Please note that extremist, poorly reasoned, aggressive or racist comments will be removed.

@philzambo

4 жыл бұрын

Wow Nate, this is a real departure for you, well done.

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks! We worked hard on this one 🙂

@philzambo

4 жыл бұрын

@@NateMurphy Top work mate, more people need to speak out about this, the actions of the Israeli government can be horrific at times. Bless you.

@DonQuiKong

4 жыл бұрын

good luck trying to moderate this comment section. you will need it.

@bornfreefreedom4900

4 жыл бұрын

Truly amazing Best wishes

As a Palestinian and as a climber, this really hits home. Thank you for inspiring hope and sharing your story, it means a lot.

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks, glad it has reached you.

came to look at van build guide & found this amazing footage. you gave this man an expanded view. great story & easy to watch critically. thank you.

Amazing Nate, an excellent video and a powerful piece of symbolism. Well done!

Thank you for an amazing video and for giving Marwan the space to speak. It's so easy to despair over what seems like an impossible struggle, but when I hear the hope in Marwan's voice, it lifts the spirit and I am reminded of the goodness in human nature. We are not born hateful, but it is taught to us by those who seek to control us. Many Israelis are aware that their government purposefully creates conflict and fear to stay in power. Someday, there will be a turning point.

Superb video Nate. You should be proud.

First time I’ve come across your channel. Watched the video from start to finish with interest. Really enjoyed your work - well thought out, well researched, well executed. LL

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks Liam 👍 we appreciate your feedback.

Incredible stuff Nate. Massive respect. And the graffiti at the end? Just perfect.

I think you've done really well tackling this with enough sensitivity. Good work!

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks Kevin! We worked hard to do so!

This is incredible brother. So stoked to see you using your platform to start these conversations and make a difference. Keep it up👍🏽

Good, well informed, largely balanced piece Nate. Interesting quote '..40% of my audience is American...' sadly with only 13+K views so many of your audience choose to ignore it. Thank you.

What should you do if you are an 'influencer' and you come across injustice? ..... Interesting film on the philosophy on you tubers/ influencers. You tube is the real reality tv, so to speech, and this is why they are beginning to Marshall the channel as the power is really here... . traditional reporting understands the status quo and therefore plays the game to educate within the given parameters of power and economics ...

This has been on my mind so much. This was such a good video . Hope like this is being wiped away

Cool video , I can relate to the Palestine people as iam from Northern Ireland 👍☘️

Incredible!

Exposing oppression and injustice is ALWAYS the right thing to do....

Great stuff, Nate, well done. That was really inspirational and filled a gap in climbing content that needs filling. I'd be unbelievably excited to see more stuff like this in the future!

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks Patrick!

You have mentioned you have done a research, but there are a lot of inaccuracies within your video, and over all you had only represented one side of the story. Most of the video is very populist in its attitude as well. First of all, this wall is very short. Its only exist within the borders of Jerusalem city. Along the other parts of the green line border there is a fence, and along the most parts there is nothing. Overall the situation in Israel is very complicated. You cannot simplefy the problem as you have done in your video. Im talking as an Israeli Jew who's ancestors lived within the boundaries of Israel for at least 500 years, much more than most of the Palestinians can attest for themselves. The circumstances has brought the Israeli nation to hold this regime. You cant tell the full story without a full representation of at least 150 years of the Jews history and Israeli politics. The circumstances has brought the situation on us, and there is no simple or magic solution to it. To boycott Israeli products wont help to solve the problem, to ban weapon commerce wont help as well, and sure not climbing on walls (even that I am a very keen climber myself). What might help is bringing the Israelis and Palestinians to closer relations. I am sorry to say that, but you are just creating more eerines when you represents the story in this particular way.

@Klopp2543

3 жыл бұрын

There is a very simple solution to this quagmire. Since the 2 state solution is now impossible how about one state which is secular,democratic,equal,for every Israeli and Palestinian? Like let's say like how every other country is in the world?

Great video!

Wow that was touching! Thank you for giving some insight about this rarely spread out topic!

