This is the most informative review of the new charcoal cleansing balm I’ve seen thus far. It’s helped me decide to to stick w the original as I have extremely dry and somewhat sensitive skin. Thank you!

@AmyAstridBeauty

Жыл бұрын

That’s so sweet, thank you! So glad it helped you 💕

Thanks for the video. I bought the small version and I threw the box away and the jar doesn’t have instructions. Also this is the most informative video about this make up remover 😊

I came here to to decide if i want the original. I got the small charcoal one as a free gift with purchase. I've decided on the original formula after hearing seeing review.

Yay! You're back on KZread! I like your cosmetics videos. It's so much easier to watch and save them on KZread and refer back to them. I like the product info that you gave. Would you use it, or other skincare, everyday for a month and let us know your thoughts? You look fabulous btw, loving the hair!!

@AmyAstridBeauty

Жыл бұрын

Thank you Kara! Yes, most of the reviews I make sure to have used the product for an extended period before I give my final thoughts. Usually it’s in production for around a month before I post it so I can make sure that my final thoughts are representative of extended use (I’m super ahead of filming right now so I’m trying things out which likely won’t be posted until April). I only tend to show the first impressions to keep the video length down but the final thoughts at the end usually do incorporate those thoughts. This one I don’t think I would use every day for a month because it’s not quite the right fit for my skin type but I’ve used the original formula for years so can definitely vouch for that one! 🖤

Hello! I just discovered your channel because of this video (loved it and already subscribed!). I just tried the charcoal version of the cleansing balm and I completely agree with you. Because I have combination skin, the original formula suits me better. I will save the charcoal one for warmer days and for when my skin looks more oily.

u explaind really good, my mather language isn't english but I am undertand you perfectly. Thank you for your exhaustive explanation

Instantly subscribed after your video. Thank you

Thank you for this video. Very informative. Greetings from Mexico!

Very informative video. I’ve been waiting for this video. Thanks! Ps I loved your outfit in the opening.

@AmyAstridBeauty

Жыл бұрын

Thank you Lisa! So glad you enjoyed the video 🖤

Hi there! 👋 I am so glad you reviewed this product. I am a super fan of the original take the day off and so I bought this on a whim when it first came out. I have oily skin and thought it would be a good fit. It's just ok to me. It didn't wow me like I thought. I agree it seems much harsher. Since I bought it and it's not terrible, I use it every 3rd day on my skin just so I can make my cleansing balm last longer.

@AmyAstridBeauty

Жыл бұрын

Thanks so much for sharing this! Seems like we have a similar view. I will use it sometimes but it definitely hasn’t replaced the original for me 🖤

@sunshinehoover4630

Жыл бұрын

@Amy Astrid Beauty I just found your channel a few months ago and we seem to have the same views on all of clinique products (except 1, I do not like the moisture surge 100h. It leaves my skin so sticky! )

@sunshinehoover4630

Жыл бұрын

P.S. thank you for the replies ❤️

Thank you for your review and demonstration Amy. I absolutely love how clear and concise you are during your review. You left no details. My question is does this stain your skin and wash clothes? I absolutely despise a products that just stains everything. I’ve tried the Peter Thomas Roth charcoal mask it was black mess. Sink was black and wash clothes was stained. Since then I’ve shy myself away from charcoal products. I pretty much have dry skin so I’m not too sure if I will try this product. I use the original take the balm off and it leaves my face squeaky clean. I feel like the charcoal one will make it feel stripped. I’ve tried the take the day off liquid cleaners and I felt like it was too liquid of a texture. I had to take that one best asap. Plus the bottle was leaky as well. Therefore the balm is best in my choice. If you continue to use it and have any changes please update us, thanks ☺️

@wplants9793

Жыл бұрын

Does not stain at all. Probably why she didn’t mention it staining , it’s such a non issue with the product. Super easy to rinse off, washes right out of white clothes too no problem

@shauntelowe2

Жыл бұрын

@@wplants9793 thanks for replying. I’m looking forward to trying it in the future.

Thanks heaps Amy 🤗 am curious to try this, my face is fresh glowing an matte in morning after regime,but come 12pm I'm wiping my sides of nose and tzone, and Sydney's hot right now, bless blotting papers!!! Luv watching ur vids keep up great work, might go to Clinique and get trial size charcoal today, thanks sweetie luv from ducky Sydney xoxo

@AmyAstridBeauty

Жыл бұрын

Sounds like it could be a really good fit for you if you have an oily skin type. Hope you love it! So glad you enjoyed the video 🖤

Here for Clinique 🎉❤ do you have a video on their lash enhancement serum ? If it works or not. I’m running out of my babe lash serum. Thanks Girl :) if not would love one bc I love your Clinique reviews

@AmyAstridBeauty

Жыл бұрын

Ooh I didn’t even know they had a lash serum! I’ll look into it. My fave lash serum is iglow xx

Have you tried Softymo Kose Speedy Cleansing Oil, ELF Holy Hydration Balm or Juno & Co Cleansing Balm?

you are so pretty ❤❤

Texto en español por favor

Sadly this is my favorite makeup remover by far. Sadly because it is so expensive and I never want to be without it! It’s the only remover my kids will tolerate to get sunscreen or face paint off their faces. If I use any other type they hate it.