One of the finest,of lectures,I hv ever heard from prof.guha.

An EXCELLENT speech - SO VERY WELL ARTICULATED with supporting FACTS & EVIDENCE. I completely agree with Mr. Guha that we Indians have NEVER UNDERSTOOD the PAIN that our Visionary Forefathers suffered, so we enjoy a FREEDOM that we take for GRANTED !!!! I LOVED his reference to C. Rajagoplachari as well - he was UNDOUBTEDLY a TRUE BLUE Indian who translated the Ramayana and Mahabharata into SIMPLE READABLE English and I have copy. IF ONLY we Indians could RALLY together and embrace our DIVERSITY - we could bring back the LOST Glory of a 5000-year-old civilization. Thank you Mr. Guha for your PASSION

Hoping the university will stand by its scholars, teachers and researchers. Do not let down yourself, your students and Indian citizens at large.

"India was founded in Aug 1947." It ends the debate.

@manojkumarbiswas2

Жыл бұрын

Hindusthan was existent as an entity from time immemorial .The difference is that the scattered identity was put under one administrative unit known as India .Let Guha and his ilk try. not to be oversmart

What a pleasure to hear an objective analysis , on history. People like Ramachandra Guha are very rare in our country

@bandanachatterjee7389

5 жыл бұрын

@jayaveeran 0l

@asdfgh9300

4 жыл бұрын

Objective? What you been smoking?

@mohanasrao

4 жыл бұрын

Guha's Lecture is strongly one-sided and verbose. I wish he had also glanced through some Historians of Indian Origin of early Twentieth Century and American Historians.

@karls9879

4 жыл бұрын

Thank goodness. Ppl like him are the hypocritical elite with an academic degree (sic.)

India did not start in 1947, as Guha and other Gandhians state. India was there, before East India Company came to India. East India Company was named in 1600, before they came to India. All western neighbours call us Hindustan, although we call ourselves Bharat. There was Bharat, since the times of Ramayana and Mahabharata. We start all our prayers with Jambu Dweep and Bharata Khand.

Guha sir ,thanks for making us aware, I m extremely flattered by the commitment of revered Gandhi ji's intent of abolishing castism.

@sukhatirthadr8904

Жыл бұрын

A most blatant lie! Gandhi believed in varna. Check Ambedkar statements on Gandhi. Nonsense! Gandhi was more concerned about Muslims than Hindu genocides under Gandhi

Dr. Guha is a very passionate man and critical historian and hearing him is an unmatched experience.

@Heretic-007

Жыл бұрын

Lol the guy is a massive fraud and a Gandhi Dynasty Mouthpiece. There is nothing critical about his Distortions

A sane voice. Special thanks for introducing the remarkable lady. I'll surely try to gather more material about her.

@KayEmnz

Жыл бұрын

Three feminists talking about Kamladevi Chattopadhyay kzread.info/dash/bejne/hIiil8-DZdGaoLg.html

Kamaladevi Chattopadhyay. What a life!! It's a shame that I didn't know this much about her!

@anuradhainamdar8967

3 жыл бұрын

Yes,I also stand in awe of her.

@sridharmahadevan7694

Жыл бұрын

Same here

@ashokdas7041

Жыл бұрын

Thanks to great historian Ramachandra Guha for this remarkable lecture where we get the scope to know about Kamaladevi Chattopadhyay.

We take this democracy and unity for granted today. Very true sir

@southernwind2737

2 жыл бұрын

👍🏾kzread.info/dash/bejne/X4WOmbRyc5mfZdY.html👈

I wish I knew about this video 3-4 year back.. I would have had an upper hand in my argument with my teacher about Nehru..

@tonymontana1965

2 жыл бұрын

nehru loved edwina mountbatten.