Dude, this film is awesome! Thoughtfully and respectfully put together. And the graffiti at the end...👌More like this please!! #smallactsofrebellion

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks Alan, when we come across injustice and have some agency - then we will certainly do more.

This guys made history for sure. When this wall comes down, people will remember Nate as one of the first Europeans/British to defy the oppressive regime wall.

One of the best films I have ever watched, very interesting and informative.

Fantastic mind expanding video. I have a couple of Israeli friends who think that their country is barbaric and they were army officers for nine years! Let's hope one day people can live together in that region

Thank you for this, Nate!

Very, very interesting, thanks for your efforts. So now I'm interested in the background, is this an issue you were not really aware of or would you now not go climbing to a location that was wrapped up in such issues? Or would you go but only on the basis that you would have a story to tell? As a climber/mountaineer (sort of resting post kids...) I'm wondering which guide book your new route will be published in?!!

This is worse than apartheid at least we had the numbers to fight back and set boundaries when it got too bad South Africa stands with Palestine 🇿🇦🇯🇴

Wow, that was brave. You may not have stuck your head over the wall, but you raised it nonetheless. At least you seem to know how severe the backlash might be and maybe you inspired one more person to speak up about something they cross paths with. Respect.

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks!

I wish this film would influence other influencers to think more about their own ethics and also responsibility that naturally comes with their job. Great film, Nate!

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks - I hope it reaches some too!

I've been watching your videos for a few years now, and I never expected you to release a video like this. However, I have to say, I'm pleasantly surprised. This is probably the longest youtube video I've sat through it's entirety in months now. It's good to see people raising awareness of the violence and atrocities happening to Palestine. Solidarity with Palestine

Very good content, Nate!! Proud of you !

Thanks for posting Nate, I found it so hard to watch and only managed about 15 mins of it as the injustice makes me feel so powerless and angry. We've all long known that Israel has been very unfair (to be polite!) to the Palestinians, and have stolen land, and killed with no repercussions or justice. Yet, if we dare speak about this, we're labeled anti semitic, or worse. It is indeed incredibly complex and I know that there are Israelis who also want peace, and I pray for the day when that can happen. I fear that the damage that Israels policies have created will have left a lot of muslims with hate, anger and revenge on their minds, so peace is going to take a long time in coming.

Loved it mate... Filled me with hope... Much love bruv 💙

Absolutely brilliant. Thanks Nate.

If they will say you might have a bomb why don't you climb the wall nude than they have no feet to stand on

You brought tears to my eyes when you touched the wall... You bring so much hope and I just hope one day that this hope pays off

Thank you for sharing this video to the world sir. My respect to you for doing this. To my Palestian brothers by Allah i really wanted to do something for you, i want to give you help but i could not do anything i am not capable nor had ang afford to send you help only some du'a and prayers for you. That the only thing i can offer for you as of now. May Allah help you and deliver you out of misery and oppression from israel. My heart cries for you o my defenseless Palestinian brothers and sister.

Thank you so much for making this important film, Nate. I wish more travel influencers were brave enough to use their platform to expose the injustices they encounter along the way. "There comes a time when silence is betrayal." - MLK Jr.

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks Rose & also thank you for watxhing.

Perfect video my g. I hope you got to see the beauty of the Palestinian people and that they are the real oppressed in the face of a mighty oppressor.

😭😭😭😭..yes, my heart is crying for you Palestines.💗💗💗💗💗

I feel sorry for these people 😢 i pray that God will see their sufferings and give justice they deserve 😭💔

Why do you think Nate, its a wall of oppression?

I agree you're good man who know the value of people

YOU HAVE TAKEN THE MORAL OPTION GOOD CHOICE

That video was very sensitive and you could really see how important the topic is to you but as an Israeli subscriber of yours I just felt it’s missing the other side of the coin, which also just seeks for peace 🙏

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks Robert, I know there are many Israelis and Israeli politicians and organisations that look for peace and better treatment of Palestinians. I was careful to talk about administrations/governments not people - although it is people en-mass who do vote for their policies.

