I did really good this year. The only eyeshadow palette I purchased was Kaleidos’ Cold Brew. I was tempted to get a few others but kept reminding myself that I had over 40 eyeshadow palettes. I’m down to 37 and my goal for 2023 is to continue reducing the amount of make-up I have and to buy less in the new year.

I finally bought the mothership X.. those 40% off was definitely necessary for me to justify the splurge. I'm really excited to get my first PMG product. Love the Natasha Denona my dream palette too ❤️

I got the Vega palette on launch after your recommendation and so glad I did. It is the perfect everyday palette. Thanks for all your hard work this year.

Yes! Called it on the top 4, but I lost points for forgetting the ND Dream Palette! You’re in trouble though, Charlotte, because now I want it! As well as the Lisa Eldridge Vega Palette 😅! Good job I don’t make resolutions. Pointless as I have no willpower 🤣🤣! Happy New Year to you, to those you love and to all of we subscribers! ❤xxx

I loooove my TF Tiger Eye palette , i almost hit pan !! Love love love it

Hi Charlotte, 1. Vega LE 2. Myth LE 3. Sorcery 4. Pat’s Quints both of them 5. ABH Nouveau 6. Chanel Mediterranean

My palettes of the year: 5- ND pastel 4-Anastasia: Nouveau palette 3- Lisa E. Sorcery 2- Vega 1- Myth Very surprising for me as I am a neutraliser tunes lover and have pink, red and orange eye shows but Myth with Brown eyes is so stunning! I replacer the mauve colour by a Grey Tone and the palette is perfection to me! I was amazed of th blue violet colour! Stunning!

I was so proud of myself this year i only tried 6 new palettes this year and 3 were a all in a set collection 😆☺: 4: Sydney Grace mountain trail palette ( great palette that i love just a very specific color story ) 3: ND retro glam palette ( great palette that i love just a very specific color story 2: Sydney Grace x Temptalia palette trio collection ( love this trio set it’s all i will ever need for jewel tone color shadows ) 1: ND my dream palette

I got all five of Lisa’s palettes! Call me crazy, but I love them! I also got the two Natasha palettes and Mothership 10 and the two Bridgerton palettes!!!

This was the year old got midnight sun finally so I've mostly been wearing that! Thank you for this breakdown - what a great year its been for eyeshadow!

I loved your ranking, Charlotte! MS X is added to my wishlist! Happy holidays! Cheers,

Charlotte your make up is amazing ❤

Thank you.. Vega is my favorite. I wish you a happy new year🎉

Yes! The Vega palette. Really surprised me. I really love it! For me, it is very unique. I didn’t think this would work on me, but it, it really does. Beautiful formula.

Hallo Charlotte. Great ranking. I love so many of your top picks.

I must admit that your Top 5 held no surprises for me 😂. I recently saw the PML Mothership X in person at my Sephora. That VR Sextacy shade 😱. It literally made me gasp when I swatched it.

Happy New Year Charlotte, went back and got Vega based on your review and I cannot thank you enough as well as for all your great work. ❤ Btw, my favorite this year was the in Mel’s memory bundle from Sydney Grace but as an actual palette, Vega.

Another honest review. Wishing you and your family a happy and healthy new years. Looking forward to more wonderful videos🎉

Yay,, I'm here for this video. Love the rankings. I purchased about 10 palettes year. What can I say they are my favorite makeup item. 🙊Great job on this video. Happy new year! 🥂🎉

Just perfect, Charlotte! I did guess the X palette, but I had forgotten about several of the others. One of my favorites was the ABH Rose Metals palette, in addition to the Nouveau. I was just as excited that she didn’t use a nasty velour-feeling cover this time as I was about the color stories! 😂 Happy New Year, and I’m looking forward to spending another year together! 🎉❤🥂

Happy New Year my beautiful Charlotte ❤ I have enjoyed your videos through out the year. You are amazing ❤ 2023 here we come !

Great round up! I love the ND Dream Palette and LE Vega. I think if we could only have two palettes, those two would cover all bases. That said, Mothership X looks gorgeous, and I’ve just ordered it as a birthday treat to myself. Thanks for your videos Charlotte, they are such a joy to watch. I love how you adore your makeup and your irreverent sense of humour. Looking forward to seeing you again in 2023. Happy New Year! ❤🎉

Love your makeup looks Charlotte, you are a big makeup inspo

Pat and Lisa sure took home best-in-show awards this year! I would have ranked the ABH palette a bit higher. I find it to be very user friendly and versatile for fresh everyday looks.

