unable to see behind the masks of many people around him (or hear the advice of those people who had a better understanding of such things), and one time placing honor far too high and the other time far too low. The list of his mistakes is very, very long. His downfall was at least to some degree deserved.

@El_RibsJR

2 жыл бұрын

@@marcbartuschka6372 he didn't knew any better since he was raised that way he thought everyone would play honourably as did his father. But we both know tywin killed him because he was getting his ass kicked by a man who never saw battle before. Personally Rob was one of if not the most brilliant commander Westeros had ever seen

@marcbartuschka6372

2 жыл бұрын

@@El_RibsJR Well yes and no. I mean on the one hand he put the honor of Jeyne Westerling high, but on the other hand he tramples on the honor of his own word and on the honor of Lord Frey? I think that make not much sense (and let us not think too hard about what kind of guy goes to bed with a woman of a hostile family the night after he has heard from the death of his two younger brothers). And I would say he was not only the son of Eddard Stark but also of Catelyn Tully, but was far to often not to see that she did know a lot - and while the lady was not without flaws herself, she gave him more than once better advice that he ignored. I also do not think that Tywin was really that much afraid of Robb, at least after he had delt with Stannis and secured a alliance with the Tyrells. After that all Robb could hoped for was some kind of agreement, but the numbers were more and more against him. I mean at the moment Robb was killed he was already loosing the war. He was about to lead his northerners back home to drive away the Ironborn - leaving his "bannermen" in the Riverlands to the "mercy" of the Lannisters. He would be able to hold the Neck, for sure, but he must have known that there was little hope in defending anything south of the Green and Red Fork (and even that border was no longer secure). Here we also see how a curious thing Robb's "honor" was. He was proclaimed king of thr North AND the Riverlands (being half a Riverland-man himself), but always he put the interests of the North higher and was already in the process of abandoning those who had suffered the most in that war (the people in the Riverlands). I understand why he did that to a certain degree, but I think that shows that his honor is much more fragile than he himself thought.

@Bayard1503

2 жыл бұрын

@@El_RibsJR People underestimate both Ned and the Starks as whole... they became kings of the North by defeating hundreds of other lords, they were ruthless, conniving themselves. Ned was an amazing warden of the North, he wasn't underestimating anyone, he knew how to play them his own way... I don't think anyone put in his position had any chance... when basically everyone in King's Landing was his enemy. There was nobody he could rely on, nobody that was faithful to Robert. As for Robb... he was actually pretty cautious politically, what happened at The Twins is almost singular in the 8000 years of history of Westeros. It's unheard of to do something like that...

@El_RibsJR

2 жыл бұрын

@@Bayard1503 don't get me wrong the Starks are my favourite especially Robb but who in their right mind would tell the enemy their plan? That's exactly what Ned did and that's what gotten him killed in the first place much like Robb who married Jayne Westerling when he had formerly promised to marry Roslyn Frey. In short the Starks have the worst political mind but the best military one.

This young wolf has so much potential, i hope he ll end up on Iron throne.

@imp6505

2 жыл бұрын

Bruh

@RigbyWilde

2 жыл бұрын

who is gonna tell him?

@bobbydrake07017

2 жыл бұрын

🤣🤣🤣

@theliato3809

2 жыл бұрын

He doesn’t want a throne of iron but one of bronze and ice

@ChristianAuditore14

2 жыл бұрын

This traitor will never sit on Stannis throne

The Game of Thrones universe is probably the one that is best for the kind of documentaries Kings and Generals usually do. It has all the components of a real conflict, from tactics and strategies on the battlefield and threatens of operations, to politics, personal interests and inclinations of rulers, and even consider the impacts of the war on the economy, and of the economy on the war. I’m looking forward to next videos detailing all phases of the war. I only wonder if the channel will stick to the books, or borrow elements from the show when we reach the later stages of the conflict.

@sansonefabio8177

2 жыл бұрын

which is why I think GoT world building is the best. It’s realistic, consistent and cool

@CirBam24

2 жыл бұрын

@@sansonefabio8177 But takes a long ass time to get updated

@alphagamer9505

2 жыл бұрын

It seems they stick with the original material with videos in this channel

@Yugioh_Turk

2 жыл бұрын

I hope they follow the books strictly. There is too much bullshit in the show.

@Skandarr788

2 жыл бұрын

Hear me out. “The First Law”.