Sadly the impetus and necessity for this wall is brought about by bad policy making in the name of Palestinians by their leaders and by those extremists within Palestinian society who have committed cold blooded murder and mayhem. I hope the need for the wall will dissolve and that the common humanity on both sides will prevail.

PEACE AND LOVE BROTHER, LONG LIVE PALESTINE

Great story, seen through the eyes of Palestinians.

Amazing Nate!

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks James

Very cool.

The eloquence in choosing the appropriate set of words when describing such touch users is mind blowing. Respect! I really don't know how many people you influence and how, but your narration in this video is truly an inspiration. You don't have to take a side to say what is just.

@Hamudy3591

2 жыл бұрын

honestly he did so so well to document in a respectful, credible way.

I agree with you man!

Dont you believe that both the terrorists and civilians who supported all those coward bombings and stabbings should have thought about this before committing those seriously cowards acts? Why they complain now?

I’ve loved this video thank you! New to climbing and as an immigrant from a colonised country one thing I’ve always thought about and sometimes felt conflicted about the climbing community’s maybe underdeveloped discourse of ethics relating to climbing in non western places (use of traditional land - post colonial attitudes of entitlement). This was something I thought about watching your last video climbing in Israel/Palestine ( not saying there was something wrong with it). Rather it is reassuring to see u engage respectfully and deeply in the discourse of the place you visit.

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

Thankes Ale, it is always a bit disappointing when people dodge the issues and therefore help to maintain the status quo.

Very nice video!, I'm an Israeli, it was very interesting to see and hear your thoughts about the situation, And as an ex special forces in the Israeli army I can say that some of what they say is true and some of it ain't, why? Because that I have seen the situation closly with my own eyes not like this video from the side... I can go supper political and state so many facts against this video, because in the end of the day nobody can go into a fight of two men and persuade them to stop in the middle without knowing real real facts about the situation, this video is amazing but unfortunately it did choose a side... Peace all

@jasontwynn7356

3 жыл бұрын

Israel is right,it's israel land . There home,it's little the pals have a big area to live on. If they don't like jews,move it's that easy. Home is where you hang your hat.

Cause and effect.

No real mention of the occupation during recent election campaigns, and Netenyahu promising to extend settlements if he wins. Looks bleak.

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

That was a bit too recent to include but is a clear demonstration of how Israels government abuses their position of power

@craigbee

4 жыл бұрын

Nate Murphy sorry, Nate - I meant that there was little mention *in the recent election campaign* of the occupation. Your video was excellent and informative and, impressively, offered a fresh angle on life behind the wall.

nice video

Thank god for The security wall it saved thousands of Jewish life's.

Amazing!

Thank you Nate for making this video and standing up against injustiuce. If the world gets more people like you and Sir Roger Waters who are influencers and peace activists, The world would be a good place for sure. Peace and Love for everyone.

Thank You!

Hi Nate I was watching your videos and I saw that you were taking things seriously and studying them to the end! From this I would expect that in this video you will also explore the issue from both sides and of course show both sides. And not just one side. I invite you to meet with the Israeli side of the story. And so finish what you started. "And really touch the end of the wall" You also mentioned that racist comments are being removed, I ask that you remove the awful reaction of the "Palestinian Patriot"

Nate - excellent video in all BUT ONE aspect; it needs a perspective from the Israeli side. Perhaps a good topic for a follow-up. Your choice of topic is the biggest ‘climb’ you have ever undertaken!

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks Stuart, actually I think it does include the Israeli perspective -perhaps not as much but when Israel has total power over the lives of those in the Westbank - it is their behaviour from a position of power which needs calling out. Punishing and humiliating a people after you have won a war does little for long term peace.

Nate, congrats, a point well made. I do believe that influencers like you should not avoid this kind of topic out of fear of losing an influencee or two, or even a sponsor. Rather lose them and gain long-term credibility as a result. I’m biased towards one side here (who isn’t?), and I fully expected you to be as well-just differently. So I wasn’t sure if I even wanted to watch this video. Was then positively surprised that you were only discussing the recent evolution of this conflict, and not the whole story back to the Balfour Declaration, and yes, I fully agree with you here. Giving at least some room to the Israeli side however might have been of benefit. Always two sides to a story.

