update: the part where I was wondering if it was intended, it doesn't seem like it was as per Kasper's choreo kzread.info/dash/bejne/qIp5uc6OgcrNYdI.html (at 1:36). even though they're switching formations, the same leg kicks out. unless it was changed during the process :)

@lesserafimchangedmylife

3 жыл бұрын

Ya ya it might've not been intended, but I observed that part a little bit more after u did in this video, and idk if it's supposed to be that way here but that outer end guys sync up more than the others, the middle end guys also sync up more, and as well as the most inner dancers. It looks like parallel syncing to me but I don't know if that's a thing JSPDF The whole shoulder movements tho are really all over the place, maybe they wanted that part to be more artistic individually? Who knows honestly 😂 Like u said, we just gotta respect itt.

@JeffAvenue

3 жыл бұрын

@@lesserafimchangedmylife haha ya at this point anything could’ve changed during the process

@erention1390

3 жыл бұрын

please react to bambam ribbon

@ineedyoumyheart

3 жыл бұрын

Well you're right, but when I was analyzing it, it seems like they're in sync by mirroring themselves (left side with right side) because both sides does the same but it just looks messy (idk if you understand me haha). In the last course when all of the dancers are together it's in sync and it wasn't so messy anymore

@mangopineapple579

3 жыл бұрын

Seeing it performed ‘clean’ and in sync in Kasper’s makes me appreciate some of the ‘messiness’ in the MV as keeping in with the themes of the song. I interpret the imperfect aspects as purposeful to the whole message 🙂

"Taemin is the only one doing couture" love that.

Taemin: king of the industry

@mukundakrishnan2678

3 жыл бұрын

*LEGEND OF THE INDUSTRY

jeff: this is taemin's best look me: ...but taemin's move era jeff: except for taemin's move era YES WE HAD THE SAME MIND MOVE ERA TAEMIN STAYS UNBOTHERED

@romigimenez

3 жыл бұрын

i know but what about want era??? he was looking GORGEOUS then 😭💕

@shineeng_kriss7520

3 жыл бұрын

@@romigimenez I thought exactly the same! 😍

@jb.i.love6v675

3 жыл бұрын

I honestly love want era first, then Move and Advice but everything Taemin era is just masterpiece

@zhulin2531

3 жыл бұрын

@@romigimenez And Taemin said himself he thought he looked the best in Want area

@STALKER777LK

Жыл бұрын

​@@jb.i.love6v675 yup it's Want era Taemin for me

i think that this dance is not supposed to be all together to kinda of emphasize the “crazy” or “ chaotic” vibe that the mv gives as well if u look at the girls portion as well they seem to be rushing to catch up with taemin as well. i think this is all on purpose. also the dancer all have their different variations of the choreo as well. it did bother me as well at first. i’m a competitive dancer and i’m used to everything being synchronized…so it kinda threw me off too lol

@milys8902

3 жыл бұрын

Totally agree with you lol!

@torr3n

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah that's what I thought as well

@minhtrang9501

3 жыл бұрын

ikrrrrr

@finnlinnsone

3 жыл бұрын

I'm a dancer and studying dance, personally I don't think it's entirely on purpose. I think they had very little time to practice properly considering the difficulty of the choreography. As far as I know the song was finished very recently, a bit little after he changed his hair to what we see in this video. I definitely agree that the dancers are showing their individual colors in their execution, and I love that for them. I just think for a choreography like this they probably should've emphasized synchronization more, but I understand Taemin was due to go to the army right after he finished promoting it so maybe we'll get another performance of Advice in a future live concert 🥰

@dalemynep.1019

3 жыл бұрын

@@finnlinnsone yes absolutely the time limit tht they had must have played a huge part regarding the synchronization of the dancers i agree

I think it was intended. In the hip hop genre, it's less cool to get it right. Taemin is a perfectionist, so if his team was wrong, Taemin would not have been able to accept it. Because he's the one who practices all night to create a perfect stage. And so are his dancers. (His dancers are talented and famous choreographers.)

@Moonwalkmj

3 жыл бұрын

I feel the same !

