Imagine working for months on an animation that you've poured your heart and soul into just to lose to a guy that typed "planets and guitars" into an AI prompt.

@andrewlloydpeterson

3 күн бұрын

Ok, type planets and guitars into an AI prompt and surely you will get this video. What? No. Thats not how that works. You dont know how any of this works yet make confident assumptions that it was that easy

@fatmariothethird468

3 күн бұрын

@@andrewlloydpeterson Even if it is hard to make, it still doesn't look good. It's just a mess of stock photos combined together.

@andrewlloydpeterson

2 күн бұрын

@@fatmariothethird468 i agree that current AI is capable of more interesting results and other non AI submissions for this song were more interesting

@joeflip2993

2 сағат бұрын

That's not how he did it

Damn April fools came 361 days early

@frostbitetheannunakiiceind6574

Ай бұрын

fr

Even if you don't care about AI. Giving this the win over the absolutely amazing work that was done by other submissions is an insult to every single competitor.

@bluehabs

Ай бұрын

Ignoring how it's made; in animation perspective this is ugly. each frame doesn't have consistent continuity. watching this give me nausea

@frocco7125

Ай бұрын

That was for a DIFFRENT contest.

@lauraceae8037

23 күн бұрын

Exactly. Even if the other video WASNT made by ai and was actually handmade, this would have still deserved to win. It’s so much more interesting and visually exciting. It’s not even “computers are outcompeting humans” here. The non-ai submissions were STILL better. I’m actually baffled.

@EdgarMorrisandTheDead

21 күн бұрын

Sounds like a skill issue

@jorami4838

18 күн бұрын

@@EdgarMorrisandTheDead There is literally no skill in generating ai images

actually disturbing how this won

@frostbitetheannunakiiceind6574

Ай бұрын

genuinely disturbing

@MsScarletwings

28 күн бұрын

It’s literally like having a raw plate of dandelions someone picked out of their yard win at a banana bread bake off. I wish I felt like I was exaggerating.

@blehh_mae

28 күн бұрын

@@MsScarletwings nah this is like somebody cutting out multiple banana bread ads, taping it together poorly and not even all oriented right, and putting it on a plate for that contest

This garbage makes me appreciate the actual animations in this contest even more.

@MM2isBest

Ай бұрын

Not me, I like it

@ozzemie

Ай бұрын

@@MM2isBest Must be the first time you're seeing this particular style of AI then.

@cunning_linguist.

Ай бұрын

​@@ozzemieNah, from what I can tell, people just think it's pretty colors and that's what makes generated images good.

@Cherry_Zabix

Ай бұрын

​@@MM2isBest I also like it! I think it's pretty cool. The issue is that this was a CONTEST. There was no skill or effort put into this. It's like turning in an essay for a writing contest that your parent wrote for you but somehow even worse. Even more harmful is something as big as Pink Floyd putting ai "art" over actual art because it will convince other people it's okay.

@chocokeeki

Ай бұрын

You know, this would've been impressive if each frame was actually made by a human. Maybe they didn't know it was AI, so they thought that's what happened.

Nope, we don't like this color.

@frostbitetheannunakiiceind6574

Ай бұрын

fr

Pink Floyd were the last people who I thought would ever approve of ai art.

@itslene

Ай бұрын

So what's your conclusion after this? That Pink Floyd who you supposedly admired before are actually a bunch of unartistic hacks? Or is it that perhaps you were a little bit wrong in your interpretation of AI art..?

@pidza_hub7532

Ай бұрын

@@itslene pink Floyd right now is three boomers at war with one another all while being behind the times. Neither of your gatcha answers are necessarily true

@THEMONEGASQUE

Ай бұрын

It's art. Why gatekeep?

@duskyphantom

Ай бұрын

​@@THEMONEGASQUE AI "art" is not real art, it has no soul and is made by a machine, and it definitely shouldn't be put against real art made by real people who put effort into their work and win.

@gagi121

Ай бұрын

​@@THEMONEGASQUE I saw a guy uploading 49K AI images to an art platform a few days ago. He uploaded all of those last year. He used at some point a script that upload a new image every 20 seconds. How many images, do you think, did this guy actually look at? Tell me, how are you supposed to be an artist of an image you haven't even seen? Does this make sense?

As an animator and lover of Pink Floyd, that also submitted a video for this, an actual animation, I am INCREDIBLY disappointed that the judges in charge had picked an AI video over several other actual artists that put months of hard work into creating their video, only to get snubbed by someone that took the lazy route with generated, stolen images made through a prompt My respect for Pink Floyd, but especially for the judges on this panel, is lost. You do not promote art any more. Picking AI over animation is rejecting the idea of human creativity.

@NylaTheWolf

Ай бұрын

I am so sorry 🫂🫂🫂

Welcome To The Machine was an instructional guide i guess.

@heyoka9012

Ай бұрын

Yes. Yes it was.

@nicov1994

Ай бұрын

Ironic

@THEMONEGASQUE

Ай бұрын

I guess people misunderstand the meaning of that song and PF in general with these types of comments

@krycklund

Ай бұрын

@@THEMONEGASQUE cring

@vindurza

Ай бұрын

@THEMONEGASQUE buddy if you're trying to defend this shit it's damn obvious you certainly do.

Will the new Pink Floyd album be AI generated?

@Bryan-ce6bo

Ай бұрын

yeah

@irucsolrac101

Ай бұрын

Of course, eventually everything will be ai generated. 😊

@Venomous9

Ай бұрын

@@irucsolrac101 gross!

@Iknowwereyousleep289

Ай бұрын

@@irucsolrac101 honestly fuck humanity

@brupts7297

Ай бұрын

Idk it'll probably sound AI generated 🤷🏻‍♂️

How to destroy your 50th anniversary:

@THEMONEGASQUE

Ай бұрын

Stick to your pedo art or whatever the hell is going on at your channel.

