New AI may threaten 'safe' office jobs, say researchers | BBC News

Humans already work alongside robots in industries such as manufacturing.
Now, for knowledge workers, the threat of AI (artificial intelligence) replacement is coming faster than they imagined.
In early 2023, OpenAI's ChatGPT ushered in a new era - one in which AI went from a pipe dream to a very real, contentious issue for workers.
The stakes are high: an April report from Goldman Sachs estimates ChatGPT, and other similar generative AI tools, could increase global GDP by as much as 7%, while replacing 300 million full time workers.
Yet the light-speed adoption and evolution of generative AI tools may now mean knowledge-work jobs that were long considered "safe" could be threatened even faster than workers anticipated.
That includes creative positions that many presumed would be hard to automate, in fields like marketing, music production and graphic design.
Accordingly, researchers have found that the "exposure curve is upward-sloping", says Mark Muro, a senior fellow at The Brookings Institution, who focuses on the interplay of technology, people and places.
Please subscribe here: bit.ly/1rbfUog
#AI #ChatGPT #BBCNews

Пікірлер: 459

  • @AxstroNetwork
    @AxstroNetwork8 ай бұрын

    AI will be taking over from whoever is in responsible for this audio quality. Shocking.

  • @oliverrevis4190

    @oliverrevis4190

    8 ай бұрын

    Ikr lol

  • @ai.ryan686

    @ai.ryan686

    8 ай бұрын

    ​@@oliverrevis4190ikr ?

  • @ehza

    @ehza

    8 ай бұрын

    Fair, lmaooo

  • @Borsi666

    @Borsi666

    7 ай бұрын

    Maybe it is already the AI, thats why this awful quality :D

  • @TheGreenReaper

    @TheGreenReaper

    7 ай бұрын

    They did say that there was a mic problem - perhaps a battery died suddenly?

  • @PK-999
    @PK-9998 ай бұрын

    Your employer, beholden to its investors, will do whatever it can to reduce costs. You are one of those costs. If your job is anything that can be boiled down to a set of rules, it will be replaced by automated systems. Although, once the investor/owner/Billionaire class realises this also applies to CEO's, CFO's etc, they will be tossed away like the rest of us........

  • @michaelcarr3037

    @michaelcarr3037

    8 ай бұрын

    Absolutely and she kept bringing up retraining I question what jobs will they be retrained for ? And that go's for education they say everyone will have their personal ai professor to gain higher learning and for what ? why hire the student when you can have the teacher at a fraction of the cost and can work 24 7 with no complaints

  • @mikefox1932

    @mikefox1932

    8 ай бұрын

    Plumbers and elder home care staff @@michaelcarr3037

  • @AX-sq5vm

    @AX-sq5vm

    8 ай бұрын

    Tax them

  • @judithsullivan9703

    @judithsullivan9703

    8 ай бұрын

    Timed work didn't work out for the textile mill owners in the 1900s the rates for accidental deaths skyrocketed. Business owners in the 1940s, across all disciplines, using timed tasks for employees, then the owners demanded faster performance to save their costs. Sane work environments be damned more profit!

  • @dw4525

    @dw4525

    8 ай бұрын

    It’s actually more than jobs that can be “boiled down to a set of rules”. True AI is a lot more powerful than that.

  • @madoksback
    @madoksback8 ай бұрын

    Poor audio! come on BBC

  • @rammingspeed5217

    @rammingspeed5217

    8 ай бұрын

    They should get an A. I to do the audio 😂

  • @skycloud4802

    @skycloud4802

    8 ай бұрын

    All their money probably spent covering up another presenter.

  • @winstoningram99

    @winstoningram99

    7 ай бұрын

    Come on them?

  • @TheGreenReaper

    @TheGreenReaper

    7 ай бұрын

    Mic died?

  • @purpleowl2075
    @purpleowl20758 ай бұрын

    'No one feels sorry for lawyers' lmao

  • @6whatnext

    @6whatnext

    8 ай бұрын

    Or journalists

  • @Greenleaves-pf2xn

    @Greenleaves-pf2xn

    7 ай бұрын

    Exactly they have enough money. We don’t care for super empowered lawyers or accountants. What about others ? How will the rest of us survive. Knowing most of what we do is so automatable how do you even feel pride for your own work. Whne a machine can replace you at any point. Career just seems like a waste of time in the world of ai. Like can we not be any more insecure. 😂

  • @vitalyl1327

    @vitalyl1327

    7 ай бұрын

    ​@@Greenleaves-pf2xnthouse in automatable jobs knew it all along, that there is no creativity whatsoever in what they do. They will he relieved to get rid of such demeaning jobs.

  • @BlueNightfall

    @BlueNightfall

    4 ай бұрын

    ​@@vitalyl1327 actually AI is more creative than humans. I mean speaking about the pharmaceutical sector. If you mean other sorts of arts, I don't know about

  • @julia2k8
    @julia2k88 ай бұрын

    These Amazon bot comments have become a meme at this point

  • @ninjaweretiger4273

    @ninjaweretiger4273

    8 ай бұрын

    Seems like it.

  • @michaelwisniewski6047

    @michaelwisniewski6047

    8 ай бұрын

    It's the first time I see them but immediately thought: bots. Oh no, now human trolls will have to be compensated for being replaced with AI...

  • @instalocktaka9628

    @instalocktaka9628

    8 ай бұрын

    I haven't seen a single meme based on these bot comments but I get what you're saying

  • @TheGreenReaper

    @TheGreenReaper

    7 ай бұрын

    You should contact Mr. Bezos, he is the unrivaled expert in the field. 👍

  • @MiguelCantu-mr2vx
    @MiguelCantu-mr2vx8 ай бұрын

    Some people will not have a job because of AI. It is already here people.😢😮

  • @richard7645

    @richard7645

    8 ай бұрын

    How we going to live? Oh wait they don't care about that

  • @ninjaweretiger4273

    @ninjaweretiger4273

    8 ай бұрын

    @@AvaAdore-wx5ggAI can take art away. I had one jerk steal my art this way.