@TaeminnieLee

3 жыл бұрын

I disagree... he was really pressed for time for Advice. I think it just might have been lack of time to re-film. He kept on saying he didn't know what he was supposed to focus on during this era because his time was so limited. I think it looks amazing regardless and it's just nitpicking of a small section.

@oriented0009

3 жыл бұрын

@@TaeminnieLee I respect your opinion. As a fan of Taemin, I knew his situation well. In the hip hop genre, There are a lot of times when you dance according to your own feelings. Just match the timing of the beginning and the end. Personally, I think formal movements that are tailored to the angle are more inappropriate.(in this song) I felt it after watching all the video clips from the broadcasting company. Especially when I saw the last performance(sbs ingigayo), I was sure. Anyway, that's what I thought. It's not a comment I wrote to argue what's right or not! I'm not good at English, so I can't express it in English anymore anyway.hehe I respect your opinion too :)

@hij2296

3 жыл бұрын

@@oriented0009 I agree, too, I think the unstructured movement has rather increased the coolness. I saw a reaction video of a Korean hip-hop dancer thinking the same thing.

@TaeminnieLee

3 жыл бұрын

@@oriented0009 yeah, I'm not fighting either 💕 I haven't really paid attention to that specific section in different performances, so you might be right! I just thought he might have been busy to the point it couldn't be changed. I know Taemin is a perfectionist so it would make more sense that it's intentional... but he seemed overwhelmed as well, so I didn't want to discard the option that it just might be a mishap! You make a good point though, that if it's the same in other performances (like inki) then it was probably meant to be. Thank you for taking your time to reply to me and being so kind as well 💎 Edit: just to say I love how respectful Shawols are! And for trying to explain their thoughts even in a language they're not fluent in. My first language isn't English either 😅

It is difficult to dance like Taemin and difficult to be Taemin's dancer because he has his own movements so peculiar that they are unconventional to do or see in dancers and thanks to that he has the most unique choreographies, fast, powerful, smooth etc. and with so many artistic details and all with the same level of complexity and ADVICE was no exception. Taemin is a true King Dancer and a complete genre of dance, as well as musically and is more than proven.

i personally think the "messiness" in the second chorus is intentional because if my eyes is not wrong, taemin and the two guys at the end are in sync, then the two guys beside taemin are in sync, and lastly the two remaining guys in the middle of both sides are in sync as well :)

One of korean dancer reviewer also curious about that part, and he guessed it was intended.

@JeffAvenue

3 жыл бұрын

oh ok it wasn't just me then lol

@KamilaDalmate

2 жыл бұрын

What is the name of the channel?

As far as i remember taemin prefer girl dancer when it comes cleanliness maybe, that's why. he said girls are much flowy and smooth than guys. That's why taemin use girls dancer as his back up dancers in move era, i think he only use guys once?

@wirantopora4506

3 жыл бұрын

Taemin is genius as hell

@mariapaulas199

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah, he said before in an interview that he uses his dancers according to the feeling and what the dance needs to represent. So in Move era it was more about sensuality, graceful but powerful movements. I noticed that in Advice, he uses the girls in the beginning where its fast but with more elegant movements, while in the second verse, we can hear a sound similar to a tapping, marking a rhythm with the piano in the background, and there he uses male dancers similar to a march.

He’s not just been busy, he’s been BUSYYYYY. Don’t Call Me era, We Do for Superm (skunk hair), then Shinee Beyond Live, then Atlantis era, then his own Beyond Live and Advice. And a Shinee japanese album that’s yet to be released. And promos and interviews and even a reality show on top of that 😦 at this point the military will be a vacation for him.

Your reactions provide a thesis on dance and movement. You get it. And your presentation is SO complete I feel like I've just attended a master class on music and dance interpretation.