@gaiatiful

Ай бұрын

@@THEMONEGASQUE angry because they actually draw stuff?

@beef3442

Ай бұрын

@@THEMONEGASQUEat least they can draw.

@horse493

Ай бұрын

No es como que tú seas un gran artista amigo

@ToxicTurquoise454

Ай бұрын

The anniversary was LAST YEAR.

It's not too late to call this an April Fools' prank, guys...

@slipies

Ай бұрын

furry

@jordy9606

Ай бұрын

@@slipiesthe roblox avatar in ur pfp has cat ears..?

@Langorithmic

Ай бұрын

@@jordy9606 shhhh, their mating ritual is starting

@slipies

Ай бұрын

​@@jordy9606 ofc

@iwasneverjoebiden

Ай бұрын

​@@slipiesbro what

They really think that zooming around a 3d scene and using stable diffusion on it literally taken from a youtube tutorial is amazing

@andrewlloydpeterson

3 күн бұрын

Some people think literally White canvas is amazing, so what?

To think so many *actual* creatives wasted so much valuable time (and presumably money) towards something that was never to be fairly judged in the first place. Real shame.

@tr33br06

Ай бұрын

Seriously man... I feel so bad for everyone who actually puts their soul into their art.

@eerieyellowlights

Ай бұрын

if they made something good it wasn't a waste of time at all. too many artists care about fame and don't give a shit about making cool shit. who fucking cares if an AI generated video won?

@MM2isBest

Ай бұрын

Most popular art is highly derivative nowadays anyways. Look at Pink Floyd, they are just milking the teet of 50 years ago still.

@c.s2193

Ай бұрын

​@@eerieyellowlights Tell me you're not an artist without telling me

@PopBROMOSGaming

Ай бұрын

​@@MM2isBestall art is derivative. Humans are inherently non creative. Look at how we name cities lmao. The issue with pink floyd these days is they lack both passion and vision.

pink floyd and their team must have some sort of lead poisoning to think this is good

@pokemonfanmario7694

Ай бұрын

Pink Floyd and their team going the way of the Romans.

"The technique that I used for creating my animation is AI" So they didn't do a thing?

@somename86

Ай бұрын

"The technique that I used for creating my animation is Blender" So they didn't do a thing? They used to hand draw those but now everyone is using a tool how dare they!

@nintyfanr

Ай бұрын

​@@somename86 Not the same thing and you know it

@thunderheadcinema6743

Ай бұрын

​@@somename86 And a slot machine is basically investing in the stock market. A microwaved burrito is the same as a home cooked meal.

@somename86

Ай бұрын

@@nintyfanr It is the same thing but gatekeepers don't like it that their hypocrisis is called out

@somename86

Ай бұрын

@@thunderheadcinema6743 Oh the irony because you could use the exact same stupid argument here. Those damn factory created food stealing all the jobs and work from real chefs!!!

"AI Colour you Like"

@cricocola8910

Ай бұрын

92 likes and no comments? i can fix that.

@GrumpDog

Ай бұрын

So what? Doesn't matter unless you just wanna tell other people what tools you think are acceptable. Plenty of people have shown the process it takes to utilize AI tools well. If you cannot see the creative input, that's your problem. It shouldn't matter one way or the other. Use the tools that are now available, to create stuff and bring imagination to life more easily. Y'all are no different from the bullies that told digital artists to draw for real, in the 90s. You cannot deny it, I remember.

@Bonaboo

Ай бұрын

@@GrumpDogthat comparison doesn’t make sense. Those digital artists were making much more controlled and meaningful choices, and made stuff that actually looks good, not a pile of ugly sludge. And the creators of these AI programs have admitted that they require the theft of real artists’ stuff in order to work. AI generated theft.

@amyroseliz

Ай бұрын

@@GrumpDog Digital art isn't the same as AI image models that were built off the back of millions of stolen artwork ripped from the internet. False equivalency

@GrumpDog

Ай бұрын

@@amyroseliz It's not false equivalency. I lived through the behavior in the 90s, and this is exactly the same, regardless of what you think about the details of the tool. If you don't like the comparison, stop acting like that.

AI generated art shouldnt have counted, let alone win. The world is doomed.

@BJcanal270

Ай бұрын

I disagree with you.

@CanalSince85

Ай бұрын

Totally agree.

@randywoodworth4022

Ай бұрын

Not doomed, just bored AF!

@corradonoceti9958

Ай бұрын

I don't agree. the regulation also provided for videos created with AI. this video is not done well because the prompts do not respect the metric beats of the song. the world is not doomed if ai is used well, as a tool not as a solution

@stevemagiclantern

Ай бұрын

the world is fine! It still takes a human to generate this stuff. it is not going away. well done to the winner!

A spit in the face of actual artists who poured their heart and soul into each frame of work they made and submitted for this competition. I'm absolutely disgusted in you.

@Effortless_Perfection

Ай бұрын

I understand the frustration, but artists had to know their chances of winning was slim. And pouring your heart out for a "win" isn't necessarily the goal anyway... is it?

@corknakovastein

Ай бұрын

I mean, this guy put hours into making this as well, allot goes into these videos, not to mention the rig you need to speed up the process is very pricy

@Bryan-ce6bo

Ай бұрын

business has no regard for sentimentality, or how much work an artist or group puts into a product. They're only concerned about the product itself and here it really shows. Then again it's so nauseating to watch that I fail to see how this was accepted in the first place.