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks Thomas for your thoughtful comment. Appreciate your view point too.

17:21 (the T-Shirts) Actually......... It's the other way around. 😂😂😂 (these people are so delusional)

Bruh I get your reasoning but it comes off as a bit self righteous. Having admitted you knew little about the conflict, you then proceed to judge who is right and wrong based on talking to only one side, while also failing to consider the geopolitics involved. By offering overly simple explanations for a complex issue, you bring huge bias into your documentary making it completely one-sided.

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

I knew little. Then I read for about 150 hours until I became informed. I recommend anyone to do the same if they have time, after which it would be interesting to see your point of view and how it differs.

If I just discovered you before! I would of met you..

Maybe do one for Cyprus and Turkey invasion

Thank you, and well done

Hi Nate. To get true view on the current situation, you should observe both side of the wall. If you wisit Isarael in future let me know "if you are willing". Maybe we will find a time to climbe together and ill show you around.

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

I spent most my time in Israel climbing with Israelis. I was surprised that with a few hours research I could know about the basic functioning of the West Bank occupation than than most of the Israeli people I met - and this isn't the subjective parts - just large simple things like how the West Bank is governed. On that basis I decided to represent the story which is not part of the current dominant narrative - for obvious reasons. I would also note that every single narrated statistic/fact comes from an Israeli-based source. It took weeks of full-time research to reach the position in this film and the hard truth is that if you win (which Israel in all intents and purposes, has) it is simply wrong to use your strength to dominate, oppress and take more from the losing side. You have to ask, what is the end result of this behavior? How will the conflict ever properly end? Even if Israel wishes to assimilate the West Bank into Israel itself - do you think people will forgive and forget? Do you think that 2.4 million people will just accept it? Of course not - instead of acting magnamonously they are acting as bullies and people know when things are unfair. Just remember that there are 18 year olds who are too young to remember the 2nd Intifada but are treated the same as if they perpetrated it. How do you control a people who you instead of fostering reconciliation and peace have fostered more hate? The end result is delivering them a totalitarian police state with an apartheid base - and for that to be enabled everyone has to be afraid all the time, including Israelis - who also have to pay for it. It is bad for everyone. There are two aspects of human fairness hardwired in to our brains: the wrongness to take advantage of one’s strength to exploit weaker people, and the appeal of distributions where the reward is proportional to the contribution. This film falls in to the former.

@elanmarko8831

4 жыл бұрын

@@NateMurphy I appreciate the thorough research. I've watched almost all your videos. I do have to say that as someone who sits on both sides of the fence, the story was 90% one sided. Would have appreciated a more balance look by speaking to Israelis who are pro Palestinian. I agree, many Israeli's have a biased opinion and perspective, as do Palestinians. There's a perspective they both live everyday and are fed by their news sources and families. Hence the reason to find Palestinians who understand the Israeli side, and Israeli's that understand the Palestinian side. As an Israeli myself living in Canada, I took a trip to the places you climbed, and luckily had a friend who was Israeli but advocated for Palestinian rights. That was the first time I felt like I was hearing the Palestinian side. Something to consider as well with using the term settlers...any climbing you've done in the united states like "Yosemite" were previously Indigenous land that was overtaken by European settlers. But we still climb there, and we don't use the term settlers to describe Americans. Food for thought.

