As long as I can be in the same room with Paul McCartney on the piano, I'll sing the songs for him if he cant. ❤️

@elisa7881

2 жыл бұрын

I'll listen to him speak his songs.

@m0aze611

Жыл бұрын

I've seen him many times, as far as I'm concerned he can just stand there in silence if he wants and I'd go home happy. We will never see the likes of his kind again, a magical time for me growing up in this era. His Glastonbury performance was second to none. No autotune and no feedback ear piece. xxx

I am just so glad he's still ALIVE and TOURING!! I will be seeing him for the first time in one week, and I feel like it'll be a dream come true. Do I care that his voice might sound different and not be the best it's ever been? NOT AT ALL. I am happy he's still going and giving ME the chance to see him in person. That's all I care about. So much LOVE to Sir Paul McCartney.

@susannconnelly7826

2 жыл бұрын

Right on!👍

@joshjoseph7628

2 жыл бұрын

Yes agree. His voices changes with age. We all change with age and our voices

@marty3888

2 жыл бұрын

You are going to see a fantastic concert and I'm glad you're getting tis chance. But I hope this is his last tour.

@bigtimestories7506

Жыл бұрын

@@marty3888 I get it he’s old but I’m 15 I haven’t seen him since 2016 and before that 2014, I need to see him one more time, I hope and pray he comes back to my state 😢

Ok let's do the math. In this video montage, his voice showed almost no change until 2014. So that's 38 years from 1976 folks! He was already 34 years old in 1976 and 72 years old in 2014. So his voice stayed remarkably strong for a long long time! Especially when you remember he's been singing non-stop since his teens. All of the concerts and recordings with The Beatles, Wings, and his solo recordings and concerts with his current band! It's a crazy amount of singing! That's not even to mention rehearsals, and special guest appearances with other artists. Oh, and probably hundreds and hundreds of interviews. It all adds up. So now he's 80 years old all of a sudden and it seems like the time just flew by! We should all enjoy him for who he is, the gift of his music he has given us, and the fact that he's still out there doing 2-1/2 to 3 hour concerts, and killing it! It will be a sad day when we can't see him sing and play anymore. 😔❤️

@markv.5962

Ай бұрын

those of us who love him dont really care about his weakened voice.i dont. just to be in the same place with him is good for me

It’s beautiful actually. Life is a journey… If we are moving, it changes scenery as we go. We’re all human beings. Every day is a gift. Rock on Paul.

@derekec

2 жыл бұрын

One of the best simply stated comments anywhere on any subject I've ever read. We love Paul as we love our blood family and happy to have them in our lives for as long as we can.

@NisseOhlsen

2 жыл бұрын

Yes it changes. In some cases the wine gets better. In other cases not so much.

To his credit...even though he's struggled with his voice over the last few years, he's still singing Let and Let Die in the same key. Love you Macca!!

@dinolisi9812

2 жыл бұрын

Time for him to drop the key a step or 2…

@da_great_mogul

2 жыл бұрын

He's too used to them in that key. It would take a lot of effort to learn the new chords for a shift down a key or two.

@brendanryan8439

2 жыл бұрын

@@da_great_mogul I promise you Paul McCartney is more than capable of changing the keys of his songs

@george4821

9 ай бұрын

I reckon if he did an Elton John and didn't try to sing it as high as he did when he was 20, people wouldn't complain.

@BuddhaofBlackpool

3 ай бұрын

Elton lost his falsetto after a voice operation when he was forty. ​@@george4821

He is a fucking icon and legend! Even his voice at 75 to 80 percent, seeing him live is worth the price of admission....so much so I took my 15 year old son to see him in Baltimore. My son loved every minute of it! Paul and the Beatles one of his favorite groups/performers. My son plays bass because of Paul McCartney.

@TheCheermeister

2 жыл бұрын

How about 40%? Macca embarrasses himself and his amazing legacy every time he performs now.

@ericstrauch3215

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheCheermeister Macca is more than just his voice live.

@graniterhythm53

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheCheermeister 100,000 + folks at Glasto might beg to differ!

@iggydip

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheCheermeister No he doesn’t. Even if he used spoken word to perform his songs people would still go to see him.

