I'm in awe of the process, and the sheer amount of labor involved - kudo's, gentlemen. Your axe and this film are a work of art.

@Brad-py7sj

8 ай бұрын

Missed your opportunity for a great dad pun there.

By far the most complete and comprehensive smelting/forging video I've seen to date. Many of the videos I've seen skipped a lot of important steps you gentlemen showed, and their results were predictably far inferior. Watching your seamless teamwork was as fascinating as the processes involved....great job, guys!

@stephenmankowski3679

Жыл бұрын

Conrad, thank you. Lee Sauder is the best and an excellent teacher.

@283518

5 ай бұрын

exactly, whats the point if steps are missed?

I didnt even know ore dogs were a thing. Makes sense as iron oxides definitely have a scent to them. That is insanely cool

it took many iron tools to make an iron tool. add to that a herculean amount of power, precision, and perspiration, and the result is nothing short of wizardry.

@roqua

6 күн бұрын

Hence why the popular and skilled creator of the Primitive Technology channel is having trouble smelting more than iron prills from his furnaces (5-6 attempts documented so far). One man running the blower/bellows and stopping to add charcoal and ore charges invariably leads to an inferior bloom.

I don’t get tired of watching this video. Im on my 5th

Superb video. Somehow I found myself following peoples attempts at smelting iron (often failing). I think your video completes my journey. Thank you so much for posting this, just amazing to see the skill, effort and care you all put into your craft.

@stephenmankowski3679

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for you very positive feedback! We had fun making it !

@danielwebb1004

Ай бұрын

Haha! Same here. This video is a "finally, someone who actually knows what they're doing" moment going down this rabbit-hole of a historical hobby.

Excellent. Really adds perspective on the cost of this essential and ubiquitous tool 200+ years ago.

When I studied Blacksmithing some years ago, making Iron and steel this way was one of the classes. When we did our charcoal, we tightly packed our wood to the point where we almost had to batton the wood in to the container. However our containers where massive. We could stand 3-4 people shoulder to shoulder inside those. Tho our coal where supposed to last over a year, as we used charcoal to light our forges. Doing the same i would estemate you would get 3/4 of the quantety placed inside your barrels. + Dont let the wood get thuroly started, but light it and let the fire get a good grip, then put the lid on, and alternate the openings at the bottom, A good burn will take about 1.5 days depending on the quantity placed in to the container. Slow burn = high yeld. As my teacher said. "A good burn, will make the local fire department thinking about making a visit." (Due to a large amount of slow drifting smoke being released from the barrel/container.)

Ore-sniffing dog? Who knew! This is such a lovely video. Thank you.

Back when it was made this way, it lasted well over the creator's lifetime, and for some it was their most valued possession. I've done blacksmithing as a hobby using rail spikes myself, but had no clue how an axe is actually made, very interesting how the traditional axe was not entirely made of steel, but it also makes a lot of sense. Very insightful, thank you for this elaborate guide, not too many of these floating around the interwebs, that's for sure!

the amount of sheer labor is incredible - amazing human men in 2022 still possess this knowledge

A fine example of the whole process, complete with the end product. Thank you, well done guys.

Great project documentary. I like to think most of us understand the primordial call of attempting to build essential technology from scratch (hence the broad appeal of the Primitive Technology channel)... but... as your film shows, inserting just a few modern upgrades in the process allows for superior and more predictable results, which end up being a bit more satisfying when coming out the other side. With only a few exceptions, modernizing the air blast variable is what most "build it from scratch like our ancestors would have" enthusiasts end up doing.

This is an incredible video! Thank you so much for creating it.

48:52 "We have come full circle this has been a journey to understand the ancient means of making iron to reproduce that method and to generate a material that has not been available to western blacksmiths for nearly 200 years" ?!

I'm usually inclined to try (at least once in my life) the "old way" of doing things. This, not so much! Very cool to see, and I appreciate all the little metal objects a bit more now.