@abhijeetanand9877

2 жыл бұрын

@@tonymontana1965 so why you are jealous? no one loves you? Aww

@sawan8011

2 жыл бұрын

@@tonymontana1965 ok boomer

@tonymontana1965

2 жыл бұрын

@@sawan8011 nehru banned Hindu Sadhus from Nagaland.

@rjayanti5988

3 ай бұрын

Nehru was a anti Indian culture person.

What a great time to be alive and have such thinker as "contemporary". One of the remarkable things about his speeches is, he tries to clear the misunderstandings of people caused by politicisation of history.

@bmniac

4 жыл бұрын

The leftists have politicised history too. Is there a historian today with he integrity and commitment to truth like Sir Jadunath Sarkar?

@sunilputhan6282

4 жыл бұрын

Nehru was an Edwardian idiot, who Gandhi was in awe of , because of his brown sahib ways, if Patel was made the PM we would have seen a different confident India, Nehru was this enslaved colonised apologetic ashamed of his identity stupid egoistic man... he is the one reason of all the problems we have.... these sycophants distorians morons like guha claims to be a historian, Nehru was instrumental is creating the echo system here and abroad, his daughter institutionalisation of the suckup's creating this glory story of them with the help of Marxists & evangelist groups, this family has done irreparable damage to this glorious history & civilisation of this country

@sanjaykumar-rj9ns

4 жыл бұрын

@@bmniac I can assure Mr. Guha's works are completely unbiased and neutral.

@joyalsajan1168

2 жыл бұрын

@@sanjaykumar-rj9ns Nope,hell no.🤣🤣🤣🤣. A product of marxist indian historians.🤣🤣🤣🤣

@tonymontana1965

2 жыл бұрын

guha's career is one big misunderstanding.

Excellent, very clear crystal, impartial analysis without any political inclination. Really a jewel in present india. Pray to God for your mind and health. A macro broaden presentation.

Thank you AU for uploading this!!!

@anuradhainamdar8967

3 жыл бұрын

I agree

This talk of Prof. Ramachandra Guha is very enlightening and throws a lot of new insights into the lives and work of our great stalwarts of India's freedom struggle. It is to the credit of fearless and passionate leaders of our freedom movement that India was freed from the shackles of colonial rule. It is India's fortune that an erudite scholar, writer and thinker like Nehru ji became the Prime Minister of independent India. His Tryst With Destiny speech made in the wee hours of 15th August 1947 in the Constituent Assembly is a living testimony to the vision of a nascent nation. They were all great men and women, who fought relentlessly for the independence of the country. It was a colossal task to lay down the foundation for a nascent nation. Nehru was a statesman politician and was much respected and admired across the world. His policies have stood the test of times. However, it is painful to see that there is an orchastrared and malicious move in the country now to defame him. Nehruji was a democrat, who showed utmost respect to his political opponents. The present generation has to learn a lot from his life and work. Kind Regards.

Ramachandra Guha sir has great understanding on our modern history. Great work. Nice speech.

@raomadhukar3104

4 жыл бұрын

Extraordinary speech educating the present generation the modern history of India.

@omjee0

4 жыл бұрын

And also a great beef eater.

This video should be seen by every high school and college student to know real history of modern India.

Salute to Shri Ramchandra Guha, first I heard him on you tube and couldn't end the video without finishing it.

I thank Ramachandra Guha for giving this informative speech I thank Ashoka University tv for uploading this speech in KZread

@sangramkale3375

2 жыл бұрын

Yes we need more like this on KZread not just in the top universities

I had seen this book by Dr. Guha in a book shop from which I usually buy books, coincidentally the first of Dr. Guha 's biography on Gandhi. But I am a English literature connoisseur too, & because there were novels of Indians writers in English I chose them.Now hearing Dr. Guha lecturing so eloquently on these makers of Modern India, I feel I have read the bulky book, because he has succinctly gone through the want he has written. This Oratorial power of Dr. Guha is praiseworthy. I am pleased that I saw this video because I hadn't known of Ashoka University for so long until the 2020 controversy.