I got a few PML palettes and the cool tone holiday quint which I adore. Same with ND the palettes I got are stunning I’m so happy to have them in my collection. Great ranking video Charlotte 💕 I love watching you and the way you think, the color stories that you prefer is very similar to mine 😊Happy New Year 🎉

I so enjoyed this video! Thank you, Charlotte. All the best to you and yours and to everyone who reads this. Anne.

I love your voice and I fell asleep last night watching this lol 😂 so I came back today. Perfect. I agree with your selection I feel the PM palettes I was expecting to be on the top top winners. Those eyeshadow have something so magical and unique to them ! My favorite palette of the year was the Huda Beauty empowered one

Number one was not a surprise. It’s been my number one too, I’ve used it most days since I got it. I do need to get the 2 Lisa Eldridge palettes when they’re back in stock, I’ve heard so many good things. Happy New Year!! Xx

I like how thorough you are in your videos.

This was a fantastic video! I am ecstatic because I just got the Mothership X in the mail today!! I haven’t even used it yet and came across this video. When you said that was your number one I wanted to jump up and down lol. Your eye makeup in this video is stunning. Do you have another video of how you did your eye makeup with that palette?

I have 4 Pat palettes ( divine rose 1 & 2, huetopian dream, and moonlit seduction) and each one is better than the last! Moonlit seduction is my favorite fall-spring palette being a pale gal, but huetopian dream has my heart for the summer for bright colors!

Well you tipped me off the fence Mrs H!! Been undecided with the PM mothership X for months! But thanks to your review and the 40% sale I’ve fallen off my fence and danced my way into purchase town!😂 totally can’t wait to try this out!! ❤️❤️

I just ordered Mothership X, got some gift cards for Christmas 🎄 its my second Pat palette and I am excited!

This kind of video helps me what to buy next.

Straight to the description to see what that glorious nail varnish is 💕

I bought the moonlit seduction for Black Friday. Even though I only have it a few weeks, I absolutely love it. And it didn't even grab my attention when it was released. There's something special with Pat's palettes that you only experience once you use them.

I knew you were going to choose the PMG mothership! My favourite palette this year was the Chanel imaginaire quad, the Chanel Mediterranean quad, the Charlotte Tilbury pillow talk dreams and the chantecaille giraffe eye quartet. ❤

I know this was an eyeshadow video, but I couldn’t stop staring at your nails. Love❤❤❤

I definitely knew your 1 and 2 spots!!! I wasn’t surprised by any of your picks. And I agree with your choices and comments. The Dior palettes work great with my skin tone so I love them. I passed on the Chanel ones. I couldn’t help but crack up every time you said quint. So glad it wasn’t a drinking game and I thought of that too immediately before you said it! Great minds and all that! 😂 Loved the video! You know, when you were talking about the ABH palette (and I also agree), I realized I started following you about the time Soft Glam came out! I remember loving the looks you’d come up with. 😮😊 Happy New Year Charlotte!! 🤗🥰😘

Its amazing that you create so much stellar content while only purchasing 22 palettes. Its an inspiration.

Happy New Year to you and your family, may Gods bless you and yours.

Definitely PM X my favorite. Love!! All the Brigerton are loved. I haven’t ordered Lisa’s yet but I will. Love her lipstick. I. Agree the Chanel is blaa… I also love the Dior Cashmere. You might need it. Love this video. Well all your videos. Happy New Year’s. 💄👄💖

Vega and Myth are my two palettes taking the No.1 spot. Used separately or together, the looks are gorgeous and (it seems) endless!!! Oden's Eye Christmas Eve palette has a great colour story and the packaging is super cute 😍 Chanel Et Brun is a solid, reliable and classy palette. Love you 💞🤍💞🤍💞

I was on a low buy this year and I only got divine rose 1 (finally on an amazing sale) and ND my dreams palette. I loooove both so much ❤ Moonlight seduction is on my wishlist though 😊

Mine as of today is Vega. Like you, I am amazed at how versatile and beautiful that little, ordinary looking color story is. But.... Moonlit Seduction arrived this afternoon. I have ummed and ahhed on this one since launch having lost my love of the PMG brand, but couldn't resist it with 40% off! I plan to try it tomorrow, I swatched every shade and am excited to see what I do with it. So who knows, Vega might be knocked off top spot right at the last minute!!

