For the skirt issues everyone is clamouring about. I just wanted to get this out of the way the problem with the Skirt morphing is in it's Makotos animation screwing the dress. Not the model or skirt. It has nothing to do with whatever political correctness people are assessing. The issue with the skirt is due to the Tartarus and Event animations The actual skirt model is fine. The animation screws the model up which stretches it. And Atlus used a process that baked the animation to the characters. Which means Makoto animation screws the skirts since he likes doing the pelvic thrust. If you look at the placeholder victory animation other than the leg clipping, the skirt length is fixed to the appropriate length because it's not using Makotos animation. If you look at the over world the animation looks fine because the team ported Yukari's following you open world animations in as replacement and mix match to make the skirt work in the over world. The problem with Tartarus is the mod team is forced to use Makoto animation without having to break things. And the current process to change the animation is too much. Makoto has 100+ animation alone in Tartarus unlike the over world animations. The animation data also has sound ques something a proprietary plugin is required to make it work. Replacing animation also means losing footstep or slash animation sounds. Notice the griddy animation there is no walking sound that's the issue with the system and workflow. The plugin to make this work is expensive and requires proprietary license and the team only has 1 person on the team that has access to this. And currently the workflow to get this all done is too much for one person and there isn't a faster method to fix this. We can't use Yukari's animation to fix the skirt in Tartarus due to Makotos gameplay mechanics work and it makes no sense to use a bow animation for Kotone as people keep suggesting to reuse yukari tartarus animation. All these tech limitations is causing a huge headache for the team and this probably the last time I will mention about this.

@LillieMakesVideos

20 күн бұрын

@@kingddd what does broken skirt physics have to do with political correctness

@AlvinAnakMudaGameandfun

20 күн бұрын

@@kingddd i don’t mind waiting until it’s fixed, no matter how long it takes. You can’t rush and expect the best to came out of it

@robertbernard7844

20 күн бұрын

As a guy who casually fiddles with MMD models, I hate it when outfit "physics" are baked into the model as animations. I can understand why they did that, though. Using real time physics would probably mess with way too much stuff and result in multiple headaches to deal with (Cyberpunk 2077, GTA Trilogy Definitive, any fighting game that uses 3D models, just to name a few). Also, skirt physics allow the possibility of skirt clipping, which in turn means lots of unintentional panty shots. No one wants that in a game where people shoot themselves in the head to bring out their inner deities.

@ZPu95

20 күн бұрын

@@LillieMakesVideos Pray the mod doesn't get abandon because of November results because this creator does not seem well at all...

@user-zl1vf4me1p

20 күн бұрын

@@ZPu95 wym november results?

There is some uncanny valley with the model and poses but damn the modders are really making sure that they get the details fit with remake.

@hundvd_7

21 күн бұрын

It's definitely the skirt If that is fixed, everything will look significantly better

@danielcampos8046

21 күн бұрын

The face... specifically, the mouth. Notice, when there is the close-up for All out Attack - 3:15

@cafequente8252

18 күн бұрын

​@@danielcampos8046Makoto's face features clearly didn't fit FEMC lol

@wrentic

16 күн бұрын

It always modders who saves the day

@johnathan5906

15 күн бұрын

There's only so much these modders can do. It's impressive how much they have done. I wish Atlus would have put FeMC in the game. But at least these modders are adding her.

The day the skirt gets fixed is the day I get p3r on pc to download the mod

@thebestastronot

21 күн бұрын

It can be fixed, it will just take a lot of time because only one person has the plugin necessary to be able to fix it. I think.

@Raven-vt2fo

21 күн бұрын

real. only reason i dont use it is because of the skirt with the legs going through it

@Ashez418

21 күн бұрын

@@Raven-vt2fo I just don't like the bump at the top of the skirt, hate that, also I currently play on playstation so I have no reason to play p3r on pc other than mods

We need to do something with the edgy pocket hand pose!

@mochie9360

21 күн бұрын

Just make it a pocket

@newquestion15

21 күн бұрын

hands at the back, probably?

@jadebayoba7073

19 күн бұрын

Like Yukari?

@nil2819

17 күн бұрын

I think she's more like a 'hand on hip' gal tho (I mean femc)

Is that mfin Pull the Trigger?? The best battle theme?? Damn I’d actually buy this mod lmao

@legithuman5486

21 күн бұрын

yes, _Mosq made a great remix of it for this mod

Kotone fans are a different breed

A lot of progress has been made! The fans are doing work. Thanks for showcasing the changes!

