I honestly draw/paint alot and quite frankly it's the only thing I've ever been "talented" at and not to mention it's the strongest passion I've had for anything, I've only ever drawn anime, and fan art. But I've read and studied alot about this issue for the past few months. I never draw with the intention of competing or mocking Allah's creation, but on the other hand if Allah does not like it, then I have no choice but to stop. Maybe he gave me this talent, ability, and passion as a means for me to sacrifice it for his sake, perhaps that's the goodness in all this for me. It worries me and is a bit painful for me, but I am willing to let it go, Insha'Allah Allah makes it easier for me and for other people who are also willing to do the same, for only he knows our intentions behind doing this act are not evil, but if the act itself is something that he does not approve then Insha'Allah he forgives us and makes it easy on us to let it go, Ameen!

@twilights187life

5 жыл бұрын

Beautiful!! I believe it is ok to draw inanimate objects. Also if you draw animate objects than outlines are ok. So distinguishing features such as the face.

@abbysheyba8421

5 жыл бұрын

Drawing used to be a great passion of mine, until I heard the hadith. I have not drawn anything for years, I'm even afraid of painting landscapes. It is said that whatever the prophet gives you take it and whatever he forbids abstain from it. It is not befitting for the believers to have a say in a matter after Allah and his messenger have passed it. What we should say is, we hear and we obey even though we do not understand. Scholars are humans and will say some things out of their own desires. I'd rather not meet Allah and say, " this scholar said I should ignore the hadith" as an excuse. I'd rather not. We can always find something else to be passionate about, for me, I found writing and I love it. Keep it up bro, paradise is circled with limitations and things the heart doesn't desire.

@darthbike189

5 жыл бұрын

@@abbysheyba8421 you are right. I stop myself from drawing living creature after i read the hadiths. Actually, Im into figurative drawing. I believe this is a trial for us. Islam mean to submit to allah. When prophet ibrahim being told to sacrifice his son, he just did it to obey allah's order. He may not question why but he obeyed. It a test of iman and tawheed. Dunya is a test and it is temporary. Maybe we can divert our passion into something else.

@Novause

5 жыл бұрын

Ameen💎

@Meyra97512

5 жыл бұрын

I know that your comment is pretty old but I still want to share my thoughts. When I was younger, in my teenage years, I used to draw people and animals and I received a lot of praise for my work. I truly loved doing portraits and was heartbroken when I discovered that it was allegedly haram. Thankfully at my young age, I had enough iman to give up what I loved for the sake of God. Just as the scholar in the video, I can't make sense of why it would be prohibited, it doesn't make any sense to me and I hope God isn't angry with me for that. However, I just take it as one of those things that I will never understand and will just have to trust God about. Even if that hadith is false or misinterpeted, it's not worrh gambling my afterlife for. I abandoned drawing and discovered my talent and love for painting last year. I do landscapes, seascapes, flowers and all sorts of other things which have proven far more fun for me than drawing on paper. I hope that you will eventually find some other way of expressing your creativity, God didn't give you that talent by accident.

Allah is the greatest artist

@sweetsoul3169

5 жыл бұрын

Indeed 😍😍

@nonomalk6586

5 жыл бұрын

Of course💗💗

@ClaraJC99

3 жыл бұрын

@Ard Tru Allah created Van Gogh

@ClaraJC99

3 жыл бұрын

@Ard Tru but clearly it didn't work because computes can't think and feel like humans can

@ClaraJC99

3 жыл бұрын

@Ard Tru Allah created you and you body what more of a blessing is that

God knows well what's in my heart when I draw... I don't draw to worship them... These thoughts never came into my mind

@halfphantom8818

3 жыл бұрын

True

@nazmaparvin2423

3 жыл бұрын

Tru

@duncan3998

3 жыл бұрын

Even i found it weird when it was not even suppose to mock His art whatsoever. But it better be haram for the animators since they make it ''move''' and is MUCH more worse than drawing itself.

@cloudydraws2846

3 жыл бұрын

Do I give up my drawing I love to draw very much and I would like to make it my career and I do not have the intention for people to worship my drawing and I only draw up too the waist :(

@bhatabrar6376

3 жыл бұрын

Me too i didn't draw them for worship them

As a 12 year old who started drawing since 8 years old i always imagined working for disney land, until i found this out and researched more, luckily i found architecting which was halal, and now im almost a year working on it for my future, alhamdulillah, i was guided to the right way

@blaze56701

Жыл бұрын

How is it going ❤

Yah but there are so many scholars who say it is haram while there is this one guy who say it is not. I can't even decide what to do now. I seriously stress about this everyday and i can't destroy my old drawings, those are my dear memories. 😢

@bhatabrar6376

3 жыл бұрын

Same i was thinking to destroy my drawings

@shafinsadi9949

3 жыл бұрын

Why you want to destroy? didn't he cleared that drawing isn't haram if its not for worshiping

@xr1mp

3 жыл бұрын

just go with majority to be safe(which say its haram) because they literally have a authentic hadith for their argument while Shabir Ally just has his opinion behind his argument and Islam is not about your logic, it is about the Quran and the authentic hadiths. why would you follow the opinion of a person that just disregarded a sahih hadith on the prohibition of drawing living beings.

@shafinsadi9949

3 жыл бұрын

@@xr1mp Following this rule is not absolute in Islam, It can never be

@bhatabrar6376

3 жыл бұрын

@@xr1mp well its prohibited. And hadidh also says that its only prohibited when its not worshipped.

The prophet (PBUH) was talking about the sculptures and pictures of that time where people were worshipping them and taking them as deities to other than Allah (SWT)

@hecate3988

Жыл бұрын

100%

@ayako_samaa

8 ай бұрын

But hey, in the hadithes it doesn't talk about worshipping or anything, but just art

Subhanallah i love this person may he enter janatul firdaus inshallah and inshallah may join him too

@mistressannie2742

9 жыл бұрын

Ameen

@lpsstarz7232

8 жыл бұрын

+Annie QuratulAnn Ammen

@vanessaevangelista5766

4 жыл бұрын

ameen

@Vascotheman

3 жыл бұрын

Ameen

@mohamedsr5817

3 жыл бұрын

Because he says what your desires want.If the prophet (ص) have said that drawing living creatures is haram,who is he to say it is not prohibited?

I draw cartoons and sometimes human shapes. It's a hobby of mine.. but i don't khow..! I mean im not comparing myself to the almighty Allah...but im a little worried

@mxdz_art

8 жыл бұрын

same here :/

@gamerbear645

8 жыл бұрын

Youre right.

@ioriyagami4254

8 жыл бұрын

same here

@shafiullahnoory6761

7 жыл бұрын

rafsan pantho dont...

@abdulrahmanalmesaad4951

7 жыл бұрын

rafsan pantho there is no reason to be worry becoz Allah knows what's inside the hearts

When I heard about this hadith I was shattered. I am still sad and it's affecting my health. I thought of leaving drawing but I am not able to. I am going to depression now. I don't want to make Allah angry at all but I don't want to live like this as well. They say you can draw unanimated objects but that doesn't help, I believe art is something boundless and if you are restricting it, It dies there. Art is a very big support in my life as I have OCD, it helps me keep calm. Now I am nowhere. I don't want to make Allah angry and I don't want to leave it as well. 😔

@nasiba942

4 жыл бұрын

I know. I don't want to make Allah angry by complaining but I have been doing art ever since I was a little toddler. i love drawing animals. it keeps me happy. i can never draw sceneries as well as i can draw animals.

@AvdW69

4 жыл бұрын

My daughter is in art school at an advanced level. At the time I found out about this ruling it was already "too late". Still, there are several solutions or gradual changes artists like her and you can apply to their artwork. I try to tell that to my daughter as well. It's really hard though, because for her, her drawing art is also a way of expressing her emotions. And a way to deal with the stress of everyday life. I don't know (in the kind of art each of you are making) if it is possible to adjust some things in your artwork. For example, leaving out certain parts of the body when drawing something human-like? Like the neck or the nose? (See in the video in the link below.) As I mentioned, do it gradually. Allah Subhanahu Wa Ta'ala knows your struggle and He knows what is in your heart. Ask Him to guide you, He will make it easy for you. Btw, I also suffer from OCD and depression and I know how extremely difficult it is. Please, try not to be too hard on yourself or to be perfect. Furthermore, listening to Qur'an recitations has a healing effect. It really eases the mind ánd body. To me it's much more than that. I hope my words helped a little. Before I forget: Eid Mubarak! May Allah Azza Wa Jal reward you for your fasting and give you both strength and perseverance. Aameen. "Everything's Haram Gun": kzread.info/dash/bejne/iYaC27iHYLzAZJc.html

@sta._rina

3 жыл бұрын

Allah (swt) bases all of your deeds on intention. Alhamdulilah he knows why you draw and inshallah will forgive you. As long as you arent doing it to compete with his status of the creator or for idol worship, it's fine. Just do your best and Allah (swt) will appreciate it.