@kittykatz3518

3 жыл бұрын

@@NateMurphy mfa.gov.il/mfa/foreignpolicy/terrorism/palestinian/pages/suicide%20and%20other%20bombing%20attacks%20in%20israel%20since.aspx

@alixmorris5953

8 ай бұрын

@@elanmarko8831 Hey Elan - I went to bed thinking about your comment though it was simmering long before in my mind. Climbers in Yosemite and where I live in Bishop, are settlers. That is fact. It always will be that way, just in the same that Israeli's are settlers. Bishop is an interesting place because we have a reservation and what natives, in this case the Pauite tribe, weren't killed off in the colonial genocide... are here today. The Buttermilks main used to be their sacred site for marriages. Today, it's overrun by climbers. Rarely, do you see any natives there anymore. Maybe in the US, the term doesn't get thrown around as much because it's less recent then the occupation of Palestine and we also killed the VERY large majority of indigenous people in our settler colonialism conquests. I think what's happening and has been happening in Israel IS textbook to what the US did, and our hand are bloody and hearts... dark. It's devastating to see what's happening there and has been happening there for the last 75 years and more...it's devastating because we've seen all over the world what settler colonialism does and it marginalizes, destroys, creates multi-generational trauma, and slaughters non-white groups. Anyone with a decent moral compass can watch what's happening in Gaza, the fear in the eyes of these children, the systematic racism the settlements breed in the West Bank, and blatant disregard for human life, can see the injustice in this.

Nate Murphy, Ezra Byrne Thank You 🙏😥

why the hell does the usa give this country money when its own citizens need it more!!

such an informative video telling us what that what climbing that wall means death for Palestine people

You interviewed a Palestinian perspective of the situation why didn't you interview a Jews perspective so we could make our own decision?

@sinjindelmore1203

4 жыл бұрын

Because blindly showing both sides does nothing to speak truth to power.

@avigetsbored

4 жыл бұрын

Is that a joke? How could it be blind to show multiple sides rather than just one side, not to mention that this is not a two sided issue. There are many sides and huge amount of nuance that require context, history, and an understanding of both the politics of Israel, Palestine, the surrounding Arab nations and the US. Not to mention geopolitical tensions, economic interests and the extra element that within the small piece of land that is Israel and Palestine there are a large amount of the worlds most holy sites.

@avigetsbored

4 жыл бұрын

@Sinjin Sanders

@sinjindelmore1203

4 жыл бұрын

@@avigetsbored Just showing both sides means absolutely nothing. You wouldn't show the South African Apartheid regime officials perspective because it doesn't change the fact that the regime the official works for is racist and immoral. You would never show a war criminals perspective.

@sinjindelmore1203

4 жыл бұрын

@@avigetsbored and yes I agree that this is a highly nuanced issue. That doesn't mean you have to show the perspective of war criminals and apartheid regimes.

Did you really say Kaiser Wilhelm II started WWI? May want to revaluate that statement.

@NateMurphy

3 жыл бұрын

His arrogance and behaviour was a significant contributor. If he had behaved differently it could have been avoided.

Of course everything the Palestinians tell you is true? I mean it must be, right? How about listening to the Israeli perspective?

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

All facts stated can be found on isralei based and reliable sources.

@NorCal-Killa

4 жыл бұрын

Nate Murphy very 1 sided to the overall situation. The death to Israel chants and rockets shot into Israel were conveniently left out

@pjf7943

4 жыл бұрын

@@NateMurphy But, you didn't post any.........

@lzilbermints8240

4 жыл бұрын

@@NateMurphy As an Israeli I can say that most of what you said and heared in the video were correct or nor too far from the truth but there were also some exaggerations, for example Marwan says in the video reffering to Gilo's population that "the settler is the most crazy person in the world", in fact Gilo is a neighborhood of Jerusalem (although outside of the 67 lines) with population simmilar to the other Israeli neighborhoods of Jerusalem and people there arn't much different from the avarage Jerusalamite or Tel avivian, in the 2015 elections about 30% there voted for the Centrer left parties that support a 2 state solution including an 8% for the (mostly Arab Palestinian) Joint list party, there is also higher than avarage Arab population there for Jewish majority neighborhoods of Jerusalem.

@NateMurphy

4 жыл бұрын

I think Marwan's reference to the crazy settlers is probably more alluding to the settlers that count as illegal even on Israeli terms - those with extreme zionist ideology who see them as carrying out gods work no matter what the cost.