The models and especially the dialogue splicing could use some refinement but for a fan project on a game that I would assume doesn’t have particularly good mod support, this looks really good so far.

5:04 Kotone: Nah, I’d win.

Loving all the music remixes so far. It would be interesting if the music options were togglable by changing in game costumes rather than the mod menu

it's insane that she's not just in the game by default

@jujublue4426

21 күн бұрын

Would've been too much work with the anime sequences and the different SL fully voiced, but I would've bought a FEMC version of the game or a DLC if they made one

@Artemi22

21 күн бұрын

guess it would've been too much work. after all, atlus is a small indie studio and their games aren't priced at 70$

@camirock17

21 күн бұрын

And they don't charge for skins and season pass at 100usd ​@@Artemi22

@Oliver-ld3ei

21 күн бұрын

@@Artemi22that also totally does not have access to Sega funding and manpower lol.

@skywoofyt5375

21 күн бұрын

​@@Oliver-ld3ei I mean, it was exactly because of the limited funding Sega gave them that they couldn't make a FEMC route, and that exact reason id also why they had to pack the Answer as a DLC cause otherwise they wouldn't be able to fund it.

Feels like it’s an unspoken rule that when a female MC is being modded into a game on a dedicated scale like this it WILL have a Hatsune Miku costume in it lol

@Sonic171K

20 күн бұрын

They should give her the P4D Miku costume too.

Yeah gendered audio needs a lot of work but besides that things looking good so far

Holy shit femc Japanese voice is so cutee Aeeee

Kotone-chan will never be forgotten. Who did her Japanese voice? Nice job.

@gren_3352

21 күн бұрын

I think its her voice from PQ2

@AlvinAnakMudaGameandfun

21 күн бұрын

@@gren_3352 thanks!

@slicknickkcin

21 күн бұрын

inoue marina

@AlvinAnakMudaGameandfun

21 күн бұрын

@@slicknickkcin thank you!🙏

Even after Makoto is literally removed from existence, he's still causing problems.

It’s driving me insane that some elements of the UI and menu are still blue. It’s driving me nuts (not talking about the SP or theurgy bars)

@anziepanzie

21 күн бұрын

i think it’s also driving the modders insane too lmao

I like how the first school day suddenly turned lesbian.

This is crazy good! And as someone who is fiddling in a sort of modding too, I completely understand the current problems with her skirt animations. Way to go so far, love FeMC. ⭐

im sure modeling is extremely hard and this would probably be difficult but having a violet/sumi yoshizawa costume would be very cool !! especially since shes part of the main game of p5r and her design was originally intended for a female protagonist

@leohernandez8751

18 күн бұрын

I mean since Joker and Violet are seen as the de facto pair for P5R, it would be a neat reference to that pair if to go along with Makoto getting Joker’s outfit, Hamuko can get Violet’s costume to match!

the splicing is actually pretty good!!!! so happy that its not ai. also, with the dialogue, there is so much accidental yuri happening. absolutely love it!

@germanpalomaresdelpalomar5883

21 күн бұрын

You love yuri between highschoolers? Ehem...

@ShadySpice187

21 күн бұрын

@@germanpalomaresdelpalomar5883 Because straight relationships between highschoolers are any better, grow up!

@frikizone2.03

21 күн бұрын

AI would make it much easier and better

@LillieMakesVideos

21 күн бұрын

@@frikizone2.03 it really wouldn't

@soulnha

21 күн бұрын

@@frikizone2.03no it wouldn’t

But great mods and efforts! Thank you👏👏👏

20:18 Hands down best AOA in the series.

Amazing work! All of the custom portraiture and remixes work fantastically. Keep it up!

All things lead to a Miku reference

@Jocavimo01

20 күн бұрын

The Miku Is The Means By Which All Is Revealed

@jadebayoba7073

19 күн бұрын

Miku has been canon on Persona for a while

@icycappuccino

19 күн бұрын

miku exists in P4D

the rock cover is so sooo good

Maaaaan, GillStudio's covers are amazing, give them a try, I love The Battle For Everyone's Souls, they deserve more attention, thanks for add some songs

i guess it's time to play this femc mod, amazing!

Rule 1: never underestimate femc fans

Whoever came up with that silly bust idea is a genius.

Thanks for the video!

Modders doing God's work, bless you all modders 🙏

I find it weird to see Kotone holding her najinata with one hand.