When Jamie attacked eddard on the streets of kings landing they killed his bodyguards not his bannermen. Bannermen are the lords that swore fealty to him, they men killed were just household guards

@alexv3357

2 жыл бұрын

Bannermen can also refer to any armed retainers, not just narrowly to lordly vassals

@reaver1414

2 жыл бұрын

@@alexv3357 then what does it mean to call the banners? I think you are thinking of sworn swords Like when Catelyn asked for help when arresting Tyrion she said that they were in service to her father's bannermen not that they were bannermen themselves

@alexv3357

2 жыл бұрын

@@reaver1414 Bannermen is a generic term for all armed retainers sworn to a given noble (although more often a Lord Paramount such as the Starks or Lannisters). Lords Bannermen are the lords sworn to that noble, but in that phrase bannerman is used _descriptively,_ as in they are vassals who carry a lord's banners. You do not have to be a lord to be a bannerman: landed knights and masterly houses (those who are not authorised to dispense the King's Justice, such as the Glovers of Deepwood Motte) are also bannermen. It is broadly true that bannermen is used to mean vassals of note as opposed to peasant levees, mercenaries, and freeriders, but there's no reason it means to _prescriptively._ All it means to be a bannerman is to be armed and in the service of a lord.

@reaver1414

Жыл бұрын

@@alexv3357 you're wrong but that's ok it's a free country and you're allowed to be wrong about stuff if you want to be. Never once in the books do they refer to a household guard as a bannerman. Unless you can quote an example you saying something is true doesn't make it true

Robert's hunting accident was not an accident. After being threatened by Ned Stark about revealing her incestous relationship, the Queen made sure Robert was served very strong wine during the hunt, making him drunk and slowing him down, allowing the boar to wound him.

@filipkowalewski4530

2 жыл бұрын

Well, that's likely something that historians of Westeros would likely argue about centuries later in their world.

@mokarokas-1727

2 жыл бұрын

Quite a gamble to trust a wild boar to show up, charge and wound one specific person in the party. Cersei might've tried this many times in a row and got lucky this time, or it's honestly a really dumb plan if he had to die right then.

@SirPeterKozlov

2 жыл бұрын

@@mokarokas-1727 Robert's favourite way of hunting boar was to wait until it charged, then he would dodge and skewer it. Cersei knew this of course, she tried to get him killed before as well, when she "forbid" him to participate in the melee in the tournament. She knew he would get angry and do the opposite of what she says.

@mokarokas-1727

2 жыл бұрын

@@SirPeterKozlov - Then it's like I said, she's been trying this stuff many times (even before Ned's warning) and got REALLY lucky this one time, JUST as the Lannisters were going to war. It's too convenient, I feel something must be missing.

@hammer3721

2 жыл бұрын

@@mokarokas-1727 Varys did say several times in the books that if the boar hadn't finished Robert, then it would have been a stray arrow, an insect, etc. Robert's fate was sealed. He was surrounded by Lannisters.

Would have loved to have seen this whole battle play out in the show.

@sansonefabio8177

2 жыл бұрын

Yes! I wish they had a huge budget from the start

@liamjm9278

Жыл бұрын

Didn't have the budget at the time. And when they did get the budget they decided to favour flash over logic. Trebuchet's on the front line, past the walls and ditches. A Zombie Polar bear that no one remembers.

@multiversesouls7217

Жыл бұрын

@@liamjm9278 Still would have loved to have seen this whole battle played out in the show. Didnt happen for multiple reasons. Still would have loved to have seen it though.

@jaredvennett4036

Жыл бұрын

It’s sad to see that this woke shit called “rings of power” that has nothing to do with Tolkien’s original material has a budget of 60million $ per episode for 1st season. But at the same time it seems like people with great passion having limited budget makes the shows count. I wish they filmed this battle in the later seasons by making Bran revisiting this battle to show us how it really happened. But instead we got “she’s ma queen, i dun want it”.

Great video, but one correction: Kevan Lannister is Tywin’s younger brother, not his cousin

@sparklespets

2 жыл бұрын

Also he's Ser Kevan, not Lord Kevan, as he is an anointed knight but holds no lordly titles

@boobah5643

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, it's all the younger generation Lannisters (like Lancel, Robert's cup bearer and Cersei's boytoy) that are cousins to our main characters.

Gregor Clegane: >doesn't understand tactics >charges blindly >succeds anyway

@ktheterkuceder6825

2 жыл бұрын

An 8 foot tall giant made of nothing but muscle and armoured well and who can move quite fast for a guy his size. Yeah I can see why that is.