@daysjours

2 жыл бұрын

I agree. HE is the best reactor for dance videos.

taemin is art

@moonlightbae7015

3 жыл бұрын

fr.. He's insane

Also fun fact, Taemin during the shoot of studio choom, he said that the girls were ‘crazy’ they dance really powerful and he felt the energy. Hehe

I MEAN ... TAEMIN IS ANOTHER FULL LEVEL OF DANCING. IT'S HARD TO SYNCHRONIZE A SONG THAT FAST WITH SO MANY DETAILS OF TAEMIN'S UNIQUE MOVEMENTS. THAT'S WHY TAEMIN SAID HE WAS CONCERNED ABOUT EVERYONE COVERING THIS DANCE. I HAVE ALWAYS THOUGHT IT IS HARD TO BE A TAEMIN DANCER BUT THE GIRLS KILLED WITH HIM AS ALWAYS.

20 minute Taemin reaction from Jeff? I’m here for it 😍😌

About the other dancers, I think it's just a matter of individual style. In the case of the guys, you can see a lot of them (especially those who were at the front) doing different gestures and moving their head and legs differently even though the step was the same for everyone. It's kinda off putting at first because you end up noticing more of that than Taemin, but afterwards it's just interesting to watch how each of them dance differently. For the girls, I think they put more weight on synchronization. At points you can see them gesture differently as well, but it's hidden better because they try to keep Taemin in the spotlight. In the last chorus where all of them are dancing, they still dance with slightly different styles, but it still comes off as cleaner because of the number of dancers and the fact that the girls were positioned closer to the center.

I don't think much people talk about this, but the way you edit your reaction videos is just too good 😭😭❤

I agree, I think it just may be individual stylistic choices and how they interpret it because it's not the type of choreo that you can synchronize perfectly. But overall, I thought it looked decent, considering it's hard to dance to Taemin style of dancing!❤

I actually feel that he is so on another level in his dancing and the dancers are trying to keep up. I don’t mean that the dancers aren’t great but Taemin’s movement and rhythmical prowess is just superb. So I agree that the synchronisation is not 100%. Look at his subtle leg movements within the choreography while simultaneously hitting every beat and beautifully expressing the lyricism of the song at the same time in some of the moments in the performance. He is exceptional.

@jeeewhyyypheee

3 жыл бұрын

Taemin really knows every beat of his music and how to execute the moves musically with the tempo

„If there was a concert it’s a finale” Definitely! Taemin’s performances have this grand feel to them, he and his choreographers create incredible spectacles! For me what’s so fascinating about Taemin and his dancing is how perfectly he positions his body literally every given second. Basically whenever you pause the video he always looks better than his dancers. Idk what it is but it’s like the aesthetic of his movements and his body line is just on another level of perfection… Also I noticed it a long time ago how he has this incredible sense of balance. Since I’m not a sucker for synchronization it doesn’t bother me as much when he and his dancers are not perfectly synchronized. In a way I find it even more satisfying cause it emphasizes the fact that he is the soloist and he is the main focus. I love your analysis, it’s always interesting to listen to your points. Thank you for this reaction Jeff!

everytime when it comes to Taemin's songs I always have to pause & rewind the videos more than 1000000x times just to see I his moves clearly and to understand his lyrics well......Taemin is the ACE

Taemin is truly on a another big level

Love your praise for Taemin! TAEMIN IS ONE OF A KIND!

Aaaah I was waiting for this :) I have to say, choreo wise, I loved the Koharu era a lot more than the Kasper era, but this choreo in particular is so on point with the music. I agree with you when you say that every single musicality detail is used and portrayed, it's so great to watch ! And of course Taemin's execution is flawless.

@wirantopora4506

3 жыл бұрын

Ikr

@babylionssirenblack1595

3 жыл бұрын

I also love Koharu era. But Taemin evolves. If we look at him he has reached a different level of artistry this time around. Rough edginess is something he had not emphasized as he was always so soft and fluid as a soloist. For sure he can pull any concept he sets his mind on

@wirantopora4506

3 жыл бұрын

@@babylionssirenblack1595 that is taemin he is always improve everydamn time😶

@belerinah

3 жыл бұрын

@@babylionssirenblack1595 oh don't get me wrong, that's just personal taste in choreo, I am not downgrading Taemin's work nor evolution in any way ! I cherish everything he does and have loved to see him try out new things ever since I became his fan. I always can't wait to see what comes next. He definitely pulls of new things every time without failing his existing identity. Advice is definitely one of my favorites. Anywayyyyy :)

@le_pierrot_rouge

3 жыл бұрын

I think I like both per equal. Koharu really has a very distinctive and eerie style. She has influenced taemin in his dance style but same as kasper I found problems or things I don't really like in some of her choreos. Btw, Kasper style is more hip hop, urban and not so "artistic" in the aspect that Koharu seems to know more how to set the correct mood to the songs she choreographed. I like Koharu style more but until now I have liked the three choreos Kasper has made/helped to do. Advice is probably his best choreo to this day -of the ones I saw, obviously-.

