PlayStation 2 Emulation on PS5 Tested... And We've Got Issues

► Watch the FULL show: • DF Direct Weekly #168:...
► Support us on Patreon! bit.ly/3jEGjvx
► Digital Foundry KZread: / digitalfoundry
► Digital Foundry Merch: store.digitalfoundry.net
► Digital Foundry at Eurogamer: eurogamer.net/digitalfoundry
► Follow on Twitter: / digitalfoundry

Пікірлер: 718

  • @trevorbraun2574
    @trevorbraun25742 күн бұрын

    If they can’t get PS2 right, I have little faith PS3 is coming…

  • @gothpunkboy89

    @gothpunkboy89

    2 күн бұрын

    Dark Cloud 1 and 2 are PS2 games that seem to run fine on my PS5.

  • @Malinkadink

    @Malinkadink

    2 күн бұрын

    All they need to do is contract the emulator devs for the PC emulators and we'll have a better product, but Sony is still too Japanese to understand this.

  • @CatOnVenus183

    @CatOnVenus183

    2 күн бұрын

    @@Malinkadink I mean. they used an open source fan emulator for the PSX classic, it just didn't run on their hardware very well. Sony has not been good at emulation since the PS3.

  • @extremedee7320

    @extremedee7320

    2 күн бұрын

    ​@@Malinkadinkdude it's well more then just asking someone online to help lol

  • @carljordan5429

    @carljordan5429

    2 күн бұрын

    people think just cause they spent money they have to have everything, when in reality sony doesn't need to do this but rather are making an attempt at least. If you are desperately wanting to play ps3 or ps2 all it takes is ebay and some cash.

  • @red_noise_bomb
    @red_noise_bomb3 күн бұрын

    It's funny that on PCSX2 we get a crystal clear image while an in-house Sony emulator just produces blur and dares to sell that.

  • @deathtrooper2048

    @deathtrooper2048

    3 күн бұрын

    It's funny that Xbox has better PS2 emulation, especially when retail mode emulators were a thing.

  • @pixeljauntvr7774

    @pixeljauntvr7774

    3 күн бұрын

    ​@@deathtrooper2048Xbox isn't emulating it. PCSX is. Keep it real.

  • @jet613

    @jet613

    3 күн бұрын

    ​@@pixeljauntvr7774Those Xbox fanboys looooove getting a hard on with the fact that they can use side loaded emulators. And they tote it like an actual feature the Xbox is sold with lol. I have an Xbox myself and side loading through dev mode is most definitely not a retail feature. Besides Microsoft themselves aren't the ones behind the emulators. The praise is mis placed on Microsoft instead of the emulator creators.

  • @Zinkolo

    @Zinkolo

    3 күн бұрын

    That's because Sony forgot to disable the PS2 blur filter. PCSX2 actually has a setting for that which is why it looks so clear

  • @MASJYT

    @MASJYT

    3 күн бұрын

    Isn't PCSX2 open source? Why can't Sony just use it and base their version on it? It'd be better than this mess.

  • @zZiL341yRj736
    @zZiL341yRj7363 күн бұрын

    Not sure why Sony didn't get the PCSX2 team on board to make a PS5 version.

  • @bronzin1445

    @bronzin1445

    2 күн бұрын

    Because Sony is no better than Nintendo. As far as they’re concerned, only they know better and what’s best

  • @rizzo-films

    @rizzo-films

    2 күн бұрын

    aye, true. Then we'd probably be playing PS2 games in 4k 120fps on PS5 if they were given Sony resources. My guess is that it's cheaper to take employees already on the payroll and assign them to the project than to hire an outside crew. But this would be the dream.

  • @bernasrp

    @bernasrp

    2 күн бұрын

    @@bronzin1445 they are jackasses that's what they are

  • @jc_dogen

    @jc_dogen

    2 күн бұрын

    they hired 2 of them over 10 years ago to help with emulation on ps3 and 4, and both left eventually. i doubt it would be possible again.

  • @symphony137

    @symphony137

    2 күн бұрын

    @@bronzin1445 Nintendo's emulation efforts (developed by NERD) for Switch online were at least better than what Sony's been doing lately. If we ignore their N64 emulator, that one has issues too...

  • @MrTapWater
    @MrTapWater3 күн бұрын

    What's sad is that they already remastered the Sly games in HD on PS3. The PlayStation legacy is a mess.

  • @skycloud4802

    @skycloud4802

    3 күн бұрын

    Similar issue with Code Veronica X. The PS3 remastered version was better than the PS4 ones, which were a blurry mess.

  • @CruxisAngel954

    @CruxisAngel954

    3 күн бұрын

    The PS3 versions of sly and code Veronica had numerous issues that weren’t present in the PS2 versions.

  • @skycloud4802

    @skycloud4802

    3 күн бұрын

    @@CruxisAngel954 now that you mention it, I do remember CVX have an issue with black balance on PS3. Some areas were very dark.

  • @DeesBees85

    @DeesBees85

    3 күн бұрын

    @@CruxisAngel954 they must have been pretty minor. I platinum’d Sly 1 on PS3 and never noticed a single issue.

  • @GhabulousGhoti

    @GhabulousGhoti

    3 күн бұрын

    Sly 1 on PS3 had some issues. Controls felt a tad off to me and the music was all remixed and largely inferior IMO. The framerate also dipped a lot but that's an issue on a real PS2 as well.

  • @myscorebig
    @myscorebig2 күн бұрын

    Just let me pop in my old discs. No way in hell im paying for my own games again

  • @deathtoraiden2080

    @deathtoraiden2080

    2 күн бұрын

    ho oh, and put value back in the customer's hands? I don't think so sister, you will buy the things you used to own 10 times over.

  • @myscorebig

    @myscorebig

    2 күн бұрын

    @@deathtoraiden2080 no I won't. Watch

  • @_CrimsonBlade

    @_CrimsonBlade

    2 күн бұрын

    @@myscorebigyes you will and you’ll like it

  • @TheKayliedGamerChannel-YouTube

    @TheKayliedGamerChannel-YouTube

    Күн бұрын

    ​@@deathtoraiden2080the MarioTax is now the Crash- Tax too 😂

  • @TheJohhnyE

    @TheJohhnyE

    Күн бұрын

    You better pay for your games at least twice. Otherwise, you don't support the devs.