@annother258

Жыл бұрын

I mean, If you have a grand to toss in the firepit, sure...His ticket prices are offensive.

Seen him about 15 years ago and he was struggling then. Still grateful and a treasured memory.

I saw him a week before his 80th birthday and thought he sounded AMAZING. One of my fav concerts of all time!

@kenlieck7756

2 жыл бұрын

Any time I've been able to obtain a recording of a rock show I attended that sounded AMAZING live, the playback sounded about like those last couple of performances on the video! (Which oddly enough, looked to be audience recordings while the earlier ones were pro shot...)

@aapoeepo

2 жыл бұрын

@@kenlieck7756 he's pretty good for 80 years old. My grandfather's 75 and can't sing. Even though he's not much of a singer like Paul.

Frankly he is bloody amazing and still brings it to the people all these years later. I hope he never retires. Can you imagine what a huge amount of responsibility and pressure it must be to be "Paul McCartney"? He carries the Beatle and Solo legacy so well. Stay strong Macca!

@tonyajohnson7948

2 жыл бұрын

He is amazing!

@susannconnelly7826

2 жыл бұрын

I love your “bloody amazing comment”!!!

Wow....he got older and his voice older...imagine that ! The man is a musical legend and his name will live forever. 80 years old and performing around the world...Rock on Paul !!

Pro English - Thanks for sharing this link. I have 2011 at wrigley field & 2017 at Tinley Park (both Chicago gigs) In 2011 I don't hear a break in his voice. The version you used at the end on this is at Lambeau Field which is a legendary field itself as is Wrigley. I guess as we age our vocal cords change. He still puts on an amazing show. He's such a legend.

@proenglish5886

5 жыл бұрын

cindyward19- Thanks for your comments. It seems that Paul’s vocal has been broken since 2014. But He is still puts on an amazing show as you said.I wish he lived forever🤭

@markparker4842

5 жыл бұрын

He has been singing on stage since 1957 and has been putting records out sinse 1962 plus for the most part he is either puting a album out or he is on tour or doing some other kind of musical project he mainly is doing something every year and he has been touring almost every year since 2001 i have to see how many live concerts he has had since 2001 im sure its a super super amount he is on stage 3 plus hours alot longer them most performers are all the other ones do maybe a hour and a half and thats with a few breaks paul talkes no breaks he never has has the beatles played from 8 to 16 hours a day in Germany before they got famous and they would have had longer concerts when they got famous but the load screaming you could not hear them after 62 years i can imagine his vocal cords a pretty worn but he still put on a concert better then anyone else

@iloveresses7277

2 жыл бұрын

I was at both shows (Wrigley and Tinley Park, both 1st night) and the change in his voice was substantial. He pretty much sounded like Beatles/Wings Paul in 2011 and raspy old Paul in 2017. I'd pay to watch Paul even if his voice was a barely audible whisper, but its sad to hear his voice degrade to this level. The 2022 shows sound AWFUL. I still wish he was coming to Chicago this time around though :)

@robtgoldstein

2 жыл бұрын

@@iloveresses7277 at least he did not bill this as “the final tour”. He just loves to entertain people and obviously this is not about the money.

@NisseOhlsen

2 жыл бұрын

I'm Danish, and pro English. But the 2018 on-wards should never have happened. I realize that it is up to Paul to do whatever he pleases. And I also think I understand that he feeds off the communication with the audience (who wouldn't). This has nothing to do with technicalities such as vocal chords, but everything to do with embarrassments.

We who love Paul McCartney ❤️ don't care about his voice we are so happy to see the living legend we sing along like I did in Boston two weeks ago and didn't notice or care! He's Paul McCartney!

I saw him live in 1976 in St. Paul Wings Over America tour.. We were on the main floor not too far from the front. I will never forget it.

@michaeldillon1027

2 жыл бұрын

I saw him in Houston on that same tour. Phenomenal concert as you know.

@trudic7505

2 жыл бұрын

lucky you!❤

Interesting. Still rocks Paul is so one of a kind that I think most of us rightly cut him some slack for his voice going a bit now that he's 80. I would go see him live still in a heartbeat, and he still makes great records. He'll have my ear until he leaves this earth, and he'll have it until I follow suit as well. There will never be another Paul McCartney, and having him with us for as long as we have is one of the great things that has happened in this world. Thanks for keeping the pyro stuff in the video, by the way. This song must be a blast to see and hear live.