@mightyuso3140

3 жыл бұрын

Allah will not forgive you, you will be sentenced to hell

@halfphantom8818

3 жыл бұрын

@@mightyuso3140 I dunno tbh drawing good stuff is fine as long as u have good intentions. If drawing cartoons is haram then u can see alot of cartoons even on Islamic books for children and then art schools shouldn't have existed in Muslim countries. Every hadith had a hidden meaning behind it. We should just believe in Allah and His Prophet and do good deeds in life. May Allah guide us to the right path Ameen.

Quick note: The Hadith referring to the punishment of image-makers is, according to the majority opinion of scholars from what I’ve researched, to do with idols that are created to compete with Allah, and for the intention of being worshipped, and DOESNT apply to people making art for the sake of art. HOWEVER, just because I said this doesn’t mean it’s 100% halal because it’s still a topic that has a lot of difference of opinion. I only mention this because I feel like some scholars use that Hadith in the wrong context to strike fear in fellow Muslims that could drive them to depressions (I’ve seen comments about this and honestly it isn’t right at all). I hope with this information I laid out it will put some hearts at ease Inshaallah. Allah knows best and it’s better to stay away from doubtful matters anyway.

@mohammedmasud2150

8 ай бұрын

there are other narrations that discard the (competing with god creation) all together as a reason, including us artists as (مصورين), and stating how badly those who dare to do that would be punished, ... now I understand that the fear of god is enough of a reason to stay away form that,( which is why I almost stopped drawing my self) but god did gift us a brain you know, and there is a reason for that, we must come to our own conclusion, based on our logic and research, please dont just follow blindly, ..... you can not enter paradise by avoiding the test all together, read ! think !, no excuse now days, this is our burden, our test

@G1assWater

8 ай бұрын

the way i interpret it, its how you use the art. If you intended to use the art as a worship tool then it was haram. Just like knife, if you use it to cut a fruit its okay but if you use it to stab people its not.

Masha Allah. I am so happy with Quran Speaks :D it makes things clearer to understand. May Allah give you many many rewards :D

@ADeeSHUPA

4 жыл бұрын

NiCe

@imtiaz5633

3 жыл бұрын

He said we can drae right?

@saffiyabikodalayil2646

3 жыл бұрын

@@imtiaz5633 yep as long as we don't challenge god's creation or worship them...

I have to agree with Dr. Shabir Ally. At the end of the day everyone creates something, but it doesn't mean that we're competing with Allah (s.w.t.). According to this Hadiths principle, people who create houses, cars, clothes, etc. are all creating because they want to compete with Allah (S.w.t.) astaghfirullah.

@lfaizaanl

3 жыл бұрын

Drawing a human being is different from building a house don't you think?

@Br020XX

3 жыл бұрын

​@@lfaizaanlhow is a sketch of a human or an animal different than building a house or designing something , if you build a house you still need rocks , we also can't create rocks out of nothing can we ? can we create fire out of nothing ? can we create glass out of nothing ? no we need sand and fire to do that right ? don't you think that Allah The Almighty does know that we don't have the ability to create humans or animals and we will never be able to and don't you think that Allah The Almighty knows what our intentions are ?? of course Allah the most Supreme and The Almighty and The Most Perfect and The Most All Knowing knows everything , so why can't we draw things with a soul ?? but we can draw entire landscapes with the sky and rivers and stars and the outer space and what not ? we also can't create a simple rock , a small stone , we can't even create a little sand stone let alone a human or an animal or a soul or the universe .. so with this logic we can draw the entire universe with all of the planets that Allah the Most Supreme The Most Almighty has created , but we can't draw a cartoon human or an animal .. because only then we challenge Allah the Almighty Creator (EstafigrUllah let's be real here guys .. i disagree with this hadith , i think this is eighter a fake Hadith or this Hadith is based for the Arabs from that time that worshipped statues and (maybe ? ) even pictures .. and this prevented them from doing so .. i really don't know but May Allah forgive me if i have this wrong , this Hadith clearly goes against the Qur An , that clearly does not prohibit any form of art or painting exept of course if you draw profane things may Allah The Almighty forgive my mistakes

@honoredguest5283

3 жыл бұрын

@@Br020XX You are out of context. The comment didn't say that the people created the materials to make all those inventions (such as houses, cars, clothes, etc.). They only discovered the way to use them. But if all that has been writen in the comment is true (According to this Hadiths principle, people who create houses, cars, clothes, etc. are all creating because they want to compete with Allah), then all kinds of electronic that has been invented (including phones, laptops, and computers) are haram.

@Br020XX

3 жыл бұрын

@@honoredguest5283 that is exactly what i was saying , maybe you should read it again , because we could not even create fire out of nothing

@irshadazeez4764

2 жыл бұрын

@@Br020XX good points. Funny how a lot of the things that cause Muslims the most confusion come from hadith.

We just drew because we love Allah's creation not to compete him by any means. Is it wrong ?

@exodus3504

5 жыл бұрын

asman khan it is

@sairafarin2751

5 жыл бұрын

Spring tap why?

@exodus3504

5 жыл бұрын

@@sairafarin2751 watch the whole video

@hamidr8391

4 жыл бұрын

I am also an Artist and used to draw human faces but Now I have quit drawing human or Animal faces instead I had shifted my passion toward buildings and logo design etc.. and I am very happy Alhamdulillah... May Allah forgive us and make us true Muslims as he wants us to be.

@sallieceelee5660

4 жыл бұрын

@@exodus3504 i've watched it. he clearly said: I wouldn't subscribe to that as being prohibited. since you insist that it is prohibited, can you explain why you decided to contradict this scholar's explanation?

This youtube channel has such a refreshing perspective on islam and I love it. Although I'm not very religious to begin with, Dr. Shabir Ally is probably the only muslim scholar/preacher who I have ever enjoyed listening to and agreed with. I used to always think that everyone had the same closed minded views but seeing this channel and listening to Dr Ally has made me really happy :)

Thank you again Dr. Ally for bringing sense to this question with your explanation behind why you don't subscribe to this prohibition.

Why did Allah bless me with this gift? I’m confused if it’s haram or not to draw cartoon characters? Allah knows best

I love drawing and I'm a Muslim , I was searching for the right answer everywhere and this is where I got my answer

@muhammadaaus105

3 жыл бұрын

Asalam-Alaykum. Brother drawing is prohibited unless you draw under the guidelines of Shari'ah, for example, missing out the face, detached limbs, etcetera.

@Nitro2275

2 жыл бұрын

@@muhammadaaus105 No,if you dont worship it and the intension is just to have fun and NOT to challenge Allah it is permissible if you're still muslim

@muhammadaaus105

2 жыл бұрын

@@Nitro2275 No, rather this is wrong and one should understand this and try to comprehend this to the best of his ability. That which has been said by you is based upon one's own understanding which is contradictory to what has come in the textual evidence. We have a narration of the Prophet (ﷺ) where he instructed her wife to take off the curtains which contained images, this shows clearly that they were images upon cloth. As well as a narration where ibn 'Abbās the cousin of the Prophet (ﷺ) met a man who would makes pictures and shapes and he advised him to draw mountains and as such. ____ I use to believe in something similar as what you've stated and I used to draw much and I was becoming very good at drawing. Allāh Guided me and I then threw everything away and I have not drawn a picture till this day, Alhamdulillah by His Guidance Alone.

@Nitro2275

2 жыл бұрын

@@muhammadaaus105 Yes but,Some scholars hold the view that image making is essentially lawful. It is permissible to make two-dimensional illustrations as well as three-dimensional statues. The scholars who hold this view argue that the texts that prohibit image making are to be understood in the context of the state the people were in at the advent of Islam. The people had just emerged from the times of ignorance and from idolatry. After people became distanced from the worship of images, the prohibition was no longer necessary. This is why we see in some history books that when the Muslims opened up the lands of the Persians and Romans, they did not interfere with the pictures and statues found there.

@muhammadaaus105

2 жыл бұрын

@@Nitro2275 My brother, I gave you a Hadīth of the Prophet (ﷺ) and an account of his very close companion who was from amongst the scholars of Tafsīr of this 'Ummah. Other than that, the majority of the scholars have forbidden this since the early age of Islām. Of what then is the avail of such statements of a minority of scholars? I obey the clear evidence to the best of my ability and the evidence has been established upon us. This is an invalid statement that the Muslims didn't do anything to their idols and statues since I ask for a narration or a report which says that they kept it for themselves and this is contradictory to the saying of the Prophet (ﷺ) again. _Abu Al-Hayyaaj Al-Asadi said: “ ‘Ali ibn Abi Taalib said to me: “Shall I send you for a mission once the Prophet had sent me for: Do not leave an idol unless it is destroyed, nor you leave an up leveled grave unless you level it down to ground.'' [Muslim]_ Also, as observed from the Hadīth that the Prophet (ﷺ) ruined all idols once he had conquested Makkah and he didn't build the Ka'ba upon the foundations of Ibrāhīm so people would be turned away; we learn from this that a wise moment is chosen and if the outcome is greater of harm then we refrain until the outcome will be of greater benefit. _____ *And whoever opposes the Messenger after guidance has become clear to him and follows other than the way of the believers - We will give him what he has taken and drive him into Hell, and evil it is as a destination.* *And (as for) the foremost, the first of the Muhajirs and the Ansars, and those who followed them in goodness, Allah is well pleased with them and they are well pleased with Him, and He has prepared for them gardens beneath which rivers flow, to abide in them for ever; that is the mighty achievement.*

I thought that i was the biggest art lover.... Drawing was like therapy for me... I spent hours and hours in drawing and sketching... But one day suddenly a question popped in my mind... "What if drawing is prohibited in islam?"... I found this video... And now i decided to sacrify my skills for Allah... 💜

@aryanbaviskar1186

Жыл бұрын

There are different ways to interpret the verse. Context matters a lot in Islam. For example, in the Quran 9:5 it says to kill the disbelievers wherever you find the after Ramadan. It doesn't mean that you should actually kill all the disbelievers wherever you find them because the context tells us that the actual meaning of the verse was to only kill the disbelievers who were in a war with the ummah and had disobeyed a treaty. The same thing applies to the hadiths about drawing. The context was that meccans used to worship drawings and idols and the hadiths were meant to prevent them from doing so. But if you do not have the intention to mock allah or to worship the drawings then it is absolutely fine to draw in my opinion.