That's why Mcountdown to Taemin in 2021: "The One and Only Dancing King" 👑👑👑

Thank you for your in depth and thoughtful analysis of Taemin's latest masterpiece. As another person commented, it's like attending a master class. I'm glad you acknowledge how busy Taemin was before his enlistment. Like he said, finding Advice at the last moment was like a miracle because he didn't have to postpone the album. He wanted to leave us something to remember him by. (Ive been listening to his Advice album everyday.) Now I'm looking forward to attending dance recitals, musicals, and concerts once again, and Taemin and SHINee are at the top of my list. Take care and good luck with your projects.

Is jeff leaning more into SM's artists because I'm loving it.

how to say you're a legend, without saying you're a legend...

I think for the last few comebacks he got some new dancers because i havent been a big fan of some of them lately, they look messy sometimes. I have always loved his Japanese dancers more. I think they just fit with him so well and are able to keep up with him better.

@sofeels_

3 жыл бұрын

Honestly, same. And I loved his original girl team from Move era better too.

@sehnissmile

3 жыл бұрын

sofeels yes! I really loved the girl with the short hair. Ugh she killed it every time

@_Anastasia__

3 жыл бұрын

Always thought about that when I watched the last comebacks

@le_pierrot_rouge

3 жыл бұрын

Really? In general, I think his actual team have better dancers than his past girl team. But yes his japanese crew is superior

@jiloi632

3 жыл бұрын

My favorite taemins backdancer is Famous's dancer

hey jeff i think u should react to the demo choreo too it’s basically all the same choreo but TOTALLY different vibe

When I watched Caspers choreography it kinda seems similar as if main dancer is a little bit faster then rest and Taemin is very detail oriented person so I think it was intentional? Because I don’t think he would mess around with his choreography