@tnbhat2850

Жыл бұрын

Mm Mmmmmkkkmmk Mmmmmkkkmmk aep

@maninatarajan5514

Жыл бұрын

Dr maybe historynbutis43

@shabarinathrao7870

Жыл бұрын

he propogate partial truth..to exemplify the Congress by burying facts

@Heretic-007

Жыл бұрын

Lol Guha is a Propagandist for the Gandhi Dynasty. He spreads Delicious Disinformation to gullible audience. He is a Marxist Jihadist Mouthpiece with a pathological hatred for hindus. His Biography should be better called Hagiography of the "Mahatma".

Had heard a lot about Prof. Guha. But watching him and listening to him is altogether a superlative experience……very liberating in many ways!!! 🤩👍🏼👌🏼✅💐👏🏼

@tonymontana1965

2 жыл бұрын

it is not liberating. it is nauseating.

For this one hour speach only God knows how many hours u have to study

Ashoka University, congratulations on getting such great panelists and speakers time and again. I have a request - show the audience fewer times during speeches. The perennially disinterested and distracted looks on most faces undermines the speaker and their message. Thanks.

An outstanding recapture of real happenings . Most of it is not known. Authentic and sensible statement of factual history. Thanks Mr Guha.

@tonymontana1965

2 жыл бұрын

guha is not known for factual history. his history glorifies one family and one religion.

@shirishdesai8328

Жыл бұрын

Not knows because they never happened.. these are the fragments of selfish stories created to carry on with a British style rules

A deep insight indeed! People of India need to realize that their roots are intricately spread in plurality of caste, gender, language and religion. Fanaticism and nepotism never yield progressive results! Political ideology should be more valid way beyond political personality. The pursuit of equality and equanimity should not be set aside by the feudalistic political parties. Lot of ideological responsibilities lie on the statesmen today! The silly contenders for MLA seats today can not even know what is enormously alerted in this speach. Lot of regards for speaker! Thanks for the upload!

@southernwind2737

2 жыл бұрын

👍🏾kzread.info/dash/bejne/X4WOmbRyc5mfZdY.html👈

This lecture for understanding our honourable leadership what they have done gooh or bad for whole nation.I appreciate to the professor he explained very nicely thankyou

Find out the person behind Ashoka Univ and you will get to know their agenda and their mission : fortunately India is in safe hands and future looks bright with current leaders

Caste System is one of the biggest challenges in India. Should be eradicated completely for India's good.

@rupendra79

4 жыл бұрын

@ur calpal I didn't get you. Do mean 'Chaudhary' or for that matter any name is responsible for 'Caste System' ?

@rishvinwin

4 жыл бұрын

@Shreya Seshadri point blank

@rishvinwin

4 жыл бұрын

@@rupendra79 Not necessary, after all a name is for identity, the point is that we should not be identified thro the caste name suffixing our names, it would look too digital if we start identifying each other with our Aadhaar numbers

@braveindian4870

4 жыл бұрын

Please watch video of Sri Rajiv Malhotra under Decolonising Indians series to understand the origin of caste system

@braveindian4870

4 жыл бұрын

kzread.info/dash/bejne/ZYt4qLiGf9fJZdY.html

In present times person like Ram Chandra Guha needed to guide youths of India for harmonious nation.

Great analysis.... Which I had never known earlier in detail... Specially tremendous effort of Gandhi ji, nehru ji and Patel ji...

i've got to know so many new things today... thank you

@roamaniacharri3976

4 жыл бұрын

All lies

@mohanamohan8726

3 жыл бұрын

@@roamaniacharri3976 ac to bjp, the only orgn that fot for our independance stuggle ! ?

Following you sir ......Thank you very much

@umarelan5789

3 жыл бұрын

M

I have thoroughly enjoyed this presentation. Thank you to Ashoka University and One of my favorite speaker 😍😍👌👌

What an amazing ending. Inspiring to say the least.