@TheCheermeister

2 жыл бұрын

It was a blast up fill about 15 years ago when he could still sing it. Also his last 5 or so albums have been horrible compared to his earlier catalog.

Most people can barely walk and have a extremely raspy talking voice and most 77 year olds dont even leave their house other then dr appointments paul McCartney is still doing 3 plus hour concerts doing world tours travels the world is constantly active he is still doing world tours i think he is doing great for his age he is 31 years older than me and he can run circles around me he does better then most 40 year olds do he is in in better shape then people half his age

@angus7278

2 жыл бұрын

That doesn’t change the fact that people are paying to hear him sing, not to just see him, and not to watch him run circles around out-of-shape forty year olds.

@framey3830

2 жыл бұрын

That's beyond untrue - 77 can be an extremely youthful age. My beautiful gran was in full fiddle until her abrupt and sudden death at 87; able to walk to the same degree as I can, and certainly able to get out and do everything she wished to do.

@strings53notlob50

2 жыл бұрын

Completely irrelevant when you’re paying $400 for a damn seat! Give me a show or pack it up.

@dinolisi9812

2 жыл бұрын

@@strings53notlob50 $400 for nose bleeds … he is charging $3250. each for floor seats first 10 rows.

@Bipbop66

2 жыл бұрын

I am a big Macca fan Saw him in a concert twice. Paid good money to see him perform in all these great gigs, like in Joe Robbie (Hard rock stadium) '89, BBT center (FL line arena) '05. Why I wouldn't pay double the amount that I paid for BOTH of these concerts to see him at this moment in his life? I love him, but it is not worth it for me anymore. Ship has sailed, but Macca will always be forever!

Like us all everyone gets older and things begin to lose their strength. He still is one of those if not the greatest musicians and song writers that ever lived. At 80 years old he still packs stadiums! Absolutely amazing!

I saw him in 2012. Probably the best concert of my life. Hats off to Paul for touring the world and sharing the Beatles legacy.

Big differences in 2018 & 2019. To be expected really. That happens to all vocalists as they age. Live on Paul 👍

Proves what a damn good song Live And Let Die is

It’s still amazing to see Paul performing nowadays with a huge set list. Had the honor to see him live in 2014 and his voice was still pretty dang good, at 80 years old I think he is still killing it.

@TheCheermeister

2 жыл бұрын

Yes, killing his legacy as the greatest rock vocalist of all time.

@flyer5347

Жыл бұрын

@Rick Ster that logic doesn't work

@Aderin.

Жыл бұрын

​@@TheCheermeisterbruh it's not possible to kill paul mccartneys legacy lmao. He's just that god tier. I watched glastonbury and I don't care about that one voice crack I heard in maybe im amazed, he sounds pretty damn good in that actually. My friend said that's actually impressive so it's nit actually killing his legacy, it's more impressive that he can perform like that at 80

I saw PM in 2010 and cried like a baby being in the same room and hearing the songs that meant so much to me LIVE and in person. I'll never forget it till my dying breath. There is a saying about when a singer should retire from public performing: Better that they should say, 'What! Already?' than 'At last. Thank God.'

We went. We saw. We don't care! It was Paul!!!

Father Time is undefeated. Paul will still always be the best and should now focus on songwriting instead of touring.

@robtgoldstein

2 жыл бұрын

What do you think? kzread.info/dash/bejne/n6Gezc6PldK4caw.html

@GoDawgs18

2 жыл бұрын

I saw him in Knoxville, and it was still a great show and his voice sounded better than his previous shows.

@TheCheermeister

2 жыл бұрын

I would agree except his last 5 or so albums have been horrible. His artistic well is dry and his voice,( the greatest ever), is shot.

@mainman127

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheCheermeister yep I hear you. The thing is Paul is never going to stop writing music anyway so he might as well focus on that …maybe he has some more good music coming …I never count him out. Plus in the studio they can auto tune his voice unlike live concerts

It's not all about the voice though, it's about actually seeing a legendary performer in the flesh. Of course some of us will call the guy out but at eighty he's still rockin' on.