@Alizey2730

Жыл бұрын

@@aryanbaviskar1186 I have thought a lot about this issue... I also think that Islam is not that difficult... Action depends on intention... Thanks a lot for the guidance...

@aryanbaviskar1186

Жыл бұрын

@@Alizey2730 You're welcome. Do you agree with me?

@Alizey2730

Жыл бұрын

@@aryanbaviskar1186 yeah... I do 🍂

@-juicy_boi-

Жыл бұрын

Don't underestimate the mercy of Allah SWT Allah SWT forgives and He is The Most Merciful Remember the story of the man who killed 100 and Allah SWT forgave the man because the man wanted to repent Allah SWT is The Most Merciful

I m still confused?:(

@MrTahabk

5 жыл бұрын

You have to put your faith in Allah, he knows what's best. I dont think you will be judged on when you didn't know. But if it displaces Allah, and you give it up. Allah will reward some way or another. Have faith in the All Mighty for the love he has for us is unmatched.

@roberthannah7983

5 жыл бұрын

Ally says he does not subscribe to the idea that drawing is prohibited. That is clear.

@hamidr8391

4 жыл бұрын

I am also an Artist and used to draw human faces but Now I have quit drawing human or Animal faces instead I had shifted my passion toward buildings and logo design etc.. and I am very happy Alhamdulillah... May Allah forgive us and make us true Muslims as he wants us to be.

@ricksanchez1527

4 жыл бұрын

@@hamidr8391 thats haram too

@firdauseliyasu4462

4 жыл бұрын

@@ricksanchez1527 hpw

When i was little , i like to draw a lot and even thought of becoming an artist in future, but one day when i heard this hadees from my father , it literally broke my heart , i felt so frustrated and helpless ,but i cnt do anything ,so i let go my art bck then , but now I'm in confusion whether it is haram or not , honestly in my heart there is still regret that i didn't polished my skill ,but also kinda grateful atleast i had a strong iman bck then to let it go , inshallah if this isn't haram then i will try to polish my skill atleast as a hobby Cuz art is really something ,only thing which make me feel I'm not worthless ,i do hve something beautiful inside me to portray and express my emotion

My View: See If You Draw Something and Having In Your Mind That You Are Competing God Creation (As Hadith Says That We Are Competing God Creation) That That's Prohibited. But If You Draw With Pure Heart ❤️ Our Allah Is Above All This, He Knows What's In Our Heart. So Don't Be Afraid That's Normal.

i've been drawing all my life and have degree in 3D animation, it would literally ruin my life if i can't draw if it was considered Haram. I've never even thought about competing with Allah swt when drawing or doing a 3D model, all i think when doing it is to have fun in doing so. Allah swt can literally create life while i think(not think but literally can't) i can't and will not be able to do so in my whole life. So reading the hadith making me a bit skeptical since Allah will humiliate those who make an image of something by challenging the artist to give life to their drawing. What if the artist never intended to challenge Allah swt to begin with? What if the artist never intended to give life to their drawing and know that only Allah swt can do it? Also in Muhammad saw time, drawing and sculpting lead to idoltry and worship while nowadays people don't think that at all. I think it was important to give context on that time as to why the prophet prohibited it in the first place.

@G1assWater

6 ай бұрын

@Eli_Muwahhid ah thank you! Since it was so weird to me how a drawing of something was punished deeply even if the artist doesn't mean any harm in it especially shirk. It was a good idea to give context in Muhammad S.A.W. time, since his time is where most idol worshipers sculpt and paint to worship their idol.

Bro I just want to draw. I would never even think of comparing myself to Allah. I just draw for fun and also want to follow my religion. I just am confused and sad for these few days. I don't want to challenge Allah. I would never even think of that.

@Wafi-ig4jk

3 жыл бұрын

IMO you can still draw as long as you didn't draw any inappropriate propiate or sensitive content. The fact that the Hadith said it was an act of challenging Allah of who is the better creator is already ridiculous. Even the person in the video said that he would not see it as prohibited.

@weird7159

3 жыл бұрын

@@Wafi-ig4jk bro ik

@shrek-vh4nl

3 жыл бұрын

Me too :/

@Axelroy_Mari4

5 ай бұрын

I'm feeling you :(

@Axelroy_Mari4

5 ай бұрын

​@@Wafi-ig4jkHadiths content looks so realistic but it's still confusing

Why is free to drawing mountains And trees You still drawing allhs creation Who understand me 😐

@KILLINGGAMER07

4 жыл бұрын

He means living creations with soul

@hamidr8391

4 жыл бұрын

I am also an Artist and used to draw human faces but Now I have quit drawing human or Animal faces instead I had shifted my passion toward buildings and logo design etc.. and I am very happy Alhamdulillah... May Allah forgive us and make us true Muslims as he wants us to be.

@memoonatehseen8686

4 жыл бұрын

@@hamidr8391 I also did the same. What do you do if a client asks for animations in logos etc? Do you clearly refuse to draw? I'm so worried about this, I'm going to start job as a Graphic Designer

@ramshadnk8466

4 жыл бұрын

We are living things we have soul

@juhisultana4770

4 жыл бұрын

I too think it

Ramadan Mubarak! Subhan Allah!!! سُبْحَانَ اللَّه Alhamdu Lillahi!!! الْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ La illaha illa Allahu!!! لاَ اِلهَ إِلاَّ اللَّهُ Allahu Akbar!!! اللَّهُ أَكْبَر Allah Ar-Rahmaan!!! الرَّحْمَنُ اللَّه Allah Ar-Raheem !!! الرَّحِيمُ اللَّه

if its prohibited to draw people, then isnt it also prohibited to take pictures or video recordings of people, as it is also picture making

@D.A.Jamal.

Жыл бұрын

Who said it is prohibited to draw ppl?

I have heard this all before but I have a question I know we can't draw faces cause then we are comparing ourselves with Allah but I use to draw eyes mouth and nose and what ever but then my teacher told me that we should not draw facial stuff but when we draw a body or anything with out the facial things it is OK ...so ... can we draw without facial stuff ...

What if you're drawing a picture to appreciate Go's creation? Is that still considered as competing?

@kushinaa1XD

6 жыл бұрын

Art In Anime i agree. And prophets, right?

@markcarey8426

6 жыл бұрын

Who knows what god looks like? So who is going to say it's god or not? Do you know? Do you know better than others?

@blueberrytae

5 жыл бұрын

Ya'll Annas not saying that she/he is gonna draw God she/he is asking that can they draw God's creations in appreciation

@sajidteg4682

5 жыл бұрын

The reason we don't draw Rasullah PBUH is because he didn't want to be worshipped same with the rest of the prophets we must respect their decisions

@holdshiftt2run308

5 жыл бұрын

Majority of the scholars say that if the features of the face are not fully complete it is permissible.

I love to draw manga just like someone does but my friend also does so she said i can't....and plus im REALLY good at it and i tried focusing on being better on drawing faces then realised i cant draw faces

@thehourglassfan3515

3 жыл бұрын

Keep doing it. Anybody can make false claims under the guise of good/evil. You should only follow the evidence.

I m into sketching faces from a very young age ,I agree that it is forbidden but this talent has been given to me by ALLAH itself only..I mean not every 1 can sketch. .. I always found myself blessed to get this hunar and I can't truly understand although I am willing to give up .

@zestyb7512

Жыл бұрын

As a fellow artist for many years. I’ve just recently struggled with this Hadith. But I feel like Allah made this skill come easy to you maybe as a test. He will make the haram easy in this dunya and the good things hard.

@trumanetalks

Жыл бұрын

And now when you sacrifice that Allah will give you talent in something else. Or you can use that talent into drawing other things such as cars, trees etc

@ValleyOfMecca Thanks for your articulate input. Apparently, dismissing "hadiths" that openly contradict & compromise the contents & context of Al-Qur'an is blasphemous to "Muslims"... What's blasphemous to me is that so many "Muslims" blindly follow "hadiths" that are in no way, shape, or form, within Islam, whatsoever. But, that's ok - for you is your way, & for me is mine.

