Responding to Viewer Comments on our Series | Concubines in Islam, Part 11 | Dr. Shabir Ally

Dr. Shabir Ally responds to some of your feedback on our "Islam and concubinage" series, including the following:
1. If concubinage was so widely practiced at the time of the Prophet (peace be upon him), why didn't the Quran speak out against it if it wasn't a good thing to do?
2. Doesn't Muhammad Asad's commentary and understanding of "whom your right hands possess" make the Quranic wording seem redundant and repetitive?
3. How does the Quran compare to other scriptures on concubinage?
If you enjoy this video, please support our work financially by visiting our website www.quranspeaks.com or sending an etransfer to igive@quranspeaks.com
► SUPPORT: www.quranspeaks.com/
► SUBSCRIBE: kzread.info_...
COMMENT, LIKE and SHARE
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Instagram: / quranspeaks.tv
Twitter: / quran_speaks

Пікірлер: 49

  • @chioptnstdr3448
    @chioptnstdr34482 жыл бұрын

    I love this channel because it take on the tough issues and provides a balance perspective. Thank you.

  • @fidelcatsro6948

    @fidelcatsro6948

    2 жыл бұрын

    my cat loves u too🐱♥️♥️♥️👍🏿

  • @chioptnstdr3448

    @chioptnstdr3448

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@fidelcatsro6948 Tell your cat I said hi

  • @fidelcatsro6948

    @fidelcatsro6948

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@chioptnstdr3448 roger that🐱👍🏿

  • @thetruthwithproof8802

    @thetruthwithproof8802

    2 жыл бұрын

    Please note the Complete & Perfected islam told us 👉🏼 A man who believed in Allah was told by the the Prophet (pbuh) he cant become a muslim, because he was wearing a taweez ( Masnud Ahmed 16969 ) Please note the Complete & Perfected islam told us 👉🏼 ``Whoever wears an amulet has committed SHIRK ( Masnud Ahmed 16969 ) WHY HAVE PEOPLE DECIDED THOSE TAWEEZ WITH QURAN VERSES ARE NOT SHIRK ❓ As we know asking the dead for help is SHIRK, If l was to claim asking the dead for help is not SHIRK because this dead person is going to ask ALLAH to help us will PEOPLE agree with this ❓ The answer is no, which is correct ✔️ WHEN PE0PLE ASK THE DEAD TO ASK ALLAH FOR HELP, THE PEOPLE CALL IT SHIRK WHEN PE0PLE USE A TAWEEZ TO ASK ALLAH TO HELP, WHY DO WE NOT CALL IT SHIRK❓ WHY D0 WE USE A DIFFERENT RULE F0R THE TAWEEZ ❓ Do we put Quran verses on an idol to make it Halal ❓ Do we read Bismillah before eating pork to make it halal ❓

  • @thetruthwithproof8802

    @thetruthwithproof8802

    2 жыл бұрын

    IMAN B😊😊STER 🔲 You might be thinking why am l going through hardships And we will surely test you with something of fear and hunger and a loss of wealth and lives and fruits, but give good tidings to the patient, ( Quran 2 : 155 ) 🔲 You might be thinking could l of avoided the problem l am in No misfortune can happen on earth or in your souls but it is recorded in a decree before we bring it into existence - ( Quran 57 : 22 ) 🔲 You might be thinking l am lucky to of avoided such a calamity And you should know that whatever befalls you was never going to miss you and whatever missed you was never going to come to you. (Tabarani) 🔲 Are you scared people might harm you Know that if the whole world were to gather together in order to help you, they would not be able to help you except if Allah had written so. And if the whole world were to gather together in order to harm you, they would not harm you except if Allah had written so. The pens have been lifted, and the pages are dry.’ ( Tirmidhi ) 🔲 Fear only Allah if Allah touches you with harm, none can remove it but he - ( Quran 6 :17-18 ) 🔲 Only Allah can cure you Nothing can change the divine decree except dua”- Musnad Ahmad, 5/677 ( Yet we are searching for other solutions to block these calamities rather than doing dua & asking Allah the only one capable of solving our problems 🤲🏻 ) 🔲 Why are evil people getting away with their crimes And never think that Allah is unaware of what the wrongdoers do, he only delays them for a Day when eyes will stare ( in horror ) ( Quran 14 : 42 ) ( Yet we make comments such as why is Allah not helping me ?) The Prophet P.b.u.h said, whoever has oppressed another person concerning his reputation or anything else, he should beg him to forgive him before the day of resurrection when there will be no money (to compensate For wrong deeds), but if he has good deeds, those good deeds will be taken from him according the oppression which he has done, & if he has No good deeds left then the sins of the oppressed person will be loaded on him ( Sahih Bukhari 2449 )

  • @sohailchaudhry4820
    @sohailchaudhry48202 жыл бұрын

    Thank you for this information. It has helped me to understand the issue in a clear manner and in compatible with compassionate nature of Islam.