Fantastic and informative documentary! I highly recommend it to all blacksmiths, persons interested in history, metallurgy, or even hard work! Bravo gentleman!

Awesome documentary. Really enjoyed it.

Great video! Thanks.

Absolutely glued me to the screen. Well done

Excellent discription! Enjoyed every minute.

I know it's been one year but I got to say, this is the most beautiful thing I've ever seen

I own the DVD well done! Thank you for your contributions to the CRAFT and documenting the process!

As a mechanical engineer its fascinating to see all the different process and the understanding of the material that the olf ones already have, thanks for the excellent video

I learned a lot from this video. The effort and ancient ingenuity that went into something that seems so trivial nowadays. I have a new respect. I didn’t know Hudson’s Bay Company had an outfit in Vancouver, WA, I should have known.

Probably would have been a good call to bring a backpack with you to gather 50 pounds of ore in the woods, rather than just bringing a flour sack with you lol

this is excellent

So much work going on in this vid. I needed a beer just watching it. Great job, guys!

Phenomenal. Well done fellas.

This is so wonderful film...Fantastic! The dog !!😍 I use neodym Magnet which finds rich iron black stones.

good movie, awesome music too.

This is so educational. Thank you

This is the best video on KZread. Thank you for detailing the process step-by-step and making it easy to follow.

Amazing video! Words can't describe how much I enjoyed watching it. It's the most complete iron production process video I've ever seen, actually. I think you guys should wear masks when crushing the roasted ore and ear protection when hammering the iron. Not for safety, but for your health! Thank you so much for sharing this precious knowledge and craftsmanship.

Thank you guys that was amazing work and educational

this looks fun, learning a lot over here. hope to make it my first tool from my forge this summer

@stephenmankowski3679

22 күн бұрын

Thank you! It is fun !

amazing video. Thank you so much for uploading it to KZread so me and others in the younger generation can watch it. I can see how much work went into making this film

Great 👍 I love this stuff. And one day i will try this.

Impressive from every angle. Which material hasn't been be available to western blacksmiths for 200 years? Iron blooms?

@danielwebb1004

Ай бұрын

I'll guess he means wrought iron which is actually wrought out of a bloom vs. modern processes, but I barely know anything about this subject.

video ini membuat saya ingin sekali mencobanya, di tempat saya banyak sekali batu besi, terimakasih sudah membagi video ini..

Very interesting video, thank you so much for this experience

WOW!! Just WOW!!!! 👍

Wow. Thank you so much for this film gentlemen, may God bless you.

I really enjoyed watching y'all work. I do have a question. When converting the iron bloom into steel, would a crucible have been a better option to produce a higher quality steel?

Incredible

What an amazing video! What a truly incredible journey Major kudos to this team! Thanks!

you guys are ledgends

This was great! Thank you for the high level of explanation!

Just made my own blast furnace, going to melt down some pre I found next week. Do I need to be concerned about the fire getting TOO hot?

Such a good video, thank you for the excellent explanations to go with the meticulous footage

Well done! Thank you for sharing.

Great job

Kudos, awesome video👌

Great film, thanks for sharing! Inspiring. Can't wait to use the iron I got from you :)

Excellent production! Thank y'all for taking the time for a great video!

Great job on the ore, and great video!

Nicely done folks. A well made video of an amazing process. Love to see it.

Old fired pots contain grog too

Wonderful video fellas. An excellent look at the historical production of iron axes. I've been fascinated with smithing for years and I love the historical stuff that revolves around it. I also have a question about the music in this video. Who are the musicians and where can I find more of their music specifically around the 15min point

Get an e-ssist electric trolley. They're really good for outdoor stuff. Essentially an electric, all terrain wheelbarrow.

@stephenmankowski3679

2 ай бұрын

Thanks for the tip!

What an amazing documentary!

@stephenmankowski3679

Жыл бұрын

Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it.