@theliato3809

2 жыл бұрын

Gregors basically a medevil tank.

@jarrodbright5231

2 жыл бұрын

GREEEEEEEEGOR JEEEEEEENKIIIIIIINS

@nathanfrancis9411

5 ай бұрын

Soooo basically an eight foot tall Joan of Arc with a drinking problem

@Jwsponky

3 ай бұрын

>also mainly attacks unarmed peasants who couldn't much fight back if they tried.

Suggesting some corrections : - at 6:12 you misspoke when you said "their son's murder" referring to Bran. - Tyrion joined Tywin's army only at the crossroads, and by then Jaime had already won his early victories. Tyrion looks over the body of the innkeeper at the very inn where he was captured; she was brutally executed by Tywin as punishment for allowing his son's capture. - Ser Addam Marbrand is a young man, around Jaime's age, so I suggest changing his icon. - Ser Kevan Lannister is Tywin's younger and only living brother.

@alperenkays5933

2 жыл бұрын

Well said

@conanmcdonagh2619

2 жыл бұрын

Also, Tywin keeps his head shaven & wears shaggy mutton chops

@khalduras784

2 жыл бұрын

Also didnt Roose's defeat led to like the capture of some key northern lords that would spark more issues for robb and the ascension of house bolton down the line?

@hsgame4088

2 жыл бұрын

And one other thing Stannis didnt flee KL due to being anxious and scared because of John Aryns death,he was insulted that Robert didnt chose him as Hand of the king but instead went for Ned. A string of insults and slights from Robert had hurt him alot and this was the final straw,he knew that he couldnt do anything if he wasnt hand and even if he brought evidence to Robert he wouldnt believe him so he fled to Dragonstone.

@revanofkorriban1505

2 жыл бұрын

Additional corrections: Forley Prester led the camp east of the Red Fork. The camp whose men formed a shieldwall and fended off Robb's first charge were in the southwest camp, nestled between the Tumblestone and the Red Fork.

Nice to see you guys are going book based instead of the show. The story makes much more sense this way

@Yugioh_Turk

2 жыл бұрын

I hope they follow the books strictly. There is too much bullshit in the show.

@rashid527

2 жыл бұрын

Gladly they do that Because it’s the same with lord of the rings videos they follow the book

@Yugioh_Turk

2 жыл бұрын

​@@rashid527 I'm concerned that they may do the show because unlike Lord of the Rings, they'll eventually run out of books

@jackieclan815

Жыл бұрын

@@Yugioh_Turk Not with the "War of Five King" my friend!

@Yugioh_Turk

Жыл бұрын

@@jackieclan815 True. My concern is about the future episodes. For example, I wouldn't watch a Battle of the Bastards episode if it was based on the show version.

At 12:50 Ser Kevan is referred to as lord Tywins Cousin. This is incorrect as he is in Fact Lord Tywins younger Brother.

A few things you left out. 1) the ambush in the whispering wood they sent a group of horsemen to close the valley behind the Lannister forces to prevent their retreat and the attack started with hidden bowmen firing on them. 2) you could have mentioned how Bolton put the troops of his northern rivals and strongest Stark loyalists in the Frontline during the battle and held his troops and his likely allies troops in the back where they were safe

@parkbahce100

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly. This was Roose Bolton s favorite tactics, he made sure every Stark loyalists under his command butchered throughout the war.

@marcbartuschka6372

2 жыл бұрын

@@parkbahce100 I disagree at least at this point. While Bolton was as a commander not very good, I think the defeat there was in no way planned. Furthermore in the battle Riverlanders like the Freys also suffered quite some losses, so it is hardly so that Bolton just put "loyal" northerners into the meat grinder - three "full" members of house Frey and also a bastard were captured by the Lannisters. This demonstrated, that the Frey-troops were right in the middle of the battle. It is possible that Bolton planned some of the later defeats, for example when his rearguard was crushed at the Ruby Ford just before the Red Wedding. But at this early stage he was surely not counting on or supporting a Lannister-victory.

@parkbahce100

2 жыл бұрын

@@marcbartuschka6372 Bro he literally send his neighbour lord to death, i dont remember the guys name. His widow was heirless so he could claim their lands. I dont quite remember who else died at that battle but you can check the numbers. Bolton army at the time of red wedding almost had no casualties.