@wirantopora4506

3 жыл бұрын

That is taemin for sure

Advice is a masterpiece Taemin is king

RESPONSES TO YOUR POINTS/QUESTIONS: ー ー ー ー ー TIME & EFFORT ー ー ー ー ー Taemin has to be the single most hard working artist in the game. Many professionals and peers in the industry have complimented how he seems to still work even harder than junior rookies despite being 13 years into his career which is where you'd expect things to be taken more easily or get kinda stale/soft/dry. 2 groups, 1 solo career. Within less than 1 full year he gave us 4 top-tier features (Kid Milli, BoA, Wendy, Taeyeon), 1 commercial song, 1 OST, and 9 comebacks for a total of 6 albums with everything adding up to 57 songs overall. FIFTY SEVEN SONGS IN LESS THAN 365 DAYS WITH ALL OF TOP QUALITY. That's fucking insane. Majority of artists don't even do half of that within like 3 years or so of their careers and even Western mainstream artists still spend over 1 year promoting 1 album. While the general public to this day still hasn't even finished getting over Don't Call Me, SHINee already put out Atlantis then Taemin's Advice and now they even have another Japanese mini album on the way for July 28th so he really had to prepare this solo project in a tight crunch as a final parting gift for us fans. Advice is the only dance he's done in a long time that also only has 1 single choreographer credited which is Kasper who's worked closest with him since his solo debut and across the whole past year in everything else while additionally being occupied in doing stuff for other acts like Baekhyun and more as well. The song also came to him at the very last minute like a miracle when they were just about to postpone the album entirely since they couldn't find a perfect title track before then, so for us to get this type of quality through all of that pressure speaks volume about the artist we're working with here in terms of making the most out of anything. ー ー ー ー ー ANTI-SYNCHRONIZATION ー ー ー ー ー A Korean professional dance trainer of 15 years named Ruda Kris had a near frame by frame analysis of the choreo across all 3 of the music show stages (excluding Studio Choom cuz the full focus cams weren't out yet at the time) and he actually found it more refreshing that this performance wasn't so super synchronized, unlike what's become the norm in K-Pop, and that factor gave him a lot of nostalgia to old school hip hop dance crews which had the same structure so he thinks that's even cooler. Correct me if I'm wrong but many modern/underground dance crews are still like that too (obviously not like the Kinjaz/Poreotics/JustJerk/etc). He was also impressed in noticing that each stage in its entirety was different as Taemin and his dancers improved and changed little details over time. And like you noted: even though you can Pause at any frame and find everyone being "off" from one another, they still feel like a whole unit/team in Motion because their energy levels are altogether at the max (which seems to be the case where the current best and most popular choreographers and dance crew leaders in Korea most often work with Taemin to prove themselves and go all out too while dancing beside him whereas most other acts have like regular dancers and team members without the actual choreographers in it) so it's kinda dope to see "backup/background" dancers who are so often just used entirely as peripheral accents finally being able to step up and let loose in showing off their own unique styles too without necessarily taking any actual attention away from Taemin who's doing the absolute most himself in doing things differently from everybody else as well. I also personally find it sort of poetic that the visual concept of the song is so classy and clean-cut with the perfectly 50:50 split of black and white everywhere but then the performance and lyrics are so aggressive and "chaotic" as an ironic contrast which I'm pretty sure is the point ー ー ー ー ー ANTI-SYNCHRONIZATION ー ー ー ー ー Conclusion: TAEMIN is the solo King of K-Pop and the greatest performing artist of our generation. The industry themselves said it, not just us fans believe it or not. He's not called "the idol's idol" and "critics' favorite" for no reason.

@4Peace.

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you for your reactions and analysis, and in response to Jeff as well. I agree with you, especially in your conclusion that Taemin is a once in a generation artist.

@daysjours

2 жыл бұрын

You put a lot of time and thought into your comment. I learned a lot from you and appreciate your sharing your thoughts/knowledge with us.

king taemin♡

Finally got to watch this video to the end. Your reaction is superb as always, and I'll simply say that I really enjoy Taemin and his dancers - shame we'll have to wait for him to come back now.

Hey Jeff! I think the second chorus was intentional cause in the mv during the seconds verse and chorus you can see that Taemin is slowly getting crazier and crazier (the different taemins disappearing and appearing and him twitching(?) in the car) so the messy footwork would indicate the moment where he’s starting to lose his mind. If it is intentional it was extremely well executed cause I was getting chills 🤚🏼

He prepared the songs kn few days!!!!!! Really perfect he hadn't enough time so busy But the result omg!!!

I'm a female ballroom dancer. For the new shoes thing, you are so right! Dancing in heels in itself is not that hard. The hardest part is not slipping. We put either wax, rosin or hairspray under the shoes to avoid slipping. What we use largely depends on the surface we are dancing on. Though I have to say, I would rather slip than dance on carpet 😂

@JeffAvenue

3 жыл бұрын

omg yess dancing on carpet is TERRIBLE. i did it once and i have never againnn since

@codexone2194

3 жыл бұрын

@@JeffAvenue any kind of turn becomes immediately impossible xD We were supposed to dance Chachacha. I tell you, I felt like a beginner again 😂

I don’t really think Taemin would stand for sloppiness in his dancers that wasn’t purposeful. To me the dichotomy between the clean synchronization/formation and the seemingly free form interpretation of the choreo at times reflects Taemin’s duality that is often showcased in his music/MVs. He’s both a perfectionist and someone who hates to be boxed in…does that make sense?

Thank you for explaining briefly with this choreo, i do love this choreo so much

I think some were intentional in the MV since Taemin said in the Behind "I should make my dance a bit more wild" He also said that it was 3 days since they practiced the choreo when they filmed the MV (i can't seem to find where he said this in a video but my TL was full of concern for him that time because he managed to practice the choreo in just 3 days since he's super busy) also in his flo interview he said that it took them less than a week to practice the choreography. A fan also pointed out that it seems like he finished this album in a span of 2 weeks which is insane based on his hairstyles during the recordings and shootings he done for Advice.