@dinolisi9812

2 жыл бұрын

Bullshit … do you want to see Bridget Bardot naked? Well it’s not about her age….

Wow. Nice compilation. It is hard to accept age. Age is revered as the enemy in so many cultures, mine included. We need to break out of the confines of this perception of age. It is amazing that Paul is still enjoying life and giving us everything he has got when he is up there. Nothing has changed that way.

@NisseOhlsen

2 жыл бұрын

Listen to Leonard Cohen. Also on his last album "You want it darker". There is no fixed age. But when it's over it should be over.

@JusticieroBurning

2 жыл бұрын

Mick sing good

I saw him in 2010 and 2018 (both freebies). The only crack in his voice in 2010 was on the high part of My Love. The vocals in 2018 were not too good, but were somewhat drowned out because of the Montreal Bell Centre's acoustics, but his frail voice was appropriate for Here Today. His band is phenomenal.

I can only hope to sing half as well as McCartney does when I’m his age. I’ll be lucky to be alive!

That voice has a lot of miles on it but the man is a true legend and people will always go just to see him, I would!

An interesting compilation. Thank you. A few points. 1. PM started his career long before foldback was widely used. This in itself leads to straining and the risk of vocal damage. 2. To do this fairly you’d need to generalise a suite of gigs from each of the chosen years: everyone catches cold, suffers fatigue, doesn’t feel like it-ie has off days. 3. PM, perhaps surprisingly, hasn’t adjusted the keys of his songs. Robert Plant, for example, has developed a new style of singing to suit his voice and consequently sounds great. 4. Many of the songs in his live shows are high intensity vocally. Any changes in his voice are likely to be foregrounded by this. 5. PM is a great musician: it’s that, probably before his standing as a singer, that makes people want to see him. Much like Dylan, in that respect. But thank you for providing a very interesting starting point for discussion. Oh and a final point (6): it’s important on each occasion to consider where exactly in the relevant set the song was placed. Hitting high notes when nicely warmed up but before any vocal strain has occurred is entirely different from hitting them when either not warmed up or else tired.

@angus7278

2 жыл бұрын

To summarize (ahem), his voice is shot.

@TimothyOBrien1958

2 жыл бұрын

Elton John, in a doc about the making of Yellow Brick Road, listened to the original recording and exclaimed, "My God, I sound like a castrati (sic)." My voice has changed over the (64) years. I used to have a near 5-octave range. I can assure you it's not that broad now.

Vocal technique is not something that most rockers really pay attention to. He was blessed with remarkable natural technique. I could hear him using an operatic protected voice in the Get Back movie outtakes of him singing Besame Mucho. He’s doing a ersatz serious voice but it’s exactly what is required to make that sound. And he could do a lot for a long long time. A remarkable gifted musician. No question

The tipping point is 2010, Pauls vocal maturity would have been back in the early 80's, and from that point there's no going back in time.

@madcap_9539

15 күн бұрын

I'm guessing around 82ish with Tug of War was probably his last years with his voice still fully powerful like how it had been for decades. There's a difference with the Flowers in the Dirt tour and Wings tours but that's just ageing.

No surprise at all with him being 80 years of age. Lovely tune that song. I really like it.

One guy I met said to me, I don’t care what he sounds like. I’ve never seen him in concert. I want to see him while I have the chance. How can you argue with that kind of logic. I hope he enjoys himself.

He has been an inspiration for many in the music business. So please let it be.

When you go see a 77,79,80 year old performer you are going to reflect on all the wonderful memories he provided and say Thanks 🙏 No one cares about his voice really -

Interesting video. Biggest difference was definitely between 2010 and 2014.

@proenglish5886

5 жыл бұрын

Yeah, I’m on the same page. Paul’s vocal has been changing.I think between d2002 and 2010 changes little bit.On the contrary,there are very big changing from 2014 to2018. ⚠️I’m not good at English. If there are some mistakes, please tell me.

@NisseOhlsen

2 жыл бұрын

2007 already was deteriorating. Listen again. Now, the test is who will perform his songs without him, as they are still performing the works of Mozart and Cole Porter.