I miss FEMC so much in this game 🥹😍✨

So nice to see all this progress! Someday I might end up buying Reload after all!

the fact that this is so perfect amazes me like im in awe

For the gendered audio, and I know you've probably thought of this, but for most of the lines, couldn't you record or add the voices in from P3P?

@brkli1485

21 күн бұрын

it could work for the japanese voices, but the english actors have been replaced in reload

@noterobrine9921

21 күн бұрын

@@brkli1485 Good point, but it's a small price to pay for salvation...

@Riolu1209

21 күн бұрын

@@noterobrine9921 I'd hate to suggest this for ethical reasons, but did they considered using AI? If not that's totally understandable

@ArtisticCeleste

21 күн бұрын

@@Riolu1209 Pretty sure they already said they wouldn't-would likely harm the mod's reputation too, and potentially kill any goodwill from people higher up down the line. If the mod gets popular enough who knows who could see it after all. If a VA for example saw the mod what would they think if they saw the modders using an AI of their voice? What could've potentially lead to them either simply complimenting/voicing support could be soured.

@Riolu1209

21 күн бұрын

@@ArtisticCeleste yeah I thought so

5:50 aww kotone in womder phantom outfit 🥹🥹🥹

YEAH 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

Looking forward to seeing the dialogue changes when the answer comes out.

gonna be honest, the fact we are getting G stuiod covers is so cool

She is precious

cant wait for this update

The portrait of the face when in a in game talking scene still looks a bit off, but aside from that it’s looking good!

YES! THIS IS A PERSONA'S FAN DREAM!! COME TRUE❤!!!

Great mods effort

nice work, even watching this I hardly believe this

I'll buy the game when this mod is 100% complete

Demolition coming back is the best part about this mod

I really love all the stuff you've done so far. It's so nice the dialouge got adjusted to femc. And it's great that we have so many options to choose from. I'd like to ask, can anyone try and make a bust up portrait for femc and send it to you? And if so, are there any conditions how it needs to be? (size, colouring, format)

This is why I love kotone fans sm

She buff 💪

I still can't get over he poses on in game cutscenes im crying 😭

@jadebayoba7073

19 күн бұрын

Make her do a Pose 28 on cutscenes plz and thx u xoxo

@irenesleatherpants

19 күн бұрын

@@jadebayoba7073 And then some Jojo poses pls and thanks

your work is astounding ! the gendered audio is a little strange since you could definitely hear the difference but hey, better than nothing. and i suppose there is way to improved it.

this mod continues to be incredibly impressive, definitely going to buy the game and download this once gendered audio gets some improvements

I haven't been following this project closely but amazed at how far it's come since I last saw. This comment section is strange though. it just a free mod calm down EDIT: Yukari denying the gay allegations is hilarious

Would it be easier to just force the player to use trousers in tartarus

would be cool to have her fr

1:40 _Aww, the wink is cute._ *_I think they still need to work a little on the drawings of the bust, the eyes are too big so she looks like the "Overly attached girlfriend" meme._* _Beyond that, I notice that everything is fine, even better than fine; except perhaps the poses she makes sometimes, like when she sits down, she does it like a man, and the bugs with her legs and skirt._

Really dig the music for the first dungeon during japaense voices section and then the school life music showcasing the portrait update. Are those from P3P? All of this just looks awesome. great job!!

As the fence of p3 I can approve

C'est si bon que j'ai commencé à parler français. Jokes aside, it looks really good, kudos!

Hearing the rock covers of the battle music makes me want a Strikers style game with the Shadow Operators

The skirt will be fixed eventually, could there be a no skirt option in tartarus in the meantime if its too distracting? Im more interested in the social links than the skirt fix

Best believe one this hits its final officially updated release. (Publicly) I'mma happily buy Reload on my PC even if I already have the PS5 version. The work and dedication put into the project is worth doing so! Side note, while the other remxes DO sound great in their own respective way. I feel it's going to be hard, personally, to top the work put in by _Mosq. They've stunned me every step of the way and I continue to listen to them slmost daily. Again though, praise to the other artists for tgeir contributions as well!

I’m curious about the cutscenes. Will you reanimate it and put Kotone instead of Makoto or are you going to leave the cutscenes alone or not include them?

The default running is weird but hope to be improved

Are the social links from p3p possible or being looked at at all? Just curious, I know this is the hardest thing and likely the last thing that would be finished.