I just ordered the Mothership X with the recent 40% off sale and I was HOPING that was the one on your eyes! I'm so excited to get it. 😆

Loved this countdown! It made me feel even better about my investments this year! PML Moonlit seduction and the holiday quints, ND Dream Palette, and the one I said “no” to….and held strong, the Lisa Eldridge launch. That is, until the reviews rolled in. I bought not only Vega but Myth! Since they arrived, I have worn nothing else. I love my collection (and include the Kaleidos Flowing Haze - not in your list) and feel I need nothing more in 2023! (Famous last words…lol)

I hemmed & hawed but decided to pull the trigger on the Pat McGrath Mothership X today. The 40% off & your raving about it finally convinced me😂

I loved both your choices and the order in which you placed them. I have quite a few of them. It would appear that I now must try Lisa Eldridge!😂

Wonderful video … Charlotte Tilbury is more accessible for me and l have bought Bobbi Brown and Bareminerals this Christmas. I wonder if you could do videos on these types of products which would be so helpful ( at least for me !) Thankyou and a Happy New Year x

wow what a video very comrehensive and detailed, another palette i would add would be pat mcgrath midnight sun.. i bought the mothership X in the sale and its fantastic xxx

I went kind of palette crazy in 2021 so only bought 1, yes, I know, I can’t believe it either, only 1 in 2022. One of my favourite brands, Oden’s Eye Christmas palette. I love their formulas and the colours are spectacular. Would love to see you try their shadows.

I'm surprised that the Nars Climax palette didn't make it into your Top 22. I purchased it after watching your video and it doesn't disappoint. Wishes for a happy and healthy 2023🎁🥂❤

@elainebines6803

Жыл бұрын

It may be because I think Charlotte bought that palette in 2020 or 2021? 1. Like you I bought after the video and thrilled I was able to ger it as limited edition. So easy to blend on my more mature eyes too

@katherineseymour6239

Жыл бұрын

I believe it was part of the Fall 2021 collection release. This video is ranking 22 from 2022. I see why you like it, it looks like something I’d enjoy too.

This year had some pretty good releases. My favourite was the Natasha Denona my dream palette, it suits me skin tone a lot so I like using it.

Love your earrings! Details please!🙏🏻😍🤩

I definitely knew which palettes would be your top 5, and strongly suspected Mothership X would be number 1. I thought ND Retro Glam would rank above her other palette, because it’s more unique and interesting.

Interesting to see your ranking! It would be even better if you could insert eyeshadow looks you've done with them before for reference

I am doing my nye makeup with the Moonlit Seduction. 🥰

Hey Charollet..u look stunning 🤩 ❤

Out of these, I only have CT Dreams, and it is 😍 I’m hoping to pick up Vega next year, but otherwise, trying to avoid buying more palettes as I’ve been leaning towards one and done cream shadow looks.

Oh my god!! I love you!

Have you ever seen Miranda Show? She says "fun words" over and over. Quint...quint, such a fun word. LOL Thanks for sharing. I love your videos.

Did I guess that Mothership X would be your favourite, oh yes I did. But you walk down memory lane with each palette was just delightful.

I'm so wanting the Vega palette yet it's been out for weeks now.... hope they restock

New sub & I just read the description & you are NOT 30!😳What kind of Hogwarts sorcery are you doing?!!! I need to know! I thought you were only about 25 maybe 28. I’m in shock & awe of how gorgeous you are!😍

I feel like my next ones will be Lisa Eldridge palettes. Maybe not all of them but I’ll have to choose but that will be difficult. I only bought one this year which was the ethereal palette but I was late in the game with it so I’ve only used it twice. I got it in the restock. I was really strict with myself. I could have bought way more. I really wanted the Mel bundle.

I’m so proud I guessed your top two! 😂

I was so drawn to Sorcery and I think the FOMO got me big time. Turns out Myth has my heart instead and will try and rehome Sorcery. I think I will be needing that ND dream palette though 😍

@kileaste

Жыл бұрын

If you don’t want your Sorcery I can happily and humbly home it if you don’t think you will use it. I can pay for the shipping costs 😍 It will feel amazing to use it second hand and do a bit of a sustainable effort.

I knew already your num 1 :)

I loved the ND my dream palette best this year!!! Mothership X is not my favorite - the mattes are a bit patchy on me and I would have preferred more browns rather than burgundy… however the special shades are her best ever!!

Oh my god, I just counted my eye palette I bought this year and they are 16!! Most of them are quad, but... OMG. I really need to go to a low or no-buy next year. My favourite of all of them is probably the smoky quartz by TF because I wear and love very understated and simple looks on my eyes

@MyCrownstar

Жыл бұрын

I love that pallet also for the same reason. You probably would like the new Burberry pallet. Understated elegance.