@ToxycBanana

Ай бұрын

@@Effortless_Perfection Their chances of winning were slim enough without many entries just like this one for every one of the songs that are a part of this celebration. It is just a computer being told "space rock" with the images stitched together in a way that's at least not harmful to the eyes and has believable movement. There's no care taken to touch up details or keep the scenes consistent, there's a fundamental change in the scenery every single frame that completely severs my suspension of disbelief. Artists poured their heart out not to "win," but to be recognized for their love and talent to express it of another artists music, if they were being truthful to themselves. And their recognition has been taken by someone commanding a program that has been trained by analyzing images from all over the internet to make a video - it's all uncredited stolen imagery. That is the main problem here. ​@corknakovastein Tell me, would this video not look better as a 3D render? Like, the guy used stable diffusion to make it, which requires about as "pricey" a rig that you'd need to use something like Blender. Why didn't he just actually take the time to hand-craft an animation for this song? Every model painstakingly moved to create the same scenes, but more consistent, would look infinitely better, it would be much more representative of the artist, and take about as long to create as any 2D animation at 30FPS. At best, I'm counting 8 individual frames per second on this video. The image generation for this project probably took two days, with a couple of weeks to edit; which is the problem, because the "generative" part of real art is the most personal, incorporates the most characteristics of the artist into the work, and takes the longest because the most thought is put into it. There was no thought put into this. This is just a video that plays at the same time as "Any Colour You Like." Feel free to disagree but this is not real art.

@ryderprogram

Ай бұрын

​@@corknakovastein You literally just put in a sentence and wait. You can do anything else in that time. There's no "hours of work" in that. It's like paying money for an art commission, because you didn't make the AI "art".

The fact you guys picked this as a winner makes me question not only your integrity, but if you guys even created your own music.

@beneficient7467

Ай бұрын

who are these "you guys" and whose music do you think this is?

@yoloyo7019

17 күн бұрын

What a dumbass comment lmfao Ur right bro pink Floyd ai generated their albums in the 70s. Fuckin Sherlock Holmes over here.

@Georges_IV

11 күн бұрын

Youre acting like roger waters himself picked this, probably some random dude who runs the youtube channel

If you're gonna hold a contest, at least have some standard about the entries you're accepting. AI trash shouldn't be allowed to compete in a creatives' competition, much less win it.

@Effortless_Perfection

Ай бұрын

If this "trash" is what AI is capable of, then why are we trying to stiffle it. This entire video provided an experience I've never had before. The visuals really stand out as unique. And perhaps the point that it's different is what draws me to it. This is truly an outside the box depiction. And I get the frustration that no one can compete when AI is involved, but shouldn't that be accepted as a challenge to other artists?

@bensadfleck9972

Ай бұрын

​@@Effortless_Perfection"unique experience" and it's just a glorified winamp visualizer

@Mynder16

Ай бұрын

@@Effortless_Perfection The fact of the matter is that AI generative models, at least a majority of the ones available to people, are trained on content that many MANY artists are not okay with having had their content included in the training model. It's not really fair to say "this should be accepted as a challenge to other artists" when generative models like this are capable of outputting images at levels that are impossible to compete with by an actual person. There's an inundation in general art spaces of AI nowadays that if not properly tagged (or not required to be tagged) is overtaking regular artists who are now being forced to compete with said models. I do agree that AI does have a particular look to it that can't be replicated by people, because the way that it 'thinks' (which it doesn't) is very different from how a regular person might have approached it, but this project was done to reward creatives for creating something new as an anniversary for Pink Floyd. There are artists and animators and all kinds of other people who poured hours and hours into making a new video for the sake of this competition. Even if this person is proven to have made this entire video with a model trained on their own art (which I've seen being mentioned around) it's still a matter of effort in that a model was used to generate the entire thing where other people meticulously made everything from scratch. I say all of this as a person in the general art space (as someone who's dabbled in fanart as a hobby for over a decade). There's a worrying trend in the industry towards generative models like this because of their high output capabilities compared to regular people, and instances like this where people who have worked years and years to hone their craft and achieve their level of creative output are being pushed to the side in favor of AI is further reinforcement of this worrying trend.

@cunning_linguist.

Ай бұрын

​@@Effortless_PerfectionYou're on some AI glizzying crusade. The point is that this was meant to be art. Generated images are not art, definitionally. This really might as well be the windows player visualizer, it has as much meaning as those procedurally generated images.

@chad4858

Ай бұрын

@@Effortless_Perfection If you think this is good, you've got to be some 60+ year old without any neuroplasticity left to recognize how bad this is.

Stock images of instruments, electronics, and planets display a tourist's understating of Pink Floyd. But what's arguably worse is the apparent lack of interest in making it work with THE SONG. There's a big sting that we all know at 1:19, and NOTHING changes! Then, at 1:43, a new shot, motivated by NOTHING. Since the invention of sync sound in movies, animators have have used their unique position to create visuals to music where action fell on specific notes, on specific beats. There's none of that here. This is just some animation which runs the length of the song.

@haroldgimmy2821

Ай бұрын

Just correcting you. This isn't exactly stock images but a horrible horrible use of AI (which I guess learns from stock images). The "animator"'s (quotation marks important) use of AI has even less effort than using stock images in the video. But 100% agree with you, doesn't even match with the song. Wasted potential, as I was hoping for some abstract animation which matches the song, not an AI drum and guitars...... Like what do planets have anything to do with the Dark Side of the Moon? The title, "DARK SIDE OF THE MOON" is a metaphor... not the soundtrack for NASA and their moon expeditions.

@4perf

Ай бұрын

@@haroldgimmy2821 But doesn't the AI program find existing images of, say, guitars and planets, to work off of rather than creating them from scratch? I need to learn more about this.

@haroldgimmy2821

Ай бұрын

@@4perf Yes. The AI is trained on millions of images to form an output based on your input. I can't explain this well but you can search "Stable Diffusion" online (which was the AI the "animator" used). Apparently the method which Stable Diffusion uses differs from other AI programs. If you ask me, "Stable Diffusion" definitely doesn't look stable lol

@1sthename70

Ай бұрын

​@@4perfjust search up how ai "art" works

@EuhoriaChick

Ай бұрын

@@4perf this slop gets generated from many sources at once but yeah, all from videos and images, that were scraped online

As an artist, reading all these backlash comments makes my heart warm. Hopefully, those corrupt corporations will realize that people don't want art generated via algorithms. People want art created with heart.