I'm more concerned that I'm putting my students in an awkward position. We have recently worked on self-portraits, only to have several students tell me AFTER the fact that they are prohibited from drawing human images (pupils in the eyes, specifically). I don't want to cause any trouble for anyone (myself included) and am wondering if they can do an abstract self-portrait- basically a collage in which they think of favorite books, music, stories, etc and use those images to portray themselves.

@Wafi-ig4jk

3 жыл бұрын

IMO you can still draw as long as you didn't draw any inappropriate propiate or sensitive content. The fact that the Hadith said it was an act of challenging Allah of who is the better creator is already ridiculous. Even the person in the video said that he would not subscribe to it as being prohibited.

Drawing used to be a great passion of mine, until I heard the hadith. I have not drawn anything for years, I'm even afraid of painting landscapes. It is said that whatever the prophet gives you take it and whatever he forbids abstain from it. It is not befitting for the believers to have a say in a matter after Allah and his messenger have passed it. What we should say is, we hear and we obey even though we do not understand. Scholars are humans and will say some things out of their own desires. I'd rather not meet Allah and say, " this scholar said I should ignore the hadith" as an excuse. I'd rather not. We can always find something else to be passionate about, for me, I found writing and I love it. paradise is circled with limitations and things the heart doesn't desire.

@roberthannah7983

5 жыл бұрын

The modernist approach is to understand the message that the prophet was getting at in his time and place in his society, not the literal word for word action that he directed, and apply that message to our modern world. And as you know, there is also a great deal of doubt about the validity of many ahadith, even Bukhari and Muslim. The prophet discouraged the writing of ahadith because he was worried that they would conflict with the message of the Quran.

@Wafi-ig4jk

3 жыл бұрын

IMO you can still draw as long as you didn't draw any inappropriate propiate or sensitive content. The fact that the Hadith said it was an act of challenging Allah of who is the better creator is already ridiculous. Even the person in the video said that he would not subscribe to it as being prohibited.

With that logic then using my imagination to create new technology should be prohibited because it is using our imaginations to create new things that god hasn’t given us in nature

Masha Allah. I am so happy with Quran Speaks

the way i go, is this......if there is a question mark on it i stay away from it, i dont want to take the chance, what am i gaining from music? nothing if i memorize a song i would feel bad cause i could have memorized a few verses of the quran, if the prophet might have said it is forbidden to draw a picture, i'll stay away, why even approach the fire? what will i gain from drawing, nothing. what will i gain from abstaining from something that might be harram? allahs mercy, ask urself which 1?

@jennate4386

4 жыл бұрын

I understand what you mean but it's not as simple as that when you've been drawing for a long time and really enjoy it and it's the only thing you're good at you can't stop that easily

I believe the prohibition of some drawings, paintings and sculpting among Muslims (not all), or as a strong tradition, is a big mistake that had important consequences. I think some abstract visual arts were important for the Sciences progression in the Islamic world, but the limitations also limited that progression. Math and physics (including Astronomy) was studied and developed with drawings, prose and poetry. Those drawings were abstract and minimalist. But in natural sciences, at some point, the mindset should be different, more concrete. Trying to draw what you see helps you understand better what you see. It's like studying. That was very important for anatomy.

ALLAH is the master of all art he is magnanimous beyond our imagination I love Allah 💖💖💖💖💖💖

*I Think We Can Draw, Our Hearts Know We're Not Worshipping Them.*

I love drawing so much😭 I’m sad I have to give it up, it is a good stress reliever ( there are still other ways I can do art ) but I liked song portraits. I’m sure Allah gave me this talent to test me, so we should obey. Does anyone know if we are allowed to draw justs the body, like human figure with fashionable outfits on then

@lamiyatarannum6079

5 жыл бұрын

Drawing fashionable outfits isn't wrong though it'll be better to not put the head on. And you can draw landscapes, abstract and still life. I know that these are permitted, other than those living being who have sentiments and senses.

@petarpetrov5548

4 жыл бұрын

That sounds so sad, a person who loves to express himself in way that it doesn't hurt or affects anyone else in a bad way consider to stop doing that because a book tells him to do that. Please don't stop drawing.

@sarax9178

3 жыл бұрын

Petar Petrov I won’t stop drawing, there are millions of other things on this earth which I can draw, just simply giving up dawing faces Isnt going to do much harm haha. It’s not just a book to me, it’s Gods word, and I follow that. I understand where you’re coming from totally but my religion means 1000000 times more to me, than drawing 💕💕💕

@sarax9178

3 жыл бұрын

waternotcoffee Heyy, Thankyou :)) but please respect that this is just my religion. And it means far more to me than drawing. There are many things I can draw besides faces. Also - Essentially, I am ‘God’s slave’ because I live for God, I live to obey and worship him. And I wouldn’t want it any other way. I do think for myself, but my religion guides my thought process and I trust in God and know that he knows what is best for me. Lastly, no, I don’t only have this life, in islam we believe in an after life, and there I will have all the happiness and freedom. Making sacrifices in this world is definitely worth the reward of the afterlife, this life is a test and it’s supposed to be challenging haha. Either way, I am enjoying my life :))

@ant-hw9os

3 жыл бұрын

@Beech yes, we believe we were created by a higher being, someone unlike us and He created us and gave us life so its only logical that we worship Him and enslave ourselves to Him. We do what He tell us to because we believe whatever He has told us to do or forbidden for us is for our own benefit. If you believe you're created by a higher being, you would want to know why that Creator created you (with what purpose) And we as Muslims believe Qur'an is the word of God, where He tells us how to live Please don't think that this oppresses us, rather it actually gives us guidance and makes us better versions of ourselves :)

Well it depends on your intentions right? What if am not trying to compare with Allah? Just for fun is there like further explanation on why it's prohibited

Everytime i study, i have a pen and copy with me so how can i stop my self from drawing cartoons from my imagination, this is just hurtful.

@AbcXyz-hh7cb

4 жыл бұрын

Right same happens to me

@AbcXyz-hh7cb

4 жыл бұрын

I have made a lot of drawing and cartoon and human but i lost most of them. Is it enough to stop making them or i have to destroy them all but i cannot do that because some of them are lost some of them i have given to my friends .please answer me???????

@naecries9472

3 жыл бұрын

@waternotcoffee dont tell people what to do dude

@samia6888

3 жыл бұрын

Think to yourself that the pleasure of Allah is greater than the pleasure you get from drawing. By giving it up He will bless you with unimaginable blessings. This life is a test. If it was easy then it wouldn't be a test. Some people have a difficult time giving up alcohol, others have difficult time giving up fornication, we have a difficult time giving up drawing. That is what we are being tested with. Just be patient and not draw humans and animals. If you need to draw then draw inanimate objects like trees and landscapes or just paint random colors to get it out of your system. You will be able to paint all of what your heart desires in Jannah. Please have patience till then. You aren't giving anything up permanently. Allah is taking it from you and holding it for the hereafter. Take care of yourself and hope to meet you all in Jannah.

@samia6888

3 жыл бұрын

@@AbcXyz-hh7cb sincerely repent to Allah and never do it again. That should be enough and not worry about what you lost.

As long as we do not draw for worship to anything... it is OK to me....we the artists never compete with God... it is out of our imagination... we never imagined it... moreover, we try to mimic his beautiful creation in our own way...

What if we have to draw diagram for learning purpose like diagram of cell or heart etc is it haram as well

@randomtas8840

5 жыл бұрын

Hammad Bhat no it’s fine if you have to do it for educational purposes

TO ALL PEOPLE THAT CAME HERE SEEKING REASON TO DRAW ... JUST DO IT .. AND BE RESPECTFUL . ART IN FIRST PLACE REPRESENTS AND CONVEYS BEAUTIFUL MEANINGS AND EMOTIONS AND I KNOW FOR SURE THAT GOD WON'T BE AGAINST THAT . JUST BE RESPECTFUL TOWARDS OTHER PEOPLE AND CULTURES WHEN YOU DO ART

@herticate8579

3 жыл бұрын

we. cant draw living creatures.......... it would be disrespectdful to mimick gods creationg

@herticate8579

3 жыл бұрын

@@Ninsensce . I Get your point brother/sister. well said! ^^

@gharibsoufiane4981

3 жыл бұрын

@@herticate8579 did you know that aicha the wife of the prophet peace be upon him used to make her own toys while she was young mimicking god's creation. did you know that the prophet Soloman had creatures that are called jinn who used to make him status . there is a verse in Quran referring to that.

@afreen676

3 жыл бұрын

@@gharibsoufiane4981 😮😯😍 I really really love human pencil sketch🤧😔😔

I draw manga and love draw it. I had or still have dream of making my own in the later future, because i have a lot and a lot of story to tell. so my Question is, it is really Haram to draw manga? because I imagine manga as lifeless drawing and not as living things. so even though manga isn't living things like human and animals is it still haram drawing.

