PERSONAL RANKING: English voices (Disney heroines | 19 voices)

Finally found time and motivation to pull together another ranking! This time for my childhood versions ^^
Sorry if some of the comments aren't long enough on the screen, I tried to make the clips rather long but I forgot to take into account that some people might be slow readers! So I do apologize if that's the case :(
Also, let's ignore the UGLY cutouts of both Anna and Anastasia...
-
© Disney.
I'm not making profit from this video.

Пікірлер: 27

  • @meliae.
    @meliae.3 жыл бұрын

    First of all, the editing is so eye-catching and pretty! *-* To me, some English voices seem to be perfectly polished and schematic despite their pretty tones (if that makes sense). Tara is a ball and chain amongst other ladies, she's probably the only one that I dislike. As for Cindy, some years ago I used to think that neoteric sound works better on her, but to some extent, there's a thin line - for example, EU-PT and Polish 12' (I'm not a big fan). My main disagreement has to be Judy, she's got a beautiful voice, but that perfection and linearity of hers bothers me.a little bit - every bit of her performance is foreseeable, unfortunately. Kristen has that attractive quirkiness, however it may sound x), she's a ball of fire! 💕 And Auli'i - the States couldn't have chosen a better Moana, she's so purely crystalline with an exotic vibe to it.

  • @Elysianyt

    @Elysianyt

    3 жыл бұрын

    Thank you so much! 💕 Agreed on Cinderella (assuming you're talking about Ilene's rendition of the character), as I said, I can picture her to have that kind of voice, but there's a limit. I understand your point on Judy - she was the only one that moved up on the list from a relatively low spot - but I think her voice really does work on Pocahontas. Glad we agree on Kristen and Auli'i! ^^

  • @fandedisney1020
    @fandedisney10203 жыл бұрын

    KZread send me that you post a video one week later! Good video

  • @ClaudiaBronte
    @ClaudiaBronte3 жыл бұрын

    Wow, we almost disagree on everything here xD But since there are too many disagreements I'll just say I'm glad to see Judy that high, she's childhood, along with Mary Costa's Aurora and Liz as Odette, and I really love her, as well as the others

  • @Elysianyt

    @Elysianyt

    3 жыл бұрын

    Wow, was not expecting that - I thought my opinions were rather "common" 😂 Anyways, glad we agree on a few! And thank you 💕

  • @Julie-jy5cj
    @Julie-jy5cj4 ай бұрын

    Cendrillon Pocahontas Anastasia Ariel Blanche - Neige Mulan Jasmine Anna

  • @johnkara1010
    @johnkara1010 Жыл бұрын

    Adriana Caselotti Tara Strong Amy Adams Paige O’Hara Susan Egan Ilene Woods Mary Costa Jodi Benson Heidi Mollenhauer Idina Menzel Julie Fowlis Kristen Bell Tami Tappan-Damiano Liz Callaway Anika Noni Rose Lea Salonga Mandy Moore Judy Kuhn Auli’i Cravalho

  • @Meirenyu
    @Meirenyu3 жыл бұрын

    After seeing how much you love Giselle, I didn't expect Amy Adams to be so low - but I guess character is different to voice. But I agree with her placement, Amy Adams is probably a big part of why I don't like Giselle (she's perfectly fine & so sweet in 2D-form). Agree about Paige & Susan too! I've never really liked the sound of their singing voices. I really liked your comment for Idina, it was so sweet - even if I'm not a fan it's sad that she's become the one that everyone loves to hate 😔 haha no the cutout of Anna is cute! Anika Noni Rose, love her, and couldn't agree more with what you said about her being underappreciated. Something that instantly made me respect her that much more was when she wrote to Disney criticising that Tiana's design changed in Wreck-It-Ralph. I wasn't sure where you'd placeLea because for some reason she's not very beloved in our community - but glad to see you high, I'm 'protective' of her 😅 This editing has got to be one of my favourites from you! will you make other language rankings? ☺️

  • @Elysianyt

    @Elysianyt

    3 жыл бұрын

    I wouldn't say I *love* Giselle haha - one of the reasons for her being my favorite heroine, is the fact of every other female character being a princess 😂 Anyways, you'd be right saying voice doesn't equal character (though I do love Amy Adams 💔). I guess I get protective over Idina the way you do over Lea haha - I'm not Idina's biggest fan either but the hate is so unnecessary... The cutout itself is fine, it's the awful way it's been cut out that looks bad 😅 I'm glad I'm not the only one who loved Anika! She's literally an amazing person. Thank you so much! 💕 At the moment I'm working on one for Baltic voices (Latvian, Estonian and Lithuanian in one) ^^

  • @Julie-jy5cj
    @Julie-jy5cj Жыл бұрын

    Cendrillon Ariel Pocahontas Tiana Mulan Esméralda Anastasia Elsa

  • @SpinelSun
    @SpinelSun3 жыл бұрын

    My favourites have always been Heidi, Anika and Kristen so I'm happy to see them get some love. Specially Heidi, she's my number one, there is just something so hypnotising and mesmerising about her voice to me

  • @jaisajosh8310
    @jaisajosh83103 жыл бұрын

    I adore your editing firstly. And it was a very interesting ranking to watch! I agree with you 100% about Idina, Lea, Liz, Mandy and Kristen. I don’t think I’ll put Auli’i this high, despite being such a good voice properly talking, she is not among my favorites. Probably because of the character, which lacks a bit of originality or fantasy to me. (But the movie is amazing) I am so sad to see Ilene, Susan and Paige this low!!! 😭 Of course I respect your judgment ahah but they would be waaaay higher with me. Anyway, love it !