  • @TheSubZero187
    @TheSubZero1873 күн бұрын

    Sony is just half assing most of this backwards compatibility or “classics”. The PS1 classics showed great promise but they’ve been drip feeding games and just not releasing the bigger games. We got lucky to get some games like Legend of Dragoon and such. The PS2 emulator is still shit compared to what Microsoft was able to do for OG Xbox games on the Series X. Again it’s Sony half assing it. I’m not holding my breath for PS3 backwards compatibility to be great either. They’re going to half ass that one and just say “they play like they do on PS3”. So no higher resolution or boosted performance and all the screen tearing. I hope I’m wrong but god they like proving I’m right.

  • @Deliveredmean42

    @Deliveredmean42

    3 күн бұрын

    Seems to be regular occurence with them? Seems they are done that with the later half of the Vita's life and now we seeing similar with PSVR2, they didn't bother to make a good Adapter for PSVR2 on PC!

  • @TheSubZero187

    @TheSubZero187

    3 күн бұрын

    @@Deliveredmean42 yeah as much as it sucks to say it’s classic Sony at this point.

  • @MiguelRodriguez-lp9et

    @MiguelRodriguez-lp9et

    2 күн бұрын

    ​@TheSubZero187 They offer trophy support, save states, rewind, and controller configurations per game. Calling it half-assed isn't fair, Microsoft doesn't offer any of that.

  • @TheSubZero187

    @TheSubZero187

    2 күн бұрын

    @@MiguelRodriguez-lp9et that’s why I said PS1 is great at first but not all games have trophy support and again drip feeding. Resident Evil Directors Cut doesn’t have trophies. Half assing where it’s great if they keep going and improve upon it and give us more games. PS2 will be no different but also already off to bad start compared to OG Xbox emulation by Microsoft.

  • @MiguelRodriguez-lp9et

    @MiguelRodriguez-lp9et

    2 күн бұрын

    @@TheSubZero187 They JUST updated some games that lacked trophy support. The games are fairly priced at 10/5 dollars, in my opinion the extra features make it worth it. At least the performance on the new PS2 emulator has been perfect, I'm surprised they didn't talk about that, only pointing out the performance issues with some PSP games.

  • @wielku
    @wielku2 күн бұрын

    The fact we have DuckStation that fixes wobble and warps, PCSX2 which is still the only way to get crystal clear PS2 rendering, and PPSSPP which works on refrigerators at like x8 resolution Is kinda insane when we have PS5 power levels of console oh and yeah RPCS3 is getting so good you can pretty much play most important exclusives/console exclusivers on it at 60/120 fps x2/x4 resolution, the only thing sony can do with PS3 emulation is to make it fully BC with physical disc support

  • @laughingseal2282

    @laughingseal2282

    18 сағат бұрын

    PCSX2 has issues too on several games. Many are missing shadows, for example: Haunting grounds, soul calibur 3 etc. The ps2 is probably one of the hardest consoles to emulate properly IMO.

  • @almendraman
    @almendraman3 күн бұрын

    And we're supposed to be excited for PS3 backwards compatibility?

  • @retrogamer64007

    @retrogamer64007

    2 күн бұрын

    Yeah aren’t you looking forward to playing PS3 games in 360p resolution?

  • @TheKayliedGamerChannel-YouTube

    @TheKayliedGamerChannel-YouTube

    Күн бұрын

    ​@@retrogamer64007Extra Screen Tearing modes?

  • @Alorso_

    @Alorso_

    Күн бұрын

    You're better off getting an actual PS3, hacking it and using an upscaler like an MClassic for a better experience at this point, Sony will unfortunately never put in the kind of effort we want

  • @laughingseal2282

    @laughingseal2282

    18 сағат бұрын

    FYI ps2 has a ton of proprietary hardware that does a lot of processing and post processing making emulation really hard. PC emulator on ps2 is still very iffy as well even after like, 15 years+. On the ps3 slim/super slim for instance it ran ok and playable but it had a crapload of input delay. Some games get notoriously harder because of that.

  • @victorvargas9330

    @victorvargas9330

    9 сағат бұрын

    And we're supposed to be excited for the PS5 Pro and PS6?

  • @Sword420
    @Sword4203 күн бұрын

    This is sad. I'm steadfastly losing faith in PlayStation's ability and respect for game preservation. If the PS5 had the ability to emulate PS3 exclusives from discs, like it does with PS4 titles, I would buy one just for that feature. I'll just stick to using PCSX2 and RPCS3. EDIT: Adjusted wording to emulate. I was using the term "native" as capable, straight out of the box.

  • @LukeSolo-One

    @LukeSolo-One

    3 күн бұрын

    Hack sony😊

  • @Saiyangod41205

    @Saiyangod41205

    3 күн бұрын

    If it had that ability it wouldn't cost 500 dollars more like 1000 would you still buy that?

  • @sphericalred

    @sphericalred

    3 күн бұрын

    ​@@Saiyangod41205 Xbox emulates 360 just fine. The PS5 CPU can emulate PS3 just fine.

  • @Saiyangod41205

    @Saiyangod41205

    3 күн бұрын

    @sphericalred You didn't read the comment fully he said, "native ability to play ps3" the only way to play a ps3 game natively is by a ps3 or something with the ps3's chip set. Emulation is not native. I never said the ps5 couldn't run a ps3 game if it had a good ps3 emulator like RPCS3 it could.

  • @asa-ze1kn

    @asa-ze1kn

    3 күн бұрын

    Sony is too lazy to develop a PS3 emulator

  • @mondodimotori
    @mondodimotori3 күн бұрын

    What's even the point of an official ps2 emulator on ps5 if you can't play from original ps2 discs? And let's not talk about pressure sensitive buttons. And, most importantly, WHY TOMB RAIDER LEGEND? Not only it has a superior 360 port, IT HAS A PC PORT DRM FREE ON GOG.