Salute to you sir for putting the facts in right perspective especially the relation between Jawaharlal Nehru and Vallabh Bhai Patel.

Fabulous! Just love to hear from people like him .

@southernwind2737

2 жыл бұрын

👍🏾kzread.info/dash/bejne/X4WOmbRyc5mfZdY.html👈

We must at the same time praise Sikhs, who started the custom of Langar, community dining. Where everyone, irrespective of caste, religion, social status, will all sit together and take, same food.

@adivisuryakumari7455

Жыл бұрын

Good talk on important subject notknown hitherto. Thanks to ramchanda guha

@cillverbullet

Жыл бұрын

😂

This guy is awesome

you have done great service by uploading this post .. this is the power or service of net neutrality i or many like me have such privledge to listen master piece ..thanks

Great lecture and very enlightening about the great leaders of freedom struggle . I am so proud of their visionary minds.

I am yet to lisren to a speech of this kind Very sensitising gripping speech on equality Gender religion and language which not many have realised muchless practised Borne out of years of study let me hug you thru this letter i have heard u in Chennai more than once Greetings for the Year Guhaji

Real challenge is our limited identities (of gender, race, religion, nationality, ideology). If we are identified by such limited identities we will exclude others, what we need today is a cosmic identity, in that way we will naturally become inclusive.🙏

I would hope Ashoka University will launch a lecture series on India after and before Gandhi by Dr. Ramachandra Guha. Waiting for its arrival. Really appreciate this work you're doing.

comprehensive & balanced speech☺☺☺

One of the finest speeches on the role played by early Indian leadership in shaping the vast Indian state after the partition of 1947. Many Thanks.

@pankajpanwar9799

2 жыл бұрын

P

@pankajpanwar9799

2 жыл бұрын

Hl

India is great Country and history to be rwad and know more snd more

1947 India was decided and Muslims got their demand fulfilled. Many if jot most of the Muslims stated back in India because of practical reasons, not for they believe in secularism or democracy. Now my question is, after getting what hey needed, how come only Muslims had 'wounds of partition' and how come these Makers decide to treat them with kids glove?

SIr, I may be late in this post, the Boundaries of the Country Bharat were defined in our culture right from the time when the great epics were written, the Ramayana & the Mahabharata. No one can shake us from the connection that we have to our Mother Land. anyone born and living in Bharat will never give up easily to let our country disintegrate.

@anritindia8309

Жыл бұрын

True words Buddy...

@disliketheclickbaits8858

Жыл бұрын

Yeah..but Bharat of that time wasn't one country. It's not like we had a boss king of all the kings.

@manojkumarbiswas2

Жыл бұрын

@@disliketheclickbaits8858 so what ?

@justsaying9189

Жыл бұрын

@@manojkumarbiswas2 nothing

@manojkumarbiswas2

Жыл бұрын

@@disliketheclickbaits8858 you are echoing Rahul who said India is not a nation but a union of states Of course it was not India It was Bharat or Hindusthan ,a land mass bounded on the north by the Himalayas ,and Bharat mahasagar (Indian Ocean )to the south ,known since yore by outside world and identified as such by its glorious civilization and an imitable cultural homogeinity

In 2008 the world bank said there is not fit-all-economic-model and each country should do what is best based on its culture

@sairaj8219

Жыл бұрын

Then why nehru copied soviet model. Then why india copied democracy from west

@manojkumarbiswas2

Жыл бұрын

@@sairaj8219 Soviet model failed in Soviet itself .copy cat Soviet model in India also failed.Nehru who described himself a Hindu by accident failed to catch the spirit of India

@manojkumarbiswas2

Жыл бұрын

@@sairaj8219 simple , because he had no model of his own which would be cmpatible to our national need and aspirations .Neglect of rural economy with undue stress on industrialisation created massive rural unemployment which various poverty alleviation programmes undertaken by successive later govts could not eliminate .Lack of financial discipline and large scale corruption ,nepotism in core sectors to which Nehru always turned a blind eye , resulted in a drainage of public exchequer .Nehru was a dreamer ,not a pragmatic leader of a newborn state .