@bariizaya9671

7 жыл бұрын

thanks

@ikhadji

6 жыл бұрын

Aya_has_ Secret no

@gamer2popspops970

5 жыл бұрын

I hope that you saw that. There are ahadith in books like Sahihal-Bukhari which contradict the Holy Qur'an, so we need to be careful about ahadith.

@MusantoSus

5 жыл бұрын

@@gamer2popspops970 No Sahih hadeeth contradicts the Holy Quran. You have to understand the context.

@hamidr8391

4 жыл бұрын

I am also an Artist and used to draw human faces but Now I have quit drawing human or Animal faces instead I had shifted my passion toward buildings and logo design etc.. and I am very happy Alhamdulillah... May Allah forgive us and make us true Muslims as he wants us to be.

Drawing remained the hand of my mind ...but when l check the video to clear my doubt whether it is allowed in lslam l find no...and for me the order of Allah the merciful and prophet Muhammad sallaallahualihi wa salam is enough so l intentionally sacrifice the inteion of my mind.

@Wafi-ig4jk

3 жыл бұрын

IMO you can still draw as long as you didn't draw any inappropriate propiate or sensitive content. The fact that the Hadith said it was an act of challenging Allah of who is the better creator is already ridiculous. Even the person in the video said that he would not subscribe to it as being prohibited.

this is stupid, why am I competing with God, I am drawing with my own free will. I love ART.

@rahi4443

3 жыл бұрын

@amy whinehouse did you just replied to a 10 year old comment?

@nousinjahansumi9442

3 жыл бұрын

@@rahi4443 ha!ha!ha

For years I’ve had a dream of becoming a artist and a animator (this channel is my animation channel) I heard the Hadith and I don’t want to twist the prophets (SAW) words! Within these year of practicing I wasn’t that Islamic and I didn’t pray at all but I was focusing my time on how to get better at drawing anime. I wanted to drawing my own oc’s (original character) and make a song in the background and they relate to the song kinda like a animatic of something. For 2 years I practiced and I’m at a semi pro level. I made all my characters backgrounds and their appearances, I listened to 100 + songs( most that have bad language in them) and wanted my characters to sing it or relate to the song. I written more than 50 things they can do in each song over the years. And to finally when I’m at a stage I can publish my animatics “I FIND OUT ITS HARAM TO DRAW?!!!!!” I couldn’t believe it! Then I search everywhere for a answer and some were saying it’s haram and some were saying it’s not! I was confused, so I listened to the ones who are saying it’s not haram. But after that every time I drew a anime or manga character I had a big doubt and it was killing me from the inside my heart was hurting! I didn’t continue to draw and felt miserable the whole 3 days. I felt lost. All these years of work for nothing? Even when my family was struggling I bought pencils and thought to myself I’ll make them rich!? By the way it’s the third day and I finally am ready to give up art. It says it clearly in the Hadith. Listen to your heart and if it’s in doubt even if you spend years on it give it up for Allah. And inshallah god will give you better. And have patience. If you can’t draw in this word. And still want to draw in the next. He will give it to you. Now I don’t know what to do. I do like instruments so I’ll try finding something new. May Allah make it easy for us all. I even bought a laptop and drawing pad. So The reason I’m telling you that is because I will give up anything for god. Oh and I got a lot of anime drawing books about 500 + books and 2000 + videos of drawing anime that I’ll never read or watch.

@theswagycookie4952

3 жыл бұрын

Damn wow that’s just painful to just leave a thing you have trained for several years is it better now for you?

@scarlettista6930

3 жыл бұрын

The Swagy Cookie after a couple of days I didn’t feel like drawing and didn’t feel sad at all even though I wanted to. Some more days after I have a dream where I ask a scholar a question about something (i can’t remember what the question was but I was something not related to art) and the scholar replied that it was only forbidden in the prophets time and is now allowed. So In my head I though does that mean art is allowed? Then my dream ended. After that I’ve been drawing faces The doubt that was once there has disappeared, I have nothing hurting my heart. So yes I still draw faces and plan on drawing my animatics. I now have something I didn’t have before. A peaceful and happy heart. That is probably because I’ve started to pray and focused most of my time on god. Right now I’m confused. But I’m confused and happy. If it’s wrong then may god forgive me. I’ve asked my local scholar and he said he’ll find out for me. So I’ll await for him to give me my answer.

@scarlettista6930

3 жыл бұрын

The Swagy Cookie in the meantime. I’ll be drawing faces and doing my animatics. If it’s haram then I’ll stop the faces and draw the mountains and trees

@theswagycookie4952

3 жыл бұрын

Mrs Animate that’s nice to hear and by the way if it’s haram I think you still can draw a “person” or something if you don’t draw the neck of it by my research

@scarlettista6930

3 жыл бұрын

The Swagy Cookie thank you! I’ll keep that in mind

by drawing picture we cannot compete God bcoz creation which is made by God is all perfect and precised but pictures made by men are imperfect even if it looks beautifull however it's a Talent given the God himself right

I want to ask that can we make hijabbies sketch like having veil? And sketches like the dont have faces on? Like having black and white sufi images... Or a head, hairs body but not face features? And can we jusst make eyes, just nose just lips i mean not all of them making face but seperatly?

I am not fotografier or an artist i just have a posters of celebetrise in my room that have bougth is it haram ?

What about drawing biology diagrams of eyes and organs for purposes of gaining and remembering knowledge?

@azybes6510

7 жыл бұрын

Dana Solaria me too

@sunshineart3564

7 жыл бұрын

nice question

@TheMelopeus

7 жыл бұрын

You should do whatever makes you happy. No all loving god would stop you from that.

@johnnyenglish1264

6 жыл бұрын

Yes, it's allowed but only for educational purposes. If you're doing it earn fame and money, then it's haram.

@yamidhossain8870

5 жыл бұрын

not haram

Is painting nature also prohibited ? I'm fighting with severe depression.its only way to release my depression. I've severe phobia n anxiety. Whenever i feel symptoms ,i paint to relieve myself.

@phoenixero8161

3 жыл бұрын

Nothing wrong with painting landscapes or anything that isn't a human/animal.

@zazahere_

3 жыл бұрын

@@phoenixero8161 is selling also haram?if we only paint nature ?

@phoenixero8161

3 жыл бұрын

@@zazahere_ While I am not entirely sure, from my understand it should be allowed to paint nature such as trees/landscape etc. Hadiths discourage only drawing of humans/animals or anything with a soul in it. I don't think it is haram to sell, or become landscape artist as a profession. Still, I am not 100% sure so you should do some research first.

@sunflower-ww1gp

3 жыл бұрын

@@phoenixero8161 can I draw space objects like planets

@phoenixero8161

3 жыл бұрын

@@sunflower-ww1gp again, a planet is not a living thing so it should be fine

Thank You! 🌺

I dont draw human face. Sometimes I just draw pictures of hands and.. Like boats buildings is that okay?.. Is it okay to draw pictures of hands???

@muhammadaaus105

3 жыл бұрын

Yes, drawing should be missing a face, limbs, etcetera.

I'm still 😕 confused... if image drawing is haraam then photography n videos would also be haraam.... who in their right mind would draw animals to compete to Allah... its always to praise His perfection....???? Humanly figures I understand should not be made bcz of the fear of idolatry that is caused from drawing humanoids...

@roberthannah7983

5 жыл бұрын

You are right. Ally is saying that, in view of the uncertainty surrounding hadith and how they should be interpreted in our society, it is impractical to follow all hadith directives as though one were living at the time of the prophet in his society.

@ADeeSHUPA

4 жыл бұрын

@@roberthannah7983 uP

Okay so I'm again searching for this topic because I have a entry test for which I have to draw a portrait and I'm really confused what should I do..

@vainalyrics9957

5 жыл бұрын

Same here

@iAmeer

3 жыл бұрын

Drawing is not haram unless your intention of drawing something is to: worship it, sexual pleasure, or challenging Allah.

@food-chief

3 жыл бұрын

@@iAmeer yeah, if we draw for just our own fun, if it's our hobby.. if we do not use it for worship and all..is it then permissible?

@iAmeer

3 жыл бұрын

@@food-chief ofcourse

@food-chief

3 жыл бұрын

@@iAmeer yup.. thanks

I used to draw, once I found out that it is haram I stopped. I only draw inanimate objects and nature but the urge to draw a friend, a human or even manga was strong but I still refrained from it. I want to make Allah happy so I gave up the only thing that was a good talent of mine. I can always just find another hobby like writing but I love drawing, so it is hard but I will overcome it. I am 13 so it will be hard not to live up to my passion when I grow up. Allah knows best if I am doing right or wrong.

@rehanfarooqui2071

2 жыл бұрын

MashAllah may He (swt) bless you with more blessings for your amazing sacrifice Ameen

Is it okay to draw anime style because their facial expression are different from drawing realistic drawing I'm just really confused right now 😐

We are all doing our creative talents as we have strong belief That these are all given by our Allah

@hiraimran2848

4 жыл бұрын

HUZAIN FZR very true. Art can be a means of appreciating our beloved Allah’s creation not to compete with Him. Humans can never even imagine to compete with Allah.

@amna5904

2 жыл бұрын

@@hiraimran2848 maybe your talent is a test from Allah SWT.