Never in my whole life would I have expected Pink Floyd to do something as disgraceful as this. A band with almost 60 years of history creating art and it all comes down to this? Fucking over actual artists and rewarding this slop?

@NotoriousF.A.G

Ай бұрын

@@MissingNo2k this ai chud is so mad he's actively seeking comments to rabidly defend the slop hope your ai girlfriend sees this man

@damienjeralds2301

Ай бұрын

@@MissingNo2k Counter-point: Shut the fuck up. If it has to be explained to you why it's insane for someone who typed in text in a prompt to win a contest that had countless people enter putting in ACTUAL WORK like even making a water-color animation BY HAND, then you don't care about the arts despite artists building every god damned thing you enjoy today, and as such you're as stupid as you are useless. AI was fun when it was for shitposts and humor, now it's literally sucking the joy out of every creative craft, and I'm well past the point of tolerating people who defend it in situations like this which by all accounts should be plain as day why it's reprehensible and objectively bad.

@warehouseradio4321

Ай бұрын

They're elderly people with brains fried from acid, what do you expect at this point.

@TooMuchSascha

Ай бұрын

@@MissingNo2k Kiss my ass

@Crobat7269

Ай бұрын

@@MissingNo2k the fuck is AIphobic? No one is scared of AI "art"

This is an ANIMATION contest. What a way to give the middle finger to those who spent months manually creating amazing visuals and stories for this competition only to be squandered by a souless unthinking machine using an amalgamation of prexisting videos and images. Should never have been allowed to be submitted in the first place. AI may be a tool, but this is a contest for art.

@andreviews7101

Ай бұрын

Nobody cares.

@steffimaier7297

Ай бұрын

Contests like that are a huge scam and a sneaky way to get free (or for really cheap) art and animation.

@StarChaser1879

Ай бұрын

The person who made this is a 3-D animator and he took months to make this

@ShineOnYouCrazyPiper

Ай бұрын

​@@StarChaser1879i have stable diffusion installed locally, you can make this in about 28 minutes by putting in a base image and stating a style, most of the time spent making it is generating it, it takes no effort whatsoever

@sinnykensc2352

Ай бұрын

​@@StarChaser1879 it took him months? Damn that's a long time just to write a few sentences... Hope he's dealing well with his disability ❤

Extremely dissapointed. Expected legends to recognize true art. Not something slapped together in less than an hour with no soul

I hope the Studio releases your next album fully on AI and you guys get no share whatsoever

@asw7696

Ай бұрын

What does releasing an album fully on AI mean? AI is neither a medium nor a music streaming platform.

@danielventuri9620

Ай бұрын

@@asw7696 I think i meant that the studio should make and album with AI software based on Pink Floyd songs and release it as an actual album and give the members of the band no share. I dont really understand that much about it I was just mad that they let an AI "artist" win an real art contest. And dont get me wrong i fricking love their songs

You guys have lost your touch with reality, what are you doing lads lmao

@Flermpo

Ай бұрын

Love you shoocharu

I thought this was an art competition?

@balanceboy3089

Ай бұрын

I was, appa AI is "art" now. And we should "respect" the "effort" they put into prompt typing

@sbeps1195

Ай бұрын

@@balanceboy3089hahhahahah there is no effort. “Ohhhh, give me praise for having ideas and knowing how to use a keyboard”. Ffs, you guys are more pretentious than the most obnoxious performance artists at the MOMA or something.

@balanceboy3089

Ай бұрын

@@sbeps1195 We can do something you can't. And you hate us for it. And now that there's something makes you feel like you can do what we do, you're defending it as if you're skilled. Sorry the concepts of hard work and passion never came up in your childhood. Be better than this.

@sbeps1195

Ай бұрын

@@balanceboy3089 wait hang on is your comment pro ai or anti ai? Its hard to read, I’m not sure where your coming from here now that I’m reading it a 2nd time

@balanceboy3089

Ай бұрын

@@sbeps1195 Anti AI, idiot you don't even know what you're arguing against .

Disgusting that a machine won over real artists

@SeventhSwell

Ай бұрын

Right? This is the kind of crap Pink Floyd would have sung about, before they got old and rich.

@frostbitetheannunakiiceind6574

Ай бұрын

revolting

You were the chosen one, Pink Floyd! It was said that you would destroy the AI, not join them. You were to bring balance to the arts, not leave it in darkness!

AI cringe. Revoke their reward and give it to someone who actually put in some damn effort beyond putting a prompt into a plagiarism machine.

@THEMONEGASQUE

Ай бұрын

The human brain is a plagiarism machine. Literally all art is derivative, all the time. AI just takes it a bit more literally.

I can’t even find the right words to say how disappointed I am. Good lord

@tikob9045

Ай бұрын

Right? Pink Floyd out of everybody..

Remember kids, AI art isn’t art

@13Percent52PercentYikes

Ай бұрын

Mfw it is and artistic value isn't exclusive to a whiny teenager

@MrNocturnal310

Ай бұрын

@13Percent52PercentYikes the AI apologists in these comment threads are hilarious. It's so obvious this competition got robbed it's painful to watch. Every artist who put forth blood sweat and tears got jipped

@13Percent52PercentYikes

Ай бұрын

@@MrNocturnal310 Wah, producing something doesn't entitle you to an award, especially when it's a competition. This fit Pink Floyds lame ass reddit TrIpPy vibe so it won. Also I'm not an AI apologist bro what the fuck does that even mean 💀 You 12 year olds sure love to make up phrases. My other favorite is "systematic racism"

@ex15808

Ай бұрын

@@13Percent52PercentYikesjust by ur username i kno u have fetal alcohol syndrome

@abhiii3068

Ай бұрын

@@13Percent52PercentYikes No, it's just pathetic that you can't pickup a pencil and put in the work.

to Pink Floyd legal team: You don't have ownership over the imagery of this video. Several states have declared that anything generated by AI can't be copyrighted because it can't be verified what copyright infringements the program committed to create what it created.