Thank You Mr.Guha.

This one hour lecture by Ramchandra Guha, one of the greatest researchers on Gandhi, gives some glimpses of Complex socio- economic situation prevailing (@100years and more) prior to independence and how it progressed few years after independence and developed further thereafter. Those interested in Indian history but blindly follow false claims CREATED by current regime and propagated by paid media should listen to this.

Prof. Guha you missed one important fact that Odisha was formed on linguistic basis well back on 1936, by the visionary leadership of Barrister Madhusudan Das.

@adityadosi258

2 жыл бұрын

And also that, linguistic states were not a vision of Nehru. He and also Patel, in the JVP committee opposed it. It was only after Potti Sriramulu died in the hunger strike that he had to bow down under the pressure and accept the formation of Andhra Pradesh in 1953

Prof, Mr. Guha could you just bring some light on the BBC Archive Interview of Dr. B. R. Ambedkar where he has said that he has seen the fangs of the Old man when he gone to meet Gandhi on Gandhi's call from Jail. Further he stated that on one hand Gandhi was discouraging untouchability while simultaneously published article in Gujrati in support of untouchability and classism system of age old Sanatanism Practise.

@lazypops3117

4 жыл бұрын

he noted in a different talk that Ambedkar was very strongly insistent on the dalit cause, which Gandhi originally didn't know equally well, as he was an upper caste hindu himself. but with perpetual communication and disagreements with Ambedkar, who was 20 years his junior, Gandhi came to uphold dalit welfare, even in his own ashram. Ambedkar was an angry young man basically, and guha notes that overall he influenced Gandhi more than Gandhi did him.

I google about the dairy of that british civil servant, but no proper results.. where can i get information about it.

thanks sir

what a powerful speech.. thank you Dr. Guha

exelent how nobel speech about the indian history or reality

Thank you Sir 🙏🙏🙏

Fascinating talk. Thank you, Ram Guha., for making us see how the six you talk about are responsible for our belief in India as one country. Culturally diverse we are, but that belief is too deep rooted in too many of us now. It is hard for any goons with a lust for power and money to uproot. (This greed for power and money is why, although the Swiss have disclosed the list of individuals who have cash stolen from the country and stashed away in their private Swiss accounts to the parties in power, the list still hasn't been disclosed to the people.) The sad thing is, while they carry out their systemic loot, political parties create distractions. One political party has created this dangerous distraction of one race, and only one, to benefit from the spoils of India's progress. It is impossible to make good on that promise. Nobody thinks of asking them their exact plan, but it keeps many Indians fired up and busy and loyal to them. Surely these Indians see that India has progressed because of the input of all her people irrespective of race.

@clementgerard5892

Жыл бұрын

Well Said - Culturally diverse we are, but that belief is too deep rooted

Nehru was a visionary leader..Patel was a great administrator...Ambedkar was a learned and sharp constitutionalist.......and many more.....India was lucky to have them and many more

@sunilputhan6282

4 жыл бұрын

Nehru was an Edwardian idiot, who Gandhi was in awe of , because of his brown sahib ways, if Patel was made the PM we would have seen a different confident India, Nehru was this enslaved colonised apologetic ashamed of his identity stupid egoistic man... he is the one reason of all the problems we have.... these sycophants distorians morons like guha claims to be a historian, Nehru was instrumental is creating the echo system here and abroad, his daughter institutionalisation of the suckup's creating this glory story of them with the help of Marxists & evangelist groups, this family has done irreparable damage to this glorious history & civilisation of this country

@sauravindraguru3377

4 жыл бұрын

That's why India is still poor .

@sanjaykumar-rj9ns

4 жыл бұрын

@@sunilputhan6282 PM Atal bihari vajpayee praised him because he knew Nehru.