Hey Jeff , I think I can answer your question from part 12:14 , I think the reason the guys feet were not synchronize was because they had to make a way for some of the male dancers that was coming forward and also the ones that was moving back jus so no one will trip and fall

I really like how you give a definitions of Taemin's dance move...pretty good 👍

I feel like there were a lot of parts in the chore where the dancers were allowed/encouraged to execute the move as they saw fit, just because how different they look when you compare them to each other. I'm thinking specifically of the little walk they do towards the end of the chorus and especially the first time with the girls (0:53 in the MV, ps I love how the female dancer to the left does the move

HI!!! Love your honest reviews on music videos and dances, keep going, don't be afraid to point out the mistakes in the music video it helps a lot in improvisation.

I should list down the terms Jeff uses to describe Taemin vids -Couture -Orchestra

been waiting for this thanks jeff!!! i hope you can also react to taemin's old stuff while he's on hiatus :)

I'd love to see more in depth analysis as this one, ofc sometimes there isn't so much to talk about, but I love when you do the moves too makes choreo more humanly possible

The choreography for this was done by Kasper, and he’s released a video of himself performing the dance and it’s so radically different to Taemin that it would be great to hear your thoughts about it (and even to get a compare & contrast with what Taemin does). As always,love your videos, cant wait for more.

Taemin ❤❤😎😎🔥🔥

I really love it how you put insight into every detail, with full respect to the artist! Btw Taemin himself said that this time was the fastest he had to prepared for a comeback, so I think for a rushly learned choreo it's still pretty amazing.

This is the original choreography from his beyond live concert which I like the best. As far as his dancers go Taemin does choose the dancers he wants and most of the dancers in ADVICE are also in IDEA! As to the MOVE era because the choreographer was Japanese I would expect him to have Japanese dancers as well which he did. As far as the Choreo not being synchronize if you will as much as Taemin its a perfectionist if it was an issue for him it would’ve been corrected which leads me to believe that it was intentional.Always love your reactions 💓💓

Jeff reactions when you don’t know him very much are the reactions you don’t know you need until you see him. When you know him, you just expect more reactions to know more about your favourite artist. Thanks for reacting to Taemin, please keep doing it even if he is gone. We are gonna miss him so much and see these videos from time to time will help us a lot for the waiting. Also if you could check more Shinee videos will be much appreciated 😊🥲

From what I understand, this was Taemin's last album before going to army. Taemin wanted to try something totally new and gave his dancers much much more freedom than usual. In his previous albums, he made sure that all his dancers are all moving together as a unit. However, he wanted all dancers to show off their own vibe and feeling and this was the result.

Your WORDS! THANK YOU for not making stupid faces AND using such a beautiful vocabulary to describe art. He IS a conductor/composer and honestly I think, while everyone knows he's a great dancer, most people don't actually fully grasp what an artist he is on ALL levels. And so young! He's on such a trajectory... I truly hope he's not phased by his service. I wonder if he was so busy so that his body of work representing THIS stage in his life was well fleshed out. I think he's intelligent enough to have grasped that potential for coming back a changed person.

@daysjours

2 жыл бұрын

You say a lot in very few words. One thing is clear -- Taemin is extraoridnarily intelligent. I think he left for the army really shaken by the idea of losing his fans and his place in the music scene. But he is never scared of his challenges as an artist -- he will always have the soul of a creator rather than a star.

I miss him 😭😭😭😭

Really enjoy your reactions. Very insightful. Would love to see more reactions to his live performances since there aren't always dance practices available and I feel like he really shines on the stage. Also, I feel like you could give insights on stage performance vs in studio/controlled environment. I would recommend Taemin's Heaven (2nd concert) as well as his performance of Door at MAMA 2017.

Thank you so much for these kind of videos. It makes me go back to dancing and pay more attention to details, expressions, and overall the attitude. Also, your comments make the choreos richer and more meaningful us, who doesn’t know more about dancing

Taemin is so so so so unique. I love him!!