  • @notafanboy355

    @notafanboy355

    2 күн бұрын

    You cant play from discs because sony are anti consumer its a port to buy again

  • @1990muthafukin1

    @1990muthafukin1

    2 күн бұрын

    Hey man, what's GOG? DRM free sounds amazing

  • @strykah92

    @strykah92

    2 күн бұрын

    By that logic, what was the point of any platform ever emulating the PSP if we can't play from the original PSP UMDs? And people use PCSX2 and RCPS3 with modern controllers without a second thought, even for games that did utilise the pressure sensitive buttons. "B-but..." Look, it's okay, you can drop the whole 'I already own a copy (ISO) of this game!' facade now. We won't judge you.

  • @mondodimotori

    @mondodimotori

    Күн бұрын

    @@strykah92 No, the logic still stand. Why would I want to emulate (poorly) a limited game library when I can alredy do it MILES BETTER on PC? Where not only the original pressure sensitive PS2 and PS3 controllers still works, but where there are even third party options (retro fighters sells a modern controller with both sixaxis and pressure sensitive buttons) that supports that feature, that was pretty important in major games like Metal Gear Solid and Gran Turismo. The only advantage to an official emulator on SONY's hardware would be to be able to directly use your own PS2 library and, maybe, fully emulate it with official hardware support. Instead we get a very limited and poorly executed experience on a minimal number of games. One of wich is NATIVELY AVAILABLE ON PC. I don't need to hide it: Ripping an ISO from the internet and play it on PCSX2 is still the best way to enjoy PS2 games today. Instead with a microsoft console you can pop in your game disc and play it. I have several 360 and OG xbox games that I play on microsoft consoles. GG WP on accomplishing the mission of looking like a nincompoop fanboy.

  • @Marmite101

    @Marmite101

    Күн бұрын

    It's about making old games seem inaccessible and outdated... They did same with dumping PS2 back compatability on PS3... You need to go proper retro or move onto new gen - Sony doesn't care.

  • @DeadPhoenix86DP
    @DeadPhoenix86DP2 күн бұрын

    Tomb Raider Legend is not correctly emulated on the PS4/PS5. Because, the shadow's are missing. Which are actually present in the original PS2 release.

  • @laughingseal2282

    @laughingseal2282

    18 сағат бұрын

    A lot of post process on ps2 was done by extra hardware parts. I tried the pc emulator and soul calibur 3 shadows also were missing. It's a difficult console to emulate.

  • @DeadPhoenix86DP

    @DeadPhoenix86DP

    18 сағат бұрын

    @@laughingseal2282 Shadow's seems to work fine with PCSX2. So clearly Sony is not doing a good job.

  • @Jun123
    @Jun1233 күн бұрын

    Sony didn't make a bad decision, they made no decision. As in, they dropped it into the PS5, and said jobs done. Damn.

  • @Whit3WolfXArcadia
    @Whit3WolfXArcadia3 күн бұрын

    They should have outsource this project to the pcsx2 and ppsspp teams Sony can't get software emulation right compared to the hardware one

  • @otherprisma7354

    @otherprisma7354

    3 күн бұрын

    They did.

  • @Snaaake_Beater

    @Snaaake_Beater

    3 күн бұрын

    ​@@otherprisma7354proof?

  • @ReveriePass

    @ReveriePass

    2 күн бұрын

    They definitely should not. The main devs of PCSX2 don't really work well with others!

  • @symphony137

    @symphony137

    2 күн бұрын

    @@ReveriePass How so? If they get paid, I'm sure they wouldn't say no.

  • @DP12321

    @DP12321

    2 күн бұрын

    Sony bought Connectix and Bluepoint, they have talent and tech under their belt. They just don't care. RIP bleem!

  • @byronramos5746
    @byronramos57463 күн бұрын

    Just something to add, the emulator is also being used on PS4 👀 it even has the PS5-like menu!

  • @destroyermcw626

    @destroyermcw626

    20 сағат бұрын

    Thanks!

  • @PalmDesertRock
    @PalmDesertRock2 күн бұрын

    6:54 rare footage of Rich losing his composure. The state of PS2 emulation must be dire indeed.

  • @TheDarkguide
    @TheDarkguide3 күн бұрын

    It's ironic how inside developers don't understand how their old school consoles worked and should look but instead emulators do better job of conveying original hardware.

  • @Cleoli2

    @Cleoli2

    3 күн бұрын

    It's probably because the people making these emulators in their free time care about making them as good as possible, while Sony just wants something good enough to sell to people

  • @mikeuk666

    @mikeuk666

    3 күн бұрын

    Old technology. Devs moved on

  • @KingAgniKai

    @KingAgniKai

    3 күн бұрын

    Cell is a nightmare to deal with and Sony abandoned it long ago

  • @arielramos1722

    @arielramos1722

    3 күн бұрын

    @@KingAgniKai cell it's PS3's chip. Emotion it's the one you're thinking.

  • @rizzo-films

    @rizzo-films

    2 күн бұрын

    ​@@Cleoli2 that's the answer. Someone doing it for a hobby is working with passion and love for the games, while Sony is thinking in terms of ROI and that emulation isn't going to sell as much as first-party games or their latest hardware. That's not to say that the Sony employees don't also have passion and love for the very same games, but when you're billing hours, given a directive and a specific timeline, you do as much as you're paid to do. Which apparently is just, "Make these old games work on PS5."

  • @jumhig
    @jumhig2 күн бұрын

    PS2 via component cable was the bomb. Also running PS2 games on PS3 phat .

  • @b3lial
    @b3lial2 күн бұрын

    The KZreadr Mystic did a good dive. This new emulator needs to run on the PS4 as well. The PS4 starts that games with the enhancements turned off. I think there’s an issues running on the PS4 and they’re trying to make it compatible with both generations.

  • @RazzeeTV
    @RazzeeTV3 күн бұрын

    Wait, the PS5 version of Sly is seriously limited to 4:3 aspect ratio? The PS3 remaster supported, and you can patch the ISO with widescreen hacks to run on a real PS2. Real shame.