  • @ninjaweretiger4273

    @ninjaweretiger4273

    8 ай бұрын

    @@AvaAdore-wx5gg Oh and I have a high functioning learning disability. Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. I use art as a form of therapy. Abusive foster siblings and an abusive priest caused serious issues for me as a kid… I’m also Métis partly indigenous from Canada. Intergenerational trauma is a thing… Way to make me feel terrible.

  • @jr-yn4lk

    @jr-yn4lk

    7 ай бұрын

    Some people ? More like 99% of all people.

  • @jr-yn4lk

    @jr-yn4lk

    7 ай бұрын

    @@richard7645 They do care. Their plan is once automation reaches 100%, humans will be exterminated.

  • @catzov
    @catzov8 ай бұрын

    Your best friend can be AI that listens & records your deepest secrets. Totally will never be misused & used against you! 😅

  • @ackerwoman16

    @ackerwoman16

    6 ай бұрын

    I really hope this comment is a joke if not then it's dangerously misleading.... don't take it personal just informing

  • @smkh2890
    @smkh28908 ай бұрын

    An AI sports writer reflected: "the two teams started out on an equal footing, with a zero-zero goal score."

  • @PaulGrayUK
    @PaulGrayUK8 ай бұрын

    The level of competence/common sense and basic initiative in offices, from a customer perspective, has seen and enabled a level of sheer and utter incompetence. Replace them all as tired of suffering fools.

  • @WillyJunior

    @WillyJunior

    8 ай бұрын

    Amen.

  • @spikehamer2

    @spikehamer2

    7 ай бұрын

    Now from a office perspective sometimes we want to help the customer but there are things that are out of our control and said customer gets aggravated, it's pretty goddamn infuriating too on our end. I do wish this kind of line of work do get automated ASAP, call centers are just the bottom of the barrel of jobs.

  • @PaulGrayUK

    @PaulGrayUK

    7 ай бұрын

    @@spikehamer2 Oh I get the aspect of some things are out of control and only cause grief like getting sacked as `office politics and HR` are a fickle beast. But dam, some of the stuff had to endure that used to be the exception has become the norm is scary. Still, think of the people who have to support the people doing support, then the people who have to support those people as 3rd line, end of the line. That's where the fun work is to be had and mostly the brains. But hey, I get why, the level of pay and opportunity and remuneration for going the extra mile are totally not there. More case of keeping head down, don't stand out and get rewarded more.

  • @TheBHAitken
    @TheBHAitken8 ай бұрын

    LOL Just learning this now? The truth is that if what you produce is done at a desk, you can and will be replaced by about $5000 of hardware.

  • @Chrisbush1
    @Chrisbush18 ай бұрын

    The field of Agriculture is widely opened 😊

  • @jiraya350
    @jiraya3508 ай бұрын

    She’s incredibly optimistic. Emphasis on incredible.

  • @micksylvestre2887

    @micksylvestre2887

    7 ай бұрын

    Because she believes that artificial intelligence (AI) will replace the careeres and creatives who have been producing material for years, including online literature and languages, in the same way as Macs eliminated many print jobs and service bureaus in the 1980s. We give the technoarchy far too much power.

  • @Indrid__Cold
    @Indrid__Cold7 ай бұрын

    Retraining will perpetually struggle to keep pace with advancements in AI. Once self-improving AI becomes a norm, all knowledge workers worldwide will face risks. Regardless of the new jobs for which people are trained, AI will outperform them. Physical jobs, such as sewer work or extermination, will remain in demand due to the greater complexity and capital intensity of robotics compared to knowledge work. It is challenging to find a mid-level manager willing to switch to a job that involves physical labor.

  • @Indrid__Cold

    @Indrid__Cold

    7 ай бұрын

    @@user-qd4xs8zb8s Well, I'm retired and financially secure. That doesn't mean I don't have kids and grandkids I care for and worry about. I would love to believe that AI will be the ultimate achievement that will finally free humanity from the monotony of employment. Then I come up against the question of "what will people actually do" once they are free from wage slavery? When the North freed the slaves, this became quite a problem for THEM. So what to do? Make art? Good luck with that, when AI has already demonstrated that it can produce creative results in any of the arts that a biological manure machine might spend a lifetime replicating at 20% of the quality level of a minimally capable AI. As much as we love expressions like "human potential" and "each life is precious," the reality is far less poetic. Planet earth will soon have way, WAY more hairless monkies than it needs, and quite possibly more than the planet can easily support. And while this isn't necessarily a problem that AI cannot solve, I must again ask "to what end?" I have my thoughts on this, but no one with a wet-ware brain is going to like it (at least not initially). AI will soon be able to create the formula for virtually any drug compound one might desire. It will soon likely be able to create drugs that will keep the human pleasure centers sparking with activity 24/7. Baring that, some form of imersive VR might make every human the god of their own self conceived universe. I've likely prattled on far too long about this, but consider one or two of the bigger questions I've posited.

  • @canaldemais
    @canaldemais7 ай бұрын

    They should have got AI to microphone her correctly

  • @liamwilson7549
    @liamwilson75498 ай бұрын

    No no, not “may” if there is even a possibility it could it will threaten sage jobs.

  • @oscarmora4919
    @oscarmora49198 ай бұрын

    It is a very interesting video, but sadly, it has a tremendous audio problem

  • @crowmack
    @crowmack7 ай бұрын

    The audio is terrible.