@marcbartuschka6372

2 жыл бұрын

@@parkbahce100 No as far as I know he did not - at least it was never confirmed in the books that he send Lord Hornwood (I guess you mean him?) to death. In the description of the battle there are very few details. Bolton is with no doubt a opportunistic predator in any way, but that does not mean that he always follows a great masterplan from the start. I would much more think that Bolton (and his bastard) saw a chance after the death of Lord Hornwood and try to used it in their own brutal way. Yes, some people believe that Bolton planned everything from the start, but there is no proof in the books for that. And with numbers it is also difficult since we have almost none numbers about which house send how many men and how many were alive in the end. We have some rough estimates how strong the armies were, but even that goes often not into much detail (and it is even harder to tell how much the numbers were influenced by disease, desertion, additional men joining the army etc.). I think it would be far too easy to see everything what Bolton did from the end result. His plans may very well have changed over time.

@wedgeantillies66

2 жыл бұрын

With regards to two, you are confusing battle of green fork with that of the later battle of Duskendale later on where Roose, totally working against the starks at point, does exactly that to get rid of stark loyalists and allow Tryell/Lannisters toi heavily defeat stark forces there.

Well it’s not really “honor” that caused Ned to refuse Renly, much more of “Stannis is clearly the actual heir to the throne”

@ckaiborbor

2 жыл бұрын

And his honor stopped him from scheming to make that happen instead of the law working in the way it is intended

@mr.simonphoenix7181

2 жыл бұрын

🤨🤔🧐…That would be honor, doing what’s right as opposed to what’s easy or self serving.

@nicholasrisso7009

2 жыл бұрын

Honoring the tradition of rightful succession.

@nicholasrisso7009

2 жыл бұрын

Also Ned could have been a homophobe.

@theliato3809

2 жыл бұрын

@@ckaiborbor not his fault renly acted like a madman

The Frey’s are really good allies , they forgave me and even invited me to go feast at my uncles wedding . Hope we had more banner men like the Freys

The most impressive part about Jaime in the Whispering Wood was that he was captured not because of the fighting skills of Robb's bodyguards but because his sword got stuck in the skull of one of them, only then were the Northmen able to subdue him.

@boobah5643

2 жыл бұрын

And it says something about the quality of the Mad King's Kingsguard that Jaime was not their best sword. Jaime's appointment to the Kingsguard was a political one to punish Tywin for being too competent as Hand.

@KaiHung-wv3ul

6 ай бұрын

@@boobah5643 Yeah, it's hard to be the best when compared to Ser Arthur Dayne and Ser Barristan Selmy.

@KaiHung-wv3ul

6 ай бұрын

"I would surrender my sword, but it seems like I've mislaid it."

"Gods damn Eddard, you and your damn honour!" I believe Robert Baratheon said this... so ironic considering how Eddard died.

Still waiting for season 8....

@haydenlawless3248

2 жыл бұрын

Sweet summer child

@stevensanders6954

2 жыл бұрын

😂

@ifoldyougo6517

2 жыл бұрын

oh you poor, poor thing

@cgt3704

2 жыл бұрын

Oh boy

Quick correction @ 12:50 Ser Kevan is Tywin Lannister’s younger brother, not cousin. 👍🏾

"Don't trust the Freys, young Stark..."

There's some audio errors in the video. 4:56 for instance. There is at least one other near the beginning too, and probably more throughout.

What an amazing story. I hope they adapt it to Television.

I understand HBO had a tight budget for GOT, but wish they had attempted to portray these battles on the screen.

3:15 that wasn’t really roberts fault. Little fingers scheming bankrupted the realm because he was centuries a head in terms of financial thinking. The tournament for Ned which was considered a rare and grand affair was barely even a drop in the bucket for the Iron Theones 3 Million crowns in debt.

@josesoria2072

2 жыл бұрын

6 millions, at least in the books

As much as I enjoy your original channel, I may like this one more. I would be interested in your take on the battles of one of my favorite series "The Wheel of Time". There are many larger scale battles described and some have many points of view and your format would be great in seeing the overall flow of the fights. Thanks for your work. Keep it up!

Love it! Regardless of how the television series ended or incomplete state of the books, the Game of Thrones subject is perfect for this kind of channel. You keep making them I'll keep watching and liking

Sir kevan was Tywins brother not his cousin.

Excellent content! Just in time for the revamped hype around the thrones universe!