  • @kriskater

    @kriskater

    2 күн бұрын

    Yeah… i bought it immediately when it came out because i thought it was the ps3 remaster that i played on ps now. But no… the blurry old ps2 version .. which is fine but damn they could have given it a little love :/

  • @symphony137

    @symphony137

    2 күн бұрын

    @@kriskater No offense but this sounds a bit like lack of research. Why would you think it's the PS3 remaster? There are no PS3 remasters on PS5, it's simply not a thing. Every PS2 game that was released on PS4 and PS5 since 2015 is just straight up emulation of the PS2 games. PS Now had actual PS3 games because they were cloud steamed from real PS3 hardware, you weren't playing it natively.

  • @kriskater

    @kriskater

    2 күн бұрын

    @@symphony137 i was just excited okay! Lol but yeah you’re right. I just expected it to be nicer and smoother looking. It doesnt even have widescreen ffs. I ALWAYS research games before i buy, heavily. But Sly Cooper (ps5 app) was a no brainer. But ive learned once again that research must ALWAYS be done. No exceptions 👍🏽

  • @nickblomgren
    @nickblomgren2 күн бұрын

    Them talking about how weird it is that Sony decided to put the PS2 version of Tomb Raider Legends/PSP version of Tekken 6 is a good reminder that Sony thought it made sense to put not only the PS2 version of Psychonauts on PS4 but also the PS2 version of MAX PAYNE. The port of Max Payne that doesn't have rendered bullets in bullet-time. If those selections aren't an example of people being asleep at the wheel somewhere at Sony, I don't know what is.

  • @GameBeatenakaKevinS

    @GameBeatenakaKevinS

    Күн бұрын

    And then they took time to feature every version of MediEvil and Ape Escape on the store.

  • @samusaran11
    @samusaran113 күн бұрын

    Sony continues to half ass their emulation. They could have easily up rezed the game to 1440p-4K and they would have looked incredible.

  • @YouTubeCensors

    @YouTubeCensors

    2 күн бұрын

    Yup, I can see that on SSX3 , Ninja Gaiden 1-2 on XSX and others like Jade Empire, etc and that's not counting Emulation on Xbox with it's amazing PS2, PS1, etc emulation.

  • @jc_dogen

    @jc_dogen

    2 күн бұрын

    nope, just setting an arbitrary resolution for ps2 games causes a ton of problems. the pcsx2 team has had to work on this for years (decades really), because of how many edge cases there are. it's one of the most difficult consoles to emulate for a reason.

  • @MarbleThumbs

    @MarbleThumbs

    2 күн бұрын

    ​@jc_dogen It's Sony's job to solve those problems, I don't really care how difficult it is, they're getting payed alot to do a poor job.

  • @jc_dogen

    @jc_dogen

    2 күн бұрын

    @@MarbleThumbs i'm not saying sony did a good job here. i'm just saying just setting the resolution higher the simple way is a bad idea. sony did it the right way, on ps4. their high res technique avoids all of those problems (but only renders in multiples). not sure what's going on with some of the games on ps5 now.

  • @Marmite101

    @Marmite101

    Күн бұрын

    Sony's business model is half assed... That's why Nintendo Switch still wiping the floor with the competition 😂😂😂

  • @pishbot
    @pishbot3 күн бұрын

    super important topic. great analysis rich/john

  • @mimimimeow
    @mimimimeow3 күн бұрын

    Honestly Sony should've just set the PS2 emulator to run on CPU mode, and spend the rest of budget on nearest neighbor scaling and good CRT filter. That would've saved all the headache with per game custom configs and game compatibilities. Games would run at 448p/576p only but at least they WORK and scaled properly.

  • @n64fan60
    @n64fan603 күн бұрын

    We just need options. I would personally put them at raw native res if I could, for example. Particularly with PS1, where I have to use one of the shabby CRT filters to get it looking anywhere close to original.

  • @EnjoyArtwork
    @EnjoyArtwork3 күн бұрын

    JOHN! What game do you have there plugged into your SNES? 😁

  • @REALPEDROGAMEPLAYS
    @REALPEDROGAMEPLAYS2 күн бұрын

    ⁠​⁠Sony used to have good emulation up until the PS3 life cycle. PS2 had full PS1 chipsets until the slim models after 7000x replaced it with emulation. Said emulation was rocky, but got more compatibility by the time the last PS2 model released and the PS3 was rearing its 600 dollar head. The PS3 was more capable of emulation so it used PS1 emulation, but put the full PS2 chip on board. They later removed it to cut costs, naturally. This was pretty justified, but the models of ps3 that emulated ps1 and ps2 had the SOFTWARE removed entirely! This meant that past a firmware update, you couldn’t play the games you owned because Sony removed the software emulator from your console! Sony made this change around the same time they introduced slim model PS3s and around the same time they started working on PS2 classics in the store. This meant you couldn’t play your PS2 games but instead had to rebuy *a couple* of them on the digital store to play them with arguably worse emulation. The PS4 has support for CDs, DVDs, and Blu-Ray, but Sony took away the software to read CDs in order to introduce streaming with Spotify on their consoles. The PS4 was also planned to release with or have software emulation for ps1 and ps2 native to the console, but of course they took it away when selling classics on the store became profitable. Whenever you see Sony selling any of this stuff, remember that it’s all based on BS that is being drip fed to us because they’re too scared to do anything that could appease actual PlayStation fans over investors because it has a slight risk of losing profit.

  • @MichaelM28

    @MichaelM28

    2 күн бұрын

    Sony never removed emulation in a software update. What are you talking about?

  • @REALPEDROGAMEPLAYS

    @REALPEDROGAMEPLAYS

    2 күн бұрын

    @@MichaelM28 I’m talking about rumors, as I’ve now read, but this doesn’t mean Sony is just a-ok nor does it mean anything else I said is wrong. Soon after Sony removed any traces of backwards compatibility from PS3 models starting with the 400 dollar 40gb model onwards, they introduced PSN games that are PlayStation 2. So that people would get their games instead of buying used from GameStop for example, they didn’t allow for any discs to play ps2 games. This means that the emulation for ps2 games was now on Sony’s end and not on the players end. Custom firmware gives you the software to run ps2 games like the emulator already does, but it shouldn’t have to be an option. Truth is, the ps2 compatibility would actually be very beneficial to the console if Sony had just stuck through with making it a console feature that supported discs, too. Instead, they locked away every piece of it.