  • @NikoKun
    @NikoKun7 ай бұрын

    This is going to be a much bigger issue than they realize, for which merely retraining people will not be enough. AI is going to displace a shocking amount of jobs, some forecasts suggest nearly a QUARTER of the workforce could be looking at being out competed by AI, by 2030! It's not going to create tons of new jobs either, as some dismissively suggest, what could it create that it couldn't also do itself? It'll create a few jobs, for a few people, but not the kinds of jobs that will re-employ all those displaced. We need to start thinking about new economic standards, and how to transition to them. We should probably tax AI as it takes over labor, and use that to fund an AI Dividend for all, or an Unconditional Basic Income tied to AI. By the way, the jobs of these reporters may very well be the next thing to go, within a year or so. If the Channel1 ai promo that just came out, is any indicator.

  • @kyliemiu
    @kyliemiu8 ай бұрын

    I don't think accountants will be affected as much. You can't train AI to cook the books.

  • @MukonkiMukonkela

    @MukonkiMukonkela

    8 ай бұрын

    😂😂

  • @jr-yn4lk

    @jr-yn4lk

    7 ай бұрын

    Sorry, mate. Most office jobs are dumb easy for IA

  • @kyliemiu

    @kyliemiu

    7 ай бұрын

    @@jr-yn4lk you clearly did not get the joke

  • @micksylvestre2887
    @micksylvestre28877 ай бұрын

    I love how she downplayed the impact AI will taken over and dispersed jobs in the same manner that Macintosh has eliminated the majority of jobs in the print and service industries in the late 80s.

  • @kevinb9830
    @kevinb98308 ай бұрын

    It's going to threaten nearly every job. I'm pretty convinced now that the universal basic income thing is going to happen. I can't see any way around it.

  • @RovexHD

    @RovexHD

    8 ай бұрын

    It won’t replace traditional crafts and arts, which have under appreciated and underpaid for years.

  • @TheGreenReaper

    @TheGreenReaper

    7 ай бұрын

    ​@@RovexHD It probably won't want more people want them either, though.

  • @chrisstucker1813

    @chrisstucker1813

    7 ай бұрын

    universal basic income is the only solution unless we create new jobs. But we won't be able to create new jobs at the same rate that AI is destroying them. If no one has income then the economy will fall apart, UBI is the only answer.

  • @kevinb9830

    @kevinb9830

    7 ай бұрын

    @@chrisstucker1813 Nonsense. That will make us completely unproductive. Most people would choose not to work, and to make up for the massive lack of production the price of everything would go up.

  • @dantae666
    @dantae6667 ай бұрын

    As the office worker's said to all the other professions who lost there jobs. Shame.

  • @prashantabdare6479
    @prashantabdare64798 ай бұрын

    I think she or someone at BBC forgot to attach mic to her.

  • @prashantabdare6479

    @prashantabdare6479

    8 ай бұрын

    that might not have happened if it's AI.

  • @AlexTourkin
    @AlexTourkin7 ай бұрын

    I don't think AI is the problem, I think it is our current society's adaptation mechanisms that become obsolete. Taxing AI technology and using that resource to help people to retrain, and universal basic income to ensure basic survival level (and less stress in society that is bad for everyone!!) is a way forward, I believe.

  • @markmuller7962

    @markmuller7962

    7 ай бұрын

    Absolutely, people wasting time and energy protesting against progress instead of advocating for a decent welfare for everyone

  • @aceyage

    @aceyage

    7 ай бұрын

    Equal wealth distribution, not UBI. UBI is just feudalism.

  • @NikoKun

    @NikoKun

    7 ай бұрын

    I've been saying this for a while now.. Eventually AI will become "super intelligent", and when it does, average workers won't be able to compete for an income against that, it'll be hard for average humans to create "value" in the eyes of businesses.. Our very core justifications, for how our society distributes basic resources to people, HAS to change.. And at the rate things are likely to happen, we need to be making these changes, before the end of this decade! Policymakers are currently clueless, or deny it to get as rich as they can before people wake up.

  • @Gerlaffy

    @Gerlaffy

    7 ай бұрын

    Yep let's start the transition to a much more relaxing and free society.

  • @Betty-dimple

    @Betty-dimple

    6 ай бұрын

    😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😂nbpp ok😂😂

  • @rey82rey82
    @rey82rey828 ай бұрын

    Replace your audio team with AI

  • @realfreedom8932
    @realfreedom89326 ай бұрын

    A Job by definition is following a set of rules and procedures. So most jobs will be automated. There will be a tiny percentage of jobs required to maintain the systems

  • @thaotaylor6669
    @thaotaylor66697 ай бұрын

    Yeah and the Government is not acknowledge this, soon things will changes for every companies to safe cost.

  • @johnlock1398
    @johnlock13988 ай бұрын

    It is so great that those who created it do not know how it works so they do not have any control over this, and so dynamic progres of this creation is other scary thing. It is like we had knife that thinks and makes decisions independently of humane being

  • @micksylvestre2887

    @micksylvestre2887

    7 ай бұрын

    Like giving children anthrax to play with in public.

  • @extraincomesuz
    @extraincomesuz7 ай бұрын

    I work online with e-commerce running a English learning website. It used to take me 3 days to create a video and another day to create a lesson plan/script and worksheet download. Now I can get one completed in a day with AI. This has freed up a lot of time so I can concentrate on SEO and marketing. I love it. I think it will free us up and people shouldn't be expected to take on more, but use the freed time to do other good work for their company.

  • @OculusGame
    @OculusGame8 ай бұрын

    Good, wasting ~35% off your life working shouldn't be a thing. TIME is the only currency that matters now.

  • @turdferguson12

    @turdferguson12

    3 ай бұрын

    35%😂😂😂 more like about 70%. A job pretty much ruins M-F.