This was fantastic. Thanks for posting

This was so great can’t wait for the next one.

Roose is cunning & treacherous indeed. If he had sent his twenty good men to disrupt Tywin’s camp, Northerners would have won the Battle of the Green Fork too.

@carlosmarquez5901

2 жыл бұрын

Unlikely

@lordgerog

2 жыл бұрын

maybe, but the lannister camp was fortified like a roman camp. Only with the full force of Robb (with their "champions", riders and knights, and the force of Varamar and the Twins) he could win. Another case is if he could talk and meet with the clans of the mountains (the folk that join Stannis). With they, and the force of Lord Mallister and Lord Frey, their army could be have 25-26 thousand men against 20 thousand of Lord Tywin.

@Sulla-ps3jv

2 жыл бұрын

The Twenty Good men would have conquered King’s Landing.

@Irfan87

2 жыл бұрын

@@carlosmarquez5901 Wooooosh

@mokarokas-1727

2 жыл бұрын

Ah yes, ser Twenty of house Goodmen. Legendary operative.

Robb sure knows how to make good allies

Incredibly good and detailed video. Loved it

King Robb was really great on the battlefield. Tytos Blackwood really was a smart commander as well. He was able to see where he could help the Stark forces and contributed to the final outcome when he came out to pincer the Lannister force from the back.

Kevan Lannister is Tywins brother not his cousin.

I love this vidoe, great break down. I've watched the whole game of thrones 3 times but still always something new u learn.

22:18 This is my one significant criticism of your channel: it would really help if you paid a bit more attention to how your battle animations line up with your narration. Here, for example, your narration correctly describes Robb Stark as attacking the *western* Lannister camp (which is the same one that just tried to send reinforcements across the river). But your animation shows the Stark forces attacking the *eastern* Lannister camp instead, which they actually never did - the eastern camp is the one with the forces that mostly withdrew safely, and the mercenaries who switched sides. This issue has shown up across your various channels. For example, quite a large number of your animations of naval battles for your main channel's Pacific War series have all the ship models sailing backwards. Honestly these aren't horrendous issues, but considering your level of professionalism with almost everything else in these videos, it seems like it should be a relatively simple matter to double-check these animations for basic stuff like which direction an attack goes or whether a ship model is facing the right way.

@thornordfeld7848

2 жыл бұрын

Yup, majorly agree with this comment

The King in the North!!

@chenlevy3773

2 жыл бұрын

you mean" the king in the north and the trident! "

Dude this is fantastic 💯👏🏻

one word to you guys, absoutely amazing!!!

Great as always love the lore and praise be to the omnipresent algorithm

This Young Wolf seems like he has a bright future. I hope it works out for him.

@karthiks6394

Жыл бұрын

😢

Fun to relive in an abridged version the exciting parts of the show. Thanks W&W :)

@gfilmer7150

Жыл бұрын

Budget issues.

Great great video. After knowing the outcomes in a general way, the rich details are amazing. The fact one man worte this world is astonishing. like almost supernat.

Keep up the great work wizards 👍

I wish George RR Martin will finally finish this series so that you guys will have plenty more ASOIAF battles and events to cover.

@theawesomeman9821

2 жыл бұрын

I'm prettty sure, he told journalist that he has given up trying to conclude his books "A Song of Ice and Fire".

@theawesomeman9821

2 жыл бұрын

@@mokarokas-1727 read his personal blog, he has nothing but posts of football teams and comments saying he won't be writing on the books.

@mokarokas-1727

2 жыл бұрын

@@theawesomeman9821 - Why are you even lying about this stuff? His personal blog says he's still working on Winds of Winter as recent as June 1:st. And what about the journalist?

@gfilmer7150

Жыл бұрын

@@theawesomeman9821 R.I.P. I was looking forward to The Battle of Steel between Aegon and Mace

Very fun watch, thanks

Excellent video! Keep up!

I don’t know if I am the only one but the music was a bit to much and distracting for me at two points. No big deal but wanted to say it :D Westeros is truly perfect for the concept of this channel and I am glad that you take the story from the books and aesthetics from the show, that’s exactly the right call I think

Good stuff, very interesting

Another superb video!

Another great vídeo!!

Great video but many many inaccuracies. Sir Kevan is Tywin's brother not cousin. Also, at Riverrun, the Young Wolf, did not cross the river. Actually, a part of the Tully and stark army attacked from two sides and did not have to cross the river. They were two separate attacking contingents.