  • @Elysianyt

    @Elysianyt

    3 жыл бұрын

    Thank you so much! ❤ Happy to see we agree on so many! Auli'i is one of my favorite character voices ever haha but we all have our different opinions! :) Paige was originally higher, but mostly because of Belle being my favorite princess... I do love all three but compared to others they just don't "do the thing" for me :(

  • @princessmina2920
    @princessmina29203 жыл бұрын

    At least I'm not alone with the Tara as Twilight Sparkle! Personally, I definitely prefer her there than Melody. I absolutely adored this ranking and I agree with all your opinions and rankings!

  • @Elysianyt

    @Elysianyt

    3 жыл бұрын

    Thank you so much! 😄

  • @Julie-jy5cj
    @Julie-jy5cj Жыл бұрын

    Raiponce Mégara Jasmine Mélodie Blanche-Neige Anna

  • @Julie-jy5cj
    @Julie-jy5cj2 жыл бұрын

    Belle Raiponce Mégara Mélodie Elsa

  • @jennykefalas3256
    @jennykefalas3256 Жыл бұрын

    Adriana Caselotti Tara Strong Amy Adams Paige O'Hara Susan Egan Ilene Woods Mary Costa Jodi Benson Heidi Mollenhauer Idina Menzel Julie Fowlis Kristen Bell Tami Tappan-Damiano Liz Callaway Anika Noni Rose Lea Salonga Mandy Moore Judy Kuhn Auli'i Cravalho

  • @johnkara1010
    @johnkara1010 Жыл бұрын

    Jodi Benson Heidi Mollenhauer Idina Menzel Julie Fowlis Kristen Bell Tami Tappan-Damiano Liz Callaway Anika Noni Rose Lea Salonga Lea Salonga Mandy Moore Judy Kubn Aulii Cravalbo

  • @vickykaramanis7120
    @vickykaramanis712010 ай бұрын

    Adriana Caselotti Tara Strong Amy Adams Paige O'Hara Susan Egan Ilene Woods Mary Costa Jodi Benson Heidi Mollenhauer Idina Menzel Julie Fowlis Kristen Bell Tami Tappan Damiano Liz Callaway Anika Noni Rose Lea Salonga Mandy Moore Judy Kuhn Auli'i Cravalho

  • @YHTheGamer
    @YHTheGamer3 жыл бұрын

    Your editing is as always mesmerising and neat! Idk about you but maybe I will put Paige just a little higher as her voice gives me a lot of goosebumps but since I share her as the same favourite princess as you, I wouldn't be too mad at all. But I do kinda disagree Susan, Ilene and Mary's position:( Opinions are opinions. Nah you are wrong about the cutouts. They still look pretty good at first glance! The ones that I truly agree will be Idina, Liz, Lea, Mandy and Judy so 5/19 fully agreed, not too different at all! Not too sure about Auli'i on first though, she is the best Moana out of all dubs but maybe a while later her voice isn't too nostalgic and magical anymore imo. Your videos as always will never get me bored:) More of this kind of videos and you will sure get 1K in a year time!

  • @Elysianyt

    @Elysianyt

    3 жыл бұрын

    Thank you so much! ❤ I wanted to put Paige higher but I don't like her on Belle whatsoever 😭 Glad we agree on quite a bit! I'll defend Auli'i to the death if I need to lol I just love her so much - but I guess my opinion was a little biased on her 😅 That's so encouraging to here! Thanks! 💕

  • @juliapakarinen7956
    @juliapakarinen79563 жыл бұрын

    Why I haven't commented on this before? I like both Idina's and Paige's speaking parts, but singing-wise I don't see them as their characters. However, your comment about Idina's Elsa made me appreciate her work a little more. Because of this ranking I realized that I have rooted for Ilene and Susan mostly for nostalgic reasons, but they really don't fit their characters that much. Mary has a wonderful voice as its own, but I just have never seen her as Aurora. That's why I have always watched BATB, Hercules and Sleeping Beauty in my own motherlanguage (Finnish). I think our voices for these characters are more fitting. Heidi and Julie belong to my favorites, and I find them really underrated. I would have put Anika, Kristen and Liz a little higher, but I completely agree with your comments. I am glad you like Tami and Judy so much as well. Lea is a diamond, of course (no pun intended). Somehow I guessed who is your number one, and I think this place for her is completely justified. Thanks for the great ranking! =)

  • @storymaker1004
    @storymaker10043 жыл бұрын

    Pretty editing! I'm not sure how I feel about English voices, as most of them sound so perfect that it has become boring to me. Agree so much on Snow White, to me she sounds really annoying tbh, but she does portray the character well. Biggest disagreement: Idina, She's a really good singer but I just don't like her voice (not because it's a "trend" but because it's just not my taste). Overall we seem to quite agree. Some I'd place a little higher/lower, but then we're talking about 1 place or smth

  • @morianarnia9356

    @morianarnia9356

    3 жыл бұрын

    I disagree about Snow. Her voice is not annoying at all. It's actually really pleasant. Why do people hate on Snow for some reason (voice, character etc)?

  • @storymaker1004

    @storymaker1004

    3 жыл бұрын

    @@morianarnia9356 I don't hate Snow as a character at all, I actually grew up with her and I really like her. Her VOICE on the other hand sounds, to me, very high pitched and annoying tbh. She has the skills but not the voice itself IMO, you know what I mean?

  • @Julie-jy5cj
    @Julie-jy5cj3 жыл бұрын

    L'Angleterre ( English ) Gabrielle et John Gabriella et Alejandro L'anglais New-Yorkais ( English American ) Prue et Jack L''anglais Alaskaine ( English Alaska ) Margaret et Andrew L'Écosse ( Scottish English ) Monica et Chandler L'Irlande ( Irlandese English ) Ursula et Georges