  • @symphony137

    @symphony137

    2 күн бұрын

    They never removed the software emulator on PS3. The only thing they did is they locked the PS2 emulator in later models, so it wasn't accessible officially. With a hacked consoles you can still use it. And PS1 emulation was never removed, you can play PS1 discs on every single PS3 model...

  • @REALPEDROGAMEPLAYS

    @REALPEDROGAMEPLAYS

    2 күн бұрын

    @@symphony137 never ever once said they removed ps1

  • @strykah92

    @strykah92

    2 күн бұрын

    @@REALPEDROGAMEPLAYS”the models of ps3 that emulated ps1 and ps2 had the SOFTWARE removed entirely!” Even if you meant something else by that statement, it does insinuate that PS1 emulation was removed, which is false. Also the software PS2 emulation never allowed non-PS2 hardware PS3 models to play PS2 discs at any point. PS2 classics on the PSN were first released late 2010ish but the situation in which PS3 models could or could not play PS2 discs never changed. Respectfully, you might have some Mandela effect going on. On a side note, I do have a jailbroken PS3, and while yes you can rip PS2 discs to the system and use the software emulation to play them, the vast majority of games have varying degrees of visual and performance issues. It’s debatable whether PS2 games via software emulation ever should’ve been made commercially available.

  • @ArabianFreedom
    @ArabianFreedom3 күн бұрын

    They look blury and awful. Embarrassing in so many level.

  • @newjackgaming88

    @newjackgaming88

    2 күн бұрын

    yup when u can run ps2 games in 4k and 1080p on xbox series x and s

  • @d0jima
    @d0jima2 күн бұрын

    haha, I love watching Rich's face as John relays the details.

  • @thedarkside3899
    @thedarkside38993 күн бұрын

    what is your take on the rumored ps3 emulation then? i mean if they can't really do a good ps2 emulation.

  • @Snaaake_Beater

    @Snaaake_Beater

    3 күн бұрын

    someone saw the mystic video huh

  • @notafanboy355

    @notafanboy355

    2 күн бұрын

    Thats in tbe toilet now lol

  • @MichaelM28

    @MichaelM28

    2 күн бұрын

    @@notafanboy355ironic name you have xbot lol

  • @symphony137

    @symphony137

    2 күн бұрын

    I would actually say PS3 games should be easier to present properly on a PS5. The only hurdle is that you need much more raw power to emulate it in the first place. But the games already used HD resolutions of 720p and 1080p and that scales much better, so there's less to fuck up. That of course doesn't mean there there can't be other issues, like sound glitches etc.

  • @notafanboy355

    @notafanboy355

    2 күн бұрын

    @@MichaelM28 cry pony cry

  • @Emikeb
    @Emikeb2 күн бұрын

    And Tomb Raider is the most expensive of the Classics too.

  • @jasonlawrence360
    @jasonlawrence3602 күн бұрын

    Can you put your old PS2 disks in the ps5 or are these PS2 games download only?

  • @symphony137

    @symphony137

    2 күн бұрын

    They're included in PS Plus and you can purchase them from the store. So yes, it's a download like any other digital game.

  • @CatOnVenus183
    @CatOnVenus1832 күн бұрын

    It's weird, I don't think the PS4 version of parappa 2 suffered from these issues. I did notice a few visual glitches in one part but besides that it seemed fine

  • @TheWaffleFactory
    @TheWaffleFactory2 күн бұрын

    wish they took a page from xbox and let us put a disc in as proof of purchase ( i know its not actually reading from the disc on xbox but still its a nice feature for collectors)

  • @AndroidsDreamTV
    @AndroidsDreamTVКүн бұрын

    It's funny that every free ps2 emulator on PC and android is more detailed that an official emulator that cost money.

  • @PS2GAMER100

    @PS2GAMER100

    Күн бұрын

    Yeah I play ps2 games on my phone and can play the whole ps2 library and can go up to 4k and 60fps over sony small selection of games at sd resolution and 30fps lol

  • @deabreu.tattoo
    @deabreu.tattooКүн бұрын

    How can Sony's engineers, with access to documentation and microcode and all STILL do a worse job than a handful of nerds with nothing but talent and determination on their side? Lol

  • @5persondude
    @5persondude2 сағат бұрын

    I imagine that Sony is just assigning these port duties to random employees on their payroll, and either these employees don’t care about the end result, or maybe they do care but aren’t given proper time and support from Sony to make good-quality emulation. And I’m sure Sony doesn’t want to invest much money into anything that isn’t the *over-the-shoulder 3rd person cinematic walking simulator*

  • @djtomoy
    @djtomoy3 күн бұрын

    Nothing make poor John sad like bad quality commercial emulation of classic consoles 😢

  • @Marmite101

    @Marmite101

    2 күн бұрын

    Plus he's such a Pony is funny

  • @MichaelM28

    @MichaelM28

    2 күн бұрын

    @@Marmite101And you're an xbot with no games 😂😂😂

  • @Marmite101

    @Marmite101

    Күн бұрын

    ​@@MichaelM28really? lol Seems you pony_boys still wanting PS2 games to play on your PS5 😂😂😂🤦‍♂️

  • @Marmite101

    @Marmite101

    Күн бұрын

    Should have bought a Switch

  • @Marmite101

    @Marmite101

    Күн бұрын

    ​@@MichaelM28enjoy paying MS for your Call of Duty 😂😂😂 SaltPony

  • @TheHOOfan1
    @TheHOOfan12 күн бұрын

    Sony put an entire team of 2 unpaid interns on this project, what more do you want?

  • @lirfrank
    @lirfrank3 күн бұрын

    Sony did a good PS1 emulator for the PS3 and PSP but then proceeded to never do it again. PS2, PS3, never well emulated. Even the PS Classic came out pretty bad.

  • @ibrohiem

    @ibrohiem

    3 күн бұрын

    PS3 actually had a hardware PS2 compatibly at first then software PS2 emulation that they never advertised. It only came to light when people started to hack it for pirated games and emulators.