@revlarmilion9574

Ай бұрын

This is false.

@gaiatiful

Ай бұрын

@@revlarmilion9574 literally isnt

Hey, the guy used a program called stable diffusion, trained on millions of images from other artists.

Delete this and give the prize to someone who actually put hard work into their entry, instead of typing in a prompt.

Such disrespect to the people who probably spent hundreds of hours creating submissions. Just label it as ai competition next time so people don’t waste time creating something meaningful. Vile

My comisiarations to all the talented artists who have worked on a artistic entry.

@cedricaguilar4501

23 күн бұрын

I did animate for this song, I don't think I deserve to win because I could've done better. But picking AI? WTH they doing?

This probably took around an hour to make. The person who submitted this submitted 10 AI generated videos in total. It doesn't sync to the music, and if you played the video without sound I couldn't tell you which track it was made for.

This isn’t shocking but so woefully disappointing. You had so many wonderful entries made by PEOPLE by your FANS, and they spent countless hours and put in time and effort they can never get back just to lose to poorly “made” AI generated trash. Was this not to celebrate the PEOPLE who love the band?? To celebrate the PEOPLE in the band?? Why even hold a contest if you’re going to award 1st place to trash you could’ve typed into a machine yourself? You have lost the love for creation and art, lost the respect for the artists in this world, if you ever had any. You better award money to those who actually worked to create something beautiful *for you* and make this right. Or you can decide to double down and ruin the legacy of the music.

@frostbitetheannunakiiceind6574

Ай бұрын

Well said

Absolutely infuriating that after tons of real artists spent hundreds of hours creating their submissions, that you would chose a lazy thieving hack who spent 5 minutes typing some words into a program that they did not provide any art to train as the winner.

@eerieyellowlights

Ай бұрын

"real" "artists" i keep seeing these moronic qualifications thrown around but no substance to back them up

@c.s2193

Ай бұрын

​@@eerieyellowlights Nah, you're right. There are just hundreds of explanations under every comment made by AI bros. But don't worry, I got you: Real artists: Do the work themselves Not real artists: Type a line and let an algorithm do the work I know, the difference is really hard to understand. But I believe in you

@MrDonNobody

Ай бұрын

​​@@eerieyellowlightsreal artists = humans with talent. I see why you left the "I" lower case when referring to yourself. It's definitely fitting.

@eerieyellowlights

Ай бұрын

@@c.s2193 so what about 'real artists' who use stuff like perlin noise or other algorithms to give texture? 'hundreds of explanations' which don't explain shit, just keep saying things like 'they do the work' and other nonsense. art isn't about the implementation, it's about the idea; tools are just a way to get there. doesn't matter if you're generating texture maps or w/e, the art ain't the tool and it never has been.

@eerieyellowlights

Ай бұрын

@@MrDonNobody oh damn you got me i didn't use a capital somewhere holy damn son you got me good i've been defeated

"I feel like this is an insult to life itself" Theses are the words of Hayao Miyazaki, the world greatest animator, when asked about AI animations

@degayify

Ай бұрын

That is not the context of the quote

@sbeps1195

Ай бұрын

@@degayifythat’s literally the context of the quote. He was referring to generated animations some morons presented him with. Furthermore, the morons mentioned they wanted to make a machine to create art, to which the documentary cut to him saying a quote that went along the lines of “the world is doomed”. He’s referring to ppl who use this kind of evil technology and how we’ve been accepting lower quality entertainment more and more as algorithms and short form content rot our brains

@frostbitetheannunakiiceind6574

Ай бұрын

fr

@biospark8385

Ай бұрын

@@MissingNo2k bro directed several of the most iconic and beautiful films in the world that can be comparable to the movies Disney used to make, and you say that AI is better than all of his accomplishments?😭 I never understand the appeal of AI, all of this is soulless work done by a robot, every pixel fabricated by a machine. When films such as Miyazakis have several dedicated animators and artists including himself as director putting thought into every single stroke and every single frame. Something that takes years to do. A statement like this really just shows you have no appreciation for life itself, and will consume as much AI slop as you can Seriously why would you want a robot to make art for you?

@mossbenson

Ай бұрын

​​@@sbeps1195Except the image presented to him wasn't AI. The model learned how to walk through AI, but the animation presented was generated from its movements. Semantics, perhaps, but your statement is still disingenuous nonetheless. Additionally, his comment on the world being doomed is not necessarily directed at AI art "rotting our brains." If you actually saw this video, you'd see he follows up this line with a message about how humans doubting themselves and losing confidence with their innate abilities. The point here is that yes, while Miyazaki was and still is vehemently against AI art, his stance is not that of hate and disdain. Instead, it's more of a sadness in that humans lost faith in themselves. He's not angry, just disappointed.

this is so dissapointing.

This isn’t animation. It’s a garbled mess of stock images.

@user-ex5kv1tt8y

Ай бұрын

И тут меня стукнула идея. Как только я выпиваю лишнего, меня начинают стукать разные идеи. Иной раз с похмелья все тело болит.

@the-NightStar

Ай бұрын

You are actually wrong and your ignorant statement is inaccurate as to how AI art operates and works.

@andreviews7101

Ай бұрын

Nobody cares.

@zendio6882

Ай бұрын

that's not how ai art works beethoven

@Cwazy9

Ай бұрын

@@the-NightStarshut up, you’re missing the whole point. The fact that this won instead of many other WAAAAY talented videos is shameful. ‘They have to do it frame by frame!’ Yeah, and what about the several other talented artist who actually had to DRAW this stuff.