I’ve found my people. I won’t shut up about her not being in this game.

I so wanna play this

But will you be able to switch between Door-kun and FemC playthroughs without removing the mod? That's my concern.

the fact that people can make new character but not new fuuka hair is blown my mind

P3r if it was peak

@AkameshS

20 күн бұрын

P3r if it was MID

@Sonic171K

20 күн бұрын

@@AkameshSIt’s already mid.

@bu773rkim

20 күн бұрын

​@@AkameshS it's not already?

@AkameshS

19 күн бұрын

@@bu773rkim yes but we don't want it to go even lower now do we

@voltaireentertainment

19 күн бұрын

​@@Sonic171K L take, clears all other versions of Persona 3

I need the mod to be compatible with the not a phase mod😭🙏

@kingddd

18 күн бұрын

it is. Jinx the creator works closely with the FeMC mod to get it working

SHINJI'S SPLICES ARE SO CLEAN WTF

@xxProjectJxx

19 күн бұрын

Eh. The sound-alike doesn't quite nail it, so it's pretty distracting IMO.

👀

The gendered dialogue feels weird... why don't just remove part of the audio lines that feature genders?

@hipersonicc9736

21 күн бұрын

sometimes it feels great though

@nymphia

21 күн бұрын

The dialogue splicing isn't the best but it's still a WIP (also because there's a lot of audio that features the protag's gender)

@JR-rm4nw

21 күн бұрын

@@nymphia I think this is one of the only circumstances where AI voices might be better. Just to say a single word to be spliced into the dialogue.

@Signedcentaur

21 күн бұрын

Based that they're using dialogue splicing though

@elias-tt7vx

21 күн бұрын

​@@JR-rm4nwnah

can someone tell me if the mod ia fully playable or not? can I safely start playing it from beginning to end?

Alright, but why does the phantom suit turn you into Naoto instead of Yoshizawa? 😅

why are some people being so weird in the comments, it's a WIP mod, of course shit isn't going to look that good yet and still use certain animations and such

How about the romance options?

It would be cool for her to have a shujin uniform

yall gave her a miku outfit. we won today

THISRULES

No matter how hard it's been to make this mod, just remember.... This won't be as hard as implementing all the romance routes. XD Looks good though, considering it's drastically more showy than the original I'm surprised at how much you've actually altered. Guess that's just a testament to your abilities. ^^

If they managed to change Mrs. Frisby to Mrs. Brisby in 1982 by taking the b sound from other lines and made it seamless, I'm sure you guys can do the same in 2024.

Why in the original version there's no protagonist girl?

I am wondering. does the romance routes are the same as makoto?

Not using AI 👍

@bigweebshawny4230

19 күн бұрын

These are the times using AI might actually be the better option tbh. Its not taking away from the VAs since its a project that will never be officially released by the studio and the creator of this mod isn't going to heir VAs to re-record the insane amount of dialogue in the game

@midnite59

17 күн бұрын

@@bigweebshawny4230who knows? The VA’s of P3R seem to love their job.

@bigweebshawny4230

17 күн бұрын

@midnite59 I'm sure they do, but I'm also sure they won't do a persona long project for free/price cut and I'm sure a single modder has enough to fund all the cast to do so.

Lol is that how she still attack with her sword ?😂

Is the Mod still in progress? Or is it usable yet

Do you need to buy the normal game? I bought it only on ps :(

Another day of regretting buying this on ps5 😔

The sprinting animation is so silly

No battle panties costume yet? Well take your time, everyone here knows that's the costume they're really looking forward to.

@chino-1291

4 күн бұрын

what theeeeeeeee helllllll

guys whats the song at 3:24 🔥🔥🔥🔥

@kingddd

20 күн бұрын

kzread.info/dash/bejne/gJ-C25uqdLrPcdo.html

@BowtieSpy

12 күн бұрын

@@kingddd THANK YOU 🙏🙏🔥

Looking nice! However the skirt is too long, make it a little bit shorter.

Why is nobody talking about FeMC being removed from this game?

@xxProjectJxx

19 күн бұрын

Because the game has been out for months and most people have moved on.

@irenesleatherpants

19 күн бұрын

​@@xxProjectJxx This mod wouldn't be a happening if people ''moved on''.

@mehhh728

17 күн бұрын

Because its a remake of the OG game cmon its been said like a million times already

8:15 what’s with the eboy ahh dialogue here 😭💀

wish i could romance the MEN 😭😤