Biggest change seems to be between 2010 and 2014. In 2010 he sounds fairly normal, maybe a little bit of limitation to his vocal range, in 2014 he sounds a lot older. In 2018, he was able to change his phrasing of certain words or go into falsetto to hide sections of songs he could no longer do the same, but in 2022 he can't even do that. Paul can tour forever as far as I'm concerned, but its hard to listen to.

@robmartinez7517

2 жыл бұрын

Agreed.

@angelomisterioso

2 жыл бұрын

it is very painful, but then again, many people would probably be ecstatic if his band would be performing with Paul's ashes in an urn onstage beside them., ''because it's Paul'' . "But the Emperor has nothing at all on!" said a little child. "Listen to the voice of innocence!" exclaimed his father; and what the child had said was whispered from one to another. "But he has nothing at all on!" at last cried out all the people. The Emperor was vexed, for he knew that the people were right; but he thought the procession must go on now! And the lords of the bedchamber took greater pains than ever, to appear holding up a train, although, in reality, there was no train to hold.

@sharpvidtube

2 жыл бұрын

"Pipes of Peace" was the last album where I liked his voice. I think he started to struggle after that, back in the mid eighties. I don't mind when he uses his frail voice in some newer songs, but I can't listen to him singing his earlier songs now.

@iloveresses7277

2 жыл бұрын

@@sharpvidtube I kind of liked his aged but still strong voice in albums like Flaming Pie and Chaos and Creation personally. Not peak McCartney but still strong IMO. starting with memory almost full his voice started to sound a lot different but could still hit most of his notes. But it dropped off a cliff after 2010 and a further cliff after like 2018

@TheCheermeister

2 жыл бұрын

Whyndompeople ,( other than for the bucket list), want Paul to continue performing when his voice has been shot for the last 15 years or so? I have too much respect for his talent and legacy to want to see him perform with such diminished ability vocally.

I don't think I realized how great his voice still was in the early 2000s with the Driving Rain and Back in the World albums.

It's so sad, but he's still a legend

@chairmanmajong

2 жыл бұрын

It’s not in the least bit sad. People age. The longevity of his voice up to about 6 years ago is the miracle.

@UnclBerry

2 жыл бұрын

@@chairmanmajong It's not particularly sad, it's just you know

@zlrs0113

2 жыл бұрын

It is not sad it’s natural. He smoked/ took drugs for a period of his life and years of signing will put strain on someone’s vocal chords. He still sounds very decent for his age, but I think he would sound better if he dropped a octave or two.

@UnclBerry

2 жыл бұрын

@@zlrs0113 smoking is hardly natural

@zlrs0113

2 жыл бұрын

@@UnclBerry well excepted is a better word. Anyway you get my point.

The major damage is there between 2010 and 2014.... from then on it's been more of a croak. But when we was at his peak he was amazing vocally.

La naturaleza hace su aparición ,que maravilloso seria que la voz le durara mucho mucho mas,pero sabemos que es imposible.pero con todo lo que ya dio es mas mucho mas que suficiente ,Gracias por tanto Sir.Paul .

If the man just stood on stage and did nothing, it's worth the price of admission. That's rock royality right there and they'll never ever be another one that comes close to what he's done for music. Enjoy every minute while we still have him.

@robtgoldstein

2 жыл бұрын

I think he sounded pretty good in his first show on this tour. kzread.info/dash/bejne/n6Gezc6PldK4caw.html

@moeb4348

2 жыл бұрын

I really enjoy when Paul tells little amusing stories from his early days with the Beatles, what inspired the songs, all the amazing lucky coincidences that shaped their careers, etc. I'd pay to see a one man show like that.

@kenlieck7756

2 жыл бұрын

@@moeb4348 Just as long as he didn't tell "the joke"...

I was fortunate enough to see him on the '02 tour. I was a little apprehensive about how his voice would sound even back then, as the "Paul Is Live" album, recorded during his '89 tour, featured Paul sounding pretty rough around the edges and some noticeable strain in the high notes. Fortunately, his voice was actually stronger in 2002, something I can hear even in these short clips. I would have loved to have seen him earlier, still, but I still think I was damn lucky to have seen him when his voice was still comparatively strong (not taking away anything from those seeing him now--- like you, I'd be happy just to be in the same room with him, but I can't afford $450 for nosebleed seats).