Look at the animations from The Wall movie. Those were drawn by hand. Think of the amount of work that went into that. A full team of talented animators working their fingers off to make some of the best animation associated with pink floyd. Now look at this. Ouch.

How generous of them! Letting thousands of artists win at once- just that these artists have been fed into that AI without their consent nor do they get credit or the reward for this. Isnt that just great...

this is my favorite song on the album and the thumbnail had me excited but i must say im disappointed that its just all ai.

@Isabelly_Passos

Ай бұрын

Your words are mine too.

@andreviews7101

Ай бұрын

Nobody cares.

@ggman.

Ай бұрын

@@andreviews7101 then why reply?

@andreviews7101

Ай бұрын

@@ggman. It's just a joke, but I swear, everyone is over exaggerating about AI. Yes, it's not true animation, is it the worst thing in the world? No. Dying is worse than AI.

@ZCEKanimations

Ай бұрын

@@andreviews7101no they’re upset cuz some artists spend months on their animation and then there’s this dude generating ai in a click of a button and he managed to win. No effort, no expression, no nothing. It’s soulless. Art is about showing what the human mind can create. This is not art.

Absolute garbage. You can generate frame-stacking videos like this automatically using stable diffusion and typing a few words. Incredibly disappointing and shameful.

@SamTheMightyMan

Ай бұрын

Better toss out all your old Pink Floyd albums then I guess

@THEMONEGASQUE

Ай бұрын

Really? Do you feel disappointment and shame at this? The gatekeeping is unreal

@beef3442

Ай бұрын

@@THEMONEGASQUEnot gatekeeping if the person trying to get in is actively harming the careers of everyone inside the gates

@THEMONEGASQUE

Ай бұрын

@@beef3442 what you just said is gatekeeping 101

@somename86

Ай бұрын

@@beef3442 Oh you mean like the printing press that was harming the career of manual writers or the robotic arms that was harming the career of factory workers come on...

As a band that has been of such vital importance to art as a whole, seeing them endorse an AI generated video feels like a middle finger to the industry they've been in for almost 60 years.

@Turnenkof

Ай бұрын

Most of them are dead the band is over

@bastiaanbosch7093

Ай бұрын

@@Turnenkof Alright? What was your point of writing that comment? And I wouldn't define 1 of the 4 being dead and Syd Barret being dead as "the most". I don't even care about what you think your comment has of a purpose, as in the end somebody still vastly underestimated this action.

To the people arguing that the submitter was a 3d artist and thus justifies this being the winner: Van Gogh can take a shit on a pedestal and it'd still be shit, guys. This literally looks the exact same as every other ai music video that zooms in and generates images

@ScoopMeisterGeneral

Ай бұрын

Honestly, if the guy who "made" this really did put loads of effort into this like people are saying, that makes it somehow worse. Imagine putting actual effort into producing soulless, empty slop like this.

@sbeps1195

Ай бұрын

@@ScoopMeisterGeneralai bros just straight up lie, or think that how much time ai takes is “a lot”. Aka they expect everything to be lightning fast. It’s all a scam at this point, the voters got scammed.

Normal people: this looks terrible and using AI for a competition is cheating AI dorks: YoU DoNt KnOw HoW iT wOrKs!

@haroldgimmy2821

Ай бұрын

Agreed. Even if this didn't use AI (it did), it still looks like utter garbage.

@ScoopMeisterGeneral

Ай бұрын

Thank you! It's garbled nonsense with no actual meaning or intention behind it. Utterly soulless.

@cube4547

Ай бұрын

yeah this isn't even about how it works at this point, this is just visual diarrhea

@arbitool

Ай бұрын

Or... Do you have any idea how many iterations it took?!

I swear the commenters acting like it’s a form of art to type prompts into an AI generator must also think their search queries on R34 have as much artistic merit as the images that come up.

What a pathetic excuse of a winner. How was this even allowed?

Cool screensaver. That's what this was supposed to be, right?

I have to admit that I´m a little disappointed. The winning animation for Any Colour is A.I. and the two honourable mentions as well. I put a lot of work into my "handcrafted" approach. It´s pinned on my channel, if you want to watch it :)

@NotAHero123_7

Ай бұрын

That video looks way better, and I can see that there was actual talent put into it. Good job!

@ooraycreation

Ай бұрын

@@NotAHero123_7 Thank you, much appreciated! ❤

@michelledelhaye3473

Ай бұрын

Falait pas la faire mais c'est un plaisir des yeux en plus de la musique sublime ta EU de la chance de pouvoir le faire .merci 😅

@torna2508

Ай бұрын

I hate self promotion, but is was needed this time. I really like your video. It's a thousand times better than AI shit

@roguemutantbrain119

Ай бұрын

Like this comment, it’s the real winner

so inserting some text and letting a machine basically throwing up a mix of other peoples art into a video is allowed to win? what the hell man...

@andreviews7101

Ай бұрын

Nobody cares.

@StarChaser1879

Ай бұрын

The guy who made this spent months making it and is a 3-D modeler.

@andreviews7101

Ай бұрын

@@fall1n1gr Thanks! 😀👍

@StarChaser1879

Ай бұрын

@@fall1n1gr it took a month to Rotoscope with 3-D animation that he made himself yes

@amyroseliz

Ай бұрын

@@StarChaser1879 You reply to literally every single comment defending this guy. You're either his alt or you're deepthroating him lmao

AI SHOULD OF BEEN BANNED FROM THIS COMP IF YOU TRUELY CARED ABOUT ANIMATION

You can really feel the intent behind e̶v̶e̶r̶y̶ ̶b̶r̶u̶s̶h̶ ̶s̶t̶r̶o̶k̶e̶ the two or three words used to generate this Never mind, there's another two or three words for the next prompts at 1:42 a very artistic choice because at 1:42, nothing happens in the song

And the winner goes to......... a computer!!!! Robots rejoice. I would've never thought Pink floyd would allow this to win. Crazy

For anyone who doesn't have the "show KZread dislikes" browser extension: At the time of writing, this video has 1.8k "thumbs up" and 5.3k "thumbs down" from 42k views

@coryneff7048

Ай бұрын

Update?