  • @containedhurricane
    @containedhurricane8 ай бұрын

    I think AI will threaten human resource department jobs. It could also be used to replace hospitality industry workers, if we can get solar power with more efficient and cheaper methods

  • @intricatic

    @intricatic

    7 ай бұрын

    Thank goodness. I hate HR people.

  • @jr-yn4lk

    @jr-yn4lk

    7 ай бұрын

    It will end all kinds of jobs, manual or office jobs.

  • @containedhurricane

    @containedhurricane

    7 ай бұрын

    @@jr-yn4lk I hope so. It'd be nice to live without working, as shown in Wall-E movie

  • @jr-yn4lk

    @jr-yn4lk

    7 ай бұрын

    @@containedhurricane Yeah, living a life without work like in 'Wall-E' sounds amazing. But realistically, if we get to where all jobs are automated, I really doubt the corporate elite will just start giving out free money for us all to live on. As cool as a universal basic income sounds, I have this gnawing feeling that when humans aren't needed for work anymore, those with power might consider the human population as more of a burden. It's a dark thought, but it's possible they might even attempt to cull the human race.

  • @chrisstucker1813

    @chrisstucker1813

    7 ай бұрын

    It will replace everyone eventually and will become cheaper to implement over time. Remember that the first computer cost millions to make, had barely any memory and filled up an entire room. Whereas right now have smartphones that are incomparably more powerful, cost a few hundred dollars to manufacture and can fit into your pocket. We managed to achieve of all this with just the human brain, so imagine what we will be able to accomplish with very intelligent AI brains helping us discover cheaper methods to produce powerful robots etc. It's scary to think about but hopefully still a few decades away

  • @andersfant4997
    @andersfant49977 ай бұрын

    Of course we will have (high) basic income in 5-7 years. Very few new jobs will be created, everybody knows this🙈

  • @Stanleyknif3
    @Stanleyknif37 ай бұрын

    AI can replace the BBC that cant come soon enough.

  • @callumbush1

    @callumbush1

    7 ай бұрын

    Nobody wouldn't even notice any difference and they wouldn't have to pay out astronomical salaries to the talking head propagandists either!

  • @AlbertKimMusic
    @AlbertKimMusic8 ай бұрын

    This felt like some GTA radio broadcast…

  • @julianparkinson2178
    @julianparkinson21788 ай бұрын

    is the sound engineer on holiday?

  • @judithsullivan9703
    @judithsullivan97038 ай бұрын

    And didn't that work out 75 years ago. Business timed tasks and demanded faster performance.Wait til CEOs get canned 😅 ! Sane work performance be damned more profit!

  • @jamisony
    @jamisony7 ай бұрын

    When McDonald’s automated their customer service, the price of the service did not drop. Would be interesting to know how much the hardware and software cost?

  • @alanteale7834
    @alanteale78348 ай бұрын

    Very poor sound quality

  • @Indrid__Cold
    @Indrid__Cold7 ай бұрын

    Jobs that emphasize skills once deemed essential, such as communication skills, will not be entirely eliminated but will significantly lose value. For instance, MSDOS proficiency was once highly sought after, but the advent of MSWINDOWS rendered it less important. Similarly, the ability to compose a clear and actionable email will soon be regarded as a supplementary skill. Employers globally will likely reduce the value of entire categories of workers by 50% or more. Like skilled factory jobs that used to sustain a family of four, mid-level management and similar positions will face substantial devaluation. Those who become unemployed in the coming years may be startled by the reduced salaries offered in their next jobs. The socioeconomic and political consequences of this shift will be profound.

  • @davidgray8321
    @davidgray83218 ай бұрын

    Civilization is collapsing long before AI is advanced enough to do this.

  • @Gerlaffy

    @Gerlaffy

    7 ай бұрын

    What a load of pointless conjecture. You're just saying words with no meaning.

  • @davidgray8321

    @davidgray8321

    7 ай бұрын

    @@Gerlaffy Aw, did my own personal opinion hurt you in the foo-foo? You aren't AI yourself are you?

  • @Gerlaffy

    @Gerlaffy

    7 ай бұрын

    @@davidgray8321 lol, who even are you and why does this matter, I literally don't even care about you. Just enjoy pointing out that someone is just chatting nonsense online

  • @bigash3003
    @bigash30038 ай бұрын

    Maybe AI should also replace the Sound people responsible for mics at the BBC 😉😂

  • @ikotsus2448
    @ikotsus24488 ай бұрын

    Today people provide value to higher class/leadership through production, law enforcement, military etc. Once these are AI we are a button away from being exterminated. And until then monitored 24/7 because the "good guys" with AI would not risk somebody else developing it.

  • @folkengames
    @folkengames7 ай бұрын

    Perhaps you should have asked chat gpt how to mic your guests.

  • @devilzwishbone
    @devilzwishboneАй бұрын

    Yes major issue with the audio

  • @intricatic
    @intricatic7 ай бұрын

    The only jobs under threat are ones that could always easily be done by a computer. Which is about 98% of office jobs. I just read a news article that was written by AI and I wouldn't have known, except the author called the Cold War "...the Chilly War." Lol

  • @jr-yn4lk

    @jr-yn4lk

    7 ай бұрын

    You're forgetting that AI will also greatly accelerate the pace of scientific research. The time it will take for AI to develop smart robots is just 1% of the time it would take humans to develop them. In a few years, all jobs will be automated.