@nilbiswas328

4 жыл бұрын

Such moron you are ! I can understand your level of knowledge by your comment. You think Nehru was a visionary leader, I can only say that this is the jock of the decade, the damn truth is Nehru was extremely fool a sex addict he never had the ability to imagine anything good for our nation he was a coward backboneless so called leader. We are ashamed to have him as a PM.

@sudeepmenon17

4 жыл бұрын

@@sunilputhan6282 you surely have your right to disagree.....so enjoy man

Sir, at 19:00 you mentioned Ambedkar was elected 🗳 Minister from being an untouchable. USA 🇺🇸 had African American congressmen and senators long before Obama became the President. India 🇮🇳 still didn’t break that point yet. We have Kovind now but not in the position of Prime Minister.

@ramnadmichettu8117

2 жыл бұрын

You cannot compare slavery of blacks to untouchability in India, you have read/watch what the arabs,europeans,americans did with them for over 300+ years and lots of it still remaining in a different very clever way. Don't believe everybody who says he knows everything.

@MrAntonysimon

2 жыл бұрын

You are talking of a president a dummy of modi. What about making a sc or a adhivasi as pm. Let modi vacate and me space for a sc or adhivasi.

@naveenmanglur7078

2 жыл бұрын

Yes I agree. Law Minister & President are not the same. I'm surprised that learned Guha make such a comparison. It's a grudging comment in my opinion.Would not say it is back-handed.

@daffodilempire

Жыл бұрын

@@rammohanbabumallavarapu8452: Babu, I’m not comparing Ambedkar with Obama. Ambedkar was one of the founding fathers of India. I am comparing Rammohan Mallavarapu with Obama. When they elected Obama as President, why can’t Indians elect someone from affirmative action as commoner as you are. Hope you got it. Thank you

@PS-ej2xn

Жыл бұрын

@@daffodilempire How many governors of state in the US have been Black? Compare that against the rise of people from all different castes to the level of Chief Ministers in India. To become the President of United States, Obama had to rise above a narrow considerations and become a candidate of all people. That's what we need in India too.

thank u .ashoka university for uploading this video. .

Great talk.

If U give credit to Neheru for Hindu code bill then why Dr Ambedkar had to quit ministry of Neheru ! I think u are hiding facts here .

@nageshkolkar63

4 жыл бұрын

Yes sir

@akshaygoelcom

4 жыл бұрын

Did you read Chapter 11 of India after Gandhi. He clearly lays down all the facts and then gives his opinion. His opinion may be disputable but not his integrity or intellect.

@wethepeople1680

4 жыл бұрын

Because Ambedkar resigned. The Hindu code Bill he designed by him did not pass in the parliament. Because Hindu Brahmins and castists people protested against it. Nehru passed it in pieces.

@sanjaykumar-rj9ns

4 жыл бұрын

Ambedkar's Hindu civil code bill was not able to pass because of the castists. Pt. Nehru passed it in various pieces.

@hardayaldawra1458

4 жыл бұрын

Alok Biswas , the composite bill in original was not passed by the parliament. Nehru’s opinion was to break it up in 4 parts, to which Babasaheb did not agree, earlier he was frustrated by widespread opposition to his bill by fundamental Hindu organisations, so hr resigned but remained an MP of Rajya Sabha. Then the bill was divided into 4 parts, which was passed by parliament.

More people need to see this.

@imishy007

5 жыл бұрын

People should see many others.

@trick_er

4 жыл бұрын

@@imishy007 link pls

@VikramSingh-vg7gv

4 жыл бұрын

@@trick_er type Sanjeev sanyal on KZread and listen what he says on history...more so on freedom struggle.....

THANK YOU SIR...!!!