@NoOne-wd2ts

Ай бұрын

@@coryneff7048 4.7k dislikes

@coryneff7048

Ай бұрын

@@NoOne-wd2ts thanks bud

@floydnut5908

Ай бұрын

5.1k dislikes now

@lduv1

Ай бұрын

5.1k now

Pink Floyd - Eclipse animated music video by "Yosh" should be the winner AI crap

Well at least they can't legally own this video. Anyone who wants to reupload this video and monetize it can do so.

@funtechu

Ай бұрын

Just not the music (be careful)

It's genuinely unhinged how @Pink Floyd accepted and choose an AI generated animation over artists who put their thought and dedication into their submissions. I've lost what little respect I had remaining for the Pink Floyd team.

@StarChaser1879

Ай бұрын

The Pink Floyd team knows better than you do

@TheMirrorslash

Ай бұрын

This animation is mostly human created though. This is a 3D render with stable diffusion rendering over each frame in the end. Probably took weeks to create this. There's no AI model putting this stuff out. Look up stable diffusion animation workflows, very hard work still

@SulpuuricAcid

Ай бұрын

@@StarChaser1879 Yeah I'm sure they do!

@Banana_Quarrel

Ай бұрын

@TheMirrorslash spend that time on real animation then, that doesnt steal preexisting works without consent

@THEMONEGASQUE

Ай бұрын

Oh no, SulpuuricAcid has lost respect for Pink Floyd, how will we ever recover. This video reallllly brings out that characteristic sanctimony from PF "fans"

One of the best...an AI?? REALLY????

"Oi Dave, this video's a bit trippy innit hurhur" - Maximum extent of the judge's thought process choosing this as the winner

Ah yes AI overtaking creativity, shame on you Pink Floyd

@hendrx

Ай бұрын

AI is great at art, nobody cares

roger waters would never have allowed this shit

@darylabbott2032

Ай бұрын

Who cares what he thinks anyway, he's a bid egotistical jerk! Just ask Nick and David.

@REAL_ROGER_WATERS

Ай бұрын

Every word demonstrably true.

@rebeldeconcausa9227

Ай бұрын

@boligrafohacker7592 roger waters is a degenerate lefty who lives in Switzerland while defending the dictator of Venezuela. What the hell are you waiting for?

@SirLordHatCawk

Ай бұрын

Well he did butcher DSOTM with that revisit but this is on a whole next level of negligence.

@DJVARAO

Ай бұрын

RIP waters

April fools was 5 days ago...

Having seen the other submissions the fact this won is a god damn travesty. I imagine Floyd lost a lot of fans with this blunder.

Wow, bad renderings of objects aimlessly morphing into other uncanny badly-rendered objects? What a unique and original style that I've never seen before. Surely a lot of effort went into every last frame!!!!!

@InvisibleYetVisible

Ай бұрын

I love the fact it starts with a weird Les Paul with two humbuckers and three Burns Tri-Sonic lookalikes and a bridge that looks like it clamps the exhaust on a Ford Escort 😂 genius.😂

@beneficient7467

Ай бұрын

*sniff sniff* is that sarcasm i smell?

Murió el arte

Using AI to win a competition is messed up. It would be just as bad if he stole art from a live person

@GrumpDog

Ай бұрын

I'm watching a video right now, by an AI artist, that proves all you haters wrong. The process is every bit as involved as a traditional digital art workflows.

@coryneff7048

Ай бұрын

@@GrumpDog cope harder

@mushroomcrepes4780

Ай бұрын

@@GrumpDog how many will bite this bait

@THEMONEGASQUE

Ай бұрын

Jesus, it's a visual aid, no one ever said this was da Vinci level art. These comments reek of pseudo elitism

@coryneff7048

Ай бұрын

@@THEMONEGASQUE it's elitist to think art should be done by hand like it has been?

For any mobile users out there, this video has 2k likes and 7.5k dislikes. Just in case anyone was curious...

@sbeps1195

Ай бұрын

Its also been ratioed by quote retweets on Twitter by a thousand

@BoserPSN

Ай бұрын

Good

@1sthename70

Ай бұрын

Deserved

@Bryan-ce6bo

Ай бұрын

love your profile. very fitting

@slimekingmc8057

Ай бұрын

@@Bryan-ce6bo Thank you

It’s a shame that the same band responsible for The Wall movie, which featured some of the most brilliant animation segments in film (which by the way took months to make and was done by a small team of animators with colored pencils), chose an AI “animation” over someone’s blood sweat and tears. And fucking Gerald Scarfe, the lead fucking animator of that movie is one of the judges? Oh how times have changed.

@gaiatiful

Ай бұрын

@@RetroNumanox dont you dare compare digital art, something that take efforts, ingenuity and time, to ai.

@gaiatiful

Ай бұрын

@@RetroNumanox what does age even matter in this situation? cant come up with literally anything else aside being like an old crusty fuck on his lawn screaming at passerbys? go huff comet powder until you pass out for good, grandpa is getting cranky because he literally doesnt know shit about the world he lives in

@tinypurplefishes2903

Ай бұрын

⁠@@RetroNumanoxyou realize digital art still takes time and ingenuity, right? Even if you think being able to go back and redo something is wrong (as if it’s not been shown the Mona Lisa was painted over countless times) there still is creativity there. I’ve never heard of a digital artist going and stealing others art and putting their name on it

this sure is the greatest example of "man press enter" efforts of this generation. people will study their enter pressing like the masters of the old.