Yes💃!! Thank you very much for the reaction! I was literally dancing when I saw the video notification😅! Thanks for all the details and explanations! It's like being in dance class and it allows me to better understand and appreciate the song of TAEMIN even more!☺️☺️

I loved your analysis ! it was so detailed ! Overall I think the advice album was very rushed, Taemin wanted to have a "goodbye" album before enlisting but there was not much time between shinee album, superm song and advice, so things might not be as perfect as criminal or idea (still Taemin's performance is breathtaking)

Ahhh Taemin is just perfect

When some hoobaes wanna cover his dance, he always told them to put their own color into it. Taemin isnt really serious about synchronization if you ask me, and if you watch his concerts, their dancers always danced pretty different, unsynchronized and kinda improvised. I think its because he knew although they're professional dancers but also with various genres and skills, he didn't want to be bossy, or fussy about it. If this vid upset you, I dare you to watch Sexuality @ dream concert. OHMYGOD one of his dancers really hurt my feelings, he cant even keep up with the choreos 🤦‍♀️ but I'm quite used to it now. If Taem's okay with it, I'm all ok with it. His korean dancers are not bad though ... but I love his japanese dancers more. They're very artistic and super duper awesome.

@shineetaemint6548

3 жыл бұрын

Agree to your statement of his japanese dancers crew...they all awesome

It is a repetitive song but i do love it so much, the choreo is just super amazing

It makes my day when I watch your reaction to Taemin!

I definitely think it's intentional that not everything is in sync. Besides it being hip hop the song is also about Taemin not doing what haters want him to do. He's listening to his own advice. So the fact that everyone is kind of dancing to their own beat definitely feels like an artistic choice. Especially since Taemin is such a perfectionist and all the dancers are professional as well

Thank you so much for reacting to this video, I was waiting for it! I love your reactions!

I think that it was intentional to emphasize the crazy aspect of the song. Or at least partially. But probably it's also because they didn't have much time to practice and make everything perfect. I noticed that too this time. The girls in particular were kinda messy. I think it's like the dancers were trying to catch up with him. Personally i think his movements were perfects all along... it's more the backup dancers

i remember on the video of the recording of the first verse, when the producer asked him what feeling he wants to convey, he insisted on the idea he had about people mumbling around him and how he is trapped into this, so i think the footwork, which seems messy its purposeful, there is this chaotic thing around him and he wants to break free. i can feel this frustration in the choreo, especially that footwork in the chorus. masterful

Really like that this guy has the guts to offer real criticism instead of just recycling the same generic praises ("so on-point," "the execution is great," "much dance," "wow," etc.).

jeff,thank you for such a neat,articulated and knowledgable video commentary. i enjoyed a lot listening to it.

Taemin es la personificación de perfección!!

ooo i was waiting for this

I love this review so much. Thank u. Your observations are amazing.

Thank you for making these reactions!

King taemin

Personally, I feel that Taemin's dancers can never really keep up with him and that just shows how unique Taemin's dancing is. He dances like he weighs nothing (which he prob doesn't lol), but it's effortless for him. He dances like he's water. Maybe that's why it's easier for the female dancers to sync with him? Cause they're lighter and more flexible? Whereas his male dancers are a little bulkier so their movements are slowed down a little causing that delay. That's what came to mind anyway!

TAEMIN IS ART.

TAEMIN

I love your honest and accurate comments. And yes, this one siunds like a master class :) I'm glad you pointed out the shoe issue. As a dancer myself I hate when the time comes to change. Even if I perform successfuly It makes me feel insecure and makes me think I was not at my best... This conversation I just had with a friend yesterday because Taemin can dance with whatever his feet are wearing or not. His level of control is just amazing.