Still a excellent musician + artist 🎸

I have commented on this before, Paul should lower the key of the song or tune down all the instruments to make it easier for him to sing. No big deal many 1960's bands that are still playing concerts have already done this, like The Stone. Let's cut Paul some slack, he's not 20 any more he's 80 now.

I Like what what Noddy Holder did, retire from music at 46, what a legend. REM did it too, not many musicians have the guts to walk away. Maybe ABBA will start a new trend, retire and let the holograms tour. Can't listen to McCartney and Elton John now, but at least I can look at their older stuff.

@jewante

2 жыл бұрын

i totaly agree with you, but fans don't want to face fact...👍👍

It would be an honor if Paul just stood on stage and waved, let alone to have the privilege to hear him play and sing. To get just an in-person glimpse of a legend the likes of whom you will literally never see again when he’s gone. This man and his original bandmates, John, George and Ringo changed the entire landscape of pop & rock music and for the kids out there, they did it in essentially 8 total years if you include when Ringo joint; 6 years from a US introduction perspective. In a mere 6 years, The Beatles grew from “I Want to Hold Your Hand” to “The Long and Winding Road” and everything in-between. No autotune, no digital gimmicks, just raw talent and genius ingenuity. Paul, just with the Beatles alone, Wings hits not withstanding, has to his credit totals of 20 No. 1 singles and 19 No. 1 albums, numbers which have never been matched by any artist and likely never will be.

@TheCheermeister

2 жыл бұрын

Paul should go on small speaking tours where he discusses the Beatles and his.life if he chooses. The pretence that he can still sing garnishes his legacy and is embarrassing.

Bruh Val Kilmer is half his age with throat cancer and a voice box. Paul is doing it man 🔥

@TheCheermeister

2 жыл бұрын

Kilmer never performed as the greatest vocalist in rock. That's the sad point of Mac a still insisting on touring he can no longer sing well.

Idk something about Paul in the early 2000's I think those were his best concerts

Comes a time for everyone in life to acknowledge the truth and know when to quit.

Sir Paul is great, a legend, the best!

The Greatest of Rock Legends No one will Ever Come Close

@TheCheermeister

2 жыл бұрын

Yes, he's healthy and looks great for his age. That does not mean he should still be trying to perform with such a compromised vocal ability hat this point

The man is 80 years old give him a break. He still sounds pretty damn good.

@susannconnelly7826

2 жыл бұрын

Yes he does and true McCARTNEY fans get it! No, I get it his voice is changing, but it’s the reality of aging! Rock O͏n͏ MCCARTNEY , I still love you since the first time I saw you at Shea Stadium!!!

@TheCheermeister

2 жыл бұрын

Paul in his prime would have been insulted if you called his vocals "pretty damn good.". He should have more respect for his legacy to perform vocally at about 50% of his former ability.

@lumpylumpyloo

Жыл бұрын

@@TheCheermeister i think you're putting words in his mouth, bitch

@Aderin.

Жыл бұрын

Glastonbury sounded so much better, the whole thing sounded great and the only time I recall a voice crack was at the start if maybe im amazed. He sounds really great screaming actually, his voice cracks when he's singing quietly like during let me roll it. His voice is just shakey though, I always expect a voice crack even though it never actually happens lol

@Aderin.

Жыл бұрын

​@@TheCheermeisterhe didn't call his former self pretty damn good, he said he *_still_* is pretty damn good meaning that he's talking about him now

You can hear his voice has gone but at least he's still out there. For a song like that I'd put the mobile phone down and actually enjoy the experience.

As a huge Beatles and McCartney fan who has seen Macca 6 times (all prior to 2002), I am horrified that he continues to tour when his voice sounds so utterly old and tired. For those who don’t mind shelling out hundreds of dollars for a hit of nostalgia, go right to it. For me, his singing is now an embarrassment, and I wouldn’t pay five dollars to see him.

@TheCheermeister

2 жыл бұрын

Couldn't agree more Craign Its sad for me to see Paul still trying to sing when he lost his voice 15 years ago. Been a Huge fan since 1964 but wondering why nobody close to Paul can convince him to hang it up.