@07:24 the 3 padayathras of Gandhi including the forgotten 1933-34 march against untouchability

I'm happy that you acknowledge the legacy of atleast one lady at the end of your speech👍

@anuradhainamdar8967

3 жыл бұрын

Dr.Guha is not ignorant of women's contribution in India's freedom struggle this is clear from this profiles of Kasturba, Mira Behn, Kamala Nehru,& Sarojini Naidu.

Exceptional knowledge bank. What a great speech !

@sunilputhan6282

4 жыл бұрын

Nehru was an Edwardian idiot, who Gandhi was in awe of , because of his brown sahib ways, if Patel was made the PM we would have seen a different confident India, Nehru was this enslaved colonised apologetic ashamed of his identity stupid egoistic man... he is the one reason of all the problems we have.... these sycophants distorians morons like guha claims to be a historian, Nehru was instrumental is creating the echo system here and abroad, his daughter institutionalisation of the suckup's creating this glory story of them with the help of Marxists & evangelist groups, this family has done irreparable damage to this glorious history & civilisation of this country

I am thoroughly impressed with the respect and love Mr. Guha has for the British officials.

@vipintripathi2831

Жыл бұрын

Mr. Guha is self-declared saviour of Indian history...

Oh my god historians must be impartial and not biased and must not defend any criticism

Worth listening,, with spending time,,, course of history starting our republic with great visionary leaders,,,,,

He is simply a brilliant historian .Hats off to a truly great intellectual and every Indian should pause and reflect on his views

Wonderful illustration Sir. Am more inclined to learn about Nehru's foreign policies and mistake which invoked dire consequences in 1962 of Indo-China war.

What an amazing man 😭

@tonymontana1965

2 жыл бұрын

an amazing hagiographer.

Mr. Guha is the person who discouraged RESEARCH & ARCHEOLOGICAL EXCAVATIONS, how can one trust him to be a true historian!!

Awesome sir.

Very much informative, gives much more clarity on the history of our country.

Great lecture. Thanks.

Mr. Guha, when you go back in history,why have you not mentioned Shri Aurobindo who was the biggest threat to the Britishers, also one of the leaders of the Congress. Refer to his works and then talk about,why India survived till today. This is his 150 birth anniversary and his birth date is 15 the August too .

@prithvigulati6965

Жыл бұрын

Initially he was active but afterwards he went into the field of spirituality so his contribution to secular foundation of India is not that great that he be mentioned in a lecture like this

@shirishdesai8328

Жыл бұрын

He will not mention anyone that cracks his false narrative of history… there are different frauds , Guha is a fraud created by false leftist history’s ..

@anthonyfernandes4764

Жыл бұрын

​@@prithvigulati6965

@vijaydharsaun1777

Жыл бұрын

Yes,He became spiritual leader .

Well. British also thought that USA will not survive, and even attacked USA in 1812 to prove it. Great British thinkers are not all that great, and are mostly self congratulatory people.

@vasukinagabhushan

4 жыл бұрын

British are splitting apart now. Karma comes back.

@chandrareddy4392

3 жыл бұрын

The cases of United States of America and the independent India was entirely different. By the time us became independent in 1776, they have got single religion and language which partly United the United States. When it comes to India, everything is different including religion language tradition. On top of that, India was never United under any ruler as a single political entity

Brilliant!

Dr B R Ambedkar is No 1 scholar in the world , He has and till today is having lot of respect in the World except India.Based on his educational qualification ,Views , concerns , Ideas and experience Constitution is done.If we follow that constitution human rights and law thats more than enough to achieve the growth of the Government .We should all make to sure to follow his principles Even now none of the other ppl dont have best education , Knowledge . It's easy to talk and discuss but hard to achieve " Respect constitution of India " .Always Government should give free education and free hospital service it's their responsibility.But in this government they dont have projections for better Growth.Everything is inter connected it will affect in all the ways .So avoid unwanted things and make Better India

@lakshmananpk1457

2 жыл бұрын

No. Ambedkar was not the No.1 scholor in India. He was proped up by Congress. RCGUHA IS A PSEUDO HISTORISN, PLANTED BY ANTINATIONALS TO SPREAD FALSE HISTORY! HE SPEAKS LIKE A FOREIGN AGENT!