I'm surprised CT didn't do a big pallette this year.

have you seen the new blushes from Charlotte Tilbury, pillow talk Pink pop and Peach pop in the matte version

I though that on the 1st place will be Make up by Mario… What a lovely surprise!

I just have to share that I think the Retro Glam pallet is somewhat off putting to me. Never going to get it. But in my list I would have had ABH’s Rose Metals - such a well curated collection of smokey colors that all look good on me which is not usually the case - just love it!

@lesliehatch-herman9325

Жыл бұрын

Yes! That Rose Metals palette just sucked me in, and I love it!!

Those Chanel quads remind me of Avon quads…. Exact same packaging, and even color stories are very similar

I’m hoping one of these brands will bring out a blue or green color pallet with matts and satins and end the nudes! So many of these, which I have, look the same.

I was watching this during dinner with a glass of wine in front of me. I did drink when you said quint and oups, I got tipsy.......😵‍💫

@lesliehatch-herman9325

Жыл бұрын

😂😂

Hi Charlotte , yes perfect way , i would do it the same way , chanel tweed palette just didn’t do it for me , i don’t know why. i will second that i could have cried as i saved up for that ,I thought Tom Ford would be wonderful, yes Charlotte Tilbury love her ! yes its got to be natasha in various order ? please !!

I definitely agree with your top two but I love the Pat McGrath bronze bliss quint so would rank higher for me. Great video I loved your experiences of each and everyone of them. I think I need to pick up the Natasha Denona My Dream Pallette because it looks right up my street xxx

I don’t own one high end eyeshadow palette. I want to buy one, but I don’t know which one should be my first purchase! I want to make sure I don’t regret it, spending a lot of money on an eyeshadow palette…because it really will be a financial splurge for my budget. What palette should be my *first* purchase? I like the same colors you like…grays, cool tones, rosy tones, pinks, browns and neutrals. I don’t care for bright colors. I like muted colors, shimmers, and mattes. Soooo which palette (under $100) would I absolutely love, use all the time, and not regret? ☺️ 🙏🏼 Edited…I’d like gray cool tones, rosy, pinks, neutral browns, shimmers and mattes all in one palette if possible ☺️🙏🏼

@chinchillin6280

Жыл бұрын

I’m waiting for someone to answer you on this…..cause I need one too…. But I don’t need to buy so many either. One and done deal is my preference. 😅

You know, it’s odd to me that there are a good number of KZreadr makeup gurus that are bashing lisa eldridge eyeshadows…..so much so that I was afraid of them and returned 😢 I should’ve kept them!! But for a few you ladies, I see that these eyeshadows end up on these 2022 eye palette top 5! Thanks for sharing and taking the time to give us important intel. What do you think of the tarte eye palettes?

My eyeshadow collection is mostly bonkers/statement I suppose, or my neutral palettes are quite big (eg Biba), so I actually thought the Nars Unrated was great to stick in my everyday basket. Tbf though, I basically got it free because work gave us vouchers for Xmas, otherwise I'm not sure I would have.. Pleasant surprise workhorse palette is what I'm saying I guess :) (and don't come for me but I actually like it more than that small red Nars palette with the autumnal greens that I thought I'd love for sure o.O)

i gotta refill my drink 🍹

Yep, Mothership X is definitely my palette of the year. 2022 was a low buy year for me so I only bought 5 palettes and I would rank them as follows: 5. ND Mini Biba (maybe this came out last year but I only tried it this year) 4. ND My Dream Palette 3. CT Pillow Talk Dreams 2. Pat Bridgerton I 1. Pat Mothership X However, I do love all of them and all except the ND My Dream Palette have had loads of use. I definitely need to spend more time playing around with that one! Have a great NYE, Charlotte! xx

22 palettes in 2022… that worked out well!

have you seen the nars spring release whe I saw it today on a new new releases video it's awful it looks like a repeat of repeat xx

But where is ABH ??? the nouveau palette !!?? I don't understand 🧐 I m surprise 😳😳

@lesliehatch-herman9325

Жыл бұрын

The Nouveau palette was mentioned. I thought the ABH Rose Metals would be there, though. Now I’m trying to remember if she ever reviewed that particular one!

🥰😍🥰

drink every time i say quint!😂😂❤

💖💖💖

I meant 38 but I did think you were 28 at the most

🍹 🥤 🍺 🎉😂❤

I hope next palette is natural…..

Because you no longer show you makeup

After watching your best 3 of, it's clear you are beyond most of us, Dear.

@deecee5922

8 ай бұрын

I'm not sure what world you actually live in dear, but it's not in a fucking world where most of us can afford a 100 pound fucking blusher