  • @lirfrank

    @lirfrank

    3 күн бұрын

    @@ibrohiem Launch units actually had this enabled, the problem is that it came out with a lot of bugs on the software side. So they disabled it on later units and I think later models like the Slim and Super Slim just don't have the hardware. But of course the software emulation stayed throughtout, and you can even buy those games today.

  • @SamuelSarette

    @SamuelSarette

    3 күн бұрын

    There's rumors that the PS1 emulator on PSP/PS3 was based off the Bleem code they bought. So not completely done in-house...

  • @CeceliPS3

    @CeceliPS3

    3 күн бұрын

    They did? Because if so, they didn't use that emulator on the PlayStation Classic Mini since that has terrible input lag.

  • @lirfrank

    @lirfrank

    3 күн бұрын

    @@CeceliPS3 I'm guessing you stopped reading my comment halfway through.

  • @mexdrago3009
    @mexdrago30092 күн бұрын

    OG Consoles forever.

  • @MiguelRodriguez-lp9et
    @MiguelRodriguez-lp9et2 күн бұрын

    Maybe its the added trophy support and the rewind features that make it more demanding. On ps4 these features are disabled by default, and turning it on drops performance.

  • @powerfrenzy
    @powerfrenzy2 күн бұрын

    Good thing I took the time to replace the power board on my old 39000 fat PS2. Running fine and with RT5x it's looking pretty nice.

  • @cemsengul16
    @cemsengul163 күн бұрын

    Yeah I gave up waiting on Sony to make a good emulator. I got into PCSX2 Nightly when I built my new 14900k and 4090 desktop and oh my God it is like I am able to remaster every game. Playing at 8x scale 60 fps with a widescreen cheat is stupid good.

  • @AZBCDE

    @AZBCDE

    3 күн бұрын

    It’s also stupidly expensive and inconvenient 💀

  • @TheDarkguide

    @TheDarkguide

    3 күн бұрын

    I don't like how oldschool games on 8x and more fps. It kinda ruins ascetic of the original and makes it look old or cheap. But each on their own. Everyone likes different things.

  • @JCSA79V

    @JCSA79V

    3 күн бұрын

    ​@@TheDarkguide You're right. Even ignoring the potential graphical issues that come up with upscaling certain games.

  • @chris_player2995

    @chris_player2995

    3 күн бұрын

    ​@@TheDarkguideyeah I sometimes play on 4:3 just for the old vibe (The Punisher and Manhunt for example)

  • @2psah2

    @2psah2

    3 күн бұрын

    ​@@TheDarkguide To be fair, you can just not scale the game of choice to 4k/2k/1080p. You can keep it the way you want and still enhance some aspects. 😊

  • @Axtmoerder
    @Axtmoerder23 сағат бұрын

    I platinumed Ghosthunter and clone wars over the weekend and both look incredible on ps5. There is no aliasing or flickering, it’s such a nice clean image Yes the resolution could be higher, but it’s still looks like 900-1080p to me

  • @kpsk8031
    @kpsk80313 күн бұрын

    Being able to play "Contra - Shattered Soldier" in good quality on PS5 would be more exciting to me than any new game from Insomniac.

  • @MichaelM28

    @MichaelM28

    2 күн бұрын

    You're definitely in the minority

  • @Bayr0n
    @Bayr0n2 күн бұрын

    Why doesn’t Sony contact DF before releasing stuff like this?

  • @sms-ux5kl
    @sms-ux5kl2 күн бұрын

    the modern video game industry loves TAA so much they put it into ps2 games

  • @SeanUCF
    @SeanUCF3 күн бұрын

    Is there anything that Sony produces that ISN'T sloppy?

  • @AlucardsQuest
    @AlucardsQuest2 күн бұрын

    I'm surprised that you guys didn't mention how dark Tomb Raider Legends is. Even when you turn the in game brightness all the way up, it's still hard to see. It's been a long time, but I don't remember the PS2 version looking that dark (although i'm far more used to the GameCube version). Why didn't they just use the PS3 version? People would have complained that it wasn't the full trilogy, but at least it would have run better.

  • @Ocelot35
    @Ocelot352 күн бұрын

    When Sony made the PS3 backwards compatible with PS2 and PS1 games, everyone said.... nah. Love me some 360 red rings. And when Microsoft made 360 games run beautifully on the Series X, people said... nah... I want to buy TLOU remastered-twice on the PS5.

  • @destroyermcw626

    @destroyermcw626

    20 сағат бұрын

    Me:Xbox 360 got great Backwards Compatibility at 1080p!! Also me:Oooo free upgrades on my 360 and OG Xbox games for Xbox One X and Series X!

  • @symphony137
    @symphony1372 күн бұрын

    One of the many reasons why I stick to original hardware. PS2 (or any older console) with the RT4K looks absolutely beautiful, especially when you set up nice looking CRT effects.

  • @johnboona4048
    @johnboona40482 күн бұрын

    Me playing ps2 with 4k resolution on pc 😂😂😂

  • @Nemesis_T_Type
    @Nemesis_T_TypeКүн бұрын

    It's crazy how the PS2 is more than 20 years old now. Feels like yesterday when I bought a PS2.

  • @destroyermcw626

    @destroyermcw626

    20 сағат бұрын

    I still have mine (Fat and the better one).

  • @tehf00n
    @tehf00n2 күн бұрын

    I had a Japanese PS3 import with the PS2 emulator chip on it. I was devastated when I switched to a non-import version and it was gone. However I'm no fool. I do my emulation on a PC and get all the goods, not the least amount of effort.

  • @TyroClint
    @TyroClint2 күн бұрын

    I hate the analogs limited directional input that I’ve noticed in sly cooper. Jak and daxters is worst (8 way directional input) rather than the original smooth 360 direction

  • @1chiTheKiller
    @1chiTheKiller2 күн бұрын

    It's a huge bummer that the retro community is now coming out with amazing recompilations of older titles and yet none of these companies seem to want to do this for their older game re-releases. It would allow them to give each game major upgrades without messing with the game code and ruining the experience. I know it may be some work for each title, but you'll have a version of each game that'll be in far better shape for future consoles moving forward. Also, I love Rich's Bespoke shirt.