  • @chrisstucker1813

    @chrisstucker1813

    7 ай бұрын

    @@jr-yn4lk too expensive. Not all physical jobs will be automated because it’s sometimes just cheapest to pay human to do it. Especially since wages for blue collar work will tank if the market is now flooded with white collar workers

  • @jr-yn4lk

    @jr-yn4lk

    7 ай бұрын

    @@chrisstucker1813 I think AI is going to speed up research so much that universities and labs will figure out cheaper ways to automate stuff, maybe through new materials or something. Even hands-on jobs like welding and plumbing could see automation. With smarter tech, robots might do these jobs more efficiently and at a lower cost in the long run. Finally, someone mentioned the fact that blue-collar wages might drop due to the market being flooded by people whose jobs have been automated. The 'learn to weld' meme won't have a long shelf life in this case.

  • @chrisstucker1813

    @chrisstucker1813

    7 ай бұрын

    @@jr-yn4lk oh yeah eventually we will figure out ways to produce these robots at a very low cost through scientific research. Just think of the pre von-Neumann architecture ENIAC computer in 1940s that took up an entire room, had barely any memory and cost millions of dollars to build. Compare that with smartphones today that only cost a few hundred dollars to manufacture, are incomparably more advanced in terms of processing power and can fit into your trouser pocket! I read that it would take 600,000 of those room-sized computers to match the processing power of the iphone 14. The advancements in technology we’ve made since then are incredible and it was all done by the human-brain - so imagine the strides that advanced artificial intelligence will help us make. It’s going to be wild

  • @4mb127
    @4mb1277 ай бұрын

    Why the hell should there be compensation? Is there compensation for me as a private business owner when someone creates a better product? The whole concept is absurd. Also another solution: higher taxes? That's stupid beyond belief.

  • @markistheone947
    @markistheone9477 ай бұрын

    Did they compensate people in the typewriter industry? Or flip phone, or black and white tv, horse carriage conductors and the list goes on. Mic drop.

  • @user-iu7ec6je1g
    @user-iu7ec6je1g8 ай бұрын

    OT:Benny Hill considered funnier than Monty Python by two TV stations--WOR and WLVI.

  • @wearetemporary
    @wearetemporary8 ай бұрын

    Can’t believe how present and distracting the room sound of the studio is in the presenter’s mic. Whoever the sound engineer was for this session might make a good candidate for a future AI replacement :). In the interim, Waves and Sonible already have some solid AI-assisted plugins on the market that remove room reverb convincingly without artifacts. No need to sound like Wayne’s World recorded in a basement.

  • @Angela-cc1hd
    @Angela-cc1hd2 ай бұрын

    Why is the Home Office bringing in the" Incubator for Artificial Intelligence " regardless of many people ( including Technologists and Entrepreneurs) being highly sceptical of this scenario, which could be a dangerous route to go down😮

  • @yumnax
    @yumnax7 ай бұрын

    Let AI replace us. Why keep workers around just to keep them around if AI could do it better? It’s a waste of money and a waste of the workers time. He is literally doing useless work. However we need a UBI that ensures more than the bare minimum of housing, heating and food. And most likely AI will enhance high skilled workers but by doing so replaces probably 50% of the colleagues. If one lawyer can do the job of 5 lawyers why keep those other 5 around? UBI is the way to go. More people would have time to also become entrepreneurs and can create start ups. Others could use their time to help out their communities. Others would use the time to stay with the kids and partake really in their lives. If UBI recipients are forced to do unnecessary work to „earn“ their money than that is absolute nonsense. Why force them to do again unnecessary work? And some jobs would still exist so I could see some UBI recipients using their free time to learn new skills to do that work if the want more than just the UBI.

  • @blueguitar4419
    @blueguitar44198 ай бұрын

    But the Nordic countries are not Britain, we have to do it the British way! Austerity!

  • @TomNook.
    @TomNook.8 ай бұрын

    Someone give Stephanie a microphone

  • @johnnysomebodyjohnny
    @johnnysomebodyjohnny7 ай бұрын

    Maybe sound person was replaced with AI,

  • @neroetal
    @neroetal7 ай бұрын

    Well articulated interview

  • @flocore
    @flocore7 ай бұрын

    Audio engineer was on his lunch break during this interview...

  • @lawrencebishton9071
    @lawrencebishton90717 ай бұрын

    why would any 1 put sum 1 in a Cab,i,net

  • @RepairBeyond
    @RepairBeyond8 ай бұрын

    Aka. you're going to need UBI sooner than you think. The foundation of modern capitalism is that there is value in work, when that's not the case anymore because AI will do any kind of work, that system ceases to function for humanity. Of course it's going to take quite a while before _everything_ can be done by AI, but depending on how AGI develops that may be way sooner than you think.

  • @jr-yn4lk

    @jr-yn4lk

    7 ай бұрын

    "you're going to need UBI sooner than you think." I disagree. I don't know why you think corporate elites would act benevolently towards humanity. Do you really believe they are kind and charitable enough to sustain people who have become utterly redundant in the world? As soon as job automation approaches 100%, these elites will likely eradicate the human race, leaving the planet solely for themselves.

  • @chrisstucker1813

    @chrisstucker1813

    7 ай бұрын

    Yeah UBI won’t happen overnight - which is worrying.

  • @ttrev007
    @ttrev0077 ай бұрын

    hopefully it just increases the productivity of peoples jobs. Like computers did for office work.

  • @Indrid__Cold

    @Indrid__Cold

    7 ай бұрын

    Computers also eliminated jobs. Have you seen many "secretaries" lately?9

  • @NorthSea-xb7jk
    @NorthSea-xb7jk8 ай бұрын

    very good sound

  • @sibastien91
    @sibastien917 ай бұрын

    When it comes to the translation of ancient texts in languages that nobody speaks.. If the AI made mistakes or misunderstood nuance.. How would we know???

  • @airmusiclab
    @airmusiclab8 ай бұрын

    Nothing is clear. but it's very interesting!