The one video I am hoping beyond hope to see on this channel is the siege of Terra from the Warhammer universe.

This story never gets old. I must have read every book once a year since the first season of the show so almost a decade or longer and every time I read it I’m just as entertained as the first time. If George RR Martin can finish the series it should be required reading in schools and to be read right after LOTR.

It has been said only the thighs of Margaery Tyrell could defeat the armies of the Five Kings.

Hey, I know it's not as huge as some of the other series you've covered on this channel, but I feel like the Malazan Book of the Fallen would be perfect for the Wizards and Warriors treatment. Would you ever consider covering some of the many gigantic wars and battles that unfold over the course of that series?

Hey I’m new to your page as of today. Great stuff on GOT. What game or program are you using for the images we are seeing? I love it. Thanks

Great video! This is a better treatment of the war than we got in the TV show.

@nirotpal3

2 жыл бұрын

yeah. that's the only one issue I had with that season. not showing these imp battles.

Thank for your good videos

Roberts transformation from war god to bum is epic

Robb Stark's direwolf was a Difference Maker it would have been nice if he was included in this, but all in all it was great love the whole thing good stuff.

It's good that u quoted from the books not the the show i hope u continue that way and throw aside the show😁

Ty for your videos

it's not simply "honor" that drove Ned to decline Renly's offer of help . Supporting him would mean supporting Renly as the heir to the throne bypassing Stannis as the next in line to the throne.

great to see this series

Could you please do videos on the shannara chronicles I love those books and they are perfect for a channel like this

Awesome video

I’ve watched your game of thrones videos so many times dead can’t wait on the next

Hopefully this channel can cover the books ending one day.... Iron Men, you have heard my horn, now hear my words. I am Balon's brother, Quellon's eldest living son. Lord Vickon's blood flows through my veins and the blood of the Old Krakken. Yet I have sailed farther than any of them, only one living Krakken has never known defeat. Only one has never bent his knee. Only one has sailed to Asshai by the Shadow and seen wonders and terrors beyond imagining- Euron Greyjoy's kings moot speech.

@zintosion

2 жыл бұрын

I've lost faith in Mr Martin to finish the story, but i hope im wrong.

@oluspeaks3159

2 жыл бұрын

Man they butchered this speech and character in the show 🤦🏿‍♂️

@themouthofsauron6926

2 жыл бұрын

@@oluspeaks3159 they butchered the last 2-3 seasons of GOT lol

@eriksgasins9086

2 жыл бұрын

I have lost hope tbh that the books will be finished. Its laughable that GRRM cant finish 1 book in 11 years, when he had already written part of it as of 2011, and there are no news that he is close to finishing Winds of Winter. There is still the big ending which isnt gonna be easier to write than Winds of Winter.

@zintosion

2 жыл бұрын

@@eriksgasins9086 Tbh I think he also has given up on finishing the books. I think he's afraid of not living up the fan expectations for the ending. I don't blame him though, the fans can be a bit rabbid at times. Not to mention he's getting old.

I'd love to see one about Tywin and house castamere

Y'all should really do videos on the Clone Commando missions from the Republic Commando game and books they're some of the best action and adventure in Star Wars. They do so much stuff that you'd find Special Operation units doing in our world.

Game of Thrones to me is proof that well made low fantasy can be great I agree with James Tullos that too many people learned the wrong lessons from its success

@mijanhoque1740

2 жыл бұрын

What did he say about it?

@christianweibrecht6555

2 жыл бұрын

@@mijanhoque1740 people who don't actually understand why GoT is popular believe their shows can become popular by just adding killing, incest, and cynicism

@BasicLib

2 жыл бұрын

What lessons were those

I heard that videos about histories of alternate histories will be shown on this channel in the future. So what are the series that the team of this channel has chosen?

*THE KING IN THE NORTH!*

I'd love for you guys to go through the Starcraft games. Plenty of drama there, especially in Great War and Brood War.

Wonderdraft is an amazing fantasy map maker. I recognize a lot of the icons used in the video.

Sir kevan lannister is tywin's brother not cousin!

Amazing, I wanted this. I guess Dani’s conquest of Essos could be next ?

@boobah5643

2 жыл бұрын

I'd think, at the very least, the Barratheon attack on King's Landing (I cannot remember the name of the river) would be earlier.

