I like to think it’s Gordon himself, abit of a meta take on how Gordon’s model in the pilot was used for set dressing in scrapyard scenes! Really good story :)

@joshuabrown6791

9 ай бұрын

Or a continuation of, "A part of me stayed behind."

@Readdisyougey

8 ай бұрын

@@joshuabrown6791I dont think so bc that’d imply that there was another body for him alr when they were made after the accident at the mines. And there wouldn’t be a reason for Gordon’s original body to be in the smelters yard bc they were left there bc of the dangers of the mines

@cassandraperna1727

4 ай бұрын

It’s probably one of his siblings. We did hear he had siblings.

@the_purple_caboose

Күн бұрын

Maybe Gordom had an identical twin?

16:37 “He’s just standing there… MENACINGLY!”

This... was one spooky story. The whole bit of Gordon looking at that scrapped engine felt like a reference to A Part of Me Stayed Behind.

I love how this story is open to interpretation. Maybe the engine was one of his brothers? Maybe he was a failed prototype of Gordon? Or maybe he was something else entirely. Whatever the answer is, Gordon will likely take that secret to his death.

@user-fr1wg4tn7e

3 ай бұрын

my guess, it's the failed prototype who's plans became the basis of Henry's old shape.

Even though Horror of the Rails is over, you always know how to make and tell some amazing spooky stories.

@matthew_natividad

9 ай бұрын

It is?

@tomoliver4756

9 ай бұрын

@@matthew_natividad This story is NOT part of the Horror of the Rails series as it ended last year.

After rewatching this many times, it's either implying that the scraped engine is Gordon himself (going for a reference to "Part of me stayed Behind" or this was the prototype A1 that failed to work and was sent to scrap after Gordon (the improved version) was built Either way, this was a good story

@shimesu443

9 ай бұрын

That's my take, that it's Gordon's older sibling that failed and was cut up for scrap. Makes me feel very sorry for that engine if that's the case. I wonder why it came up to Gordon then. Was it happy to see its little brother? Angry? Sad?

@SpaceDetectiveTravis

9 ай бұрын

@@shimesu443 Who knows? Could have been a variety of emotions considering Gordon showing up to the smelter's yard due to a job was completely by chance. If it's the latter in that it's the nameless older sibling that never got the chance to live the life that Gordon, Scott, and the others would due to being "the failed prototype" maybe the entire encounter was just it wanting to interact with one of it's siblings for the first & last time, along with having one of them remember it so they, at least, don't be forgotten before it left to who knows where

@Nausicaafan-go6lq

9 ай бұрын

I think its both... but I also have a feeling that it became the Killdane Experiment/Halloween Engine...

@shimesu443

9 ай бұрын

@@SpaceDetectiveTravis That's a very good take. Of course, that just makes me feel sadder for the poor thing. A lost soul, reaching out to lost family, hoping to not be forgotten.

@bob-le2mf

3 ай бұрын

@@shimesu443 this failed engine's plans would eventually be stolen and become Henry's old shape.

There's some strange things supernatural in the scrap yard

I'd like to think the scrapyards warps into whatever dark past an engine has had. For Stepney's, it was being caught and almost scrapped by two unknown diesels, while gordon's was seeing the ghost of a lost relative, or he's early prototype design. Great video by the way ! Loved the editing.

@princesmooth6226

3 ай бұрын

I like your idea the only thing that's got me confused is you have to remember one of the diesels pushed Stepney in now if they are just a figment of is imagination that means stepney was never pushed he moved on his own. But that idea was kicked to side after Thomas and The Magic Railroad and we went back to the engines having drivers and fireman. Unless the engines still have the ability to move on their own but they choose not to due to regulations.

Sorry I didn’t comment sooner, but this was definitely a real spooky story there. I like to think that that engine was probably one of Gordon’s brothers, but was a failed prototype when they were first built. Though judging by the comments, it might also be Gordon’s former shell somehow. Either way, excellent work on this, Joe!

@user-fr1wg4tn7e

8 ай бұрын

that failed prototype could have also been the one Henry's old shape was based on too.

