Incredible ranking and you said such sweet words about Jana! It really shows how much you admire and love her work! A wonderful hommage!

@karenling2106

3 жыл бұрын

batman soul of the dragon on digital and bluray january 17th

I'm not even germany but Jana voice is just too beautiful. It is very sweet yet mature, and yes her vibrato unrivaled.

Hey, great ranking, and I love this “new” editing :) Of course, I mostly agree and your number one is my number one too x) A few of German voices are my number one (Belle ’91, Poca and Tiana). :)

@jaisajosh8310

6 жыл бұрын

Diddykun6 Thanks a lot! I’m glad you like this editing, I used it for my Alternative Voices video, and I had the idea of using it for this vid too :) I’m glad you share your opinion and that we have the same number 1! :D

Well, now that I am speaking the language, everytime I see German ranking I concidere it as a ranking of my dubbs. Overall, we agree! I would put Debby higher, I can see why people don't enjoy her Moana, simply in my mind there is still the voice's shound of young Kiara, young Miriam and Melody, I don't have the heart to place her lower. I would also put Alexandra higher, let's say that she is my number 1! Ich liebe Alexandra!! However what can I say about Jana? The fantastic, the incredible Jana, she is perfect!! Great ranking and I like this new editing!! ❤❤❤❤❤❤

@jaisajosh8310

6 жыл бұрын

Anastasia Pat I also speak a bit German since I practice it at college :) It’s even better when you understand the language I think! I understand what you mean, I’m not that attached to other Debby’s roles so it doesn’t help for me liking her Moana. Alexandra is so amazing, a true legend of German dubs. My heart will always belong to Jana

@natasharomanov7565

6 жыл бұрын

Jaisa Josh You're welcome, honey!! That's very interesting!! I agree with you, I believe the same :3

Oh, I really LOVE you video. Your editing is magnificent! And I really agree with your opinion, specially with Jasmin, Cassandra, Caroline and Jana! Your comments are perfect, it's clear you've put a lot of effort in them! And I love how you talked about the singer's diction, most people don't talk about it and it's a very important thing when it comes to dubbing imo. Great job!

@jaisajosh8310

6 жыл бұрын

Magdalena Jasmén Thank you so much, really, it’s very nice to hear. :) I tried to make my comments the most precise & personal possible, I’m glad it paid off for you! I’m glad you like the editing! And I’m glad we agree on some characters. Yes, diction is very important to me, it makes the language more beautiful so it adds a plus to the dub. :)

Maria Milde is my ultimate aurora favorite ❤ I'm glad that you love her too. But yes Jana deserves it, she is so fitting in everything she does and her talent is unbelievable :)

@jaisajosh8310

6 жыл бұрын

Valeria Roa Rizo Thank you very much. I’m glad we agree !!

Great video again, it's a good idea to use the editing of your video of Alternative voices, it's simple, different and efficient :) I'm glad you love the language too and that you don't say like some people that it's an agressive and ugly language because they associate it to Hitler^^ Of course I agree with your number 1 and everything you wrote about her it was perfect and true. My favorite role of her would be Belle I think because it's the role where she provides both speaking and singing and as you said, the role where she has the best connection with the character. So after I don't know what could be my least favorite of her since she's perfect all the time ;) Totally agree with the last place (and the bottom 3 actually), and infact the only German voice I dislike. She could have been great but her attitude ruins everything, like if she wants to push Aladdin from the carpet^^ I was also disappointed by Debby as Moana (though she's one of my favorite voices of Melody). It's a shame because Lina Larissa Strahl the speaking voice is an awesome singer so I don't understand why Disney remplaced her for the singing because she was judged "not good enough". When I listen to her in her own songs, I can't believe Debby was better than her, of course 15 years after TLM2, she doesn't have the same freshness^^ I would just put Jasmin and Cassandra higher but as you said German voices are mostly amazing so after a certain place, the number doesn't mean anything anymore, I agree with rest though :) Cool you made a mention for Nena as Peter Pan's solist, she's great here, but I'm not fond of her Kayley that I find messy, weak and lifeless. Thank you for not describing Pia as "mature and tomboyish" voice just because she has a husky voice. As you said the maturity is in the attitude (Jana Werner doesn't have a husky and deep voice but she brought the maturity and the personnality Belle needs so there's nothing wrong or unfitting). I love the fact as you said that she's a great mix of calm and power, she's one of the best to cumulate both. And when I listen to her Rapunzel, I think "Rapunzel is 18, not less, not more". In fact she was 18 when she dubbed Rapunzel and makes her sound so authentic and human, the same for her Anna. Because when some Rapunzel or Anna voices just go for "it's a happy exicted girl, let's go crazy and sound like a baby", the result is just too much and parodical (Maria Ylipää, looking at you). Sorry for the long comment, but excellent job again :D

@jaisajosh8310

6 жыл бұрын

Stru Bel Thank you very much, and I’m really glad you like my editing here! About German; associating it to Hitler is extremely stupid, sadly many people do this (in my college for example) and I’ve always been alone to prefer German to Spanish, but well I love this language, I can’t helpt it. And I understand a bit of since I’m studying it at college :) I completely agree with you about Jana & Sabine ! She had potential... It was really hard to place the voices from Jasmin to Jana, I love them all so much! About Pia, I’m very glad you agree here I know she’s your favourite and I tried to describe her as precise as possible :) Her voice itself isn’t mature, it’s a bit husky, she’s mature in her attitude, I wanted to precise that. I really love her, she’s very beautiful and I’m glad of the place I gave her. I also prefer Nena as Jane, her Kayley to me is great but a bit forced, as Jana soloist she’s fabulous. Thanks a lot for your nice comment!!!