And he was also working on Super M comeback- We Do. Love Taemin!!

most of Taemin’s dancers are famous choreographers so I think the anti-synchronisation is entirely on purpose to interpret the crazy part of that particular verse imo Taemin’s a perfectionist & he wouldn’t have let a small mistake like this (if it’s not on purpose) go if he saw it trust me

Yes, Taemin is like a director of an orchestra. He lead to his dancers perfectly and they manage to support him to make the show even more incredible, however Taemin never loses the limelight on stage. He is the protagonist. Thanks for your reaction ☺️. I loved it!

around 4:30 i get exactly what you mean about the footwork looking cleaner here than in the MV. i think a huge part of it is that the MV setting is so extravagant, it’s hard to focus on the dancers and their footwork

Truly love it

i reeeeaaally love your reaction videos about taemin 😍😍😍 wish you could do more of it specially his past videos 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🥰

Please, watch this live, it was only 3 performances and 1 from the concert. God I miss Taemin😭 Also, Baekhyun just released video on his YT. I wish they do the same for Taem🙏 I miss Taem-logs.

Came here coz I am watching Lucifer at work (it's slow 😅) and I saw you! The episode with the poisoned chef Pops. So random to recognize a face in the cast 😁

I love that i feel smart by listening to Jeff explaining everything........

I loved this reaction! Hope you will react to Taemin more and more hihi

Thank u for.the break down Jeff.. 😊😊😊

Hii thanks for reacting to Taemin's performance. I hope you'll react to Yunho (TVXQ) performance at Studio Choom too ^^ He's the first Male Artist of The Month for Studio Choom.. and I really enjoyed his performance there ^^ Thank youuu

Woww you explained it so beautifully love that....

I've always thought his Japanese dancers for Famous were on another level and better than his Koreans back up dancers that have worked with him. They would've been perfect this and wouldn't drag the choreo down. They're always on point and their energy matched Taemin's. I hope after Taemin's discharge from enlistment, we get to see him perform with them again especially Advice. I would love to see it and to compare it with his Korean dancers.

excellent reaction 👌👏🤣😆👍

"Music made visual" In his past interview with StacyNam( Want Era). He was asked how he would introduce himself/ his music to someone who haven't heard of him before. In a nutshell, Music made visual was his answer. I coudnt agree more.

Please react to Advice music show stages too! Thanks, Jeff! :)

Taemin's focus on synchronization has changed, since IDEA i think, Ive heard other ppl describe it as trying to transmit a style more alike to those of like, HipHop groups, where everyone just dances in their own style and not two dancers are perfectly synchronized, I think it must be a mixture between choice and just not having enough time to practice, cause the choreo got better the more they performed it too, he was very very busy. Also the theme of the song isnt clean at all, I actually prefer everything to be more erratic and unsynchronized, although its obviously subject to personal interpretation, It feels.. "dirtier?" less polished and just right for Advice's theme. There's a dance cover of IDEA that I would say is a lot more synchronized than Taemin's own renditions and arguably more enjoyable if the idea is to make the dancers seem like a part of Taemin's body, it works to make them be super synchronized and not to stand out and let Taemin be the most important part. Apparently for IDEA it was important for him to make the dancers keep their own styles, so as to transmit a merging of different ideas or smth? Thematic stuff. But in Advice they seem more like, underlings? Under Taemin who is the bid bad villian, so having them unsynchronized, as too give them some kind of identity makes it feel more complete, to me at least, it's an interesting thing, dance is art after all, and there's a lot of different ways to see it, his dancers are proficient enough that if the most important thing was to be as synchronized as possible i'm sure they could achieve it, but we can never actually know for sure. They had like a month to prepare the whole thing after all.

@le_pierrot_rouge

3 жыл бұрын

For me idea is synchronized, at least in the timing. But, I have seen few dance covers of idea. May I know which do you refer?

@aryzaryz4840

3 жыл бұрын

@@le_pierrot_rouge kzread.info/dash/bejne/pIhnu66rh6zeYZs.html Idea is synchronized timing wise but the movements aren't synchronized with each other that much, angles shapes etc.

@le_pierrot_rouge

2 жыл бұрын

​@@aryzaryz4840 I realized I had already seen this cover. It's a good cover. If I have to put my grain of salt I can say taemin's dancers always have had their own distinctive movements, maybe not that notorious as now but they always has been present.

I love this!! And i keep waiting for the vid for the dance practice of monsta x gambler🔥