I don't get the rationale behind the attempt to infuse carbon into the bloom by heating it a second time. When the ore is being smelted into the bloom, wasn't it already in a high carbon environment with all that charcoal surrounding it? what's the difference between that and the second time? I thought carbon would only dissolve into steel when it was in the liquid form?

great

grog is any prefired ceramic material not just furnace lining.

Maybe I need to rewatch it But during the reheat process to make it steel, was it the first made bar of iron placed into the pit and then heated with the slag or was this the iron pills potentially in the slag reheated to make a new bar of ore?

@jacobmarshall5391

3 ай бұрын

I think the latter

Excellent video! Have some young men we will show it to. Blessings

I have a couple of questions. Do you know approx. How long the total manufacturing time would be from start to finish. Also did they ever just drift the complete eyehole like they do today? Thanks, loved this video.

@stephenmankowski3679

Жыл бұрын

Jason, it’s about 3-4 hours from the pre heat of the furnace to the removal of the bloom. The folding and welding plus drifting is the most common method we see from past methods using wrought iron. But slitting and drifting works with good quality iron and certainly mild steel. Steve

@tijlaerts

Жыл бұрын

Because of the grain in wrought iron its more likely to split the bar if you slit/punch and drift to shape. If it's high quality wrought it can be done but there is more risk. Doing everything from scratch like this would take at least like 30 hours or so, probably more.

What an amazing and fascinating video! Quick question: Wouldn't it offer the finished axe head a little bit of protection to hot blue it in oil? Rust is the enemy of every ferrous metal. Just curious!

How did you train the dog though?

Again, amazing film. I have a question. Could the axe head be made entirely out of steel with no wrought iron?

The film seems to be very authentic. Unhappily, although quite used to english clips in general and iron forging in special, I couldn´t understand more than half of the statements, due to strong accent.

@onanysundrymule3144

9 ай бұрын

You might like to try using the closed captions option, either in English or in you own language.

What rocks did you use

What did you use to find the general area for locating iron ore because I'm having a hard time finding info about my state

@stephenmankowski3679

Жыл бұрын

The area in this region of Virginia was in the early 19th century a very large iron producing center. There are many blast furnace sites and plenty of abandoned ore mines not far away. Check your state’s geological history and iron making history. Steve

@tiresomekarma4054

Жыл бұрын

@@stephenmankowski3679 Thank you for the extra info Steve. Have a blessed day

@jacobmarshall5391

3 ай бұрын

​@@stephenmankowski3679Truly?! I live in the Appalachian mountains in VA. Im assuming that that is where this is filmed. So there is a good source of iron here? I was skeptical about trying this out, because I didn't know if there was a viable source of ore here, but my spirits are somewhat lifted. Excellent craftsmanship, and thank you for the abundance of knowledge. Cheers!

Subbed

@ore dog productions I wanted to ask you guys about this primitive channels. I’m thinking they’re mostly fake, but, after watching the process by you, I’m almost sure they are. I want to ask you because you know this subject very well and I’m sure you could give a definite answer. I can’t post links here, but, one of the channels that does a lot of iron and tools from it, is called, primitive skills. I’m not sure that you would even see this comment, but, if you do, I’ll be very grateful and honored to know what you think. Thanks in advance if you take the time.

👏👍

Did that dog really sniff out the ore or are you guys just messing with me? And where is this? What state?

@canadiangemstones7636

7 ай бұрын

It works. If you want to find gold ore, use a golden retriever.

@jacobmarshall5391

3 ай бұрын

​@@canadiangemstones7636😂

It look like tamahagane

As soon as he got out the large steel lump hammer to smash the ore I was disappointed.... was hoping for a more authentic process than a "let's use tools to make tools we already have which are probably better than what I'M making" video...

Africans do this with less tools… Spiritually at that.

@canadiangemstones7636

7 ай бұрын

Please make a video of you smelting iron, would love to see it.

less than 5 seconds showing the finished axe? thumbs down 👎👎👎

@danielwebb1004

Ай бұрын

I would have liked to see a lot more about that too.