@kenlieck7756

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheCheermeister You can look at those giddy screaming people and still wonder? Be honest, you know why.

I can't fault him for aging and all the natural decline in faculties that results. I can fault him for allowing nosebleed seats to go for $400 to see a performer FAR past his prime. He's still the greatest melodist in Western music since 1950 and the 2nd greatest songwriter, period, in my book (behind Bob Dylan), but I'm not shelling out that kind of dough to see him at this point. It's obscene to expect working people to come up with that kind of money to further line the pockets of rock music's richest person.

@kenlieck7756

2 жыл бұрын

If you look into it, the situation isn't so simple. Megastar acts who try to charge fair prices get scuttled by the arenas, the scalpers and Takeitmaster...

Up to 2010 he sounded 👍. If only science could renew vocal cords...

From 2014 on is really painful. He works too hard. He sounds so great in 76, doesn't he? As Mose Allison sang: "There I am back in 68, Lookin' good and feelin' great, Many moons past silently, And this ain't me, this ain't me."

Time to retire and release more outtakes from the good 'ol days !

когда вы только слышите первые ноты вы уже знаете, кто поёт)) он може меняться - но это Пол, навсегда!)

Paul has bucket loads of charisma, he had the audience in the palm of his hand at Glastonbury ...so yah boo to the few who criticised his performance..

This man has given the world so much through his music. Incalculable, really. He is an international treasure & always will be.

It appears that 2010 was the last time he could pull off this song. By 2014, that was no longer true. His vocal chops were gone. 😥

@aapoeepo

2 жыл бұрын

Nope. In 2013 he was still the same as in 2010

@Aderin.

Жыл бұрын

2014 was still good

Paul's voice hadn't changed very much through the years

if his voice had not declined that would he the news. We seem to think he and others never age. I think seeing him over the decades has become like the Beatles shows of the 1960's. You can say you saw him.

He's older, and as a former smoker, I can tell you that does a number on your voice (Sinatra), singer or not. This clip has a lot of careful editing just to be cruel.

He could change key. But what a heck! Paul The McCartney! The Ruler 🙏

on one hand I think it’s great he’s still doing it as he’s pushing 80 (!) but maybe lower the ticket prices?? how many billions of dollars does one man need?

Time and tide are two cruel phenomenon. When you wake up one day and realize you're not up to it then it's time to call it quits. By far the crowd has been polite unlike the ones at Whitney Houston's live appearance.

I saw Paul McCartney live in Los Angeles in late 1980s and to me it was obvious he could no longer sing the rockers like he once did. His singing has gone downhill from there. He was still singing well for Back to the Egg in 1979. Not sure about early 1980s. Let's be honest: No one is ever going to tell McCartney he has lost his voice, so he will likely keep going until he dies. If he did get feedback and took it to heart, he might limit himself to the easy ballads. But that is clearly not the case, as he still sings Helter Skelter.

he's one of the greats, but at this point his concerts are a sing-along.

If anyone wants to complain about Paul's voices changing let's see you sing at an early age than years later you will see your voice isn't the same. Paul's voice is fine

@TheCheermeister

2 жыл бұрын

No, its not fine. Yes, it was Tue greatest in rock history but now Paul needs to stop pretending he can still sing. Like a great athlete there comes a time to hang 'em up and Paul has reached that point

Like a machine..his voice is overused...

If you want to see contrast, they should do this with Bob Dylan.

Sir Paul🤩 has given so much joy, peace, comfort, and laughter to so many of his fans for decades, through his music and personality. Why can't people give him a little slack on a few notes?!🤔 Anyway his ongoing 2022 tour has his vocal range way better than Paul Stanley, Bon Jovi, and David Coverdale!! And Paul is older than each of the three, so enjoy the show and celebrate the positive🤙!!

2014 ... break !

They are all great or good but i can't understand why he doesn't lower the key a little from his range in 1973 when it was written, thats 49 years ago, next to no-one would notice.

he is pretty damn good at 80. biden is younger and can barley walk or talk. .... but i hope this is pauls last ride....

It is evident Paul’s voice is not the same at 80!