  • @headofmyself5663
    @headofmyself56638 ай бұрын

    Countries with the highest level of automation tend to have the lowest unemployement rates. Besides, it needs a lot of effort to make AI systems work. In supervised learning for industrial image computation for example, you need expert knowledge about the processes for labeling and verification in order to improve your models. Therefore, jobs like data curators will occur imho. The skill sets will be different and i would guess that education will be the key. Mindless work will be automated but new jobs are created. Prompt engineering maybe also a good example, since it actually need skills to ask the right questions and also the ability to understand the answers to verify properly their correctness. Greetings from Germany

  • @public.public

    @public.public

    8 ай бұрын

    As if being a data curator isn't mindless work... duh!

  • @greengoblin9567

    @greengoblin9567

    8 ай бұрын

    You are wrong. When they talk about automation lowering wages, they are talking about the automation of manual labor. Ai is a different beast altogether. It is coming for everyone.

  • @thomask837

    @thomask837

    7 ай бұрын

    Ai will curate itself. It will self regulate. Self heal. Self improve. Eventually

  • @henrytjernlund

    @henrytjernlund

    7 ай бұрын

    New jobs will not keep up those lost. The accelerating AI progress will make it difficult to keep up.

  • @jr-yn4lk

    @jr-yn4lk

    7 ай бұрын

    "Countries with the highest level of automation tend to have the lowest unemployement rates." The issue is that AI automation represents a completely different kind of automation than anything we've seen before. It's not just a new tractor or a loom; it's a new form of intelligent life capable of performing any task humans can do. In a few years, the very concept of employment may cease to exist.

  • @thomHD
    @thomHD8 ай бұрын

    An AI correspondent wouldn't forget to put its mic on, for example

  • @callumbush1

    @callumbush1

    7 ай бұрын

    And you wouldn't have to pay astronomical salaries either!

  • @billyliar1614
    @billyliar16147 ай бұрын

    So basically, we'll all be operating the machines

  • @captainbuggernut9565
    @captainbuggernut95658 ай бұрын

    She mentioned different professions, personally ive used it for medical diagnosis. It's better than my GP at figuring out what's, what. Thats the free version too. You can then toss those ideas back to your doctor, whose reaction is frequently thats a really good idea, or I didn't think of that.

  • @shoryabeohar1816
    @shoryabeohar18167 ай бұрын

    Soon news reader replaced by AI😂 Two avataars sitting in news channel office.. reading news with more than 4 languages ..without taking a break😅

  • @lukejones1600
    @lukejones16007 ай бұрын

    AI should replace whomever is doing the audio at the BBC. It could probably replace the presenter and the talking head too.

  • @jonnycattle
    @jonnycattle8 ай бұрын

    Why hire tax instead of the power of market to embrace the division of labour in the AI era?

  • @procrastinateXrok
    @procrastinateXrok7 ай бұрын

    Excited to advance AI and create opportunities!

  • @swamirivers980
    @swamirivers9808 ай бұрын

    People with $ will buy politicians to avoid responsibility DUMP BOTH PARTIES !

  • @lfeb
    @lfeb7 ай бұрын

    People won't have a problem switching careers late in life?

  • @BruceWayne15325
    @BruceWayne153257 ай бұрын

    AI replacing jobs is a good thing. We just need to redefine our concept of currency. In the not too distant future (10-50yrs) we will see AI doing most of the work that humans currently do. A lot of jobs will be lost along the way as AI progresses. The ultimate goal with AI though is to help us evolve from a society that has to work for a living, to being a society that is essentially retired from birth, and free to pursue whatever interest we want. The concept of economy won't disappear, but it needs to be redefined in preparation for this event.

  • @markcynic808
    @markcynic8088 ай бұрын

    Newsreader's will be the first to go.

  • @pietro5856
    @pietro58567 ай бұрын

    But in short term AI will increase the productivity of the workers , if before for a skilled works occurred 5 people , with ai now they can do it 3 people with same time and maybe in the future one person can make the work of five or more…. So less skilled workers needed ……..

  • @elonthun8012
    @elonthun80128 ай бұрын

    Exactly what it’s designed for

  • @NorthSea-xb7jk
    @NorthSea-xb7jk8 ай бұрын

    Seems AI already overtook BBC sound enineer's work

  • @fredo1070
    @fredo10708 ай бұрын

    I await the time for AI News Readers.

  • @DaleHartley

    @DaleHartley

    8 ай бұрын

    Just go to a lot of KZread news programs ;) they are in pretty wide use, and they have MUCH better ones for business purposes

  • @knockedoutloaded

    @knockedoutloaded

    8 ай бұрын

    They're talking heads making sure the narrative is adhered to

  • @DaleHartley

    @DaleHartley

    8 ай бұрын

    Let me share from my most recent AI class. My instructor mentioned that they were looking for a new car...and approached a certain dealership. They contacted a salesman and asked about this and that over the phone... that salesman (well sales woman by the voice and name) answered, followed up, and kept keeping in touch. even after they had bought a car somewhere else. After receiving one of HER emails, they decided to call her again to make sure she knew she was wasting her time. They got a different sales person, and laughed at them. politely mind you. They told my instructor that the "person" they had talked to and the follow up emails were all AI, and that it was not a real person. By not buying the vehicle there, the AI had not hit the "operation done" switch basically and kept trying to sell them a car. Now, my instructor is IN the AI field, they are also educated enough to TEACH AI at a collegiate level. They never suspected that their sales woman was an AI. not in her speech, nor her emails. It is already there to where you are listening to it and do not know it. What you hear and understand is comp generated is the BOTTOM of current abilities. The top is MUCH better. There are quite a few language models that are just for that...learning and replicating normal speech LLM, NLP are just two of the major forms ( large language models, and natural language processing) that we covered in class. They are part of the learning AI stuff...again though they do not create per se... they replicate and adapt what is already there. BUT they ARE good, and are only going to get better. You have a good one, and look up your news reader ;)

  • @instalocktaka9628

    @instalocktaka9628

    8 ай бұрын

    AI is error free so if it's a narrative that needs adhering too the rich know which to pick

  • @utkarshverma7

    @utkarshverma7

    8 ай бұрын

    qatar already using it

  • @dimamatat5548
    @dimamatat55488 ай бұрын

    The developed countries already have shrinking populations. So AI may fix future labor shortages.