Nate, just watched the film its very well produced and thought out. My thoughts: you have obviously spent most of your time at the Palestinian side hearing their injustices and thoughts, of course this will create a bias, go to the Israeli side and find out their injustices and thoughts. I know a lot about the arab-Israeli conflict and was always taught during my studies not to take a side, why? because like you mentioned this conflict is so old its crazy, it spans back millenia, and has so much pain and suffering from both sides. I assure you the Israeli have suffered tremendously in this conflict to, go back and ask them. I dont want the comment to be to long I could go on and on. In my opinion your film is ONE SIDED, like the side of the wall you spent your time at and any conflict ever , thats a fact and why it , in my opinion, doesnt paint the exact picture.

@siuoldub

4 жыл бұрын

Hi there, Maybe talking people from Israel would have made a for a more nuanced video. However, I disagree with the fact that just because this conflict is old and complex one cannot put that aside to show the situation as it is today. And I think that was the aim of this video. Why should the actions of passed generations dictate the life of Palestinian children today? By refusing to "take sides" what is your message? "It's complicated so it is ok". I might be ill-informed but the balance of power seems to tip in the favour of Israel " like a big fat fucking retarded fucking black girl on a see-saw opposite... a dwarf" (that's a quote from a movie not very PC out of context but the movie is great "In Bruges" if you want to check it out). What would an Israeli have to say that would in any way justify the current situation? It is very much Israel's responsibility to try for peace as they hold most of the cards. But hey that's just my opinion on the situation and I am by no means an expert.

He's taking Resk

23:49

Shalom Rings Hollow

WORTH TO MENTION this wall was built after the second intifada where 1000+ Israelis were killed by palestinians. after the wall was built it became realy hard for the palestinians to execute suicide bombing attacks.

Maybe dont declare war on Israel and don't attack them and leave their land

Uprising? You mean they attacked and lost.

Your video is one sided .i was hopping to see you getting an israel citizen and the opposing views. But as suspected you were not interested to do that

Excuse me but its called palestine🇵🇸 1:08

Seems like a one sided narrative.

I love you Palestinians

There is a rational reason for this wall.

@gulab3483

4 жыл бұрын

Maleficent Hardware maybe same rationale hitler had?

@maleficenthardware

4 жыл бұрын

@@gulab3483 Nope, I dont think so.

@timothybruns6857

4 жыл бұрын

Yes, the ‘rational’ reason is to create a demographic reality in Jerusalem where Israeli Jews have a majority by building the wall to include Jewish communities (like Pisgat Ze’ev) and exclude Arab ones (like al-Ram). The UN estimates that 30,000 Palestinians cross the wall illegally every single day to work under the table in Israel. This does not include Palestinians that cross with a permit. Now, knowing that fact, make a compelling argument that the wall is for “security.” It would be difficult....

How about the injustice of the 8,000 rockets hamas launched into Israel a decade ago, and however many more attacks since then?

@NorCal-Killa

4 жыл бұрын

Palestinian Patriot it’s God given land, Israelis been there much longer than you

@DonQuiKong

4 жыл бұрын

two wrongs dont make a right. both can be wrong.

@NorCal-Killa

4 жыл бұрын

DynoSour it’s called self defense not a 2nd wrong. If Mexico launched even 1 rocket into America what do you think we would do?

@Xiph1980

4 жыл бұрын

@@NorCal-Killa well, Mexico did not fire a rocket into the US, and any act like that from either side on that border would have an entirely different political impact, locally and globally. You can't compare the two. However had Mexico fired rockets as a response to the US snatching land through "settlements" I'm not sure the United Nations would side with the US... You can't use a response to an act of aggression by yourself as an excuse to retaliate.

@NorCal-Killa

4 жыл бұрын

Xiph1980 like I said, the immigrants are the Palestinians, Israel reclaiming the land not stealing. The Mexico thing was hypothetical. Hamas is a terrorist organization not a lagitjtimate government. If the cartels were launching rockets from Mexico it would matter not the reasoning, no excuse makes terrorist actions lagitimate. Attack me and I will kill. Self defense is an American right. Shouldn’t be any different for a country. Tbh I’m surprised they let 8k rockets in before retaliating I wouldn’t have waited so long if I were in charge. Do u also support the Iran regime that chants death to Israel while making nuclear warheads?