People get old! The man's probably gonna die onstage, & he'll go doing what he loves best! Three cheers for Paul McCartney!😎

Some degradation from age would be normal and to be expected. But I’ve long suspected there’s something else going on with Paul’s voice. It’s the throttled sound and uncontrolled wobble - I think he may have a voice problem such as spasmodic dysphonia, something that would create the serious issues he has singing even low notes properly. It’s a real shame, but he was great for a long time.

Paul's still rockin' on. I saw him live in 89 and his voice was in best shape. In his 70s he added more vibrato at the end of long tones to cover up his lack of holding them constantly. But that's okay for me, because he still sings this songs he wrote as a young man. And if you actually hear him at the "Got Back-Tour" 2022, still singing songs like "Birthday" or "Helter Skelter", he still sounds powerful and full of energy. And by the way, this man is 80 years old! My greatest respect and admiration to this living legend. Keep on, Paul!

At last someone is talking about the elephant in the room McCartney's voice has deteriorated over the years this is most likely due to age. However one thing is for certain he is still one of the best songwriters on the planet its obvious he now has to write new songs for his vocal range a perfect example of this is a song called...MY VALENTINE... kzread.info/dash/bejne/fJOh2aqGfrDgqqg.html

@sharpvidtube

2 жыл бұрын

Not the elephant in the room, I think most people know he can't sing anywhere near his best now. Some fans ignore it, but maybe they can't hear what I hear?

@TheCheermeister

2 жыл бұрын

I think his last 5 albums have been embarrassingly awful compared to his earlier work, much the same as his vocals The well has gone dry and really, its ok. Glad we have the rich legacy of his work to enjoy for generations.

@yell50

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheCheermeister Well said.

What is the point of this??

3:26 老いを感じる

@proenglish5886

5 жыл бұрын

ポールマッカートニーなんでthけれども、何歳かわか〜りますかね？

@user-cg1xy9mb7o

5 жыл бұрын

seventy seven

@proenglish5886

5 жыл бұрын

あっ惜しいでthねー。ポールマッカートニーの誕生日は1942年6月18日なんでthけれども、あと丁度1週間で77歳となるわけでthねー。

If he cut back on his performances & rested his voice it may sound better

And in my best day, I could never hit these notes even in my 20's. So.....

@TheCheermeister

2 жыл бұрын

The point being that Paul could and no longer can't When time takes the toll it has on Paul's voice, he should have the respect for his legacy and his fans to humbly admit his performing days are behind him.

@derekec

2 жыл бұрын

Rick Ster Can't agree less. Paul isn't a quitter, going out at the top. He's a journeynman as much as he is royalty and it shows as much now as ever. He'll go till he can't or no one wants him. That's part of his legacy and his respect for his fans is shown by giving his all at every point in time. Plus, his music isn't about just him - he loves a band and the band as a whole delivers a great show. I don't care to listen to Joe Shmoe playing his songs, I want it from Paul.

Sucks to see people get old

NEVER changed the key of the song to make it easier to sing.

The first one looks dubbed.

well it’s not his fault but something had to happen to him in order to lose his voice ??

The say his voice is great for the first few shows and then of course it tires now..he's close to 80 so??

I’d see him today in a heartbeat. Legend, second to none.

Of course it's changing, the guy is 80!!!! When you can no longer give a quality performance it's time to call it a day. Don't embarass yourself.

You think….

So sad

What's happening to Paul Mc Cartney has happened to Elton John, AGE! in Elton's case it was the drugs he did for a time when younger like Whitney Houston. Why do artists want to destroy the very thing they use to make their living with? their voice. In Mc Cartney's case, it is just age. We love you, Paul.

@sharpvidtube

2 жыл бұрын

Paul did drugs too. Smoking seemed to help many singers from the 60s. As they stopped smoking, their voices deteriorated. Bono seemed the opposite, smoking made his voice worse.

If I could see John Lennon on stage reading the phonebook for 2 hours, it'd be money well spent.

@TheCheermeister

2 жыл бұрын

I wish Paul would read the phone book, or go on speaking tours, instead of trying to still sing.

we get old

I think he should still gig- (just) BUT make them free shows. He's a dollar billionaire-think of all those fans who have never been able to afford to see him ....come on on Paul. I'm the biggest Macca fan going, I love him and all he stands for. But the modern voice makes me feel a little awkward.