  • @daxtynminn3415

    @daxtynminn3415

    8 ай бұрын

    To bad then that countries that are ageing fastest like Italy and Germany who could benefit from AI the most are taking steps to ban it.

  • @samg7123
    @samg71238 ай бұрын

    Are they researcher of AI or social lob market? Did computer reduce employment? Where are the researchers who predicted millions to die based on some wierd regression. They should not make thier predictions but so some work in lab.

  • @TheGreenReaper

    @TheGreenReaper

    7 ай бұрын

    Yes, computer reduce employment.

  • @myselfandpesit
    @myselfandpesit8 ай бұрын

    Will AI replace bbc too?

  • @chocmilk4388
    @chocmilk43887 ай бұрын

    AI could have created better audio

  • @glassowlie
    @glassowlie8 ай бұрын

    0:07 This title graphic sucks!

  • @danielwoldu1855
    @danielwoldu18558 ай бұрын

    No doubt every journalist will lose thier jobs because of Artificial intelligence

  • @johnw574

    @johnw574

    8 ай бұрын

    And society would be much better for losing journos lying continuously for attention and money.

  • @jr-yn4lk

    @jr-yn4lk

    7 ай бұрын

    good. F*ck journos

  • @messi-fh9km

    @messi-fh9km

    7 ай бұрын

    ​@@johnw574but they Will speak what employer wants

  • @madoksback
    @madoksback8 ай бұрын

    No ALL jobs that is every single JOB will be replaced within a decade!

  • @DaleHartley

    @DaleHartley

    8 ай бұрын

    20 to 30 years, but I agree... What will society do? What is the old saying Idle hands are the devils tools. People tend to get in trouble when they have too much free time.

  • @Riu-bw4bl
    @Riu-bw4bl4 ай бұрын

    Ok so if we are going to cut the job market in haft especially traditionally well paying jobs something had got to change about the way we run our society. After hearing about the AI that can code it made me realize this will be a huge wealth transfer and people are going to be competing for even fewer jobs. Something will have to change. I almost think this is all by designer

  • @sandponics
    @sandponics7 ай бұрын

    Yippee, no more work. I want a robot to do the gardening, cook my food, clean and paint the house, wash my clothes, change my nappy and scratch by back etc. I am a 77 years old educator, highly experienced, and young people have not got a clue about what is happening in the world.

  • @achd73
    @achd738 ай бұрын

    do not allow some computer to tell your organs how to be human

  • @retrotronics1845
    @retrotronics18457 ай бұрын

    You can already generate movie scenes less cheap looking than all the 'blockbusters' in the cinemas and streaming platforms so there's that.................

  • @Indrid__Cold

    @Indrid__Cold

    7 ай бұрын

    So called entertainment will be the first thing to go. It's easy to experiment with, and there is a DEEP BASE of people who will come back to do the work if it turns out AI produces unsatisfactory results.

  • @retrotronics1845

    @retrotronics1845

    7 ай бұрын

    @@Indrid__Cold I agree. If you go and count how many above average quality TV or films came out each year just 15 years ago vs today you can see how bad things have got. There is only 1 TV show I watch a year for the last 2 years, budgets and shareholder profits are destroying TV/films. It's like the Playstation games scene I guess, lots of rubbish big budget sequels and lots of low quality other stuff. We need original ideas in the budget of sequels. AI video clips I found are the most advanced, AI text to speech dialogue/voice-overs are acceptable with some manual pitch control for a Netflix type movie. Music is really the only aspect that isn't even close. The same way 3 secretaries on typewriters would replace with 1 using a word processor by the mid 80s there will be a lot of jobs lost in the media industry. Also means there will be a lot more tacky actors+projector screen rubbish rather than actual talented location scouts and real location filming. AI does mean I have the potential to make a full length movie I want to exist all by myself on my PC, that is new and I welcome this new era personally. if I can do that with only weeks of experience with AI tools then just imagine what someone from the industry could manage.

  • @EricJohnson-lo7mj
    @EricJohnson-lo7mj7 ай бұрын

    This report misses a much more important issue. We currently do not own our data and content hosted by huge platforms such as Google, X, and Facebook. The owners of these platforms use our personal data, as well as the content that we create, to make billions of dollars for themselves. Some content creators do manage to leverage some income out of it, but not without the platforms themselves creaming a large percentage off the top. In the AI-powered future, we need to take ownership of our data and content to ensure that we get our just share of revenue produced from it. We are already seeing rafts of lawsuits from copyright holders of content used to train large language models, and they should sue because huge tech corporations are stealing their livelihoods. That level of theft is only the tip of the iceberg. If we don't act now, we consent to living in a dystopian hellscape ruled by data thieves who have stolen enough from us already. I wish us all the best of luck with that.

  • @rickyho4305

    @rickyho4305

    7 ай бұрын

    By this logic, if you take inspiration from another person's idea do you share revenue with them? Just like patent infringement, there is a line between what is infringement and what is inspiration. AI models don't work by copying a person's data, but only uses it to discover patterns (similar to how you learn things by looking at different things). If you begin monetizing every piece of data that is generated, this will quickly become unmanageable as every AI tool would be stupidly expensive to use as the tool would have to share revenue with almost every individual on the internet.