  • @palestine7456
    @palestine74562 жыл бұрын

    To the merciful hearts 🤲🤲 I am a mother of orphaned children from Palestine, Gaza Strip 🇵🇸 I appeal to the good and doers of good. I appeal to the servants of the Most Merciful to help me and help my children We are a needy family, our conditions are very bad, life is difficult and there is no breadwinner for my children, and the conditions are harsh in Gaza because of the war and the siege We live without a home in Zingo's room, made of very bad iron I hope a good person who does good and works for the sake of God can help us with the expenses of the house and finishing the room It protects my children from rain, winter and cold Forgive me for entering this way, the circumstances are stronger than me 😢😢 The number inside the picture ☝

  • @MohamedAkhbar

    @MohamedAkhbar

    2 жыл бұрын

    How can anyone reached u

  • @watch13famouspeoplewhoacce45
    @watch13famouspeoplewhoacce452 жыл бұрын

    1 The Prophet P.B.U.H ➡️ NEVER ⬅️ instructed us to follow any imam. 2 Allah ➡️ NEVER ⬅️ instructed us to follow any imam. 3 The Imams did ➡️ NOT INSTRUCT ⬅️ us to follow them. 4 The ➡️ Complete & perfect ⬅️ Islam existed before the arrival of all the Imams. 5 All the four imams said, if you find a hadith which contradicts what we have taught you then ➡️ REJECT ⬅️ what we taught you & follow the teachings of Prophet P.B.U.H. 6 Are you ready to follow an imam if it means ➡️ REJECTING ⬅️ a Hadith 🤦🏻‍♂️❓

  • @pulsarstargrave256
    @pulsarstargrave2562 жыл бұрын

    It may not be called concubinage in the secular world but too many men have slept with maids or college age or older babysitters for centuries! A person must be strong in their faith, practice and love for ALLAH and their spouse to resist temptation!

  • @farzanarimi2763
    @farzanarimi2763 Жыл бұрын

    6:54 makes much more sense.

  • @MergedElement
    @MergedElement6 ай бұрын

    Scholar sure love to ignore the part of slaves that had not “yet” menstruated in this verse.

  • @Wisdomseeker1028
    @Wisdomseeker1028 Жыл бұрын

    Who says muslims do not accept concubinage? You cannot speak for all muslims. Isis for example adopted concubinage. I myself also like the idea of it as a muslim. And classically it was permissible. The ottoman sultans did it too. Whatever is ambiguous in the koran is a mercy for mankind. So if the meaning of "what your right hand pocesses" is ambiguous in that we dont know if it only means wife but also slaves, then its open for interpretation and ambiguous which is a mercy to us.

  • @user-iu4se2ps7d
    @user-iu4se2ps7d2 жыл бұрын

    Please do a video on the Ukraine crisis , thanks

  • @saleemuddinsyed8870
    @saleemuddinsyed8870 Жыл бұрын

    Your analysis are based on reality, but no book is available on mariya qibtiya, some refer on without clarity. You should prepare a boolet about Mariyah Qibtiya - mukhtasar aur jamey. If it is available in pdf format kindly suggest.

  • @HH-pv9ex
    @HH-pv9ex2 жыл бұрын

    Can Dr Shabir comment on the pressing issue of refugee child kidnapping in Sweden.

  • @kanizfatima3447

    @kanizfatima3447

    2 жыл бұрын

    What?

  • @einerftonog
    @einerftonog2 жыл бұрын

    I like you videos, btw Im Christian.

  • @deepmalatiwari900
    @deepmalatiwari9002 жыл бұрын

    You all know arbic language and you all interpret the verses you can understand what ever you all wish

  • @fidelcatsro6948
    @fidelcatsro69482 жыл бұрын

    so concubinage is allowed in the other 2 abrahamic religions too thank you Dr Shabeer!! Case adjourned

  • @takhtar4877

    @takhtar4877

    2 жыл бұрын

    It was allowed in all Abrahamic religion . Those who deny don’t read their scripture or not bold enough to admit it .

  • @Mizmania1
    @Mizmania1Ай бұрын

    Only 48 comments?

  • @ericbrazau6533
    @ericbrazau65332 жыл бұрын

    BUT what about the women my right hand possesses? Is that concubinage or sex slavery?

  • @farzanarimi2763

    @farzanarimi2763

    Жыл бұрын

    That means SAME as described in this video 6:54, they can get married and have sexual relationship with them.