I cant challenge allah swt and I cant even thing of challengeing Allah I used to draw realistic animals and I want to continue. What if my intension is not challengeing Allah swt but just doing my hobby and Allah swt has given me this Tallent

@AbdulRehmanTahir-wy7cl

10 күн бұрын

Same here buddy 😢

Assalam wa aleikum. I'm really into drawing fashion sketches for the sake of displaying clothes. But ever since I heard of this Hadith I haven't drawn since. I never draw facial features (eyes, mouth, nose, ears, eyebrows, eyelashes) just a round face shape and the body. Is this allowed? Jazak Allah Khairan.

@Wafi-ig4jk

3 жыл бұрын

IMO you can still draw as long as you didn't draw any inappropriate propiate or sensitive content. The fact that the Hadith said it was an act of challenging Allah of who is the better creator is already ridiculous. Even the person in the video said that he would not subscribe to it as being prohibited.

So I was watching Sultan Abdul Hamid series and there he draws a portrait of his wife and gifts it to his wife, can someone explain why he did that

I dont understand the position of the speaker towards hadiths He mentions a hadiths then clashes it at the end

@unfrozenleaf970

4 жыл бұрын

Because it is a given that drawing human shapes is not an act of competition towards God. Dr. Shabir is alluding to a more fierce interpretation of the term "drawing," such as creating humans in vitro-fertilization in scientific laboratories. We now have the technology to draw or create people, however we do not have the means of creating the fundamental soul or the very fabric of life which propels one into action.

@Capkauna

4 жыл бұрын

I'm going to say he avoids giving a clear answer because of the murderous nature of some Muslims? Man wants to get home to his wives and sleep peacefully in his bed, not get mauled for daring say the truth, that some books considered holy are just insanely wild and should be taken more lightly that they clearly are...

@unfrozenleaf970

4 жыл бұрын

@@Capkauna The best advice I can give you is to refrain from judging people for their religious beliefs. You once justified slavery through Christianity and imported over 3 million slaves to build a nation. Stop judging others please

@Capkauna

4 жыл бұрын

@@unfrozenleaf970 you might want to reconsider. I'm East European. My ancestors were too busy keeping the invading hordes out off their lands and blocking access to the rest of Europe, and orthodox christianity never taught about slaves but servants. Keeping people as animals has never been a practice in the lands i'm from, nor in the religion. Closest to slaves we had was the feudal times and those were not comparable to the ones colonial countries kept... Fancy of u to assume I'd be Catholic...

@ADeeSHUPA

4 жыл бұрын

@@unfrozenleaf970 صور

So, drawing for simple amusement is haram? I'm not a professional and I usually draw when I'm bored. I have no intentions in selling anything. If anyone can answer this, I'd be very grateful.

@Zerin666

6 жыл бұрын

same i draw manga not because im tryiong to be superior :/

@Person-nw1mp

3 жыл бұрын

There is always other options for drawing, like landscapes and plants, this is a test from Allah, it may feel severe and a lot of people in the comment section feel this way but this is a very debatable topic so its best to just consider is haram and stay away from punishment

Certain Chinese characters such as 人 (man) and 天 (heaven) evolved from ancient drawings of men, and still vaguely resemble these drawings. Does that make writing these characters forbidden?

My understanding was back in the 6 th century ce that there were artist depictions of Muhammad. Is this true ?

I drew many images and I REGRET PLEASE HELP ME! what do i do should i completely cover it with the same coloured pen over it...pleaseee telll!!! .....ALLAH IS THE GREATEST ALLAH KNOWS BEST!

@herticate8579

3 жыл бұрын

repent, and abandon the images...

@duncan3998

3 жыл бұрын

Just give this up for the sake for Allah. but you are allowed to draw landscapes etc. just as long it has no soul ''living being'' like animals or humans.

@ahmadnawaz3401

3 жыл бұрын

@@duncan3998 ok Jazakallah hu khair!!!

@duncan3998

3 жыл бұрын

@@ahmadnawaz3401 Or if it also makes you better, you can also draw objects that are lifeless like furtnitures, weapons etc. just to soften your heart, your welcome

@ahmadnawaz3401

3 жыл бұрын

@@duncan3998 Jazakallah!! thank you so much

I have my thoughts. Allah didn't forbid us from watching cartoon and anime. And small children are okay to play with dolls. So doesn't it mean that it's okay to draw anime and cartoons. Because the cartoon character have to be made

@Wafi-ig4jk

3 жыл бұрын

IMO you can still draw as long as you didn't draw any inappropriate propiate or sensitive content. The fact that the Hadith said it was an act of challenging Allah of who is the better creator is already ridiculous. Even the person in the video said that he would not subscribe to it as being prohibited.

What about "Innamal Amal o binniyat" as i dont have intentions about challenging or competing or mocking Allah Almighty's creation.

if drawing the pictures of animations and all is haram then applying lipstick listening music TV is also haram but also some are following this so what is there in this to not follow

I have been drawing anime for a long time, i am very worried.

@iAmeer

3 жыл бұрын

Drawing is not haram unless your intention of drawing something is to: worship it, sexual pleasure, or challenging Allah.

@duncan3998

3 жыл бұрын

Well, you gonna be since drawing humans is totally prohibited in Islam. Same with animals.

@Wafi-ig4jk

3 жыл бұрын

IMO you can still draw as long as you didn't draw any inappropriate propiate or sensitive content. The fact that the Hadith said it was an act of challenging Allah of who is the better creator is already ridiculous. Even the person in the video said that he would not subscribe to it as being prohibited.

@ValleyOfMecca Not quite... I'm Muslim. I'm not a sufi, or a shia. A wahabi or a sunni. I'm Muslim - I refer to, & rely on Al-Qur'an, ALONE. If a "hadith" happens to compliment & adhere to Al-Qur'an, I certainly cherish it - but if it doesn't, (like ones that ban dogs as pets, or music as being "haram", or that drawing pictures is blasphemous") I dismiss it entirely. If you feared God, & relied on what He says about that sort of matter, you would too.

@ADeeSHUPA

4 жыл бұрын

mK

I really appreciate Dr Ally's answer on this perplexing question. He always approaches an issue from a learned position with with cool reasoning and a lifetime of study. Art within Islam has fascinated me for a long time, though I am not a muslim. Unlike the other major Abrahamic faiths, Islam has particular Hadiths which can cause much costination, especially is that individual is an artist. I myself am a portrait painter and have painted several Muslims friends and colleagues. I often wondered how a Muslim with an interest in drawing could be gifted with such a nature, if it was not from Allah himself? Through out history there have been many great Islamic portrait artists, and clearly they were not creating idols or anything to be worshiped, but instead recording important figures with in the great tapestry of Islamic history. This, I believe, is also a view shared by the great of scholars of the Al-Azhar University. God willing (there is only one God and Muhammad was his prophet), Dr. Ally's answer will go some way to help those struggling with concerns regarding drawing and portrait art.

@muhammadaaus105

3 жыл бұрын

Hadith are the sayings of Prophet Muhammad. In the Qur'an it is mentioned to obey the Prophet, for obeying the Prophet is to obey Allāh. We Muslims are obliged not to draw that which has a soul unless it follows a specific guideline accordingly to the Shari'ah.

@townsendm794

3 жыл бұрын

@@muhammadaaus105 I don't doubt your understanding, but why then do Dr Ally and the scholars of the Al-Azhar provide a different interpretation?

@muhammadaaus105

3 жыл бұрын

@@townsendm794 As an analogy, there are Hadith in Islam that forbids us to listen to musical instruments. The majority of the scholars agree with this matter, however there are still a minority of scholars which disagree, even though the scholars in minority are well versed, learned men, following the mainstream Islam. The same applies with Dr. Shabir Ally's verdict upon this matter.

@townsendm794

3 жыл бұрын

@@muhammadaaus105 Many thanks for your answer, that is interesting to know.

A question, there is a problem drawing a face?

Sahih Muslim Book 024, Hadith Number 5246. Chapter : Angels do not enter a house in which there is a dog or a picture. 'Aisha reported that Gabriel (peace be upon him) made a promise with Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) to come at a definite hour; that hour came but he did not visit him. And there was in his hand (in the hand of Allah's Apostle) a staff. He threw it from his hand and said: Never has Allah or His messengers (angels) ever broken their promise. Then he cast a glance (and by chance) found a puppy under his cot and said: 'Aisha, when did this dog enter here? She said: BY Allah, I don't know He then commanded and it was turned out. Then Gabriel came and Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) said to him: You promised me and I waited for you, but you did not come, whereupon he said: It was the dog in your house which prevented me (to come), for we (angels) do not enter a house in which there is a dog or a picture.

@afiqahsaid828

9 жыл бұрын

Wait was it a picture or doll ._. I remember my mom told me about a hadith saying about an angel would not enter a house which have a dog or a doll ( like teddy bear like that ) .. May i know which one is more sahih ? Is it the doll or the picture ?