@strubel946

6 жыл бұрын

Pia will still be high when I will re-upload my German ranking (because I will re-upload my old rankings like Portuguese, Arabic or Norwegian where I didn't include Moana like I did with Finnish, and also because I ameliorated a bit the editing with the time) but she's not the 1st anymore, I have another, they are all amazing (from Jasmin to Jana as you said) but I've changed some places with the time, like you said in your comment about Willemijn, it's the same for me :) I agree about Nena, when I listenned to her Kayley I said "Where's the amazing singer of 99 Luftballons ?" Comeback to French : Quand tu dis "college", tu fais bien référence au collège ? Car en anglais c'est un faux-ami vu que ça correspond à l'université :)

@jaisajosh8310

6 жыл бұрын

Stru Bel Oh okay I see, I think I will re-upload my rankings too, but not now. I’m glad you love Willemijn as much as I do! Haha the famous 99 luftballons!! Non non je suis à l’université haha sinon je crois que collège correspond à... middle school ? J’aurai probablement dit qqch comme ça, mais je parle bien de la fac

Caroline Vasicek is speaking &singing Ariel in austrian german and singing voice of mulan in german

L'Allemagne ( German ) Norma et Juan Isadora et Léonardo Nora et Tom L'Autriche ( Austrian German ) et ( German ) Julie et Ian Alex et Ramon

Cendrillon Ariel Pocahontas Tiana Esméralda Mulan Anastasia Elsa

Aurore Ariel Jasmine Pocahontas Mégara Belle Elsa

Tiana Ariel Pocahontas Cendrillon Mulan Anastasia Anna

Beautiful Ranking! Disagree with Cassandra Steen, she is my favorite Tiana voice. And I totally agree with your number one! Jana is my love forever...

@jaisajosh8310

6 жыл бұрын

The Korean Disney Princess Thanks a lot!!! I’m very glad we agree on number. 1 :)

Jana❤❤❤

Aurore Mégara Esméralda Jasmine Mélodie Elsa

Sabine is a bit shouty Debby is better than that Naomi sounds beautiful but sometimes she slips into a Kermit register Jasmin has the sass Julia is good, but the passion is missing. Susanne is a cute Snow White and Shanti but a bit pitchy Cassandra is my favorite Tiana voice, so to see her here hurts a little bit Ute is a bit shouty for my taste, but Esmeralda is her best role I love Alexandra so much she fits every role! Pia is great as Rapunzel and Anna Eva sounds beautiful and dreamy just like Ilene Woods Willemijin is great as Elsa, fierce and queen like. Love her! Caroline is one of my favorite Ariel and Belle voices. She fits both but I think she really shines as Mulan Maria is a good voice for Aurora, she makes her sound like someone in love and also like a siren YAS QUEEN! Jana Werner is my absolute favorite German voice. Her Belle is amazing, also love her as Odette. Her Thumbelina sounds so cute but I think she really shines as Anastasia. She sounds so polished there.

Sabine Hettlich Debby Van Dooren Naomi Van Dooren Jasmin Tabatabai Julia Scheeser Susanne Tremper Cassandra Steen Ute Lemper Alexandra Wilcke Pia Allgaier Eva Ingeborg-Scholz Willemijn Verkaik Nena Caroline Vasicek-Pfeifer Maria Milde Jana Werner

Raiponce Barbie Raiponce Aurore Jasmine Mégara Anna

I love your video ;) I disagree with Debby (cause I love her melody so much :) ) and way higher Alexandra Wickle (she is my second fav voice) I think I would put lower Ute LEMPER and Eva INGEBORG We have the same number 1 ;) (I love her so much)

@jaisajosh8310

6 жыл бұрын

Lemoine Julie Thanks a lot! Glad to hear! I’m not that interesting in Melody’s voices sadly. So I didn’t include her, but I think she’s a definitely better Melody than Moana ! I adore Alexandra and I wanted to put her higher, but I just adore German voices, from Meg to Jana they are all amazing to me. I’m glad we share the same number one though! :D

@julielemoine5029

6 жыл бұрын

I understand for Melody but for me she is the first german voice I listen and she makes me love german voice and see it' s not just good for villain ;) completely agree that she is better at melody ;) I also understand cause I love them so much too ;) Jana is so good clearly she could be in my top 10 (and maybe 5) for all of her character :)

@jaisajosh8310

6 жыл бұрын

Lemoine Julie Yes, German dubbings are good at casting villains and heroes too, they’re masters in this. I’m glad we agree :)

Ariel Mélodie Cendrillon Anastasia Mulan Anna