I love this story! I feel like the engine Gordon saw was himself sort of like in A Part of Me Stayed Behind

I have a theory that the 2 unknown diesels (Likely Arry and Bert) aren't really engines, but as the demons from hell, transformed into diesel engines to take the souls of the steam engines. That would've been a good storyline for this series

After watching the video I came to a conclusion, but first I will give my explanation so you understand. Gordon is the prototype of the A1, seeing the memory of him realizing who that rusty locomotive was, can help us understand that Gordon was not the only prototype, why do I say this? because how Gordon acted.

Pretty spooky tale here.

Young and green.

It’s like Horrors of the Rails never ended.

It might have been Gordon’s old shell

Wow. What a story. It really is. I love how this turned out. The pacing, the photoshop scenes, the music, and how the characters are like. Mainly Gordon. That part with Gordon and.....who that engine may be kinda reminds me of A Part of me Stays Behind in a way. Also I'm wondering what music was used there during that sequence. This is a fantastic spooky story here. Well done on it! And I hope you have a Happy Halloween!

I like the implication that 'Arry and Bert might actually be supernatural beings that reside in the scrapyard and might not actually be real engines that work there. Topham might be right to be very nervous about that place...

You know, I almost scared myself after that engine without a face.

This scared the shit out of me. This was good

Cool story Joe.^^ Yours are just like my parents would write it... If they'd ever done it. Quality, spirit and thought. 😁

I think the engine is one of the loaned engines from the early days of the NWR, perhaps 87546 or 98462, or maybe it's what's left of Dudley. (even though in one of my headcanons, 98462 was killed in a wreck while Dudley and 87546 were withdrawn from service in the early 60s and sent for scrap)

WOW another amazing story PLEASE DO MORE OF THESE STORIES but maybe you could do a story like this about Bertie The Bus Because in the model series the episode where Thomas meets Bertie you can see busses siting in the shed but we never know who they are

So does this mean that Gordon was built out of a failed scrapped engine?

@evanclarke5561

8 ай бұрын

Who knows?

@octopus1066

Ай бұрын

well given gordon was an A0, and in the story of him meeting scotmans, he told him he also got a rebuilt, that wasn't true to there maker's design, but it served. So who knows.

Telling the truth? Since when does Gordon ever own up to his fears. Either way, it’s deserved here. If the rusted engine wasn’t him, then it had to be one of his brothers.

@user-fr1wg4tn7e

8 ай бұрын

probably the one who's plans were stolen and became the basis of Henry's old shape if we're going by the "Failed Prototype" theory.

@Jaytotea

2 ай бұрын

But then that would mean the engine was old shape Henry

i think that gordon had a twin but when they where completed gordon was the only one to wake up

It maybe Gordon himself, or a sibling, however I like to think that it was all in his head. Either way Gordon will never say who that was

I really love this story. I’m not a huge fan of scary stories but this one is great. I have a little theory: I think that engine that was in front of Gordon was the engine that went down the mine. And maybe at some point off screen it was sent to the scrap yard and got scraped at some point. Maybe Gordon was seeing the scraped Gordon that fell down the mine.If that makes sense. Anyways I Love this story so much ❤❤❤❤ This reminds me of A Part of me that was left behind

what if the scrap engine is the 1920 draft of the a1 before gordon and was scrapped soon after gordon was built

Wow that’s some story, very scary and even terrifying and it nearly made me in horror for a while anyway

That was a real good story! And Happy Halloween!

17:28 given the shot is closing in on an engine next to Gordon, I think the scrapped engine is one of Gordon’s brothers that he forgot about. Thus, the title of the story.

@bob-le2mf

3 ай бұрын

i like to think that this engine became henry's old shape basis as it's plans were stolen and Henry was built from them.

Am I the only one who thinks that the scrapped engine Gordon encounters is the one from the episode ‘Halloween’? It probably isn’t but just some food for thought.

@AbbeyYard

20 күн бұрын

That one was 2-10-0

I think maybe that that scrap engine was Gordon’s old body.what if he got into an accident and had to be entirely rebuilt like Henry however Gordon losses his memorys

Great story as always.

That was pretty screwed up. But if I was Gordon then I would've told the other engines the truth about my brother.

I love it! The story is spooky and amazing.

"A part of me stayed behind" in S5 but if it was written by Narrow Guage?