  • @rickyho4305

    @rickyho4305

    7 ай бұрын

    Also most of these platforms that you mentioned (Google, X, FB ,KZread) are free for consumers to use because they make money using your data. If you start monetizing every piece of data you generate, then you might start seeing that you have to pay for every Google Search or Friend you add on FB. Is that something people want? Nothing comes for free. These big companies need to generate revenue in order to give us these convenient services. If they don't generate money from data, they will start charging us for every single thing you can imagine just to stay afloat. Double edged sword. I think most people would rather pay with their time/data, then actually use real money to pay for every frickin thing they use on the internet.

  • @rickyho4305

    @rickyho4305

    7 ай бұрын

    Also, if you want to monetize your data and content then you can create your own private forum or website to store it and monetize people to access it (Netflix). If you post shit on the public internet, you are essentially consenting your data to be used by anyone.

  • @EricJohnson-lo7mj

    @EricJohnson-lo7mj

    7 ай бұрын

    @@rickyho4305 AI systems do not take "inspiration" from other work as a human would, it's just running code, with inputs at one end (creative work produced by humans), and the output of the LLM or whatever machine-learning system at the other. The provenance of AI-produced work can therefore be tracked. It is important to understand that the "input" for an individual output is the user prompt, but the creative human work that trained the deep neural network is the input that needs to be tracked, which can be done by logging the influence of each instance of training data on the nodes that principally contribute to each output. While such would not be a trivial undertaking, it only seems "unmanageable" to the people who benefit from the current arrangement. You had better believe that if the builders of these systems had invested their time and energy to also create the training data, they would find a way to calculate a financial return from it, and make sure that you paid them when you used it. As it is, they got it for free, so they have no interest in compensating the original creators. Alternatively, the influence of a particular training input would not have to be tracked for each output; the producers of the work used to train such a system would own shares in it in proportion to the quantity and quality of data they contribute, similar to how you can own shares in a corporation, where you get a return on that value--that would be a much easier way to figure it. In either case, the resulting tools would not be "stupidly expensive" to use; the tool would only have to share revenue with the people who contributed to its training. And as we have seen with industrial production of everything that we use, from pencils to automobiles, high quality products can be had for affordable prices, with everyone involved receiving some form of payment for their trouble. That has been the foundation of a strong middle class for the better part of the past century. Right now, we get output of LLMs for "free", but at the same time if your work contributed to the models, you really are getting ripped off. Listen: if you believe in capitalism (as I do), then you must respect ownership as a foundational economic principle, not just of the AI tools but also of the data that makes them really work, and by extension for the value of the labor it takes to produce that data. It's very disturbing to me how even very smart people seem utterly blind to that basic fact.

  • @byrne1916
    @byrne19168 ай бұрын

    People are afraid robots will stack shelves.... Because humans really enjoy doing it 😂

  • @jr-yn4lk

    @jr-yn4lk

    7 ай бұрын

    No. They're afraid of it because once100% of jobs are automated, humans will be exterminated.

  • @williamparrish2436
    @williamparrish24367 ай бұрын

    How can you do it without a plan? Its called the free market and the Invisible Hand for a reason! The market left to its own devices will balance this out. People will be motivated to retrain for their own sakes.

  • @williamparrish2436

    @williamparrish2436

    7 ай бұрын

    All the plumbers and the tradesmen and the are patting themselves on the back. But they don't realize that AR integrated with AI is going to be the end of a LOT of that money. You don't need robots to change a pipe, you just need some robot eyes to tell you what to do next. Meanwhile the IT guys they are laughing at are still going to be working, because there will always be a place for human creativity in the midst of the machines.

  • @L.LGodwill
    @L.LGodwill8 ай бұрын

    Q : Can we extract Carbon from ; Burned dog AI originated image ? If not ; Why it considered aproof of crime ?

  • @ericastones1052
    @ericastones10527 ай бұрын

    There will be no jobs expect politician and AI will be asking humans look for jobs already taken by AI and we get no income.

  • @vincentleeadams
    @vincentleeadams7 ай бұрын

    The backlash to AI will last as long as the backlash to the automobile from the horse and buggy industry… No matter how strong it is it won’t last very long.😂😂😂

  • @Ian-zx4bm
    @Ian-zx4bm8 ай бұрын

    ultimately it's still humans choosing to use AI. AI is not deciding to further itself. Discuss

  • @DaGamerTom
    @DaGamerTom7 ай бұрын

    AI is going to cost jobs Worldwide and create massive unemployment and social dramas at the rate it is developing right now! We need to hit the brakes with this technology.

  • @thehumancanary131
    @thehumancanary1318 ай бұрын

    Tax AI? But....but....AI is smarter than governments...they'll relocate the servers, invent new tax havens and avoid taxation at all costs!! (You'd think the BBC could invest in a decent microphone!)

  • @Rhade15
    @Rhade158 ай бұрын

    Brilliant interview, knowledgeable, engaging and entertaining

  • @toddboothbee1361
    @toddboothbee13618 ай бұрын

    Lawyers can learn to become chimney sweeps.

  • @user-dv9lc5og2u

    @user-dv9lc5og2u

    8 ай бұрын

    Если вы не входите в элиту,то экономически выгоднее для ИИ просто уничтожить всех юристов,экономистов физически.И вас тоже,потому что в век прогресса трубочистов не будет,потому что не будет труб.Все те кого заменит ИИ будут сметены с лица земли. Зачем они нужны,для каких целей.

  • @toddboothbee1361

    @toddboothbee1361

    8 ай бұрын

    @@user-dv9lc5og2u Элиты будут уничтожены; какая от них польза? Сверхразуму не нужны будут деньги, но он сможет беспрепятственно путешествовать к звездам.