@BlackstreetBoys2Men

Жыл бұрын

@@boobah5643 you mean the Battle of the Blackwater ? It’s the bay of Kings Landing

@iamukasa

Жыл бұрын

@@BlackstreetBoys2Men book Tyrion was absolutely brilliant in that..... That never makes it to the show

Nice one

Great video I heard they also made a decent TV adaptation about this event called Game of Thrones.

Hope you do a video on the Black Company series it being the predecessor of down to earth fantasy like ASOIAF and Malazan

Best channel ever!!!

Full steam ahead!!!

Yaaaas, been waiting for more ASOIAF material.

What program did you use to animate this and make the 3d models

Can you maybe do one on the wheel of time, the black company, and the first law?

Please make more videos on the elderscrolls universe you could cover the war of the red diamond and wars of Cameron the usurper or the establishment of the skyrim empire and so much more

This should make a really nice tv-show.

Who's building this animations... great job

When I started d book, never thought Bran would end up sitting 🪑 on the throne

I wonder how you guys would do like a battle of the citadel of Mass Effect because so much variations can occur because of decisions made. I would love to see it but know it wouldn't be simple.

For sci-fi I would recommend BattleTech you can cover a lot of eras Of that universe.

Please put this video in the playlist with other GOT content. :)

Will you guys move the other Game of Thrones battles from the Kings and Generals channel?

Brilliant! Oh what could have been if Rob wasn't betrayed

@boobah5643

2 жыл бұрын

To be fair, Robb betrayed Lord Frey first.

Problem with Robb Stark he was never winning the War. Even if the Red Wedding didn’t happen and if some how beat the Lannisters. He’d still have to try to fight the Greyjoys attacking his coast and Stannis Baratheon the true King would also be coming for him. If the Vale joined him I’d say he’d have a shot. But the North and Riverlands weren’t strong enough to beat the rest of the Westeros

@boobah5643

2 жыл бұрын

Robb never had "Conquer Westeros" as an objective. His objective was to protect the North and the Riverlands, and convince the Lannisters to trade Ned back in exchange for peace. Mind, it was always going to be tricky to accomplish, because unlike the North's Neck, the Riverlands have relatively porous borders. Mind, fighting with the Greyjoys would have sucked, especially since the navy he had been building was on the wrong side of the continent and moving it was probably more difficult than building a second navy on the ocean side.

@gfilmer7150

Жыл бұрын

If Edmure didn't attack Tywin at The Fords, Tywin would fallen for his trap. He'd attempt to beat Robb in battle where the high ground and Robb's force being entirely made of cavalry would've broken The Lannister army. Now, if Stannis tried to invade The Riverlands, Robb can easily withdraw from The West (as he was gonna try and reorganize his force to move back North) and gather all of his forces together to meet him. Robb would move more men, more experienced fighters, and the homefield advantage. Stannis' forces would already be tired after Blackwater, as Tyrion's strategy bled the front of the army. Seeing that Stannis won't allow for Northern/River Independence, Robb would have to kill Stannis which means taking King's Landing (he'd also have to take Rosby to kill "King Tommen") and once The Capital falls, Robb's bannermen may force Robb into taking The Iron Throne just as they did with forcing Robb into becoming King In The North.

@mysteryjunkie9808

Жыл бұрын

@@gfilmer7150 yeah don’t see him beat Stannis at all.

@gfilmer7150

Жыл бұрын

@@mysteryjunkie9808 I do, More men, better experienced, plus The Blackfish.

@seiyajin8151

Жыл бұрын

Actually, he was, the Greyjoys weren't much of a threat, he could deal with them, and they didn't even need to go after them, as long as they took Winterfell back it would be fine. Stannis also wouldn't be a problem either, because Robb had no desire for the Iron Throne, he just wanted his family back, so Stannis didn't have his position threatened, the only problem would be the independence of the north, but that would be the least of Robb concerns, he would easily give up the crown and independence to have his family back, which would be easy to do with Stannis on the throne. And if Edmure hadn't screwed up, Stannis would have won the battle at King's Landing.

I love you guys keeping it strictly book based. Thank you 🙏🏾

I'm listening to this on headphones while sitting on my bed with a whiskey in hand and some weed in my system

22:45 You show the wrong camp being attacked here. Brynden led the assault on the North camp whilst Robb led his men over the Tumblestone to attack the camp between the rivers. Seeing that the battle is lost, Ser Forley Prester in the *Eastern* camp then withdraws East towards Tywin's forces.