Thank you so much for your oratory skills,and being in academics and a lecturer I couldn't understand what you want to say, maybe I am not an intellectual as I am not from JNU,AMU,Jamiya islamia,even BHU, but I know a bit of Indian history, better we have a discussion some time,I'd you allow Warm regards

@noolsaalaram-7355

3 жыл бұрын

One plus one is equal to two.

History is written by winners. In the era of 1910-1920's Britishers captured , sentenced most armed revolutionaries and their supporters . But they were miserably failing in that because lot many started joining armed struggle. That is when Britishers brings a man now known as MK Gandhi from South Africa in 1915 who doesn't approve armed struggle . As soon as he comes to India they provide him curated platform and portrays him as leader of masses allows all his movement public speeches. In just 15 years most revolution is succumbed to this well hatched plan. All the revolutionaries like Bose, Savarakar etc were kept out of history Mr Guha like historians are encouraged to emphasize the history which was written by then winners aka seculars /MK Gandhi/ Britishers

Correction required by Guha Andorra: It is known as a principality as it is a diarchy headed by two princes: the Bishop of Urgell in Catalonia, Spain, and the President of the French Republic. Not prime minister of France

It was Dr. Ambedkar who gave the rights to women and Dalits through the constitution. Also that if he worked in partnership with Gandhi on Caste matters is something he has never mentioned or I have come across. Both worked on their own.

Excellent presentation.

Somewhere the very essence of what India was and stood for throughout history - her intrinsic and perennial quest for freedom have been relegated to the bottom of the heap of the modern day discourses. Individuals have been elevated to sometimes unnatural positions of prominence at the cost of her masses and her uniquely emancipating cultural and religious ethos. Entertaining talk but limited in content and context.

@anuradhainamdar8967

3 жыл бұрын

Satya Naidu in order to really really appreciate Dr. Guha you must take the time off , have you read his detailed biography on Gandhi? Do. 2 His book 'Patriots & Partisans' is another feather in his cap. To understand all these Makers of Modern India buy the book/ borrow from library & read & you should naturally apprehend India 's intricate intrinsic quality. Since I haven't read that book I listened to him ,I think within the time given, he has covered all aspects, now come your effort to get hold of the book anyway.

@satyanaidu452

3 жыл бұрын

@@anuradhainamdar8967 It is fallacious and rather reckless to think that one man, however erudite could encapsulate in his narrative the grandeur of India and her civilization. Each person is offered the opportunity to take from her whatever he or she can and each one will have a different story to tell.

@basusri1120

2 жыл бұрын

Sathya Naidu why don’t you come up with a Lecture or book and enlighten us on the “essence of India’s intrinsic and perennial quest for freedom”?

Awesome speaker 👌👌👌👌

Nehru was the one who got Ambedkar defeated from Mumbai.. n used article 356 for the first time against left government in Kerala

Its unfortunate he had to disclaim himself before offering a historical perspective on the state of democracy in India @35:00

@aatish8559

7 жыл бұрын

kesava Exactly. Goons are everywhere. 😅

Excellent speech.

यदा यदा हि धर्मस्य ग्लानिर्भवति भारत। अभ्युत्थानमधर्मस्य तदात्मानं सृजाम्यहम् ॥४-७॥ परित्राणाय साधूनां विनाशाय च दुष्कृताम् । धर्मसंस्थापनार्थाय सम्भवामि युगे युगे ॥४-८॥

Excellent.......

Neheru was reminded by Ambedkar many times of his (नहरू’s) own book contents to bring him on right track

informative speech.

Excellent

It is a great achievement and thanks to providence that you people completely lost your plot. As it stands, India that is Bharat was not founded in 15.08.1947!?