Nate, i invite you to visit Shiloh. I' ll show you my reality behind the wall: Molotov cocktails, stone throwing, knife terror, and terrorists who enter communities and murder families in their homes. I am 24. Terrorists threw a Molotov cocktail at me ten minutes from my house and miraculously I live. My girlfriend's father is brain-damaged and blind because terrorists shot him on the vehicle. My girlfriend's brother was murdered when a terrorist entered his "yeshiva" and planned to shoot everyone. Another girlfriend's father was brutally stabbed to death. A terrorist entered tvillage and murdered half a family. The head of an 18-year-old girl was beheaded as she walked through the woods. These are my brothers, and they are all citizens. You can choose to ignore it as an influencer, but this reality exists. This is my westbank.

@rudi4250

3 жыл бұрын

I also come from outside. You cannot understand that people tend to take the side of the weaker party. The attacks and deaths you report are sad and there is no doubt about that.On the other hand, you live in an area that according to international law does not belong to Israel, no matter what Trump says and no matter how many Israeli soldiers protect you. Using mathematics for the dead is a simplification, but if you do it nevertheless, there are almost 100 dead Palestinians for every dead Israeli.

Trump says walls are the way

@LoriCor-

4 жыл бұрын

Try to get into Schengen illegally. :)

This is a big departure from your usual videos, nonetheless it's cool to see you trying something different! I think it's sad that you are using your platform as an influencer to peddle a message with no balance. As far as I can see you took everything your Palestinian interviewees said without challenge. Is the situation between Israel and Palestine fucked up, yeah. However israel is the ONLY state in the middle East where peoples of white, Arab, black ethnicities live together in relative harmony. It is the ONLY state where religious freedoms are enshrined within the fundamental founding documents of the state. Israel has arabs, Muslims sitting within the Knesset. The west bank and Gaza strip are administered by governments which are, and have been for some time, absolutely set against a two state solution, and have supported terrorist attacks against Israeli civilians. Does this justify the use of force by the Israelis in all circumstances, no it does not. Does the behaviour of settlers contravene international law, yes. But you can't have it both ways. If the settlements are not Israeli territory, then the 'crimes' committed on that territory do not fall within the Israeli legal system. If they are Israeli territory, and thus the crimes do fall within the Israeli legal system then what exactly is the problem with the settlements? (For context, I do not believe that settlement building is acceptable in its current guise.) You criticise a 'zionist' ideology but fail to consider and criticise the extreme Islamic ideology which has led to brutal acts against Israeli civilians also. I'm saddened to see you're promoting the BDS movement, who's leaders are on camera as stating they want to destroy the state of Israel, drive out the inhabitants (Jews) and take back the land. I'd urge you to look more deeply into the BDS movement and the nuances of the situation. It is difficult to tell from the film how much research or knowledge you have on the subject.

@sma91dc78

4 жыл бұрын

Gotta agree with this, does seem like nate doesnt have the full context of this old and painful conflict, I urge people to not take a side in this conflict, so many mistakes and atrocities committed by both sides

@philzambo

4 жыл бұрын

The Israeli government are insidious.

@clydehoho9240

4 жыл бұрын

Found the American 😂

@emc8366

4 жыл бұрын

@@clydehoho9240 British actually, but nice use of critical thinking to address my reasoned arguments instead of attacking the person making the argument. Oh wait.

Palestine IS free all they need to do is quit hating Israel. We love Israel

Feel really bad to see so much hate. Israel calls its self Gods Chosen people . I doubt if God sees that he wouldn’t have made different nationalities. Israel land grabs from Palestinians is not gods will. He’s angry probably shaking his head in grief to see what cruelty to the Palestinians. The Palestinians need their freedom and be recognized as state. Israel should not have any say it’s not their country.Gaza and WestBank belong to the Palestinians not Israel. Leave them alone they are innocent human beings.