@akku5786

8 жыл бұрын

+Afiqah Sa'id it applies to both

AN OPPOSING VIEW POINT IS that drawing animate object (so humans) is NOT forbidden (haram) and only the act of create mimications of the depictions of holy figures, so drawing pictures of any prophet (as/saw) or allah (swa) is haram. I would be encouraging somebody to believe this viewpoint, even when given no Hadith as evidence, just because even during the times of the prophets (as/saw) Muslim people were creating images of each other and the animal kingdom, this has carried on for hundreds of years and is even embedded in some Asian Islamic cultures. It is up to you what you choose to believe with the evidence you research and read. Remember allah (swa) is all forgiving and accepting and will greet you with warmth and love no matter what you choose to believe as long as you believe in Him and the prophet (saw). These aren't my views i have found these from Google on some side who knows your intension better then Allah may this me true bcoz this is the only hobby i have and i even Sketch my taking name of Allah(bismillah) n i believe it iss and may Allah forgive us❤️

@zoyamotiwala

4 жыл бұрын

@Stando Powa what?

It’s so hard not having a concrete answer on this. Him saying “I” wouldn’t say it’s prohibited threw me off😩 are the Hadiths talking about statues/3D images only when they say ‘image making’ or is that also concerning flat drawings?

Allah knows we can't give life nor we have the "audacity" to compete against him... So it's getting over my head...

@iAmeer

3 жыл бұрын

Drawing is not haram unless your intention of drawing something is to: worship it, sexual pleasure, or challenging Allah.

@Wafi-ig4jk

3 жыл бұрын

Ally himself said that he wouldn't subscribe to it as being prohibited and the fact that it is an act to challenge god creation is just ridiculous

This is so wrong. Drawing some features of living creatures such as eyes, is prohibited. I'm not sure why the reason is which is why I'm searching the internet to find out. Allah will in no way feel competition by a man. Drawing is not prohibited in our deen. You shouldn't believe everything you hear. There are arguments between our sheikhs as well. Before believing what you hear, analyse the stories.

@farisqneibi2371

5 жыл бұрын

sunnah.com/bukhari/78/136

@Wafi-ig4jk

3 жыл бұрын

IMO you can still draw as long as you didn't draw any inappropriate propiate or sensitive content. The fact that the Hadith said it was an act of challenging Allah of who is the better creator is already ridiculous. Even the person in the video said that he would not subscribe to it as being prohibited.

Then this video also Haram. We can bring apple to class if we want to teach about Apple. What you do if you want to teach about Hitler?

@Count_Bleck

4 жыл бұрын

That's why we need to realise that there is nothing wrong in mindless drawing, painting or sculpting. We don't have the intention in mind that we are mimicking Allah nor are we creating something that we will later worship (like Hindus do for example). It's fine, people need to wake up and think rationally. And Allah knows best. May He forgive and guide us all.

@PCmonke

4 жыл бұрын

@@Count_Bleck I honestly share the same opinion as you.

@Count_Bleck

4 жыл бұрын

@@PCmonke 👊🏻 it seems to make total rational sense to me. If only people stopped thinking so rigidly.

@ADeeSHUPA

4 жыл бұрын

@@Count_Bleck uP

People say that drawing anything haram is prohibited like murder, idol worship etc. So can i still draw pictures which does not include these things rather contains peaceful things?

If the picture making in and of itself is applicable to social constructiveness. To conclusively say no in the end was maybe rushed on his part and the 2 minute programming. The Hadith with Aisha being allowed to play with her dolls by Muhammad(PBUH)in order to learn was a lesson being taught, and in this regard can be useful to a social cause. It is of great importance to tread carefully in the field of art concerning these matters of constructive learning and take your lesson in Gods creation.

i still dont get it, i draw portraits because its my hobby its the only thing that comes to my mind when im bored, and i know taht any portrait will never be be as perfect as gods original creation, please answer the question briefly , is it haram to draw portraits (living things) or is it not, through out watching this video i have not collected a clue to answer my question.

@TheMelopeus

7 жыл бұрын

In my opinion you don't commit a sin by drwaing anything, you don't hurt anyone. Art and creativity MUST not be prohibited by any Dogma. PLSEASE, for the sake of Art, don't let yourself fooled by idiotic dogma.

@ADeeSHUPA

4 жыл бұрын

@@TheMelopeus hM

@ishimorasakib3089

4 жыл бұрын

So after conducting plenty of research and thinking, here is my perspective of drawing that some might find enlightening. There are 3 views Islamic scholars have concluded about drawing. 1. All types of drawings ,paintings, animations, statues, and sculptures of living or animate beings are haram
 2. Only handmade images of living or animate beings are haram, not computer animations. 3. All types of drawings ,paintings, animations, statues, and sculptures of living or animate beings are allowed as long as they are not created for haram purposes such as idolatry or challenging Allah (SWT). View #1 is based on the Bukhari hadith claiming, "Every image maker will be thrown in the fire. And on the Day of Judgement he will be told to put life in them." This hadith has been interpreted to refer to only living (animate) things such as humans and animals. You might wonder what is the reasoning behind this? One answer was that if someone is to draw these they are challenging Allah (SWT) creations. In other words, believing or thinking they are a better creator than Allah (SWT). So ask yourself, has Allah (SWT) created numerous other things such as rivers, lakes, streams, mountains, clouds, plants, deserts, tundras, stars, the sun, the moon, planets, and the galaxy? Why is it not considered a challenge when someone uses art to create any one of those things mentioned? Allah (SWT) knows your intentions behind your reasoning of creating art. If it is not to do haram things like worship them or challenge Allah (SWT), isn't that acceptable? View #2 has been claimed due to a Bukhari hadith referring to the image maker as a "musawwir". Which is the Arabic word for a person who draws images. So ask yourself, is it understandable for Allah (SWT) to forbid handmade drawing but allow technological drawings? Also, computer animations may rely on handmade drawings. Some scholars have even claimed that any animation containing a living or animate beings is haram. Taking this into consideration, the creation of every single cartoon show containing humans or animals would be a haram act. The creation of every single video game containing humans or animals would be a haram act. It would not end there. Watching, playing, and purchasing video games containing animations of humans or animals would also be a haram act. Allah (SWT) tells us in the Quran (59:7), مَّآ أَفَآءَ ٱللَّهُ عَلَىٰ رَسُولِهِۦ مِنۡ أَهۡلِ ٱلۡقُرَىٰ فَلِلَّهِ وَلِلرَّسُولِ وَلِذِى ٱلۡقُرۡبَىٰ وَٱلۡيَتَـٰمَىٰ وَٱلۡمَسَـٰكِينِ وَٱبۡنِ ٱلسَّبِيلِ كَىۡ لَا يَكُونَ دُولَةَۢ بَيۡنَ ٱلۡأَغۡنِيَآءِ مِنكُمۡ‌ۚ وَمَآ ءَاتَٮٰكُمُ ٱلرَّسُولُ فَخُذُوهُ وَمَا نَہَٮٰكُمۡ عَنۡهُ فَٱنتَهُواْ‌ۚ وَٱتَّقُواْ ٱللَّهَ‌ۖ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ شَدِيدُ ٱلۡعِقَابِ Which translates to, "What God has bestowed On His Messenger (and taken Away) from the people Of the townships,-belongs To God,-to His Messenger And to kindred and orphans, The needy and the wayfarer ; In order that it may not (Merely) make a circuit Between the wealth among you. So take what the Messenger Assigns to you, and deny Yourselves that which he Withholds from you. And fear God ; for God Is strict in Punishment." As muslims, we are supposed to abstain from what is haram. For example, drinking, purchasing , and selling alcohol would be haram. Therefore, the same concept would apply to human and animal animations. Does Islam forbid watching all cartoons containing people and animals? Does Islam forbid playing EA sports FIFA because it contains animations of people? Once again, Allah (SWT) knows your intentions behind your reasoning of creating art. Nowhere in the Quran does it prohibit the creation drawing, painting, animating, etc. Reflecting back on the prophet's times there were reported to be idol worshippers. The Bukhari hadith preventing image making is very controversial. View #3, all types of drawings ,paintings, animations, statues, and sculptures of living or animate beings are allowed as long as they are not created for haram purposes such as idolatry or challenging Allah (SWT). That view is logical correct?

@ADeeSHUPA

4 жыл бұрын

@@ishimorasakib3089 uP

I loved to draw faces and anime and I still miss it almost everyday... I have tried to draw sceneries but just could not draw it as well or as easily as pictures... Nevertheless I have stopped drawing faces... But have always been confused by this Hadith... If you read the Quran... There are so many places Allah says he spoke to the earth,.. many things like mountains and trees, clouds, rain etc listen to HIm and obey HIm.. there is even one where the earth or something is given a choice of free will like man and it refuses ... if these are objects without life how is it possible ?? And also aren't we to consider that everything will be brought back to life on the day of judgement... The earth will spit out everything that has done to it etc... Many objects which we consider non living will be able to speak and bear witness... I dunno .. I have just followed the Hadith because it's what has been told but have been confused a lot... Anyone can clear this out?