For those that don't have the YT dislike plugin, the ratio as of 14 April is 2.7k likes to 16k dislikes.

Me when I'm in a Ruining your band's well-built reputation competition and my opponent is David Gilmour:

"Welcome my son Welcome to the machine Where have you been? It's alright we know where you've been"

Ai can’t make art without stealing from actual artists, this shouldn’t qualify.

@hendrx

Ай бұрын

artists are inspired by other artists

@iwasneverjoebiden

Ай бұрын

​@@hendrxyes exactly

@iwasneverjoebiden

Ай бұрын

​@@hendrxand art isn't scraping the internet for images, art isn't something that doesn't take any effort and was made by a soulless machine learning program. ai should be used as a tool to enhance, not create.

@cypress2647

24 күн бұрын

@@hendrx Artists are sentient beings that create unique connections based off neural connections. Generative AI is nothing like a human brain, not in form or function. If you dont understand the difference then maybe YOU aren't sentient. Im starting to think AI shills aren't fully sentient themselves, because their single digit IQs dont fully qualify them as human.

Pink Floyd died in 1984

@andre6563

Ай бұрын

Nah, The Division Bell was a masterpiece

@DBumple

Ай бұрын

As much as I love Roger, final cut was ass as a whole album lmao

@THEMONEGASQUE

Ай бұрын

So you're here why....?

@NaaHva

Ай бұрын

And was replaced with Fink Ployd.

@RonJhadm

Ай бұрын

@@andre6563 in the same way Lil Pump’s debut album is a masterpiece? I would agree

This is like having a burger grilling competition and the person who brought a Big Mac they ordered wins

@robleee9

Ай бұрын

i love this comment, perfect analogy, also stop doing that to the moon, obama is angry

You should walk around town, ringing a bell and yelling shame ! 🔔🔔🔔

When AI beats genuine hard work, that's fucking depressing, but knowing how record labels work i doubt the band would even know or care about what the outcome was Ban AI from contests since the shit comes from stolen art anyway

Of all the talented animators and artists that entered I am unbelievably disappointed that they went with this AI one.

Why don't you publish AI music next?

@Dexter01992

Ай бұрын

Oh, the publisher definitely will, eventually. Anything to ensure profits over anything else...

@haroldgimmy2821

Ай бұрын

@@Dexter01992 "Have an AI" from the new AI album, "Wish you were AI".

Because this song now uses video AI, the song itself should be allowed for music training data. Hope you like the taste of your own medicine as an artist.

Shame on you Pink Floyd I preached all of last year to disqualify people using Ai. This is a spit to the face to all those artist that busted there ass. This is cheating anyone could have done this with Ai

@user-ex5kv1tt8y

Ай бұрын

​​Да, нет, другое?

@andreviews7101

Ай бұрын

Nobody cares.

@user-ex5kv1tt8y

Ай бұрын

@@andreviews7101 Не могу жить в деревне. Но бывать там люблю - сердце обжигает.

@theghoulavenue

Ай бұрын

@@andreviews7101You care a lot considering you're commenting this on every single comment who calls out how lazy AI is, so maybe do some self reflection.

@Mr55662

Ай бұрын

They are like Roger on the 77’, they spit on the fan

shivering at the thought of this guy putting something like "pink floyd the dark side of the moon triangle rainbows" in the prompt. like was this made by a 7 year old? can we be serious

@andreviews7101

Ай бұрын

Can we not be serious? Because nobody cares.

@aleksejkaramazov

Ай бұрын

@andreviews7101 i mean, i care. And (even though you are delusional and a lot of other people clearly care) i wouldnt give a shit if no one else did. Do you usually need other people that care for you to care about something?

@StarChaser1879

Ай бұрын

The guy who made this spent months making it and is a 3-D modeler.

@aleksejkaramazov

Ай бұрын

@StarChaser1879 1. he didnt make it, the computer did 2. the fact that you spent a lot of time on something doesnt automatically mean it's good 3. then why didnt he use his 3d modeler skills to make a good video?

@StarChaser1879

Ай бұрын

@@aleksejkaramazov there’s creativity there. Creativity makes art. Based on your logic Jackson pollock didn’t make art. Also, he did make it, according to your logic a photographer, doesn’t make their own art.

Syd and Rick would hate this

What's irritating me is that the whole "morphing instruments concepts" could have been done way better by an actual animator. With this, every frame is some random device or thing that has something to do with music but there's no connecting piece that I can see. I mean you could have done research and used the exact instruments Pink Floyd used for the song and did something with that.

this is genuinely one of the most distressing, depressing things i've experienced in a while. what's the point of being an artist? what's the point of being alive?

@eerieyellowlights

Ай бұрын

if a video is making you question the point of being alive you've got way more problems than AI

@jesseknowles3837

Ай бұрын

@@eerieyellowlightsah, the human understander has logged on

I was enjoying all the winners until this AI generated video

the fact this isn’t illegal is mind boggling to me, it’s low effort slop that only serves to spit in the faces of real artists who applied for this project.

Gonna host a cooking competition and give the prize to some guy that managed to shove 20 takeout containers in a microwave and reheat food they didn't make

NoPe.

Art is communication between sentient beings and ai isn't communicating anything.

@frostbitetheannunakiiceind6574

Ай бұрын

fr

Even without the reliance on ai this is creatively bankrupt work

An artist using AI to create is like an orienteer using Google Maps to navigate.

I never thought I'd dislike a Pink Floyd video, but here we are

@NaaHva

Ай бұрын

How about the More album? That's worth of dislikes if you ask me.

@happymonster9098

Ай бұрын

@@NaaHva I just remembered that trash is a Pink Floyd album, I erased it from my memory.