  • @matheuskiskissian
    @matheuskiskissian3 күн бұрын

    Guess I'll just stick with my PS2 with component cables

  • @MichaelM28

    @MichaelM28

    2 күн бұрын

    Get the pixelfx retrogem. It's awesome

  • @WhirlPoolMedia

    @WhirlPoolMedia

    Күн бұрын

    That has always been the move 💯 people that are waiting to play ps2 games on ps5 is wasting their time. Wish Sony would just focus on modern stuff and stop go backwards..

  • @ismo9529

    @ismo9529

    Күн бұрын

    ​@@WhirlPoolMedia just get an Xbox, play all that's recent, enjoy gamepass and emulate all of the ps2 games for a one time purchase of 15 euros. I have a 2tb harddisk filled with ps1, ps2, n64, gamecube, wii,.. games. Some people are really allergic to owning an xbox

  • @buschg7106
    @buschg71062 күн бұрын

    I've been rebuilding my classic console collection and got PS3 and PS2 fats this summer. U don't need a tink or mods. The $30 hyperkin looks GREAT on my 65-inch 4k FALD tv.

  • @Therizinosaurus
    @TherizinosaurusКүн бұрын

    What??? I didnt know they do emulation again

  • @luigocelo
    @luigocelo2 күн бұрын

    Actually this is the same interface used for ps1 games, and the filters work great with ps1, tried Grandia, Legend of Dragoon, Arc of the Lad and Wild Arms 2.

  • @Mezziah777
    @Mezziah77721 сағат бұрын

    Even if they could up the resolution 2 to 4 times of the original game, it's still going to look weird and out of place, and all UI and text is still going to be hella ugly if not unreadable. Only thing I feel really fixes both things at once is a really good CRT filter, and there are some really good ones out there, but they're not as common as they should.

  • @PrinsessePeach
    @PrinsessePeach6 минут бұрын

    How does the Tomb Raider Legend PS2 version on PS5 run compared to the Xbox 360 version on Xbox Series X?

  • @Youraveragegamer_97
    @Youraveragegamer_973 күн бұрын

    Backwards compatibility is one of the few things xbox does better the playstation Edit everyone ignore Michael28, he's a waste of life console fanboy

  • @iconofsin4578

    @iconofsin4578

    3 күн бұрын

    *One of the many things Xbox does better

  • @Youraveragegamer_97

    @Youraveragegamer_97

    3 күн бұрын

    @@iconofsin4578 no, not really

  • @mattmccaughen7371

    @mattmccaughen7371

    3 күн бұрын

    Xbox Kills sony in features and even games now sorry

  • @Youraveragegamer_97

    @Youraveragegamer_97

    3 күн бұрын

    @@mattmccaughen7371 the last 10 years say otherwise, there's alot more to gaming then old games and gamepass, yea I can't wait to play helldivers 2, rise of the ronin, and black myth wuking, oh wait I can't play it...

  • @femto8402

    @femto8402

    3 күн бұрын

    Well yeah and not only for og xbox/360 games, even xbox one/one x games are amazing on series consoles. The backward compatibility is really amazing on xbox compared to ps5

  • @TheKayliedGamerChannel-YouTube
    @TheKayliedGamerChannel-YouTube2 күн бұрын

    They don't want you playing these older games - even on their own new hardware - they are always pushing the current systems playing newer games narrative.

  • @notafanboy355

    @notafanboy355

    2 күн бұрын

    Then all they do is resell games

  • @headninjadog8120
    @headninjadog81203 күн бұрын

    Just an FYI - I have GTA4 on PC and Xbox Series S backward compat and you can clearly see that the Xbox emulator does not upscale GTA4 too great.

  • @TheIrishGamerGuy
    @TheIrishGamerGuy3 күн бұрын

    Saw this coming ever since Shawn Laden left Playstation. Tim Ryan running it into the ground. Swapped to PC in 2019 and never touched a sony console again. Have an Xbox Series X as my retro console for PS2 and PS3 era games tbh cos all the Splinter Cells, MGS games and classic Tomb Raider etc. all run perfect on it and look great. I expect Xbox to be ran into the ground now with Sarah Bond now though since Phil Spencer's replacement seems closer to a Tim Ryan than a Shawn Laden.

  • @newjackgaming88

    @newjackgaming88

    2 күн бұрын

    xbox series x can run any ps1 ps2 psp gamecube wii and more in 4k in dev mode

  • @Pasixable
    @Pasixable2 күн бұрын

    It's called the "PS-Button". I mean it's a button in the shape of the PS logo, come on John you gamer XD

  • @destroyermcw626

    @destroyermcw626

    20 сағат бұрын

    Yeah I said this above to and it kinda stung when at 1:34 he said that.

  • @greenhoundgaming
    @greenhoundgamingКүн бұрын

    I still can't just drop a PS2 disc in and play

  • @destroyermcw626

    @destroyermcw626

    20 сағат бұрын

    Good luck with that with Sony.

  • @8bitnation419
    @8bitnation4192 күн бұрын

    I wish we just got the Cell again and then just get it to work with the GPU on the APU.

  • @SunspotGallery
    @SunspotGallery3 күн бұрын

    I'll be sticking to RRV on PCSX2, thanks

  • @chris_player2995

    @chris_player2995

    3 күн бұрын

    RRV? pcsx2 1.7 has been a blessing , the only game I have trouble emulating is Stuntman (the first one) because the AI is broken (even on 1 6)

  • @SunspotGallery

    @SunspotGallery

    3 күн бұрын

    @@chris_player2995 Ridge Racer V!

  • @mixmastermacaroni
    @mixmastermacaroni2 күн бұрын

    Is it the PSP version???

  • @przemeksz8203
    @przemeksz82032 күн бұрын

    there is no reason those ps2 games should not run on a high resolution and 60fps on ps5

  • @0mar3li1
    @0mar3li12 күн бұрын

    The concern I have is Richard death stare

  • @jiwii1
    @jiwii1Күн бұрын

    It's a real shame that the Retrotink 4k is more than a thousand cad right now.