Amazing work

Rezurrected Memory - Audio Production

Awsome Work You Made There

*Just like old times…*

I think the ghost was Gordon's younger self.

Maybe gordon had another brother who worked on sodor before him and something must have happened to him 🤔

I love how they were implying Arry and Bert were Ghosts

Damn that was good

13:59 Scared the crap out of me.

I have a theory that that is actually Robert the devil or Pretty Polly dead corpses and Gordon recognizes them

Incredible

Good Work With The Video.

My own take on this, Gordon wasn't the only prototype, but there was actually a second. There were some problems or other with the second engine, so the other engine was decommissioned, and they used parts from it to help complete Gordon. Gordon himself never really knew anything about it, that is, of course, until now. At least, that's my take.

and so, it begins. time to shit myself at the end. I'll tell you all if I do.

Sorry to be a stickler, but may I ask? Do you pronounce "Resurrected" as rezurrected or resurrected?

Expiration: Gordon get scared by his prototype Reality: Gordon screams like a ten years old pigtails girl by his prototype. This is what I thought of inside my mind. 😂

Who thinks that particular scrapyard is haunted

@evanclarke5561

8 ай бұрын

I guess so. (But remember this is fiction)

Who is Gordon the only a0 or was he the only one of those kind because I know Israel’s was he was the prototype, but was there another prototype for him know Henry is technically part at one, but that cannot be him. What is the brother of his that long forgot about navy that was that and a one that wasn’t completed or just a zero that was still in the process, but then they just abandoned us and I served all the eyes to Gordon. Is that what happened or do you not know yet?

Wonder what this could be

Happy Halloween everyone.

Series 5(1998)

@jimmymccartney2049

9 ай бұрын

Narrated by:Alec Baldwin

@NathanielPiscian

9 ай бұрын

Directed by David mitton

Let's call him Bill

@evanclarke5561

8 ай бұрын

I think something such as either Jeroboam, Solomon or Manasseh would be more appropiate due to their regal sound

one question. what happen to your old videos about Sidney?

Who was the engine??

@sabertooth3studioshq838

9 ай бұрын

one of Gordon's brothers probally

Let’s see are they scary

In order to understand who this engine is, we must understand what Gordon is. Since Flying Scotsman is is canon, as is Great Northern, I present that Gordon is number 1471, Sir Frederick Banbury. Still older than Scotsman, but not causing timeline issues if he were Great Northern. As to who this is... yeah I still don't have an answer. :I Maybe Great Northern was just having an off day.

I thought at first that the engine was the Killdane experiment!

15:50 What's the Piece of Music Called Here?

What is the ghost engine's name?

why is the audio so quiet?

10:29 why dose this look ai. Generated

I think that the scrap engine was a failed prototype of Gordon cinde of like shed 17 mines the human turned into taking coo coo train element

@hyperstaredits3521

9 ай бұрын

Don’t talk about that stuff here

@agentnintendonate1thee2tan89

9 ай бұрын

"We don't do that here."

What did the engine say to Gordon?

Hey Joe. Could I make your take on the two Henry’s theory canon in my AU? I’ll give credit.

Gordon's twin?

Was the scrap engine the same one from his memory?

All Scrapyards are personalized

Is this a new episode for horrors of the rails? Edit: whats the name of the song that’s playing at 19:30

@TARDIS9

9 ай бұрын

No, that series is long over and done with. This is more likely just a special story for Hallowe’en.

@Cassertte

9 ай бұрын

@@TARDIS9awww man i really loved that series

@InfinityRed520

9 ай бұрын

@@Cassertteme too man but 22Tesla is a worthy successor i’d recommend watching his Tales From The Scrap Sidings stories

@Cassertte

9 ай бұрын

@@InfinityRed520oh i know about that, i love that series

@InfinityRed520

9 ай бұрын

@@Cassertte that’s good

I don't get it

17:26 Spoilers: Gordon: “Oh… My… God…. YOU’RE MY TENDER?” Ghost: “Are you serious?”

@gordonthebigenginenwr4

9 ай бұрын

Lol

So if Arry and Bert either weren't really there or were supposed to be somewhere else at the time, why did they appear there? @narrowgauge9717