@KILLINGGAMER07

4 жыл бұрын

See... Azrail Won't take Their lives. They Don't have lives.... Even tho they can do what u narrated... It’s all because of Allah's will... They even pray

@ADeeSHUPA

4 жыл бұрын

@@KILLINGGAMER07 hM

@sidx_zz

Жыл бұрын

Human beings are His best creations...we are perfectly fashioned in the best way...better than the mountains and trees n animals...so it's a different case when it comes to drawing humans...we often call ourselves or others ugly...calling Allah's creations ugly...we draw cartoons however we want n we find them more beautiful..it's not our intent but we should try to gain a lesson here...we do compare real life with drawings. We do find anime more attractive than ppl in real life. The lesson is...learn to appreciate God's beauty more, don't try to change it or "make it better".

I don’t know what to do! I love drawing animals and I am not the sharpest on my landscaping. I cannot do anything else but draw what am I supposed to do with my life now? And I’m confused about what the person said so are you allowed to draw animals or not?

@duncan3998

3 жыл бұрын

No, not even animals are allowed sadly. but you are free to draw landscapes or objects like a vase, furniture, pen, etc. as long as there is no ''soul'' in it like ''living beings''

@Wafi-ig4jk

3 жыл бұрын

IMO you can still draw as long as you didn't draw any inappropriate propiate or sensitive content. The fact that the Hadith said it was an act of challenging Allah of who is the better creator is already ridiculous. Even the person in the video said that he would not subscribe to it as being prohibited.

@duncan3998

3 жыл бұрын

@@Wafi-ig4jk Yes, your opinion which means it doesn't make it factual. also stop spamming with the replies.

@Wafi-ig4jk

3 жыл бұрын

@@duncan3998 didn't remember typing my opinions as facts and no, I'm not spamming my comment? There's only one here.

Sorry i didn't watch the full video. i am studying biology now, it will easily for me to understand the organ , nervous system , etc if i draw the structure of a living things. my question is: what if i draw a porifera(this is coral-like or sponge-like animal) what if i draw an anemone(this is plant-like animal or in bilogy its called 'polyp', some polyp can generate a small jellyfish) what if i draw a parasitic worm just by a line(a line is very simillar to a parasitic worm real life) what if i draw bacteria or virus please someone answer my question, i need this immediately

@Wafi-ig4jk

3 жыл бұрын

Imo you can still draw as long as you didn't draw any inapropiate or sensitive content. The fact that the Hadith said it was an act of challenging Allah of who is the better creator is already ridiculous. Even the person in the video said that he would not see it as prohibited.

can we draw animation

@yasminy.7243

7 жыл бұрын

Sobia Khan No living beings

@ikhadji

6 жыл бұрын

Sobia Khan

@markcarey8426

6 жыл бұрын

You must not draw animation. Animation offense to Mahmood. You will burn in hell for eternity if disobey Mahmood and Imam. Be good Muslim, obey, submit, pay homage, support Mosque and Imam, Make Imam wealthy. Halal wealth is good, Imam good, obey Imam. Do not think for self, _very_ Haram. Obey Imam. Imam good. Make Imam powerful man, wealthy man, be good good Muslim. Obey.

@AjieA

6 жыл бұрын

mark carey ugh why do people have to be like this smh. Muslims dont act like this....

@ifratjahan7050

5 жыл бұрын

mark carey I feel like u think we are in jail or something 😬

he looks like the director quentin tarantino

I have drawn many soulful drawings, I apologised ti Allah, Now should I burn my all drawings?

I dont know how to draw or anthing i just trace pictures on adobe illustrator is it Ok to trace picture??

@b.tsy.4657

3 жыл бұрын

Same. I’m just tracing and making it into cartoon

@iAmeer

3 жыл бұрын

@@b.tsy.4657 Drawing is not haram unless your intention of drawing something is to: worship it, sexual pleasure, or challenging Allah.

@Wafi-ig4jk

3 жыл бұрын

IMO you can still draw as long as you didn't draw any inappropriate propiate or sensitive content. The fact that the Hadith said it was an act of challenging Allah of who is the better creator is already ridiculous. Even the person in the video said that he would not subscribe to it as being prohibited.

I draw cartoonic characters,,, is that haram? ..

@akku5786

8 жыл бұрын

Well actually there are two types of Hadith. Hadith Qudsi which is The words of God in the words of the Prophet (May Allah's Blessings and Peace be upon Him), it's In Arabic It is not used in forms of worship. And then there is Hadith Nabawi which are The words of the Prophet (May Allah's blessings and peace be upon Him) In Arabic. AND they Give us extra details about the forms of worship we are to do that is not in the Quran. The hatih nabawi aren't mentioned in the quran because these were, in a way an extention of the prophet saw's life. What he told us in the Hadith is what we should do beacause what he told us and the Sahaba was his lifestyle, it how we should live our lives too. So if you are saying that Hadith were made by non prophets you are wrong. Hadith were made by Allah and his prophet saw and they were collected by great people such as imam Bukhari and Iman Muslims in books so that we may follow our prophets ways. Ps. Forgive me if I made any mistakes

@akku5786

8 жыл бұрын

Plus if your so wanting to draw a face or something you can leave a facial feature out like some artists do since this does not resemble what Allah swt has created

@Zerikix

8 жыл бұрын

Before SHTF Who the hell told you that raping and killing and slavery is freakin okay in islam? HUH? bec , the one who told you that. is stupid and doesn't know anything. BTW islam forbidden all these stuff. don't say something while you don't understand it. the people who kill and take slavery and call themslefs " Muslims" Aren't they just got the whole thing wrong so stop talking and if you think that islam is "bullshit" Oh man. You are gonna suffer too much during doomsday

@akku5786

8 жыл бұрын

+Before SHTF your user name is like a child made it. If you really were a scholar you could have had the decency to make a better name so people could actually believe your lie.

@bariizaya9671

7 жыл бұрын

+Before SHTF- you are funny, I like how you said "before I write book there" it is true, sometimes to express your feelings, you want to say so many things that it feels like writing a book and yet, you still feel like you haven't said anything or want to say more, because you don't get the satisfaction feelings that you express yourself and said what you wanted to say. I feel you and really understand what you trying to get at, your point, I understand.

So I can still draw my dinosaurs? They are non living lol

@1999590

5 жыл бұрын

Cute🤣🤣

@abrahamarts1331

4 жыл бұрын

Zed 9659903 😅😅🤣

@rubyduby9358

4 жыл бұрын

They are because I have one....... Don't belive me 🦖🦕 hello calling me a non living thing huh ....we will see about that! I'm calling my friend now 🐦🐉🐲🐍🦎🐸🦖🦕🐊🐢 Oh you what you saying about dinosaurs my uncle.

@KILLINGGAMER07

4 жыл бұрын

They had life when they existed 😄

@ADeeSHUPA

4 жыл бұрын

@@rubyduby9358 hH

What if you draw it but it has no nose or ears....

Im confused surrounding the topic of art in islam bc im from an Islamic country where comics, art and animation are done here. Maybe bc we follow under Iman Shafie but I dont really know

@ValleyOfMecca You sound like a great representative to the deen, yourself! A differing opinion doesn't make me "less of a Muslim", but you judging me does to yourself... It really says something when I can cite from The Quran exactly why I have a certain viewpoint, but all you can do is attempt to make a mockery of me, & tell me how I'm not a Muslim...I'll live fine with your opinion. As for this dunia - I'm not for it, or against...I'm just in it. Now, if you could please leave me alone...

It cant be prohibited . If photography and video making is not prohibited , then why drawing . Maybe Shia Islam forgot it is prohibited . Look at those drwaings in Iran

@azybes6510

7 жыл бұрын

Sabrina Shahab actually photos are for some forbidden because you try and imitate Allah's creation but not by drawing but by pressing the button but some other say no that's it's just a reflection of yourself but videos are okay since it's not a still image but dude I don't am not an imam or sheikh

@sabrinashahab795

7 жыл бұрын

So stop creating Robots , they also imitate creation . Photo taking and drawing is very similar . So argument does not sound OK

@azybes6510

7 жыл бұрын

your choice, your judgment

@fathimaazha2614

7 жыл бұрын

Whoever created robots? I have no idea what it is you are trying to say... With regards to the previous argument, it is completely valid. Photo taking for purposes that really matter is allowed just like how drawing is (like for educational purpose). Photos aren't supposed to be hung on walls just like drawing aren't supposed to be. And creating pictures of lifeless objects are allowed (By lifeless I mean trees, rocks and such) There are many divisions in Islam and as such the ruling may differ but just one region of Muslims cannot be taken as an example. There are many other Islamic countries too, like UAE, Saudi Arabia, Qatar etc.

@TheMelopeus

7 жыл бұрын

And they say that Islam encourages you to be creative and free thinking. I guess it is not like that.

Did he said it's okay to draw pictures of ppl and animals.? Am confused with his answer...

I am an artist I make a lot of portraits and my thesis was in the portrait series.I heard about it but I thought I am not disobeying Allah I am just doing what I like and It is a gift from Allah but now I researched about it and I feel very bad that I did it. I completed my graduation in art and it became my profession and I realized now that it is totally forbidden.May Allah forgive me and make it easy for me😭😭😭😭

@pellesvansl

11 ай бұрын

Is this a joke?