  • @Henkibojj
    @Henkibojj2 күн бұрын

    5:05 I've never been a Nintendo guy but I got a Wii for free and the biggest problem I have looks-wise is that it sits in purgatory between 4:3 and 16:9. The console can't produce widescreen so it squeezes top and bottom and let's whatever TV you have force a zoomed perspective instead. That's what I believe happens anyway, because no buttons or circular items look circular at all on a widescreen TV. It's all olive-shaped, including the letters in written text. That's a common problem even today with subtitles created for 4:3 and then applied to a widescreen release which makes the letters go w i d e. You may not think of it, but if you force such a DVD into 4:3, the letters look nice and normal. It's a shame that this purgatory persists with PS2/other emulation in modern days.

  • @danielposey0620
    @danielposey06202 күн бұрын

    I don’t get why Sony can’t do like Microsoft does with original Xbox games on series X/S. Those are super clean & clear & sharp but when Sony does it for ps2 games it’s all super blurry looking. What is the deal with Sony & emulating their old games??

  • @notafanboy355

    @notafanboy355

    2 күн бұрын

    They half ass it just to charge for it none of this is compatability

  • @destroyermcw626

    @destroyermcw626

    20 сағат бұрын

    The old Blur station times.

  • @jamesdavid2893
    @jamesdavid2893Күн бұрын

    When in doubt get your ship out. Be a Pirate.

  • @Saiyangod41205
    @Saiyangod412053 күн бұрын

    Many are saying Sony should just hire or buy PCSX2 not realizing that they would have to start paying for those roms now. It's also just kinda bad to compare a emulator thats been active for many years vs a newer one, but yeah it's bad that it's not performing well since they have the original ps2 code.

  • @weebsquit347
    @weebsquit3472 күн бұрын

    If this is how PS2 games run in PS5, then im worried for PS3 games in PS5. I'm considering just getting a PS3 outright for that.

  • @BillBinder
    @BillBinder2 күн бұрын

    At least put on the option to play in the proper aspect ratios.

  • @unbearifiedbear1885
    @unbearifiedbear18852 күн бұрын

    Crazy this hasn't all been figured out for years - preserving the Legacy catalogue should be *priority one* for Sony, when designing a new machine

  • @notafanboy355

    @notafanboy355

    2 күн бұрын

    They never cared after ps3

  • @unbearifiedbear1885

    @unbearifiedbear1885

    2 күн бұрын

    ​@@notafanboy355 checks out, unfortunately

  • @aaronc9294
    @aaronc92943 күн бұрын

    Sad that sony keeps fumbling their legacy content while xbox has had great Back compat for years.

  • @rus218musiculove
    @rus218musiculoveКүн бұрын

    NTSC and PAL are not regions.

  • @coladict
    @coladict2 күн бұрын

    I thought the PS4 versions were just ports, not in an emulator. Only just finished the first Jak and Daxter game yesterday. I don't see why Sony would keep failing at the emulation here, but they do.

  • @toryliss3925
    @toryliss39252 күн бұрын

    I don't think they actually cared about the presentation before releasing these games.

  • @ModestMouseTrap
    @ModestMouseTrap2 күн бұрын

    Have you considered that someone might prefer the softer image rather than razor sharp chunky pixels? Also… I literally don’t see anything wrong with the emulation itself. Sly Cooper feels totally correct.

  • @D88niel
    @D88niel14 сағат бұрын

    Don't you dare disrespect the pal versions!

  • @jayclarke777
    @jayclarke7772 күн бұрын

    Wow I was just playing Transformers on PCSX2. It ran without a hitch. You got your work cut out for you Sony.

  • @sswishbone
    @sswishbone2 күн бұрын

    Meanwhile X Box One X could display Elder Scrolls Morrowind at 16x resolution, and SSX2 at 4K... Sony need to essentially bring the dev team for PCSX2 on board so they can sort this for them. PC is definitely best place to play PS2 games

  • @chrisvarnado900
    @chrisvarnado9003 күн бұрын

    This was one of the one things that made me consider finally getting a PS5. Just Ordered an Odin 2 instead.

  • @destroyermcw626
    @destroyermcw62621 сағат бұрын

    1:36 PS button (Been called that since PS3).

  • @KhalCrochet
    @KhalCrochet2 күн бұрын

    Alright now we just need manhunt

  • @Flip86x
    @Flip86x2 күн бұрын

    I bought Legend on Steam for my Deck for dirt cheap after the 1-2-3 remaster came out. I own every TR game now cause Steam had all the old school TR games on sale the week the remaster launched.

  • @warrenbadze
    @warrenbadze3 күн бұрын

    me having just finished simpsons hit and run on my steamdeck

  • @sabakunovedo
    @sabakunovedo2 күн бұрын

    Sly Cooper looks awesome and that's all that matters 💙

  • @Melsharpe95
    @Melsharpe953 күн бұрын

    Sony obviously doesn't give a shit about its own legacy so why should we? It's truly maddening because so many of us grew up with these bangers and would love to play them all again conveniently on modern hardware. Time to start up PCSX2 again.

  • @V3ntilator
    @V3ntilator2 күн бұрын

    People thought N64 emulation were great until they started to get the games run natively on PC instead in 2024 with unlocked frame rate. Emulation in general isn't as good as people think, and not even N64 emulation after 26 years.

  • @ahicracing884
    @ahicracing884Күн бұрын

    If you use Open Source GPL licensed code depending you have to release your code based on it. If Sony did this then all would have access to PS5 code which could be a risk for Sony So Sony, if respecting the PCSX2 license cannot use PCSX2 code as a basis for their emulator and with the need for signed programs on console the two cannot co-exist.

  • @dustarma
    @dustarma2 күн бұрын

    Sucks about the Tomb Raider LAU trilogy that there's no "definitive" way to play them on modern systems, the PC versions are inferior visually to the 360/PS3 versions and those are stuck on their respective consoles.

  • @o27001
    @o27001Күн бұрын

    How is it that a bunch of people in a cave with a box of scraps can produce a much better emulator than a multi billion dollar corporation?