  • @ericbrazau6533

    @ericbrazau6533

    Жыл бұрын

    @@farzanarimi2763 What is your point?

  • @farzanarimi2763

    @farzanarimi2763

    Жыл бұрын

    @@ericbrazau6533, there is nothing about MY point. However, the point here is: whether you are male or female, you have to be legally, rightfully married to each other to have sexual relationship.

  • @shentatsai
    @shentatsai Жыл бұрын

    Respect moral value first, than talk about respect comments

  • @cissejr7695
    @cissejr76952 жыл бұрын

    Well now the question is should the owner of the female slave give her talaq, if he wanted to give her to someone else. That's a reasonable question and no from my knowledge few knowledgeable Muslims struggle with this topic, it is just those who are weak and not knowledgeable of history of human civilization

  • @peterhwang1860
    @peterhwang18602 жыл бұрын

    God's ultimate message to mankind should not conform to the immoral practices of the day. Jesus is God's ultimate message, and he proclaimed one husband, one wife, one flesh that God has joined together and let no onr separate, just as God declared from the very beginning.

  • @TheMuslimImam
    @TheMuslimImam2 жыл бұрын

    Keep the commandments given in the Quran and none can enslave you

  • @kanizfatima3447

    @kanizfatima3447

    2 жыл бұрын

    Literally

  • @NRFP
    @NRFP2 жыл бұрын

    Allah is injustice with war captive non muslim women. I compelled to say this after reading Bukhari hadith and fiqh. they must not be in any commodity..but Islam has allowed them to be sell and buy as product. that is sad. the security of women prisoners of war could have been arranged differently. There was no need to do that. i am a muslim boy but sorry to say that. should not sell & buy them like product

  • @takhtar4877

    @takhtar4877

    2 жыл бұрын

    You are putting the same Comments in all the series .

  • @user-fg6uu2fu9x

    @user-fg6uu2fu9x

    2 жыл бұрын

    I'm a Muslim woman . I think its fair. They were doing the same time muslim women at the time. Why should we have to take care of their women after they went to war with us? The people at that time were poor so it makes sense to get financial compensation. In the same way you would expect an employer to keep an employee for free in the same way back then there was a contract. The prisoner will work to pay back their debt to society (for going into war with Muslims) and in return they would be taken care of with shelter, food and treated like a family member (you know, all the things that they wished to deprive Muslims of!) And look at how muslim prisoners are treated now. Look how mothers and children are being kept in camps ! You think that's humans ? In islam you're not allowed to refer to the pow as a slave .

  • @kanizfatima3447

    @kanizfatima3447

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@user-fg6uu2fu9x people forgetting even the enemy side has captured Muslims as Pow and probs is treating them very bad ! Hadith says the Muslim ate only dates and water while they have the POW bread so they put the POW first ! We need to learn our history sister ! They don’t care they Bilal(ra) was tourtured with hot fire by the polytheist this is how slaves were treated for centuries before Islam

  • @user-fg6uu2fu9x

    @user-fg6uu2fu9x

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@kanizfatima3447 exactly. You never heard how the Muslim pows were treated. Sorry just read your comment now

  • @Sorel366

    @Sorel366

    Жыл бұрын

    @@user-fg6uu2fu9x But the women and children were bought and sold too even though they were innocent

  • @javeedahmedkhan5416
    @javeedahmedkhan54162 жыл бұрын

    Hello sir/ma'am, I have a question and trust me it is honest question. I wonder when allah will land on planet earth and solve all the problems?

  • @rereraira4863

    @rereraira4863

    Жыл бұрын

    What's the point of heaven if this world becomes one?

  • @stayhalal2520

    @stayhalal2520

    Жыл бұрын

    Allah SWT will not come down. Imam Mahdi will come and Isa AS will return to bring peace.

  • @stayhalal2520

    @stayhalal2520

    Жыл бұрын

    @@rereraira4863 this world cannot become heaven

  • @temporaryaccount5307
    @temporaryaccount53072 жыл бұрын

    Leave it to this guy to use his favorite excuse: “it was a wide spread practice.” He uses that excuse to defend mhamed’s pdolia too, for which not a single mzm can tell me what other king, let alone religious leader, did the same. If it was so “wide spread practiced,” u shouldn’t have a prob coming up w one name!

  • @Think_pls
    @Think_pls2 жыл бұрын

    It seems Allah cant speak very clearly, So lawyer apologist have a way of using technicality , to win there case. Religion and politics , I don't find any difference , the leaders knows the target market, so speak accordingly, Use damage control strategy I feel sorry for the genuine fallowers, who happens to be the majority Sad facts of Life I guess